Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Schnorbitz on March 16, 2018, 09:13:39 PM

Title: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Schnorbitz on March 16, 2018, 09:13:39 PM
I'm just on the brink of ordering a Handry. The right hand will be what I am used to - D/G/Acc (Heim System). But I am stuck between 12 and 18 basses. My current box is a standard 12 RH D/G layout. However if I go for an 18 bass, I am a bit stuck as to what I would choose for the inner row of basses.  I am therefore keen to hear what other people are using 18 bass wise - especially what works (and of course, what doesn't work) and why.

Thanks

Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Baron Collins-Hill on March 17, 2018, 01:22:12 PM
It sounds like you are looking to keep the stock 8 or 12 bass, but in case you want to be adventurous, I went unisonoric and love it. I also use my box to play in other keys (F, C, A, E). Even if you don't go unisonoric, you could break apart my bass layout and see what I have in terms of reversals and other basses that you don't already have.

Thanks,
Baron
Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: -Y- on March 19, 2018, 10:15:59 AM
Unisonoric, as Baron suggested, could be really good. I know it would not fit me, as I tend to use all the 12 notes all the time, but what is great is having the most notes as possible on the same button pushed and pulled.
For my 18 basses layout, I went for a similar approach than the Milleret/Pignol layout: more-or-less standard 12 basses layout, and the inner row are only basses and allow me to have all the 12 notes on the bass on both pull and push.
The rationale behind it is that I used the chords only on the home keys (and some closely related keys), but never on distantly related keys. So I ditched the useless chords and replaced them with basses.

If I had to purchase an accordion now, I think I probably would go for a 24 basses unisonoric system, such as the Darwin or the Lamarck (see attachment). Having to think again and again on the pull/push direction for left and right hand at the same time is more and more tedious, and also, the two layouts are quite logical: up one tone from bottom to top, up one fifth from the inside to the outside. And, also, that's not really much heavier, seeing that you don't have the thirds. And with carefully chosen registration, you end up with a 2 octaves free bass system.
Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Peter Savage on March 19, 2018, 11:07:03 AM
This is what I have on my Handry.
Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Chris Brimley on March 19, 2018, 01:39:12 PM
Here's the layout I use on my FR18 DGAcc.  I have the third removal option on the LHS, and seldom leave the thirds in.

My ideas stemmed from my experience of my Saltarelle Tramontane 14 bass DGAcc.  The basic idea for me has always been to start from the DG 8 bass two-row, and fill in the missing gaps to allow fully chromatic playing in the home keys, plus reversals where necessary.  I deal with other keys by changing the key of the FR18.

A particularly useful feature of my 14 bass is the push F# pull/C# bass button 13, because that allows nice bass runs using the thirds in the key of D.  I replicated that on the 18 bass by having those basses and chords as close as possible extras to the D/A chords on an 8 bass layout.

I find push A chords very useful, because that allows you flexibility of bellows direction when playing in D or A, easing fast fingering and bellows control. 

I am used to the F pull/Bb push design from the 14 bass, which allows straying into flat key areas a bit, so kept that.  Having RH F, C and A notes fits in with the F (and D as a minor) chord, and Bb, D and G push notes with the Bb (G as a minor) chord. 

The rest are logical fill-ins to mop up the missing basses to giver full LHS chromatics.

The concept is therefore to be able to play almost all tunes you might wish to in the home keys with a bit of thought, with a steady but varied bass accompaniment.  If I want to play a tune in another key, it may well be possible, but usually I would change the key of the FR18.
Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on March 19, 2018, 01:40:44 PM
This is what I have on my Handry.

I rather like that. It looks as if I could pick it up and play it in D/G and the extra rows make sense.
Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Baron Collins-Hill on March 19, 2018, 07:53:42 PM
Also, if you want to go all in, I understand Castagnari is now making a 24 bass for Handrys.
Title: Re: D/G 18 bass LH layout suggestions
Post by: Schnorbitz on March 20, 2018, 09:16:22 PM
Wow, have been away for a few days and came back to all the posts that you've written. There are some really interesting (and logical interpretations of the 18 bass possibilities). I had already copied out the system used by -Y- from a previous post. Using the additional 6 basses as just basses (not chords) to fill the gaps makes a lot of sense. However, looking over some of the other possibilities makes wonder! More to think of   ;D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal