Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: petefoth on January 01, 2008, 03:50:22 PM

Title: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: petefoth on January 01, 2008, 03:50:22 PM
Hi
I have just started learning to play on a 2 row C/F box. As I couldn't find any tutorials for a C/F box, after a quick skim I bought a copy of Dave Mallinson's absolute beginners book for D/G box. In it, he says the following
Quote
...when you learn a tune in C on your C/F box...you still need to read it in the key of D...
Learn to read music for the D/G system only: anything more will introduce confusion and is totally unnecessary. Whatever system you are playing, always transpose your music to D, G or occasionally A to read it
Am I correct in thinking that
(I'm quite happy whit the mechanics of transposing, having spent years in a past life accompanying myself and others with three or more chords on a 12-string guitar. I can also use various ABC tools to produce notes in whatever key is most appropriate)

Thanks for any advice on this issue

Regards (and Happy New Year)

Pete Fotheringham
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 01, 2008, 05:14:41 PM
the simplest way to use a DG tutor for a CF box is to pretend that it is a DG box     i.e. that your third button push on the inside row really plays G rather than F and the third button on outside row plays D rather than C etc etc etc.

You can then use any DG Tutor book,   if it gives some form of notation indicating which button to press & in which bellows direction  you can use that or you can read the dots directly onto the keyboard whcih you have majicaly deemed to be in the keys of D & G!

All will work perfectly well exept that the box will automatically transpose what you are playing int0 the keys of C or F!.  Once you have learned how to physically play the box  you can then deem it back to being itself i.e. CF  and proceed accordingly . 

The problem comes if you really want to play with others in D or G and at that point its worth thinking about buying a DG box.

george ( wishing everybody a happy new year)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: TomB-R on January 01, 2008, 11:02:48 PM
Nicely put!

I guess the only time when this approach is likely to be a problem is if you are one of the tiny minority of people who have "perfect pitch" or a sense of absolute pitch.  (If you've got it you can sing a C or whatever on demand with no reference to anything else.)
Not many people have it, and it's probably as much a curse as a benefit for musicians!
Tom
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: trombonetom on January 02, 2008, 10:06:39 AM
How can it be a curse? If you're tuning, it's a godsend. And you can use to winv bets. I don't have it, but i wish i did. :(
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 02, 2008, 11:07:05 AM
How can it be a curse? If you're tuning, it's a godsend. And you can use to winv bets. I don't have it, but i wish i did. :(
It can be a curse, because it means that you might be at a disadvantage if you ever want to play transposing instruments, such as clarinets, saxophones, trumpet, horn, etc. using written music, i.e. if you want to play in a band or orchestra.

In these cases, the written music is usually transposed for you - so, to take my own case of playing the clarinet in an orchestra, when I see a written C, I finger and play what I have learned to be a C, but the actual pitch of the note which is produced is a B-flat.

I don't have perfect pitch, so it is not a problem for me, but for people that do have this 'gift', the effects of the mental/aural disparity (caused by seeing one note on the page and yet hearing a completely different sound on playing it) can range from confusing to downright uncomfortable. I have heard someone describe it as being forced to accept that an object's colour is green, when you yourself know that it is red.

Hope this helps explain this double-edged sword.

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: trombonetom on January 02, 2008, 11:37:14 AM
I see your point, but can't people just ignore it?
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 02, 2008, 11:49:23 AM

I don't have perfect pitch, so it is not a problem for me, but for people that do have this 'gift', the effects of the mental/aural disparity (caused by seeing one note on the page and yet hearing a completely different sound on playing it) can range from confusing to downright uncomfortable. I have heard someone describe it as being forced to accept that an object's colour is green, when you yourself know that it is red.

I've certainly heard of it being a problem amongst singers of early music where the tuning standard can vary quite widely, something like A=415 to A=465, potentially leading to everything sounding a semitone out.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 02, 2008, 12:07:26 PM
I see your point, but can't people just ignore it?

I've heard people with perfect pitch say that it can be a curse as much as a blessing.  For instance if an orchestra is pitched to A=435 Hz the listener with perfect pitch hears it all as slightly flat which riles them.  Although I've not got anything approaching perfect pitch some sounds I find highly irritating, such as triangles and symbols, and if they are overused by a band pretty rapidly all I hear is the horrible sound of the triangle or symbol to the exclusion of everything else.

It's a bit like using incorrect grammer most people happily ignore it but for some people it drives them up the wall, I guess it's just they way they're built
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: trombonetom on January 02, 2008, 12:08:38 PM
A=440Hz, unless you're in Germany, where I think it is 445Hz
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 02, 2008, 12:47:42 PM
A=440Hz, unless you're in Germany, where I think it is 445Hz

A=440Hz is only a convention Tom, not the law, and from what I've heard many orchestras, especially on the continent, don't "abide" by this convention.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 02, 2008, 01:30:17 PM
A=440Hz, unless you're in Germany, where I think it is 445Hz

A=440Hz is only a convention Tom, not the law, and from what I've heard many orchestras, especially on the continent, don't "abide" by this convention.

The excellent Dr. Blood (great name that) has an article on the Dolmetsch website discussing the history of pitch http://www.dolmetsch.com/musictheory27.htm (http://www.dolmetsch.com/musictheory27.htm) as well as temperament (if you're having trouble sleeping).

It's interesting that after an international standard was set, tuning continued to be widely variable.

Tom is quite right that there tended to be a preference for a slightly higher pitch on the continent (I put it down to the French axiom of rules being for the others). I don't know if that is still the case.

What's more, there used to be a practice in the old days of vinyl to adjust the pitch when cutting the master to get it on the disc, to the point where sometimes the pitch of two movements of a symphony would be slightly different on the same recording.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 02, 2008, 02:08:12 PM
Tom is quite right that there tended to be a preference for a slightly higher pitch on the continent (I put it down to the French axiom of rules being for the others). I don't know if that is still the case.

The explaination I heard was that it was down to fiddle players (or similar) who preferred the sound of their instruments when they were tuned a bit sharp (brighter sounding) so the other instruments followed them up whereupon the fiddlers upped the ante again (materials technology permitting of course) so over the years the pitch has risen by up to 6 semitones from where it "started" from.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: trombonetom on January 02, 2008, 03:36:25 PM
3 Tones!! Are you sure? it seems a bit much. I could understand maybe 1 tone but not three.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 02, 2008, 04:02:08 PM
I see your point, but can't people just ignore it?
:-[

Yes, I suppose so, much in the same way that you can ignore a belting migraine, or excruciating toothache.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 02, 2008, 05:48:45 PM
.... so over the years the pitch has risen by up to 6 semitones from where it "started" from.
Do you really mean 6 semitones? I could believe 6 Hz....
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 02, 2008, 06:17:12 PM
.... so over the years the pitch has risen by up to 6 semitones from where it "started" from.
Do you really mean 6 semitones? I could believe 6 Hz....

I think its a mistake to assume that changes in pitch have always been upwards.  In the Dolmetsch link posted previously by Roy the highest pitch for A (current concert pitch 440Hz) is 570.7Hz in the year 1619, and the lowest 376.3Hz in 1700.
I see it more as a gradual convergence as musicians gradually became more mobile and wanted to play with people from further afield, combined with the invention and increased popularity of fixed pitch keyboard instruments.

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 02, 2008, 06:33:52 PM
Wikipedia says (so it must be true ::)) that A has been as low as about 307Hz (flattened D#) but 376Hz is a sharp F# so as Theo says that's about 3 semitones.

I think pitch inflation was a problem in the 17th cent:

From Wikipedia On at least two occasions, pitch inflation has become so severe that reform became needed. At the beginning of the 17th century, Michael Praetorius reported in his encyclopedic Syntagma musicum that pitch levels had become so high that singers were experiencing severe throat strain and lutenists and viol players were complaining of snapped strings. The standard voice ranges he cites show that the pitch level of his time, at least in the part of Germany where he lived, was at least a minor third higher than today's.  which seems to tally with what I remember reading years ago in some music book I had.

Anyway, back to the original question - look at these boxes as different capo positions on a guitar you may finger a G chord but it comes out as an A with the capo on the second fret.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: petefoth on January 03, 2008, 09:00:14 AM
Thanks for the replies, and for an interesting discussion of perfect pitch, which will certainly not be a problem for me!
Regards
Pete
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 03, 2008, 09:06:50 AM
Thanks for the replies, and for an interesting discussion of perfect pitch, which will certainly not be a problem for me!
Regards
Pete
Yes - we did rather stray off-topic.  :o
I think George Garside's first reply to your query has answered it very well. I hope it was helpful.

Just as an  aside, I have recently acquired a C/F Erica which I am enjoying playing. The whole tone step down in pitch from a D/G box, although it doesn't sound much, definitely results in a perceivable mellowness, even when playing on my own.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 03, 2008, 09:22:12 AM
.... so over the years the pitch has risen by up to 6 semitones from where it "started" from.
Do you really mean 6 semitones? I could believe 6 Hz....

I think its a mistake to assume that changes in pitch have always been upwards.  In the Dolmetsch link posted previously by Roy the highest pitch for A (current concert pitch 440Hz) is 570.7Hz in the year 1619, and the lowest 376.3Hz in 1700.
I see it more as a gradual convergence as musicians gradually became more mobile and wanted to play with people from further afield, combined with the invention and increased popularity of fixed pitch keyboard instruments.



Yes, I was pretty gobsmacked by the wide variance which was probably down to there being no easily portable pitch reference. That organ at A=570 was probably an attempt to clear the belfry of bats.

Just think of the fun we would all have if our boxes were tuned differently for each county we went to (and how much tuning work you would get Theo). Still, up in your neck of the woods there are still the pipes players keeping tradition alive.

Last night I was having a look at the blurb on temperaments in the article I mentioned and, before my eyes glazed over, I was amazed by how many different temperaments have been proposed. No sign of Melodeon or Accordion, but it did mention Hammond Organ Tuning (I always thought they sounded a bit "special").

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: press on regardless on January 03, 2008, 02:39:53 PM


From a musical dunce's perspective the only problem I can see is if that if you eventually change to a DG box you will be massively disappointed with its sound compared to the sweet CF, or is this just me?
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 03, 2008, 02:55:48 PM
No, I prefer the sound of a CF to DG and I think Steve_F does too (and Rich Arrowsmith uses a CF for Pecsaetan I believe).
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 03, 2008, 03:57:47 PM


From a musical dunce's perspective the only problem I can see is if that if you eventually change to a DG box you will be massively disappointed with its sound compared to the sweet CF, or is this just me?

its more likely to do with the gradual deteriation in hearing that goes with increasing age!  I too prefer the sound on CF  and wondered why until I haad a hearing test  which revealed that I have SLIGHT difficulty picking up higher pitches , which the audiologist said is quite normal - later that day it dawned on my why I prefer the sound of C or G!

on the 3 row I often transpose stuff into  AEBflats which also sound quite nice & is dead easy on a BCC#!!

george
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: press on regardless on January 03, 2008, 04:10:28 PM
CAN YOU SPEAK UP PLEASE GEORGE
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Jake Middleton (brinwins) on January 19, 2008, 10:22:44 AM
I also started on the malison absolute beginners, some say its too wordy but I found it to be really very good. As for c/f and D/g i cant say much more than has already been said, but here is a youtube video of a man playing morris music (as usually played on a D/G) on a C/F box:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=2FvW_7LqNaA
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Brian Peters on January 20, 2008, 12:28:32 PM
Anyone who's ever had any kind of tutoring from me (and hello to those of you already on this thread) will know that I advocate using the ears and brain whenever possible.  The logic of the melodeon is such that sight-reading directly onto the right-hand buttons is actually quite hard unless you have a lot of experience, so for most of the twenty-odd years I've been playing, I've sight-read the tune (or used a piano keyboard in extremis), learned it in my head, then worked it out on the melodeon, essentially by trail and error.  If you already know a tune like, say, "Princess Royal" in your head, then you can learn it on any melodeon regardless of key.

What the Mally book means by "learning to read music in the keys of D & G" is something I'm not quite clear about.  When you learn how to read music 'properly' you usually start with a C scale and progress gradually onto scales with more accidentals.  To read music in only two keys would mean you couldn't, for instance, read a tune from sheet music in C or A, and adapt it for your D/G box.

But yes, the general point is that the fingering is essentially the same regardless of the key of instrument.  Tablature will work regardless - although I'm not a great fan of that either!
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 20, 2008, 03:40:37 PM
Anyone who's ever had any kind of tutoring from me (and hello to those of you already on this thread) will know that I advocate using the ears and brain whenever possible.  The logic of the melodeon is such that sight-reading directly onto the right-hand buttons is actually quite hard unless you have a lot of experience <snip>

Yes, but I think it's worth the learning effort! Many other instruments, especially brass instruments like the trumpet, do not have fingering that follows what we find on a score like a piano would. I agree with the memory thing, but sight-reading definitely has its benefits whether it's a melodeon, piano or clarinet. I've come across too many players who knew nothing about music theory, and to me it's a major handicap, especially when you want to join a group of serious or pro musicians.


 
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Lester on January 20, 2008, 03:47:37 PM
I've come across too many players who knew nothing about music theory, and to me it's a major handicap, especially when you want to join a group of serious or pro musicians.
I 100% agree about the music theory part of your argument. The more I understand music theory the easier many aspects of melodeon playing becomes. I wish I had bothered many years ago.
But I do disagree re sight reading many of the people I know who do sight read seem to have to have the music in front of them all the time and are constrained by the way it is written. I believe writing down folk music is the first step in killing it. YMMV
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 20, 2008, 04:10:52 PM
I'm with you there Lester.  I can read notation to the extent that given a bit of time I can work out a tune from notation, but I certainly can't sight read.  I reckon its actually impossible to "sight read" traditional material because the notation records only a skeleton on which to build the music.  So much information about dynamics, timing, rhythm, ornamentation is missing, and rightly so.  It would take out most of the fun if everything was down on paper.

I left a band partly because of the sight readers in it.  We were pro musicians in that we got paid to play.  I always adopted the principle that if I was giving a paid performance I should know the music well enough to not require notation in front of me.  I finally realised  that I had to go when I looked across at the band leader while we were playing something as well known as Jamie Allan and his full attention was on the notation.  We had been playing together for several years at that point and the material was well rehearsed and familiar.  Really no need for that in my humble opinion.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 20, 2008, 04:35:13 PM
 agree with Theo - some ability to read the dots is useful to get an outline of a tune  or to sort out the bit you can't get quite right by ear.  However many , but by no means all, classicaly trained musicians sole aim is to play the stuff exactly as written, not even indulging in the slightest variation, alteration or whatever.
  The theory of crotchets, quavers etc is fine as far as it goes  but a good traditional musician may well feel inclined to play  a crotchet minus  9% or plus a 'wee bit' which cannot be shown on written music, thus varying the gap between notes. 

The funny thing is that at the top of the musical pile the classical people do much the same as do traditional  players. I think the following quote by the concert pianist Artur Schnabel ( can't remember where I nicked it from) says it all.

"The notes I  handle no better than many pianists, but the pauses between the notes - Ah that is where the art resides."

george

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 20, 2008, 08:50:41 PM
Yes, but I think it's worth the learning effort! Many other instruments, especially brass instruments like the trumpet, do not have fingering that follows what we find on a score like a piano would. I agree with the memory thing, but sight-reading definitely has its benefits whether it's a melodeon, piano or clarinet. I've come across too many players who knew nothing about music theory, and to me it's a major handicap, especially when you want to join a group of serious or pro musicians.

Sorry, but I could hardly differ from you more profoundly.

I know many of professional musicians who do not sight read.  Site reading has nothing to do with the proficiency of a folk/traditional musician.  In fact I've often seen it acting as a positive hindrance.

What do you get by sight reading?  Simply quick way of knocking off a few notes as written on a piece of paper.

Theo quite rightly points out that things such as "dynamics, timing, rhythm, ornamentation is missing", I would go further to say that It also cannot carry the understanding of how a player makes a tune fit upon a particular type of instrument and how a player uses the quirks of their instrument to embellish and improvise on a tune.  Music notation also cannot teach about the social context of a tune and how it should be played in that context.

It takes no account of local styles, no account of who you're playing with, what you're playing for or where you're playing. 

So, what does sight reading give you that is of use?  Can you learn a tune more quickly?  I would say no since you must go through exactly the same process as anybody else to truly start to understand the music.

Does it allow you to build a larger repertoire more quickly? If you call a book of sheet music a repertoire, then yes. If the mechanical recital of dots on a page is a repertoire, then yes.  If you never break away from the dots and start trying to understand the music properly, then yes.

I seriously cannot think of a single upside for a folk musician of site reading, I can however think of many downsides for those who aspire to play folk music.

I've seen those who have destroyed sessions by their ignorance in bringing music stands and blithely setting off into bizarre renditions of tunes made nonsensical by "sight reading".  I've also experienced the unbelief of classical musicians who have come to dances (as dancers) and cannot understand how we knew so many tunes.

The greatest skill for a folk musician is that of listening, observing and the practising, ie. actually experiencing and understanding the music in it's context.

Please, please, don't anybody be put off by thoughts of inadequacy because of the people who tell you that you *must* learn to read music, let alone sight read.  The melodeon is a simple instrument, the traditional tunes are simple, learn them and start doing them justice in the wild away from the stuffiness of "formal" music education and the musical snobs who have no understanding of what it's all about.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 21, 2008, 01:55:40 AM
I did not mean to say that written music is everything! It's a reference, and a way of passing along tunes that otherwise might be forgotten. Sound recordings or listening of live real performances are obviously better than written material, however scores can be used as a jump-start tool in learning the bases of a tune if there is no audio reference.

I don't understand that agressive attitude towards people who can use scores in order to help learning a tune! I never said one must learn how to sight read, I just said that it helps if you can do, and it can be a useful tool. I can play by ear and I can read, to me it's a nice thing to be able to do both.

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 21, 2008, 02:35:46 AM
Quote
I can play by ear and I can read, to me it's a nice thing to be able to do both.

Yes, I agree. I have classical training but learn all folk music stuff from records, from players who know the music. In this process notation is very handy and quick learning aid if you use transcribing.

I have to disagree with Brian Peters, the melodeon - referring to BC - is a very logical and simple instrument, after sixteen tunes I can sight read and play from notation, only the far ends with notes rarely used need some tinkering. Though it may be that the chromatic layouts are more easy to internalize I am absolutely sure that if you only played from notation it wouldn't take long till you remember where the notes are, even if there weren't any logic at all. That is one of the wonders of the human memory, you learn them by heart. After all there are only 42 notes to remember.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 21, 2008, 08:28:54 AM
I don't understand that agressive attitude towards people who can use scores in order to help learning a tune! I never said one must learn how to sight read, I just said that it helps if you can do, and it can be a useful tool. I can play by ear and I can read, to me it's a nice thing to be able to do both.



It's an attitude which surfaces every time sheet music gets mentioned on this forum. It's prevalent amongst those who don't sight read - "I can't do it so it's the work of the devil". I agree with you that it's a useful tool but not essential for folk music.

Oh and Andrew, you must know some really crappy classical players.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Lester on January 21, 2008, 09:01:59 AM
I don't understand that aggressive attitude towards people who can use scores in order to help learning a tune! I never said one must learn how to sight read, I just said that it helps if you can do, and it can be a useful tool. I can play by ear and I can read, to me it's a nice thing to be able to do both.
I believe you are misreading what people are saying. I use manuscript (very slowly) and ABC (a bit faster) to learn tunes regularly, I also learn by ear. I believe that if I learn by ear I can remember the tunes better. What I do think is wrong is people who ONLY play from "the dots". My view is that it makes their playing stilted as the manuscript only has the notes not the essence of the tune. Others have expressed this better in this thread.

This is my view of the world and you are more than entitled to disagree.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2008, 09:39:38 AM
I don't understand that agressive attitude towards people who can use scores in order to help learning a tune! I never said one must learn how to sight read, I just said that it helps if you can do, and it can be a useful tool. I can play by ear and I can read, to me it's a nice thing to be able to do both.

Hey François,  I think you are seeing aggression where none was intended.

My reading of this thread is that we all pretty much agree that notation is useful, so is learning by ear, so is playing from memory.  The debate seem to centre round the balance between these things.

I also think that we may mean different things by the term "sight reading".  Probably what some mean would be the skill prized among classical/orchestral players of "playing at sight"  ie being able to play a previously unseen piece at performance speed.  A keyboard player friend of mine can do this with a four part score.  Its an absolutely amazing skill, and of great value to him as a church organist.  It would help him much less in a ceilidh band, though he is also passably good at doing improvised piano accompaniment to almost anything!

Anyway getting back closer to the topic ;)
My experience is that D/G C/F or other fourth apart systems naturally lend themselves to playing by ear.   And because so many notes are duplicated it's less easy (not impossible, just less easy) to learn from notation because in most cases a single note on the stave can be played in two different places.  For example in the key of G major every note except C can be played in two different places, likewise in D major every note except C# and low E exists in two places.  So in addition to interpreting the written score, there is a decision to be made about where to play almost every note.

In B/C and C#/D (which I don't play) there are only two note duplicated between the rows, so much less decision making is required about where to play each note.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 21, 2008, 10:18:35 AM
just a couple of thoughts on this thread. I am not anything near a site reader as described by Theo. In fact I am like many traditional musicians in that I can read the music for any tune I already know! but otherwise struggle sometimes dot by dot!. But if I learn a tune from the dots (slowly) I find it much more difficult to play from memory.  It's almost as if the subconcious is saying 'I don't need to remember that because I can get the bit of paper out again next time'. 
On the other hand if learned 'by ear' it has to be commited to the memory  as ( with a bit of prompting  I can play tunes I havn't played for years so the bare bones of them must lurk somewhere in the brain for a very long time. 
this must be why those who learn from the dots become dependent on them.  When teaching a good dot reader I  swiftly remove the sheet of music part way through a tune in the hope that the player will then continue without it.  I also suggest that good readers when practicing/playing at home  turn round part way through a tune so they cant see the dots. - it works quite well in converting site readers into good listeners.(I find that many readers rely totally on visual  input to the brain & hence down the arm to the fingers & buttons and don't opperate a 'feedback loop' via the ear!)

I would however agree that some command of the dots i.e. a simple melody line, is very useful at times just to kick start a tune that you may only have a vague idea of or perhaps only know by memory the first few bars.

 for session playing reliance on dots is a total handicap. A few years ago when  leading a very large session at Sidmouth (around 150 players) an elderly lady ( probably about my age! but I still think I'm about thirty!!!) with large piano accordion turned up early, her husband was carrying  a suitcase full of sheet music and music stand!  She asked me what tunes we would be playing.  My reply was 'just try to busk as best you can as I have no idea what is going to be played or in what order, and if you happen to have the music, which is fairly unlikely we will be tree tunes furthur on by the time you find it!  Thankfully she stayed aand had a go at busking for the first time in her life - and more importantly enjoyed it.

I too am envious of the true site reader who can , without previous knowledge, play a complicated orchestral piece at performance speed and high quality - but of course the aim is to play exactly as written, the conductor having already made any adjustments to the dots to put his stamp on it ----hence the joke ' what is the definition of an orchestra?  - a bloody big musical instrument played by a conductor'

george (feeling verbose this morning)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 21, 2008, 02:13:38 PM
this must be why those who learn from the dots become dependent on them

Oh come on George, you're just Trolling now.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Stiamh on January 21, 2008, 02:55:07 PM
My experience is that D/G C/F or other fourth apart systems naturally lend themselves to playing by ear.   And because so many notes are duplicated it's less easy (not impossible, just less easy) to learn from notation because in most cases a single note on the stave can be played in two different places.  For example in the key of G major every note except C can be played in two different places, likewise in D major every note except C# and low E exists in two places.  So in addition to interpreting the written score, there is a decision to be made about where to play almost every note.

But then surely you have to make that same decision even when you're playing by ear?  So what's the big deal?

If knowing where the duplicate notes are poses a particular difficulty for playing from written music, then it means you have to get to know your instrument well - another advantage!

I'm a very strong advocate for playing by ear and over years of teaching fiddle and tin whistle I have done my utmost to discourage learners from using sheet music - until they have really got a handle on the music they are trying to play - which may take years.

Once you do know what you are doing on your instrument, and in your idiom, being able to read music (either sight-reading proficiently, or being able to work out a tune from music) has to be an advantage. Why knock it?

Of course, thousands of utterly fantastic trad musicians cannot read music - clearly you don't need to be able to read to master a folk idiom. But it's still a very useful skill, and I don't see the point of arguing otherwise.

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2008, 03:40:19 PM
But then surely you have to make that same decision even when you're playing by ear?  So what's the big deal?

Interesting point,  I'd not thought of it that way.  I suppose I was mentally making a comparison with other instruments.  Recently learning the fiddle I find the notation makes more sense with the fiddle. I'd put that down to traditional fiddle having only one fingering for most notes, and even when using the 4th finger to avoid changing strings there are no harmonic consequences as there are with the changes in bass availability when you choose to play on push or pull on a D/G box.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 21, 2008, 04:32:36 PM
I  find it more difficult to read music on the DG than the BC, finding it easier in G than D (on the DG).  As a player of both systems I think the difference could be that the origins of the 4th apart boxes  were simply the sticking together  effectively of two single row boxes  to provide 2 keys without any particular intention of them being played 'accross the row' as  composite item.

There is, in my opinion, a lack of logic in that  if playing on the row eg the Gs As etc are in different directions  and are not logically situated adjacent to each other. On the other hand the BC box is perfectly logical & works systamatically  in that the C row is like piano white notes  and the B row the black ones.  You therefore use exactly the same notes (and buttons) for ALL th white notes irrespective of what key you are playing in, so its much easier to remember where they are.  The appropriate 'black notes'  are played on the B row and  again there is only one of each so it is always where it belongs.  The duplicated B & E  do not need to be used untill proficient  but offer  the experienced player  some useful options.  The BCC# works in exactly the same way  for a beginner but offers  a great many more options that  make playing much easier but that are not essential.

When playing a Dg ( which I do quite a lot of) I stick on the row most of the time  one reason being that I can easily forget which type of box I'm playing and have a nasty accident musically speaking.

george
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2008, 05:33:36 PM
......I think the difference could be that the origins of the 4th apart boxes  were simply the sticking together  effectively of two single row boxes  to provide 2 keys without any particular intention of them being played 'accross the row' as  composite item. ...

Interesting theory. Is there any evidence for that origin George? 
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 21, 2008, 06:46:28 PM
<snip>
Once you do know what you are doing on your instrument, and in your idiom, being able to read music (either sight-reading proficiently, or being able to work out a tune from music) has to be an advantage. Why knock it?
<snip>
Exactly. Music-reading skills means that you can read a chart and actually "hear" what is written and/or sing it; once you get the structure of the tune in your head you can play it on the [put the instrument name here] and add your artistic color to it without needing the chart anymore: it has just been used to get started. This is very different than reading a chart and merely do what an orchestra conductor tells you to do!


Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 21, 2008, 07:12:05 PM
[
Interesting theory. Is there any evidence for that origin George? 
 
There may well be but so far I havn't found it so my statement  is pure conjecture! My thinking is based on the one row following the mouth organ  ,   and that somebody must have had the bright idea of making one box playable in 2 keys to save having to buy  & cart around 2 boxes etc etc. presumably at some later stage somebody else must have thought why not make the buggers a semitone apart so they are chromatic in theory.Then somebody else trotted along and said let's add another row to make it even more chromatic, but it was very big & clumsy, then a man called Shand had the bright idea of combining three rows of buttons with only two rows of pallets and it became much more compact. Can the 'history' experts throw any light on any ofthis.

george
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2008, 07:22:59 PM
George I'm no history expert, but my observation is that the oldest two-rows I've seen have all been C/C#.  This is a small and completely random sample so may meant very little.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 22, 2008, 12:46:37 AM
Quote
... the BC box is perfectly logical & works systamatically  in that the C row is like piano white notes  and the B row the black ones. 

I've heard of that approach but in that way of thinking the places of the sharp notes are not cosistent in regard to the naturals when you go from low to high.

I see the B row as the flattened C row. In my mind I convert the sharps notes to flattened notes and vica versa. (D#=Eb etc.)  Sounds complicated? Perhaps, but it has the advantage that there is no shifting and you always find the flattened note from the B row right below the corresponding natural and always having the same bellows direction as the natural. For instance, if I need C# I think it as Db and voila it's right there under the D natural. The B row being also physically half button "flat" to the C row somehow lead to this thinking and it seems to work, at least for me.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: EeeJay on January 22, 2008, 11:11:34 AM
origins of the 4th apart boxes  were simply the sticking together  effectively of two single row boxes  to provide 2 keys without any particular intention of them being played 'accross the row' as  composite item.

This a bit of a proverbial "chicken and the egg" argument. I'm not entirely convinced...

I know the stories of some the old English musicians, about being asked what the other row is for, replying "oh, thats a spare in case the other row breaks"... Yet certain traditions (such as those across Latin America) row cross like crazy, and this is integral to what they play...

... then a man called Shand had the bright idea of combining three rows of buttons with only two rows of pallets and it became much more compact.

Nope.... goes back years before Mr Morino met Mr Shand - Émile Vacher was playing such a machine round Paris in the 1920's...

Here's a snippet off Daniel Dénecheau's website... (http://denecheau.free.fr/spip.php?article28) in French, but fairly understandable. Loads of nice pics. Plus it makes the link between the "accordéon mixte" and '"british chromatic" systems - developed in isolation and a 30 year time gap, but essentially so similar...

Ed J
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 22, 2008, 11:54:22 AM

This a bit of a proverbial "chicken and the egg" argument. I'm not entirely convinced...

I know the stories of some the old English musicians, about being asked what the other row is for, replying "oh, thats a spare in case the other row breaks"... Yet certain traditions (such as those across Latin America) row cross like crazy, and this is integral to what they play...


I suspect (again with no supporting evidence) that the limitations of a one row box were apparent and the adding of an extra row was a logical step in the development of the instrument.  There were possibly two schools of thought in that some players wanted a chromatic instrument (Scots/Irish?) and the second row became accidentals and others (Continental Europe/America?) wanted a much smoother sound so the addition of an inner row tuned a fourth higher enabled cross rowing and a much smoother bellows action.  If we ignore for the moment the "English" two row style which seems to be an abberation, this difference seems to be Irish/Scottish chromatic vs Rest of the World Fourth.  The English seem to have developed the almost one-row style on a two row box.

What I would add in support of my thesis is the range of Italian one-row boxes (I don't how far they go back) with an extra part- or complete row designed to allow cross-rowing for the whole octave or more (with even the Dutch reversal allowing the doh note in both directions).

Just my ideas on the subject.

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 22, 2008, 02:39:57 PM
Noooo, not aggression here, just assertiveness  ;)

So, why be assertive about this sight-reading thing?

I've come across so much musical snobbery and ignorance about folk music from many "trained" musicians or those who plead their case that I will tend to react. I feel concerned that people will be put off from trying to play because they are made to feel that they are not in the charmed circle of specially gifted and trained people.

Music on a page (or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music. This is especially so for folk music.  The folk idiom(s) (thanks SteveJones, that's the word I was struggling for in my previous post) can only be learnt from from it's practice.

Would I argue that you should never refer to written music on any occasion?  Of course not.  Though I think SteveJones explains the best approach to the written text for anyone learning a folk idiom (usefull word, eh).
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 22, 2008, 02:51:09 PM
[ ]
 ... the BC box is perfectly logical & works systamatically  in that the C row is like piano white notes  and the B row the black ones. 
[/quote]

I've heard of that approach but in that way of thinking the places of the sharp notes are not cosistent in regard to the naturals when you go from low to high.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  By far the easiest way of learning the location  the sharp (or flat if you prefer so to call them) notes is to practice scales (at least FCGD&AE on a BC box) the full length of the box until you can play them at a reasonable speed. In this way any sharps or flats that crop up as accidentals will be exactly where they always were & you will know instinctively where that is!

george

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 22, 2008, 02:53:24 PM
If we ignore for the moment the "English" two row style which seems to be an abberation

Not from an English point of view.  The rest of the world is an abberation  :P

It is an interesting question the extent to which the increasingly differing styles of English, Scottish and Irish (Welsh, what do they play???) players during the 20th century has been caused by the different systems.

Were the English always fated to go for a fifth apart two row, and the Irish/Scottish the semitone apart system?

If you get enough players of a certain system together in one area it becomes a self-fullfilling prophesy I suppose, but players such as John Kirkpatrick prove that the "bumpy" English style can certainly be played on the semitone apart system.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 23, 2008, 12:56:00 AM
Quote
...(or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music.

Gosh, you have to tell that to Kirkpatrick and all the rest too.  ;)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: TomB-R on January 23, 2008, 03:04:29 PM
I've come across so much musical snobbery and ignorance about folk music from many "trained" musicians or those who plead their case that I will tend to react.

I've come across as much, if not more, musical snobbery and ignorance amongst "folk musicians" directed at the classical types than in the other direction.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 23, 2008, 03:44:21 PM
I've come across so much musical snobbery and ignorance about folk music from many "trained" musicians or those who plead their case that I will tend to react.

I've come across as much, if not more, musical snobbery and ignorance amongst "folk musicians" directed at the classical types than in the other direction.

Hey but we are all big enough to rise above that stuff.  Music is too important to let that sort of thing be a worry.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 23, 2008, 04:25:09 PM
[quot
Hey but we are all big enough to rise above that stuff.  Music is too important to let that sort of thing be a worry.

 totally agree.  It is also unrpreductive to over generalise  as there are brilliant 'folk' musicians and brilliant 'classical' musicians. likewise there are the crap veriety of both genres.  The sad thing is that many of the crap veriety will always remain so  because they are totally entrenched in a very narrow furrow and forget there is often something to be learned  from other musicians irrespective of instrument or  musical background.
george
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: TomB-R on January 23, 2008, 04:26:36 PM
Well said, gents.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: rees on January 23, 2008, 05:56:03 PM
Most melodeon players in Wales play D/G or D/G + half row. There are also a handful of B/C and one -row players.
The style is adapted from the English but then most box players living in Wales are English anyway!
Shock horror .........!!!!
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 24, 2008, 12:07:02 PM
I've come across so much musical snobbery and ignorance about folk music from many "trained" musicians or those who plead their case that I will tend to react.

I've come across as much, if not more, musical snobbery and ignorance amongst "folk musicians" directed at the classical types than in the other direction.

and I love classical music  8)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 24, 2008, 12:11:45 PM
Quote
...(or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music.

Gosh, you have to tell that to Kirkpatrick and all the rest too.  ;)

I think he already knows   :P
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 24, 2008, 12:36:54 PM
Music on a page (or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music. This is especially so for folk music.
Does that mean that people shown on photographs are dead too?
Recording devices and musical notation have been invented so we can transmit the music to other people without having to play it. There is good and bad in this, but I can tell you that in the case of folk music, it's been rather useful to be able to pass along one's repertoire to other people, even after the original player has passed away!!!
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 24, 2008, 02:13:43 PM
Music on a page (or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music. This is especially so for folk music.
Does that mean that people shown on photographs are dead too?
Recording devices and musical notation have been invented so we can transmit the music to other people without having to play it. There is good and bad in this, but I can tell you that in the case of folk music, it's been rather useful to be able to pass along one's repertoire to other people, even after the original player has passed away!!!


Ooh, shock horror, Francois. Surely if you didn't sit at the master's right hand and learn it by ear, it's not folk.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 25, 2008, 12:03:02 AM
Quote
...(or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music.

Gosh, you have to tell that to Kirkpatrick and all the rest too.  ;)

I think he already knows   :P

So if Kirkpartricks music is dead, then what is that on your web site?  ;)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 25, 2008, 07:37:05 PM
Quote
...(or even to a great extent on a CD) is dead music.

Gosh, you have to tell that to Kirkpatrick and all the rest too.  ;)

I think he already knows   :P

So if Kirkpartricks music is dead, then what is that on your web site?  ;)


Zombie music?  At least that's the living dead :-)

But, wait, did I say John Kirkpatrick's music is dead?  No, of course I didn't.

Also, for others, did I state that electronically recorded music, or even written music is useless?  No, of course I didn't.

I'm feeling ill and fractious so forgive me for going on a bit. (actually it's just a bit of a cold and sore throat, I hope to be out and about again tommorrow wowing the world with my musical antics...)

I also can misrepresent people by attributing beliefs that they have not expressed. For example, Beethoven completed his third symphony in 1804.  As it's written down on paper, you're saying it doesn't need to be performed?  As it has been recorded already, you're saying it doesn't need to be performed again?

A quotation often attributed to Martin Carthy goes along the lines that the only way that you can damage folk music (song) is not to play (sing) it.  I'm not sure of the exact quotation, but I think my paraphrasing gets the gist of it. By the way, playing a CD doesn't count.

Even popular music and language understands this difference between "live" and recorded music.  "A live performance", "live from the proms".  As in the question about Beethoven, why do they bother?

A book is designed to be read. Left sitting on a bookshelf it becomes a mere artifact until someone performs the act of reading it.  Art is displayed in art galleries, and even shipped across the world as in the current exhibition of art from Russia at the Royal Academy.  There is nothing like the real thing.  A collection of music or dances on a library shelf may be interesting for an academic exercise, or for historical research, but as a current cultural phenomenon it needs to be performed.

Yes, of course there is discussion to be had. If Aristophanes had not written down his plays in Classical Greek times then none of the few that do survive would be known and so could not be performed.  However, it's their performance and reinterpretation that people watch and comes under discussion in Radio 4 arts programmes.

So, written sheet folk music is essentially dead music?  Yes, because folk music only has life when it is played and it's form in life is also given by it's cultural context; something a piece of paper cannot endow.  Just look at the changes in much of "traditional" Irish music as it drifts further away from dance.  Morris tunes also start to change their form when divorced from the dances. When you learn a tune and play it in different circumstances, with different people, over time, it changes, it develops. Go back to the recording, or the sheet music and you will find it unchanged, immutable.

Folk music only lives when it's done, by real living folk.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 25, 2008, 08:09:02 PM
Now it makes your thinking a bit clearer! Of course, music that is recorded or written is dead if nobody cares to play it. However, listening to recorded folk music for the joy of it is a good start!

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 25, 2008, 09:40:30 PM
Quote

Even popular music and language understands this difference between "live" and recorded music. 
...
 "Folk music only lives when it's done, by real living folk.


That is sematics. The problem in your explanation IMO is that you confuse the performance situation and the (essence of the) music itself. The recording of music played by living persons will not kill the music itself (EDIT: or the interpretation) but it may kill the athmosphere of the live performance because that usually can not be captured on a recording or even on video.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 25, 2008, 09:58:20 PM
Now it makes your thinking a bit clearer! Of course, music that is recorded or written is dead if nobody cares to play it. However, listening to recorded folk music for the joy of it is a good start!



Yes indeed, but if that is the only form (the recorded music that is) then people simply become consumers rather than participants.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 25, 2008, 09:59:03 PM
Indeed, folk music means nothing without the folks...
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 25, 2008, 10:13:09 PM
Quote

Even popular music and language understands this difference between "live" and recorded music. 
...
 "Folk music only lives when it's done, by real living folk.


That is sematics. The problem in your explanation IMO is that you confuse the performance situation and the (essence of the) music itself. The recording of music played by living persons will not kill the music itself (EDIT: or the interpretation) but it may kill the athmosphere of the live performance because that usually can not be captured on a recording or even on video.

Sorry, I'm not sure what you mean about "semantics"? Are you disagreeing on the interpretation of my words?

What you go on say only goes so far, it simply treats the music as a commodity or the product of a performance without regard to anything else in society.

Lastly, I agree, how can recording someone "kill the music itself"?  That's clearly, as you imply, ridiculous.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 25, 2008, 10:16:29 PM
<whisper>
This isn't simple thread drift, it's more like continental drift   :o
Did petefoth get a satisfactory answer to "Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor"?
</whisper>
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 25, 2008, 10:17:12 PM
Quote

Lastly, I agree, how can recording someone "kill the music itself"?  That's clearly, as you imply, ridiculous.


I agree and that is what your were actually saying.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 25, 2008, 10:35:37 PM
Quote

Lastly, I agree, how can recording someone "kill the music itself"?  That's clearly, as you imply, ridiculous.


I agree and that is what your were actually saying.

Wahey, this really is semantics now   ;D

No, it isn't what I was saying.  Simply recording someone doesn't kill a tradition, it also doesn't render "the music" as a generalisation, worthless.  A recording, however, only captures a moment in time and one single historical approach to a tune or a song and as such should be approached with circumspection.

How many times have you read or heard the phrase that some commercial recording or other is "the future of folk music"?   >:(
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: risto on January 26, 2008, 12:51:45 AM
Quote
How many times have you read or heard the phrase that some commercial recording or other is "the future of folk music"?   >:(

Probably never in those words, but all in all, recordings have changed the music tastes through out the world probably more than anything, including traditional music. Besides that recodings have has set new higher standards for playing skills.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 26, 2008, 09:13:00 AM
Quote
How many times have you read or heard the phrase that some commercial recording or other is "the future of folk music"?   >:(

Probably never in those words, but all in all, recordings have changed the music tastes through out the world probably more than anything, including traditional music. Besides that recodings have has set new higher standards for playing skills.

Wholly agree with Risto here.

I think you are misinterpreting what someone has written in a review Andrew. Yes they are reviewing a recording, but they are commenting on the performers and performances not that "the future of folk music is in listening to recordings".

Anyway, there's no difference in folk, rock, classical or whatever in this sense. The best way to enjoy music is to play it. 2nd is to listen to live performance, 3rd is recordings. But I wouldn't be without my hi-fi and CDs.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Alison Scott on January 26, 2008, 10:38:44 AM

Anyway, there's no difference in folk, rock, classical or whatever in this sense. The best way to enjoy music is to play it. 2nd is to listen to live performance, 3rd is recordings. But I wouldn't be without my hi-fi and CDs.


What a fascinating thread! But I think that as a way of enjoying music, dancing to it is right up there with playing it; certainly ahead of sitting and listening.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 26, 2008, 10:55:26 AM


What a fascinating thread! But I think that as a way of enjoying music, dancing to it is right up there with playing it; certainly ahead of sitting and listening.


Damn forgot that one - and me a dancer!! Hangs head in shame.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: petefoth on January 28, 2008, 09:36:28 AM
<whisper>
This isn't simple thread drift, it's more like continental drift   :o
Did petefoth get a satisfactory answer to "Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor"?
</whisper>
Yes thanks. I have also enjoyed the 'thread drift': I've been using online discussion forums since the mid eighties and I often find that the 'off-topic' discussion can be just as enlightening (if not more so) than the concise, just-answer-the-original-question replies. I'm grateful for both.

Cheers

Pete
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Theo on January 28, 2008, 10:01:34 AM
There was a wonderful example of thread drift over on concertina.net last year, in which the original topic developed into a  game of Mornington Crescent!  Some non-UK members found it perplexing.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: rees on January 28, 2008, 02:47:53 PM
Now we're talking.

Ladbroke Grove?
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Pushpull on January 28, 2008, 03:06:26 PM
Now we're talking.

Ladbroke Grove?

Hang on we haven't determined which rules we're playing. I think Theo should be chairman as he started it.

Roy.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 28, 2008, 03:22:16 PM
Now we're talking.

Ladbroke Grove?
No question as to the next move, then....
Oakwood (someone has to get it in......  :D)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Lester on January 28, 2008, 03:23:37 PM
There is a fine game underway on Concertina.net as we speak.

http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=7049&st=0 (http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=7049&st=0)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Malcolm Austen on January 29, 2008, 04:19:30 PM
If we were playing Mornington Crescent and this was the concertina net the next move from Ladbroke Grove should be Kensal Green.
 Next Move (http://www.stereoscopy.com/faq/wheatstone.html)

malcolm
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 29, 2008, 04:40:02 PM
If we were playing Mornington Crescent and this was the concertina net the next move from Ladbroke Grove should be Kensal Green.
 Next Move (http://www.stereoscopy.com/faq/wheatstone.html)
Malcolm - are you challenging the validity of the previous move (Oakwood), then?
I should point out that within the rules of the melodeon.net version, all references (obscure or otherwise) to a certain inventor are to be discouraged, if not banned, as this heightens the risk of being trapped in a Kensal Green loop (akin to a Dollis Hill loop, but more unstable, owing to its proximity to the target destination). As I'm sure you are aware, any attempt to gain the target destination from a Kensal Green loop is fraught with danger, due to the excess bellows pressures involved. In the worst-case scenario, immediate explosive warping to a Zone 4 location can occur without warning. This is usually followed by a reassessment period in Nidd lasting for a minimum of two turns.

Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Malcolm Austen on January 29, 2008, 08:55:49 PM
Steve,
I stand truly humbled............
but if you did make the move via Kensal Green, Oakwood only being allowed in a royal flush with Chorleywood, Colliers Wood, Northwood and St John's Wood, you could look up Brunel as well.
Now if only Brunel had turned his attention to the melodeon.
 
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: oldclubII on January 29, 2008, 09:48:35 PM
I  lived in the Ladbroke Grove area of London for about 6 months many years ago, but I have no idea what you guys are talking about here...
How about a little walk to Wormwood Scrubs?
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2008, 12:12:13 AM
...but if you did make the move via Kensal Green, Oakwood only being allowed in a royal flush with Chorleywood, Colliers Wood, Northwood and St John's Wood...

Damn! You are quite right. How could I have overlooked that? It must have been the stress of anticipating a Kensal Green loop (which fortunately, has not occurred, I'm so pleased to say). OK - I humbly withdraw Oakwood.
Quote
....you could look up Brunel as well.
In that case, I'll go for Paddington instead. (Is that allowed, Humph?)

Quote
Now if only Brunel had turned his attention to the melodeon.
It would have had a totally different sound owing to Brunel's acoustic innovation - the GWR (Great Wide Reed)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2008, 12:29:06 AM
I  lived in the Ladbroke Grove area of London for about 6 months many years ago, but I have no idea what you guys are talking about here...
http://www.isihac.co.uk/games/mcvariations/index.html
Quote
How about a little walk to Wormwood Scrubs?
Definitely not a valid move. You could try East Acton or White City, although moving to either (or both) of these from Ladbroke Grove may be considered risky unless all other players are in Nidd. But who am I to judge? Come, make your move and damn the torpedos.
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Dazbo on January 30, 2008, 09:00:51 AM
Ooo! can we play the Armitage shanks charity bowl rules?  Please, please, please, pretty please.

Finsbury Plop!

Title: Time to deactivate notification on this topic...
Post by: petefoth on January 30, 2008, 09:04:38 AM
...as MC has never been my favourite game.
Thanks for all the advice and I'll see you in other topics.
Regards
Pete
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: george garside on January 30, 2008, 10:45:55 AM
does this spread like a virus?

george
Title: Re: Time to deactivate notification on this topic...
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2008, 12:58:42 PM
...as MC has never been my favourite game.
Thanks for all the advice and I'll see you in other topics.
Regards
Pete
Ok Pete... Seeing as it was mostly me that hijacked your thread for MC, I guess I owe you an apology.
However, I thought you'd got all the genuine responses that you needed to answer your original query, so I suppose I didn't feel too bad about the thread drift.

Perhaps we need a separate thread for MC.  ;)
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2008, 12:59:52 PM
does this spread like a virus?
It has been known!
Title: Re: Time to deactivate notification on this topic...
Post by: george garside on January 30, 2008, 01:02:12 PM
 

Perhaps we need a separate thread for MC.  ;)
 

and why not!  although  personally I havn't a clue what it is or how its played

george
Title: Re: Learning on a C/F box from a D/G tutor
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 31, 2008, 09:44:00 PM
I  lived in the Ladbroke Grove area of London for about 6 months many years ago, but I have no idea what you guys are talking about here...
http://www.isihac.co.uk/games/mcvariations/index.html
Quote
How about a little walk to Wormwood Scrubs?
Definitely not a valid move. You could try East Acton or White City, although moving to either (or both) of these from Ladbroke Grove may be considered risky unless all other players are in Nidd. But who am I to judge? Come, make your move and damn the torpedos.

Nope, torpedoes are only relevant if you live in Peterborough.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal