Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Prestidigitator on August 29, 2009, 06:07:43 PM
-
I've played melodeon in East Anglia and London on and off for 4 decades, and I think I've mastered some of it. I'm always open to doing better and learning new things, and often think about going to Witney or, closer, Mendlesham.
Like many others, I've spent a working life competing under pressure. For me, playing music, especially melodeon, isn't "a job", a competition or anything else. It most certainly isn't an opportunity to sneer at other people.
I've looked very hard at some of the posts on the Forum about Witney, "New Melodeon workshops" and so forth, and the cliquey arrogance of some of the posters is a bit hard to take. To read them would suggest that each and every one of them is the equal of Tony Hall, JK, Squeezy or many other players. They know it all (perhaps).
Is there any place where someone "ordinary" can learn and enjoy without all this bullshit?
-
Who cares what other's say?... adults are just overgrown children at many times. If you learn and enjoy ignore their comments.
-
Stevejay,
Sound advice.
I am keen not to land up in the musical equivalent of a middle management paintballing weekend. Great for them as likes such things, but I'm not one.
On the other hand, perhaps I should just go anyway and allow my nihilistic tendencies a free rein. That could be fun.
-
I've looked very hard at some of the posts on the Forum about Witney, "New Melodeon workshops" and so forth, and the cliquey arrogance of some of the posters is a bit hard to take. To read them would suggest that each and every one of them is the equal of Tony Hall, JK, Squeezy or many other players. They know it all (perhaps).
Is there any place where someone "ordinary" can learn and enjoy without all this bullshit?
I have many years experience of Melodeons at Witney and the EATMT Mendlesham day, both as a punter and, more recently, as a tutor.
I suspect you are mistaking friendliness, enthusiasm and a sense of humour for "cliquey arrogance".
Both Melodeons at Witney and the Mendlesham day are very much for, and populated by, ordinary people, many of whom contribute to this forum. I also know many of them personally and they will bend over backwards to help and encourage others, particularly those who are inexperienced and/or nervous.
To accuse them of being cliquey and arrogant, and spouting bullshit is just total rubbish; nasty and exceedingly hurtful.
I suggest you actually go to Witney or Mendlesham and take part to see what it is really like.
>:(
-
I'm always open to doing better and learning new things, and often think about going to Witney or, closer, Mendlesham...For me, playing music, especially melodeon, isn't "a job", a competition or anything else. It most certainly isn't an opportunity to sneer at other people...I've looked very hard at some of the posts on the Forum about Witney, "New Melodeon workshops" and so forth, and the cliquey arrogance of some of the posters is a bit hard to take..Is there any place where someone "ordinary" can learn and enjoy without all this bullshit?
When written down, attempts at humour are sometimes misinterpreted because the signals that one is speaking with one's tongue in one's cheek are usually conveyed through the tone of voice. I suspect this may be why Prestidigitator has seen "cliquey arrogance" in some postings, which were probably meant to be humourous. I am not suggesting that there are no arrogant melodeon players, but the vast majority are friendly and helpful people and this has certainly been true of those attending the various courses and workshops I have attended over the years. In my experience, people on these courses are non-competitive and helpful. They are there because they want to improve, not to score points off others.
I've never been to Mendlesham, so I can't comment about it, but I have been attending Witney for about ten years now. I first went there when I had only just started to play and I was petrified that I had bitten off more than I could chew, but I needn't have worried. Everyone - tutors and students - was very helpful and there was no cliquiness or sense of superiority. I learnt a lot in a friendly atmosphere where everyone shared an interest in improving their playing and I've been back almost every year since then. I'll never be more than a journeyman musician, but much of the progress that I have made in the last ten years is down to those friendly and helpful men and wonen and Witney. Try it: I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.
-
I've played melodeon in East Anglia and London on and off for 4 decades, and I think I've mastered some of it. I'm always open to doing better and learning new things, and often think about going to Witney or, closer, Mendlesham.
Like many others, I've spent a working life competing under pressure. For me, playing music, especially melodeon, isn't "a job", a competition or anything else. It most certainly isn't an opportunity to sneer at other people.
I've looked very hard at some of the posts on the Forum about Witney, "New Melodeon workshops" and so forth, and the cliquey arrogance of some of the posters is a bit hard to take. To read them would suggest that each and every one of them is the equal of Tony Hall, JK, Squeezy or many other players. They know it all (perhaps).
Is there any place where someone "ordinary" can learn and enjoy without all this bullshit?
I've spent a little while reading and re-reading this thread before responding. Firstly, because I was a little taken-aback at what appeared to be the general thrust of the initial comments, and secondly because I have never been to a workshop before in my life. My first workshop is going to be the Button Box event run by Graeme Mackay up in Aviemore next month. And I hope that I'm not going to be the only workshop 'virgin' there as I'm pretty scared but / and excited at one and the same time. But I do feel confident that the people who I've encountered on this forum who are going to the workshop are a good bunch of folk, many have already shared so generously of their time, effort, energies and skills with me - some of them are also professional box players and are simply put easily the equal of 'Tony Hall, JK, Squeezy or many other players'. In fact, some of the poeple you are accusing of arrogance ARE 'Tony Hall, JK, Squeezy' etc. They just don't all advertise it.
I think its patently obvious that when people get to know each other there is often a friendly enthusiasm that is meeted out when they meet up again on forums like this. But I've not noticed any cliquey-ness. In fact the opposite. There has always been general encouragement for all to join in if and wherever possible. I've lost count of the number of private emails I've had from total strangers asking me if I was going to be able to attend Witney etc this year. The helpful and friendly nature of this forum is what attracts me to it - and makes me want to be a part of it.
I can't speak for Witney etc as I've never been - but I'd like to and will go (hopefully next year). I suggest (like Steve_freereeder) that you do likewise and find out for yourself instead of carping from the sidelines. Get stuck in - I'm sure any workshop leader would be delighted to have your forty years experience of box playing in a group - and could more than easily cope with what you admit to being 'nihilistic tendencies' (which I personally don't believe for one minute!).
AL
-
As one of the nervous /inexperienced players i will concur with steve that mendlesham was very friendly and i didnt see any cliquey or over competativeness at all.
-
My first workshop is going to be the Button Box event run by Graeme Mackay up in Aviemore next month. And I hope that I'm not going to be the only workshop 'virgin' there as I'm pretty scared but / and excited at one and the same time.
Al, I have also never been to a workshop and am getting a bit very windy about it. Although, bearing in mind all of the helpful advice I have had from members of this forum I feel sure that the other bods at the workshop will only be encouraging to we beginner BCC#ers.
Is it just Al and me who will be rank beginners on the course??
Is it better not to know?
Mike
-
Is it just Al and me who will be rank beginners on the course??
We'll be in a class of our own Mike!
;D
-
Al, I have also never been to a workshop and am getting a bit very windy about it. Although, bearing in mind all of the helpful advice I have had from members of this forum I feel sure that the other bods at the workshop will only be encouraging to we beginner BCC#ers.
Is it just Al and me who will be rank beginners on the course??
Is it better not to know?
Mike
Och, dinnae fash yersel'! It'll be fine. It's Scotland you're coming to, where "we keep a welcome on the hillsides", or some such. Everybody will be hoping to learn something, no matter where they're starting from. As for skill level - as I remarked somewhere else, I talk a good game; you'll find out that's about the size of it. ;)
-
Och, dinnae fash yersel'! It'll be fine. It's Scotland you're coming to, where "we keep a welcome on the hillsides", or some such. Everybody will be hoping to learn something, no matter where they're starting from. As for skill level - as I remarked somewhere else, I talk a good game; you'll find out that's about the size of it.
Thanks Bill, that's very comforting ;D
AL
-
We'll be in a class of our own Mike!
Al
Do you mean a classROOM by ourselves?
Och, dinnae fash yersel'! It'll be fine.It's Scotland you're coming to
Bill
An Aberdonian morning roll for breakfast and mince n' tatties with a mealie pud for my tea, couldn't be better.
-
Sorry, there's been arrogant and cliquey replies? On this forum? Where?!
-
Al
Do you mean a classROOM by ourselves?
I suspect I do!
;)
-
Is there any place where someone "ordinary" can learn and enjoy without all this bullshit?
If there were, sooner or later something you didn't like would crop up. :-*
I regard forums as like sessions - you put up with what you don't like for the sake of what you do. For brief periods of time you will find one that is perfect, but they never stay the same for long. When the ratio of unpleasant / pleasant gets too high, you can always leave.
Forgive the sermon - but if you want to stay and improve the tone, I think the most effective course, when someone says something you really object to, is to raise it directly with him or her, either by pm or in the thread concerned. If you calmly and respectfully set out why you find their post objectionable, people will generally take you seriously.
A general complaint - as you can see from the responses above - isn't likely to be very effective. Especially if you employ sarcasm - which it seems to me isn't a million miles from sneering ;)
-
Can I just add that the workshop will be my first one too. So I'm also a workshop virgin! And I'm the tutor...help!
Best Forum Ever. I've encountered such arrogance and cliqueyness elsewhere, but never on melodeon.net. It's not a terribly serious place to be. Thats why we all love it!
If you want help, you are in the right place. Just ask and you'll get it. I hope you'll be able to accept the advice with the knowledge that everyone is trying to help, the peace of mind that everyone is genuine, and the sense of humour needed to translate some of the posts.
We are all ordinary, regardless of our abilities. We all enjoy the music, this forum is an added bonus to give us a wee social world to come and enjoy others experiences.
-
I do slightly worry about this. This is the second or third 'mel.net is cliquey and useless' thread we've had in a few weeks. I love the forum as it is; but I do want it to be welcoming to newcomers as well. Should we be doing things differently?
Meanwhile, I hadn't realised that we were supposed to be competing! That would explain why those chaps started all those tunes of 10.0 difficulty at Towersey. (Execution 3.6 mind...)
-
This is the second or third 'mel.net is cliquey
This is the only forum I regularly post to as the replies here are either helpful or humourous and never as nasty or dismissive as some of the stuff on some of the techie forums I have read.
-
I do slightly worry about this. This is the second or third 'mel.net is cliquey and useless' thread we've had in a few weeks. I love the forum as it is; but I do want it to be welcoming to newcomers as well. Should we be doing things differently?
I am positive in my own mind that melodeon.net is neither cliquey nor useless. Everyone seems friendly to one another (none of the 'flame wars' that take place on some other groups) and whenever anyone asks for advice or assistance, they get helpful, considerate and constructive responses. The evidence is there for all to see.
However, perception is as important as reality; if some people perceive the group as cliquey and unhelpful, then they need to be specific about why they think this, which will enable us to address the issue, either by explaining (tactfully) where they have misinterpreted comments in a negative way or by doing something about it if their points prove to be valid.
-
I do slightly worry about this. This is the second or third 'mel.net is cliquey and useless' thread we've had in a few weeks. I love the forum as it is; but I do want it to be welcoming to newcomers as well. Should we be doing things differently?
I am positive in my own mind that melodeon.net is neither cliquey nor useless. Everyone seems friendly to one another (none of the 'flame wars' that take place on some other groups) and whenever anyone asks for advice or assistance, they get helpful, considerate and constructive responses. The evidence is there for all to see.
However, perception is as important as reality; if some people perceive the group as cliquey and unhelpful, then they need to be specific about why they think this, which will enable us to address the issue, either by explaining (tactfully) where they have misinterpreted comments in a negative way or by doing something about it if their points prove to be valid.
I agree otherwise off hand critical comments could be interpreted as a form of trolling...and we don't want that. :o
-
This is the second or third 'mel.net is cliquey
This is the only forum I regularly post to as the replies here are either helpful or humourous and never as nasty or dismissive as some of the stuff on some of the techie forums I have read.
As a beginner to the melodeon and an newish, avid reader of the forum (whether I understand the topic or not) I can't say I have seen any evidence of 'cliqueyness'. Some grumpiness, pedantry & evidence of full blown MAD - perhaps ;D
I recognise that many contributors are hugely experienced in music & melodeon and are friends, having been 'compadres in squeezing' for many years. I enjoy the good humour this generates, alongside occasional outbreaks of what may only be described as 'mischief'! It does mean though, that some threads/posts might be more or less accessible than others. Also, there will be a proportion of folk on here that have little experience of forums generally - and just not know what to expect.
It's clear to me that posters make every effort to share knowledge & skills with the on-line melodeon community 'at large'. I think the forum's great. :-*
K.
-
Gosh! That's me told then!
Let me clear up one misconception. I most certainly did NOT intend to suggest that this forum was in any way cliquey. If I have done so (unintentionally) and have thereby offended people (dozens, it appears) then I apologise.
At the risk of piling Pelion on Ossa, I'll try to set out what concerned me in a different way.
I would like to improve my playing and now have a bit more time to do so. I think I also have sufficient humility to recognise that a self-taught player such as myself has an awful lot to learn, even after many years of bad habit formation.
A possible method is to attend a workshop. I haven't been near anything resembling an educational class since about 1966, and I am possibly the least competitive person in the world. Put bluntly, I am a tad "worried" about setting myself up as an elderly Aunt Sally, in a situation where I know no-one (but everyone knows everyone else) and where one person is compared to another (i.e. competition). That, of course, is my problem, and the answer is clearly to "get in" or "stay out". Some comments (the polite ones, that is) suggest that I am wholly wrong in my suppositions, and well off the mark; and that I need not fear this. Thanks for that.
I work in the fishing industry, which is supposed to be the most dangerous occupation in the UK. I can sincerely say that the perils are nothing in comparison to those to be endured from making ill-advised and misconstruable remarks in this Forum.
Once again, my apologies to anyone I've upset. Such was not my intent.
Peter
-
I haven't been near anything resembling an educational class since about 1966
Peter
You sound as though you are about the same age as me and I am going to my first workshop in a week or two and feeling a bit nervous, although more than anything else I am looking forward to it. HallelujaAl is going to his first workshop as well, we've never met but are in the same beginner state of mind, which gives us loads in common. Although from his picture I reckon that Al is a youngster.
Mike
-
There is an interesting thread on c*ncertina.net about Witney from some years back:
http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=3394
It, of course, reached no conclusions but interestingly raised the fact that at least one person found Melodeons at Witney far mor friendly the C*ncertinas at Witney.
-
I'm late to this thread, but Peter, if you have been playing around East Anglia for forty years, I would love to meet you.
There is a Traditional Music Day at the Museum of East Anglian Life (near Asda) this Saturday, September 5th.
Is there any chance you could come? I'll be running my melodeon stall just inside the main entrance from 10.30am.
Details at http://www.eatmt.org.uk/traditional_music_day.htm (http://www.eatmt.org.uk/traditional_music_day.htm)
There will be loads of music and step-dancing around the site all day long. You only need to pay the normal museum entrance fee to get in so please come and introduce yourself.
Hmmmm, it's just dawned on me which Peter you probably are, in which case you'll be a steward at said event. If you are who I think you are then you have a very unique version of Oh Joe The Boat Is Going Over. Am I close? Apologies if i've got the wrong Peter!
-
Pelion on Ossa,
Is that like a Pigeon on a Gate? ;D
Never forget, irony and t'internet were ever strangers...
Baz
-
Let me clear up one misconception. I most certainly did NOT intend to suggest that this forum was in any way cliquey. If I have done so (unintentionally) and have thereby offended people (dozens, it appears) then I apologise...I'll try to set out what concerned me in a different way. I would like to improve my playing and now have a bit more time to do so. I think I also have sufficient humility to recognise that a self-taught player such as myself has an awful lot to learn, even after many years of bad habit formation. A possible method is to attend a workshop. I haven't been near anything resembling an educational class since about 1966, and I am possibly the least competitive person in the world. Put bluntly, I am a tad "worried" about setting myself up as an elderly Aunt Sally, in a situation where I know no-one (but everyone knows everyone else) and where one person is compared to another (i.e. competition)...I work in the fishing industry, which is supposed to be the most dangerous occupation in the UK. I can sincerely say that the perils are nothing in comparison to those to be endured from making ill-advised and misconstruable remarks in this Forum. Once again, my apologies to anyone I've upset. Such was not my intent.
Peter
Peter, as one of those who responded to your comments about this forum, it seems as though I may have misconstrued what you were trying to say. If so, it is I who should apologise.
As someone who took up the melodeon late in life, having never played any instrument before, I can sympathise with your anxieties about attending a workshop for the first time. The first time I went to Meolodeons at Witney, I was worried that I didn't know anyone, that I wouldn't be able to keep up, that the workshops would be at too high a standard for me, etc., etc. Although I was not a very good player (and I'm not that good now!), I needn't have worried on any of those accounts. Everyone, without exception, was friendly and helpful. By the end of that first weekend, I had made new friends, I had learnt a lot and I had really enjoyed myself. Others I know have had the same experience. Be assured, workshops are neither competitive nor intimidating: they are a way to improve one's playing in a friendly and supportive atmosphere.
If it seems like a lot of us know each other, it is partly because we have met at sessions, at festivals and at workshops over several years. Some of these acquaintances have blossomed into friendships. However, this is not an exclusive club. New people come along and become part of that circle of friends and acquaintances. Come on in: the water's lovely!
-
Gosh! That's me told then!
Let me clear up one misconception. I most certainly did NOT intend to suggest that this forum was in any way cliquey. If I have done so (unintentionally) and have thereby offended people (dozens, it appears) then I apologise........
Peter,
Many thanks for your latest posting. I think we have all had misconceptions in one way or another. I must say I was a bit alarmed when I read your original post, but I hope you are now reassured by the subsequent thread that you need have no fear of cliques, or being left out, or any sort of competitiveness at workshops, tuition days, sessions, etc. As others have remarked, this forum is really one of the friendliest on the whole interwebthingy, and this spills over when we meet in real life at these various events.
If you can, do try and get to the Stowmarket Traditional Music Day, as Rees has already mentioned, or Melodoens at Witney, and so on. You will be welcomed by all.
Best wishes,
Steve
-
Peter,
I would strongly recommend both Witney and Mendlesham. I've never experienced any sense of competition or any pressure from the tutors or fellow class members.
The workshop environment at both is very supportive, helped by great tutors who are keen to ensure every person has a rewarding experience in their workshop.
Neither is a 'mel.net' exclusive event and the age range vast.
Whether you want to consolidate existing skills, learn new tunes and styles, or try something new - I don't think you can attend better events for the melodeon in England.
So get that form and cheque in the post today (:)
Andy
-
Gosh! That's me told then!
A possible method is to attend a workshop. I haven't been near anything resembling an educational class since about 1966, and I am possibly the least competitive person in the world. Put bluntly, I am a tad "worried" about setting myself up as an elderly Aunt Sally, in a situation where I know no-one (but everyone knows everyone else) and where one person is compared to another (i.e. competition). That, of course, is my problem, and the answer is clearly to "get in" or "stay out". Some comments (the polite ones, that is) suggest that I am wholly wrong in my suppositions, and well off the mark; and that I need not fear this. Thanks for that.
I'm one of the people who misinterpreted you! Sorry.
Ooh you should definitely go to Mendlesham or Witney. I think you will be delighted. The first time I went to Mendlesham I had been playing for about 3 months and I was totally rubbish and couldn't pick up anything by ear at all, and didn't know hardly anybody, and couldn't get into the inexperienced workshop because it was full, and nevertheless everyone was completely sweet and lovely to me the whole time. It's the most amazingly supportive atmosphere.
Also, almost everyone is mostly or entirely self-taught apart on melodeon apart from attending the odd workshop. It's one of the things that's nice about the instrument; there's such a massive variety of playing styles and approaches.
-
Well, I read this thread when it was originally posted but despite reading it through many times, I wasn't too sure how to reply! I could sort of see where Peter was coming from and disagreed but the bottom line 'Is there any place where someone "ordinary" can learn and enjoy without all this bullshit?' made it difficult to reply without sounding sarcastic or facetious!
I've never been to a workshop (yet), never had any lessons, probably acquired a few bad habits and learnt all I know from other musicians at sessions, by practising, listening and watching BUT by far the best help I have received is from the Awfully Nice People on this Forum!
I simply ask a question and wait, knowing full well that all replies will be clear and logical. Yes, with some of the threads and comments, I sometimes feel that I'm surrounded by Numpties but they're the Best Numpties in the World, as has been proved by the replies and apologies I've read since Peter's initial comment!
Heart Warming......... God Bless You All!
Skipy
-
I sometimes feel that I'm surrounded by Numpties
What is a "numpty"? We have never heard of them at gravels bank, it could be that we are all numpties here in gravels bank of course. Lord Wesson of Welshpool will know if this is true.
-
I sometimes feel that I'm surrounded by Numpties
What is a "numpty"? We have never heard of them at gravels bank, it could be that we are all numpties here in gravels bank of course. Lord Wesson of Welshpool will know if this is true.
I thought that was a 'Southend' coloquilism...didn't realise it was in the wider domain. i always thought Numpty means a harmlessly silly or foolish person.
-
I sometimes feel that I'm surrounded by Numpties
What is a "numpty"? We have never heard of them at gravels bank, it could be that we are all numpties here in gravels bank of course. Lord Wesson of Welshpool will know if this is true.
I thought that was a 'Southend' coloquilism...didn't realise it was in the wider domain. i always thought Numpty means a harmlessly silly or foolish person.
It comes frae Bonny Scotland
Scottish usage:
a) Someone who (sometimes unwittingly) by speech or action demonstrates a lack of knowledge or misconception of a particular subject or situation to the amusement of others.
b) A good humoured admonition, a term of endearment
c) A reckless, absent minded or unwise person
a) "No. That wisnae wit she meant, ya big numpty!"
-
a self-taught player such as myself has an awful lot to learn, even after many years of bad habit formation.
Some seriously good players are self taught, its good way to avoid a conventional style of playing
I haven't been near anything resembling an educational class since about 1966,
A lovely incident that happened to me. A couple of years ago I started to learn the fiddle, and I've been having lessons from a very talented player/teacher who is younger than my children, and was a student on the Newcastle Folk degree when I started lessons. She now deps in my ceilidh band. About a year ago we played for a family audience, and after the first number a girl of about 12 came up and started talking to said fiddler. Fiddler turns to me and says of the girl, "she is one of my pupils" whereupon I tell the girl that I'm one of her pupils too. The look of surprise was amazing!