Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Fungusface on August 28, 2009, 05:50:48 PM

Title: No Bass Required
Post by: Fungusface on August 28, 2009, 05:50:48 PM
I am intriqued by all accordion players who use Bass when playing and wonder why so many People who play Irish music and other music ,never use the bass side, wouldnt makers not sell more accordions cheaper that didnt have any bass.Im an old grunter just teaching myself and cant understand how to cope with Bass, and yet I feel ok when watch some Pro's never use it either, have to admit its not so good sounding its like bagpipes with no drones.
Do You use bass
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: MadDogMurdock on August 28, 2009, 06:16:01 PM
G/C I'm all over the bass...makes the tunes complete. 

B/C I'm just learning and if they fit...wonderful.  Most often they don't. 

Left hand bass and chords is the whole reason I began playing squeezebox,  I could accompany myself.  I also enjoy throwing boomerangs...the lonely man's frisbee.  I suspect both of these activities say something about my social graces (or lack thereof). 

Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 28, 2009, 06:32:54 PM
CG and DG:  I basically work out the bass run for a tune, and then fit the tune around it. I'm a left hander if that matters (as is Andy Cutting AFAIR)
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: rees on August 28, 2009, 10:05:32 PM
I usually work out the tune in the right hand first making a mental note of alternative fingerings so that I can vary the bass, then when playing the tune I tend to fit the bass in on the fly depending on the general ambience.

If the basses don't fit, like when playing F# minor blues on a standard 8 bass D/G box (more on this at Witney you A1-ers) I just leave them out.
Even when they do fit perfectly, like when playing in G on a D/G box like what normal people do, I will often leave them out for the sake of my mate from Llangadfan, Dai Namics.
On a one row four stopper of course just wham those basses wrong or right.

Nawr te, I'm off to Birmingham International to catch a flight to Amsterdam. Minibus and ferry to Ameland in the Dutch Friesian Islands for a gig tomorrow night at 1.15 at a club on the beach. Zydeco at Zee Festival:http://www.zydecoatsea.nl/ (http://www.zydecoatsea.nl/)

Thence back to Brum on Sunday eve, drive to Towersey maybe in time to catch the end of EII's set.
 :Ph :Ph :Ph    Note to self: watch them pesky speed cameras between the M40 and Thame.

It's not rock and roll but I love it (3 songs in there I think, erm... I don't like reggae, I love it.      erm...... it's only rock and roll but I like it.      erm........... what's the other one..... answers on a postcard.............


If any of you are at Towersey on Monday, I will be ligging around the Music Fair stalls upsetting all my friends at The Music Room and Hobgoblin and generally getting tipsy with Marcus and Dave and Neil and Tim and Tora and everybody. See you there, bring money.


Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: ACE on August 28, 2009, 10:21:30 PM
I spent so many years letting the rest of the band play the chords, My tunes sound so weak without the accompaniment, I am relearning how to play the left hand.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: ganderbox on August 28, 2009, 10:36:09 PM
I'm a left hander if that matters (as is Andy Cutting AFAIR)


Which seems to support my theory that many good players are left-handers who play the box the usual "right-handed" way round, or right-handers who play it upside down, and it's the right-handers playing it the usual way (or left-handers playing left-handed boxes) who are in fact playing them upside-down, and are therefore disadvantaged from the start. (Did everyone follow that?)
Sadly I think it's a bit too late for me to turn my box the other way up and start from scratch. Maybe it would be something for beginners to think about, though? It might just be worth turning it upside down and seeing what happens.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Sandy on August 28, 2009, 10:49:03 PM
  Note to self: watch them pesky speed cameras between the M40 and Thame.

Watch out for the cheeky police cars sat on the bridges....or is that just after Thame. Either way...careful  8)
 

Cheers

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Bob Ellis on August 28, 2009, 10:56:30 PM
As a left-hander who plays the melodeon right-handed, I think there are positive advantages to doing so. A strong steady rhythm is essential for dance music and that comes from having good control of your left-hand, which, of course, controls the bellows as well as playing the bass buttons.

IMHO, the basses are essential in giving the melodeon its distinctive and appealing sound. Last spring, a piano accordion player said to me that she quite liked the melodeon but thought that it could only produce one type of sound. That set me thinking, so the next time I saw her I played Dark Island as a slow waltz with um-pah-pah basses and then played it again as a slow air with droned basses using just the chords. She agreed that it gave the tune a totally different feel and that it proved my point that the melodeon can be a versatile and sensitive instrument. The next time I saw her, she had bought a Dino Baffetti and had begun to learn to play it. She has hardly touched her piano accordion since. What a result - and it was the different ways the basses were played wot did it!
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: risto on August 29, 2009, 02:41:25 PM
Even simple tunes start to sound like 'real' music when you take the basses along & playing alone gets very boresome if you play just the melody & basses are essential if you want to accompany others with an accordion. Up tempo tunes probably need a totally different approach with the basses, haven't been there yet.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Ellison on August 29, 2009, 03:08:20 PM
Fully agree with Rees about dynamics. Light and shade can suddenly rejuvenate a tune on, say, 4th time through especially if it's coupled with a few variations/harmonies/octave swap in the melody.

I don't see how leaving the basses out makes a tune less complete. I'd venture a guess that the majority of music played by folks on this forum are trad tunes which overwhelmingly are notated without accompaniment or even chord suggestions.

Also agree with Bob in that different use of the bass - drones, just chords, just bass notes, runs (or a combination of all) add to the possibilities of musical colour. I sometimes find myself forgoing an um-pah rhythm and playing both bass and chord together whether I'm playing a jig, waltz or whatever.

And just because I've never used an emoticon in my life:  :Ph
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: forrest on August 29, 2009, 03:48:57 PM
I have an old Hohner in which I have blanked off the thirds of the chords. When I play melody on the treble and just tap the abbreviated chords, the simplicity of the of the outcome is very nice. Sometimes the basses are just overpowering, great for a rousing polka or waltz, but too strong for a hornpipe or jig....

BTW....what is this little robot supposed to be doing? >>> :M
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Ga on August 30, 2009, 11:04:23 AM
I understood one of the reasons Irish box players don't often play chords, is their preference for B/C or B/C/C# boxes, which are chromatic, and allow them to play those lovely "diddly diddly diddly" runs, by using the extra accidentals on other rows, not normally available to D/G players.   They still often play in the keys of D, G or A though, as that's what fiddlers and guitarists are drawn to, and the Left Hand chords available on a B/C box just don't usually fit with the chords in the D and G keys, so they simply leave them out and let the other players fill in the chord gaps.

Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 30, 2009, 11:17:41 AM
Quote
BTW....what is this little robot supposed to be doing? >>>  :M
Um..I think its a hey or a half hey or somesuch thing. Anyway - it's a pretty good imitation of the way I dance Morris!
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2009, 11:38:28 AM
I understood one of the reasons Irish box players don't often play chords, is their preference for B/C or B/C/C# boxes,

I always thought it was the other way round.  Irish music is very much focused on melody, and the great melody players put all the rhythm you need into the melody.  Many Irish tunes use lots of clever tricks to make the harmonies ambiguous, and as soon as you add actual chords that delightful ambiguity is gone.   An instrument playing chords is a optional extra. 
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Falseknight on August 30, 2009, 12:27:27 PM
When I started melodeon the first time (many years ago) I started on B/C.  It is a chromatic instrument and the ideawould seem to be that the basses should fit the keys you want to play in.  The C row was OK, but basses to accompany a B Major row?  Try playing accompanying basses in D, G, A and related minors with that lot!  You can't I didn't and moved happily on to G/C.  The Irish chromatic players want the melody flexibility and live without the basses - it all depends how you cut the cake.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 30, 2009, 12:41:33 PM
Which is where something like my little Trichord wins out with its (albeit limited) stradella bass. Enabling one to play satisfactorily (though not me as I'm still learning) in C, G, D, A (& E, F, at a push). Other keys, such as Bb for example, I'm still able to play on right hand side and put in the odd punctuated bass note where poss. It's a super little box, and seems to offer much more flexibilty than a B/C with standard 8 bass (which'll probably not get used). BUT, having said all that, I watched the BBC ALBA programme yesterday, a documentary of Fergie MacDonald, and he was playing his B/C box and punching the bass buttons as well like a good 'un. So, I'm not so sure anymore. ???
AL
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Falseknight on August 30, 2009, 01:49:30 PM
I confess, I wondered about the possibilities of putting a D/G bass end on a B/C, but I strongly suspect it would not have worked well.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: EeeJay on August 30, 2009, 04:07:31 PM
BUT, having said all that, I watched the BBC ALBA programme yesterday, a documentary of Fergie MacDonald, and he was playing his B/C box and punching the bass buttons as well like a good 'un. So, I'm not so sure anymore. ???
AL

Ah well, there's a reason for that - they aren't any bass buttons on Fergie's Saltarelle...

Just 8 bi-directional chords. I recall Mr Garside of this parish mentioning about this...

You can see how Fergie uses it too... by just vamping on the offbeat. Which is quite effective.

Ed J
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 30, 2009, 04:11:25 PM
Quote
Ah well, there's a reason for that - they aren't any bass buttons on Fergie's Saltarelle...

Just 8 bi-directional chords.

That's mighty clever, that!
 ;D
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: EeeJay on August 30, 2009, 04:24:33 PM
When I started melodeon the first time (many years ago) I started on B/C.  It is a chromatic instrument and the ideawould seem to be that the basses should fit the keys you want to play in.  The C row was OK, but basses to accompany a B Major row?  Try playing accompanying basses in D, G, A and related minors with that lot!  You can't I didn't and moved happily on to G/C.  The Irish chromatic players want the melody flexibility and live without the basses - it all depends how you cut the cake.

This thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2222.0.html) attempts to explain why/how this hellishly odd bass setup came about...

Ed J
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Owen Woods on August 30, 2009, 07:53:12 PM
BUT, having said all that, I watched the BBC ALBA programme yesterday, a documentary of Fergie MacDonald, and he was playing his B/C box and punching the bass buttons as well like a good 'un. So, I'm not so sure anymore. ???
AL

Ah well, there's a reason for that - they aren't any bass buttons on Fergie's Saltarelle...

Just 8 bi-directional chords. I recall Mr Garside of this parish mentioning about this...

You can see how Fergie uses it too... by just vamping on the offbeat. Which is quite effective.

Ed J

That's a good idea  (:) Not as good as a limited stradella though, like on the Trichord.

I spent so many years letting the rest of the band play the chords, My tunes sound so weak without the accompaniment, I am relearning how to play the left hand.

I did exactly the same, spending around 8 months playing only melody. When I started to play for Morris it meant that a massive shift in thinking had to take place. I've relearned the bass end and the difference in my playing is astounding.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: rees on September 01, 2009, 01:39:18 AM
Modern B/C boxes including the Double Ray have sensible basses that work in the keys of C, G, D and A - especially if you remove the thirds.

I have a couple of spare sets of new Hohner Double Ray bass blocks in stock.

See here: http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21modernbass.gif (http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21modernbass.gif)
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: triskel on September 01, 2009, 02:56:59 AM
I ... wonder why so many People who play Irish music and other music ,never use the bass side, wouldnt makers not sell more accordions cheaper that didnt have any bass.

I've only ever seen one button box that was made without basses (though even that one had dummy buttons glued on for appearance-sake) and that was an old Casali made for a marching band in Northern Ireland, but I think manufacturers would find them very hard to sell without basses, unless they were made to special order for a band like that.

But Tombo do market piano accordions without basses, for use in accordion orchestras/bands in Japan and the Phillipines.

... many good players are left-handers who play the box the usual "right-handed" way round, or right-handers who play it upside down, and it's the right-handers playing it the usual way (or left-handers playing left-handed boxes) who are in fact playing them upside-down, and are therefore disadvantaged from the start. (Did everyone follow that?)

Cyrill Demian, the inventor of the (button) accordion, thought the same, so his earliest instuments are all left-handed (to our way of thinking).

I confess, I wondered about the possibilities of putting a D/G bass end on a B/C, but I strongly suspect it would not have worked well.

Ummm, your D basses would have been going the wrong way...  :o
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on September 01, 2009, 05:19:41 AM
I saw a Corona I,yes a I, listed for sale a few months ago from someone from Texas.It had a small left side,no bass buttons or room to put bass blocks on it and a full celluloid cover.It all looked factory made.Very strange.

Chris
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Alison Scott on September 01, 2009, 09:30:47 AM
I saw a Corona I,yes a I, listed for sale a few months ago from someone from Texas.It had a small left side,no bass buttons or room to put bass blocks on it and a full celluloid cover.It all looked factory made.Very strange.

Chris


I have certainly read in the past that button accordions made for the tex-mex market routinely have no bass reeds. (I think they need the extra weight for bling to be honest).
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Howard Jones on September 01, 2009, 04:05:17 PM
I find it a little surprising that so many accordion players with stradella basses seem to ignore the multitude of chords available to them and just plod along with a standard 3-chord trick, whereas so many melodeon players, with far more limited chord options available, try to use these in imaginative and inventive ways.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 01, 2009, 04:42:16 PM
Quote
I find it a little surprising that so many accordion players with stradella basses seem to ignore the multitude of chords available to them and just plod along with a standard 3-chord trick, whereas so many melodeon players, with far more limited chord options available, try to use these in imaginative and inventive ways.
complete and utter gibberish - I suggest you get out and meet more piano & button accordion players.
AL
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: xgx on September 01, 2009, 05:16:51 PM
Not like you to hold back Al.... tell it like it is :P

(about time you changed that Haka avatar of yours... it's meaningless without the sound ;D)
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Falseknight on September 01, 2009, 06:19:52 PM
I'm sure Weltmeister used to do 2.5/3 Row boxes without basses - sort of Club like?
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: rees on September 01, 2009, 09:13:07 PM
Tex_Mex players often jettison the bass blocks from their 3 row Coronas/Gabbanellis, etc.
It cuts the weight down quite a lot.

They play mostly on the pull but can get a fully extended bellows closed in a flash - they do have 13 air buttons available!
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: EeeJay on September 01, 2009, 09:50:05 PM
I'm sure Weltmeister used to do 2.5/3 Row boxes without basses - sort of Club like?

Here's one on eBay... (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Harmonika-Weltmeister-Wiener-559-ohne-Bass-wie-neu_W0QQitemZ230372366547)

Set to a fashionably modern Norteno pitch, F/Bb/Eb - as Rees mentions, this style of playing uses the air button (and empty bass keys) as an 'air dump' - similar to how the B/C/C# concept works - so I'm assuming the air valve on this box might be more useful if made considerably larger...

Another option for a bass less box (such as this one) is setting it up as a bass instrument (treble end set up an octave lower than normal) - Hohner/Weltmeister made/make bass piano boxes, always without anything on the L/H end, just an airbutton...

Ed J
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: jb on September 02, 2009, 12:42:15 PM
Another option for a bass less box (such as this one) is setting it up as a bass instrument (treble end set up an octave lower than normal) - Hohner/Weltmeister made/make bass piano boxes, always without anything on the L/H end, just an airbutton...
That's a new one on me. What a fine idea (I think). Any further info on those PA models? I tried googling "bass accordion" with predictably useless results except for a wikipedia stub (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bass_piano_accordion). Also a fruitless quick browse of the Allodi site.
And any known button boxes along the same lines? [edit] I discover that I'm only four years behind Theo (http://melodeon.aimoo.com/category/Bass-melodeons-do-they-exist-1-902500.html) with this question [/edit]
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: Stiamh on September 02, 2009, 01:58:06 PM
More recently, as Andy in VT pointed out a while ago, Denis Pépin has had D/C# boxes made with no basses. The first was by Messervier and the next, IIRC, by another Marcel, Marcel Desgagné.
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: waldoB on September 02, 2009, 04:31:40 PM
Another option for a bass less box (such as this one) is setting it up as a bass instrument (treble end set up an octave lower than normal) - Hohner/Weltmeister made/make bass piano boxes, always without anything on the L/H end, just an airbutton...
That's a new one on me. What a fine idea (I think). Any further info on those PA models? I tried googling "bass accordion" with predictably useless results except for a wikipedia stub (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bass_piano_accordion). Also a fruitless quick browse of the Allodi site.
And any known button boxes along the same lines?
Chris Parkinson plays a Hohner bass PA - perhaps the Music Room can help
Title: Re: No Bass Required
Post by: rees on September 02, 2009, 05:29:52 PM
Pete Grassby has them in occasionally.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal