Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andrew Kennedy on August 15, 2018, 10:23:57 AM
-
Does anybody recognise this? https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loffelbasse-Bauer-Akkordeon/163174019838?hash=item25fdedf2fe:g:WCkAAOSweLBaW5E0 (https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loffelbasse-Bauer-Akkordeon/163174019838?hash=item25fdedf2fe:g:WCkAAOSweLBaW5E0)
It's described as a Hohner Imperator V, but the Hohner product list attached to melnet gives the Imperator V as a piano accordion.
Any suggestions welcome.
AK
-
Sometimes people are editing old adds instead of creating new. May be Hohner and Imperator are relics of old add.
Sadly I can not say anything about this instrument except that it is melodeon/accordion and not bandonika for sure.
-
Does anybody recognise this? https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loffelbasse-Bauer-Akkordeon/163174019838?hash=item25fdedf2fe:g:WCkAAOSweLBaW5E0 (https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loffelbasse-Bauer-Akkordeon/163174019838?hash=item25fdedf2fe:g:WCkAAOSweLBaW5E0)
It's described as a Hohner Imperator V, but the Hohner product list attached to melnet gives the Imperator V as a piano accordion.
Any suggestions welcome.
AK
There's no mention of a Hohner Imperator V in the current Ebay listing. Perhaps (as Andrius has hinted) the listing has since been edited to remove the reference.
-
Yes, Andrius might have just hit the nail on the head there!
The seller has even left that which says "Pianoakkordeon Imperator V Diskanttasten (treble keys) 41 and HOHNER", so it definitely doesn't accord with the instrument for sale. My inexpert eye can see nothing in the pictures which would lead me to think that it was manufactured by Hohner, but maybe an expert can?
(I've just refreshed the page and that info is still there, Steve.)
-
Oh, so it is - I missed it in the small(er) print.
It doesn't look like a Hohner, but perhaps Triskel or someone else will tell us otherwise.
-
It doesn't look like a Hohner, but perhaps Triskel or someone else will tell us otherwise.
Nope! :o
-
In the description it says:
Musikinstitut C.A. Bauer Dresden
"Musikinstitut" translates to "institute of music"
"C.A. Bauer" is most definitely the name of a person
"Dresden" is a city in the eastern part of Germany
Maybe that helps someone? Most likely not. :P
-
Thanks for all the comments. There was only ever going to be one way to find out properly, so I've taken a punt and bought it. I'll continue this when it arrives.
AK
-
... I've taken a punt and bought it. I'll continue this when it arrives.
Goodness, that's very brave of you at the price! :o
It'd be not untypical of a better-quality style of Deutsche Harmonika that was not uncommon in Germany before WW1, but nevertheless it still probably has either "Ajax" (hard brass) or "Neusilber" (nickel-silver) reeds on long plates.
I have one that's somewhat similar (only it has real trumpets, whilst they're dummies on the eBay one), and it's quite a behemoth...
-
A fair point, but firstly, I can return it within 14 days if not satisfactory (and it was described as playable, admittedly an elastic concept), and secondly, I've just had two others off German Ebay at very reasonable prices, so in a way I'm ahead of the game.
We'll see. I've still got to smuggle it into the house.
AK
-
This title keeps catching my eye. I’m struck by the need to mark the last resting place of the unknown melodeon. Perhaps an empty case, q.v. the Cenotaph.
-
This title keeps catching my eye. I’m struck by the need to mark the last resting place of the unknown melodeon. Perhaps an empty case, q.v. the Cenotaph.
Just as a point of History Chris, The Cenotaph in Whitehall is not " an empty case" but contains the remains of one anonymous soldier chosen at random to represent all the others killed in wars.
-
Not sure about this. At the risk of going off-topic with regard to what was a lighthearted comment, cenotaph quite literally means 'empty tomb' in Greek; there is an unknown warrior buried in Westminster Abbey. The melodeon case would be just the thing if something awful had happened. Like my wife finding out I'd bought another one.
NB: I didn't manage to keep the Sousaphone secret.
AK
-
Respectfully sorry Henry, :( but the Unknown Soldier is buried in Westminster Abbey. (I bet you remember that now ... ). A cenotaph is a memorial put up because the person memorialised is buried elsewhere, the empty burial ship at Sutton Hoo was such a memorial. The London Cenotaph was built to remember the dead of the British Empire. Wikipedia does a better job than me here - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cenotaph,_Whitehall
Chris B.
-
Respectfully sorry Henry, :( but the Unknown Soldier is buried in Westminster Abbey. (I bet you remember that now ... ). A cenotaph is a memorial put up because the person memorialised is buried elsewhere, the empty burial ship at Sutton Hoo was such a memorial. The London Cenotaph was built to remember the dead of the British Empire. Wikipedia does a better job than me here - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cenotaph,_Whitehall
Chris B.
Absolutely Correct Chris and others !! My apologies I was confusing the two !! ….Now back to the post !!!
-
Does anybody recognise this? https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loffelbasse-Bauer-Akkordeon/163174019838?hash=item25fdedf2fe:g:WCkAAOSweLBaW5E0 (https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loffelbasse-Bauer-Akkordeon/163174019838?hash=item25fdedf2fe:g:WCkAAOSweLBaW5E0)
It's described as a Hohner Imperator V, but the Hohner product list attached to melnet gives the Imperator V as a piano accordion.
Any suggestions welcome.
AK
So E-bay is doing a really annoying thing and not letting me see the completed listing - instead it shows a similar item it thinks I might like. I do, it's a Hohner one row pressed wood style, but really we have enough melodeons in this house. Does anyone know how to get around this on E-bay?
-
...but really we have enough melodeons in this house. Does anyone know how to get around this on E-bay?
Not sure that Ebay can help you with that, H...
PS scrolling right down to the bottom of the page worked for me.
-
On the right of the page, is written "Originalartikel ansehen" click on that and it takes you there.
But you then have to scroll down a bit.
-
Photos from add for future, part 1
title:
Handharmonika diatonisch 2 reihige Bandonika 4 Löffelbässe Bauer Akkordeon
description:
Antikes Akkordeon
Musikinstitut C.A. Bauer Dresden
diatonisch
Zweireiher
4 Löffelbässe
Siehe Fotos
schöne Optik
sofort spielbar
Keine Rücknahme, keine Garantie, Privatverkauf
-
Photos from add for future, part 2
-
PS scrolling right down to the bottom of the page worked for me.
Thanks Malcolm. That works now I'm on the laptop but not from mobile.
-
Progress of a kind. The melodeon arrived and sounds very pleasant, although it's a little leaky. The nameplate (C.A. Bauer, Dresden) refers to the supplier rather than the manufacturer. Key is A/D, treble end absolutely as one might expect, but the four basses are organised along lines with which I'm unfamiliar, although the chords themselves are as expected. Details on attached pdf.
Meanwhile, at Whitby I found its big brother (photos attached). Specs are in the pdf, but it's in G/C and has 8 stops - right-hand end is a bit like two 4-rows cobbled together back-to-back. (Frank Lee saw it and asked where I'd bought my sideboard). Bass chords as expected for an 8-bass 2-row, but again on a different system. It sounds gorgeous, but some of the workmanship is crude. I'm wondering whether it is of post-WW2 Eastern European manufacture. I've not looked inside, and will not be opening it without good reason as I prefer to leave well alone.
Once again, any thoughts would be welcome.
-
Did you buy the big beasty? It looks very beastly.
-
I did indeed, and I love it. The only drawback is not only having to learn a new bass system but having to un-learn what comes naturally. Fortunately(?) it feels so different to play - even just to hold - from my others that there are constant reminders.
-
I think I've got it. The big one seems to resemble a Czech heligonka, with standard treble end (no gleichton), bass chords as on familiar 2-row 8-bass (albeit in a different order), helicon basses, the bass keys being diagonally offfset from each other, and the characteristic clips (rather than pins) which hold the ends on. See http://www.tresbohemes.com/2018/01/czech-slovak-heligonka-instrument/
The website I'm referring to here suggests that production more or less ended with WW2. I'm still persuadable that the mixed quality of the workmanship (not nearly as lovely as the instruments illustrated on the website) suggests postwar Communist manufacture. The smaller instrument which started this thread looks like a cheaper version of the same thing, having helicon basses and the metal caps which mimic the horns familiar from the steirische and which are also found on some heligonkas.
I'm getting the hang of playing them now. Thanks for all your comments and suggestions.
-
I don't know how much help this will be, but just after I read through this post, I was procrastinating at work and I ran across this: https://youtu.be/lw90RlfH9N0 (https://youtu.be/lw90RlfH9N0)
It looks to be the same make as the one you posted, just a different model.
-
I don't know how much help this will be, but just after I read through this post, I was procrastinating at work and I ran across this: https://youtu.be/lw90RlfH9N0 (https://youtu.be/lw90RlfH9N0)
It looks to be the same make as the one you posted, just a different model.
The instrument that shows now on eBay, if you click on the link in the original post, is a completely different accordion, with helikon basses.
You need to use this link, and scroll down the page, to see instrument being asked about by the o/p: https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loeffelbaesse-Bauer-Akkordeon-/163174019838?nordt=true&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.m43663.l10137 (https://www.ebay.de/itm/Handharmonika-diatonisch-2-reihige-Bandonika-4-Loeffelbaesse-Bauer-Akkordeon-/163174019838?nordt=true&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.m43663.l10137), which does not have helikon basses...
-
The instrument that shows now on eBay, if you click on the link in the original post, is a completely different accordion, with helikon basses.
Oops. I guess I should have paid more attention to the previous comments lol. Sorry about that!
-
I think I've got it. The big one seems to resemble a Czech heligonka, with standard treble end (no gleichton), bass chords as on familiar 2-row 8-bass (albeit in a different order), helicon basses, the bass keys being diagonally offfset from each other, and the characteristic clips (rather than pins) which hold the ends on. See http://www.tresbohemes.com/2018/01/czech-slovak-heligonka-instrument/
The website I'm referring to here suggests that production more or less ended with WW2. I'm still persuadable that the mixed quality of the workmanship (not nearly as lovely as the instruments illustrated on the website) suggests postwar Communist manufacture. The smaller instrument which started this thread looks like a cheaper version of the same thing, having helicon basses and the metal caps which mimic the horns familiar from the steirische and which are also found on some heligonkas.
They're not Heligonkas (which have very loud and extra-deep basses that imitate a Helikon = tuba), they're typical of more-developed/expensive forms of 2-row Deutsche Harmonikas = German accordions = melodeons made in the first quarter of the 20th century, especially before WW1.
The portholes/trumpets in the sides of the eBay one, which can be genuine but are more usually only ornamental, are features that go back as far as the mid 19th century on German concertinas and melodeons, whilst the use of drilled (rather than fretcut) designs in the end grilles/soundboxes of German concertinas and melodeons was there normal construction.
-
The larger (8-bass) one has basses which are reminiscent of my Hohner 356, which certainly has helicon basses. I'm still curious about the unusual layout of the basses.