Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Richard Shaul on May 02, 2018, 10:18:05 PM
-
just some stray thoughts..
the normal left hand of our melodeons are bass notes and pre-defined chords. Are there any forms of melodeon (or accordion) where the left hand side consists entirely of individual notes so that the player can create their own chords? would this be practical?
-
It has been done before ... and yes it's very practical if you want to play bass notes only ... but it's rubbish if you want to play chords. It's possible to make chords out of bass notes, but they sound very odd with all the reeds in the low register.
-
They call that an Anglo-Concertina.
-
Hi there
there's a pretty interesting thread where I discuss a mod i had done to my box to do this.
see here : http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,21624
if you want to know any more, drop me a PM, I'm happy to help
Benammi
-
On my Castagnari Mas it has a register to do just this. When i put that in, the low octave of the basses is removed, and the prime o the chords, leaving only the fifth.
I never use that option though,...
W
-
It has been done before ... and yes it's very practical if you want to play bass notes only ... but it's rubbish if you want to play chords. It's possible to make chords out of bass notes, but they sound very odd with all the reeds in the low register.
I think it depends on the repertoire you want to play. Agreed, on relatively fast tunes, or when you want to do some oompah-oompah, it's tedious work. But on slower tunes, « manual » chords really shine, and you can do good voicing with it too.
It's a pretty common (at least it's more and more common) feature on CBA, where you can convert the left-hand side from pre-made chords to a melodic keyboard (although in the low end).
What Cooper and Benammi described is more or less the equivalent for diatonic accordions, IMO.
You can have a go on the Darwin (or Lamarck, if you want to push the logic to its fullest) system, which is quite good in this respect.
-
My 18 bass boxes both have all 12 notes both ways (ie 6 chord buttons) and a register can take out the low bass voice.
You "can" play music there, but … the response is still bit slow, it's easier to do with a spare finger on the right end, and … bass taken out it is no longer a "bass run".
Anahata is a master at this sort of thing, on standard kit!