Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Fungusface on September 03, 2009, 11:33:45 AM

Title: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: Fungusface on September 03, 2009, 11:33:45 AM
People Asked me, But I dont Know:

1, Why is a one row with for stops hard to play compared to 2 row

2, Why does most people buy  "C " in one row rather than D or G or Bb, Eb
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: Lester on September 03, 2009, 11:58:05 AM
1)  My reasons are:
   

But worth all the pain

2) Most everyone I know, who play 1 rows, play in D. I admit I would like a 1 row in C but they are anti-social in a session.
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: Howard Jones on September 03, 2009, 02:26:11 PM
The spiritual home of one-row playing, in England at least, is East Anglia, where C is the preferred key. 
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 03, 2009, 04:33:29 PM
I have to confess that most of the 1 rows that I've seen for sale have been in C? Though just the Music Room they are selling both C & D tuned models.

My understanding was that one reason why the 1 row is actually harder to play than a 2 row is for the simple reason that it doesn't have so many notes - and a certain skill level is required to tunes out that would be easier on a two row?
AL
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 06:17:11 PM

My understanding was that one reason why the 1 row is actually harder to play than a 2 row is for the simple reason that it doesn't have so many notes - and a certain skill level is required to tunes out that would be easier on a two row?
AL

Sort of but not quite - it's mainly to do with the fact that all the notes are available but in the higher octave. English melodeonists don't like it up there. The French on the other hand go up there all the time, as that's where they play in G on their G/C boxes.

Also, as Lester says, with all four stops out there's more air to shift.
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: craigus on September 14, 2009, 12:16:55 AM
The key of C is popular in Cajun music, because you can play up a fifth in G, and get the nice flattened F note.
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: melodeon on September 14, 2009, 01:33:38 AM
I sold a Castagnari Melodeon in C and regret selling it

Cajuns also use D  and can play iin A...
and Bb and play in F

Most popular key in Quebec  D
Ireland D   

I don't believe the one row any more difficult than the 2 row or 3 row
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: craigus on September 14, 2009, 11:08:17 AM
I'd almost class the one-row as a completely different instrument to a 2, 2.5, or 3 row. It's not that it's harder to play, it's just a totally different technique. It's completely dependent on fast fingering, dexterity and punchy bellows control, and, of course, you can't play across rows! It's incredible what a good one-row player can get out of a box. Some of the Quebecois stuff is just mind-blowing.
However... give me a two-row any day! They can be lyrical, mournful, graceful and smooth - as well as all the things a one-row can be.
It's like playing in 3-D as opposed to 2-D!!!
Title: Re: People Asked me, But I dont Know
Post by: pipives on September 14, 2009, 12:29:32 PM

My understanding was that one reason why the 1 row is actually harder to play than a 2 row is for the simple reason that it doesn't have so many notes - and a certain skill level is required to tunes out that would be easier on a two row?
AL

Sort of but not quite - it's mainly to do with the fact that all the notes are available but in the higher octave. English melodeonists don't like it up there. The French on the other hand go up there all the time, as that's where they play in G on their G/C boxes.

Also, as Lester says, with all four stops out there's more air to shift.

There is more air to shift, but I like playin up the top end on my one row, in G. Probably due to my concertina playing antics!  :||:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal