Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Rog on September 30, 2018, 07:45:43 AM
-
Someone recently jokingly (sort of) pointed out the prevalence of animal product (skin) in a melodeon, and went on to ask if there is a vegan version. I have seen an occasional set of (leaking) bellows with rubber gussets, and I suppose with plastic valves and some other material for pallet facings it would be possible. But has anyone else been asked about vegan accordions/melodeon? It’s a slightly bizarre notion that I’d not considered before. Though if you happen to be vegan perhaps it isn’t so bizarre.
-
Been discussed on concertina.net (https://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?/topic/18640-a-vegan-concertina/&tab=comments#comment-176724)
-
I don't know about vegan melodeons, but I knew a flautist once who was a strict vegan and managed to source pads for the keys/toneholes which were covered with a synthetic material rather than the usual fish skin or animal skin.
I am vegetarian myself, but mainly because I actually don't like the taste and physiological effects (makes me ill) of meat and fish, rather than for any ethical reasons. I do accept that there are some applications for which leather has flexibilty and durability properties which make it a far superior product than any synthetic material (as far as I know).
Melodeon specifics:
I am happy to use Vileda (synthetic leather) valves, and have done so for over 10 years with no discernable loss of performance (stiffening, cracking, noise, etc.). I would think that Vileda would also be a suitable pallet facing material, especialy if combined with a felt backing, although I've not come across this as a product so far.
However, I suspect Vileda gussets on bellows corners would not be durable; the constant flexing would probably cause premature cracking. Unless there is a suitable synthetic product which has been developed, I think this is a situation where only leather would do.
-
Also this discussion here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19832.0.html (although it's 90% off topic)
-
Would a second-hand melodeon built before one was born be acceptable to a vegan?
-
these ethical issues always interest me.
While I certainly try to shy away from some of the 'holier than thou' attitudes that can come with some Vegans, I find that the vast majority that I come into contact with are just thoughtful people trying to minimise the suffering to animals and people and lower the impact that their lives have on the planet.
Ethical and environmental issues have been considered in the world of musical instruments for a while with various countries prohibiting or restricting the use or import/export of certain materials so the desire for a 'vegan' instrument is probably just taking those ideas a step further
From a personal perspective I would think that the 'greenest' (that taking precedent in my world over 'vegan' ) option would be to reuse an older instrument -given that any suffering to animals and drain on the planets resources had already been done. If and when that instrument needed repairs? I'm sure the fettlers on this forum would know more than me but could leather parts not be made from repurposed leather rather than plastics?
-
Been discussed on concertina.net (https://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?/topic/18640-a-vegan-concertina/&tab=comments#comment-176724)
Thanks Lester, that’s v interesting.
-
Perhaps some kindly vegan box players could donate their skin to the melodeon world in their last will and testament.
Tan my hide.
-
Dick, you missed out the rest of the line..........."when I'm dead, Fred." I don't suppose that song is well received in vegan circles, anyway?
-
Thanks for that. I'd completely forgotten that song.
"So we tanned his hide when he died, Clyde, and that's it hangin' on the shed."
Brilliant.
-
If . . . . you go in the woods and find a dead moose.
You take the skin and make leather of it, and even some hideglue. And use it in a box.
Is it still a vegan box?
-
I think you're going to find that there's more that one methodology that any given individual might ascribe to. It... may come across as a little disingenuous to workshop what may or may not 'count' as vegan - some will feel that something is acceptable for them, some will not. However, taking the time to simply be aware of & identify the materials & products that are present in instruments, sourced from animals or otherwise, is still a nice thing to do.
-
Stéphane Groleau posted an account of how he built a vegetarian box here https://ecordeon.veganequebec.net/ (https://ecordeon.veganequebec.net/). And this is how it sounds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU).
-
Stéphane Groleau posted an account of how he built a vegetarian box here https://ecordeon.veganequebec.net/ (https://ecordeon.veganequebec.net/). And this is how it sounds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU).
this eco-rdeon model seems to be different to most one row melodeons. it has eleven buttons!! discuss?? it looks to be a beautifully crafted instrument.. brian..
-
Stéphane Groleau posted an account of how he built a vegetarian box here https://ecordeon.veganequebec.net/ (https://ecordeon.veganequebec.net/). And this is how it sounds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kRRjEJGZrbU).
this eco-rdeon model seems to be different to most one row melodeons. it has eleven buttons!! discuss?? it looks to be a beautifully crafted instrument.. brian..
Mélodie (Quebec) makes an 11-button one-row accordion. Bobby Gardiner used to play one, and Raynald Ouellet still does:
https://youtu.be/H15Ros-ShKE
-
I’m kind of warming to the idea. It was a TV cameraman who asked about it whilst filming me...he was being mischievous. I'll report back to him when I see him next.
-
Stéphane Groleau posted an account of how he built a vegetarian box
That is in fact vegan, according to him
-
Many people adopt a vegan diet, although a really committed vegan does not use any animal derived products. If you're truly dedicated to a philosophy, you wouldn't look for or accept any loopholes. There are quite a few vegetarians who follow vegan principles as far as they can without leading a visibly different lifestyle. One of the most difficult things, when I was with my ex who is vege, was finding smart shoes!
I wonder what those imitation chamois leathers are - is that vileda?
Rob.
-
I think a vegan melodeon should be possible.
No problem with valves, straps and pallet facings.
A few years back I was given a bag of leather and synthetic leather which included a material which could possibly be suitable for bellows gussets.
The only thing that I haven't seen mentioned yet is reed wax, which contains beeswax. I haven't tried making it from paraffin wax and pine rosin but might give it a try.
Of course the other alternative is to use screws with an olovisc gasket
Martyn
-
Bought a cheap set of bellows from a Scarlatti, that fit a Hohner too, and I see no leather. They work well, but I don't suppose they'll last.
Sir John
-
Instead of wax you can use olovisc.
Less mess. ;)
-
As I mentioned in my earlier post...Olovisc could be used as a gasket if the reed plates were going to be held in place with screws and washers between the plates as an alternative to wax.
Some manufacturers prefer this method.
Waxing isn't messy if its done right...next to tuning its one of my favourite jobs when restoring boxes.
Martyn
-
I have seen fine wax work. Old, new even on chinese toys.
But mine are just a mess!
-
I’ve thought about the wax v gasket equation. I reckon wax is faster and cheaper to assemble than gasket, which is why manufacturers use it. You do see gasket/screws/pins in high end PAs and on some early melodeons. You never see wax in early concertinas. Gasket/pins are v good for long bandoneon/chemnitzer style reed plates.
But I think Emmanuel Pariselle uses gasket because he hates wax, but, more practically, the carnage of 12 people on one of his build schools all trying to wax for the first time, and getting it all over those new reeds etc...well it would be a disaster. And then if you want to take reeds off/put em back...well, you see what I mean.
However...wax compensates for poor or tricky reed blocks, either with gaps or with very thin chamber walls. If you have (what I think of as) fair weather waxing, it all goes together very quickly. But if you have poorly matched reed blocks and reeds (which happens quite often), wax can fill in the gaps and or behave more like glue (e.g on Liliput blocks, which are v narrow, with the reed plates butted up against each other).
-
Rog , email sent on different subject
-
Hi guys read a post about making a vegan melodeon ,a chap has asked me to make a vegan banjo pot it looked easy just maple and brass tone-ring and tension hoop ,the machine shop guy that brazes my hoops told me tallow and other animal derivatives/extractions ? are mixed with mineral oils and used in numerous metal fabrications ,raw stock extruding lubricants etc
According to the pot chap even the new 5 pound note has some form of animal fat in it (i googled it and it appears to be true) I suppose my question is how vegan is vegan? should i tell the chap about animal products used in metal manufacturing
I dont really know much about vegans
thanks
-
When you start looking at the wider implications of animal products (APs) in the things that we use every day, it is very difficult or next to impossible to be sure that a certain item does or does not use APs at some stage in its manufacture, or in its constituent components.
So - are items such as cars, buses, computers, supermarket trolleys, postage stamps, etc. - the list could be vast and seemingly bizzare - free of APs? Probably not. Can we always determine this? Extremely unlikely.
Personally, I am a vegetarian, mostly through dietary choice rather than ethical concerns, and I often cook vegan meals too. But I have no problem with, for example, leather shoes and boots, leather melodeon valves, cooking with honey, woollen clothes, etc. There is probably a lot of double-think and choosing to ignore the presence of APs in these items. Similarly, I have flautist friend who is quite a commited vegan, but even she chooses to turn a blind eye to the presence of leather and fish-skin pads on her flute keys.
Is it feasible in our modern society to remove APs from every manufacturing stage in the things which we use? Almost certainly not, unless we wish to revert to stone-age technology. All we can push for is that animals are humanely treated at all stages of their lives and deaths.
-
From the Vegan Society -
"Veganism is a way of living which seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose."
https://www.vegansociety.com/go-vegan/definition-veganism
-
Hi guys thanks for the info
I had a long and very informative chat with the chap this afternoon, its was actually a favour for another friend as the chap bought a nice vintage neck from the us and dident realise the shorter scale would have been made for a smaller pot "i wasent charging just the materials" but its become so dam complex I have decided its just not worth the hassle
pic of darrens 10" walnut short scale work in progress
silly sod :D
-
forgot to mention i usually use pearl but the fret markers on the 10" are recycled spun down Casein accordion buttons have a lovely creamy white and that oversized sully/vega look
-
Casein is a milk protein.
-
Casein is a milk protein.
Darren is a meat eater so its fine for his banjo :D
The pot was effectively a freebie ! and I have no problems whatsoever with the choices people make for themselves but i think his sanctimonious
attitude towards me and the materials i use was unnecessary i,m mostly recycling and virtually all my wood comes from vintage harmoniums pianos book cases
trunks etc .I researched vegan alternatives https://veganwomble.co.uk/veganartandcraftsupplies/ and anyone that know me knows how accommodating i am
an usually free !!!
sorry for the rant you would think from his attitude I spent my weekends clubbing baby seals
-
"I spent my weekends clubbing baby seals"
And, don't you? I've heard it's very popular with PA players.
-
"I spent my weekends clubbing baby seals"
And, don't you? I've heard it's very popular with PA players.
;D ;D ;D
The only cruelty to animals in my workshop was to me !!!! subjected to his shocking rendering of bye bye blues
lol