Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: j.b.c. on September 03, 2018, 07:02:34 PM

Title: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 03, 2018, 07:02:34 PM
I need reeds with big intervals for the tuning I want to try.

reed pairs    1/2 tones
----------    ---------
 B-E          5
 C-F          5
 D-G          5
 E-A          5
 F-Bâ™­         5
 G-C          5
 A-D          5
 Eâ™­-Aâ™­        5
 F#-C#        7


Do such reedplates exist, or do I have to glue halved reeds to a carrier plate?

thanks.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Winston Smith on September 03, 2018, 07:11:21 PM
Having something of a reputation as a "bodger", I'd take an old uni-sonoric PA reedplate at the higher note and load one of the reed tips with either solder, or glue on a brass weight from scrap low reed, and then file it up to suit. But I'm sure that there'll be someone along shortly to dissuade you from that path!!!!
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Theo on September 03, 2018, 07:17:00 PM
It depends which octave you are in.  In the middle range notes are normally no more than a whole tone apart, but lower and higher ends of the range the differences get greater.  Take a look at the layout diagrams linked from the home page and you can see the pairings that are standard on several different key combinations. 
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 03, 2018, 07:49:26 PM
I've studied those tunings for hours.

Are the holes punched though the reedplate the same for both reeds, with the reed tongue alone accounting for the difference in tuning, or are the plates asymmetric?

I have been puzzling over this chart ==> https://www.harmonikas.cz/admin/files/ModuleText/16-sortiment-sizes.pdf

Does the right hand side column "Tón / Ton / Tone" indicate the absolute pitch of each reed in the reedplate, or the range of pitches the reedplate can be tuned to?

Worst case scenario: I had thought to make individual carrier plates from tempered 0,5mm Al sheet, saw the reedplates in half on the mill, and then glue them to the carrier with CA adhesive.

This is starting to be real work.

Certainly much more work than opening the catalog and ordering the correct parts.

Edit adding:  I suppose I need to follow up with the authors of this diagram ==> https://www.harmonikas.cz/admin/files/ModuleText/17-assortment-diapason.pdf

What do the grey bars mean?  Are they ranges that reeds are pre-made to?  Or are they the tuneable range for that particular numbered reed?
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Theo on September 03, 2018, 07:55:39 PM
Sometimes the pair of reeds will be the same length, other times not. Different makers have different ways of doing it.

You need a Streb or a Roland FR18 to use as a test bed, program in all the layouts you want to try and test them out. Then if you find something that works order a set of reeds to your spec.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 03, 2018, 08:27:22 PM
I might be able to chase up a Roland through an acquaintance.

There are only a very few noval tunings that make practical sense.

To see this project though I am going to need a lot of cadavers.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 03, 2018, 08:49:58 PM
Looking at your shopping list, a lot of them look like off the shelf options.
Where they are not, as Edward implied, reed pitches will shift a tone without deteriorating noticeably in tone.
Why not present your requirements to Charlie Marshall, or Harmonika,  and see what they can offer? Might be cheaper than buying up a graveyard and produce a better outcome.
Charlie is the most helpful man in the world when it comes to this sort of thing.

Butchering reedplates is probably not the best forward.
Gluing is unlikely to lead to good long term results. Waxing is relatively easy.

Whatever you do, reeds will want tuning in situ to your taste before you're done. Quoted tunings are fairly nominal.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 03, 2018, 09:11:26 PM

Gluing is unlikely to lead to good long term results. Waxing is relatively easy.


In micromechanics it is fairly common practice to glue small parts with CA adhesive to a wasteable clamping fixture for machining operations, and then to unclamp the part by rinsing with acetone.

I had thought that a thin aluminum faceplate epoxied to the reedblock would serve nicely as a mounting substrate allowing reedplates to be glued or released with CA and acetone.

A wee bit more modern than wax.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 03, 2018, 09:39:29 PM

Gluing is unlikely to lead to good long term results. Waxing is relatively easy.


In micromechanics it is fairly common practice to glue small parts with CA adhesive to a wasteable clamping fixture for machining operations, and then to unclamp the part by rinsing with acetone.

I had thought that a thin aluminum faceplate epoxied to the reedblock would serve nicely as a mounting substrate allowing reedplates to be glued or released with CA and acetone.

A wee bit more modern than wax.

I'm sure you're right. Can't wait to hear the outcome.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 04, 2018, 01:22:46 AM
You need a Streb or a Roland FR18 to use as a test bed, program in all the layouts you want to try and test them out. Then if you find something that works order a set of reeds to your spec.

I might be able to chase up a Roland through an acquaintance.

There are only a very few noval tunings that make practical sense.

To see this project though I am going to need a lot of cadavers.

I agree with Theo's comment about ordering reeds especially made and tuned to your specification.

My personal opinion is to please try to avoid harvesting lots of reeds from many old instruments which would otherwise be useful in a conventional tuning. In particular, vintage Hohner reeds from the 1930s - steel reed tongues on zinc plates, often stamped 'H' - tend to be some of the best Hohner ever made, with a unique, sweet, mellow sound. It would be a shame to radically alter such reeds which are possibly in a limited and dwindling supply and which could otherwise be used in restoration of existing vintage instruments whose reeds are missing or rusted beyond redemption.

Better to restrict your harvesting to more modern reeds on aluminium plates which are at least in plentiful supply and are still being made today. But I would say that ordering new reeds to your exact needs, especially with the wide intervals required, is the way to go.

I had thought that a thin aluminum faceplate epoxied to the reedblock would serve nicely as a mounting substrate allowing reedplates to be glued or released with CA and acetone.

A wee bit more modern than wax.

Don't dismiss wax because it is not modern. It's a long-established and highly effective method of fixing the reed plates on to the reed blocks.

Waxing reed plates in place is good because it allows easy and rapid removal of the reed plates - for example to adjust and replace valves on the underside of the reed plates, or to make small alterations to the reed chamber walls, or sometimes to fine-tune the very smallest and delicate reeds. The reed plates can then be just as easily and rapidly re-waxed in position. The waxing process only takes a few seconds and the job's done. Much easier than faffing around with CA and acetone.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Inventor on September 04, 2018, 10:07:13 AM
Had you considered approaching it from an entirely different direction and using Harmonicas Dix concertina reeds; mounted in a long strip of hardwood ? These come as individual reeds, and could be rearranged in many different combinations. Try your system out first as a one voice instrument; then when you are happy, you could order a second set of reeds to make a two voice instrument. If in the end you fail to come up with something really good; you could always sell the reeds and recoup some of your initial investment,

Inventor.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 04, 2018, 10:33:28 AM
Had you considered approaching it from an entirely different direction and using Harmonicas Dix concertina reeds; mounted in a long strip of hardwood ? These come as individual reeds, and could be rearranged in many different combinations. Try your system out first as a one voice instrument; then when you are happy, you could order a second set of reeds to make a two voice instrument. If in the end you fail to come up with something really good; you could always sell the reeds and recoup some of your initial investment,

Inventor.

What a good idea!  (:)
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: j.b.c. on September 04, 2018, 12:02:04 PM
Had you considered approaching it from an entirely different direction and using Harmonicas Dix concertina reeds.

Yes.  I looked at that.

As far as I know Hohner reedblocks, and fonds, use a raster that is nominally 19mm on center.

The concertina reeds would be an extremely tight fit, and would require some sort of adapter manifold.

The reed list I posted upthread has the right intervals, but they miss either the major 3rd or 5th for the key of "E". 

I need to transpose them so that missing pair occurs in a least favorite key.

I'm looking also for a 3-row/12-bass cadaver to build the project into.   Where I am 23+7 Clubs far outnumber 3-row accordions.

 

Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: diatonix on September 04, 2018, 05:02:36 PM
Reed plates with the desired intervals are very common in diatonic basses ad chords.
Title: Re: Reed plates with big intervales.
Post by: Jimmy on September 04, 2018, 08:21:57 PM
Hi,

[/quote]
I'm looking also for a 3-row/12-bass cadaver to build the project into.   Where I am 23+7 Clubs far outnumber 3-row accordions.
[/quote]

Perhaps one of these might suit you  ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal