Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on October 30, 2018, 09:51:09 AM

Title: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 30, 2018, 09:51:09 AM
Hi peeps,
Last night at morris, a young learner showed me her relatively new Dino Baffetti 'Red' Pearl ( I think ).
The 4th button in, B push, on the G row doesn't return properly.
A quick lift with the fingernail returns it to it's proper position. Push it again and it only half returns and feels a bit weak to the touch.
I'm not particularly up on the gubbins inside, but I wonder if maybe a spring has weakened or worse?

It was bought new at Sidmouth from one of the main retailers there so it will be under guarantee, I'm sure.
I doubt very much if it has been misused or even overplayed yet. The owner isn't a robust or heavy player.
My comment last night was to contact the retailer to get it sorted under guarantee, but that will mean a couriering it which is a pain....
Thoughts please!
cheers
Q



Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Theo on October 30, 2018, 10:04:26 AM
Go back to the retailer.  The alternative is to send it to a repairer at owners own expense and pay for the repair. 

Weak spring is unlikely, unless the wrong spring was fitted, more likely the key is too tight on the axle, or in the slot it sits in.  Either will need a keyboard strip and rebuild to fix.
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on October 30, 2018, 10:05:31 AM
Q, I’ve found Royal Mail (Parcel Force) to be very good and not that expensive. If it’s under guarantee it must be sent back. To try a self attempt at repair will void  everything.  :o
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Theo on October 30, 2018, 10:31:55 AM
Contact the retailer first,  they may arrange the courier to collect from you.
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 30, 2018, 10:47:03 AM
Hi Both, thanks for replying.
Yes will pass on the advice to start at the retailer.
Thanks  for confirming my thoughts.
cheers
Q
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: rees on October 30, 2018, 10:11:43 PM
Couriering is not a pain. It's simple and quick.
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Stotty on October 30, 2018, 11:20:32 PM
Always worth checking the insurance cover value is high enough with any courier
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 31, 2018, 08:14:16 AM
Hi Both,
I suppose my non-melodeon experience of couriers over the years has not been great, hence my 'pain' comment.
It also means my friend, a young learner, will be without the box for a time, which is a shame but unavoidable under the circumstances.

After the comments from Theo yesterday, I immediately contacted them and made it clear that contacting their retailer was the first step. They appreciated the pointer and so I've now let them get on with it. As previously said they might even get the retailer to sort that out too. It would be nice.
cheers
Q
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Winston Smith on October 31, 2018, 08:33:55 AM
"It also means my friend, a young learner, will be without the box for a time, which is a shame but unavoidable under the circumstances."

Couldn't you could offer to lend him/her one?
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 31, 2018, 10:29:36 AM
Quite possibly, we also have a 'side melodeon' which she could use if she's without a box. She used  to have a Pokerwork and I'm not sure if she still has it or traded it in to get the DB. There are ways and means to keep her practicing.
The crucial thing is what the retailer says when contacted.
Q
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Gena Crisman on October 31, 2018, 12:20:01 PM
The crucial thing is what the retailer says when contacted.
It certainly is! I had a sticky button on my black pearl 2 and it was, as Theo says, caused by friction with the axle rod. If the button arm isn't returning correctly, that'll mean the that the pallet is sticking open, too, so, I'd say it's definitely a significant problem. When I had mine stick, well, I was basically without my melodeon regardless of if I physically had it or not because it was rendered pretty unplayable by the open pallet anyway.

The margins for 'too tight' and 'too loose' on the axle rod are very narrow. While there are a few home remedies one can try without dismantling the keyboard, I'd hope the dealer will offer to resolve the problem, or give advice to her on things they're happy for her to try herself first.

The main thing I would like to add though: Once it's back working again, I'd advise your friend to be watchful in the future for any buttons gradually not quite feeling right, as the issue can recur. In my experience, once I started paying attention to it, I found I could feel the issue slowly redeveloping over time. It depends a lot on on why it's happening and how conservatively it's fixed, though.

I hope your friend is able to get it sorted because, well, you never want to have a problem with your shiny new box.
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 31, 2018, 01:04:41 PM
Thanks Gena, interesting you had it in a DB too.
I took a look in between dances on monday evening practice and her only option would be to pull a B on the D row all the time, so messing up any recently learnt fingering. Essentially yes, unplayable!
Knowing my friend, home made sorting would be beyond her and also, fundamentally, it's a warrantee issue after only ~ 3 months of what I would expect as light use.
I hope it doesn't become a reoccurring problem, I would hope that the retailer, as a large respectable organisation, would really go through the entire fingerboard properly before returning it.
Q
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Gena Crisman on October 31, 2018, 02:13:48 PM
I hope it doesn't become a reoccurring problem, I would hope that the retailer, as a large respectable organisation, would really go through the entire fingerboard properly before returning it.

Well, like I say, the margins are very narrow - If you're not familiar, the structure of the keyboard is basically I think like a 2mm metal rod going through a similarly sized hole in a piece of wood, the whole lot of which runs through a single, solid, keyboard block with notches cut into it. The wooden arms are only 5mm thick and the outside row extends 70mm from the axle. You'd probably consider 1mm deflection on the arm to be 'rather concerning wobbly'. But like, a bit of napkin math suggests that means you have a ratio of Opposite/Adjacent ratio of 1/70, doing arctan on that suggests 0.82 degrees deflection. In order to rotate that much, I guess it would need to rotate around the rod the same amount, so, be able to form a similar triangle at the axle, so with a 5mm adjacent edge and have a ratio that matches. That in turn suggests that the hole would be need only be 0.07mm too large, a 3% error on a 2mm hole, at mm precision. Now, that's not taking into account the roundness of the hole, flex in the arm/rod, or probably a variety of other things, but, this is just me trying to understand what the margins might be like. To form a tighter but not too tight correct fit, it's probably pretty exact, and minor changes such as the axle rod slowly getting rotated or shifting, or changes in the weather, may disrupt that balance.

A sticky button arm is, to the best of my knowledge & from reading mel net, just a thing that can happen with this kind of keyboard, so I'm sure the dealer will be used to encountering it. While it sucks, they sold it as working because there was most likely no detectable issue at the time. If I'm ever at a stall and play an instrument that feels like it has a problem, I let the person running it know, and I'm sure others would too, and I'm sure dealers check their instruments too because obviously problems like this should cost them to fix & they want to have happy customers. I think it's just something hidden that can slowly develop over time, and while I absolutely would expect them to make it right, sometimes it's hard to solve the issue completely forever. You can only really 'fix' an issue like this until it stops happening in front of you at that time, and hope whatever it was that made it stick to begin with can't happen again - you can easily go too far removing material when something as simple as rotating the axle rod in place, or adjusting it in and out of the instrument slightly can seemingly completely unstick it, at least for a time.

Well, at least that was my takeaway from having experienced the problem anyway. I'm sure they'll get it working right though!
(edit - I think this post makes me sound a bit like an apologist, but I'm just trying to be annoyingly reasonable.)
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 31, 2018, 02:45:34 PM
OK, thanks, I'll check your maths later  ;)
As you say, a minute change can mess up a previously working mechanism. This was on Monday when I was first aware, and the atmospherics in the southwest was far from damp, merely really cold so I doubt if that had any effect, but who knows?
I have 3 boxes with this type of button lever and never come across it before, so am not unduly worried about the inherent design.
…..it just sounds like a slight tweak such as happens on a new box is required!
cheers
Q
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 07, 2018, 01:10:35 PM
I had a similar problem with my second box, a very old model DB three voice which was later the basis of a Saltarelle model.  In my case, it wasn't the fit of the axle rod but damp weather causing the wood to swell very slightly, jamming within the slots of the keyboard.  The fix was to rub then lightly with a fine abrasive block and, once slipping nicely into the slot, rubbed the levers all over with a candle both to lubricate as used on sticky drawers and in the hope it might prevent further take-up of moisture.

I know - sticky drawers should go in the washing machine...

Rob.
Title: Re: 'floppy' button?
Post by: Lester on November 07, 2018, 01:19:41 PM
rubbed the levers all over with a candle both to lubricate


I really would not recommend this as it only gives any passing dust etc something to grab onto and build up on until the original problem returns


YMMV
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal