Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: MadDogMurdock on August 14, 2009, 09:39:11 PM
-
Hello all,
Looking for some advice.
I've been playing for about a year and started on my grandfathers old hohner pokerwork in G/C. I can't seem to put the thing down when I'm around it and feel like I've come a long way in the course of a year. I've been playing in a string band (I suppose they aren't a string bad with me in the mix....but you get the idea) and have been feeling...well...bored. The limitations of my instrument make the A maj and D tunes the fiddlers seem to love a bit of a challenge for me. We play a mix of traditional Irish tunes, Appalachian tunes, and New England contra and square dance music. I feel like a hack when I'm squeezing out some right hand chords through half a set. So, I'm considering making the leap to a half-step box, and have found a B/C box I'm quite fond of.
The question: Am I nuts to switch systems now and invest in a B/C or ought I to stick with what I have and seek out a G/C with accidentals?
-
Actually there's no reason why you can't go with both systems. I started on C/F & D/G boxes and am now learning BCC# - no probs. I still play all my boxes every day without too many difficulties. So I'd say go for a half-tone box, it probably won't displace the G/C for a while yet, if ever. So GOFORIT - you've nothing to lose and everything to gain!
AL
-
Precisely what I hoped to hear! Thanks Al.
-
Depends what kind of person you are. If you think that you would be able to get the hang of a whole new fingering system then go for it.
Also remember that the chromatic and quint boxes are generally played in very different styles, which is something that you may wish to consider.
-
The limitations of my instrument make the A maj and D tunes the fiddlers seem to love a bit of a challenge for me.
The easier option would be to get an AD box.
-
..... or C#/D. ???
-
..... or C#/D. ???
That also would also require learning another system, whereas an AD plays the same as a the GC.
-
Hello all,
Looking for some advice.
, I'm considering making the leap to a half-step box, and have found a B/C box I'm quite fond of.
The question: Am I nuts to switch systems now and invest in a B/C or ought I to stick with what I have and seek out a G/C with accidentals?
BC box is fine for playing in A & D (also C B F G E) and there is not such a huge step in changing fom a DG or CF as some would have you believe as you are at least half way there (probably more) if you have got the hang of any sook an blaw system. The downside for some is that in return for chromasticity! and a full set of accidentals for both octaves you have very limited bass which is why many Irish ( and non irish!) BC players treat it more or less as a melody instrument.
Both systems can be played bouncy or smooth on the treble side but the 4th aprt boxes have the fcility to add bouncy bass. Absolutely no reason why you can't play both systems as they are similar but different! ;)
george
-
The downside for some is that in return for chromasticity! and a full set of accidentals for both octaves you have very limited bass which is why many Irish ( and non irish!) BC players treat it more or less as a melody instrument.
Both systems can be played bouncy or smooth on the treble side but the 4th aprt boxes have the fcility to add bouncy bass.
george
For this reason I would suggest an A/D would be a better option. As you are playing in a band where all the other instruments are strings, with presumably a strong melody coming from the fiddlers, your job is to provide rhythm and bass rather than to be just another person playing the tune.
An A/D willl allow you to accompany in these keys very easily as soon as you pick up the box, even before you have learnt to play all the notes of the tunes, and I would think add more to the band in the long run.
-
From the sound of it, and judging by the type of music you play, you don't need a fully chromatic instrument, you just want one which will play in the keys favoured by the rest of the band. An A/D would give you this without you needing to learn anything new or change your style.
-
The easier option would be to get an AD box.
I agree wholeheartedly with this statement - it would be 'easier' - however I get the impression that you're a bit like a racehorse kicking around in the starting gate and looking for a bit of freedom? Another A/D box would, to stay with the racing analogy, be like simply putting on a different set of blinkers. Break free and go B/C!
If your string group is looking for a bouncy bass from you then maybe your ideal instrument would be something like my Trichord with a stradella bass (in other words why not go the whole hog and get a BCC# box?). Trichords sell for about £200 these days on eBay and the like - so it's not like they're even expensive, and you'll have better bass options whichever way you push or pull the bellows.
Finally - think of the fun you'll have with the string players when you turn up at rehearsal with a fistful of tunes for them to play in E major, Ab Major, C#min etc
AL
-
Your racehorse analogy is perfect. I had certainly considered an A/D instrument, and haven't ruled that out (or the C#/D Rees...just haven't found one I liked or could afford yet), but I am more interested in being a melody player in the group. Our guitar, mandolin, and banjo have the rhythm end nicely covered. I suspect I will always be a quint box player for all the reasons mentioned (I started playing melodeon precisely because I loved the left hand accompaniment), but I think you've all convinced me that I'll just need to get one of each system.
MAD enablers
-
If you are a racehorse then don't get an AD. Get a Trichord as Al suggests.
-
Does the key of A run nicely on a B/C? I have a vague recollection of people complaining that it was all on the draw? ::)
-
The easier option would be to get an AD box.
...or an A/D/G !
-
but I think you've all convinced me that I'll just need to get one of each system.
Yes, it is the only way to live, but be warned, that's how I ended up with a melodeon shop!
Seriously, I have just taken delivery of several sets of Hohner reed blocks in C#/D to fit Erica/ Pokerwork/ Double Ray, etc. They are in the standard Hohner tremolo tuning and I am currently dry tuning a set to go in my old black Double Ray. Look out Jackie Daly (my arse!).
I have several complete sets (treble and bass) for sale at trade price: £200. (rrp: £319).
Tuning extra - say £30.
-
Does the key of A run nicely on a B/C? I have a vague recollection of people complaining that it was all on the draw? ::)
A is absolutely no problem on a BC. Whilst it is possible to play it mostly on the pull doing so only serves to achieve over extended bellows which are then difficult to get back. just as examples athol highlanders, my home, cock of north, 100 pipers, stool of repentance, Lamb skinnet , & a great many others can be plyed in A using only a few inches of bellows & with a trichord its just the same for Bflat !
if anybody is taking up Al's suggestion of going Trichord hunting beware of those that have sook an blaw bass rather than the more usual stradella which are much more useful.
george
-
A is absolutely no problem on a BC. Whilst it is possible to play it mostly on the pull doing so only serves to achieve over extended bellows which are then difficult to get back. just as examples athol highlanders, my home, cock of north, 100 pipers, stool of repentance, Lamb skinnet , & a great many others can be plyed in A using only a few inches of bellows & with a trichord its just the same for Bflat !
Thanks George, (though despite being so often cited as an 'A' tune Atholl Highlanders is surely "cheating" given that it has no G#s! ;D )
-
Thanks George, (though despite being so often cited as an 'A' tune Atholl Highlanders is surely "cheating" given that it has no G#s! ;D )
Doesn't that make it A mixolydian?
-
just as examples athol highlanders, my home, cock of north, 100 pipers, stool of repentance, Lamb skinnet
I've had a few starts at playing in A on the BCC#, its not easy. Having seen this thread I'm encouraged give these tunes a go today.
-
I've had a few starts at playing in A on the BCC#, its not easy. Having seen this thread I'm encouraged give these tunes a go today.
Agreed - the key for me is to keep the bellows as close as poss right from the very beginning of the tune -thinking it through and making sure that I use the C# on the push as much as poss. I've a tendency to want to use the C# pull on the B row which can lead to the bellows shooting out if I'm playing a run on the notes A, B, C# D. So in Amaj I usually find that I need to use the push B & C# a lot more.
AL
-
I usually find that I need to use the push B & C# a lot more.
I find that the, I'm not sure how to describe this technically , dynamics of the tune change quite a lot depending whether I choose the push or the pull option. What I mean is that it sounds "right" to my ear with the push or pull option but that this "prettiest"option from a musical point of view can result in a dramatic loss of air as you say. I have noticed that when Graeme Mackay plays that it is not very noticeable which choice he has made which suggests that one needs to choose the best option from an air point of view and play it over and over again until it sounds "right".
-
which suggests that one needs to choose the best option from an air point of view and play it over and over again until it sounds "right".
The thing with this BCC# system which I really find interesting is that I have to really think about and work out what it is I'm doing initially. Of course the practise, practise bit then follows. But I think I'm still at the 'working things out stage'.
Just as a remark back to thread for MadDogMurdock - as you can see, switching tunings is not all plain sailing. There's quite a bit of stuff to be worked at - but it has made me think about and analyse what I'm doing a lot more, which in my opinion is no bad thing!
AL
-
but it has made me think about and analyse what I'm doing a lot more
Absolutely right. I have thumped out tunes on the old D/G pokerwork for years without much thought about what was happening because I could. Now, every piece has its own peculiar difficulty. Getting the BCC# has re energized my music making, shame that it is happening as my sixtieth year approaches and not my sixteenth. Although I still wonder what the BCC# sharp has that the CBA lacks or rather why Jimmy Shand Junior took up the CBA instead of the BCC#.
-
which suggests that one needs to choose the best option from an air point of view and play it over and over again until it sounds "right".
The thing with this BCC# system which I really find interesting is that I have to really think about and work out what it is I'm doing initially. Of course the practise, practise bit then follows. But I think I'm still at the 'working things out stage'.
Just as a remark back to thread for MadDogMurdock - as you can see, switching tunings is not all plain sailing. There's quite a bit of stuff to be worked at - but it has made me think about and analyse what I'm doing a lot more, which in my opinion is no bad thing!
AL
It is often said and probably has more than a grain of truth that a room full of BCCsharpists would all finger & bellow the same tune in a slightly or not so slightly different way! However it is sensible to develop & get used to some sort of basic way of doing things .
In a make maximum use of push B & E exept where it would involve a very awkward bellow reversal in which case try using the pull B or E , particularly if the note is very short & will involve little bellows movement. (This would of course apply on a BC box as well). It has the advantage that by just moving to the CC# rows you transpose it into Bflat absolutely free of charge! It also make sense to learn tunes in G & D on the outside rows as these transpose into Aflat & Eflat.
It also helps to play all your tunes in at least CGDA as this helps you to transpose on the hoof & very importantly to get to know your way around the keyboard. As experience develops you will find that using the odd note on the inside row can ease tricky fingering here & there and of course using all 3 rows gives greater scope for right hand chords than are possible on a 2 row box.
which alternatives to use becomes intuitive given time but as a general rule if the bellows are going ever outwards you need to look for more push notes - preferably long ones- to keep things in control. There are however some bits of some tunes where wider bellows opening is temporarily required & this is k provided you know that the situation will be balanced by a subsequent run of predominently push notes. I this is not the case it pays to go light on the bass to conserve air and to use the air bar whereever possibnle to shove the bellows back to where they belong.
its not as complicated as it sounds - honest!
george
-
its not as complicated as it sounds - honest!
??? ??? ??? ???
-
but it has made me think about and analyse what I'm doing a lot more
Absolutely right. I have thumped out tunes on the old D/G pokerwork for years without much thought about what was happening because I could. Now, every piece has its own peculiar difficulty. Getting the BCC# has re energized my music making, shame that it is happening as my sixtieth year approaches and not my sixteenth. Although I still wonder what the BCC# sharp has that the CBA lacks or rather why Jimmy Shand Junior took up the CBA instead of the BCC#.
without a doubt the continental chromatic is the most sensible box of the lot. totally logical, chords right under the fingers - suitable for the classical school of learning - in 5 row form is virtually self transposing. Why don't we all have one?
On the other hand the BCC# is intriguing, provides a life long challenge, is part of the sook an blaw family, has a unique built in random bounce that can be varied by choice of alternative notes , provides a feeling of great satisfaction when you develop the technique of playing with very little bellows opening. Because of near closed bellows playing puts far less strain on shoulder & uses much less energy.Is well suited to most forms of traditional/folk music including continental stuff but is not suited to the classical school of learning as you can't come & go at the same time!
As to why Jimmy jnr plays continental my understanding is that he was sent to have 'proper' lessons with dot reading & all that stuff but why I'm not at all sure. Interestly Jimmy Shand is reported as saying to a number of people I know that if he waas starting from scratch he would go for a continental - funny thing is that he never made the change.
george
-
It also helps to play all your tunes in at least CGDA
Blimey George, is the human lifespan adequate for this task? The grim reaper will collect his harvest before I've mastered even one tune in all four keys. ::) ::) ::)
-
As to why Jimmy jnr plays continental my understanding is that he was sent to have 'proper' lessons with dot reading & all that stuff but why I'm not at all sure. Interestly Jimmy Shand is reported as saying to a number of people I know that if he waas starting from scratch he would go for a continental - funny thing is that he never made the change.
I don't suppose he ever really felt the need to change - and given that he was already the complete thing on his button accordion I can see why.
AL
-
It also helps to play all your tunes in at least CGDA
Blimey George, is the human lifespan adequate for this task? The grim reaper will collect his harvest before I've mastered even one tune in all four keys. ::) ::) ::)
Mikhave sent you a pm
george
-
I echo 'grittite's' comment. I've had my B/C/C# for just under 2 years now and wish I'd got one decades ago. I'm 63 and still yearning to learn. Hope I've enough time left. My D/G playing has improved over recent years and my cross-row work has really taken off, helped I'm sure by having to think cross-row with both my B/C/C# and my C/C#. What probably helps is having all those tunes in one's head together with manual skills and fluidity after substantial years of playing.
-
It is often said and probably has more than a grain of truth that a room full of BCCsharpists would all finger & bellow the same tune in a slightly or not so slightly different way!
But exactly the same is true of D/Gists - just look around you at the next session. Some will be playing up and down the rows while others will be cross-rowing, but they will all have their own ideas about where in the tune to cross-row and which fingering pattern to use.
It's part of the fascination of suck-blow instruments that there's no single way of doing anything, and certainly no "right" way.