Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: boxcall on April 07, 2018, 04:29:17 AM

Title: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 07, 2018, 04:29:17 AM
So I have been really interested in geometry and numbers lately, I,ve never been good at math still I like thinking about it. Mostly I've been interested in geometry and particularly in nature's numbers or so call sacred geometry, circles, patterns, etc. My favorite number is 6 half of 6 is 3  6+3 =9. What I like about six is it is found a lot in patterns in nature , snowflakes, bee honeycomb chambers, flower petals etc. Also take a radius of any size circle measured with a pair of dividers, start at any point on the circumference of the circle and walk the dividers around it and you will have a divided it by six, if you draw out the line as you swing from point to point you'll have the six sided petal or snowflake.
Probably stuff most of you already know, I went to vocational school it was basic math right though 12 grad :o

Anyway I have been watching math stuff on YouTube algebra, geometry etc. trying to learn more.
I stumbled on this video, this guy does some stuff on Tesla who is all about the 3 6 9 numbers.
He was crazy about 3, put 2 triangles together (off set)you can make a six sided shape, so I can relate.

So in this video it is said that 432 is the universal frequency, easier or more pleasing to listen to.
4+3+2=9
I believe the key to the universe will be mathematical or explained by it and music and frequency is mathematics.
So what do you think?
Should we change back or have I been watching to much YouTube / ancient aliens ,etc.
You can tell me I'm nuts if you think so.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=-3gLxPdamK8
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Gena Crisman on April 07, 2018, 04:48:42 AM
No, (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKTZ151yLnk) at least, not unless everyone else does or you want to play mostly alone. I think it's probably come up here before, too, (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=9660.0) and people will probably be rude to one another about it on both sides. And it doesn't consider one's qualia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia). If you like it, do it, I guess: you might find an instrument that sounds better tuned to that frequency, but, you probably shouldn't discount 431 or 425.6 either.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: WestOz on April 07, 2018, 07:30:33 AM
“You can tell me I'm nuts if you think so”

Since you ask, I think you are nuts if you subscribe to this stuff.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Theo on April 07, 2018, 08:12:43 AM
So if we tune A to 432, what about all the other notes please?

Another vote for nuts.

Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Anahata on April 07, 2018, 08:15:31 AM
Whatever numerological tricks you can do with 432, as a frequency it's just a number of cycles per second, and a second is a completely artificial unit of time, not directly corresponding to any natural phenomenon. We could have divided the day in any number of ways, and the frequency of a note would be a different number each time.
So for me it's not a matter of belief, it's simply meaningless.
Give me A=440  any day, and keep it that way. (That's fundamentally meaningless too, but at least it's the current convention)
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Roger Hare on April 07, 2018, 08:33:44 AM
...So in this video it is said that 432 is the universal frequency, easier or more pleasing to listen to...

Whatever the merits of the (philosophical?) argument, A=432Hz doesn't seem to correspond to any of the 'standard' pitches for A,
so I think you'll be on your own...

And, as has been hinted, if 432 is a 'universal frequency', this (presumably) means that A=432, Bb=432, C=432, C#=432, etc.
Sounds a bit odd to me (also, monotonous  (:) )...

An alternative proposal, bearing in mind that your favourite number is 6 - re-tune to A=321 - the rationale being that 3+2+1=6...

I found this https://www.piano-tuners.org/history/pitch.html (https://www.piano-tuners.org/history/pitch.html) dealing with the history of standard pitch - I'm sure there's much
more out there.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 07, 2018, 09:39:57 AM
So far as your love of three, six and nine goes, with regard to the natural world, My understanding is that, in nature, life  tends to grow according to the Fibonacci series of numbers, where each successive number in the series is the sum of the two before it (1,1,2,3,5,8,13,21 etc.). Thus, if you look at petals and leaves, you will see plants with, for example, three, five or eight petals and leaves with three, five or eight segments and points. You will rarely see six or nine petals or leaf segments. Thus, a four leaf clover never happens in nature. Neither would a six or nine leaf clover. I have not scientifically tested this theory, but it does seem pretty common.

This type of structure does not appear to apply to musical harmony, as far as I can see, or should that be hear?
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Winston Smith on April 07, 2018, 10:04:45 AM
Mmmmmmmm!
As far as I can see, it's 1 for the money, 2 for the show, 3 to get ready, and/or 6 of one and half a dozen of the other!
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 07, 2018, 10:27:43 AM
This type of structure does not appear to apply to musical harmony, as far as I can see, or should that be hear?

It's actually the opposite. the Fibaconi series "in limit" tends to the so calles "perfect" or "golden" ratio of slightly over 1.6 … said to be beautiful in body relationships , art, etc

The equivalent ratio in music is the tritone, #4, b5, all the same, again totally symetrical with respect to ratio of one tritone interval to the next. That is to say that Bb is the tritone of E, and E is the tritone of Bb etc etc

Far from "harmonious" this is the most discordant diad possible. "The devil's interval".

So "nuts" 😐
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 07, 2018, 11:11:14 AM
This type of structure does not appear to apply to musical harmony, as far as I can see, or should that be hear?

Far from "harmonious" this is the most discordant diad possible. "The devil's interval".


Not "harmonius", perhaps but the augemented 5th/diminished 4th is definitely interesting.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Nigel on April 07, 2018, 11:29:18 AM
Some prefer 532 and others 442 but I used to prefer to play 433.
I'll get my coat......
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Lester on April 07, 2018, 11:40:11 AM
Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Fred on April 07, 2018, 11:45:25 AM
Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664

 ::)

Slightly offtopic side note: It's from France, isn't it ?
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 07, 2018, 12:26:39 PM
No, (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKTZ151yLnk) at least, not unless everyone else does or you want to play mostly alone.
I was thinking hypothetically. I should have said this in my post.

So if we tune A to 432, what about all the other notes please?

Another vote for nuts.


I would think just as all the other notes now are based around 440 that you would tune the others the same way based around 432, could you not?

“You can tell me I'm nuts if you think so”

Since you ask, I think you are nuts if you subscribe to this stuff.
(:)
Really I'm not subscribing, I am just exploring and that why I asked for opinions here.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 07, 2018, 01:27:00 PM
So far as your love of three, six and nine goes, with regard to the natural world, My understanding is that, in nature, life  tends to grow according to the Fibonacci series of numbers, where each successive number in the series is the sum of the two before it (1,1,2,3,5,8,13,21 etc.). Thus, if you look at petals and leaves, you will see plants with, for example, three, five or eight petals and leaves with three, five or eight segments and points. You will rarely see six or nine petals or leaf segments. Thus, a four leaf clover never happens in nature. Neither would a six or nine leaf clover. I have not scientifically tested this theory, but it does seem pretty common.

This type of structure does not appear to apply to musical harmony, as far as I can see, or should that be hear?
So far I just love six (:) I 'm familiar with the Fibonacci sequence and the closely related golden section as Chris says " said to be beautiful in body relationships , art, etc". As for six and four and nine in flower petals this happens often.

This type of structure does not appear to apply to musical harmony, as far as I can see, or should that be hear?

It's actually the opposite. the Fibaconi series "in limit" tends to the so calles "perfect" or "golden" ratio of slightly over 1.6 … said to be beautiful in body relationships , art, etc


Far from "harmonious" this is the most discordant diad possible. "The devil's interval".

So "nuts" 😐
In a book I read about building homes (called the old way of seeing) relating to underlying patterns shapes that would make a building pleasing to the eye (the golden ratio being mentioned ) they did not have "harmonious" patterns but often discord patterns in there visual facade. So from the conscious side things looked slightly out of place but from the subconscious side there are patterns , ratios, and shapes that give the building character. I'm not sure if this was designed in of just happen for one reason or another but some old houses definitely have that interesting look about them. Things are not perfect in nature!
Edit to add: yet there is harmony
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 07, 2018, 01:31:41 PM

...So in this video it is said that 432 is the universal frequency, easier or more pleasing to listen to.
4+3+2=9

I have seen this this question asked (and mocked) before, but asking it in these terms is pretty meaningless. A frequency will give you a tone, not a frequency.

I have never seen the question of, "is music based on a tonic of 432 easier  and more pleasing to listen to?" addressed seriously. Simple to do as well, for tuneable instruments, such as fiddles.

Record a tune in the key of A with A=440Hz, preferably tuned with just intonation, then retune to A=432Hz and record the tune again. All you have to do then is play the tunes to enough people to constitute a significant sample and ask which, if either, they prefer.

Could this be done with a Streb, or a Roland? Anyone up for trying it?
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Roger Hare on April 07, 2018, 01:50:53 PM
...I have never seen the question of, "is music based on a tonic of 432 easier  and more pleasing to listen to?" addressed seriously....

A little more grubbing about in the bowels of t'Internet reveals something known as 'Verdi Tuning', based on A=432Hz.

For example: http://songsurgeon.com/page/A440_Alternative_Tunings.html (http://songsurgeon.com/page/A440_Alternative_Tunings.html)

(which is a commercial site flogging software but which contains a brief description)
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 07, 2018, 02:05:05 PM

...So far I just love six (:) I 'm familiar with the Fibonacci sequence and the closely related golden section as Chris says " said to be beautiful in body relationships , art, etc". As for six and four and nine in flower petals this happens often.


Please don't think I'm not considering your question seriously. As I said in  cross post, I have seen the merit of  432 tuning postulated before, but never tested, or even stated in a properly testable way. That is probably why those suggesting this leave themselves open to mockery. I have certainly got experience myself of key changes changing the way I perceive music. I really hope someone can manage this.

So far as my statement about petals and leaves goes, you are right to say that there are some flowers which do not follow the Fibonacci pattern, for instance, fuscias have four petals, but these seem to be pretty rare cases. There is a fundamental scientific reason why this is the case. This  page explains it far better than I can. Don't be put off by it being "educational". It explains some very sophisticated mathematical concepts in a very approachable way.

http://www.maths.surrey.ac.uk/hosted-sites/R.Knott/Fibonacci/fibnat.html

So far as your pointing out that, ultimately, the universe is explainable in terms of numbers, I totally agree. The scientific study of this is called physics and it is absolutely fascinating.

Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 07, 2018, 02:30:30 PM
ON TOPIC

Forget the A=432 nonsense and, if it's harmony you want, change temperament instead. Old melodeons sounded much sweeter because they were tuned to "Just Intonation" (like this new Bergflødt one in G (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EU6BJ4IwxDA)) and lots of harmonicas are still manufactured that way.

OFF TOPIC

Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664

 ::)

Slightly offtopic side note: It's from France, isn't it ?

That depends on who the border region of Alsace belongs to at any given time, which changes according to who won the most recent war. ???

Kronenbourg was founded in 1664 by Geronimus Hatt in the Free Imperial City of Straßburg, presently known as Strasbourg, France. So Alsations are currently French... :o

Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Eshed on April 07, 2018, 02:34:52 PM
Even if you really like the numbers 9 or 4 or 3 or 2, they have nothing to do with 432Hz.
We can define a new unit, SuperHertz (SHz) such that 1 SHz = 440/432 Hz.
Then not only can you tune your instrument to 432 SHz (which is obviously better than 432 Hz - it's called Super for a reason), you can also still play with all the plebs and their 440Hz tuned instruments.
>:E

In other words, if any pitch can be defined by any number, they are most likely unrelated.

Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 07, 2018, 03:05:20 PM
On this page https://attunedvibrations.com/432hz/
"Some people who are not able to distinguish the 8hz difference claim they can feel the music warmer due to the longer wavelength."

I think this would be me "not able to distinguish the 8 Hz difference" but I wonder if I could feel the difference.

In the article above it states you don't have to play so loud, could be useful for the family when playing a melodeon >:E

This may be all nonsense? Still I find it interesting (:)

People said that it was nonsense or nuts that the world was round once and that we were the center of the universe  ::)

I'm not a black or white type of thinker but feel the truth is somewhere in the middle or grey area.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 07, 2018, 03:19:05 PM
Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664

Not sure if I'm following this, are you referring to beer?

Yeah I did have a couple but I don't think that's the problem I would ask this even if I didn't.
It was a session beer 4.32% by volume. :||:
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 07, 2018, 03:56:11 PM
Even if you really like the numbers 9 or 4 or 3 or 2, they have nothing to do with 432Hz.

The numerologists among you will be aware that 432 is 2*2*2*2*3*3*3, or 24*32
(Edit, I'll try again 1*2*4*6*9 Nope, still don't get it.)


Erm, I don't quite get it either.

Also, I wonder what the tolerance is on the figure of 432. Any attempyt to tune to that frequency absolutely is, of course, doomed to failure.

I'm surprised no one pointed out that a Hz is an arbitrary unit, being based on a second, itself an arbitrary unit.

Edit, but I would still like to hear it proven that it does, or does not, make a difference.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: playandteach on April 07, 2018, 04:11:38 PM
I recently had someone volunteer to bring gongs to my school, I said thanks, but that we actually used a set of bells, bowls and gongs that I own, so we wouldn't need to pay someone to run a session. 'Ah', she said, 'but mine are tuned to the planets'.
I'm getting better at saying no thanks more gently these days.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Graham Spencer on April 07, 2018, 05:28:49 PM
Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664

Not sure if I'm following this, are you referring to beer?


If so, I'm afraid Kronenbourg 1664 is French......
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Gena Crisman on April 07, 2018, 06:17:36 PM
Edit, but I would still like to hear it proven that it does, or does not, make a difference.

Well, the thing is that you often see 440 vs 432 comparisons, or people asking for them, or asking people to prove it one way or the other. But how do you perform that test? Is it like asking to compare Golden Delicious and Granny Smith to declare the best/most correct apple? It discounts the other possibilities, it discounts the culture and prevalence of what someone might be used to, it discounts philosophical variations in human experience, it may even discount the possible interactions of harmonics with the sampling frequency/encoding algorithms used to convey the tests.

Also, re math, I believe one of the derivations is that it's the pythagorian tuning major sixth 27/16 ratio from C4=256, which is 28. 16, as 24, could cancel half of those out leaving you to the conclusion that 256x27/16 = 24x33 for your A value, but, that's an unpopular intonation applied to a pitch standard that isn't used.

Pretty much everything I know about this is taken from the video I subtly linked in my first post: https://youtu.be/EKTZ151yLnk
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 07, 2018, 06:33:41 PM
Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664

Not sure if I'm following this, are you referring to beer?

If so, I'm afraid Kronenbourg 1664 is French......

It is now, but it hasn't always been - and it wasn't in 1664... ???    (See below. ;))

Slightly offtopic side note: It's from France, isn't it ?

That depends on who the border region of Alsace belongs to at any given time, which changes according to who won the most recent war. :-\

Kronenbourg was founded in 1664 by Geronimus Hatt in the Free Imperial City of Straßburg, presently known as Strasbourg, France. So Alsations are currently French... ???
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Fred on April 07, 2018, 07:08:33 PM
Used to like the German version Kronenbourg 1664

Not sure if I'm following this, are you referring to beer?

If so, I'm afraid Kronenbourg 1664 is French......

It is now, but it hasn't always been - and it wasn't in 1664... ???    (See below. ;))

Slightly offtopic side note: It's from France, isn't it ?

That depends on who the border region of Alsace belongs to at any given time, which changes according to who won the most recent war. :-\

Kronenbourg was founded in 1664 by Geronimus Hatt in the Free Imperial City of Straßburg, presently known as Strasbourg, France. So Alsations are currently French... ???

Not going to debate any of this because it's technically true. Although, as a native Franconian (http://www.franconiabeerguide.com/), I have to say that I'd rather have another beer please.  :P
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 08, 2018, 12:03:02 AM

Edit, but I would still like to hear it proven that it does, or does not, make a difference.

I would like to think a good start would be to carry out the exercise I described above and let me listen to it. If I like 432Hz better than 440Hz that'll do for me. Blow everyone else.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Anahata on April 08, 2018, 12:36:22 AM
I'm surprised no one pointed out that a Hz is an arbitrary unit, being based on a second, itself an arbitrary unit.

I did, if not exactly in those terms.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: mselic on April 08, 2018, 04:55:10 AM
I knew you would be receiving flak when I first read this post!  I don't think you're nuts at all for having an interest in the topic, or for wanting to explore it further.  I actually believe there is likely something to this 432 business, but I'm also not about to re-tune any of my instruments to it either.  A friend of mine, a professional rock and jazz guitarist, has one of his guitars at home tuned to 432Hz where'll he'll play it on his own from time to time.

The problem is that, with many topics such as this one which fall outside the accepted convention, it will attract a lot of people who will become proponents of it without really doing the research or understanding it, and who will often push pseudo-science and misinformation and actually do a particular area of interest more harm than good.  The flip side is there area a lot of people who will scoff at the very notion of anything that cannot be understood or proven within a particular framework of analysis, passing over something which could in fact have merit on a level that goes beyond what we might currently be able to understand or perceive.  The truth for so many of these things often lies somewhere in the middle, and there is usually value in the observations of both sides of an issue.  People will usually pick a side early on, and then find proof (be it YouTube videos or something else) to support it.  Rarely does one side ever paint a full picture, though ;)

I didn't realize early melodeons were tuned to just intonation?
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 08, 2018, 08:17:33 AM
I didn't realize early melodeons were tuned to just intonation?

They were still tuned that way until the early 1930s, and the Cajun makers are still trying to emulate the original tuning of their old Sterlings and Monarchs with a much simplified version of it.

Meanwhile Jeffries Anglo concertinas were tuned to 1/4 comma meantone, whilst early English concertinas were tuned to 1/5 comma meantone - though castigated by no less than Hector Berlioz for it. :o
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 08, 2018, 09:08:46 AM

They were still tuned that way until the early 1930s, and the Cajun makers are still trying to emulate the original tuning of their old Sterlings and Monarchs with a much simplified version of it.


Did they try and do this with 2 row instruments? I would have thought that wouldn't work if any cross rowing went on.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Sebastian on April 08, 2018, 09:24:23 AM
Record a tune in the key of A with A=440Hz, preferably tuned with just intonation, then retune to A=432Hz and record the tune again. All you have to do then is play the tunes to enough people to constitute a significant sample and ask which, if either, they prefer.
Yes, a simple empiric experiment. Maybe it is easier just to sing. Just sing a song with a' = 440 and than with a' = 432 Hz. I generated an mp3-file with ten seconds 440 Hz and ten seconds 432 Hz you can use as pitch reference:

https://soundcloud.com/weltsauerstoff/440-hz-432-hz
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 08, 2018, 02:10:33 PM
They were still tuned that way until the early 1930s, and the Cajun makers are still trying to emulate the original tuning of their old Sterlings and Monarchs with a much simplified version of it.

Did they try and do this with 2 row instruments? I would have thought that wouldn't work if any cross rowing went on.

They didn't "try" and do it, it's what they did. But there are degrees of "Just", just as there are of "Meantone" (and 1/4 comma is a bit extreme for playing with "Equal Temperament", but 1/5 comma works acceptably), and lots of other systems too.

Here's a horror story for you: I used to have a gorgeous late 1920's Hohner C/F Pokerwork that was octave-tuned and in original just intonation, and it sounded sublime! But a friend who is a well-known B/C box and melodeon player would sometimes borrow it, and especially after his 114G got destroyed in a flood. He asked me several times if I'd sell it to him, and finally I relented - but only on condition that I got first refusal if he ever parted with it. Eventually he bought a Quebec melodeon and I bought my box back off him, only to find his tuner had got at it in the meantime and tuned it straight - thereby destroying its charm for me! :o  I couldn't wait to get rid of it after that!!! :'(
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 08, 2018, 02:16:32 PM
Record a tune in the key of A with A=440Hz, preferably tuned with just intonation, then retune to A=432Hz and record the tune again. All you have to do then is play the tunes to enough people to constitute a significant sample and ask which, if either, they prefer.
Yes, a simple empiric experiment. Maybe it is easier just to sing. Just sing a song with a' = 440 and than with a' = 432 Hz. I generated an mp3-file with ten seconds 440 Hz and ten seconds 432 Hz you can use as pitch reference:

https://soundcloud.com/weltsauerstoff/440-hz-432-hz

All very well and good, but I don't see it as a valid test that way, because lots of people will go for the flatter of two pitches. You'd want to try them with a spread of pitches between (say) 425 and 440, and not tell them which one is 432, to see if there really is something "special" about it...
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 08, 2018, 02:42:53 PM
I knew you would be receiving flak when I first read this post!  I don't think you're nuts at all for having an interest in the topic, or for wanting to explore it further.  I actually believe there is likely something to this 432 business, but I'm also not about to re-tune any of my instruments to it either.  A friend of mine, a professional rock and jazz guitarist, has one of his guitars at home tuned to 432Hz where'll he'll play it on his own from time to time.

The problem is that, with many topics such as this one which fall outside the accepted convention, it will attract a lot of people who will become proponents of it without really doing the research or understanding it, and who will often push pseudo-science and misinformation and actually do a particular area of interest more harm than good.  The flip side is there area a lot of people who will scoff at the very notion of anything that cannot be understood or proven within a particular framework of analysis, passing over something which could in fact have merit on a level that goes beyond what we might currently be able to understand or perceive.  The truth for so many of these things often lies somewhere in the middle, and there is usually value in the observations of both sides of an issue.  People will usually pick a side early on, and then find proof (be it YouTube videos or something else) to support it.  Rarely does one side ever paint a full picture, though ;)

I didn't realize early melodeons were tuned to just intonation?

Thanks Mselic, I don't think I'm nuts either  ;)
I should clarify that I wasn't saying I think this is true, my title of the post had the words "should we tune to 432"
And not WE SHOULD tune to 432. I said this a couple times in my post but made the mistake of saying "call me nuts" instead of saying is this nuts. I hadn't bought into to it completely and that is why I asked the question here, and I do value the collective knowledge here.

Maybe there is something to it? Could be unrelated to frequency ( as it has been point out is base on arbitrary numbers) so like my earlier post about old houses with an underlying pattern or certain ratios ( subconscious structure) that can't be seen by the conscious eye but the brain sees it. If this was intended or just happens though a natural process ( just worked out that way) ?
So it could be something to it, patterns or wave forms that "feel right" but are not math related per say and it just happens to be at the frequency of 432.

Humans know so much but understand so little, I am looking to understand more that's all and to do that you have to explore things the results might be right or wrong.

Wading though facts and alternative facts a lot these days (:)
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Theo on April 08, 2018, 02:49:15 PM
Maybe there is something to it? Could be unrelated to frequency ( as it has been point out is base on arbitrary numbers) so like my earlier post about old houses with an underlying pattern or certain ratios ( subconscious structure) that can't be seen by the conscious eye but the brain sees it. If this was intended or just happens though a natural process ( just worked out that way) ?
So it could be something to it, patterns or wave forms that "feel right" but are not math related per say and it just happens to be at the frequency of 432.

Musicians generally are very good at picking up and recognising a special feature of a piece of music that is difficult to put a name to. So I think if there was any significant truth to the assertion that a particular frequency has a special quality, then over the centuries musicians and audiences would have attracted towards that pitch.  I'm not aware of any evidence of that among the many different pitch standards that have come and gone over time.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Winston Smith on April 08, 2018, 02:56:16 PM
"Wading though facts and alternative facts a lot these days"

No disrespect intended here, boxcall, but I feel sure that playing the melodeon is a much better use of time than pondering the imponderable.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: boxcall on April 08, 2018, 03:30:21 PM
"Wading though facts and alternative facts a lot these days"

No disrespect intended here, boxcall, but I feel sure that playing the melodeon is a much better use of time than pondering the imponderable.
None taken Edward, I do a fair amount playing so I'm not spending that much time pondering (:)

I was referring to the current political and news standards we have in the states (probably exists elsewhere also) there is an "alternative fact" for everything ::)
Maybe there is something to it? Could be unrelated to frequency ( as it has been point out is base on arbitrary numbers) so like my earlier post about old houses with an underlying pattern or certain ratios ( subconscious structure) that can't be seen by the conscious eye but the brain sees it. If this was intended or just happens though a natural process ( just worked out that way) ?
So it could be something to it, patterns or wave forms that "feel right" but are not math related per say and it just happens to be at the frequency of 432.

Musicians generally are very good at picking up and recognising a special feature of a piece of music that is difficult to put a name to. So I think if there was any significant truth to the assertion that a particular frequency has a special quality, then over the centuries musicians and audiences would have attracted towards that pitch.  I'm not aware of any evidence of that among the many different pitch standards that have come and gone over time.
In one article or video it was said ( I can't remember which) that a lot of ancient instruments gongs , bells etc. were pitched to 432.
Of course at that time there was no such thing as frequency measurements ( at least I don't think so) if so, what would explain that?
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Theo on April 08, 2018, 03:47:17 PM
In one article or video it was said ( I can't remember which) that a lot of ancient instruments gongs , bells etc. were pitched to 432.
Of course at that time there was no such thing as frequency measurements ( at least I don't think so) if so, what would explain that?

Without some reference to the source that isn't much help, and "some ancient instruments were probably tuned to all sorts of different pitches.  But even with a source it would beg the question as to why if a=432 was so good it did not continue in general use.  Indeed if the assertion is true then you would expect to see the same pitch independently adopted by many different musical cultures.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Theo on April 08, 2018, 03:54:24 PM
If it turns out that there is nothing special about 432 then there is always 528Hz (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PRV6w6VJbc) to fall back on.   This frequency is said to repair DNA among other things.

Missing link replaced
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Lester on April 08, 2018, 04:22:37 PM
If it turns out that there is nothing special about 432 then there is always 528Hz (http://) to fall back on.   This frequency is said to repair DNA among other things.

Possibly Theo's missing link (https://attunedvibrations.com/528hz-dna-repair/)
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Grape Ape on April 08, 2018, 06:56:26 PM
WOW! That gets really good about 3 hours in!
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Sebastian on April 08, 2018, 10:24:31 PM
https://soundcloud.com/weltsauerstoff/440-hz-432-hz

All very well and good, but I don't see it as a valid test that way, because lots of people will go for the flatter of two pitches. You'd want to try them with a spread of pitches between (say) 425 and 440, and not tell them which one is 432, to see if there really is something "special" about it...
Yes, your are probably right. Anyway, as Boxcall doesn't seem to react to the idea, I won't prepare the other example pitches. The other pitches are not so important. He could choose freely one a bit below 432 Hz and one a bit above 432 Hz.

(Of course it's nonsense. The whole idea is wonderfully ahistorical and adorably nutty. (http://wuerziworld.adbt2.ath.cx/girl/gi3.gif))
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: vof on April 08, 2018, 10:42:36 PM
WOW! That gets really good about 3 hours in!
I'm still waiting for this thread to get really good >:E Having resisted the temptation to look at it for the past couple of days, I succumbed tonight and wished I hadn't bothered. I'm amazed at how polite you all are ::) And how Theo hasn't called a halt yet...   ;D
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 08, 2018, 10:47:25 PM

All very well and good, but I don't see it as a valid test that way, because lots of people will go for the flatter of two pitches...

I thought the reason for the raising of the reference pitch was that people preferred a higher pitch, or is this only in the context of 440Hz v 432Hz?
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Sebastian on April 08, 2018, 11:22:35 PM
I thought the reason for the raising of the reference pitch was that people preferred a higher pitch, or is this only in the context of 440Hz v 432Hz?
For a quick overview cp. Wikipedia on Pitch inflation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concert_pitch#Pitch_inflation).
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: squeezy on April 08, 2018, 11:39:22 PM
As for the relationship between 'favourite numbers' and a particular artificial system of measuring frequency by humans - I'm afraid I'm with all the other naysayers.  The only numbers which have absolute significance in the universe are the universal constants (which are also in completely artificial human units) and the relationship of ratios between things.  The idea of a lucky (or otherwise) number is totally a symptom of the spiritual reassurance our brains seem to crave (which means that their placebo effects might be significant!)

My personal experience is that I have spent an adult lifetime playing tunes in D and G based on A=440 - I don't have perfect pitch, but I can certainly tell instinctively when a tune is being played in an unusual key like Bb or B - it just doesn't sound D/G-ey to me.  Another effect of this is that I hear tunes outside my normal range of keys as exciting and exotic - without knowing exactly why.  I have had a box tuned in C#/F# - and everything I play on that sounds rich and full - I wonder is that is a function of my brain or ears being burnt out on the stimulus of hearing the notes in D and G (at A=440)

Maybe a similar thing happens when we hear music played at A=432 (and probably any other standard of calibrating notes not based on A=440) ... our ears and neural pathways may just be a bit frazzled from hearing those particular frequencies over and over ... so when we hear other frequencies, we might just get a bit of a boost from hearing the different vibrations.  No evidence from me I'm afraid - just hypothesis!
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: -Y- on April 09, 2018, 09:54:51 AM
I'm with Squeezy on this, I feel it's rather the fact that you change what your ears are used to (and not some pseudo-scientific arrangement of numbers) that makes most of the appeal.
Interestingly, I had my accordion retuned a couple of weeks ago and my tuner asked me if I wanted a 440 or 442 Hz. Apparently, he has more and more demand for 442 Hz pitched instruments (a bit like pianos that are often at 442 Hz, seemingly to stand out the crowd).
Some bagpipers (especially for the Highland bagpipe) often play at higher pitches still, something like the A being higher than the Bb (for a scale with an A at 440 Hz, if you follow me).
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on April 09, 2018, 01:50:37 PM
If you are interested in understanding more about how our brains processes music and what makes it different from other sounds, then this book is a great read -
'This is your Brain on Music' by Daniel Levitin. Paperback is £9.99.

Daniel is an ex-session musician, sound engineer and record producer who became a neuroscientist. Very readable, using familiar songs as examples. It really explores why music sets the brain alight and can trigger emotional responses!
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2018, 04:00:53 PM
All very well and good, but I don't see it as a valid test that way, because lots of people will go for the flatter of two pitches...

I thought the reason for the raising of the reference pitch was that people preferred a higher pitch, or is this only in the context of 440Hz v 432Hz?

That depends on what the commonest pitch was in different places/countries, which is why an International Standard Concert Pitch was considered necessary in the first place. In Britain many instruments/bands were still in Old Philharmonic or Kneller Hall Pitch, which were half a semitone SHARP, though by the late 1930s there were tuning forks being made (by John Walker in Sheffield) in no less than SIX :o different ptiches.

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/002.jpg)

These days the climb north of A-440 is driven mainly by the classical orchestras around the World, who tend to play at 442, 443, or even 444 (which was the old "Society of Arts" pitch).
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: playandteach on April 09, 2018, 05:23:20 PM
I thought the reason for the raising of the reference pitch was that people preferred a higher pitch, or is this only in the context of 440Hz v 432Hz?

These days the climb north of A-440 is driven mainly by the classical orchestras around the World, who tend to play at 442, 443, or even 444 (which was the old "Society of Arts" pitch).
[/quote]
A main part of the issue is not favouring a higher pitch as standard, but playing on the top side of the note in order - in the case of 1st violins to sound more brilliant in the virtuosic passages (brilliant as in sound, not skill). It is also that we chase each other up. Clarinets built to cope with 440 cold, will be at least 442 by mid concert. In, for example the Vaughan Williams London Symphony, the clarinet and harp play alone together towards the end. The harpist has to start the piece really high to cope with the clarinet at the end, the strings move up to accommodate the harp.
The other chase up thing, is that our eats cope much better with sharp playing than with flat, so no one wants to be flat COMPARED TO THE PEOPLE PLAYING AT THE SAME TIME. So it isn't that we prefer a sharper pitch to a flatter pitch standard, just that we want to not be flat by comparison with others in the same performance.
Pianos are usually tuned to 442 in this country where tuners know that we are going to end up there anyway - in chamber or orchestral performances involving wind and brass.
Title: Re: Should we tune to 432 ?
Post by: triskel on April 09, 2018, 06:06:52 PM
Pianos are usually tuned to 442 in this country where tuners know that we are going to end up there anyway - in chamber or orchestral performances involving wind and brass.

And likewise, if an accordion or melodeon player was performing with an orchestra an instrument tuned at A-440 would be perceived as "flat" - they'd need a "sharp" one at A-442...

(Never fear, my Paolo Soprani "Pepperpot" is factory-tuned at A-444!  ;) >:E 8))
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal