Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ruaraidh on August 21, 2009, 09:46:38 AM

Title: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Ruaraidh on August 21, 2009, 09:46:38 AM
Hi,

I am a pre-beginner, who would like to invest in a BC box for learning Scottish (Fergie MacDonald style; in my dreams ;) ) ceilidh music. I know the music well enough, as I am a piper, but obviously learning to play it on a melodeon is going to be a challenge...

To add to that I am in Botswana ::) !

Fergie advised me to get a Saltarelle, as that is what he plays (but he also sells the things, so not entirely unbiased), but that is a huge investment for someone at the end of the earth who has no chance to try before buying etc. (to be fair he did also mention Hohner as a brand that one could start on) I've also read the various threads here suggesting that in fact a Serenellini (Cloud) might represent better value. It seems I could get a second hand Cloud for just under 1000 pounds, but even that is quite a bit for something which I don't really know whether I am going to make a hand of or not.

Unfortunately all of the try before you buy advice, which I in principle agree with, is not going to apply, because I can't find melodeons even in South Africa. Any suggestions, should I go for something much cheaper and then go through the whole logistical exercise again when I can actually play? And any advice on getting an instrument independently appraised before buying?

Thanks for you help,

Ruaraidh
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Theo on August 21, 2009, 10:12:25 AM
If you don't want to spend as much as an Italian box would cost, then a Hohner Double Ray/Erica or a pokerwork would be a good choice.  Double Ray is the brand name Hohner use for the B/C version of the Erica,  Secondhand pokerworks in B/C turn up occasionally.

Cheaper Chinese made brands do seem to be improving in quality, but I would definitely avoid them if you can't try them first.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: rees on August 21, 2009, 11:47:43 AM
I have a B/C Double Ray in stock. Practically unused at £350. www.melodeons.com (http://www.melodeons.com)
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 21, 2009, 12:29:35 PM
Quote
I have a B/C Double Ray in stock. Practically unused at £350. www.melodeons.com

Ruaraidh go for it - take Rees' arm off as well. You won't go wrong with it.
Welcome to the forum by the way - the man who first introduced me to the melodeon spent most of his life working out in Botswana as a missionary officer for the Salvation Army. Its great to meet up here with so many folk from all over the place. Best of luck.
AL
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Bill Young on August 21, 2009, 03:03:52 PM
Ruaraidh, you could hardly do better than start with a Double Ray, especially at that price. It would do you well after the beginner stage as well. It's a personal preference, but I like the Hohner tremolo sound more than the Salterelle's for Scottish music. If you take to the instrument, you might eventually want one with a slightly better action, and the Serenellini Cloud could come into consideration then (more so than the similarly-priced Salterelle Booby, but then I've never heard a Salterelle with a sound that I liked, including Fergie's. Loud - yes; pleasant - not really).
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: rees on August 21, 2009, 03:13:30 PM
Also in stock, a second-hand Irish Cloud in B/C. £1200.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 21, 2009, 03:18:34 PM
Quote
Also in stock, a second-hand Irish Cloud in B/C. £1200.
That's brilliant Rees - which means when our new friend is ready to move up to the cloud Ruaraidh will get a £350 trade in for the Double Ray!
AL ;)
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: rees on August 21, 2009, 03:21:47 PM
or a van load of balalaikas.......  :D
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Ruaraidh on August 21, 2009, 03:24:51 PM
"but then I've never heard a Salterelle with a sound that I liked, including Fergie's. Loud - yes; pleasant - not really"

 ;D

Could be that my memories of Appin village hall and the Clanranald / Fergie's are clouded by more than just fresh air and exercise!

I'll maybe try for that Gaelic IV two row on ebay. If that doesn't work I'll be in touch with Rees (think I've been convinced to go for the two step approach for the time being, thanks Rees, so I suppose the cloud will be going elsewhere - you can keep the balalaikas). Can I interest you in a good set of Strathmore pipes, hardly worth keeping three sets if I am buying a button box?

Ruaraidh

Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Bill Young on August 21, 2009, 06:33:41 PM
"but then I've never heard a Salterelle with a sound that I liked, including Fergie's. Loud - yes; pleasant - not really"

 ;D

Could be that my memories of Appin village hall and the Clanranald / Fergie's are clouded by more than just fresh air and exercise!
Ruaraidh
Don't get me wrong. I'm a great admirer of Fergie's music, otherwise wouldn't have gone 6 years running to his course on Skye. The overall ceilidh band sound is great. But I do think the Shand Morino he used to play sounded better.


I hope you're successful with the Gaelic IV. It's more than twice the box that the Double Ray is. (Robert Nairn used one to win the Mod medal for melodeon when it was in Perth). I'll be surprised if it doesn't go for several times the opening price.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 21, 2009, 07:31:08 PM
Quote
I'll be surprised if it doesn't go for several times the opening price.
Ay, probably right. I'd go for Rees' Double Ray. That way you'd know you were getting a good box from a reputable dealer - in tune and fully functional without the inherent risks that eBay sometimes engenders - not that the Gaelic looks anything other than in excellent condition - I know nothing about the vendor. But if I were to buy blind I'd rather get from a good quality dealer than an open auction.
AL
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Graeme on August 24, 2009, 05:06:21 PM
I bought my B/C Double Ray for the same reasons as you Ruaridh (the photo is my daughter as Fergie's number one fan on Skye last year with the bold man himself) and have had it a couple of years now. Most of the tunes I am learning are of the Fergie genre. I also have a Gaelic IV BCC# but revert to the Double Ray when trying to get to grips with the hard bits, of which there are many. Lucky you having Fergie playing at your wedding. I agree that what Rees has on offer will stand you in good stead for many years. Welcome to the site and best of luck with your acquisition.

Graeme
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: rees on August 24, 2009, 08:20:23 PM
erm... what are Strathmore pipes? Excuse my Welsh iggorunce, I am intrigued.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Bill Young on August 24, 2009, 09:14:19 PM
erm... what are Strathmore pipes? Excuse my Welsh iggorunce, I am intrigued.
Here you go. (http://www.hendersonreedmakers.com/)
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Ruaraidh on August 24, 2009, 09:18:27 PM
A maker of (good quality) highland bagpipes - the usual 100dB in other words. They're well made from blackwood - with great harmonics between the drones and chanter when tuned (none of this musette tuning!). Mine are #3 on the above link  (thanks Bill). As I have a set of silver mounted Naill pipes as well and smallpipes by Julian Goodacre, these are surplus to requirements. Since the Gaelic IV was beyond a beginner's purse, I now need to consider the Double Ray...
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: rees on August 25, 2009, 12:27:32 AM
and how difficult might they be to play if one has never actually squeezed one before?
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Ruaraidh on August 25, 2009, 01:40:48 PM
Returning to the topic in hand, I requested a price for the Double Ray and the Morgane from the Hohner importer in South Africa. He tells me they are both the same price? And that price is..... 13,800, or £925. I'm pretty sure Rees can beat that, even with carriage.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: rees on August 25, 2009, 02:06:08 PM
blimey!  :o
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Bill Young on August 25, 2009, 02:13:44 PM
Returning to the topic in hand, I requested a price for the Double Ray and the Morgane from the Hohner importer in South Africa. He tells me they are both the same price? And that price is..... 13,800, or £925. I'm pretty sure Rees can beat that, even with carriage.
Those prices seem ridiculous - high import duty or something? Sorry that idea seems to be a non-starter.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: risto on August 25, 2009, 03:51:34 PM
Returning to the topic in hand, I requested a price for the Double Ray and the Morgane from the Hohner importer in South Africa. He tells me they are both the same price? And that price is..... 13,800, or £925. I'm pretty sure Rees can beat that, even with carriage.

If you decide to go for the Morgane B/C form Rees, maybe you could discuss with him if he sees fit and can do something with the basses. That is, having those 3rds removed from the chords would make them more useful. If you don't have anyone there to do these kinds of jobs it would perhaps be better to have everything fixed and set up rightaway.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: risto on August 25, 2009, 03:58:47 PM
PS. Yes, the price  £925 is ridicilous. 2 years ago I paid 650 euros (with current rate appr. £744) including shipping. Rees's price £700 is very good indeed, you probably can't get it any cheaper.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: Owen Woods on August 25, 2009, 07:42:27 PM
Hah. You seen the prices that the Music Room are charging for a Bouebe? I couldn't believe my eyes.
Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: ganderbox on August 25, 2009, 09:42:52 PM
I don't believe any of the Music Room prices, new or second-hand.

P.S.  Is anybody actually buying Tommys as £2999? (although of course the Music Room are not alone in charging this price)

Title: Re: Beginner, logistically challenged
Post by: risto on August 26, 2009, 04:39:59 PM
PS. Yes, the price  £925 is ridicilous. 2 years ago I paid 650 euros (with current rate appr. £744) including shipping. Rees's price £700 is very good indeed, you probably can't get it any cheaper.

Hmm, I seem to have the currency rate wrong way around. The 650 euros I paid for the Morgane is actually appr. £570. That's a bargain.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal