Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tunes => ABC => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 10:05:27 AM

Title: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 10:05:27 AM
Hi All,
As many regulars here on the ABC sub-forum know, I've transposed a new tune book into abc format over the summer. People here have been most helpful in pointing me in the right directon when I've come up against previously un-encountered terms within the abc format.
It's now time to get into the tunes on the box, and the abc engine will help support my sight reading by giving me a midi file, the reason I've 'abc'd ' the tunes.

One tune I'm playing with has
M: 4/4
L: 1/8
and has a lovely 'dotted' step-hop feel to it when played back through abcexplorer though as a title it's a quickstep.
When playing it in abcexplorer, I see the speed is at 100 whick I presume is the default setting.
It's got me thinking about speed.

I know titles of tunes are never an accurate means of working out speed.
I realise 'speed' is down to the player, a personal choice in reality and you can play any tune at any speed you wish and even take it outside it's pigeon hole if you so wish.
i.e play a waltz not at 3/4, or waltz speed etc.
As the tune is from an old manuscript then there's probably not a Youtube video of someone playing it, though as said above their speed could be a personal choice so not necessarily an accurate interpretation of the tune.

Therefore my question: is there a natural 'built in speed' to a tune dictated by itself?

cheers
Q



Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2018, 10:25:42 AM

Therefore my question: is there a natural 'built in speed' to a tune dictated by itself?

cheers
Q

My 2 pennyworth.

A tune will have a natural speed for you at any particular time.
Or, it may may have more than one natural speed.
You may decide you like one best, at a particular time.
The next time you play it you may feel different.
So, slow, slower, quick, quicker, slow.
There again, the chap next to you will have his own ideas.
The person the tune came from will have their own ideas.
They're all good.

I will say this, the natural speed at which I play a tune has changed since a got a bit of a better idea of what I'm doing.
I tend to play tunes slower now, than I did and slower than I could play them, if I chose.
But it can be fun to up the tempo and change the rhythm, and alter the time signature and slow things right down. Sometimes all in the same rendition.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 09, 2018, 12:22:38 PM
I use my own set of default values for tunes based on the time signature. This is only a starting point and often needs to be adjusted to suit the piece. Please note that Q: values in ABC software are often very different to a setting you might use on a metronome. The default value in ABC Explorer can be set using the Options > Audio tab at the top, I have mine set at 140.


My personal starting values are as follows:


M:4/4
Q:1/4=140

M:3/4
Q:1/4=140

M:6/8
Q:3/8=100

M:9/8
Q:3/8=120

M:3/8
Q:1/8=140

M:C| (or M:2/2)
Q:1/2=120

M:2/4
Q:1/4=200
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2018, 12:54:49 PM

Therefore my question: is there a natural 'built in speed' to a tune dictated by itself?

cheers
Q


I am now wondering if I completely misinterpreted your question (:)
As Pete points out, if you want to assign a tempo you can use Q:
e.g.,Q:120 

The assigned tempo shows up top left of your score.
The beat length will default to the value assigned to default note length by  L:
L:1/8 L:1/4 etc.

You can also define the length of the your beat independently of the L value
e.g.,
Q:1/4=120
Q:1/8=120
etc.

Hopefully, one of my replies is relevant (:)
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 01:38:26 PM
Thanks both.
Pete - thank you that's what I wanted

Greg - both posts are relevant!
Your first reply sort of encompasses my dilemma. I realise I can play a tune at any speed but was wondering if the composers intended speed could be gleaned from the tune.
I too am trying to slow down a touch. My regular session often has some whistle and fiddle players who seem to play at warp speed. Therefore my slowing down needs to have a reason beyond a reaction to their speeding.
It  dawned on me there might be a built in speed to a tune.

Both I will start to set tunes according to Pete's rule of thumb.
I know he's very experienced in notation so appreciate his given starting values

As these are starting values, based on experience, I conclude you cannot predict a given speed from a tune. The speed comes from experience in those tunes and is variable depending on the tune.

Right... Off to twiddle with Q values!
Cheers
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 01:50:12 PM
Have tweaked said 4/4 tune, added a Q: 1/4=140
….and that sounds good!
A nice compromise, keeping it lively, bouncy and not too slow or fast.
Thanks.
Will investigate the other tunes with a bit more idea of at least where to pitch them within reason.
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 01:56:52 PM
ps.... is there any order or given standardisation to adopt?
i.e. going down the notation I seem to use .
T:
C:
S:
M:
L:
Q:
K:

is that where I should pop in the Q: value?
Q
wanting to get into good habits!
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2018, 02:39:46 PM
Your order looks fine.
Did I recommend Guido's guide, available here?

http://abcplus.sourceforge.net/#ABCGuide
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 03:17:52 PM
thanks.....
um  :|bl yes you have.
I thought this was a more esoteric (?) question as opposed to mechanical working of abc. Next time I'll check first!
Q.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 09, 2018, 04:53:19 PM
My (granted inexperienced) take is that a tune's expected tempo & rhythm is going to depend on what you're using it for - listening to it, dancing to it, working to it etc. From that point, it will likely have been composed, ornamented or expanded upon based on that use, especially if it's been repurposed.

An unreasonably large amount of my repertoire is dance tunes, so, dance tempos run riot. Those are going to be about a 1/4= 140-150 for most step-hoppy type affairs, and for 4/4 reels and 6/8 jigs, would be 2/4 or 3/8 = 100 to 115. If a tune, as written, isn't comfortable to play at a high speed it might not be because you need to practice it more, it might have lots of written in ornamentation from when it was played at a slower speed, and if a tune is a slow dirge, it might be because it used to be played faster. You'll always encounter people who have different opinions.

Definitely I would Investigate the R: command, as there are a few values you can place after that to get your tune sounding a bit more 'correct' if it has a lilted rhythm and isn't written in that way. Also bear in mind that in ABC you can stop writing music halfway through and add a new M, K, Q, L etc line to control the nature of the music that appears after that line as part of the same tune - doubtless you've seen that with K:.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: george garside on September 09, 2018, 05:19:39 PM
Whilst knowing bugger all about R commands or other  digital stuff I agree totally with Gena that the expected tempo and rhythm depends of what you are playing a tune for.That is a particular tune can have a number of 'natural speeds'  and changing from one to another requires a lot mote than simply speeding up or slowing down'

The rhythm that is, or should be, inherent in any music or tune  may well have to be modified or even completely rejigged  if the speed needs changing  otherwise it can come over as just a flat out splutter of the right notes in the right order - but not as the right length of the right notes in the right order and certainly not as the right length of gaps between the right notes in the right order.


 an example is teh pipetune 'farewell to the creeks'  It crops up in books as a 3/4 and also as a 6/8.   Easy - play it as a waltz or a March - but then it can be played as a haunting slow air  , a slow waltz,  a swirly waltz,  or changing from an underlying um pa pa rhythm to an underlying um pa rhythm  it can become a march (slow or quick)  a jig ,a two step, or even as a fast rapper tune


In other words  a tune should alway be played with a purpose in mind and that purpose (on that particular play of it) should be decided on and thought through befor a note is played.


There are lots of youtube vids  of tunes  being played for different purposes  , some played crappily but others taken from recordings of top hole players.  Also 'the session' website often has dots and abc for a veriety of version of tunes together with  sound tracks. 

george
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 05:58:26 PM
I totally agree that a tune should be played with purpose in mind, and that, also, you can tweak it as George and Geena says so a 3/4 can become a 6/8 if that's what you choose.

My original question is slightly different.
Confronted with an unknown tune from an old manuscript, I'd quite like to start off trying to play it at a speed for which it was intended, or written with a speed in mind *before* I start altering the speed to suit my playing or any future intended purpose.
As it's taken from manuscripts somewhere from 1750 - 1850, the original purpose isn't clear.
I was wondering if there was an inherent speed gleaned from the written notes, and I think the answer is 'no'.

Pete's earlier 'ball park figure' gathered from his experience in notating many tunes, is a great help.
as there seems to be no inherent speed, his speeds give me a starting point.

The two tunes I'm messing around with are both 4/4 rhythms.
His given speed @ 140 fits one perfectly, the other sounds like a fiddler's gone into overdrive so have slowed it to 100 where it sits much better!

Having limited experience in notating tunes or reading the written note, it was a thought that occurred today whilst having a squeeze!
cheers
Q

 
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Anahata on September 09, 2018, 06:41:46 PM
In particular with older music, you may find that typical speed vs. note value are different anyway. Around 1700 you'll find tunes written in 6/4 which are in current use as jigs and now written in 6/8 - that doesn't mean we play them twice as fast, simply that your average 1700s crotchet was faster than your average 20th/21st century crotchet. In confusing contrast, we find 19th century waltzes often written in 3/8 where we'd use 3/4 now (though it's quite likely that they played waltzes rather faster than we do now)

Early music (1600 and before) used even longer note values, which is why the longest note value you ever see these days (and quite rarely), which is 8 crotchets long (8 quarter notes or 2 'whole notes' in American musical terminology) is called a breve, which is Latin for "short"!

In classical music you'll also find extremes favoured by different composers. The best example I can think of now is Shostakovitch's 8th string quartet, whose first movement is mostly in 4/4 but those 4 beats go at a speed which would be quite respectable for semiquavers (sixteenth notes)  in other music - nearly two bars per second and quite frightening to play.

Incidentally, your problem is shared with classical musicians everywhere. Beethoven was one of the first composers to use tempo markings based on Maelzel's newly-invented metronome, but he, and many other composers since then, sometimes gave bizarre tempo markings which most performers don't follow because they're "obviously wrong". So tempo is very much open to interpretation everywhere. There are conventions, of course, but they vary from country to country and e.g. in England the speed of a rant increases as you go north...
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2018, 07:54:02 PM
chapter and verse.... fascinating!
Interesting that we are slower than past times, and that a 1700's crotchet was faster. Who'd have thought....!
Well, as long as I'm he company of such as Beethoven when worrying about speed, then I feel I'm in good company  ;D.
Thanks as ever...…
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2018, 08:52:43 PM
thanks.....
um  :|bl yes you have.
I thought this was a more esoteric (?) question as opposed to mechanical working of abc. Next time I'll check first!
Q.

Phew. I addressed both aspects. Got it right for once. (:)

Edit: And everything Gena said.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 11, 2018, 08:51:56 AM
Just re-reading and had a thought:
Pete's initial reply says that an abc speed setting is not the same as a metronome setting.
I realise that, but.....is there a direct correlation between abc speed and metronome speed?
Just wondering.....
cheers
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Anahata on September 11, 2018, 10:29:59 AM
They should be the same, if the software's not faulty. Both systems express speed in <note value> = <no. per minute>
♩ = 120
or
Q: 1/4 = 120
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 11, 2018, 10:44:04 AM
oh right.... that makes life simple!
thanks
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 11, 2018, 11:45:44 AM
I am tempted to answer Q's original question with a trite comment along the lines of "if it is a dance tune, play it at the appropriate speed for that dance; if it is a 'listening' tune, then it's a matter of personal taste." While there is some truth in that statement, it is not quite as simple as that. For instance, the speed at which a tune is normally played for dancing varies from area to area and has certainly varied considerably over time.

When I first started researching into the history of dance music from the Yorkshire Dales, I was surprised at the fast tempo at which tunes were played by people like Sam Fawcett on field recordings made in the early 1950s, which seemed to me to be too fast for dancing and seemed to lose some of the expression that can be put into a tune played at a more moderate speed. Initially, I put it down to factors like the age of the musicians and their nervousness performing in front of these new-fangled recording devices. It was only when I researched the Dales style of playing in greater detail that I realised that this fast tempo was the norm. Dancing was much more energetic than it is now. As Sam Fawcett himself said: "There was none of this lazy dancing. They had to put some vim into it to keep up!" What was considered an appropriate speed for a dance tune in the Dales in the 1950s, would now be considered too fast by most musicians and dancers.

Of course, different musicians in the past had different ideas about the tempo at which a tune should be played. There were strong feelings in the village of Stalling Busk in the 1950s and 1960s about the speed at which the waltz, Varsovianna, should be played. Locals felt that Harry Cockerill played it at the right speed, but they weren't impressed by the Beresford family and the Wallbank brothers, whom they considered to play it "at a gallop." So differences of opinion about tempo are nothing new. What matters is that a tune is played at a tempo that feels right to you and the people with whom you are playing it and, if it is being played for dancing, at a tempo that suits the dancers.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 11, 2018, 01:30:27 PM
Bob, I totally agree with your comments.
'if it's a dance then play it for the appropriate speed for the dance...……...'

OK. Suppose you unearth  a manuscript - say 1750 - it's entitled something along the lines of ' 24 Tunes for the dances of the year 1750'.
Your sight reading I expect is better than mine, so you play a tune from the dots...... but at what speed?
i.e. you don't know which dance it was written for, it's just a dance tune.
You can play it bouncy, slower perhaps becomes a dirge, and faster still takes the tune before it gets stupidly fast and an exercise in playing notes fast.
Right - so what's the speed at which it was intended?
( ball park, give or take a few beats per minute )

That's the nub of my question!
I thought it was an interesting dilemma and so approached the sages here.
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Julian S on September 11, 2018, 03:13:38 PM
Can you share the abc or dots please Q - it would be interesting to see what different interpretations (and tempi) we arrive at. Saying that, I've no idea what dances were most popular back then.

Ta

J
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 11, 2018, 04:11:05 PM
Q is transcribing a published and therefore copyright book for his own use and so cannot share any of the tunes. The book may well indicated which manuscript it has been transcribed from originally though so it could well be in the public domain somewhere.

Edit: Typo
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 11, 2018, 05:02:39 PM
The "Natural" speed of a tune is something that is having real consequences at our local chapel at the moment. Since a couple of weeks ago, we no longer have an organist. We have resorted to using the "official" accompanying cd's which are issued with the hymn book we use. They're (mostly) terrible!
Although many are played by well thought of musicians with strings of letters after their names, they seem utterly unable to play at a reasonable speed for congregational singing. So much so, that we are currently hoping for longer sermons so that we have a chance to get our breath back!
I would suggest that a "Natural" speed, for any tune, is that which the player prefers, but when playing publicly for a specific purpose (e.g. singing or dancing) the listeners, singers or dancers needs or preferences must be taken into consideration, or else the whole endeavour is wasted!
It doesn't seem like a subject which requires endless complications in discussion and advice, IMHO.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 11, 2018, 05:16:53 PM
Pete's right sadly Julian.
Much as I'd like to put it out there to glean opinions, it's a newly published book of tunes therefore it is copyrighted.

Winston: No endless complications or discussions.
I merely asked a question - can you tell the speed of a tune from the dots if you have no idea what dance it was intended for?
Answer - no!
Q
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: playandteach on September 12, 2018, 12:04:17 AM

In classical music you'll also find extremes favoured by different composers. The best example I can think of now is Shostakovitch's 8th string quartet, whose first movement is mostly in 4/4 but those 4 beats go at a speed which would be quite respectable for semiquavers (sixteenth notes)  in other music - nearly two bars per second and quite frightening to play.

Incidentally, your problem is shared with classical musicians everywhere. Beethoven was one of the first composers to use tempo markings based on Maelzel's newly-invented metronome, but he, and many other composers since then, sometimes gave bizarre tempo markings which most performers don't follow because they're "obviously wrong". So tempo is very much open to interpretation everywhere. There are conventions, of course, but they vary from country to country and e.g. in England the speed of a rant increases as you go north...
Always good to hear your thoughts. Surprised about the Shostakovich first movement tempo though, are you talking about the second movement? Fantastic piece and one where knowledge of context really helps the interpretation.
I also think that tempo can depend on acoustics, time of day, mood etc. and skill - clarity winning over pure speed. There's quite a strong theory to say that Beethoven's metronome was broken. I am currently having trouble believing that Debussy's piano roll recording of Dr. Gradus ad Parnassum is really that fast - impossible to get any nuances in at that speed. And the nuances are not only written in but clearly in keeping with his orchestral writing that depends so much on tone colour.
I was really fond of Vladimir Ashkenazy when I was a player - he was not only a great player, but really kind to my wife at a bad time. A few years ago in recovering from a small stroke, he recorded the Bach 48, with the well known C major prelude played at a really reflective speed - his playing of the other pieces was up to speed so this was clearly a choice issue.
Another fine player, Mikhail Pletnev took great delight in making even massively famous pieces such as the Shostakovich 2nd piano concerto sound spontaneous rather than ponderous by subtle tempo control.
I've trying to get my piano playing going again and working at pieces slowly is just as much fun as knocking them out. I know this is not the argument, but if they are slower you just have time to say something as you go. On the piano of course, the notes decay, so tempo makes a big difference to the intentions of the piece. Hope these musings aren't out of place.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Dick Rees on September 12, 2018, 01:18:59 AM
Early on I was told this by older experienced musicians:

1.  If the dancers shoulders are ahead of their feet, you're playing too slow.

2.  If the dancers shoulders are behind their feet, you're playing too fast.

3.  If the customers are leaning across the table to talk to each other, you're playing too loud.

Beyond that I've learned the importance of having a groove and staying in the pocket...
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 12, 2018, 07:34:12 AM
Dick, your experienced musician had good observational skills!
Food for thought.

p&t: Yes I'm tending to go slower and have been made more aware of speed after attending a thought provoking workshop in June.
It means I play those tricky bits in a tune rather than blast through hoping momentum will get me through.
Along with that, I'm discovering the difference in speed between 'blasting through' and playing the tricky bits properly is very small.

I'm also becoming more sensitised to those playing fast at sessions. As you say, no chance to get nuances in the music, it just gets to be an achievement to get the notes in.
I don't like that.

Speed is ever a debateable and variable topic!
cheers
Q

Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 12, 2018, 08:45:41 AM
Q is transcribing a published and therefore copyright book for his own use and so cannot share any of the tunes. The book may well indicated which manuscript it has been transcribed from originally though so it could well be in the public domain somewhere.

Edit: Typo

What would the legal situation be if I were to play a tune collected in the late 19C, published in a collection in 2002, personalised the tune, as you do, and then transcribed my setting of the tune and made my transcription public?
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Anahata on September 12, 2018, 09:33:27 AM
Always good to hear your thoughts. Surprised about the Shostakovich first movement tempo though, are you talking about the second movement?
(Checks CD cover...) yes, you are right, "Allegro molto" not the "Largo" (interesting that a 20th Century Russian composer is still using the old fashioned Italian tempo names). I seem to remember that one movement runs into the other without a break, which is my excuse for the mistake.

Quote
I also think that tempo can depend on acoustics, time of day, mood etc. and skill
On acoustics: I recently heard about one of Debs Newbold's storytelling sessions, in a rather reverberant room. She spent the first couple of minutes walking around the audience area speaking to them and checking that she could be heard clearly in every part of the room, then launched into her stories. At the end of the session she apologised for having run 7 minutes over time, but explained she'd had to set her speaking speed to make sure every word would be heard.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 12, 2018, 12:24:41 PM
What would the legal situation be if I were to play a tune collected in the late 19C, published in a collection in 2002, personalised the tune, as you do, and then transcribed my setting of the tune and made my transcription public?


I think you've answered your own question really. That would be your transcription of your own setting of a tune that is in the public domain.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 12, 2018, 04:47:13 PM
This issue of copyright is often misunderstood. Many people claim copyright when they have no right to do so. When I first became a writer, c.1990, my publishers insisted that I read, learn and inwardly digest a precis they had produced of the copyright laws. While the laws are complex, two relevant points stand out here.
1. You can quote small chunks from a publication provided you credit the source. This doesn't apply to pictures but a musical score is not a picture.
2. If the original document is out of copyright (as it is in this case), a new copyright does not come into existence if somebody republishes the book. New copyright only applies to those parts of the book that were written by the author.
While I am not now as au fait with copyright law as I used to be, I don't think any recent changes have altered the two points I have just made, so Q should be perfectly entitled to write out and share the score for a single tune from the publication in question.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 12, 2018, 04:51:16 PM
Going back to the question of the tempo for a dance tune published c.1750, I doubt whether anyone can state with confidence nowadays the speed at which it should be played, but does this matter? Q says there is no indication as to the type of dance for which it was used, so, presumably, he wants to play it for pleasure rather than specifically for dancing. Under such circumstances, I would try playing it at various tempi and then settle on the one that is most pleasing to my ear.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Theo on September 12, 2018, 04:56:57 PM
Going back to the question of the tempo for a dance tune published c1750

They probably had discussions about speed then too.
Title: Re: Natural speed of a tune?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 12, 2018, 05:03:13 PM
Bob, that's exactly my conclusion from the discussions here - play it at a speed that appeals to me.
Try it at several tempos and go for what suits me.
I just needed to check with the assembled sages that there wasn't a built in speed limit that I might exceed.
Don't want points on my melodeon license for speeding  ;D

Ah Theo's joined in: yep, it sounds like speed has been an eternal question.,

Thanks for all your thoughts.
Cheers
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal