Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: RVJ87 on September 27, 2018, 05:20:17 PM
-
At my wit's end! Any help greatly appreciated.
I have been looking high and low for the right melodeon for me for weeks on end. I have tried a few suppliers, and none of them have what I need. What I need to do is to find a retailer in the UK where I can sit down for a bit and try out several different boxes. I keep going to different retailers only to keep being told they only have a few boxes in stock (which is a little frustrating to say the least). Could anyone tell me if there's a UK retailer with lots of boxes of different makes in stock right now that would let me sit down for a few hours and try out different boxes until I find something that works for me?
-
Hobgoblin Canterbury seem to carry a good selection. Check the web site
SJ
-
Possibly you need to be more specific. Or are you really expecting a couple of hours in a shop to sort out how much you want to pay (£500? £3000? More? Less? In between?) what keys you want to play in, and how many rows you need? How much playing experience do you have?
Very recently I have seen a good stock of melodeons at Birmingham Hobgoblin, with several Serenellinis (I'd have a second one if I had the money), and a vast display of melodeons at Whitby Folk Week, courtesy of Acorn Instruments, but virtually all Castagnaris (AKA Mucho Costallottis). If these are way out of your price range, Allodi Accordions in London seem to have quite a few melodeons in stock further down the price range (but check that the website is up to date; looks a bit suspect to me). You can probably establish fairly quickly whether other branches of Hobgoblin have a good stock, via their website. The branches do vary a lot in what they carry.
In my experience (such as it is) trying to find the ideal box in the way you suggest may not succeed too well. Get to grips with the box, find out what situations you are mostly playing in and you will quite probably realise it is too basic/heavy/loud/quiet/lacks accidentals/has useless accidentals. Been there, done that, more than once. So buy secondhand so that you don't lose too much money.
-
I have over twenty years playing experience on the D/G box. I already know what I want to spend- £1900 max. I need a two row instrument that's light, simple, fast and responsive. In addition to english music, I also play a lot of the faster scottish and irish reels. I regularly play in sessions that feature these kinds of tune.
I know that I need a box that can handle both ends of the scale, as it were, I just don't know which box that is. I don't like castagnaris (too spongey), nor do I care for serenellini boxes (far too heavy). I have found Hobgoblin to be quite useless unfortunately, as they only ever seem to stock b/c or g/c boxes, or a few cheap chinese d/gs that frankly I wouldn't play if you paid me. I don't really rate hobgoblin as folk instrument retailers- one person at hobgoblin birmingham had never heard of the Sandpiper make
As for expecting to be able to spend more than a couple of hours in a shop, well, when the music room at cleckheaton was still around, you could do exactly that. I remember very clearly being invited to sit down and play as many boxes as I wanted til I found what I needed. I was welcome to play anything, they'd make you a cup of tea and give you the time you needed to make a decision. I need a shop where I can do that (though I don't know that I'll find that level of service again) because I won't know exactly which melodeon I'll need until I play it. It's a bit of a harry potter thing- when I do find the right one, I'll know.
-
Sounds like you need to go visit Murray at the Reed Lounge. Great bloke & he's founded it with exactly that in mind. As far as I know he'll make you a cup of tea and leave you be to noodle to your hearts content.
https://thereedlounge.com/
-
Have a look at my website, there may be something that tickles your fancy.
www.melodeons.com (http://www.melodeons.com)
You are welcome to visit my workshop in Welshpool (by appointment).
We can take it in turns to make the tea ;)
-
............. and the Castagnari CLOVIS is now back in stock - hurrah!
-
I have been looking high and low for the right melodeon for me for weeks on end.
Did anyone else chuckle when they read this? A lot of us have been seeking 'the right melodeon for me' for years ;)
And I have to travel about 10,000kms to find a retailer with lots in stock.
Anyway, good luck with your quest.
-
Well the sad thing is that I actually already found the right melodeon several years ago... it was a Gabbanelli- or at least it was made by Gabbanelli. It was absolutely gorgeous and it played like a dream. At the time it was exactly what I needed. Unfortunately I was forced to sell it some time ago owing to some financial difficulty. I've never had a melodeon that worked as well for me since.
-
"I need a two row instrument that's light, simple, fast and responsive". Sounds like a used Baffeti binci two voice. Should leave you plenty of change from £1900 for getting it set up just as you want it. As for Hobgoblin denying all knowledge of Sandpiper, remember it was made by their main competitor! Anyway I had one and it was a waste of time, two broken springs within weeks of buying new. Replaced by a Hohner.
-
It may seem an obvious question, but if you like Gabbanelli, then why not buy another one. I have 2,3 and four voice boxes, I like them all but I don't thing I will ever be able to decide which I like best, its a case of what suits me on the day.
-
@Tufty... well that would explain things... I thought it was a bit odd. As for Dino boxes, I owned one about a year ago, I also loaned a black pearl ii a few days ago, and while I can't fault them for their ability to play morris/slower english tunes brilliantly, I find that they don't seem to handle the faster stuff well. I think part of it is the stepped fingerboard, which I don't get on with.
-
@TomB I'd like to but they seem hard to get hold of (in this country at least). I'd been looking for one similar to the one I had for a while, and had been unable to find anything but some very flashy g/c/f three-rows and some rather gaudy piano accordions. I suppose I could go to an italian retailer, but the thing is I'd want to discuss tunings/layouts/etc, which I think would be quite tricky in my pidgin-italian.
-
... I suppose I could go to an italian retailer, but the thing is I'd want to discuss tunings/layouts/etc, which I think would be quite tricky in my pidgin-italian.
This is the advantage of dealing either with Rees Wesson (http://www.melodeons.com) or Pete Ward (Acorn Instruments) (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/index.cfm). They are both experienced at dealing with customers' requests for tunings and layouts, and are experts at negotiating with Castagnari to get what the customer wants. Much better than trying to do it yourself and having the hassle of returning an instrument to Italy if the maker has misinterpreted your request and sent the wrong tuning/layout.
It may well be that Rees or Pete have a suitable instrument in stock anyway. Check their websites.
I've used both Rees and Pete a good few times over the years and can vouch that their service is second to none.
-
... I suppose I could go to an italian retailer, but the thing is I'd want to discuss tunings/layouts/etc, which I think would be quite tricky in my pidgin-italian.
This is the advantage of dealing either with Rees Wesson (http://www.melodeons.com) or Pete Ward (Acorn Instruments) (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/index.cfm). They are both experienced at dealing with customers' requests for tunings and layouts, and are experts at negotiating with Castagnari to get what the customer wants. Much better than trying to do it yourself and having the hassle of returning an instrument to Italy if the maker has misinterpreted your request and sent the wrong tuning/layout.
Except that the OP doesn't like Castignaris
-
the OP doesn't like Castignaris
There are many other Italian makers
-
Presumably not to be found in a shop with lots of other possibilities, but have you considered Cairdin?
I haven't tried their "English" model or any other model in D/G tuning, but the B/Cs and C#/Ds I have tried are most definitely light, fast and responsive.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=19403.0
http://cairdin.eu5.org/range.html
-
Sounds like you need to go visit Murray at the Reed Lounge. Great bloke & he's founded it with exactly that in mind. As far as I know he'll make you a cup of tea and leave you be to noodle to your hearts content.
https://thereedlounge.com/
+1 for Murray. I bought from him at Shrewsbury. A very relaxed process and a good guy to deal with.
-
Hi,
I have an extensive stock of Castagnari Melodeons,largest in UK,you are welcome to come and without pressure
A box second hand which may be of interest,
I have a Paddy Clancy,D,G.Just been serviced and ready to go,lightening fast,Hand Made reeds.
-
@Stiamh... I haven't yet but am considering emailing them to see if they can help.
@ Nigelr I'm thinking about giving him a ring quite soon. With what people say it's possible he can help me.
@ Pete/acorn Thank you, but I'm not really a fan of the paddy clancy boxes; they seem a bit too big for what they offer. As I mentioned earlier, I'm afraid I've gone off Castagnari boxes quite a bit; they've changed a lot since the first time I played one.
-
By the way, does anyone know anything about these? https://www.verdestrumentimusicali.com/fisarmoniche/diatonica/occitan.html. Looks and sounds very nice- might be what I need. Obviously I'd need it in D/G with the correct left-hand layout. I think G/C is the standard tuning for these boxes, but I could probably send them a diagram of what I need.
-
Presumably not to be found in a shop with lots of other possibilities, but have you considered Cairdin?
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=19403.0
http://cairdin.eu5.org/range.html
Personally I would love a Cairdin, but the website shows prices from €2800 and a long delivery time - or have I misread the website.
-
By the way, does anyone know anything about these? https://www.verdestrumentimusicali.com/fisarmoniche/diatonica/occitan.html. Looks and sounds very nice- might be what I need. Obviously I'd need it in D/G with the correct left-hand layout. I think G/C is the standard tuning for these boxes, but I could probably send them a diagram of what I need.
Running a search on Melnet for "Verde" will produce a couple of dozen results, some of which will give you some idea of the quality, even if they go back a few years.
Roger
-
Thank you. I had a look at some of the older posts on the subject and Verde boxes seem quite well-regarded. I think it may possibly be what I'm looking for, though I don't know how I would go about ordering a D/G box with accidentals and correct left hand layout on my own; as I mentioned earlier, my Italian is practically non-existent. I did have a go at making an Italian translation of the standard D/G layout, but of course there's the possibility that it could be misread or misinterpreted- goodness knows what I might end up with.
On a related note, I gather that Rees Wesson used to import G.Verde boxes, but stopped because of supply issues (I think) so I'm not sure who might be able to help.
-
You're still not going to know how fast they respond until you've played one, are you?
SJ
-
I may be wrong about this one but aren't Verdi boxes made for them by another Italian manufacturer? I seem to recall someone telling me it was Mengascini but I may be wrong? Dave Jolly imports Mengascini boxes as does Belfast Music, in addition to the ones with a stepped keyboard they sell a black sparkly one with a flat keyboard which is their own design.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4kwL948C7Q (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4kwL948C7Q)
There is an earlier thread about this box somewhere which discusses it's likeness to the Gabbanelli that Rees designed and imported.
-
@Choonz Yes, though I believe they're manufactured by Polverini. I've seen the Mengascini melodeon and I see the resemblance to the Gabbanelli (I think it's the Gabbanelli Pocket)- very nice, but not sure it's for me. I did see one of the Gabbanelli boxes for sale somewhere- I can't seem to find much information about it though.
-
You're still not going to know how fast they respond until you've played one, are you?
SJ
Maybe I'm going to betray myself by saying I've never got this fast response thing. In my experience you depress the button and move the bellows and out comes the sound. Just like that. I've never had to wait around at all. But then I've always played Paolo Sopranis.
-
Bob Ellis of this parish has a Gabbanelli Pocket in D/G. He may be able to offer more help.
-
As it happens, I've just seen a S/H Gabbanelli Pocket melodeon listed on the website of Birmingham Accordion Centre.
Dave Jolly's website does not give an address. Last I heard he was living in France, though that was probably about a year ago (he did some work + buying and selling for us earlier when we lived near Northampton and has been in touch since).
-
I had a Verde on trial from Rees a while back. Listening to this video now makes me think that it was a great sounding and playing box, especially for the money. There's also an early prototype Castagnari and a Giustozzi on the video. I did get permission at the time to upload the video, as they weren't my boxes. I ended up buying something else for a strange set of circumstances - allergy to some woods.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J5F8fPIzikA
-
As that video shows, the only way to tell whether you'll like the feel and sound of a box is to play it.....
...and perhaps to hear someone else play it. I have a Giustozzi , the sibling of the one in the video, and watching that video gave me a new perspective on my own box.
One of the best way to try lots of different boxes is to visit melodeon-focused workshop event like Witney, Wensleydale etc, as most people will be only to happy to let you try their boxes. And/or festivals of course.
I'd definitely suggest having a chat to Rees as he has relationships with a number of the Italian builders and has ordered/imported small batches of custom (i.e. non-standard to the Italians) D/G boxes from Giustozzi, Gabbanelli, Castagnari.......
-
I had a Verde on trial from Rees a while back. Listening to this video now makes me think that it was a great sounding and playing box, especially for the money. There's also an early prototype Castagnari and a Giustozzi on the video. I did get permission at the time to upload the video, as they weren't my boxes. I ended up buying something else for a strange set of circumstances - allergy to some woods.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J5F8fPIzikA
Interesting video, I certainly liked the Giustozzi, never having heard one before, not much to choose between that and the Verde, but it confirmed my dislike of Castagnaris ;)
Sir John