Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: butimba on March 15, 2018, 06:07:37 PM

Title: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: butimba on March 15, 2018, 06:07:37 PM
Hi all,

I'm trying to work out how to mic up my box for an upcoming performance, but I'm a complete noob when it comes to this sort of thing. I've got two AKG 516s to attach to my box. What else do I need? I was looking at the B23 L (mixer/phantom power supply) but I've been told the output (a 3.5mm stereo jack) is no good for connecting to a sound desk. As far as I'm aware, I need a way to convert the two mini XLR cables to a 1/4 inch jack or an XLR - what would you recommend?

And what are the pros and cons of buying a mixer and having one output vs just having both cables going straight to the sound desk?

Any help greatly appreciated! 
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: benammiswift on March 15, 2018, 07:03:10 PM
So the big disadvantage is a sound engineer has no control over the balance just volume.

you can just get mini Xlr to XLR cables for relatively cheap or buy mini xlr cables then the appropriate adapter to XLR to sit on the floor. I doubt jack would work because unless they have a battery power pack they'll need phantom power I'd imagine.

If you use those cables for phantom you wont need the power supply/ mixer because that is just to power it so you can plug into like a laptop for home recording or so that they can be used with a wireless system in theater for example. Any decent desk has phantom power these days and they'll run of the +48V supply through XLR so if you can run off the desk i'd advise that

Does it need to be 1 output?

Benammi
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: butimba on March 15, 2018, 07:24:22 PM
Benammi thanks for your reply!

I don't think there's any reason why it needs to be 1 output.

An extra complication is that the phantom power for the mics needs to be 2-12V. So I've done a bit more research and it looks like what I probably need to do is buy two of these cables: https://www.thomann.de/gb/akg_mpa_vl_male.htm. Which I think a) convert 48V phantom power into what I need, and b) convert mini XLR to XLR. That's another £90 though... but seems to be the best option???
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Julian S on March 15, 2018, 08:19:30 PM
I use an AKG b23 beltpack to provide phantom power to my 516 (right hand) and a cheapish Thomann mike for left hand. Its got left and right controls so can easily mix bass and treble ends without messing with the sound desk, which we use for volume control. Output from the belt is a mini jack but its easy to get a mini jack to standard jack adaptor - I put that through a Stagg DI box which has xlr output. All works fine for us.


J
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: benammiswift on March 15, 2018, 08:32:51 PM
I think those AKG things you found should be grand

that then gives 2 different channels, which is better for any sound engineer.

strange they use that low phantom power, rather than what seems to be almost standard (48v) at the moment. I know that there are varying voltage etc justa  bit odd haha

They do look like the parts though. So that is the power supply for them rather than like the Shure PGA98H that I use has it the PSU tied to the mic but as detailed before there's many applications and I suppose the different PSU options allow for different use cases.

Benammi

Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Anahata on March 15, 2018, 08:59:16 PM
Unless it's got to be very loud or part of a noisy band, and if there's a PA system and sound engineer provided at the venue, don't dismiss the option of using a pair of mics on stands. You can get a more realistic sound i.e. more like the unamplified box, and it saves you from a tangle of cables, plugs, gadgets that can go wrong and flat batteries. Even a pair of SM57s (robust workhorse stage instrument mic used by many sound crews) will give good results.

I always do this for festival stage appearances now. One reason is that I am switching between two melodeons, a concertina and cello and can use just two mics for all of them, but there's no real downside except that it does need the sound engineer to be awake.

When I'm playing ceilidhs I'm quite happy with cheap Thomann T.bone mics clipped on the melodeon, but I sometimes use mics on stands for that too.

As you have the C516 mics already though, it looks like some good suggestions have been made. There's also the Thomann L-pack (https://www.thomann.de/gb/the_t_bone_l_pack.htm) which seems to let you create your own L/R mix and send a single feed to the PA. It uses batteries instead of relying on the PA phantom power, and you'd only need one...

strange they use that low phantom power, rather than what seems to be almost standard (48v) at the moment.
They are just bare electret capsules, and that's their normal power voltage, with a 2 pin connection. It's misleading to call it phantom power really.
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 15, 2018, 09:18:57 PM
Hi all,

I'm trying to work out how to mic up my box for an upcoming performance, but I'm a complete noob when it comes to this sort of thing. I've got two AKG 516s to attach to my box. What else do I need? I was looking at the B23 L (mixer/phantom power supply) but I've been told the output (a 3.5mm stereo jack) is no good for connecting to a sound desk. As far as I'm aware, I need a way to convert the two mini XLR cables to a 1/4 inch jack or an XLR - what would you recommend?

And what are the pros and cons of buying a mixer and having one output vs just having both cables going straight to the sound desk?

Any help greatly appreciated!
I have just this set-up which I used successfully for several years before I switched to free-standing mics on stands.

The mini-XLR cables from the AKG 516 mics go into the B23L combined power supply and mixer box. From the B23L a standard XLR cable goes to the sound desk.

The B23L box has a switch which enables you to choose between 48v line output for phantom power or low voltage mic output powered by a 9v battery in the B23L box. So long as the sound desk person knows (or tells you) which switch setting to use, it will be OK.

The B23L box also has those useful gain controls for each channel, which can help make the sound engineer's job very easy and also gives you, the player, some personal control over the output sound.

So to summarise: if you have the B23L box with a 9v battery plus a standard XLR cable to the sound desk, that's all you need.

Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: benammiswift on March 15, 2018, 09:19:33 PM
ah right so it's just the bias voltage, should've spotted that


Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: JohnAndy on March 15, 2018, 11:19:15 PM

I have just this set-up which I used successfully for several years before I switched to free-standing mics on stands.

The mini-XLR cables from the AKG 516 mics go into the B23L combined power supply and mixer box. From the B23L a standard XLR cable goes to the sound desk.

The B23L box has a switch which enables you to choose between 48v line output for phantom power or low voltage mic output powered by a 9v battery in the B23L box. So long as the sound desk person knows (or tells you) which switch setting to use, it will be OK.

The B23L box also has those useful gain controls for each channel, which can help make the sound engineer's job very easy and also gives you, the player, some personal control over the output sound.

So to summarise: if you have the B23L box with a 9v battery plus a standard XLR cable to the sound desk, that's all you need.

Steve, sorry to contradict you, but this has been discussed before, and you came to the conclusion that you have the B29L, which has now been discontinued, and not the B23L. Your B29L has an XLR output but the new B23L which superseded it has a jack plug output.

See the thread here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19306.msg236762.html#msg236762 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19306.msg236762.html#msg236762)
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 16, 2018, 12:21:50 AM

I have just this set-up which I used successfully for several years before I switched to free-standing mics on stands.

The mini-XLR cables from the AKG 516 mics go into the B23L combined power supply and mixer box. From the B23L a standard XLR cable goes to the sound desk.

The B23L box has a switch which enables you to choose between 48v line output for phantom power or low voltage mic output powered by a 9v battery in the B23L box. So long as the sound desk person knows (or tells you) which switch setting to use, it will be OK.

The B23L box also has those useful gain controls for each channel, which can help make the sound engineer's job very easy and also gives you, the player, some personal control over the output sound.

So to summarise: if you have the B23L box with a 9v battery plus a standard XLR cable to the sound desk, that's all you need.

Steve, sorry to contradict you, but this has been discussed before, and you came to the conclusion that you have the B29L, which has now been discontinued, and not the B23L. Your B29L has an XLR output but the new B23L which superseded it has a jack plug output.

See the thread here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19306.msg236762.html#msg236762 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19306.msg236762.html#msg236762)

Ah - thanks for the reminder. I'd forgotten about my earlier error!  :|bl I do indeed have the B29L and not the B23L.
It does seem as if the B23L is a retrograde step if it has the jack plug output. I guess the solution would be to purchase a cable with 1/4" jack on one end and a standard XLR plug on the other in order to use it with the B23L. Alternatively a jack to XLR converter plug. I have one; as I recall it's about 5 cm long and works fine.

Otherwise I think that most sound desks can accommodate both 1/4" jack input and XLR (at least the ones I've worked with can).

However, the main point is that either the B23L or B29L box will work fine with the AKG516 mics and will be able to use either phantom power or 9v mic power.
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Anahata on March 16, 2018, 08:22:38 AM
The Thomann L-Pack which I mentioned earlier does have an XLR connector on it, and is currently available.
(and it's probably a lot cheaper than the AKG unit of which it is clearly a Chinese copy)
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: -Y- on March 16, 2018, 09:10:23 AM
I'm with Benammi on this, I always found that having the two ends of the accordion merged before getting to the desk is to be avoided at all costs, except when really needed, or if you encounter one of those sound engineers that only dream of having no left hand at all (I find we have a lot of these, I don't know how it can be elsewhere).
If you have a decent person behind the desk, the two stand mics as suggested by Anahata is also a good solution (and sometimes putting the left-hand mic behind the player can be as good as in front, it depends).
Personally, I tend to use two clip-on ATM 350 if I'm playing only with one accordion, and otherwise asking a ribbon or dynamic microphone on a stand and using my clip-on mics for each left-hand if I have to use two accordions, this way I always have a good left-hand.

most sound desks can accommodate both 1/4" jack input and XLR (at least the ones I've worked with can).

For jack input on most desks, you'd want to ask a DI box, otherwise, you'll end-up with a non-symmetrical signal.
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 16, 2018, 09:19:49 AM
Quote
(and sometimes putting the left-hand mic behind the player can be as good as in front, it depends)

I'd agree with much of what has been said, but I feel this risks immediate feedback as the mic is likely to be pointing towards the monitor.  Selecting mics and positioning so that the monitor gives as little signal through the mics as possible is to my mind a huge consideration in any setup.
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: -Y- on March 16, 2018, 09:26:58 AM
Quote
(and sometimes putting the left-hand mic behind the player can be as good as in front, it depends)
I'd agree with much of what has been said, but I feel this risks immediate feedback as the mic is likely to be pointing towards the monitor.  Selecting mics and positioning so that the monitor gives as little signal through the mics as possible is to my mind a huge consideration in any setup.

Indeed, it may have been a recollection from a previous studio session, but as you said, that's not at all the same situation on stage. So let's forget this idea for now.   (:)
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Fred on March 16, 2018, 12:10:05 PM
The Thomann L-Pack which I mentioned earlier does have an XLR connector on it, and is currently available.
(and it's probably a lot cheaper than the AKG unit of which it is clearly a Chinese copy)

In fact, Thomann is a german company and both t.Bone and AKG produce in China. So that's not really a good argument.
From my testing, I have to say that t.Bone microphones are very very good, especially with respect to their price.  (:)
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: Howard Jones on March 16, 2018, 02:07:55 PM
The earlier AKG battery pack had a full-size jack, this was superseded by one with an XLR output (of which the Thomann is a copy).  I too was puzzled that the latest version now has a 3.5 mm jack, which as Steve says seems a retrograde step.  My guess is that a lot of people now record direct to PCs or small digital recorders and this is to cater for them.  AKG probably assume that anyone using professional PA and XLRs will go for the phantom power adaptor.

If you already have the battery pack, the simplest solution is probably to use a 3.5mm - 6.5mm jack cable to a DI box.  I don't know whether you could also use a splitter cable to divide the stereo channels to separate the left and right side mics.

If you haven't yet made a purchase, a pair of the phantom power adaptors are probably the best option as they will give you separate channels for treble and bass, and you won't then be relying on batteries.  Alternatively the Thomann L pack is a bit cheaper, but you'll need two if you want separate channels (the pack will accept two mic inputs but has only a mono output).
Title: Re: Please help! Very ignorant person trying to mic up a box
Post by: butimba on March 16, 2018, 06:23:37 PM
Thanks all! This has been very helpful. I didn't realise it was possible to use the L pack so that's good to know about. My gut instinct to leave the mixing up to the sound engineer seems to chime with people's experience of what's best, so I think I'll go with the two power adaptors to keep the outputs separate.


SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal