Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Lester on August 28, 2009, 12:28:31 PM

Title: Session in Vienna
Post by: Lester on August 28, 2009, 12:28:31 PM
As you may have seen in another thread I went to a session in Vienna (Café Concerto) last night thanks to a happenstance post by Michael. It was totally different and, though I hate to admit it, much more fun than most the sessions I have been to in England.

To start with there were some interesting instruments, two hurdy gurdys, bagpipes and double bass. But more importantly there were people who had come along to dance, what a difference it makes to a session when rather than just banging out tunes for your own entertainment you are involving the audience in a physical manner. No trouble with the right speed at this session you could see the dancers and it was blindingly obvious what the tune was for and how it should be played.

The other main difference was that the tunes were played many times through, none of your 3 times through and change here, we played tunes 20 times through and far from being boring it let me understand the tune better and add to it. John Kirkpatrick has banged on (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.htm) about this and previously I have not got what he meant but now I do and it is fabulous.  Kind of think you need everyone to be in the same place otherwise they may well just drift off, buy a beer, have a chat.   :(

So be careful of letting me start a tune in a session now as I may just play it 20 times and see who gets it and who doesn’t.

So, please can we have dancers at sessions, no more endless melodies, more interesting instrument mixes. Probably not but I may start a movement!   >:E

But if you are ever in Vienna on the 4th Thursday go to the Café Vienna, to the 3rd floor (which confusingly is in the basement) and really enjoy yourself.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: rees on August 28, 2009, 01:02:52 PM

So be careful of letting me start a tune in a session now as I may just play it 20 times and see who gets it and who doesn’t.

So, please can we have dancers at sessions, no more endless melodies, more interesting instrument mixes. Probably not but I may start a movement!   >:E



I'm with you 100% percent on these, Lester.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 28, 2009, 02:19:48 PM
Hi Lester, I'm fascinated by your description of events. Particularly the dancing. It seems obvious to me that if you've got dancers then you'll naturally need to play longer tunes (or the same tune more times through). But did the dancers say what they wanted? How was that end of things organised, or was it?
AL
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Lester on August 28, 2009, 02:41:06 PM
Hi Lester, I'm fascinated by your description of events. Particularly the dancing. It seems obvious to me that if you've got dancers then you'll naturally need to play longer tunes (or the same tune more times through). But did the dancers say what they wanted? How was that end of things organised, or was it?
AL

The dancers just got up and danced/or not to whatever was played. They did not request anything in particular. It was a French session so bourees, schottiches, waltzes etc (and rather peculiarly Circassian Circle), so when we played a waltz they waltzed etc.

As to single tunes, in my band, and most others I have heard in the UK we play medleys rather than single tunes and I am now convinced that it is not always the right thing.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 28, 2009, 02:53:06 PM
Quote
It was a French session so bourees, schottiches, waltzes etc (and rather peculiarly Circassian Circle)
Ay, that'll be the old alliance ;)

Quote
As to single tunes, in my band, and most others I have heard in the UK we play medleys rather than single tunes and I am now convinced that it is not always the right thing.
I agree, I've often thought that tunes are changed too quickly and that staying with a tune longer would be much better v.often?

But to get back to the dancing, did the dancers change what they doing in response to the music then? I love the idea of the freedom that comes with a session - and to combine that with dance - sounds really great! Did some people come along specifically to dance or were they partners and friends of the musicians, in other words was the dance a spontaneous response to the music or something a little more organised?
AL
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Lester on August 28, 2009, 03:13:35 PM
But to get back to the dancing, did the dancers change what they doing in response to the music then?
They danced the dance for the type of tune being played.

Quote
Did some people come along specifically to dance or were they partners and friends of the musicians, in other words was the dance a spontaneous response to the music or something a little more organised?

They appeared to come to dance - the session was not a music session it was a french dance session where dances were played and danced, Oh! that we did that! The dancing was spontaneous, everyone knew each othere but that is usually true at a session.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Gumble on August 28, 2009, 03:15:19 PM
I would love to go to a session like that, where the music actually gets used, as it were, in more ways.

There is a dancing-session type operation in The Waterfront in Falmouth. Not having much experience of sessions, it may not be such an unusual set up, but... They have Cornish and Breton music and dancing once a week, and although it is dance-oriented, the band feels almost like a session. There can be anything from 4 - 15 people in the band (and it's not a big place. At all.) and they'll welcome anyone along. I joined in after I'd been playing for three weeks and had one of their tunes rather hesitantly on the right hand. I owe them a debt of gratitude for persuading me to play in public so early on, even if I was hiding behind eight other instruments!

If you ever find yourself in Falmouth I can heartily recommend the place - the best atmosphere for dancing I've ever seen. Probably due to the total lack of space, excess of enthusiasm and a range of good ale!
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: nemethmik on August 28, 2009, 03:17:42 PM
As you may have seen in another thread I went to a session in Vienna (Café Concerto) last night thanks to a happenstance post by Michael.
I live next door to Vienna, and often come to visit. Can you give me more contact information about these French sessions in Vienna?
Thank You, Miki
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Owen Woods on August 28, 2009, 03:51:32 PM
I will be in Vienna in a week or so. Of course I don't have an instrument with me, but it would have been nice to attend.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: michik on August 28, 2009, 04:03:17 PM
At least there is an irish session every first monday (next one: September, 7th) in the 'Old Oak' pup:  http://www.oldoakpub.at
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 28, 2009, 04:40:06 PM
The other main difference was that the tunes were played many times through, none of your 3 times through and change here, we played tunes 20 times through and far from being boring it let me understand the tune better and add to it. John Kirkpatrick has banged on (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.htm) about this and previously I have not got what he meant but now I do and it is fabulous. 
The first time (years ago) I read this particular bit of writing by JK, I was completely bowled over by it and have tried to live by it as much as possible ever since.

Quote
Kind of think you need everyone to be in the same place otherwise they may well just drift off, buy a beer, have a chat.   :(
Well - it's their loss. If they want  to snob off, that's up to them. The only thing I can't stand is people having a fortissimo conversation whilst the tunes are going on. In my view, if you don't know a tune being played in a session, it's not a time to start nattering to your neighbour; you should shut up and try to learn the tune instead. (Don't get me started, Grrr!  :( )
Quote
So be careful of letting me start a tune in a session now as I may just play it 20 times and see who gets it and who doesn’t.
I'll be with you, Lester. Let's try it at Witney.  >:E
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: forrest on August 28, 2009, 06:06:41 PM
........ No trouble with the right speed at this session you could see the dancers and it was blindingly obvious what the tune was for and how it should be played.
 

  What a relief that must be........ :Ph

The other main difference was that the tunes were played many times through, none of your 3 times through and change here, we played tunes 20 times through and far from being boring it let me understand the tune better and add to it.

  Yes, an excellent practice! It helps contradict the conditioned 2 second attention span of our current point-and-click mentality!   ;)
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 28, 2009, 10:16:32 PM
Hi Lester,
Those are the sessions (in Vienna) that got me hooked on playing the box, and when I moved back to the states, to NY, I was rather shocked to find out that there weren't sessions like that there. (Just hyper-speed Irish sessions, and some "old-time," which is not particularly "box-friendly.")
Glad you enjoyed it!  There is one session where old Austrian tunes are played, with gurdies and bagpipes, probably the same players whom you met at the French session.
Thanks for sharing,
Andy
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 28, 2009, 10:46:39 PM
Was in Vienna in March - but sadly not the magic week. Lovely place.

I'd echo everything Lester has said. Music that loses touch with its purpose is no longer music with meaning. It is far better to move with a single theme, improvising and arranging, than to progess through these ghastly medleys that seem to obsess The English Session.

I recall John K preaching against the 'Mudley' some 20 years ago. He heeded his own advice, but very few of us seem to have have followed.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Bryson on August 29, 2009, 10:17:20 AM
I recently returned from Folk Camp Germany http://www.folkcamp.de/e-index.htm which takes place in southern Germany at Schloss Zeilitzheim http://www.schloss-zeilitzheim.de/ .
We have workshops in the morning where we learn a couple of tunes, go-over stuff from yesterday etc. The key though is that this workshop is a preparation for the English Ceilidh (not a contradiction.. google it) in the evening.
This year we were lucky to have Roger Watson and Liam Robinson as the workshop/dance band leaders (they are also booked for next year 24 -31 July 2010). This was actually my third folk Camp in Germany. The general structure in the past was to have 2 or 3 tunes for each dance. Roger and Liam changed this. First they emphasised that dancers dance to rhythm not melody so workshops focused not on learning lots of melodies but applying, for example, different rhythms to the same melody - we even had a rhythm from Ghana - thanks to Roger for that. Liam focused on, as I put it, "messing about with the melody" but maintaining the rhythm for the dances. Some people, who wanted to "play the tune as written" were a little disoriented by this but, I must admit, for me it was like a breath of fresh air.
The difference between playing in a session and playing for dancing is of the chalk and cheese variety i.e. superficially these appear similar but are, indeed, very different.
One of the things that I particularly like is the fact that the dance controls the tempo. So, rather than people playing as if their first goal is to get to the end of a tune as quickly as possible they can focus on the rhythm and musicality for the dance.
For an example of what I mean watch this - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VnGiKYzsqYg - the last minute where Roger Watson plays for dancing.

Remember 99% of the tunes we play were written for "social dance".

cheers
Bryson
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: EeeJay on August 29, 2009, 04:15:36 PM
John Kirkpatrick has banged on (http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.htm) about this and previously I have not got what he meant but now I do and it is fabulous.

Always looked upon that article as reactional. Purposefully reactional. >:E

Obviously, a well aimed (and well deserved) swipe at the (then very prim) DEAFASS (aka EFDSS) establishment - and the prevailing tendency for very smug arrangements, and general attempts to 'sanitise' the music...

Central French/Breton sessions do have a tendency to stick to one tune... allowing for all manner of counter-melodies, improvising, etc. I love doing this sort of thing on a regular basis, and it's absolutely great for making you think. Indeed, keeping a variety of musical outlets/genres is extremely advantageous. 8)

However... 'Three times around and the next...' is the widely accepted usual form for all manner of sessions - Irish, Scottish, etc... Keeps it buzzing along.... A set of Slides or Polcas stuck on one tune? 'Scuse me as I fall off my chair... Zzzzzzzzz..... ::)

And as regards dancing... Irish set dancing thrives on the drive of the tune change... As does Rapper... which is English...

To be honest, I know what JK's getting at, but this article is very narrow/specific in its scope...

Ed J
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Falseknight on August 30, 2009, 12:09:21 PM
it seems we are getting into the territory of ritual dance here.

Why do we dance what we dance?

Why do we dance what we dance to the tunes we dance to?
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Mike Higgins on August 30, 2009, 12:23:35 PM
In my opinion, is this where I should write IMHO, the 'job' of the tune in a social dance is to tell me what to do next, not to prevent me from falling asleep during the dance. If the band falls asleep at the seventh repetition of the tune I suppose it might have some consequences in that the audience would have to sing the tune until they woke up again. When I am dancing at a ceilidh the tune is only a means to an end for me.

One of my favourite dances is Oswestry Wake, I can't imagine doing the dance to any other tune than 'Oswestry Wake'. The same holds true for quite a few other dances too many to list although Sir Roger de Coverley is one of them, which can go on for as long as it likes.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: graememackay on August 31, 2009, 10:23:55 AM
I've gotten into a few discussions at sessions.  Sitting round a table and keeping all the music to ourselves is selfish.  I feel if you want to bash out tunes for your own enjoyment, do it at home!  If you are playing in public you need to be entertaining.  Whether the people are listening or dancing, they are there to enjoy the music.  It's those guys who create the atmosphere, especially if they dance.

The Vienna session sounds wonderful.  Its the way things should be.  Even informal sessions should be enteraining for spectators.  music was created to be heard.

Repeating the tunes is good to give everyone a shot at leading it, creating harmonies & variations or getting the hang of it if you don't know it.

All good fun
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: melodeon on August 31, 2009, 03:57:45 PM
The Vienna session sounds great fun.

Quite unlike the self indulgent "exclusive" sessions I have attended on the west coast ( USA )

It has long been my opinion that some of the best music is intended for dance.
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: melodeon on August 31, 2009, 08:31:23 PM
http://www.arhoolie.com/titles/454.shtml
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 31, 2009, 09:17:39 PM
http://www.arhoolie.com/titles/454.shtml

HA!  Thanks for that link. Die Citoller Tanzgeiger! I have met the musicians in the video (had several beers with them at the Styrian "Geigentag" years ago), and the youngster playing bass in the background gave me my first (and only) fiddle lesson.  Hermann (fiddler in the foreground) is quite a character and a wonderful collector of tunes and songs.  They are among the finest traditional musicians in Styria.
-Andy
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: mikesamwild on September 01, 2009, 12:34:10 PM
The Vienna session sounds great fun.

Quite unlike the self indulgent "exclusive" sessions I have attended on the west coast ( USA )

It has long been my opinion that some of the best music is intended for dance.


I think you'll find that most of what we trad musicians play is/was dance music.  Too fast or too slow can ruin a dance.  The best situation for me is good dancers who know their dance, no caller and sensitive, interactive musicians. Plus a good floor and a bit of booze and good crack!
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 01, 2009, 01:58:37 PM
There is actually a (now) traditional French dance pas d'été in which the musician(s) go faster and faster, as do the solo dancer(s). The step and notes are nicely judged for balance and generally a few of each drop out in the later repeats. I've seen both sides win on occasion.

Please note that there is nothing in the above that justifies doing Every Single F'in Tune as a medley ::)

   Sorry - above should read tune in F  ;D  (pardon my French)!
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 01, 2009, 02:26:01 PM
Quote
Every Single F'in Tune
oooh la la!
 ;)
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: Lester on September 15, 2009, 09:33:25 AM
There is a god (or goddess), I have to visit Vienna yet again next week and that is the Cafe Concerto session week. I will take a real melodeon this time.

 (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:)
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: michik on September 15, 2009, 09:46:38 AM
There is a god (or goddess), I have to visit Vienna yet again next week and that is the Cafe Concerto session week. I will take a real melodeon this time.

 (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:) (:)

Yes, the next dates have been fixed:
September 24th
October 22nd
November 26th
Session starting at 21:00

Actually there is also a session every 3rd Wednesday at the same place and same time:
It's the "EuRoots" Session, where european folk is played (traditional and new)

Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: brianread on September 15, 2009, 09:48:42 AM
good luck Lester, we are all green with envy!!
Title: Re: Session in Vienna
Post by: ladydetemps on September 15, 2009, 10:35:37 AM
So be careful of letting me start a tune in a session now as I may just play it 20 times and see who gets it and who doesn’t.
Sounds like a good idea....by 20th time I may have figured out what tune it is and got at least 80% of the notes right at least once. Even if it was one note each time round.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal