Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Steve_freereeder on October 04, 2018, 05:02:22 PM

Title: For whom do we play?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 04, 2018, 05:02:22 PM
This is prompted by a curious set of coincidences:
(a) the topic of the perceived loudness of the basses/chords on a Castagnari Lilly, especially this post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22842.msg273845.html#msg273845) and some of the responses which follow.
(b) points raised yesterday by one of my concertina students in her lesson, about playing along with others, and solo, in a session.
(c) rediscovering a very old cassette tape recording of the stories and playing of uilleann piper Séamus Ennis (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Séamus_Ennis), given to me by a friend about 30 years ago.

It led me to think anew about whom we play for, and perhaps why. Is it solely for our own enjoyment, or for others' enjoyment, or a mixture of the two?

The Séamus Ennis story, Henry Bohannan and the Fairy Piper, which I'd not listened to for years, is particularly charming (at least I think so) and I decided to transcribe it for the enjoyment of you all. It raises some interesting points.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Chris Rayner on October 04, 2018, 05:23:23 PM
Dunno who’s listening, or if they care, but I’m well impressed by the use of the correct case of the pronoun in the title.  A dying art.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Mike Hirst on October 04, 2018, 05:55:33 PM
After 40+ years as a working musician I have reached the conclusion that very rarely is anyone listening. playing gigs and playing for dancing, the biggest challenge is not to f*** up. For most public shows, paid or otherwise, the audience have come to meet friends; to cop off; to get p***ed; to dance and to have a good time. What they want is to relax and enjoy life. We are facilitators. Bum notes, angst and intensity all threaten this.

When I moved to Northumberland I had no experience of the competition scene. My first visit to Rothbury was a disappointment. I expected a lively session scene, with challenging interplay among musicians. The pubs were empty, when I asked where everyone was I was told that they were all at the competitions.

For me music has always been about sharing. The idea that I should stand up and demand that everyone look at me - I am the best, was anathema. I just didn't get it. The only way to understand was to enter. I took third place. I thought you b******s I'm better than that.

The next year I took first place at Morpeth, first place at Rothbury and first place at Alnwick. The next year I won at Alnwick again and took prizes at Newcastleton.

Playing in the competitions is the purest musical experience. There is no demand for entertainment. 'Eyes and teeth' are frowned upon and can result in lost points. In the past judges would sit with their backs to the competitors, in the case of step dancing and clog, it was not unknown for judges to sit below the stage.

I have never known this intensity in any other situation. It's like being the guy with the beard from the joy of sex.

I haven't felt the need to compete for more than 10 years now. I'm happy playing a few local gigs with friends. If I want people to listen I sing - if I want people to have a good time I play the accordeon.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Stiamh on October 04, 2018, 06:49:33 PM
Surely nobody plays purely for the enjoyment of others. One has to feel a little sorry for Henry in the story, whose playing was so good but who "took no value of it on himself" i.e. got nothing out of it.

And surely very few people play truly only for themselves, happy never to be heard by others?

So it's a sliding control, I would think. If the slide were too far in either direction I'd give up.

Some might answer, I play only for the money (not something I am able to pretend, sadly) but that answer is ruled out by the word in the thread title that Chris R so admires!

(Very nice story Mike but I'm not sure you answered the question.)
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Dick Rees on October 04, 2018, 07:09:20 PM
For whom do the birds sing?

"I" do not play.  I am just another instrument.  If the Music does not play me there is nothing.  After 40 years playing for a living I find it has all been for the birds...
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 04, 2018, 07:26:15 PM
I play for my own pleasure, and enjoyment.  I have nowhere I can go to play music with others, and my next session will be in February next year. So I keep myself amused.

Sir John
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: AnnC on October 04, 2018, 07:37:41 PM

It led me to think anew about whom we play for, and perhaps why. Is it solely for our own enjoyment, or for others' enjoyment, or a mixture of the two?

  (:) a mixture of the two plus the pleasure of listening to and playing with other people  ;D
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on October 04, 2018, 07:45:45 PM
Ultimately, I play for myself, I'm sure. But it's complicated. Playing for others brings me enjoyment. When I have a gig, it gives me an authentic opportunity to get my chops up to snuff. But I also feel like, by playing, I am joining in with the tradition -- reaching back and projecting forward.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Eshed on October 04, 2018, 08:29:04 PM
An excellent thread!
Reminds me a theory that there are 3 types of guitar players which might be transferable to melodeons:
Obviously most players are some sort of combination of these.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: arty on October 04, 2018, 08:59:58 PM
I bought my first melodeon 6 years ago and I have been teaching myself since. I have never played anywhere except at home or a few friends houses. So, I have to say that I play for myself.

However, tomorrow lunchtime, I am playing in the al fresco area of a local restaurant, with a friend who plays ukelele really well - just the two of us. We have practiced really hard and I feel well prepared, ready for my public debut but also bloody terrified!!!! We are playing a selection of French music, including 5 pieces by Stephane Delicq, a modern mazurka and a couple of traditional French tunes.

So, yes, I play for myself but after tomorrow....I don't know?!!
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 04, 2018, 09:23:04 PM
We have practiced really hard and I feel well prepared, ready for my public debut but also bloody terrified!!!!

Good luck Arty. You shouldn't need it, though. Sounds like you're well prepared. That usually counts for more than luck.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Winston Smith on October 04, 2018, 09:49:21 PM
Arty, although I don't really know you from Adam, I wish you the very best for your looming performance. Just concentrate on the music and enjoying it; not the audience. (And take note of what Mike Hurst says about audiences, as well!)
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: busbox on October 04, 2018, 10:08:30 PM
Forgive my technical ignorance but I can't get past the first page of the story when I download. Any quick fix?
Thanks Tony
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Theo on October 04, 2018, 11:18:00 PM
I play for my own enjoyment,  but mostly I like two things.  First playing with other musicians,  preferably playing different instruments, and second playing for dancing. I take Mikes point about dancers not listening to what’s being played, but that’s “not listening” in the sense of not paying detailed attention to the music,  but obviously in another sense they are listening, else they wouldn’t be dancing!  I love being able to look over a group of smiling dancers and know that if I wasn’t playing they wouldn’t be dancing.  Give me a great buzz.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 04, 2018, 11:22:17 PM
Forgive my technical ignorance but I can't get past the first page of the story when I download. Any quick fix?
Thanks Tony
It's a PDF file which has two pages. Usually, clicking on a PDF file will automatically open in a reader of some sort - Adobe Acrobat or Apple Mac Preview are two common software items which often come bundled with a computer. Or you can download Adobe Acrobat for free (google it). If you can see the first page of the story, there should be a forward arrow or 'next' button somewhere which you can just click on which should take you to the next page.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: playandteach on October 04, 2018, 11:52:04 PM
I play (melodeon) now to write tunes, and to remind myself how hard it is to learn new things - hopefully this makes me more able to understand when students make limited progress.
I play piano to be able to enjoy rich harmonies and textures that I can't achieve in other ways. I never play for other people because I was good at something else and this just highlights my deficiencies in any remaining instruments.
The thing I most enjoy is coaching excellent players, or guiding composition techniques in others. I also love analysis of complex works.
My best sounds are in my head.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Julian S on October 05, 2018, 07:50:48 AM
I play for my own enjoyment,  but mostly I like two things.  First playing with other musicians,  preferably playing different instruments, and second playing for dancing. I take Mikes point about dancers not listening to what’s being played, but that’s “not listening” in the sense of not paying detailed attention to the music,  but obviously in another sense they are listening, else they wouldn’t be dancing!  I love being able to look over a group of smiling dancers and know that if I wasn’t playing they wouldn’t be dancing.  Give me a great buzz.

That's me as well. Mostly my playing has revolved around dance - Cotswold and for many years Border morris, ceilidhs, French. It's what so much of the music is for - sessions and concert gigs are all very well but often I wish we could have some dancing !
Saying that, most of the tunes I am learning at the moment will probably not get performed - I just love the tunes ! I might never be more than an adequate player but every time I listen to a great musician and pick up the box to try to emulate them it is a joy for me.
And Arty - enjoy the performance - all the best.

J
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 05, 2018, 08:13:34 AM
It's a great question Steve!
I think I play for me.
I play for the enjoyment of the tune and the actual process of learning and the sense of achievement when I've got a difficult tune sorted. My wife enjoys puzzle books, sodoku etc, enjoying the mental gymnastics and workout through doing them. My version of a puzzle comes with dots and sometimes a strange key signature!

I do enjoy playing in a session and when it all goes well there's no better feeling, sharing a communal joy of music is a good feeling to have. It also means I'm amongst friends, or posssibly newly made friends, relaxing, having a chat and a laugh and that too is a lovely place to be.
If I'm off form for whatever reason and can't get into the session or perhaps the session is dominated by someone playing tunes I have never heard it can bring me back down to earth.

A significant number of tunes that I play or try to play are not session tunes, they are just for me. They'll probably never go beyond the walls of my home.
Q
possibly a selfish meleodon player  ;)


Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: arty on October 05, 2018, 08:15:58 AM
Thanks guys, for your encouragement and good luck wishes. I shall let you know how it went !
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 05, 2018, 08:17:58 AM
Argh, sorry arty, so focussed on thinking about my post I forgot to say - good luck!
You'll be fine I'm sure, just enjoy the time!
Q
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: JimmyM on October 05, 2018, 08:33:30 AM
great question -though not one i worry about too much (:)

I'm not a professional musician so i dont HAVE to play to eat BUT its one of the most rewarding things In my life. Its brought me such joy and through playing I've met such wonderful people that i honestly cant imagine not playing. Now my children are grown and gone my life pretty much revolves around making music. ( i take an instrument to work every day and play/practice during my break)
I love playing for dancers and in sessions but I'm more than happy to sit in my music room and practice or just play stuff for my own pleasure.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Tiposx on October 05, 2018, 08:57:59 AM
Playing out was a "bucket list" thing for me - after over 20 years hiding away with a guitar and bass. Then I  got to play along (badly)with a mate on his concertina. I took up the melodeon (cheaper than a concertina) 18 months ago and found I could get a tune out whilst playing along with him. I never thought I would play in front of others, even though it was my dream.  This summer I had a chance encounter with a narrow boat pilot who had a melodeon on the deck. I had drunk a couple of pints over lunch and felt relaxed -I had a go on his box on the towpath with people passing by. It felt great!
So by now I have played at a couple of sessions. There is nothing to compare with the lift I felt when others joined in with the tune I started.
So my answer is ambiguous  - I play for myself, and for and with others.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: nigelr on October 05, 2018, 09:04:02 AM
Taking up the melodeon was initially very much just for me - almost an academic exercise in trying something different.  However, it has opened many doors to new things and now I find my focus is very much on playing for dance, something that I would never have thought likely or even possible 5 years ago.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: baz parkes on October 05, 2018, 10:50:20 AM
Mmm..as ever Steve gives us food for thought...I bought my first melodeon at Cambridge Folk Festival in 1977...I'd thought about a set of pipes but the belt wouldn't go round my waist :|bl,,,
Since then I've played for both border and Cotswold morris teams...and of the two always preferred Cotswold and will still find myself getting in touch with my inner Cotswold when noodling in the bedroom....
Modified to add I forgot North West...and playing The Old 95 interminably from February to June as we practise for Mobberley Rose Queen Festival
I've played in the same ceilidh band for some 30 years, and as others have said there's a great buzz from looking at a room full of dancers and knowing you're contributing to them having a good time.
I enjoy small sessions...not because they're exclusive but because you can hear everyone else, and yourself. I don't really enjoy being the 23rd melodeon in the room...

Possibly the gig that has given me most pleasure recently was playing for Pass the Parcel at my youngest grandson's 3rd birthday party...
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on October 05, 2018, 11:06:08 AM
Quote
and will still find myself getting in touch with my inner Cotswold when noodling in the bedroom....

Pass the mind bleach, please.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 05, 2018, 06:21:43 PM
Many thanks for all the great responses on this thread!
My personal take on my original question...

Is it solely for our own enjoyment, or for others' enjoyment, or a mixture of the two?

... is largely a mixture of the two. Yes - I do perform on stage occasionally. Those of you who have been to Witney, Mendlesham, etc. may have seen me as part of the tutors' concerts. But I am an 'average' sort of soloist; I know my limitations and of course I am not up there with the top names and never am likely to be at this stage in my life. (Hmmm... perhaps if I'd started playing melodeon when I was a teenager....)

However, I do teach, both on a one-to-one basis and in group workshops and that seems to be quite successful, and mostly fulfilling for me.

People have mentioned playing for dancing and that really resounds for me. I can especially relate to Theo's experience:
I love being able to look over a group of smiling dancers and know that if I wasn’t playing they wouldn’t be dancing.  Give me a great buzz.

I've done quite a lot of that over the years, both in ceilidh bands and playing for dance sides - mostly for Sheffield-based womens' side 'Lizzie Dripping' and its occasional off-shoots, and also as a guest musician for womens' clog side 'Duke's Dandy'. It is personally very rewarding.

The very best playing for dancing which happens for me sometimes is one solo musician and one solo dancer. That is indeed magic and can be a sublime experience for both people.

Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: arty on October 05, 2018, 09:19:56 PM
Well, I made my debut today and, to my horror, it was a really beautiful, sunny day, so the al fresco area outside the restaurant where I had arranged for us to play was packed. The nerves were bouncing around my stomach like a loft full of bats.
A big gulp of air and we started with Stephane Delicq's "Les Amities". That went well and to my great surprise, just about everyone clapped. I couldn't believe it and it felt good ! Then a man came up and asked many questions about my accordion. Next tune, "La Discrete", this was harder because I could see that people were actually listening and there was a lady holding her phone up, I guess she was filming. That made my nerves much worse and I stumbled, recovered and stumbled again but I managed to keep going - phew, I don't think anyone noticed except the lady accompanying me who was very supportive and encouraging.
And so it went on...I did make several mistakes, to be honest but I was very pleased that I managed to keep going each time. All those mistakes I put down to nerves, my hands really were shaking at times and when your hands are nervous, they can easily hit the wrong button or even slide off the side of the button! I hope that those nerves will diminish as I play more and more in front of people.
I really was very happy that there was so much interest in the music we played, the instrument itself and people obviously enjoyed what we were doing. We will definitely do it again soon because I am sure my playing will get better as a result. One other thing - isn't it a joy to play outdoors!

For whom do we play?......after today, I would have to say that the experience has shown me an extra dimension. Is it good to listen to? Not just is it good to play at home on my own? I found it a stressfull thing to do but, when it was over, I had to admit that I had really enjoyed it. Can't wait to do it again!
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 05, 2018, 09:32:41 PM

And so it went on...I did make several mistakes, to be honest but I was very pleased that I managed to keep going each time. ... I found it a stressfull thing to do but, when it was over, I had to admit that I had really enjoyed it. Can't wait to do it again!

Nice one Arty. Congratulations on "coming out", as a musician.
I don't know if anyone's told you, but mistakes that seem glaring to the player are, often, not spotted by an audience. Brilliant job there...you did exactly the right thing and played on through the stumbles. On a good day they turn into variations you wish you could reproduce. On a bad day...nobody died. Probably nobody apart from your partner noticed.

Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: playandteach on October 05, 2018, 11:23:46 PM
Maybe this is relevant, Arty. When you are stressed by the audience reaction, try to remember that the focus is the music: the same music you practised - the same music that got you really interested. If you can manage it, try to get re-immersed in the line of the melody.
You are performing the tune, not performing for the audience or even to the audience. The tune will reward you for the investment and support you. It is both something to hold up for admiration, but also a shield to shelter behind. Once the performance becomes about you, you have let the tune down.
This is of course not my experience as a melodeon player, but as a clarinet player. I'm sure it holds true, though.
Well done, and I'm really glad that you are coming back for more.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Anahata on October 06, 2018, 12:19:30 AM
I did make several mistakes, to be honest but I was very pleased that I managed to keep going each time. All those mistakes I put down to nerves

And managing to keeping going, you can put down to being well prepared.
Well done, keep at it!

The nerves will go away, mostly, but whatever happens, don't let them stop you doing something you enjoy.

Playandteach makes a good point about concentrating on the music, not the audience. A great book I read a long time ago (I think it was called "Psychology For Musicians") said if somebody says how well you played you have failed: if they say how beautiful the music was, you have succeeded. I've taken away from that the idea of selling the music to the audience. 'I love this tune and I want to share it with you, show you why I like it and make you love it too' works far better than 'look how clever I am'.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Pearse Rossa on October 06, 2018, 12:55:41 AM
The Séamus Ennis story, Henry Bohannan and the Fairy Piper, which I'd not listened to for years, is particularly charming (at least I think so) and I decided to transcribe it for the enjoyment of you all. It raises some interesting points.

The story is an allegory. The context is colonial subjugation.
Henry Bohannan*suffers angst and depression. He represents Éire.
The piping competition/duel represents the conflict between the oppressed and the oppressor, and triumph
over adversity.
The title of the tune "The lark in the morning", is also symbolic of a new dawn and hope.

*Bohannan is an anglicized form of the Gaelic name Ó Buadhachanáin, a double diminutive which means 'victorious'.

Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: richard.fleming on October 06, 2018, 01:30:46 AM
It's the music. It needs to get played and someone's got to do it otherwise it's dead.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 06, 2018, 09:13:31 AM
The Séamus Ennis story, Henry Bohannan and the Fairy Piper, which I'd not listened to for years, is particularly charming (at least I think so) and I decided to transcribe it for the enjoyment of you all. It raises some interesting points.

The story is an allegory. The context is colonial subjugation.
Henry Bohannan*suffers angst and depression. He represents Éire.
The piping competition/duel represents the conflict between the oppressed and the oppressor, and triumph
over adversity.
The title of the tune "The lark in the morning", is also symbolic of a new dawn and hope.

*Bohannan is an anglicized form of the Gaelic name Ó Buadhachanáin, a double diminutive which means 'victorious'.

Yes - I can see that there is an allegorical interpretation which can be applied to the story.

However, Henry's choices of (a) music to please himself and nobody else, or (b) music to please everybody but to take no value of it for himself, explore something much more general and older - why and how we show our artistry, emotions and expressiveness, linked in with ideas of selfishness versus altruism perhaps; also personal feelings of self-worth and low self esteem. I think those sorts of concepts are part of the wider context of the story.

Edited to change clumsy sentence construction.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 06, 2018, 09:15:39 AM
Excellent news arty, well done!
Thoughtful comments too from Anahata and  playandteach, thanks both.
Q
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 06, 2018, 09:24:15 AM
Excellent news arty, well done!
Thoughtful comments too from Anahata and  playandteach, thanks both.
Q
Also congratulations to Arty from me too! Enjoy your achievement and do it again soon!
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Winston Smith on October 06, 2018, 09:55:23 AM
Whilst I wouldn't pretend to know anything about colonial subjugation or symbolism in popular music (for surely Bohannan's writings must have been popular in his day?) I cannot help but feel that all this retrospective analysis using modern-day standards and implying modern-day patterns of thinking and terminology is quite red-herring-ish! Why can't we just enjoy the music (or not) at face value?
It reminds me of the endless praise of a certain Mr Lennon for his great wisdom and vision in writing "Imagine"; in my opinion a worthless "pop song" written by a pretentious bore!
And, whilst others are at perfect liberty to disagree, asking "For whom do we play?" is an entirely different question as "For whom, or what, do we write music/songs?" and is therefore leading the discussion well off-topic. (I know that I'm often guilty of this as well, point taken!)
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 06, 2018, 01:55:22 PM
Those who play for dance - and in particular Morris or other social dance, for which no remuneration is expected - do have a clear audience, because were it not for us they wouldn't be dancing (the same being true for recorded music, somebody had to play for the recording).
However, that obscures the question of why we're there poised, box in hand, to do the playing in the first place. When we (or certainly, I) spend significantly more time learning and rehearsing the tunes than the dancers ever spend practising. And we're there for that, too.
Not to mention cost of instruments, travel, and the extra responsibility to turn up.
One obvious answer is that it allows non dancers and ex-dancers to remain in the team as valued members rather than spare hangers-on, which leads to the real answer - we enjoy doing it. Otherwise we just wouldn't. Altruism has its limits.
Just being part of the scene is pleasant, but as my confidence builds and I find myself more playing solo, I am discovering a real buzz - even at practice - at being out in front enabling - and controlling - a bunch of people having fun and putting on a good show. And that buzz is all mine.
But, looking back, I got into Morris because I liked listening to the music, and I got into playing because I wanted to be able to play it for my own pleasure. For me. 
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Dick Rees on October 06, 2018, 02:38:33 PM
I'll be playing my once a month public outing tomorrow, two hours of tunes for Sunday brunch at a friends cafe/coffee shop/music venue.  I'll be playing for the folks who are no longer among us from whom I have received the music...and the cook who'll be feeding me when I'm done.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 06, 2018, 06:59:23 PM
I* was going to say what Malcolm B said, but he's said it for me. Agree with everything he says.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Jesse Smith on October 07, 2018, 02:15:11 AM
I mostly play for myself, as there are no "English" or general traditional sessions in my area (Irish, yes, but that's not my focus). So mostly it is for the pleasure of feeling myself improving and becoming more fluent and comfortable with the instrument.

But a couple of weeks ago I did have the opportunity to play with others, at the Northeast Squeeze-In "free reed gathering", and it was an amazing experience. It really showed me what I am capable of in ways that surprised me, but also where my current limits are. For example, I was very pleased to discover that I could sight-read at speed from music in group workshops, at least on the slower tunes, but only in the lower octave. So I need to work on getting more familiar with the fingering in the upper octave of the melodeon.

The most amazing part of the weekend was getting to sit in with the impromptu contra band that forms to play for the dance. I was only familiar with a couple of the tunes. We had a half hour rehearsal and then it was just a matter of trying to hang on to the tune and try to make a net positive contribution! On some tunes that I was able to sight read and play along at full speed, on a few I had to cheat and only play the first note of each bar, and on the fast ones I just vamped the chords on the backbeat. If you've seen "Back to the Future" I totally felt like Marty McFly sitting in with the band at the school dance! (Except that I did not take a "Chuck Berry / Van Halen melodeon solo".)

The point of telling the story I guess is to say that although I mostly play by and for myself, it was really delightful to have the opportunity to contribute to something larger. I really envy those of you who play in bands and I hope eventually I'll have the opportunity to do so.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Theo on October 07, 2018, 08:23:26 AM
[[ADMIN]]

Off topic posts removed.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: James Fitton on October 07, 2018, 04:31:20 PM
Thinking about last night's (pretty typical) gig......


There's the core of dancers who know what they're soing, dance almost every dance, and bring others along, as they make it look fine. There's the couples who are enjoying a night out, and the time they're spending together. There are the terrible dancers, laughing and clapping out of time, but enjoying the messing avout together. The little children sliding around on the polished wooden floor. The older children practising ballet steps to the music. The people just drinking and chatting, and sometimes tapping their feet or the table in time. The people who leave early with children or jobs, the people who stay till the last dance. I play for them all, and all of them make it feel worthwhile. Sometimes I play just for myself, but mostly to help all those people have a different sort of evening, with music and dancing and friends and laughter. Nothing to beat it.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Nick Ray on October 08, 2018, 07:52:06 PM
Thank you James F.
How simply and beautifully put!
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Andrius on October 08, 2018, 09:33:56 PM
It seems most important answer still not here.
We are playing for the soul, of course  :||:
If not - misery and suffering for both - player and listeners...
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 09, 2018, 07:18:46 AM
Yes, thank you James, that strikes a chord with me too.
Nicely put.
Q
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Winston Smith on October 09, 2018, 08:18:54 AM
I feel confident that Mr Fitton's contribution will ring true with a great many of the members here, especially as (or so it seems) most play in a professional or semi-professional roll for dancing of one sort or another. I can see that they might glean immense pleasure from performing those rolls to the benefit of such a disparate "audience". (Mind you, I hope that they aren't a part of the "black economy" and declare whatever income it generates on their tax forms?)

In the meantime, "those for whom we play" will not be so diverse a bunch for the rubbish but still happy players such as myself! I mostly play just for the fun of it, for myself, and occasionally (when I'm fairly confident that there'll be no proficient squeezebox players of any kind there) I'll take one to our local folk club, in order to torture the other members there. Oh, and at Christmas time, I do a little busking for a particular charity. But that is just for local shoppers who suffer my playing for a minute or so as they go in and out! They might hum the Carol tune as they peruse the shelves, who knows?

I often find myself wondering what proportion of members actually do make money from their playing, so much so that maybe I should start a thread which asks that very question? 
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 09, 2018, 08:22:36 AM
This has been a really interesting topic. Some great contributions from everyone, thank you!

Just a quick hint for newcomers to this thread who may not have read right from the beginning...
There is a story attached to my initial post here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22898.msg273884.html#msg273884).
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Eshed on October 09, 2018, 08:31:48 AM
It seems most important answer still not here.
We are playing for the soul, of course  :||:
If not - misery and suffering for both - player and listeners...
Exactly.
We're playing because the alternative is unthinkable.
I'm pretty sure playing preserves what's left of my sanity.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 09, 2018, 09:10:42 AM
This has been a really interesting topic. Some great contributions from everyone, thank you!

Just a quick hint for newcomers to this thread who may not have read right from the beginning...
There is a story attached to my initial post here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22898.msg273884.html#msg273884).

Rereading the story, the key passage, of the first part, is:

"‘Well’, said the little man, ‘I can soon cure that for you’, he said. ‘I can give you the gift of piping.’ He said, ‘Tell me Henry – which would you prefer: music  to please yourself and nobody else, or music to please everybody and not please yourself?’"

Does it have to be an either or dilemma?
I read the moral as being if you are not self critical of yourself you will not learn to play well. Set yourself higher standards than others.

Have I got it wrong?
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 09, 2018, 09:51:33 AM
As a bit of a distantly related non sequitur, here is a quote from a friend of mine, who also happens to be a well known singer and songwriter.
"If you find yourself the best player in the group, it's time to find yourself a new group."
So it matters not for whom you play, only that you improve as you go.

Sir John
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Theo on October 09, 2018, 10:01:25 AM
That’s good advice John.  I’ve always tried to get in among players who are better than me. I’m lucky in having some very tolerant friends who are very good musicians.  I’m still learning.  That’s one of the great things about music, there is always more to learn.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 09, 2018, 10:45:45 AM
Totally agree with John and Theo.
As my wife said recently, your hobby is something that you will always be learning from, improving and enjoying.
Long may it be so.....
Q
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Jozz on October 09, 2018, 03:07:13 PM
Regarding the story for me it's not black or white. I'm very pragmatic about my playing. Private or publicly.

At home I pick up the instrument at random times for my own enjoyment or to practice. Some days I feel like it, some days I don't.

Later, outside, I get hired to do a job, so firstly I am playing for the organizer. But if crowd reception is good, you enjoy yourself also, more than alone at home.

But one thing is for sure, never have I thought: I wish this gig was over. So playing for my own enjoyment seems to be always in the background.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Randal Scott on October 11, 2018, 03:54:48 AM
Accordian - I guess I wanted to figure out how to play it, without any initial aspirations otherwise.  I persevered with it, specifically, as an effective performing instrument.  I labor(ed) with it 10 years, not always enamored, as I conceived of it precisely such.  Melodeon was always more fun, but coincidentally not as ultimately fulfilling, polyphonically.  So, I play accordion/melodeon primarily for performing.  There are other instruments I play more for myself.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on October 11, 2018, 06:49:04 PM
That’s good advice John.  I’ve always tried to get in among players who are better than me. I’m lucky in having some very tolerant friends who are very good musicians.  I’m still learning.  That’s one of the great things about music, there is always more to learn.

This reminds me of the quote, "If you're the smartest person in the room, you are in the wrong room." I want to be around people I can learn from.
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Phil Howard on October 12, 2018, 07:44:17 AM
If we play for others because we enjoy their enjoyment, isn’t this therefore a form of playing for ourselves?
Title: Re: For whom do we play?
Post by: Julian S on October 12, 2018, 08:09:37 AM
Reflecting further on this, as well as the enjoyment of providing music for others, particularly for dancing, playing an instrument is for me a fundamental part of my well being. Being retired, and probably having never being much of a success at anything ( ::)), I have the time to devote effort to trying to get better at playing the music I love, no matter whether the tunes ever get performed. And there are so many wonderful and inspirational musicians out there to listen and learn from.

J
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal