Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 10:03:43 AM

Title: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 10:03:43 AM
I'm suffering from MAD. The more I think about it and try other melodeons the more I think I've got to get a smaller lighter one.
So suggestions for the
a) best to choose if price was not an issue
b) best to choose that is both cheap and light

I've started saving (there goes the scooter fund again). lol!
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 03, 2009, 10:34:47 AM
I'm suffering from MAD. The more I think about it and try other melodeons the more I think I've got to get a smaller lighter one.
So suggestions for the
a) best to choose if price was not an issue
b) best to choose that is both cheap and light

Your Beltuna Sara II is not particularly large nor heavy as melodeons go, so there are relatively few options available to go smaller and lighter.

(a) Castagnari Tommy - a superb melodeon, small, light and powerful, 3 voice (MML), so good rich sound possibilites. But expensive.
(a2) Castagnari Lily - even smaller and lighter than the Tommy, just a single set of reeds (1 voice), amazingly loud and piercing if you want. But some people find the single voice too austere. I'm a bit like that. If I want a single voice instrument, I play the concertina.

(b) Hohner Pokerwork - superb well-known workhorse. Some people play nothing else all their life. Suitable for beginners and professionals alike. Amazingly light compared with the Italian boxes. Two voices, with that great Hohner sound. It's worth getting it properly set up, with the reeds finely tuned and the button travel limited and quietened with felt dampers. Theo's your man for this.

If your budget allows, my recommendation would be for you to hang on to your Sara II for the time being, but get a Pokerwork as well - get it properly fettled and see how you like it. You might never look back.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Theo on September 03, 2009, 10:38:56 AM
I recently had the chance to try a Loffet Touptit, and was very impressed.  Similar size and weight to a Lily, but a much less strident tone, and much lighter on the wallet.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 11:01:48 AM
Quote
(a) Castagnari Tommy - a superb melodeon, small, light and powerful, 3 voice (MML), so good rich sound possibilites. But expensive.
I tried one at Shrewsbury...drool...would love it (everything seemed the correct proportion for my small hands) but out of my budget at the moment.

Quote
(b) Hohner Pokerwork - superb well-known workhorse. Some people play nothing else all their life. Suitable for beginners and professionals alike. Amazingly light compared with the Italian boxes. Two voices, with that great Hohner sound. It's worth getting it properly set up, with the reeds finely tuned and the button travel limited and quietened with felt dampers. Theo's your man for this.
you see its the clackityness and not being able to adjust the LH strap that would annoy me....or else I'd go for the pokerwork. If that could be sorted then I'd have no problem.

I recently had the chance to try a Loffet Touptit, and was very impressed.  Similar size and weight to a Lily, but a much less strident tone, and much lighter on the wallet.
ooh just went and had a look on the website....on the edge of my budget but looks nice...
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Scallyanglo on September 03, 2009, 11:08:35 AM
Quote
(b) Hohner Pokerwork - superb well-known workhorse. Some people play nothing else all their life. Suitable for beginners and professionals alike. Amazingly light compared with the Italian boxes. Two voices, with that great Hohner sound. It's worth getting it properly set up, with the reeds finely tuned and the button travel limited and quietened with felt dampers. Theo's your man for this.
you see its the clackityness and not being able to adjust the LH strap that would annoy me....or else I'd go for the pokerwork. If that could be sorted then I'd have no problem.

Do you mean the place where the strap attaches to the box? The clackityness you do learn to love, honest  ;)
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 11:10:34 AM
Do you mean the place where the strap attaches to the box?
the one which you put your wrist through to reach the basses

Quote
The clackityness you do learn to love, honest  ;)
really? :P ;)
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Ziachmusi/Louise on September 03, 2009, 11:24:17 AM
I've been learning a three row steierische for about two years and have always found it a bit heavy, playing sitting down is OK as I can support it a bit on my leg but standing up - no way. As it's also not really suited to playing English and french stuff I brought a GC pokerwork unseen, never held one before from Waltham of this parish. The first impression was that the treble end buttons disappear into their hole and the noisy clackityness but having played about with for a few months I just love it. It's light but loud and when I do manage to play something on it reasonably the i don't notice the clackityness at all. If you find a reasonably priced secondhand one then go for it. If turns out that it's not your cup of tea you could probably sell on with out much loss.

Louise
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Scallyanglo on September 03, 2009, 11:31:46 AM
Do you mean the place where the strap attaches to the box?
the one which you put your wrist through to reach the basses

Hmmm - I use furry 'No fear' wristbands with little pirate skulls to stop my hand sliding about. I think this might be stopping me from using the air button properly though . . . .
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ganderbox on September 03, 2009, 11:35:18 AM
The melodeon player in our morris side changed from a Lilly to a Touptit, and it's a much nicer box. It has a much warmer, rounded tone than you would expect from a single voice, but it's still quite powerful.

Pokerworks - If the current models are like mine, the bass strap is attached by a couple of small screws, and it can be tightened simply by removing the screws, making a couple of new holes in the strap, and reattaching it. Not quite as convenient as those little wheels, though. 

Tommy's are nearly as heavy as your Sara, or at least mine is. The specs say 2.8kg, but mine is nearly 3.5kg. Maybe they just feel more comfortable beause they are more compact.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Ellie on September 03, 2009, 11:36:03 AM
Do you mean the place where the strap attaches to the box?
the one which you put your wrist through to reach the basses

That's easily sorted - make some new holes in the strap, and the sew some padding round it - that made a world of difference for me, and it's really not at all hard.

I've got a clacketty C basses on my Saltarelle - not quite like playing the Erica again, but a small reminder  :D

Edit: Ganderbox got there before me! Also to mention that I find that my 2.5 row Saltarelle a much better (more comfortable for hand-stretch size) size to play than the Erica, so perhaps size is worth thinking about. I've tried a Lily and find it far too small to play!!
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 11:39:44 AM
Tommy's are nearly as heavy as your Sara, or at least mine is. The specs say 2.8kg, but mine is nearly 3.5kg. Maybe they just feel more comfortable beause they are more compact.
I just felt I wasn't 'fighting' to keep hold of it or getting the ache I usually get with the sara II. And my fingers were in the right place without all the awkwardness and I could even reach the C basses without a struggle.
With the sara I sometmes feel like I've got a TV on my lap I'm trying to reach round. :-\
I've only got short arms.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: joe on September 03, 2009, 12:01:54 PM
I started on a Pokerwork and never noticed the disappearing buttons, never had a problem with the clackety sound and never had a problem with the LH strap, I find sometimes you can get a sore LH wrist from the corner of the box as it is quite square, people use wrist sweatbands to get round this but I just got used to it. i agree with the comment that the Pokerwork can be a melodeon for life, for 10 years it was my only squeezebox, would still be content if it was the only one I had.

The Erica is another Hohner option, apparently the same weight as the Pokerwork, usually cheaper? and sounds just as good. The main musician in our Morris team (Jamie Wheeler) chooses Ericas over any other melodeon (including italian), so they must be pretty good. They have smoother rounded edges so avoid the wrist problem too. Cheaper as well?
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: TomB-R on September 03, 2009, 12:42:24 PM
Pokerwork £448 Erica £648 (Current Music Room "offers" the RRP gap is less.)
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 03, 2009, 01:02:13 PM
I have to say the little red Hohner Erica that I play (C/F tuning) is the smallest box that I have. In fact it sits in the bottom draw of my bedside cabinet when not being played. Its a superb instrument ...much, much better in my opinion than the Pokerwork. The strap placements can be adjusted to suit (everyone does it) and it is so comfortable and easy to play. Its the default box when I just want my melodeon life to get easier! Having played a Pokerwork briefly I was only to happy to move onto the Erica - worth the price differential in my opinion - but then - what do I know? Allodi Accordions  (http://www.accordions.co.uk/Button.htm) in 'SARF LONDON' currently listing them at around £640 (talk to Emilio there and I'm sure he'll do you a good deal - I just know how much you love the Music Room!). Though if you have a chat with Rees of this forum he may be able to help you  - as I've just ordered a brand new Hohner 'El Rey Vallenato' F/Bb/Eb through him.
AL
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: theSmoiler on September 03, 2009, 02:37:24 PM
The melodeon player in our morris side changed from a Lilly to a Touptit, and it's a much nicer box. It has a much warmer, rounded tone than you would expect from a single voice, but it's still quite powerful.

Tommy's are nearly as heavy as your Sara, or at least mine is. The specs say 2.8kg, but mine is nearly 3.5kg. Maybe they just feel more comfortable beause they are more compact.

I agree with Pauline that the Touptit has a sweeter tone than the Lilly (and I have both). This makes it good  for playing French music (?naturally!), waltzes, etc. But, there are drawbacks, too i) if you like a box with plenty of 'attack' (and I do), then this isn't the box for you as, IMO, the Touptit's reeds seem slower in response than other boxes. Hence, good for slower, or smoother, tunes - but not for punchy ii) spruce wood on such Loffets is very soft, so more prone to 'dings' - so not the ideal box for playing out IMO iii) because it is designed for children, the left hand strap is extremely short (even for someone with as slim hands as me), and I have had it falling out of it's fixing completely during at least one Session, because of this iv) I find it very difficult to hear myself on it, when playing amongst others - unless you're a very confident player, only intend to play on your own, or don't intend learning tunes by ears 'as you go along' in Sessions unless you are aware of what notes lie under your hand in any given position (vis. touch-typing), then this is not ideal. At times I have toyed with parting with it - but, I still like to play it in some scenarios eg as a second box precisely when I am learning new tunes in a Session - as bum notes are masked on it, in a way they are not on an Oakwood!

Having picked up both on the Hobgoblin stall, the Excelsior Bilbo (2-row, 3 voice) - which I bought - is lighter than the Beltuna, but still not light. When the Beltuna Sara first came out I remember playing one at Roadhouse's in Manchester, and marvelling at how light the action was - how it virtually 'played itself'. I have since been lent one to play in a Session and can honestly say I did not find the logistics of eg holding the box a problem (and I am SMALL!) - but carrying it is another matter.

If you carry any lump of wood stuffed with steel reeds for any length of time then this is going to become increasingly burdensome. Part of this can be mitigated by what you carry the box in, and how the weight is supported and distributed (as covered in another of LDT's threads). By the end of Sidmouth week I opted to take the Touptit into town, rather than the Oakwood, for this reason - but, it was the wrong box, and didn't match the job I needed it for (C*****h in the F**d).

The moral of all this is that it is compromise, and 'horses for courses' - and why so many of us have MAD, in the quest for the 'ideal box'.

Personally, as a beginner, I never found the Pokerwork easy to play. When I was lent, after about 18 months, a Castagnari Studio which I subsequently bought, this was like a revelation to me, in it's easier action, and my playing came on apace. Admittedly I didn't keep it long - as I discovered Oakwoods in 1994, with the same effect. But, I have never really mourned my 1978 Pokerwork, and only in the last few years have I felt I could get anything really satisfactory out of one. But, I have just picked up my Hohner Model I - which seems lighter than the wood Erikas - and...great action, sound (straight from eBay Germany), and not difficult to hold. So maybe a retuned one of those would suit (you can try mine at Stowmarket if you want).

There is another danger to this constant urge to change boxes - and the thought that a different box will be easier to play = will make you a better player. Up to a point this can be true, as above. But, even though I discovered Oakwoods a long time ago, I have still fallen prey to this nagging thought - hence the expenditure of monies, and constant trade in boxes that so many of us do. LDT, you already have a 'class' box - which should in some ways be an incentive for you to master it (otherwise others will keep taking it off you and playing it better - as they used to do with my red Oakwood, so you have to fight back!). On the other hand, it may have been a bit above your level of playing at the time you bought it (and you therefore need to aspire to it!) - in which case something more basic, like a Studio, or ? Saltarelle Bouebe may have been more appropriate.

In general I would caution that, ultimately, a different box may be no substitute for a basic musicality, aptitude for the instrument, coupled with a lot of sheer hard work! With all the latter, you should eventually be able to get some sort of decent sound out of most boxes.

(Hope all this is relevant and helpful - as it's so long since I read the question, now!).

Diane  

Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 02:56:06 PM
Quote
But, there are drawbacks, too i) if you like a box with plenty of 'attack' (and I do), then this isn't the box for you as, IMO, the Touptit's reeds seem slower in response than other boxes. Hence, good for slower, or smoother, tunes - but not for punchy ii) spruce wood on such Loffets is very soft, so more prone to 'dings' - so not the ideal box for playing out IMO
Oh I need something hardy.

Quote
because it is designed for children, the left hand strap is extremely short (even for someone with as slim hands as me), and I have had it falling out of it's fixing completely during at least one Session, because of this iv) I find it very difficult to hear myself on it, when playing amongst others - unless you're a very confident player, only intend to play on your own, or don't intend learning tunes by ears 'as you go along' in Sessions unless you are aware of what notes lie under your hand in any given position (vis. touch-typing), then this is not ideal. At times I have toyed with parting with it - but, I still like to play it in some scenarios eg as a second box precisely when I am learning new tunes in a Session - as bum notes are masked on it, in a way they are not on an Oakwood!
I don't like taking my concertina to sessions because I can't hear myself....(I half read half hear)

Quote
Having picked up both on the Hobgoblin stall, the Excelsior Bilbo (2-row, 3 voice) - which I bought - is lighter than the Beltuna, but still not light.
When the Beltuna Sara first came out I remember playing one at Roadhouse's in Manchester, and marvelling at how light the action was - how it virtually 'played itself'. I have since been lent one to play in a Session and can honestly say I did not find the logistics of eg holding the box a problem (and I am SMALL!) - but carrying it is another matter.If you carry any lump of wood stuffed with steel reeds for any length of time then this is going to become increasingly burdensome. Part of this can be mitigated by what you carry the box in, and how the weight is supported and distributed (as covered in another of LDT's threads).
I do feel with the backpack that if I stood still too long I'll fall backwards. lol!

Quote
Personally, as a beginner, I never found the Pokerwork easy to play. When I was lent, after about 18 months, a Castagnari Studio which I subsequently bought, this was like a revelation to me, in it's easier action, and my playing came on apace. Admittedly I didn't keep it long - as I discovered Oakwoods in 1994, with the same effect. But, I have never really mourned my 1978 Pokerwork, and only in the last few years have I felt I could get anything really satisfactory out of one. But, I have just picked up my Hohner Model I - which seems lighter than the wood Erikas - and...great action, sound (straight from eBay Germany), and not difficult to hold. So maybe a retuned one of those would suit (you can try mine at Stowmarket if you want).
ooh, that would be lovely..i think my mistake was to buy without trying properly everything on offer first. Maybe I should have gone second hand to start with rather than brand new.

Quote
LDT, you already have a 'class' box - which should in some ways be an incentive for you to master it (otherwise others will keep taking it off you and playing it better - as they used to do with my red Oakwood, so you have to fight back!).
Hmmm....that's what happened at melodeons and more. lol!

Quote
On the other hand, it may have been a bit above your level of playing at the time you bought it (and you therefore need to aspire to it!) - in which case something more basic, like a Studio, or ? Saltarelle Bouebe may have been more appropriate.
well I did buy it when I'd never tried one before.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 03:17:47 PM
We shall continue this conversation at Stowmarket.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 03:21:04 PM
OK, I know I'm the Castagnari man and I build my own melodeons, but when all is said and done if I really had to choose one D/G box it would have to be the Hohner Erica  - preferably not a new Chinese one.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Alison Scott on September 03, 2009, 03:42:59 PM
Theo-processed Liliput, I'd say. With the proviso that the Liliput is heavier than you would believe possible, given its size, and the buttons are very small. But it is the most fantastic melodeon playing bargain, and it has conveniently placed low notes, accidentals and reversals.

All my boxes are small though.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 03, 2009, 03:46:35 PM
We shall continue this conversation at Stowmarket.
Yes, sir.  :-X
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Scallyanglo on September 03, 2009, 03:58:30 PM
OK, I know I'm the Castagnari man and I build my own melodeons, but when all is said and done if I really had to choose one D/G box it would have to be the Hohner Erica  - preferably not a new Chinese one.

Do you have any at the moment?
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Andrew on September 03, 2009, 07:17:50 PM
I have a Saltarelle Connemara II for band use, but for playing at home/sessions/pub gigs I bought a Dino Baffeti " Binci" last year from the Music Room in Cleckhuddersfax.

John told me they buy these in then get ( I think ) John Connor to rework them, especially the reeds, and all I can say is it is the most light, easy to play, superb action, LOUD if you want it melodeon I have ever used, and I am finding myself playing it more and more in preference to the others I have bought over the years - - - - - -

Feels like half the weight and half the size of the others, but boy does it ROCK !!

Well worth a look and a play, and price is around half what I paid for my Salterelle Nuage from the same Emporium.

Andrew.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: robinbid on September 03, 2009, 08:20:11 PM
When I lived there it was Cleckheckmondsedge.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 08:35:23 PM
OK, I know I'm the Castagnari man and I build my own melodeons, but when all is said and done if I really had to choose one D/G box it would have to be the Hohner Erica  - preferably not a new Chinese one.

Do you have any at the moment?

Yes, but they're mine, all mine.

I have three Ericas: Black D/G, red C/F, red G/C. Three old Double Rays C#/D, B/C and my favourite Bb/Eb. Also an old wooden Erica in A/D and two one row four stops in C and D.

My other boxes are Sander D/G wet tuned, Dinn II D/G dry tuned, Baffetti Carnival II A/D, Guerinni 3 voice in A/D, Savoy Cajun in Bb, Eric Martin Cajun in C, Hohner Corona N Xtreme in GCF.

All of the above (excluding the Guerrini and the B/C Double Ray which are in bits) are gigged or sessioned on a regular basis and none are for sale.

Then there are all the melodeons that I do have for sale............ but that's another story.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Lester on September 03, 2009, 09:03:29 PM
OK, I know I'm the Castagnari man and I build my own melodeons, but when all is said and done if I really had to choose one D/G box it would have to be the Hohner Erica  - preferably not a new Chinese one.

Do you have any at the moment?

Yes, but they're mine, all mine.

I have three Ericas: Black D/G, red C/F, red G/C. Three old Double Rays C#/D, B/C and my favourite Bb/Eb. Also an old wooden Erica in A/D and two one row four stops in C and D.

My other boxes are Sander D/G wet tuned, Dinn II D/G dry tuned, Baffetti Carnival II A/D, Guerinni 3 voice in A/D, Savoy Cajun in Bb, Eric Martin Cajun in C, Hohner Corona N Xtreme in GCF.

All of the above (excluding the Guerrini and the B/C Double Ray which are in bits) are gigged or sessioned on a regular basis and none are for sale.

Then there are all the melodeons that I do have for sale............ but that's another story.

Rees

If you want another 1 row I'm told there some bloke in Wales turning them out, but you don't seem to have one?
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 09:12:22 PM


If you want another 1 row I'm told there some bloke in Wales turning them out, but you don't seem to have one?

Simple answer - all sold. I fell totally in love with the last one I made and vowed never to sell it. Then Dan Quinn happened by. He only ever plays Hohners so how could I refuse when he offered me money.
Yes - result!!

More in the pipeline.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: waltzman on September 03, 2009, 09:32:13 PM
Tommy's are nearly as heavy as your Sara, or at least mine is. The specs say 2.8kg, but mine is nearly 3.5kg. Maybe they just feel more comfortable beause they are more compact.
I just felt I wasn't 'fighting' to keep hold of it or getting the ache I usually get with the sara II. And my fingers were in the right place without all the awkwardness and I could even reach the C basses without a struggle.
With the sara I sometmes feel like I've got a TV on my lap I'm trying to reach round. :-\
I've only got short arms.
When I first started playing (which wasn't long ago either) I started with the little light weight Pokerwork which felt very large and awkward after playing the concertina.  It made my muslces ache also.  After playing for a while all of that awkward feeling and discomfort went away.  I recommend you give the poor Beltuna a few more months before you decide she's too big for you.

If I remember correctly,  you haven't been playing the melodeon that long.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 03, 2009, 09:35:57 PM
Quote
When I first started playing (which wasn't long ago either) I started with the little light weight Pokerwork which felt very large and awkward after playing the concertina.  It made my muslces ache also.  After playing for a while all of that awkward feeling and discomfort went away.  I recommend you give the poor Beltuna a few more months before you decide she's too big for you.
The aches and pains may fade away - but once in the grip of MAD you're doomed...DOOMED I TELL YOU!
AL >:E
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: theSmoiler on September 03, 2009, 09:41:26 PM

I have three Ericas: Black D/G, red C/F, red G/C. Three old Double Rays C#/D, B/C and my favourite Bb/Eb. Also an old wooden Erica in A/D and two one row four stops in C and D.

My other boxes are Sander D/G wet tuned, Dinn II D/G dry tuned, Baffetti Carnival II A/D, Guerinni 3 voice in A/D, Savoy Cajun in Bb, Eric Martin Cajun in C, Hohner Corona N Xtreme in GCF.


Rees, you've kept that quiet, just how MAD you are! :o
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: theSmoiler on September 03, 2009, 09:47:37 PM
I have a Saltarelle Connemara II for band use, but for playing at home/sessions/pub gigs I bought a Dino Baffeti " Binci" last year from the Music Room in Cleckhuddersfax 

Well worth a look and a play, and price is around half what I paid for my Salterelle Nuage from the same Emporium.

Andrew.

Price of these has been £1800 this 'season' on the Music Room festival stalls.

Diane
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Morrisbox on September 03, 2009, 09:55:50 PM
Quote
I have a Saltarelle Connemara II for band use, but for playing at home/sessions/pub gigs I bought a Dino Baffeti " Binci" last year from the Music Room in Cleckhuddersfax.

John told me they buy these in then get ( I think ) John Connor to rework them, especially the reeds, and all I can say is it is the most light, easy to play, superb action, LOUD if you want it melodeon I have ever used, and I am finding myself playing it more and more in preference to the others I have bought over the years - - - - - -

I'd have to agree these are lovely boxes, was nearly seduced into buying one at Sidmouth, but couldn't really justify it, as already have a lovely Oakwood 2 and a Tommy and a Liliput (in C/F), Connemara 3 and others.  I think you get seduced by the sound of a particular box, and the ease of playing it, the weight only catches up with you later.  The Connemara is a lovely box, beautiful sound, but it is a tad on the heavy side for "everyday" use, the weight gets to after a while, but when you want to play a waltz, there is nothing finer.

I think the more melodeons you have, the more your mood drives which one you pick up.  I have a Castagnari Sander, which I bought as my second box (after my pokerwork), and used for a few years, and loved it dearly, then got seduced by "shinier" boxes, and it got a little neglected, then my wife started playing it, before she drifted off to other instruments.  I picked it up again the other day - sheer joy! a bit like falling in love again.  I have always had difficulty parting with a melodeon (does anyone else have this problem?), and my experience with the Sander shows the wisdom of holding on to your older boxes (of course my wife doesn't entirely agree with this analysis!!)

Trevor
 
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: melodeon on September 03, 2009, 10:04:42 PM
If  owned and liked my SARA  I would get another in another key..
or a Hohner  either Pkerwork or Erica

Rees,

How do you like the Extreme ? Is yours an Xtreme II or III  ? How is the fit, finish, action. tuning etc.....why GCF    ?  other than it is the world standard.

I have a friend who sold his Dino Baffetti GLIIA  with hand made reeds to buy one.  He plays primarily blues and Zydeco.

Also do you retune your Ericas or leave 'em inexacting and sloppy and grossly wet ?
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 11:09:46 PM

I have three Ericas: Black D/G, red C/F, red G/C. Three old Double Rays C#/D, B/C and my favourite Bb/Eb. Also an old wooden Erica in A/D and two one row four stops in C and D.

My other boxes are Sander D/G wet tuned, Dinn II D/G dry tuned, Baffetti Carnival II A/D, Guerinni 3 voice in A/D, Savoy Cajun in Bb, Eric Martin Cajun in C, Hohner Corona N Xtreme in GCF.


Rees, you've kept that quiet, just how MAD you are! :o

MADder than most, I'm happy to say.
Thing is Diane, you only ever see me at English music events where I will be wielding a D/G or a C box. My other musical ventures (Zydeco, Irish, Italian, Welsh, Tex-Mex, Cumbia, etc.) demand all sorts of other key combinations........... erm.... that's my excuse and I'm sticking to it.  ;D

Al is now tempting me to go F/Bb/Eb.  ???
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Steve C. on September 04, 2009, 01:27:29 AM
Not as light as you probably want, but if you can find them, might consider Hohner Galaad or Cap Horn.  Also, maybe Irish Dancemaster 2-row.  But as stated many times this thread, there are lot of ways to soup up a Pokerwork (including creating the "loop style" inner bass strap) and they ARE light.
My MAD is leading me towards a new style Benny.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Keithypete. on September 04, 2009, 01:41:03 AM
I love my Sara II, it really is just right. If I get another 'box it will probably be an Excelsior Mini - a Lily rip-off if ever there was one. Or a Black Pearl Dino. Or a Lillput. Or one of those oh so cute Rucksack Steirische A/D/Gs. Or  All of the above. Hmmm - not thinks.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 04, 2009, 09:04:16 AM
When I first started playing (which wasn't long ago either) I started with the little light weight Pokerwork which felt very large and awkward after playing the concertina.  It made my muslces ache also.  After playing for a while all of that awkward feeling and discomfort went away.  I recommend you give the poor Beltuna a few more months before you decide she's too big for you.

If I remember correctly,  you haven't been playing the melodeon that long.
I started playing in march so that would be about 6 months-ish.

Also do you retune your Ericas or leave 'em inexacting and sloppy and grossly wet ?
sounds like a description of me. lol!

I have a Saltarelle Connemara II for band use, but for playing at home/sessions/pub gigs I bought a Dino Baffeti " Binci" last year from the Music Room in Cleckhuddersfax.
oooh, I was looking longingly at (I think it was) one of those at shrewsbury FF....didn't get a chance to try though.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: rees on September 04, 2009, 09:33:39 AM

Rees,

How do you like the Extreme ? Is yours an Xtreme II or III  ? How is the fit, finish, action. tuning etc.....why GCF    ?  other than it is the world standard.

I have a friend who sold his Dino Baffetti GLIIA  with hand made reeds to buy one.  He plays primarily blues and Zydeco.

Also do you retune your Ericas or leave 'em inexacting and sloppy and grossly wet ?

As I've said somewhere else (ages ago) on this forum, the Hohner Corona Xtreme is the best new Hohner I've ever played. It feels and plays like a much older model. My customers who have bought one are also very happy with it.

Mine is the IIIN tuned LMM with 5 switches. I use it mainly for Zydeco and Tex-Mex. GCF because it's easier to copy Boozoo and Flaco. I'm saving up for a F/Bb/Eb - same model.

The Ericas are still in the standard Hohner tremolo tuning. I've dry tuned all the Double Rays.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: JohnA on September 04, 2009, 02:24:12 PM
Hi LDT

Just to add my voice in praise of the "Baffetti/Oakwood/Binci" (modified by Martyn Banks of Oakwood). I too was seduced by one at the Music Room. Small, light, loud if you want it to be, fast action and a delight to play (something I hope to be able to do properly eventually...). Not cheap, but I think very good value. Mine came with the usual accidentals. It's a 19 button, but I don't go anywhere near the high note buttons - hurt my ears anyway. Incidentally, visiting the shop has been a treat - John and colleagues are full of helpful enthusiasm.

Cheers     John
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: melodeon on September 04, 2009, 03:35:28 PM
Thanks Rees
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: ladydetemps on September 06, 2009, 10:36:43 AM
Thanks for the advice everyone. And thank you to all those who tried to help me figure out how to stop the aching at EATMT...now I have a couple of suggestions to try to see whether that helps over the next few months.
I think I'll still want a cheap one to take on holiday though. ;)
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: xgx on September 06, 2009, 11:28:47 AM
Holiday cheapo.... when they're in stock ;)

http://www.victormorris.com/stephanelli_2_row_diatonic_melodeon_accordion
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Martin J on September 06, 2009, 10:51:13 PM
I have a Udo Schneeburg in A/D/G which I've spoken of in other threads.  Rees converted it from sterishe to UK standard but it is still too small for me.  You can see them on his web site or have a go on mine if we are ever at the same gathering.  It has a sweet tone, buttons that don't disappear into the keyboard plus three rows, all in less space than a Polkawork. Oh, and no clacking.

The straps are well padded and the box is comfortable.  Left hand strap is a clever velcro arrangement making it infinitely adjustable.  Great box and inexpensive.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: xgx on September 06, 2009, 10:59:19 PM
Is it one of these Martin?
http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=de&u=http://www.schneeberg-harmonika.de/&ei=Zy-kSp3BIMPOjAe-qcHGDg&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DUdo%2BSchneeburg%26hl%3Den%26rlz%3D1B3GGGL_enGB249GB250 (http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=de&u=http://www.schneeberg-harmonika.de/&ei=Zy-kSp3BIMPOjAe-qcHGDg&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DUdo%2BSchneeburg%26hl%3Den%26rlz%3D1B3GGGL_enGB249GB250)

are you n the UK?
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Lizzy on September 07, 2009, 12:47:46 PM
I have a Udo Schneeburg in A/D/G which I've spoken of in other threads.  Rees converted it from sterishe to UK standard but it is still too small for me.  You can see them on his web site or have a go on mine if we are ever at the same gathering.  It has a sweet tone, buttons that don't disappear into the keyboard plus three rows, all in less space than a Polkawork. Oh, and no clacking.

Sounds very nice. Are you going to Bromyard FF this weekend? I have seen these boxes on the website but would love to see and hear one being played. I have considered purchasing one but feel reluctant without hearing first.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Andrew on September 07, 2009, 07:34:58 PM
Hi all,

Thats the one John, Martyn Banks at Oakwood for the Binci re-work - - - - -

Great sound from a VERY small box, trouble is my lady says it hurts her ears when I play it, so I try to play quietly. This is o.k for the first couple of minutes, then the sound starts to get louder and - - - -

I can't play a march such as The Hills of Alva quietly, it was not meant to be played like that - - - -

Then I got sent by the current Mrs Andrew to the Audiology Clinic, on the grounds that if it was not hurting my ears there was summat wrong - - - - -

Sure enough it turns out I have " age related high frequency hearing loss " - - -BUMMER !

Of course we all know better, thirty years playing in a band sat next to the drummer has done for me,
It's nowt to do with my age - - - - -   is it ?

And you are right John, a visit to the music room is a damm good afternoon out, lots of boxes, good coffee and nice people to deal with.

Elaine said she was going to leave our cheqbook there, as they have most of the cheques out of it already !! - - - -

Andrew.
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Mike Gott on September 07, 2009, 07:48:38 PM
How about going vintage with a Hohner Preciosa or Liliput? Certainly little and light - but very playable. Theo may be able to help there.

Mike
Title: Re: MAD- Smaller lighter and preferably inexpensive
Post by: Martin J on September 08, 2009, 10:15:49 AM
Is it one of these Martin?
http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=de&u=http://www.schneeberg-harmonika.de/&ei=Zy-kSp3BIMPOjAe-qcHGDg&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DUdo%2BSchneeburg%26hl%3Den%26rlz%3D1B3GGGL_enGB249GB250 (http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=de&u=http://www.schneeberg-harmonika.de/&ei=Zy-kSp3BIMPOjAe-qcHGDg&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DUdo%2BSchneeburg%26hl%3Den%26rlz%3D1B3GGGL_enGB249GB250)

are you n the UK?
Yes, its the "Backpack Styrian 24/12/II" in the Sterische section.  I tried putting page ref in but it throws up the same home page as above.
I'm in Poole, Dorset.
I'm away on hols until 23 Sept now but am happy to show the box when I get back.  It is too small for me so I would be willing to sell.  It's as new.

I have a Udo Schneeburg in A/D/G which I've spoken of in other threads.  Rees converted it from sterishe to UK standard but it is still too small for me.  You can see them on his web site or have a go on mine if we are ever at the same gathering.  It has a sweet tone, buttons that don't disappear into the keyboard plus three rows, all in less space than a Polkawork. Oh, and no clacking.

Sounds very nice. Are you going to Bromyard FF this weekend? I have seen these boxes on the website but would love to see and hear one being played. I have considered purchasing one but feel reluctant without hearing first.
. As above, you are very welcome to hear and try when I get back.

Martin
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal