Sour grapes by no means, but I only made it to about 2 mins. 4 secs.
How much of what we like musically is conditioned by our cultural background?I agree - the first guy's technique was without doubt dazzling and a mighty display of technical skill. But the music was, for me, almost unbearable after about a minute and a half - whereas I could have listened to the guy on PA play Bach for the rest of this week! I don't wish to rain on anyone's parade - just reflecting my own experience of the vid.
QuoteHow much of what we like musically is conditioned by our cultural background?I agree - the first guy's technique was without doubt dazzling and a mighty display of technical skill. But the music was, for me, almost unbearable after about a minute and a half - whereas I could have listened to the guy on PA play Bach for the rest of this week! I don't wish to rain on anyone's parade - just reflecting my own experience of the vid.
AL
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNTQ6ELzJDwSorry, I only lasted 18 seconds watching this one - when the warbling woman struck up I had to quit - it's just all jazz to me.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Va8Tilb9SNk
I loved it but then I've loved Hermeto's music since I first heard Live Evil. Miles Davis called him "the most impressive musician in the world" and Iain Ballamy's Acme recorded a beautiful tribute to him called Hermetology. He's pretty versatile, here he plays a solo on a glass of water:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Va8Tilb9SNk
More of his melodeon playing here, this time as (or maybe with) vocal accompaniment:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNTQ6ELzJDw
BTW surely it's the same man playing the PA and the melodeon, only with a hair and beard trim in between?Nope Hermeto is melodeon player and Sivuca is the proper accordion player ;)
This is just amazing music. Google him if you've never heard of him. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs)
This is just amazing music. Google him if you've never heard of him. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs)This simply reinforces my long held belief that men with beards and melodeons just do not mix.
This is just amazing music. Google him if you've never heard of him. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs)This simply reinforces my long held belief that men with beards and melodeons just do not mix.
I've just grown a beard
But Jan, I've just grown a beard so now I really am a Greybeard. You've put me in a very difficult position............... and I put it to you that I am simply an observer, and it is you who has put yourself in a difficult position by spurning the razor...
Mr Lucas. I fear that knocking or not (for that matter) the razor action is no part of the music of Hermeto or his many fans! Or maybe I'm not correct. Or maybe I am??
... the first guy's technique was without doubt dazzling and a mighty display of technical skill. But the music was, for me, almost unbearable after about a minute and a half - whereas I could have listened to the guy on PA play Bach for the rest of this week!
This is just amazing music. Google him if you've never heard of him. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jxh6gbohJLs)This simply reinforces my long held belief that men with beards and melodeons just do not mix.
...talking of men with beards... hello Lester, not if I see you first!
This simply reinforces my long held belief that men with beards and melodeons just do not mix.
Hi! Jan welcome aboard - see you in the Cotswolds :M
Jesus shaves. ???
Jesus shaves.
... but did he play the melodeon?
it is a well known fact that his Father is a Respected Greybeard - though not a member of THIS forum!
Quoteit is a well known fact that his Father is a Respected Greybeard - though not a member of THIS forum!
I'm not too sure about that. ;D
...melodeon players move in a mysterious way...In a sort of in/out sort of manner - the hesychastic nature of the melodeon has long been a source of contemplation for me ;). A deep association between our favourite instrument and man as an instrument that also breathes in and out...can I have another cup of coffee please as I'm losing the will to live :D
the hesychastic nature of the melodeon has long been a source of contemplation for me ;)Just try contemplating that at the end of the Friday night pre-Melodoeons at Witney session and see if you still feel the same way ;D
pre-Melodoeons??? Is that an instrument specific to Yorkshire? :D
Hermeto's instrument is a Brazilian "Hering" pokerwork,
I've been listening to Hermeto much longer than I've known about melodeons. Here's my favorite HP vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=06Qm-Z5OsHw&feature=player_embedded
I've been listening to Hermeto much longer than I've known about melodeons. Here's my favorite HP vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=06Qm-Z5OsHw&feature=player_embedded
He's only bleedin' deadly. That clip is awesome.
Anyone know what tuning he'd be playing in the original clip? Trying to figure out if it's worth trying to learn...
I think it's G/C, but am far from sure... could be a club as well, I have a feeling that they are popular in Brazil.
I think it's G/C, but am far from sure... could be a club as well, I have a feeling that they are popular in Brazil.
Damn, don't think I'll be attempting it on B/C.
It's coming back to me now, you are the Jan Lucas, sales manager for Gillette blades and I claim the £5 prize >:EBut Jan, I've just grown a beard so now I really am a Greybeard. You've put me in a very difficult position............... and I put it to you that I am simply an observer, and it is you who has put yourself in a difficult position by spurning the razor...
To be fair it could be BC, he plays the damn thing too fast :P
This one really has separated the sheep and goats in this forum.
Firstly thanks to Andy for that refence - missed while I was in hospital. I've never heard of this guys although a Brazilian colleauge has introduced me to other music from there. I'm in the Miles Davis appreciation club too, and I think this is a fantastic example about modal jazz being about sheer attitude! I mean he did all this on a 2 row 'qunt' with 8 standard basses ??? Come on chaps - that's good. - look at the sheer diversity of it! :o
If the G both ways is valid then I'd read this as a simple A/D. I think quint as he played in 5ths in the middle. A G chord both ways would explain the jazzy lydian stuff and hints of Gm and G Blues he got in
Andy - remember the skinny blonde thing that used to run around Embraud, and sit on the musician's laps? As a further example of folky 'gone to seed' here's what she's doing now http://chrisryall.net/familysong.mp3 (http://chrisryall.net/familysong.mp3). When I met up with Dols at the Opera Cafe in Tblisi - she was skatting on stage with the band already! Did anyone else like Pascoal skatting against his melodeon? I did.