Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 09:15:17 AM

Title: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 09:15:17 AM
Hello Melodeon Forum!

This is my first post, and I would like to thank the people in the background that made registration to the forum possible.

I am an old mostly jazz guitar player who made the mistake of borrowing a friends club system accordion, and then buying a Club IIb.

I really like this very expressive instrument, but find the keyboard layout awkward or impossible for reaching key centers and tonalities expressed in jazz.

I know nothing about the diatonic accordion, but have given the matter a certain amount of thought that I would like to present for review by those familiar with this instrument.

Rather than present my heretical ideas let me first ask: are there any established keyboard layouts for playing jazz on the diatonic accordion?  I haven't found anything.  Surely this has been a topic of previous consideration.

Finally, I need parts to build a box for experimenting with different layouts on.  Primarily Club IIb reedblocks!  I also have need of a couple of corpses for Frankensteining the mechanics out of.  I'll put up a  post in the parts wanted section for that too.

Thanx!
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 29, 2018, 11:01:03 AM
welcome to melnet!.  I know absolutely nothing about what you would need a box to have to enable you to play Jazz on it , perhaps if you could  post info such as the keys you would normally want to play in and whether or not you would want accompanying bass etc someone on here may be able to make suggestions.  Certainly 'jazz' is very doable on piano accordions  but they are of course chromatic by nature!

george
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tiposx on August 29, 2018, 11:15:58 AM
You probably need to convert to a semitone layout such as b/c.
 Piano accordions may be worth considering and be easier to play jazz on, but they are so heavy. I don't think they sound as good as our boxes.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Mike Hirst on August 29, 2018, 12:00:22 PM
You probably need to convert to a semitone layout such as b/c.

c/c# c#/d and d/d# are also available.

It may also be useful to search chromatic harmonica layouts. Common adaptations include be-bop, diminished and minor key variants.


Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Rayner on August 29, 2018, 12:08:45 PM
Not so much jazz, but blues.  The diatonic melodeon is first cousin of the blues harp (diatonic harmonica).  So you have the same range (actually greater) of notes available to Sonny Terry etc.  A typical D/G folky dancey melodeon has accidentals at the chin end of the keyboard; these are, admittedly only four in number, but they do allow a remarkable degree of chromatic variation.  For example, All You Need Is Love can be played in Gmaj with the chromatic run and accidentals on the standard keyboard.  There are several other jazz standards which can be played using these accidentals, Les Feuilles Mortes (Autumn Leaves), and Diamonds Are A Girl’s Best Friend are two I’ve had a crack at.  Quite what accidentals you have on your Club box I don’t know, they have often been altered to suit their previous owners’ requirements.

Eventually you will miss a note you want/need.  This is where invention and fakery come in.  I often miss a low C natural on my D/G box.  This is available as a low C on the left side of the box.  Ultimately you will run out of notes.  I cracked about a year ago, and bought a three row, G/C box with an inner row of accidentals and 12 bass buttons.  That might do you, but I suspect you would find even that restrictive.  As others have said, the chromatic semitone apart box might suit you, possibly even the unfashionable three row box championed by Jimmy Shand.  These were made with stradella bass systems, so could be played in pretty much any key.  I’m not sure if they’re still being made.

Personally I feel that the pleasure of the instrument is its compact lightweight nature.  Any attempt to make it fully chromatic compromises it to some degree.  There’s a lot of pleasure to be found in the available music, not all just rumpty tumpty diatonic dance music, although that’s a lot of fun.  Listen to the maestros of Cajun, Vallenato, Canadian and all the various European strains of diatonic squeeziness.  Not jazz, certainly, but I’d be surprised if you didn’t find something to enjoy.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Theo on August 29, 2018, 12:11:33 PM
Club system is chromatic on pull, so the larger Club boxes with 7 or more buttons on the helper row have a lot of potential too.
Other three row systems with a full row of accidentals and reversals might also do what you want.

Have a search for Stephane Milleret, Norbert Pignol Jean-Michel Corgeron  and Emmanuel Pariselle fir ideas of what is possible.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 29, 2018, 12:21:37 PM
Hello J.B.C., welcome.

Be interesting to know what you have in mind and how it differs from what is already available.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 12:33:57 PM
I know absolutely nothing about what you would need a box to have to enable you to play Jazz on

Notes outside the major scale I feel I'm missing, maybe just because I'm an absolute newbie, in decreasing order of importance:

- the flatted 3, needed for minor
- the flatted 7, needed for dominant
- the flatted 5, needed for m7b5
- the flatted 6, needed for harmonic minor


How do Klezmer players approach the diatonic accordion?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 12:40:38 PM
Club system is chromatic on pull, so the larger Club boxes with 7 or more buttons on the helper row have a lot of potential too.

I've done a little analysis of my 23+7 C/F box to try and wrap my mind around the situation, and better understand the asymmetry.

Its like trying to describe a kangaroo.

Code: [Select]
23+7 C-F Club

tone    push    draw    row
E 2               1
F 13              2
F# 1               1
G       3       2       1
G#         1       1
A 14              2
A#              13      2
B         3       1
C' 4,15    14      1,2,2
C#'         24      3
D'         4       1
D#      24              3
E' 5       15      1,2
F' 16      5       2,1
F#' 26      25      3,3
G' 6       16      1,2
G#'         26      3
A' 17      6       2,1
A#' 25      17      3,2
B'         7       1
C'' 7,18    18      2,2,1
C#''         27      3
D'' 28      8       3,1
D#'' 27      28      3,3       
E'' 8       19      1,2
F'' 19      9       2,1
F#'' 29              3
G'' 9       20      1,2
G#''         29      3
A'' 20      10      1,2
A#''         21      1
B''         11      1
C''' 10,21   12      1,2,1
C#'''         30      3
D'''         22      2
D#''' 30              3
E''' 11      23      1,2
F''' 22              2
F#'''
G''' 12              1
G#'''
A'''    23              2       


tone frequency
tone    push    draw
C       6       3
C#      0       3
D       1       3
D#      3       1
E       4       3
F       4       2
F#      3       1
G       4       3
G#      0       3
A       4       2
A#      1       3
B       0       3
 

So the chromaticity of the draw is just 13 notes.

My proposed layout is much worse, requiring more bellows reversals to realize a fully chromatic phrase, but symmetric.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Theo on August 29, 2018, 12:41:30 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkie0DoqxuI
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 29, 2018, 01:08:01 PM
Long, hopefully deep thought here. 2 rows, Vth apart have a lot of notes in common. They lack 4 from the set of 12. But we want more than that. Smooth "jazz" is not consistent with bellows direction change. We also want eg that D pull on a D/G. Indeed … no lovely Em7 without it! 😐

So any third row needs 5 different notes on the pull for chromaticity. Four if you go club system, or dutch inversion, or base your middle row on harmonic minor scale as they do in Grenoble.

There is also playability: That 4 requirement nicely matches the 4 push repeat of the main rows. My experience is that a good accs pattern also is "close to" a diatonic scale as different as possible from the main rows. My own journey took me to a C#/D/G box in 2005. C# is a 3-tone Devils interval from G and a semitone from D. Wow! just shift a finger to flatten a D row note! Suddenly all manner of blues scales became easy to play 😎

I chose not to go club, inefficient … but that involved me relearning all my tunes 😬 I achieved pull near chromaticity by filing (!) duplicated F#, C#s to F and D. Ab still a push, basically because I'd not clubbed.

My friends in Grenoble took different decisions. Their boxes are G/Amharmonic/accs. Same principles apply. Fully chromatic on pull. Here's an old youtube of their system in action. Stéphane drops from tune to Dm9 chord, alternating a push to refill bellows and generate rhythm. Norbert plays …90%+ on pull, using full chromaticity. (Many other Milleret/Pignol stuff on youtube)

https://youtu.be/mGPTV2xaFRk

But sanely … we should buy CBA's. Push pull boxes were not designed for this 😉
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 29, 2018, 01:15:06 PM
Here's Les's description of a CBA

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzoCZQdNcDU
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 01:38:56 PM
Long, hopefully deep thought here. 2 rows, Vth apart have a lot of notes in common.

Too many notes in common.  The 1 of the tonic is needlessly redundant.

More on this in a following post.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 29, 2018, 01:47:55 PM
Long, hopefully deep thought here. 2 rows, Vth apart have a lot of notes in common.

Too many notes in common.  The 1 of the tonic is needlessly redundant.

More on this in a following post.

Did you see the discussion Gena started on this, recently?

https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22664.0.html
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 01:50:50 PM
Following on with more detail.

Without loss of generality here is the core principle of my chromatic keyboard idea.

The note positions will be refined by soduko of the gleichtones to improve chordal possibilities in a following post.

I am thinking that reedplate with gleichtones will be easier so source than those with odd interval pairings.  Where to get those???

Code: [Select]
       24                27                30                33
      ╔═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╗
      â•‘  3  â•‘  6  â•‘ 12  â•‘  3' â•‘  6' â•‘ 12' â•‘  3" â•‘  6" â•‘ 12" â•‘  3'"â•‘
      â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
      â•‘  3  â•‘  6  â•‘ 11  â•‘  3' â•‘  6' â•‘ 11' â•‘  3" â•‘  6" â•‘ 11" â•‘  3"'â•‘
   â•”══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╗
   â•‘  2  â•‘  5  â•‘ 10  â•‘  2' â•‘  5' â•‘ 10' â•‘  2" â•‘  5" â•‘ 10" â•‘  2'"â•‘  5"'â•‘
   â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
   â•‘  2  â•‘  5  â•‘  9  â•‘  2' â•‘  5' â•‘  9' â•‘  2" â•‘  5" â•‘  9" â•‘  2"'â•‘  5"'â•‘
╔══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╗
â•‘  1  â•‘  4  â•‘  8  â•‘  1' â•‘  4' â•‘  8' â•‘  1" â•‘  4" â•‘  8" â•‘  1"'â•‘  4"'â•‘  6"'â•‘           
║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║ ┄┄┄ ║
â•‘  1  â•‘  4  â•‘  7  â•‘  1' â•‘  4' â•‘  7' â•‘  1" â•‘  4" â•‘  7" â•‘  1"'â•‘  4"'â•‘  6"'â•‘
╚═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╩═════╝
 1                 4                 7                 10

How to interpret the diagram.

The numbers are placeholders for scale tones.  They do not represent the ordinal position of the tone, but are only schematic to show that there are 6 tones are available on both draw and press, while the other 6 are available on only draw or press.

Surely this isn't a new idea?

Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 29, 2018, 01:57:52 PM
I think it would be easier to understand in standard notation

 1 2b 2 3b 3 4 5b 5 6b 6 7b 7 1 (#s if preferred 😀)

But the octave repeats don't look compatible with diatonic main rows? Please advise … 
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 29, 2018, 02:04:46 PM
For the sort of music you want to play, perhaps you might want to give the Chromatic Button Accordion (CBA) careful consideration. Plus points:

Disadvantages: relatively few.

Yes - it is possible to play jazz and blues on a diatonic box, as some of the earlier Youtube clips have shown. But you are somewhat limited overall, when it comes to complex modulations and harmony changes. Even by customising the layout of a Club box, you would nevertheless be trying to shoe-horn the overall harmonic basis of the instrument into something it wasn't generally designed for, and the generally limited LH basses and chords may eventually prove to be frustrating for you.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 02:15:19 PM
For the sort of music you want to play, perhaps you might want to give the Chromatic Button Accordion (CBA) careful consideration. Plus points:

A huge appeal to the diatonic accordion is the expressive dynamics of the lightweight box.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 29, 2018, 02:25:50 PM
Following on with more detail.

...I am thinking that reedplate with gleichtones will be easier so source than those with odd interval pairings.  Where to get those???...


You may be surprised at the possibilities a good fettler can create.

A couple of points:
1. Your diagram would make more sense to me if you used solfege (or whatever they call the doh, reh, meh thing.
2. It looks more like a variation on chromatic accordion layouts than diatonic ones. It seems to based on unisonority. The "gleichton" reed pairings  you show are standard accordion reeds, so it doesn't look like a melodeon which is, by definition a type of diatonic accordion (Andy Cutting insists it has to be a one row as well, but I would argue that's just semantics).
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Winston Smith on August 29, 2018, 02:45:36 PM
"Where to get those???"

Scrap piano accordions.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 02:59:03 PM
"Where to get those???"

Scrap piano accordions.

Yes, but I was wondering more about the difficulty of sourcing reedplates with intervals that don't occur on either the diatonic or PA.

Intervals like the tritone or b9.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Theo on August 29, 2018, 03:27:16 PM
If you learn the skills of reed tuning you can do quite a lot to tune a reed plate to have different pitches on push and pull.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Pearse Rossa on August 29, 2018, 04:11:23 PM
How do Klezmer players approach the diatonic accordion?

This is how Máirtín O' Connor approaches it on a DD# Hohner.
Two Jewish reels (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jNFOwhG6fl0).
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: rees on August 29, 2018, 04:28:49 PM
I know absolutely nothing about what you would need a box to have to enable you to play Jazz on

Notes outside the major scale I feel I'm missing, maybe just because I'm an absolute newbie, in decreasing order of importance:

- the flatted 3, needed for minor
- the flatted 7, needed for dominant
- the flatted 5, needed for m7b5
- the flatted 6, needed for harmonic minor


I'm assuming your Club is in C/F. If you learn to play it in the key of G you will then have the flat 3 and flat 7 on the C and F rows.
This is the method used by Blues and Zydeco musicians.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on August 29, 2018, 05:49:46 PM
For the sort of music you want to play, perhaps you might want to give the Chromatic Button Accordion (CBA) careful consideration. Plus points:

A huge appeal to the diatonic accordion is the expressive dynamics of the lightweight box.

Hello!

So, you may have to face a reality: in order to be lightweight & expressive, diatonic accordions simply have to be bad at something. You can decide what that something is, though. Forth apart boxes trade the powerful and useful chromatic nature of Semitone boxes in return for being able to have more chordal vocabulary to accompany themselves in the keys they do play in on both left and right hand sides. The 3 row layout you've posted leaves the left hand side completely out of the equation - the left hand side can be anything you want, but what do you want it to be? Consider Anglo Concertinas, which are also diatonic and bisonoric and have two keys a fourth or fifth apart. They split their notes across both left and right hand side, and tend to be significantly more chromatic than a 2 row 4th apart melodeon - they've traded our left hand side accompaniment for it, but, how interested are you in those chord buttons given you haven't mentioned them once in the thread so far? Maybe this could be a gateway to playing the sorts of thing you want to play without compromising things you care more about (weight)? Perhaps if you do want basses, would you find a unisonoric free bass system superior for your chosen music genres? In that case, do you still need reversals & a 3rd row? Speaking of 3rd rows, check out B/C/C#, too.

In the long run, I think it can work against you to think you know better than decades/centuries worth of experience with the instrument, but you also should definitely consider perhaps that system wasn't made for playing the kind of music you want to play. Sure, it's similar to what is found on harmonicas, but, you can bend reeds on a harmonica & just pick up one in another key whenever you want. The club system in particular has a goal as an addition - while it adds some chromatacism, a key element is to let you play another tick around the circle of fifths more easily (Bb major) with still only 8 bass buttons - a goal that is perhaps not in line with your objective. I'd still follow Rees' advice and look to how players have changed or used other existing diatonic instruments to play the kinds of music you want to, as well as try and work out what the players that others have linked are doing.

I think you also need to work out what you really need to be able to play. Do you want to play melody notes at the same time as one another to form chords? What kind of basses do you need to use in these Jazzier modes? Do you actually need the options that were there to begin with? Would it be easier if you used a different mode instead of Ionian as a base? Could you be served well by dropping to a single voice? If you can't draw a line somewhere then your ideal instrument will get bigger, and heavier.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 29, 2018, 06:55:13 PM

a key element is to let you play another tick around the circle of fifths more easily (Bb major) with still only 8 bass buttons

Indeed.  Noticing that the Bb scale was available in the left hand was a breakthrough moment.

Quote
If you can't draw a line somewhere then your ideal instrument will get bigger, and heavier.

The titanium bailing wire that holds my body together puts bigger and heavier out of the question.

I think that there is an optimization of the diatonic instrument by cleverly eliminating the replicated  scale tones, designing the keyboard around a 6-tone scale with 6 accidentals such that it occurs on a uniformly repeating 9-key field.

Choosing the ideal 6 tone scale and arranging the keyboard around those tones such that common scales and chords are available is a non-trivial exercise in combinatorics.  It is tricky to match a 6-tone/6-accidental scale with the 7-tone/5-accidental scale of western music.

More to follow.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 29, 2018, 07:37:06 PM

a key element is to let you play another tick around the circle of fifths more easily (Bb major) with still only 8 bass buttons

Indeed.  Noticing that the Bb scale was available in the left hand was a breakthrough moment.

Quote
If you can't draw a line somewhere then your ideal instrument will get bigger, and heavier.

The titanium bailing wire that holds my body together puts bigger and heavier out of the question.

I think that there is an optimization of the diatonic instrument by cleverly eliminating the replicated  scale tones, designing the keyboard around a 6-tone scale with 6 accidentals such that it occurs on a uniformly repeating 9-key field.

Choosing the ideal 6 tone scale and arranging the keyboard around those tones such that common scales and chords are available is a non-trivial exercise in combinatorics.  It is tricky to match a 6-tone/6-accidental scale with the 7-tone/5-accidental scale of western music.

More to follow.

It's possible that you could design and perhaps even build the instrument that you require, starting off with a C/F Club box. But based on what you have specified so far in this thread, it seems to me that the instrument you would end up with would be such a one-off and such a departure that you will have left the concept of 'melodeon' or 'diatonic accordion' as most people know it, far behind.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 29, 2018, 08:51:04 PM
maybe a small lightweight  HOHNER 40 0r 48  bass piano accordion box would be better around 4.3 and 4.6kg  which is less than a 3 voice GCF hohner corona 3 voice 'melodeon' and about the same as the 2 voice version.

other makes and models of same size would probably be of fairly similar weight

george

'
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: IanD on August 29, 2018, 10:29:30 PM
How do Klezmer players approach the diatonic accordion?

This is how Máirtín O' Connor approaches it on a DD# Hohner.
Two Jewish reels (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jNFOwhG6fl0).

I can pretty much guarantee the first one isn't Klezmer...
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 12:37:30 AM
Looking at your layout, the mixture of unisonoric and reversing notes looks clumsy to play. Sort of fish and fowl. I think it's possible, given you don't want to put too much mass into the box, that the direction you headed in is a "lightweight" three row CBA.
Using a standard 30 button club treble side you could create an instrument with at least 3 1/2 octaves. With a compromise you could have more. The issue would be with the basses which would  have to be unisonoric as well.
The standard club bass side only has 8 basses. If you could turn it into 12 you have the possibility for complete chromasticity of bass notes from which you could create bass chords if and when wanted.
I'll try and do a layout of what I mean.

It wouldn't be a melodeon, though.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 12:46:56 AM
Or, alternatively, if you had two 21 button trebles on either end of the bellows you could make the accordion equivalent of an English concertina (:)
Also not a melodeon.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 30, 2018, 01:28:16 AM
Just to point out that any "diatonic" system, which incorporates all the virtues that Gina has expounded has to be based on main rows with intervals

    tonic … t t ½ t t t ½ :        where t=a whole musical tone,  ½=semitone

In C this is the piano white notes, but eg F# diatonic scale has exactly the same intervals and so sounds very similar to the ear. In terms of then being a "melodeon" there is also a pattern of push/pull involved, with notes repeating 4th position on push, 5th on pull. Yes, this throws a different play plattern in the upper octave.  Notes above and below these main octaves might vary with instrument, but are then still regarded as a diatonic system.

This is trivial for single row. The tone separation of 2 or 3 row kit is an option. "Standards" being a musical 4th passing inwards, or a semitone apart. I believe 4th facilitates chord based play, hence "ACCORDeon" from the French word. ½ tone apart systems allow very rapid scale based play, right hand chords are IMHO not so easy until a third row is present, eg a BCC# system.

Other separations do exist. I have a looked at 3-tone apart system, others at tone apart. 5th apart also exists, basically a 4th apart "outside in"!  Minor 3rd makes a bit of sense. Major 3rd does not as many notes are duplicated in same direction.

But the main rows have to be based on the intervals above. Otherwise not diationic?

The 4th system duplicates C+D reed plate on eg a C/G 2-row. The community accepts that turning one (inner) plate over to D/C "Dutch inversion" is still "diatonic". Technically it is, but offers a different push/pull pattern on the affected row. Club GC system has an inner G/G plate, another accepted exception.

The Grenoble system has an inner row with CDEFG#ABC = Tonic t t ½ t½ ½ t ½ intervals! (3rd mode of harmonic minor scale). This is accepted as a "diatonic" box in France. I suspect not in Britain?

In all these exceptions … the note(s) modified can be still reached on the close-by outer row.

"Accidentals" rows can vary widely. However main rows, with octaves 1&2 differing from these accepted patterns would make any instument non diationic. 

The best example is perhaps the two CBA systems: based on 3 rows in a t½ t½ t½ t½ t½ t½ … pattern, semitone apart. It is termed "chromatique" in France
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Pearse Rossa on August 30, 2018, 01:55:08 AM
How do Klezmer players approach the diatonic accordion?

This is how Máirtín O' Connor approaches it on a DD# Hohner.
Two Jewish reels (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jNFOwhG6fl0).

I can pretty much guarantee the first one isn't Klezmer...

I've heard the Chicago Klezmer Ensemble play it as a Klezmer number.
I can't find the recording right now.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 30, 2018, 01:58:22 AM
The best example is perhaps the two CBA systems: based on 3 rows in a T T T T T T pattern, semitone apart. It is termed "chromatique" in France
The buttons on the CBA systems are minor thirds apart, not tones.
C system (http://www.thecipher.com/cba_c_system_spelling.html)
B system (http://www.thecipher.com/cba_b_system_spelling.html)
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 30, 2018, 02:04:45 AM
corrected. 2 a.m slip, served me right 😉
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on August 30, 2018, 02:37:59 AM
Just to point out that any "diatonic" system, which incorporates all the virtues that Gina has expounded has to be based on main rows with intervals

    tonic … t t ½ t t t ½ :        where t=a whole musical tone,  ½=semitone

I'm not sure this is exactly true? I'm pretty sure you could have a diatonic system that had the notes from any mode, so, you could have the notes be eg a Mixolydian mode rather than the Ionian mode and it still be diatonic (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_scale#Modes)?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 30, 2018, 08:10:51 AM
the concept of 'melodeon' or 'diatonic accordion' as most people know

I'm not sure what the difference between the 'melodeon' and 'diatonic accordion' would be.

I took 'diatonic accordion' to be an instrument whose key-field has different tonality on the push vs. the draw.

If a B/C/C# instrument is a melodeon, then I suppose you could define 'melodeon' to be an instrument whose draw notes are chosen from the 2,4,6,7 scale tones and push notes are chosen from 1,3,5.

Instruments of B/C/C# type have a repeating field of 12 notes on the draw and 9 notes on the press.  More generally, you could reverse one of the rows for repeating fields of 11 and 10 notes.

I propose a layout of 9 repeating notes on the press and draw.  Maybe not a melodeon, but surely diatonic.

My current thinking so far:

Code: [Select]

repeating 9-button field
duplicated notes chosen from c-major without the 6th scale degree


              24                27                30                33
             â•”═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╗
 III-b5      â•‘  e  â•‘  aâ™­ â•‘  bâ™­ â•‘  e' â•‘  aâ™­'â•‘ bâ™­' â•‘  e" â•‘  aâ™­"â•‘ bâ™­" â•‘  e‴ â•‘
             â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
 IV-dim      â•‘  f  â•‘  b  â•‘  c♯ â•‘  f' â•‘  b' â•‘ c♯' â•‘  f" â•‘  b" â•‘ c♯" â•‘  f‴ â•‘
          ╔══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╗
   ii     â•‘  d  â•‘  f  â•‘  a  â•‘  d' â•‘  f' â•‘  a' â•‘  d" â•‘  f" â•‘  a" â•‘  d‴ â•‘  f‴ â•‘
          â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
   II     â•‘  d  â•‘  f♯ â•‘  a  â•‘  d' â•‘ f♯' â•‘  a' â•‘  d" â•‘ f♯" â•‘  a" â•‘  d‴ â•‘ f♯‴ â•‘
       â•”══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╗
   i   â•‘  c  â•‘  eâ™­ â•‘  g  â•‘  c' â•‘ eâ™­' â•‘  g' â•‘  c" â•‘ eâ™­" â•‘  g" â•‘  c  â•‘ e♭‴ â•‘  g‴ â•‘           
       â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
   I   â•‘  c  â•‘  e  â•‘  g  â•‘  c' â•‘  e' â•‘  g' â•‘  c" â•‘  e" â•‘  g" â•‘  c  â•‘  e‴ â•‘  g‴ â•‘
       â•šâ•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•
        1                 4                 7                 10



This layout has the following properties:
- C, G, D major scales on the draw
- F, Bâ™­ major scales on the push
- alternating major/minor triads for I and II on the first two rows.
- mostly easy to get reedplates.
- repeating scale shapes across octaves.

B/C/C# in comparison has no scales on the push because of the minor 3rd between g♯ and b.  It heavily favours the draw, having C♯, F♯, B, E, A.

I must say the B/C/C# seems very powerful, if unsymmetrical.  I wasn't aware of it, or dismissed it, before.

A better analysis requires a little combinatoric program to check different layouts against chording and scale possibilities.

Would like to hear the pros/cons of B/C/C# from players of that system.  It seems better than Club.

More later.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Winston Smith on August 30, 2018, 09:18:21 AM
Is there a 3 row Streb, where j.c.b. could programme his concept in to try?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2018, 09:19:05 AM
the term 'diatonic' does not refer to 2 notes per button but simply that each row, be it 1,2,or 3 on a box each contains the scale for a particular key eg in the case of a DG you get the scales for D&G ! on a BCC# you get those 3 scales.

Semitone boxes eg BC, CC# etc are both diatonic and chromatic as the combination of rows provides the wherewithal to play in 12 major keys. In practical terms they are difficult to play in some keys and easy in others.  The 3 row BCC# is chromatic in a practical sense as all 12 keys are easy to play.

The 4th apart boxes eg DG,CF etc  are diatonic but not chromatic and the same goes for 3 row eg GCF.ADG etc. 

There is no such thing as 'a but chromatic' as an instrument either is chromatic ( 12 keys) or it isn't.

george ( in pedantic mode :D)
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2018, 09:23:33 AM
forgot to mention - if you want to look at some absolutely brilliant BCC# playing take a look at the many you tube vids by Brandon Mcphee. he plays a very wide range of stuff including country and western stuff on it
george
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 09:24:54 AM

I'm not sure what the difference between the 'melodeon' and 'diatonic accordion' would be.
I took 'diatonic accordion' to be an instrument whose key-field has different tonality on the push vs. the draw.


According to Andy Cutting, a melodeon is a one row diatonic instrument. An instrument with more than more than one diatonic rows is a diatonic accordion.  Having said this, these days, the name melodeon is normally given to all boxes with a diatonic layout.

In this context, diatonic means that you have all the notes of a scale arranged on four successive buttons, on the same row, in a characteristic pattern. As you go up it goes (from the tonic) 1push, 1pull, 2push, 2pull, 3push, 3pull, 4push, 4piull. (notice the change in direction on the 4th button). Successive octaves are made up of this pattern repeated.
If it doesn't have this pattern, then it is not a melodeon. Notice that if you sound all 4 notes together, on the push, you get the tonic chord. Also, the row is dedicated to a key (usually major) 
Sounds simple? It is. But, in practice people started making variations on this pattern to make the instrument more versatile.
They seem to have started from a ten button melodeon arranged, more or less, like this one, in C. https://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/1%20Row%204%20Stop%20-%20C.jpg
Then, of course, they decided to make it better, and capable of playing in more keys.
One solution is the 4th apart box, such as the CF. You could happily play along with tunes in the tonic keys and their related modes. You could fudge a couple more. If you wanted anything else, you got anothe box which had that key.
https://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20C_F%20-%20with%20low%20notes.jpg
Another solution was the chromatic melodeon (very different to the chromatic button box, which is not diatonic), such as the CC#. There you have two semitone apart rows which give you a complete chromatic scale.
https://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20C_F%20-%20with%20low%20notes.jpg
The two are very different to play, but a few people around play both.
Then people tried to improve them further, by adding more buttons (which makes them heavier) and playing with the note arrangements, outside of the central scale. The club box adds the gleichton, which is a note the same in both directions, but it is still based on the 4 button scale arrangement.

I just noticed George's post, but I'll post this anyway.
I  wonder if Theo will move this?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Lester on August 30, 2018, 09:33:35 AM
In this context, diatonic means that you have all the notes of a scale arranged on four successive buttons, on the same row, in a characteristic pattern. As you go up it goes (from the tonic) 1push, 1pull, 2push, 2pull, 3push, 3pull, 4pull, 4push. (notice the change in direction on the 4th button).
FTFY
Quote
Successive octaves are made up of this pattern repeated.
Not really the second octave is 4push, 5pull, 5push, 6pull, 6push, 7pull, 8pull, 7push
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Richard Shaul on August 30, 2018, 09:59:44 AM
In general terms I thought that diatonic just referred to the fact that it is not chromatic; its only one key. Having different notes on push or pull I have heard being called bisonoric. So to have a scale over 4 buttons it needs to be  both?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 30, 2018, 10:00:04 AM
I have been taking the term 'diatonic' to have its traditional definition as 'containing the tones of the scale'.  Note, the scale does not have to be Ionian.

I see now that in accordion circles diatonic is defined as 'containing the tones of the Ionian scale on a single row, with I on the push and ii7 on the pull".

I would rather explore bisonoric keyboard layouts than the definitions of words.

There are not many places to ask people experienced in small free-reed boxes where some of the reeds are bisonoric, and others may be gleichtones.

I am trying to approach the possibilities with an open mind.

Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Howard Jones on August 30, 2018, 11:13:20 AM
I'm not quite sure what the problem is that you're trying to solve.  If it is the deficiencies in the diatonic layout, there are several different well-established accordion keyboard layouts which are fully chromatic.

So far as I can see, the problem is that you've acquired an instrument which is not suitable for the sort of music you'd like to play.  Rather than trying to design your way out of this, which will probably put you to some expense as well as a lot of time, it would be far easier simply to sell it and buy something more suited to your needs.

Or you could accept the diatonic instrument for what it is, embrace its limitations, and explore some of the forms of music to which it is suited.

Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2018, 11:40:15 AM
Its great having someone coming to this with an open mind and from a different musical background to most of us here. It’s a well trodden path, and a genuinely new ideas will be hard to find, but there may be some new layout still to be discovered.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 11:51:15 AM
I have been taking the term 'diatonic' to have its traditional definition as 'containing the tones of the scale'.  Note, the scale does not have to be Ionian.

I see now that in accordion circles diatonic is defined as 'containing the tones of the Ionian scale on a single row, with I on the push and ii7 on the pull".

I would rather explore bisonoric keyboard layouts than the definitions of words.

There are not many places to ask people experienced in small free-reed boxes where some of the reeds are bisonoric, and others may be gleichtones.

I am trying to approach the possibilities with an open mind.

Don't be disheartened J, most of us are trying to help. It's not just semantics, though. We have enough problems here discussing the relative merits of 4th apart and semitone systems (:) Having said that, other systems do get discussed occasionally. It comes under a different topic category, though, which is why I thought Leo might move it.
I find the problem you pose interesting because the instrument you are looking for sounds like a good one and I don't think anything like it already exists (though it may). Something lightweight and fully chromatic in both directions, over a decent range of notes.
As I said, I think what you are searching for is a lightweight CBA. Forget the gleightons and think unisonoric. Much more intuitive to play than mixing it. I've attached a layout of what I mean. It worked out better than I expected.
A couple of points
1. It is based on a Bb/Ab club and I've retained the Bb/Ab bass structure. It makes sense to match it to your favoured keys.
2. I chose rather arbitrary start notes. It could start anywhere. This should be good for Bb, though (which matches the basses).
3. The pattern is slightly different at either end, because the number of buttons available is different.
4. the Bb at the top of the first full scale is repeated. This is needed to keep the pattern the same in the upper octave. Again, this makes it much more intuitive to play. Intuitive means easier to play skillfully, which is what I think you would want.

What do you think?

[Edit: I have modified the layout to include E. There are still a couple of compromises, though. It's like a 2.5 row layout where you always want a couple more buttons. I am sure there are better solutions based on this principle]
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 30, 2018, 12:33:02 PM
Greg,
There are no E naturals in your proposed layout. Is that a deliberate omission or perhaps an oversight? All other notes in the chromatic scale are there.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 12:36:36 PM
Greg,
There are no E naturals in your proposed layout. Is that a deliberate omission or perhaps an oversight? All other notes in the chromatic scale are there.

This is purely the result of coming up with ideas after an evenings morrising. Thanks for pointing it out. I will ammend. I wondered why I ended up with two Bb notes (:)
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2018, 01:02:07 PM
I'm not quite sure what the problem is that you're trying to solve.  If it is the deficiencies in the diatonic layout, there are several different well-established accordion keyboard layouts which are fully chromatic.

So far as I can see, the problem is that you've acquired an instrument which is not suitable for the sort of music you'd like to play.  Rather than trying to design your way out of this, which will probably put you to some expense as well as a lot of time, it would be far easier simply to sell it and buy something more suited to your needs.

Or you could accept the diatonic instrument for what it is, embrace its limitations, and explore some of the forms of music to which it is suited.


I totally agree -  but of course  indulging in mental contortions to come up with an ideal/different layout can indeed  be fun even if I gets you nowhere in the end

george
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 30, 2018, 01:34:26 PM
What do you think?

Designing a layout is a tricky game of Sodoku.

I'm working up something on the computer to solve layouts under different constraints.

The idea is to exhaustively search the pattern space and generate statistics for sieving the different options.

More later.

Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Stiamh on August 30, 2018, 01:57:41 PM
I am reminded of the Atzarin layout, which is/was an attempt to completely rethink the layout of a 3-row diatonic - some discussion of it can be found on this forum, and a prototype box was tried out by Owen W, if my memory serves me well. Also if memory serves me well, my comment at the time to the designer was, if this is such a good idea, how come you aren't learning to play it fabulously and impressing people with its possibilities, instead of trying to impress us with its possibilities from a point of (presumably) not being able to play it very well (or at all)?

Not sure how relevant that is to this discussion, but I think it's better to learn to play well before deciding on improvements to be made to the standard formats. (There are plenty of people who learn to play so well on a standard format that they don't need any change whatever to be able to play almost anything.) And I have some experience: I chose a 12-bass layout and a ½-row layout when I hadn't been playing long and now know that I could have made better choices with a couple of years more playing under my belt.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2018, 02:11:55 PM

 , but I think it's better to learn to play well before deciding on improvements to be made to the standard formats. (There are plenty of people who learn to play so well on a standard format that they don't need any change whatever to be able to play almost anything.) 

seconded!

george
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 03:22:17 PM

 , but I think it's better to learn to play well before deciding on improvements to be made to the standard formats. (There are plenty of people who learn to play so well on a standard format that they don't need any change whatever to be able to play almost anything.) 

seconded!

george
[/quote

That's the received wisdom, but it doesn't help the OP do what he wants to do. He wants to play a lightweight accordion type instrument,  chromatic in both directions.
That beast doesn't exist, as far as I know, although there was a posting a bit back of a PA with buttons that looked rather melodeon like (anyone remember it?), even if I have that right, they're as rare as rocking horse dung.
I can think of at least one other PA player I know who would love this.
If he wants to build something to do that job good luck to him. I think his choice of a club II is probably as good a shout as any, for the job.
The fun lies in designing it and making it happen.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 30, 2018, 03:58:06 PM
[Edit: I have modified the layout to include E. There are still a couple of compromises, though. It's like a 2.5 row layout where you always want a couple more buttons. I am sure there are better solutions based on this principle]

I see your edited layout. However, now you seem to have lost the F# (Gb) on the 2nd button of the outside row. It is shown as F natural. I would think that F#, being the leading note of the key of G, is pretty crucial to the layout.

I think yours is an interesting layout - it's nearly like a three row CBA but not quite!
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 07:40:00 PM
[Edit: I have modified the layout to include E. There are still a couple of compromises, though. It's like a 2.5 row layout where you always want a couple more buttons. I am sure there are better solutions based on this principle]

I see your edited layout. However, now you seem to have lost the F# (Gb) on the 2nd button of the outside row. It is shown as F natural. I would think that F#, being the leading note of the key of G, is pretty crucial to the layout.

I think yours is an interesting layout - it's nearly like a three row CBA but not quite!

You're right. It was a considered choice. Something had to go. That's one of the compromises I meant. The result of  using the club 2.7 shell. I made a selection intended to favour Bb. Maybe that was a bad idea.    As I said, I'm sure my attempt could be improved on.
If I were designing a system for the keys I normally play in I would probably start with a DG and transpose everything accordingly. I think you would need two or three. C BAdness rather than MAD nessIf I were to change anything it might be the  choice of basses.
I think j.b.c.'s idea is interesting but, in my opinion,  it works better with a unisonoric, rather  than a mixed approach. Having said that, I wouldn't be surprised if he were to go for his own solution. 
I wish I could find the post showing the button piano accordion.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2018, 08:15:17 PM
the only 'melodeon' that will readily play in all 12 keys is the BCC# . If a lightweight version is required the hohner trichord  3 voice  has bass FCGDAE anda treble for everything,. Larger ones have bass for 12 keys. only 4 scales plus the 'on the row one' are needed to play in every key.


george
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 30, 2018, 08:27:27 PM
the only 'melodeon' that will readily play in all 12 keys is the BCC# . If a lightweight version is required the hohner trichord  3 voice  has bass FCGDAE anda treble for everything,. Larger ones have bass for 12 keys. only 4 scales plus the 'on the row one' are needed to play in every key.

george

We're discussing a CBA, really, though. Not a melodeon.
Mind you, the Trichord might be a reasonable solution.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 30, 2018, 08:37:59 PM
the only 'melodeon' that will readily play in all 12 keys is the BCC# . If a lightweight version is required the hohner trichord ...

BCC# looks better that Club to me.

What I find troublesome is the irregularity of having to learn different scale fingerings at each octave boundary.

I've been playing jazz guitar for a long time.  Decades.  And I use a lot of different arpeggios many of which are not diatonic to the scale of the key-center of the phrase I'm playing over. 

In spite of the guitar being a much simpler instrument than the accordion and years of playing I'm still constantly finding new harmonic relationships and fingerings.  That is the core reason why I am hesitant to embrace the I-press/ii7-draw idiosyncrasy.  All the stumbles as the fingering patterns change at the octave crossings just blow my mind.

Playing music is hard enough.  I'd like a system where the fingerings are consistent from the low to high registers of the instrument.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on August 30, 2018, 08:55:24 PM
I am reminded of the Atzarin layout...

Thanks for drawing my attention this layout, and by reference also the Loomes layout.

The Atzarin layout has a repeating key-field of 12 buttons on the press and draw.  As such it is isomorphic to the CBA and offers no advantage in reducing the physical size of the instrument.

The Loomes layout is a system that uses a repeating key-field of 9 buttons on the press and draw.  It uses the whole-tone scale as its pitch collection of tones available in both directions, so it has no modes of the Ionian scale available on either the push or the draw.

Comparing Loomes and my hypothetical system based on the C-major scale without the 6th (aka Raga Nalinakanti ==>  https://ianring.com/musictheory/scales/2229) shows the difference choosing the generating hexatonic scale can make.

https://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/12/31/the-loomes-chromatic/

To be continued ...
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Rayner on August 31, 2018, 08:13:04 AM
Is there a 3 row Streb, where j.c.b. could programme his concept in to try?

Well, there certainly is an option for a third row.  Strebs are, however, artisanal products, so you need to put in an order and wait your turn.  About 18 months wait I think.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Winston Smith on August 31, 2018, 09:10:40 AM
I'm sure I've seen one or two advertised for sale second-hand, though. An offer to buy one on here could possibly do the trick, or not, as the case may be!
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 07:29:38 AM
Is there a 3 row Streb, where j.c.b. could programme his concept in to try?

I think I became aware of the Streb before I got interested in accordions, and then forgot about it.


Now it seems like a very practical idea.

Shame the concept isn't available as a set of reed-blocks to be fit to an existing instrument without otherwise needing any modifications.

MIDI instruments allow for recording the statistics of a players key choices.  It would be interesting to see a heat map generated by different styles of music.  Those heat maps could also be generated from MIDI file libraries.  But that is an exercise for another day.


I'd like to describe the class of instruments I'm thinking about as Noval Chromatic Accordions.  They have the properties of being fully chromatic and having a 3-row button keyboard where a 3x3 block of keys repeats regularly from the low to high registers.

I've programmatically sieved the many thousands of possible noval mappings by scoring them based on the scales they contain without bellows reversals.

Somewhat unexpectedly the best choices fall into two broad categories.

All the good choices offer 6 major scales, and of course all the chords diatonic to those scales.

Some tone choices have their 6 scales as neighbors on the circle of fifths.

The other interesting choices have 2-pairs of 3 neighbor circle of fifths scales, a tritone apart.  These choices offer the superlocrian on the center tone of their circle of fifths neighborhood.  The superlocrian scale is especially useful in building altered dominant chords.  All altered dominant chords are diatonic to the superlocian.

Here a couple of the most interesting note choices.  I looked up the pitch class sets of their generating hexatonic scales and found those scales to have Western names, a good sign that they are in common use.


iteration 3175 == "Minor Hexatonic" ==> https://ianring.com/musictheory/scales/1197

iteration 3245 == "Messiaen Mode 5" ==> https://ianring.com/musictheory/scales/2275

Code: [Select]
====================
39 <== score  iteration ==>  3175    {0, 2, 3, 5, 7, 10}
   d [0, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11]
   p [0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10]
   draw
        major C D G
        minor C
        superloc C#
   press
        major E A B
        minor A
        superloc Bb
====================
39 <== score  iteration ==>  3245    {0, 1, 5, 6, 7, 11}
   d [0, 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11]
   p [0, 1, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11]
   draw
        major C F Bb
        minor Bb
        superloc B
   press
        major E F# B
        minor E
        superloc F

I have not yet considered the permutations of the tone choices onto the 9 key field layout.  That is another puzzle for later.


More to come ...

Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: -Y- on September 01, 2018, 10:59:40 AM
Is there a 3 row Streb, where j.c.b. could programme his concept in to try?

I think I became aware of the Streb before I got interested in accordions, and then forgot about it.


Now it seems like a very practical idea.

Could a Roland FR-18 do the trick? I don't know whether they allow you to use custom keyboard layout (I think so, but it would need to be checked), but they're available second-hand quite easily.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 11:25:56 AM
Could a Roland FR-18 do the trick?


Yeah, maybe.

I looked at those.  They're pretty huge.  I'd like something half that size, with much less mass in the left hand.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 11:33:07 AM
Pulling out the calipers to do a proper phrenology of the melodeon I noticed an obvious error in my description of the instruments harmonic pallet.

... I am hesitant to embrace the I-press/ii7-draw idiosyncrasy.

I should have written ii6, or maybe better vii-m7b5.

I'm just going to run my combinatoric scale finder over the set of possible 2 and 3-row melodeons and see what it finds ...
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: -Y- on September 01, 2018, 11:35:56 AM
I'm not sure the left side is that much heavy. Actually, I think nearly all the weight is on the right-hand side, but it's as you prefer, I'm not a Roland reseller  :D
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Winston Smith on September 01, 2018, 11:48:17 AM
"I should have written ii6, or maybe better vii-m7b5.

I'm just going to run my combinatoric scale finder over the set of possible 2 and 3-row melodeons and see what it finds ..."

From someone who hasn't a clue of what you're on about, I salute you! (Even if only for the entertainment value of this whole [coded] thread to numpties like me!) I hope someone on here might be able to help you eventually find what you're looking for, j.b.c.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Anahata on September 01, 2018, 12:58:55 PM
Could a Roland FR-18 do the trick?
Yeah, maybe.

I looked at those.  They're pretty huge.  I'd like something half that size, with much less mass in the left hand.

The Streb would suit better on that score. 2½ rows, normal melodeon size and shape. I don't know how it does on LH weight; it's a 12 bass but of course doesn't have any reeds...
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 01:05:17 PM
From someone who hasn't a clue of what you're on about ...

A full answer probably belongs in the Teaching and Learning category of the Forum.

Briefly, in Western Harmony we build chords stacked in 3rds from notes in the scale of the tonal center.

Any chords that you can build from scale tones are called diatonic to the scale.

For triads built from the Major scale in the key of C we would have ...

Do ... I ... major ... ( C, E, G ) ... C
Re ... ii ... minor ... ( D, F, A ) ... Dm
Mi ... iii ... minor ... ( E, G, B ) ... Em
Fa ... IV ... major ... ( F, A, C ) ... F
So ... V  ... major ... ( G, B, D ) ... G
La ... vi ... minor ... ( A, C, E ) ... A
Ti ... vii ... flat5 ... ( B, D, F ) ... Bmb5

I know others spell Solfege differently, but thats how I learnt it.

In Jazz we usually use tall chords.  Stacks of 3 or more thirds. They are particularly bothersome on the melodeon.

The same diatonic chord scale in 7th chords would look like ...


Do ... Imaj7 ... major ... ( C, E, G, B ) ... Cmaj7
Re ... ii7 ... minor ... ( D, F, A, C ) ... Dm7
Mi ... iii7 ... minor ... ( E, G, B, D ) ... Em7
Fa ... IVmaj7 ... major ... ( F, A, C, E ) ... Fmaj7
So ... V7  ... dominant ... ( G, B, D, F ) ... G7
La ... vi7 ... minor ... ( A, C, E, G ) ... Am7
Ti ... vii7b5 ... minor7flat5 ... ( B, D, F, G ) ... Bm7b5


On the C melodeon if you press 4 buttons starting with the C ,
 on the push you get (C, E, G, C) or (1, 3, 5, 1) or C.
 on the draw you get (D, F, A, B) or (2, 4, 6, 7) or Dm6, which spelled in 3rds is (B, D, F, A) or Bm7b5, the 7th degree of the diatonic Major chord scale and the enharmonic equivalent of Dm6.

.


Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 06:48:54 PM
Harmonic Analysis of 2 and 3 Row Melodeons.



==== BC ====

Code: [Select]
==== BC ====
d  [1, 2, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 3, 4, 6, 7, 11]
score =  0
   draw
     scales
     chords
        D Dm D- Dmaj7 DmM7 D7 Dm7
        Eb Eb+ Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Ebmaj7 Eb9
        G+ G-
        G# G#- G#sus4 G#6 G#7
        Bbm Bbsus2 Bbm6 BbmM7
        B Bm B+ B6 Bm6 B7 Bm7
   press
     scales
     chords
        C Cm C- Cmaj7 CmM7
        C# C#+ C#sus4
        F+
        G#m G#sus2 G#mM7
        A+


==== BCC# ====

Code: [Select]
==== BCC# ====
d  [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11]
score =  61
   draw
     scales
        major C# Eb F# G# B
        minor C# Eb F# A B
        harminor D Eb F# A B
        superloc C D E G Bb
     chords
        C+ C-
        C# C#m C#- C#sus2 C#sus4 C#6 C#m6 C#maj7 C#mM7 C#7 C#m7 C#add9 C#9 C#69
        D Dm D+ D- Dsus2 Dsus4 Dmaj7 DmM7 D7 Dm7 Dadd9 D9
        Eb Ebm Eb+ Eb- Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Eb6 Ebm6 Ebmaj7 EbmM7 Eb9 Eb69
        E Em E+ E- Esus2 Esus4 E6 Em6 E7 Em7 Eadd9 E69
        F# F#m F#+ F#- F#sus2 F#sus4 F#6 F#m6 F#maj7 F#mM7 F#7 F#m7 F#add9 F#9 F#69
        G Gm G+ G- Gsus4 G6 Gm6 Gmaj7 GmM7 G7 Gm7
        G# G#+ G#- G#sus2 G#sus4 G#6 G#maj7 G#7 G#add9 G#9 G#69
        Am Asus2 Asus4 Am6 AmM7 Am7
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bb- Bbsus2 Bb6 Bbm6 Bbmaj7 BbmM7 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbadd9 Bb9 Bb69
        B Bm B+ Bsus2 Bsus4 B6 Bm6 Bmaj7 BmM7 B7 Bm7 Badd9 B9 B69
   press
     scales
     chords
        C Cm C+ C- Csus4 Cmaj7 CmM7
        C# C#+ C#- C#sus2 C#sus4 C#6 C#69
        E Em E+ Esus4 E6 Em6 Emaj7 EmM7 E7 Em7
        F+ F-
        F#sus2 F#sus4
        Gm Gsus2 GmM7 Gm7
        G# G#m G#+ G#sus2 G#6 G#m6 G#maj7 G#mM7 G#9 G#69
        A+
        B Bm B- Bsus2 Bsus4 Bmaj7 BmM7 B7 Bm7 Badd9 B9

==== CF ====

Code: [Select]
==== CF ====
d  [2, 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 4, 5, 7, 9]
score =  0
   draw
     scales
     chords
        D D- D6 Dmaj7
        Ebsus2 Ebsus4
        F Fm Fsus2 F6 Fm6 F7 Fm7 Fadd9 F69
        G-
        G#m G#sus4 G#m7
        Bbm Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bbm6
   press
     scales
     chords
        C Csus4 C6
        Ebm Ebm7
        G Gsus2 Gmaj7 G9

==== GCF ====

Code: [Select]
==== GCF ====
d  [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 2, 4, 5, 7, 9, 11]
score =  25
   draw
     scales
        major C F G
        minor F
        superloc F#
     chords
        C C- Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C7 Cadd9 C9 C69
        C#m C#sus4 C#mM7 C#m7
        D D+ D- Dsus2 D6 Dmaj7 D9 D69
        Ebm Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Ebm6 Ebm7
        F Fm Fsus2 Fsus4 F6 Fm6 Fmaj7 FmM7 F7 Fm7 Fadd9 F9 F69
        F#+ F#-
        G G- Gsus2 Gsus4 G6 Gmaj7 G9 G69
        G#m G#sus2 G#sus4 G#m7
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bb6 Bbm6 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbadd9 Bb69
   press
     scales
        major C
     chords
        C Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C9 C69
        Ebm Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Ebm7
        F Fsus2 Fsus4 F6 F7 Fadd9 F69
        G G- Gsus2 G6 Gmaj7 G9 G69
        G#m G#sus4 G#m7
        Bbm Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bbm6 Bbm7


to be continued ...


Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 01, 2018, 07:14:03 PM
Soooo... What exactly is your goal? You want to play a lot of chords  on the melody side of the instument and runs without bellows changes? I feel that your motives are the vaguest part of this thread.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 07:32:30 PM
Soooo... What exactly is your goal?

Asked and answered.


What I find troublesome is the irregularity of having to learn different scale fingerings at each octave boundary.

I've been playing jazz guitar for a long time.  Decades.  And I use a lot of different arpeggios many of which are not diatonic to the scale of the key-center of the phrase I'm playing over. 

In spite of the guitar being a much simpler instrument than the accordion and years of playing I'm still constantly finding new harmonic relationships and fingerings.  That is the core reason why I am hesitant to embrace the I-press/ii7-draw idiosyncrasy.  All the stumbles as the fingering patterns change at the octave crossings just blow my mind.

Playing music is hard enough.  I'd like a system where the fingerings are consistent from the low to high registers of the instrument.


Quote
You want to play a lot of chords  on the melody side of the instument and runs without bellows changes?

Yes. A lot of chords.  And scales, not just modes of the Ionian.  On a small instrument where the bellows changes matter.

Scales with bellows changes for effect.  And chords without, because they are chords.

Rather than making the trivial easy I would prefer if the difficult were possible.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 01, 2018, 07:47:52 PM
Nutz.

The chord matching system is in error.

The above results are incomplete.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Eshed on September 01, 2018, 07:50:18 PM
Nutz.

The chord matching system is in error.

The above results are incomplete.
Got the code on GitHub or similar by any chance? :)
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on September 01, 2018, 08:18:42 PM
if you want push/pull treble and same both ways bass  you could go for 12,24,32.40 or 48  stradella bass  with 'melodeon' treble or have  8 melodeon basses converted to unisonoric but what you would get would be somewhat limited.

Strikes me you are trying to reinvent the wheel  when what you are after exists in the form of continental chromatic or piano accordion

george
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 02, 2018, 12:59:08 AM
So... I think specifically your goals are:

If you wanted to be able to make arbitrary tonic + major 3rd + perfect 5 + major 7th chords for any tonic, you need every permutation of semitones n + 0, n + 4, n + 7, n + 11 (or some inversion += 12 thereof) in any given direction. Examining just the 7th Because you have 11 adjacent to 0, you can ascertain that if 0 is push, 11 must at least be push. If 11 were to be push, we can see that to play it's major 7th, semitone 10 must either also a) be push, or b) semitone 11 must be available on pull also. If the former (10 on push) following this pattern around the whole octave means all semitones must be available on push (so, no weight saving). If the latter (11 also available on pull), then, 10 must be on pull. If 10 is on pull, then it follows 9 is pull to match it but also push, to match 8 etc giving you a pattern of (arbitrarily setting 0 to C):

Code: [Select]
C    C#  D    D#  E    F   F#   G   G#   A   A#   B   c
0    1   2    3   4    5   6    7   8    9   10   11  12
push uni pull uni push uni pull uni push uni pull uni push

You can see that 0 = push, 4 = push, 7 = uni and 11 = uni, so in the case above, C E G B, and that as you move up every tonic + major 3rd + perfect 5th major 7th chord, you'll have 2 unisonoric and then 2 either push or pull notes. So C# F G# c is uni uni push push, and D F# A c# would be pull pull uni uni etc. This can see that this fits your hope for a 9 button repeating cycle you've posted here before.

But, now if you want to play any chord that contains a minor seventh, so, a chord with n and n + 10 (or n-2) you can see you will face the situation of wanting to combine, well, semitones 0 and 10, which are marked above as push only and pull only respectively. This layout prevents the playing of intervals of 2, 6, and 10, so the major 2nd, tritone, and and minor 7th. The major 2nd is also the major 9th. So, you can clearly see that these are intervals you'd probably want. If you change the layout to allow these in some way, you'll lose the major 7th, or, you get a 12 button repeating pattern instead of 9, and you are no longer more efficient than a CBA.

So, in my opinion, you really need to be settle on being able to say 'I want scales x,y,a and these chords', as I'm pretty confident that at least what appears to be your goal is impossible.

To be honest, my actual advice is to either make a compact lightweight 1 voice CBA with a 12 button primitive free bass left hand side without the lowest reeds, and just learn to reverse the bellows whenever you want for the emphasis you'd like. This should still weigh less than your club due to dropping the 2nd voice, but it will sound different. Or, that same bass end and a chromatic semitone layout with a push pattern that repeats every 5 buttons (just like the pull pattern, so, basically just add a note you'd like there, maybe the 7th on push?) and abandon most other full right hand chords - learn the scales you want to play, use the left hand side for your chords, but still include the most important shell chord pairings using buttons on a half row (so, you're looking for the 3rd and 7th pairs you care the most about).
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 07:06:08 AM
Got the code on GitHub or similar by any chance? :)

Sorry.

Its just a spontaneous hack that leans on Python's itertools combinatorics functions.

I think I fatfingered a data table.

I'll look into it after I've had my coffee.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 07:12:31 AM
if you want push/pull treble and same both ways bass  you could go for 12,24,32.40 or 48  stradella bass  with 'melodeon' treble or have  8 melodeon basses converted to unisonoric but what you would get would be somewhat limited.

I'd like to be able to play walking bass lines with chromatic approaches and also pedaltones.

So my current thinking is 12 button unisonoric, that could be most easily built into an existing 3-row/12-button cadaver.

Quote
Strikes me you are trying to reinvent the wheel  when what you are after exists in the form of continental chromatic or piano accordion

Those are pretty huge, and usually have massive bass ends.

I'd like a 3 1/2 octave instrument that weights ~4kg, with lively dynamics.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 02, 2018, 07:26:08 AM
Quote
Strikes me you are trying to reinvent the wheel  when what you are after exists in the form of continental chromatic or piano accordion

Those are pretty huge, and usually have massive bass ends.

I'd like a 3 1/2 octave instrument that weights ~4kg, with lively dynamics.
Have you considered the Hohner Nova 1-49 F?
It's a full 5-row CBA, with a 49 button free bass LH side. Single voice to keep the mass down - weighs in at 4.4 kg.
https://www.hohner.de/en/instruments/accordions/chromatic/nova/nova-i-49f
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 07:31:19 AM
So... I think specifically your goals are:
  • No drift in scales so fingering matches octave to octave
  • Fully chromatic with many runs and scales without bellows reversals for diatonic chords
  • Also bellows reversals are still important to the sound.
  • More efficient than a CBA so that it is Light weight / compact
  • Some kind of light weight left hand side maybe???

Bingo !!!

Quote
If you wanted to be able to make arbitrary tonic + major 3rd + perfect 5 + major 7th chords for any tonic, you need every permutation of semitones n + 0, n + 4, n + 7, n + 11 (or some inversion += 12 thereof) in any given direction. Examining just ...

There are a huge number of combinations to consider.  Many thousands.

I wrote a program to generate all the possible combinations and sieve them based upon a somewhat arbitrary scoring metric, described in this post ==> http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22753.msg272425.html#msg272425

In order to further refine the sieve I am now also considering cord possibilities in addition to scales.

One result that comes up, and is easy to compare to the GCF melodeon is iteration 3638, which contains the GCF on the draw but is more powerful on the push, while at the same being fully chromatic and more compact.

Code: [Select]
39 <== score  iteration ==>  3638    {0, 2, 5, 6, 7, 10}
   d [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
   p [0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10]
   draw
        major C F G
        minor F
        superloc F#
     chords
        C C- Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C7 Cadd9 C9 C69
        C#m C#sus4 C#mM7 C#m7
        D D+ D- Dsus2 D6 Dmaj7 D9 D69
        Ebm Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Ebm6 Ebm7
        F Fm Fsus2 Fsus4 F6 Fm6 Fmaj7 FmM7 F7 Fm7 Fadd9 F9 F69
        F#+ F#-
        G G- Gsus2 Gsus4 G6 Gmaj7 G9 G69
        G#m G#sus2 G#sus4 G#m7
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bb6 Bbm6 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbadd9 Bb69
   press
        major E A B
        minor A
        superloc Bb
     chords
        Cm Csus2 Csus4 Cm7
        D Dm D+ Dsus2 Dsus4 D6 Dm6 D7 Dm7 Dadd9 D69
        E E- Esus2 Esus4 E6 Emaj7 E7 Eadd9 E9 E69
        Fm Fsus4 FmM7 Fm7
        F# F#+ F#- F#sus2 F#6 F#maj7 F#9 F#69
        Gm Gsus2 Gsus4 Gm6 Gm7
        A Am Asus2 Asus4 A6 Am6 Amaj7 AmM7 A7 Am7 Aadd9 A9 A69
        Bb+ Bb-
        B B- Bsus2 Bsus4 B6 Bmaj7 B9 B69

As I mentioned up-thread the sieving results show 2 interesting groups of noval-chromatic tone choices.  One group favours 6 neighbors of the circle of fifths.  The other group has 2 sets of 3 neighbors of the circle of fifths, centered a tritone apart.

Of course there will be a compromise in selecting the sub-sets of the chromatic scale for push and draw.  Its looking like there are two good, if somewhat different choices.

Ever ask a horn player to play in a sharp key?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 07:37:29 AM
Have you considered the Hohner Nova 1-49 F?
It's a full 5-row CBA, with a 49 button free bass LH side. Single voice to keep the mass down - weighs in at 4.4 kg.
https://www.hohner.de/en/instruments/accordions/chromatic/nova/nova-i-49f

I've looked at those.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 02, 2018, 09:03:20 AM
Have you considered the Hohner Nova 1-49 F?
It's a full 5-row CBA, with a 49 button free bass LH side. Single voice to keep the mass down - weighs in at 4.4 kg.
https://www.hohner.de/en/instruments/accordions/chromatic/nova/nova-i-49f

I've looked at those.
And I presume rejected. What put you off? The layout or the weight? As for the former, it seems able to do everything you want.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 09:43:20 AM
What put you off? The layout or the weight?

Both those criteria, but mostly range, followed by voice.

As guitar is my principle instrument I can give this example.  The classical guitar has 12-frets where the neck joins the body, for a 3-ocatave range.  A huge part of the repertoire requires reaching beyond 3 octaves, so Western guitars have 14-fret necks and frequently also cutaways.

Most of what I play now fits the range E3-A6.

Those extra notes on top especially help in keys that don't reach the bottom.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 02, 2018, 11:02:32 AM
It's beginning  to look there are too many conflicts in your spec to make it achievable, without a compromise...
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: george garside on September 02, 2018, 11:06:38 AM
the more this thread goes on the further it seems ,to me, to be getting away from  being about melodeons.   What the OP seems to want, is a completely different instrument to either a 'melodeon' or an accordion or indeed from anything in 'diatonicland'.

 I can't work out what he is after , but then I am 'thick' when it comes to musical theory. However  by its very nature the melodeon is diatonic , at least on the treble side, and  is a direct descendent of the single  row box  of c 1829?    Direct descendents  having  2 , 2 and a bit or 3 rows tuned in a veriety of diatonic scales  . Size varying from the simple one row 2 bass to 3 row with stradella bass (Sir Jimmy Shand sometimes refering to the 117 bass Shand Morino as an overgrown melodeon!) which in terms of the treble end it certainly is.


???????????


george >:E :D

 

george


Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 11:36:37 AM
What the OP seems to want, is a completely different instrument to either a 'melodeon' or an accordion or indeed from anything in 'diatonicland'.

I propose to call this class of bellows driven free reed aerophones noval chromatic accordions.

They have bi-sonoric chromatic treble ends based on a repeating 9-button pattern.

They require 3/4 the mechanical space as a CBA, or 18/21 keys per octave as a 3-row melodeon.

Because of the compactness of the layout they need only 32 buttons for a 3 1/2 octave range.

Edit, adding:  They are certainly diatonic, because the note choices for their 9-tone push/draw collections contain scales, which in turn contain the chords diatonic to those scales.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: -Y- on September 02, 2018, 12:02:48 PM
Maybe you said it before, but, why 9-buttons pattern instead of 6? What's the benefit of having more buttons than needed? Do you also check the melodic and harmonic progressions (how to go up a scale for instance)?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 12:19:41 PM
Maybe you said it before, but, why 9-buttons pattern instead of 6?

There are 12 tones in the chromatic scale.

9 buttons is insufficient for chromaticism on a uni-sonoric instrument.

7 tones are necessary for a diatonic instrument based upon the Major scale, so you need at least that many to play diatonic chords.

9 is the smallest number divisible by 3 (because 3-rows) that contains 7.

6 uni-sonoric tones plus 6 bi-sonoric tones gives all 12 notes of the chromatic scale.

The 6 bi-sonoric tones fit nicely 3+3 with the 6 uni-sonoric tones to give 9 buttons.

It is funny that changing the tuning of the instrument, without any other mechanical change, causes such a protest.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Inventor on September 02, 2018, 12:49:27 PM
On the size and weight of a CBA look at Hohner - Pirol, Lucia, and Cornelia. The last two have decent bass ends which would enable interesting bass runs. Listen to Squeezy on his Cornelia playing "Black and White Rag"; and you will see what I mean.
His instrument is a converted Cornelia D/G/Acc. I am not sure of the exact layout, but it is on this website somewhere.
Inventor.
 
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Corinto on September 02, 2018, 01:44:29 PM
Listen to Squeezy on his Cornelia playing "Black and White Rag" ... His instrument is a converted Cornelia D/G/Acc. Inventor.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NE9y_BIEPDk
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 02, 2018, 01:48:43 PM
I propose to call this class of bellows driven free reed aerophones noval chromatic accordions.
Edit, adding:  They are certainly diatonic, because the note choices for their 9-tone push/draw collections contain scales, which in turn contain the chords diatonic to those scales.

I think you still don't understand the meaning of diatonic in the context of instruments conventionally called diatonic accordions and commonly referred to as melodeons.

...It is funny that changing the tuning of the instrument, without any other mechanical change, causes such a protest.

Possibly because what you are looking for isn't a melodeon and this is a site normally devoted to melodeons (:)
 
Your goal is not without interest but I think a PA is probably as good a solution  for you as any. They are heavier than a melodeon, but so are the solutions you favour. They sometimes come with button keys if you need buttons.
It's probably worth pointing out that extra mass on the bass side increases the inertia perceived by the player and that extra voices add more mass than a few extra buttons so, whatever you do, your solution is likely to be clumsy by melodeon standards and won't have the melodeon feel you want.
Also, as has been said, some great music is made on melodeons. Perhaps a more flexible approach would suit you in the long term.
[Edited to correct some typos]



 
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: -Y- on September 02, 2018, 02:16:56 PM
There are 12 tones in the chromatic scale.
9 buttons is insufficient for chromaticism on a uni-sonoric instrument.
7 tones are necessary for a diatonic instrument based upon the Major scale, so you need at least that many to play diatonic chords.
9 is the smallest number divisible by 3 (because 3-rows) that contains 7.
6 uni-sonoric tones plus 6 bi-sonoric tones gives all 12 notes of the chromatic scale.
The 6 bi-sonoric tones fit nicely 3+3 with the 6 uni-sonoric tones to give 9 buttons.

This is where I do not follow you. If the pattern is regular from an octave to another, why have 3 extra buttons? You won't have an isotropic pattern then, so you lose in regularity.
One thing that your method does not take into account is the fingering (AFAIK, maybe you already are taking it into account, in such a case, do not consider the followings). There's no guarantee that an optimal solution from a harmonic point of view will yield an accordion system that is easier to play. I think the trade-off between the chromatic and the diatonic scales is not easy (and perhaps cannot be solved).
Someone mentioned the Atzarin keyboard earlier. Have you seen those?
http://malomorvan.free.fr/claviers/pasapas.html
http://www.accordeon101.com/clavpolymodal.html

Two layout proposals, one from a Breton accordionist, the other from Jean-Claude Bélanger (a reference for accordion in Québec).
You'll need a good level in French, but if not, do not hesitate to get back to me (I don't know if Google translate is enough to understand the subtleties).

I don't know if they answer to your needs, but it's at least a way of having more point of views on the matter.

It is funny that changing the tuning of the instrument, without any other mechanical change, causes such a protest.

Personally, I'm not protesting. I find it an interesting discussion.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 03:25:56 PM

This is where I do not follow you. If the pattern is regular from an octave to another, why have 3 extra buttons? You won't have an isotropic pattern then, so you lose in regularity.

Maybe this provisional diagram makes it a little bit clearer?

Code: [Select]
repeating 9-button field
duplicated notes chosen from c-major without the 6th scale degree


              24                27                30                33
             â•”═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╦═════╗
 III-b5      â•‘  e  â•‘  aâ™­ â•‘  bâ™­ â•‘  e' â•‘  aâ™­'â•‘ bâ™­' â•‘  e" â•‘  aâ™­"â•‘ bâ™­" â•‘  e‴ â•‘
             â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
 IV-dim      â•‘  f  â•‘  b  â•‘  c♯ â•‘  f' â•‘  b' â•‘ c♯' â•‘  f" â•‘  b" â•‘ c♯" â•‘  f‴ â•‘
          ╔══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╗
   ii     â•‘  d  â•‘  f  â•‘  a  â•‘  d' â•‘  f' â•‘  a' â•‘  d" â•‘  f" â•‘  a" â•‘  d‴ â•‘  f‴ â•‘
          â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
   II     â•‘  d  â•‘  f♯ â•‘  a  â•‘  d' â•‘ f♯' â•‘  a' â•‘  d" â•‘ f♯" â•‘  a" â•‘  d‴ â•‘ f♯‴ â•‘
       â•”══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╦══╩══╗
   i   â•‘  c  â•‘  eâ™­ â•‘  g  â•‘  c' â•‘ eâ™­' â•‘  g' â•‘  c" â•‘ eâ™­" â•‘  g" â•‘  c  â•‘ e♭‴ â•‘  g‴ â•‘   
       â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘ ┄┄┄ â•‘
   I   â•‘  c  â•‘  e  â•‘  g  â•‘  c' â•‘  e' â•‘  g' â•‘  c" â•‘  e" â•‘  g" â•‘  c  â•‘  e‴ â•‘  g‴ â•‘
       â•šâ•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•©â•â•â•â•â•â•
        1                 4                 7                 10


That is a early concept.  I have since found better tone choices.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 02, 2018, 03:28:03 PM
Code: [Select]
39 <== score  iteration ==>  3638    {0, 2, 5, 6, 7, 10}
   d [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
   p [0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10]

May I ask, which note are you assigning to semitone 0 in this case?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 03:39:38 PM
Code: [Select]
39 <== score  iteration ==>  3638    {0, 2, 5, 6, 7, 10}
   d [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
   p [0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10]

May I ask, which note are you assigning to semitone 0 in this case?

I doesn't really matter as the arithmetic is modal.

I had been assuming C.

Don't pay attention to the early results of my chord finder,  I noticed just after posting those results an off-by-one error in the table lookup.

I'm reworking the harmonic analysis of the 2 & 3 row melodeons just now.

Maybe this time with correct calculations.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 02, 2018, 03:48:49 PM
Well yes, obviously it's arbitrary, it's just, the results/proposed benefits of the layout are displayed in the form of named keys etc. 0 being C is what I had initially assumed, but, actually I was paying attention to the scales that the program proposed were available on a single direction: If 0 is C then B is 11, and 11 seems to be displayed as draw only, so I'm not sure how it could be a scale that's available on the press. Is the scale result that was posted also suspect?
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: -Y- on September 02, 2018, 04:50:28 PM
Maybe this provisional diagram makes it a little bit clearer?
[...]
That is a early concept.  I have since found better tone choices.

As provisional as it may be, I'm struggling to see patterns for scales progression, either row-by-row or cross-rows. Maybe later iterations of your layout yield better results in this respect.
For instance, one of the greatest nuisances I find on regular melodeons is the breaking of the pattern when moving up or down a given scale (damned VIIth degree). Here, you break the progression pattern. In this respect, I find the CBA layout hard to beat: it's highly coherent, homogeneous and so forth.
It's a matter of personal choice, but if I had the same concerns than you in terms of harmony, I would very much value consistency of the progression over a small gain in size (for instance, on a 3-row CBA, you only have 3 different fingerings for any given progression). All the more so when there are small-format, lightweight CBA available.

Still, you take on this matter is highly interesting, so please do continue.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 05:33:59 PM
Is the scale result that was posted also suspect?

It is not only suspect.  It is incorrect.

Here is a hopefully corrected version of 3638, but subtle(r) errors may remain.

Code: [Select]
40 <== score  iteration ==>  3638    {0, 2, 5, 6, 7, 10}
   d [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
   p [0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10]
   draw
     scales
        major C F G
        minor G
        superloc F#
     chords
        C C- Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C7 Cadd9 C9 C69
        D Dm D+ Dsus2 Dsus4 D6 Dm6 D7 Dm7 Dadd9 D69
        Em Esus2 Esus4 Em7 Em7b5
        F F- Fsus2 Fsus4 F6 Fmaj7 F9 F69
        F#+ F#- F#m7b5
        G Gm Gsus2 Gsus4 G6 Gm6 Gmaj7 GmM7 G7 Gm7 Gadd9 G9 G69
        Am Asus2 Asus4 Am6 Am7
        Bb Bb+ Bb- Bbsus2 Bb6 Bbmaj7 Bb9 Bb69
        Bm Bsus4 BmM7 Bm7 Bm7b5
   press
        major C# Eb G#
        minor Eb
        superloc D
     chords
        Cm Csus2 Csus4 Cm7 Cm7b5
        C# C#- C#sus2 C#sus4 C#6 C#maj7 C#9 C#69
        D+ D- Dm7b5
        Eb Ebm Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Eb6 Ebm6 Ebmaj7 EbmM7 Eb7 Ebm7 Ebadd9 Eb9 Eb69
        Fm Fsus2 Fsus4 Fm6 Fm7
        F# F#+ F#- F#sus2 F#6 F#maj7 F#9 F#69
        Gm Gsus4 GmM7 Gm7 Gm7b5
        G# G#- G#sus2 G#sus4 G#6 G#maj7 G#7 G#add9 G#9 G#69
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bb6 Bbm6 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbadd9 Bb69

The sieve finds 42 patterns that result in 6 scales, half of those are reversals.

Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 05:36:57 PM
Corrected harmonic analysis of the 2 and 3 row melodeon.

Code: [Select]
==== BC ====
d  [1, 2, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 3, 4, 6, 7, 11]
score =  0
   draw
     scales
     chords
        C# C#m C#+ C#6 C#m6 C#7 C#m7
        Dm Dsus2 Dm6 DmM7
        E E- Esus4 E6 E7
        F+ F-
        A A+ Asus2 Asus4 Amaj7 A9
        Bb Bbm Bb- Bbmaj7 BbmM7 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbm7b5
        Bm7b5
   press
     scales
     chords
        C Cm C- Cmaj7 CmM7
        Eb+
        Em Esus2 EmM7
        G+
        B B+ Bsus4
==== CF ====
d  [2, 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 4, 5, 7, 9]
score =  0
   draw
     scales
     chords
        Dm Dsus2 Dsus4 Dm6
        Em Esus4 Em7 Em7b5
        F-
        G Gm Gsus2 G6 Gm6 G7 Gm7 Gadd9 G69
        Asus2 Asus4
        Bb Bb- Bb6 Bbmaj7
        Bm7b5
   press
     scales
     chords
        C Csus4 C6
        F Fsus2 Fmaj7 F9
        Am Am7
==== BCC# ====
d  [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11]
score =  62
   draw
     scales
        major C# E F# A B
        minor C# Eb F# A B
        harminor C# Eb F# A Bb
        superloc C D F G# Bb
     chords
        C+ C- Cm7b5
        C# C#m C#+ C#sus2 C#sus4 C#6 C#m6 C#maj7 C#mM7 C#7 C#m7 C#add9 C#9 C#69
        D Dm D+ D- Dsus2 D6 Dm6 Dmaj7 DmM7 D7 Dm7 Dm7b5 Dadd9 D9 D69
        Ebm Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Ebm6 EbmM7 Ebm7 Ebm7b5
        E E+ E- Esus2 Esus4 E6 Emaj7 E7 Eadd9 E9 E69
        F Fm F+ F- Fsus4 F6 Fm6 Fmaj7 FmM7 F7 Fm7 Fm7b5
        F# F#m F#+ F#- F#sus2 F#sus4 F#6 F#m6 F#maj7 F#mM7 F#7 F#m7 F#m7b5 F#add9 F#9 F#69
        G# G#m G#+ G#- G#sus2 G#sus4 G#6 G#m6 G#7 G#m7 G#m7b5 G#add9 G#69
        A Am A+ A- Asus2 Asus4 A6 Am6 Amaj7 AmM7 A9 A69
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bb- Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bbmaj7 BbmM7 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbm7b5 Bbadd9 Bb9
        B Bm B- Bsus2 Bsus4 B6 Bm6 Bmaj7 BmM7 B7 Bm7 Bm7b5 Badd9 B9 B69
   press
     scales
     chords
        C Cm C+ C- Csus4 Cmaj7 CmM7
        C# C#m C#- C#sus2 C#sus4 C#maj7 C#mM7 C#7 C#m7 C#m7b5 C#add9 C#9
        Eb+
        E Em E+ Esus2 E6 Em6 Emaj7 EmM7 E9 E69
        Fm Fsus2 FmM7 Fm7 Fm7b5
        F#sus2 F#sus4
        G+ G-
        G# G#m G#+ G#sus4 G#6 G#m6 G#maj7 G#mM7 G#7 G#m7
        B B+ B- Bsus2 Bsus4 B6 B69
==== GCF ====
d  [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
p  [0, 2, 4, 5, 7, 9, 11]
score =  25
   draw
     scales
        major C F G
        minor G
        superloc F#
     chords
        C C- Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C7 Cadd9 C9 C69
        D Dm D+ Dsus2 Dsus4 D6 Dm6 D7 Dm7 Dadd9 D69
        Em Esus2 Esus4 Em7 Em7b5
        F F- Fsus2 Fsus4 F6 Fmaj7 F9 F69
        F#+ F#- F#m7b5
        G Gm Gsus2 Gsus4 G6 Gm6 Gmaj7 GmM7 G7 Gm7 Gadd9 G9 G69
        Am Asus2 Asus4 Am6 Am7
        Bb Bb+ Bb- Bbsus2 Bb6 Bbmaj7 Bb9 Bb69
        Bm Bsus4 BmM7 Bm7 Bm7b5
   press
     scales
        major C
     chords
        C Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C9 C69
        Dm Dsus2 Dsus4 Dm6 Dm7
        Em Esus4 Em7
        F F- Fsus2 F6 Fmaj7 F9 F69
        G Gsus2 Gsus4 G6 G7 Gadd9 G69
        Am Asus2 Asus4 Am7
        Bm7b5
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 05:42:33 PM
As provisional as it may be, I'm struggling to see patterns for scales progression, either row-by-row or cross-rows. Maybe later iterations of your layout yield better results in this respect.

There are two separate parts to the layout puzzle.

The first is choosing the which 6 notes are uni-sonoric and which 6 are bi-sonoric.  The harmonic analysis part as it were.

The second part is how best to tile the keyboard once the tone choices have been made.  I haven't really considered this yet.

.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 02, 2018, 08:14:28 PM
Is the scale result that was posted also suspect?

It is not only suspect.  It is incorrect.

Here is a hopefully corrected version of 3638, but subtle(r) errors may remain.

Code: [Select]
40 <== score  iteration ==>  3638    {0, 2, 5, 6, 7, 10}
   d [0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11]
   p [0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10]
   draw
     scales
        major C F G
        minor G
        superloc F#
     chords
        C C- Csus2 Csus4 C6 Cmaj7 C7 Cadd9 C9 C69
        D Dm D+ Dsus2 Dsus4 D6 Dm6 D7 Dm7 Dadd9 D69
        Em Esus2 Esus4 Em7 Em7b5
        F F- Fsus2 Fsus4 F6 Fmaj7 F9 F69
        F#+ F#- F#m7b5
        G Gm Gsus2 Gsus4 G6 Gm6 Gmaj7 GmM7 G7 Gm7 Gadd9 G9 G69
        Am Asus2 Asus4 Am6 Am7
        Bb Bb+ Bb- Bbsus2 Bb6 Bbmaj7 Bb9 Bb69
        Bm Bsus4 BmM7 Bm7 Bm7b5
   press
        major C# Eb G#
        minor Eb
        superloc D
     chords
        Cm Csus2 Csus4 Cm7 Cm7b5
        C# C#- C#sus2 C#sus4 C#6 C#maj7 C#9 C#69
        D+ D- Dm7b5
        Eb Ebm Ebsus2 Ebsus4 Eb6 Ebm6 Ebmaj7 EbmM7 Eb7 Ebm7 Ebadd9 Eb9 Eb69
        Fm Fsus2 Fsus4 Fm6 Fm7
        F# F#+ F#- F#sus2 F#6 F#maj7 F#9 F#69
        Gm Gsus4 GmM7 Gm7 Gm7b5
        G# G#- G#sus2 G#sus4 G#6 G#maj7 G#7 G#add9 G#9 G#69
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bbsus2 Bbsus4 Bb6 Bbm6 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbadd9 Bb69

So, I don't know if this will work very well for you. If you consider any of the scales that exist on your right side and their diatonic chords:
Reference & Available on Draw due to the full scale being available:
C major Draw ( C Dm Em F G Am Bdim ), F major Draw ( F Gm Am Bb C Dm Edim ) and G major Draw ( G Am Bm C D Em F#dim )

and look for those in the other direction, you find that the population is sparse (this is what I could see):
C major Press: ( ... ) F major Press (Bb) and G major Press ( ... )

Compare this to GCF:
C major Draw ( C Dm Em F G Am ), F major Draw ( F Gm Am Bb C Dm ) and G major Draw ( G Am Bm C D Em )
C major Press ( C Dm Em F G Am ), F major Press ( F Am C Dm ) and G major Press ( G Am C Em )

(NB - the diminished chords are probably available but I couldn't recognise them in your listing. GCF is not a bad system.)

If you consider your press C#, Eb and G# scales, you'll find these chords are also basically only functionally playable in one direction. If you intend to play these chords regularly, you would be in danger of finding yourself with either too much, or no, air in your bellows. But, I'm not sure that you if you are seeing the problem that I am seeing with that. I think you could definitely improve on a standard 3 row 3 key layout, and many people already have, but I think you're pushing this algorithm to deliver more scales, keys and chords, and it's taking it too far outside of what might really be playable.

Plus you're still not including your left hand side ideas at all. Surely a set of Unisonic basses would be a) a whole lower octave, reducing your need for such a long scale RHS and b) let you play anything you want to and diminish the need for voicing every note for RHS chords?

I just want to re-emphasise: they have to be bad at something. If you need all the notes in one direction for chords, but then tell it to find as many chords and scales as it can, you'll end up with solutions like this, with those chords only working in that one direction.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 02, 2018, 08:32:41 PM

(NB - the diminished chords are probably available but I couldn't recognise them in your listing. GCF is not a bad system.)


I am not presently scanning for diminished chords, only half-diminished.  I will add the diminished triad.

I probably should score the sieve on chords rather than scales. 
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 05, 2018, 07:27:57 PM
If you want to check out all chords, also available run of scales use melodeon explorer on my site.

  https://chrisryall.net/chords/

Type your layout into the lower box as a "rodex" and press the [!!] button to build the model

Do select/copy/paste/save to a text file first! You can prefix with a number to set octave of the notes (sorry, its octaves start on A). buttons under the simulation set tonic and chord to be examined. Left end also works, assuming 1+5 chords there. ">" arrows act as insetting tabs.

Try some some of the presets to explore the explorer first 😉 Do NOT touch the Ryanair gadget 😈
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 05, 2018, 08:24:10 PM
If you want to check out all chords, also available run of scales use melodeon explorer on my site.

  https://chrisryall.net/chords/



That's a neat web application!

Unfortunately,  I'm sieving all the possible noval keyboard mapping for all their contained chords.

I've written a little Python script to do this so that I can then perform a statistical analysis on the chord set.

I see you have the "Loomes" or "Whole Step" mapping.

That mapping demonstrates the many compromises one has to balance.

The Noval Wholestep mapping is extreamly fair, uniform, and has a rich harmonic structure.

But *because* it is so uniform it has the disadvantage that it shares no simple triads between push and draw.  It forces a lot of reversals.  Gena pointed out the importance that the mapping breath well.

Here is what the Wholestep mapping looks like:
Code: [Select]
12 <== score  iteration ==>  7445    {0, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10}
   d [0, 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10]
   p [0, 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11]
   draw
     scales
     chords
        C# C#m C#+ C#sus4 C#6 C#m6 C#maj7 C#mM7
        Ab+ Ab-
        Bb Bbm Bb+ Bb- Bbm- Bbsus2 Bbmaj7 BbmM7 Bb7 Bbm7 Bbm7b5 Bbadd9 Bb9
        F Fm F+ Fsus4 F6 Fm6 Fmaj7 FmM7
        C+ C-
        D Dm D+ D- Dm- Dsus2 Dmaj7 DmM7 D7 Dm7 Dm7b5 Dadd9 D9
        A Am A+ Asus4 A6 Am6 Amaj7 AmM7
        E+ E-
        F# F#m F#+ F#- F#m- F#sus2 F#maj7 F#mM7 F#7 F#m7 F#m7b5 F#add9 F#9
   push
     scales
     chords
        Ab Abm Ab+ Ab- Abm- Absus2 Abmaj7 AbmM7 Ab7 Abm7 Abm7b5 Abadd9 Ab9
        Eb Ebm Eb+ Ebsus4 Eb6 Ebm6 Ebmaj7 EbmM7
        Bb+ Bb-
        C Cm C+ C- Cm- Csus2 Cmaj7 CmM7 C7 Cm7 Cm7b5 Cadd9 C9
        G Gm G+ Gsus4 G6 Gm6 Gmaj7 GmM7
        D+ D-
        E Em E+ E- Em- Esus2 Emaj7 EmM7 E7 Em7 Em7b5 Eadd9 E9
        B Bm B+ Bsus4 B6 Bm6 Bmaj7 BmM7
        F#+ F#-
   in push_and_draw
     chords
        Ab+ Ab-
        Bb+ Bb-
        C+ C-
        D+ D-
        E+ E-
        F#+ F#-
   in push_or_draw
     chords
        C# C#+ C#6 C#m C#m6 C#mM7 C#maj7 C#sus4
        Ab Ab+ Ab- Ab7 Ab9 Abadd9 Abm Abm- Abm7 Abm7b5 AbmM7 Abmaj7 Absus2
        Eb Eb+ Eb6 Ebm Ebm6 EbmM7 Ebmaj7 Ebsus4
        Bb Bb+ Bb- Bb7 Bb9 Bbadd9 Bbm Bbm- Bbm7 Bbm7b5 BbmM7 Bbmaj7 Bbsus2
        F F+ F6 Fm Fm6 FmM7 Fmaj7 Fsus4
        C C+ C- C7 C9 Cadd9 Cm Cm- Cm7 Cm7b5 CmM7 Cmaj7 Csus2
        G G+ G6 Gm Gm6 GmM7 Gmaj7 Gsus4
        D D+ D- D7 D9 Dadd9 Dm Dm- Dm7 Dm7b5 DmM7 Dmaj7 Dsus2
        A A+ A6 Am Am6 AmM7 Amaj7 Asus4
        E E+ E- E7 E9 Eadd9 Em Em- Em7 Em7b5 EmM7 Emaj7 Esus2
        B B+ B6 Bm Bm6 BmM7 Bmaj7 Bsus4
        F# F#+ F#- F#7 F#9 F#add9 F#m F#m- F#m7 F#m7b5 F#mM7 F#maj7 F#sus2
    simple triads
        C# C#m
        Ab Abm
        Eb Ebm
        Bb Bbm
        F Fm
        C Cm
        G Gm
        D Dm
        A Am
        E Em
        B Bm
        F# F#m
    126 chords in iteration  7445
    12 in common from  126 total in iteration  7445
    24 simple triads with 0 in common from 126 in iteration  7445
    0 common triads from 24 of 126 in iteration  7445

Its got all the trivial triads, but shares none of them between push and pull.  Its only sharing diminished and augmented triads on every other key around the circle of fifths.

Every other key around the circle of fifths is weak.

I have been searching for the best mappings who's distributions of chords are skewed towards friendly common keys, at the expense of being unfavorable to keys with lots of sharps or flats.  Of necessity these mappings have less uniform keyboard layouts.

I like mappings with chord distributions that look like this (NB- for the purpose of demonstrating skew):
Code: [Select]
   in push_and_draw
     chords
        F F6 F69 F9 Fmaj7 Fsus2
        C C6 C69 Csus2 Csus4
        Gsus2 Gsus4
        Dm Dm7 Dsus2 Dsus4
        Am Am7 Asus4
   in push_or_draw
     chords
        C#+ C#- C#m- C#m7b5
        Ab+ Ab-
        Eb+ Eb-
        Bb Bb+ Bb- Bb6 Bb69 Bb7 Bb9 Bbadd9 Bbmaj7 Bbsus2
        F F+ F- F6 F69 F7 F9 Fadd9 Fm Fm6 FmM7 Fmaj7 Fsus2 Fsus4
        C C+ C- C6 C69 C7 C9 Cadd9 Cm Cm6 CmM7 Cmaj7 Csus2 Csus4
        G G+ G- G6 G69 G7 Gadd9 Gm Gm6 Gm7 GmM7 Gsus2 Gsus4
        D D+ D- D7 Dadd9 Dm Dm- Dm6 Dm7 Dm7b5 DmM7 Dsus2 Dsus4
        A A+ A- A7 Aadd9 Am Am- Am6 Am7 Am7b5 AmM7 Asus2 Asus4
        E+ E- Em Em- Em6 Em7 Em7b5 EmM7 Esus4
        B+ B- Bm- Bm7b5
        F#+ F#- F#m- F#m7b5
    simple triads
        Bb
        F Fm
        C Cm
        G Gm
        D Dm
        A Am
        Em
    102 chords in iteration  63
    20 in common from  102 total in iteration  63
    12 simple triads with 4 in common from 102 in iteration  63
    4 common triads from 12 of 102 in iteration  63

If has fewer cords, but a more practical distribution.

I'm now looking at mappings with respect to the ease of sourcing the reedplates they require, and also the simplicity of the resulting fingerings.

I'm well down the rabbit's hole.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Richard Shaul on September 05, 2018, 10:36:23 PM
A Python script! is that as in Monty Python? we haven't seen one of them in a few years.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Anahata on September 05, 2018, 11:30:27 PM
is that as in Monty Python?
Python: the 2nd most popular programming language in the world, according to some sources.
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 06, 2018, 12:47:07 AM
is that as in Monty Python?
Python: the 2nd most popular programming language in the world, according to some sources.

Even a relatively computer illiterate old fart like me has been known to have used it.
[Edit: forced to use it with Blender, on a gaming project]
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Anahata on September 06, 2018, 08:36:17 AM
The reference to Monty Python is relevant though: the language was invented by Guido Van Rossum, who had been reading the published Monty Python's Flying Circus scripts at the time, and he was looking for a short and memorable name for his new language...
Title: Re: Ideas for improving the chromaticity of the keyboard layout.
Post by: Chris Rayner on September 06, 2018, 09:11:54 AM
<Vroop!! Vroooooooppp!!> Thread drift alarm.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal