Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Fungusface on August 28, 2009, 01:52:45 PM

Title: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Fungusface on August 28, 2009, 01:52:45 PM
Ive always wondered about these questions

(a)When does Melodeon become an accordion

(b) Do you get push/pull piano accordions
---------------------------------------
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Bill the Farmer on August 28, 2009, 02:05:18 PM
Ive always wondered about these questions

(a)When does Melodeon become an accordion
In the good old US of A.  ::)
(b) Do you get push/pull piano accordions
---------------------------------------
Well, you can, but it doesn't make a lot of difference.  ;D
     :||:
 :M  :M
 :M  :M
 :M  :M
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 28, 2009, 02:13:16 PM
AHA! One of my favourite topics. Easy answer - we're all accordions!
AL
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Andy Simpson on August 28, 2009, 02:17:08 PM
When does a melodeon become an accordion?...when it becomes no fun to play and horrible to listen to. ;D
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 28, 2009, 02:54:22 PM
When it has more than one row and is in every other corner of the world apart from England >:E
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: rees on August 28, 2009, 05:26:12 PM
When it has more than one row and is in every other corner of the world apart from England >:E

That's pretty close Al, although in Sweden it is a dragspel, Italy - organetto, Germany - trekharmonika, etc.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 28, 2009, 05:36:01 PM
Quote
That's pretty close Al, although in Sweden it is a dragspel, Italy - organetto, Germany - trekharmonika,
Yup and when translated they all mean accordion :D
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: ganderbox on August 28, 2009, 05:50:42 PM
When it has more than one row and is in every other corner of the world apart from England >:E

I reckon this is true, but it's the choice of basses that matters rather than the number of rows. Once you have any option about which bass you play with a particular note on the treble end, you have an accordion.
That would mean theoretically that a one row could be an accordion if it had more than the usual 2 basses.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Andy Simpson on August 28, 2009, 06:15:19 PM
Quote
That's pretty close Al, although in Sweden it is a dragspel, Italy - organetto, Germany - trekharmonika,
Yup and when translated they all mean accordion :D

When you translate "brustwarze" from German it means "nipple" but it literally says "breast wart"...things get homogenised in translation.  ;) :D
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Bryson on August 28, 2009, 08:09:16 PM
Simple: melodeons play different notes on push and pull accordions don't.
No matter what the owners call it :)
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 28, 2009, 08:31:14 PM
Quote
melodeons play different notes on push and pull accordions don't.
Sorry but that is nowhere near correct! Most places around the world call their diatonic instruments accordions/accordeons etc. So bisonorism/unisonorism is no way of defining an accordion.
AL
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: rees on August 28, 2009, 09:22:14 PM
In Wales we simply call it "y bocs" (the box) or "scwisbocs" (squeezebox).

http://www.neilandmeg.com/pics/SCD2211cover.jpg (http://www.neilandmeg.com/pics/SCD2211cover.jpg)
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 29, 2009, 08:41:33 AM
Quote
In Wales we simply call it "y bocs" (the box) or "scwisbocs" (squeezebox).
You're using a colloquialism there Rees. Its a well known fact in linguistic circles that Welsh is an ancient language that stopped 'growing' new words hundreds of years ago. Anything since then that wasn't already written into the language has become an adopted word and is usually a cymraic form of the English word. So 'box' - 'y bocs' it is. But if you look in a Welsh dictionary - like say the online one at University of Wales Lampeter (http://www.geiriadur.net/atebion.php?PHPSESSID=8103a911734e7d6d478c59631a8be454&uni=y&prefLang=en&term=acordion&direction=we&whichpart=exact&type=noun&PHPSESSID=8103a911734e7d6d478c59631a8be454) you'll see that the Welsh term for accordion is...'acordion'. Grand!
AL
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: joe on August 29, 2009, 09:41:41 AM
Its a box. plain and simple.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: waldoB on August 29, 2009, 10:11:17 AM
Mally's original Absolute Beginners suggests Melodeon for a diatonic, AccordEOn for a chromatic. Suck squeeze is bisonoric.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 29, 2009, 10:46:41 AM
Quote
Its a box. plain and simple.
In which case there's no distinction and the term accordion can be applied across the board?
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 29, 2009, 03:31:29 PM
It seems to me that this website is the only place an accordion is called a "melodeon".

Old Hohner advertisements show diatonic instruments and spell it "accordeon".

In Mexico its "acordeon".

In the Alps, it's a "harmonika".
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 29, 2009, 04:52:58 PM
In Cleckheaton under early Thacherism it was 'anthing to make an honest living' - which to Mally's credit he did amazingly well.

As for 'WhatsAMelodeon?; (underneath)  - I'd agree accorde/ion is the more generic term, but still hold to my view that it's mostly in the brain of the musician .. that they are different styles.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Andy Simpson on August 29, 2009, 04:56:01 PM
Quote
Its a box. plain and simple.
In which case there's no distinction and the term accordion can be applied across the board?


Would you call a double bass a violin or a bouzouki a mandolin?.

A Hohner Pokerwork and a Hohner Atlantic can both be accurately described as accordions as an umbrella term, in greater detail than that, one's a melodeon or diatonic accordion and one's a piano accordion. I call a Pokerwork a melodeon because I'm from England and for reasons seemingly lost in the mists of time that is the generally accepted, established and understood term for a diatonic bisonoric member of the accordion family, if I was Dutch I'd call it a trekharmonika and if I was French I might call it a diato. I don't see any cause for confusion.

I call those elastic things that some peole wear over their shoulders to keep their trousers up "braces" but I know what an American means by "suspenders". I also know what they mean by "your mileage may vary".  (:)

So to go back to the original question, when does a melodeon become an accordion?....what kind of accordion?. A "melodeon" is a specific term and "accordion" a general one IMHO.
 
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Nick Hudis on August 29, 2009, 11:08:04 PM
It is so important to get terminology right.

The old traditional players of East Anglia mistakenly called their melodeons "accordions" or even worse just "musics".  Have to put it down to uneducated rustic ignorance.

Wonder what Bob Cann called his.  Bet he didn't use the right word.

My Finnish friends seem to just talk about "Two Rows" and "Five Rows" as if the distinction between a bisoric and a unisoric box was not really important.  How misguided.  And the really foolish ones (like Markku Leipisto seem to be able make great music on either interchangeably.

Being a rebellious old bugger, If I'm with accordion players I call my box a melodeon, if I'm with melodeon players........

What's needed is an international committee to decide once and for all on the correct naming of free reed instruments with vicious punishments for any infringements.  The severest sanctions should be against players who commit the sin of playing both unisoric and bisoric boxes.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: graememackay on August 30, 2009, 02:00:50 AM
I would say that a melodeon becomes an accordion when stradella bass is added, along with more treble notes, couplers, bigger bellows etc etc.

I wouldn't call my Shand Morino a melodeon.  It's a button keyed accordion, as opposed to a piano keyed accordion.  In fact I'd say anything from Trichord level onwards.

So when a button box has similar characteristics as a piano box, it can be called an accordion. The only difference being the directional bellows.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 30, 2009, 02:02:18 AM
Who cares what you call your instrument?

I find that people are more interested in hearing me play it than talk about it.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 30, 2009, 02:03:56 AM
If I must call my instruments something...

The piano accordion is the big one.

The melodeon is the little one.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 30, 2009, 10:08:42 AM
Look, you're all right. Its just that no one who knows me says 'Oh isn't it fun painful when Captain AL plays his melodeon!'. Everyone in my community calls what I play an accordion. So I think that regardless of the finer distinctions - including whatever I may think - if the overwhelming majority of folk call what I play an accordion - then what I play is an accordion. It's the burden of usage.
AL
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: george garside on August 30, 2009, 11:12:36 AM
as far as I am aware  what many of us (? most of us on this forum)  call a 'melodeon' was the  great grandfather of the accordion family c 1829.   10 key single row sook an blaw box - fist harmonica  or whatever that is in German.

Therefore logically all melodeons are accordions but , depending to a large degree on where you live  the term melodeon i can be used for the subspecies of small  sook an blaw boxes  with sook  an blaw basses.  This does not in anyway make them any less of an 'accordion'!   The non box playing public  generally refer to them as accordions as in " I like the way your accordion sounds " or even  " your accordion sounds bloody awful"

george
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2009, 11:29:17 AM
And these are called melodeons too:
(http://www.pumporganrestorations.com/images/melodeon.jpg)

more details here (http://www.pumporganrestorations.com/they_were_called_melodeons.htm)

For my money they are all accordions, our type are diatonic accordions,  the ones with piano keys are piano accordions.  To my knowledge its only in England that the term melodeon is widely used.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: ladydetemps on August 30, 2009, 11:39:16 AM
I tend to get blank looks whatever i call it. I tend to resort to miming playing saying it has buttons not keys. If that fails i have a vid on my mobile to demonstrate.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 30, 2009, 11:59:23 AM
Quote
And these are called melodeons too:http://www.pumporganrestorations.com/they_were_called_melodeons.htm (http://www.pumporganrestorations.com/they_were_called_melodeons.htm)

Hallelujah! Now that's what I call a melodeon!
AL ;D ;D ;D

Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Owen Woods on August 30, 2009, 08:22:23 PM
I tried to explain all the terms in use to a friend of mine and he gave up when I got to the British chromatic Accordion :P
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: george garside on August 31, 2009, 09:30:13 AM
the term 'box' is arguably the most common term used in the UK by box players!!.  Do other nationalities use the same term eg coffre, lada, doboz,  pouzdro, kiste etc etc?

george :-\
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: ladydetemps on August 31, 2009, 09:51:01 AM
My mum keeps calling my concertina a melodeon and my melodeon a concertina. Lol
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: juker on August 31, 2009, 10:06:42 AM
Nobody here (in Australia) knows what a melodeon is. I call it a box, but can get strange looks from some people when I say that. If I say 'button accordion' most folk know what I mean.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Tattyjacket on August 31, 2009, 07:52:29 PM
When does a melodeon become an accordian?

Just as soon as the boat has docked in Rosslaire.

Secondly, What do you call an accordian at the bottom of the ocean?
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
A good start.

Phil
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 31, 2009, 08:03:13 PM
Quote
What do you call an accordian at the bottom of the ocean?
Wet tuned!
 ;D
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: ganderbox on September 01, 2009, 12:00:58 AM
However, in the words of the song...

"The Sharks they play Melodeons
At the bottom of the Sea"   (or Bay, depending on which version you sing)
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: rees on September 01, 2009, 01:17:46 AM
the term 'box' is arguably the most common term used in the UK by box players!!.  Do other nationalities use the same term eg coffre, lada, doboz,  pouzdro, kiste etc etc?

george :-\

Yes, Wales, bocs.  ::)
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Organettisto on September 01, 2009, 05:26:58 AM
In Italy they refer to a piano accordion as a "fisarmonica" and they refer to a button box as an "organetto."  Here in the States they are all called accordions, though musicians, or people who know about the instruments, will call them by their more specific terms; button box, melodeon, concertina, diatonic accordion, Cajun accordion, etc.   I refer to my organetto as an accordion to laypeople so they know what the hell I'm talking about!
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Keithypete. on September 04, 2009, 01:34:00 AM
If you wish to browse the instruments on the Castagnari and other maker's websites you often have to click the 'Accordions' button.  Beltuna have Accordions and Diatonics.  When I worked in Scotland and told people that I played a 'box, they would usually enquire 'Buttons or keys?' I guess we all know what we mean really. Some instruments are too nice just to be called a 'box though. Having said that some PAs could be referred to as 'Wardrobe' rather than 'box. However my Beltuna Sara II, is very nice but it is very box like. I concurr with Lester on where the line of dichotamy lies re concertinas.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Howard Jones on September 04, 2009, 09:36:21 AM
I find it quite handy to have a single word, "melodeon", to describe my particular variant of the accordion family.  Most of the other accordions seem to have to be qualified in some way: "piano" accordion, "continental button" accordion, "British chromatic" accordion, etc.  All a bit of a mouthful.

Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Hello on September 06, 2009, 11:26:32 AM
A Dutch person I knew always referred to my pokerwork as a "harmonica".
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: craigus on September 14, 2009, 12:14:11 AM
I always end up calling mine an accordian (although I spell it 'accordeon' in my head,, of course!) when talking to people, because hardly anybody outside the folk world knows the word 'melodeon'.
Also, in Ireland, isn't a two row called a button accordeon, and a one row called a melodeon.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: baz parkes on September 15, 2009, 11:06:38 AM

Wonder what Bob Cann called his.  Bet he didn't use the right word.
[/[i[/i]quote]

West Country Melodeon according to his Topic album title ;D...I've been searching in vain for a picture of the sleeve.

Baz
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: baz parkes on September 15, 2009, 11:10:15 AM
The old traditional players of East Anglia mistakenly called their melodeons "accordions" or even worse just "musics". 

At one of the early English Country Music Weekends I heard one old boy refer disparigingly to the number of "F***in' ole mcordeons" that were interfering with the singing.  Although in his cups, he may have had a point >:E

Baz
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: ladydetemps on September 15, 2009, 11:19:49 AM
mcordeons. lol!
seems like a good compromise between the two.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on September 15, 2009, 10:12:29 PM
A friend of mine (yes - another one, I have two!), a D/G player since the seventies, if he sees a man with a diatonic accordion, not infrequently says "Oo look! Man with squeaky handbag!"
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 16, 2009, 06:15:47 AM
hardly anybody outside the folk world knows the word 'melodeon'. ... in Ireland, isn't a two row called a button accordeon, and a one row called a melodeon.

This is what I was alluding to in my little post on the 'essence' thread yesterday. (The one that got me shot down in flames before luchtime). OK - it's a Melodeon's a very useful current name on our little island. But not if you travel.
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: Owen Woods on September 21, 2009, 05:04:15 PM
Was at a session in an Irish pub last night and someone said "Is that an accordeon?" I hesitated, thinking, "Now does he mean Accordion or Accordeon?" After a few minutes of conversation I still wasn't sure :P
Title: Re: When does a Melodeon become an Accordion
Post by: ladydetemps on September 21, 2009, 05:07:01 PM
Was at a session in an Irish pub last night and someone said "Is that an accordeon?" I hesitated, thinking, "Now does he mean Accordion or Accordeon?" After a few minutes of conversation I still wasn't sure :P
Its a thingy...I fiendish squeezy thingy....with buttons. ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal