Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Max Khanna on December 28, 2018, 10:26:23 AM
-
I have always wanted to learn what I always thought was called a button accordion - which I think I’ve now learned is actually called a melodeon... I remember hearing Andy Cutting on Radio 3 playing many many years ago; it’s stuck with me a long time! I’d love to be able to play English folk music on one.
I play many other instruments, none to a particularly high standard, but I very much enjoy playing. My enormously kind Christmas present this year was a “choose your own†melodeon. Knowing nothing and having the Bristol branch of Hobgoblin nearby, I’d really appreciate some advice before I go in. (Unless someone has a better suggestion?...)
As far as I can tell, a D/G instrument is what I should learn on, and I’m probably looking at £500ish for something worth playing but not fancy and beyond a beginner’s skill. What should I be looking for? 2 rows? More? How many bass buttons?
I appreciate that the more you pay, the better the instrument you get, but what is worth the extra and what is just going to be confusing or not worth a beginner having because they can’t get anything extra out of a particular feature?
Thank you so much!
-
£500 isn't a lot to buy a new box off the shelf with these days; you'll get something, but not necessarily of good quality. If I were in your place, I'd probably have a chat to Theo at www.theboxplace.co.uk about what he has; his website currently lists 3 D/G Hohners in the £500-£650 range, any one of which would be a fine choice. And if you don't get on with it, it will hold its resell value. But you will. Rees at www.melodeons.com and Mike at http://www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk/ would be good people to talk to too.
-
Looking at Hobgoblin's Bristol online site. They list two D/G Hohner Pokerworks (used) in stock. This model is very popular among UK melodeon players, and provided they are in decent nick, are what I would recommend a beginner to get. However, caveat emptor and all that, I would take someone with you who knows about the instrument, as it is easy to buy the wrong thing first time around, and that might put a beginner off melodeons altogether. We don't want that do we?
Sir John
-
If you're interested in Andy's music, you'll want a D/G by the way. Then go to lots of his workshops :-) The D/G pokerwork on Bristol's site should do just fine, but as John says take someone with you if you can to spot any obvious mechanical issues, not that there should be.
The D/G Maestro on there is ridiculously good value too if it's in good condition - it's effectively a Saltarelle Nuage. Not a beginner's instrument, but for those looking for an upgrade...
-
Looking at Hobgoblin's Bristol online site. The list two D/G Hohner Pokerworks (used) in stock.
One of the Pokerworks listed is also shown as made in Germany - these are the older models and are generally preferred to the shiny newer Chinese made models. They also seem to hold their value better too. Hobgoblin may also have some other suitable melodeons not yet listed on their site but are generally very good at moving melodeons between branches for you to try.
That green pearloid D/G on Theo's website does look pretty though. I really shouldn't look. We know what happens next.
-
As others have said, 2 row, 8 bass D/G is probably your best bet. My advice would be to check the layout of the box against these:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard_2_row.html
"D/G with accidentals" or "D/G G Scale (aka Anahata Layout)" are most likely to give the best flexibility/longevity.
-
To answer your initial question re nomenclature, the correct term for a two or three row box is A Diatonic Button Accordion. Strictly speaking, Melodeon should only describe One Row boxes, especially in Ireland, but like Hoover the term has become generic. Melodeon arises from the fact that a one row instrument can only play in one Major key but is ideal for playing simple melodies. The term Diatonic also means that the instrument plays in pre-set keys. This compares with the Chromatic Button Accordion which is fully Chromatic and can play in all keys. But a CBA is a totally different beast and harder to master.
Welcome to the club.
-
... but like Hoover the term has become generic...
...and most of us are very happy that way.
-
... but like Hoover the term has become generic...
...and most of us are very happy that way.
Andy Cutting isn't ;D
-
It’s an English idiosyncrasy. And the naming of diatonic boxes is a mess. In Portugal they are called concertinas, a Cajun *accordion†has just one row, in Ireland a two row is generally an “accordion†etc etc. No logic anywhere in the actual names people use. Just enjoy the eccentricity.
-
Hello Max and welcome!
I have been playing for about a year myself (although my schedule over the summer forced me to scale back my practice time :'( ) and I can vouch for the value of a used Hohner D/G two-row eight bass melodeon like a Pokerwork or an Erica. If you need any convincing of what this box is capable of, pick up a copy of John Kirkpatrick's CDs "Sheepskins" and/or "The Duck Race", on which about 1/2 to 2/3 of the tracks use a Pokerwork (the rest are concertina or a one-row melodeon).
I think Andy Cutting is a bit more of a "fusion" player, in that he uses a lot of Continental-style harmonies that aren't necessarily part of the English tradition, so if you are keen to follow in his footsteps you might eventually need a box with more bass and chord options. But I think the two-row can take you a long way indeed.
-
I have bought a number of instruments from Hobgoblin and they've been...ok but I would suggest that they don't offer the best value for money. They tend to have a high mark up on their second hand instruments and their new instruments don't compare favourably with many other retailers.
I would suggest that it is worth your while looking at some of the other people advertising on this site (no, I'm not on commission :D), and, maybe contacting a few. They will have a very good idea of what will suit you and you are very likely to end up with a quality box that you will treasure throughout your playing life well, within your budget. As others have suggested, an old Erica or similar, or German pokerwork is a great idea.
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,shops_repairers.html
-
Thank you all. So - a second-hand D/G button accordion also melodeon is indeed what I should be looking for. £500ish is a reasonable ballpark but maybe up to £600ish. 2 rows, 8 bass. Given that I don't know what I need beyond that, I will go back to Hobgoblin in Bristol next week, when their melodeon (etc) guy Cris Pierssené is in, and get him to talk me through what they have. I accept it may be more expensive than buying elsewhere, as it's a shop, but fair enough! Thanks again and I'll be back on here, I'm sure, with plenty more questions in the future!
-
That's a very sensible approach Max, and yes you will pay more at Hobgoblin (or any shop) but you also get the reassurance that brings - Hobgoblin have a very good return policy and a good reputation for after sales service.
If D/G is your thing you really can't go wrong with an old Hohner and you can find lots of advice on here about tutor books, DVDs or lessons. If you fancy a weekend away in a truly lovely part of the country with other beginner melodeon players you could do worse than take a look at Melodeon Playgroup (https://melodeonplaygroup.wordpress.com/)too.
Wishing you all the best for your melodeon journey.
-
Thank you for the reassurance!
(As for a weekend “playgroupâ€... sounds fun (plus not too far away!) - I’ll see how I go over the next month!...)
EDIT: I’ve had a proper look at the playgroup pages and it looks PERFECT. Now I just need to actually buy an instrument...
-
EDIT: I’ve had a proper look at the playgroup pages and it looks PERFECT. Now I just need to actually buy an instrument...
Actually you don't. Loan instruments are available for absolute beginners.
-
...but you also get the reassurance that brings - Hobgoblin have a very good return policy and a good reputation for after sales service.
As do the other traders and dealers who frequent this forum. And they are generally cheaper than Hobgob too.
-
...but you also get the reassurance that brings - Hobgoblin have a very good return policy and a good reputation for after sales service.
As do the other traders and dealers who frequent this forum. And they are generally cheaper than Hobgob too.
In my experience I'd say the individual fettlers can be cheaper but the shops tend to be much of a muchness in terms of pricing - although there is always room for negotiation of course. Over time you get to a position where you can generally buy and sell among friends but for a newbie dealers can offer added reassurance.
-
I have hire boxes for beginers if interested.
2 Hohner Ericas and a Hohner Pokerwork
-
... the shops tend to be much of a muchness in terms of pricing...
I saved £100 by buying from Eagle music, rather than Hobgoblin when I bought my first pokerwork and I got a bunch of freebies.
-
If you think the naming of boxes is a mess, have a look at the variety of instruments that get called (insert term or leave blank) mandolas.
-
PM sent
-
Welcome to the madness 🤪
-
Thank you everyone for all the advice. In the end I chose a second-hand Scarlatti Nero. 2 voice, 2 rows, 8 bass buttons - cheapest in the shop in the end, actually! I liked the sound of a three voice one I played on and I liked the idea of 2 1/2 rows so that it's possible to play in more keys, but in the end I went for simple, knowing that this is unlikely to be my last instrument and I will be in a much better position to buy a better instrument after I've played for a while.
(So please don't tell me I shouldn't have bought this one or that X or Y brand / model would have been better!)
I bought some books by "Mally" and I've been trying to practice playing up and down scales to get my head around the whole draw/push-being-different-notes thing...
My next question, if I may... What's everyone's advice for the best way to get on with playing?
-
...My next question, if I may... What's everyone's advice for the best way to get on with playing?
There's a question and a half.
I reckon a good face to face tutor is far and away the best, especially at the beginning, supplemented by a tutor book that suits the music you want to play. Recommendations will soon be forthcoming). A good tutor will be able to set you up and get you going far quicker than you are likely to manage by yourself.
If there are no tutors close to you, next best is Mel Biggs, according to popular wisdom in these parts.
-
My next question, if I may... What's everyone's advice for the best way to get on with playing?
Honestly I'd recommmend Ed Rennie's Melodeon Tutor (http://www.spinningpathmusic.co.uk/id17.html). It got me off to a flying start and unlike other books it includes a DVD as well as a CD. The DVD shows the two sides of the melodeon in split screen so you can see what the left and right hands are doing - invaluable. It also uses a really neat colour and number-based notation to get you started without having to read music.
I had some lessons about a year and a bit in but the book was a great start - and all for about the same cost as a single music lesson.
Also - come along to Melodeon Playgroup of course. The Absolute Beginners class will be using Ed's system BTW.
-
My next question, if I may... What's everyone's advice for the best way to get on with playing?
My advice would be to not rush it. There's this urge to know more and more tunes which is very counterproductive, especially early on.
Start with no more than 3 tunes and practice them until you're satisfied. Then record yourself playing them.
Trying to record will be a nice challenge on its own, but listening to the result will most likely make you far less satisfied than you were previously.
Go and practice the relevant bits, rinse and repeat.
Always make sure one of the tunes you're playing you don't quite get yet. Put into words what you need to improve in order to play that tune.
Meet other players and play with other players, preferably melodeonistas but not necessarily. Lessons can also help in a similar way I suspect.
-
Everything Eshed said.
-
The best advice I was given was try and get both hands going from the start.
It is tempting to just try and play tunes using the right hand. Ok, have a quick twiddle for fun, but try and establish a link between both hands.
Later along the road you'll realise the way you play the melody is dictated by the chords and bellows direction hence the need to establish the link between the hands.
Good luck!
Q
-
I would echo Q's advice about getting both hands working together, especially if you're at all serious about playing melodeon.
After about four years, I know what I want my left hand to do, but getting it to do it consistently is another matter entirely! It doesn't really matter in my particular case, as I mainly play for my own amusement, or just amongst friends who don't seem to mind anyway. But, if you're intent on playing properly, then this is very important!
Good luck.
-
Fundamental advice from Quinton and Edward. It's essential to get both hands going together right from the start. I emphasise this in my beginners workshops. Progress may be slow right at the very beginning but for most people it soon drops into place and they never look back.
-
When you're playing or doing something new, practice doing it slowly. How slowly? Slow enough for your brain and body to be aware of exactly what you are doing and learn how to do it. Playing at tempo can come once you are playing it right.
Beware of teaching yourself how to do things wrong, instead of how to do it right.
-
One optimisation is to buy second hand from an independent dealer who'll also offer sensible advice. A good place to do that is a folk festival craft fair.
You'll possibly move on to something more bespoke to your needs after a year or two, and this approach reduces 'depreciation' from a new box purchase.
The buy/sell here in the forum is essentially a free market, zero depreciation other than age. But it doesn't come with 'I'll fix anything in the first 3 months' guarantee. So is more suited to someone with a little experience.
If you have a friend in that situtation and he can look over the box, melnet buy/sell is a good option. Don't be too scared. As long as a box in not actually falling apart or bellows wheezing like an old resprarory cripple, most things can be fixed. You do need most of the reeds in tune however. Reed fettling is a skill and costs ... about £10 a reed done as a batch job (?) NB an out of tune box is not session friendly ;)
Suggest you update profile to say where you live if you want a tutor. eg: I am in Wirral. Festival teach-ins .. move you on. But it is regular tune a week practice that builds a solid and flexible technique.
-
It's essential to get both hands going together right from the start... Progress may be slow right at the very beginning but for most people it soon drops into place and they never look back.
This, absolutely this and I am so grateful for this advice early on. Although I may have, as my friend Q eloquently puts it, had a twiddle playing with the right hand only I took care to stick to the plan and persevere with the prescribed bass exercises - I can remember the frustration still.
I remember fellow learners who were disparaging about teachers, books and structure and sure enough they picked up the melody part much quicker than me and could play tunes fluently much quicker. On the right hand >:E. I persevered with the 'both hands together' approach and cracked it... while other had to go back and essentially re-learn a lot of stuff in order to put the basses in later.
So in my view too the sooner you can get both hands working together the better. YMMV of course.
-
Agree too The melodeon looks to be a right hand instrument, with some chords, but that's not the way it's played.
Most of the chords only only work in one direction. Most but not all right hand notes are in 2 directions, different rows. So a 'tune' involves fitting those to a chord sequence that works.
Sounds complex and is a bit of a brain ache as you start, but like driving it becomes automatic as you get to 'hear' what chords will work on a tune by comparison with ones you know already.
.. which is where a tutor is such a help in getting you started ;)
-
Thank goodness for tutor books, as they get both hands going.
Yes it is brain ache and feels like a wall, but... the bricks will tumble and drop away when you've cracked it, and you will have made possibly the most important step you can make when learning.
Greg's right too, keep it slow, let the brain form a good link to the hands. It's all new, let the links establish themselves.
It all feels quite slow at first but as Theo once told me at the beginning when I first started, enjoy the process, give it time and it will all come.
cheers
Q
-
When you're learning or practicing, the important thing is that you get it right before moving on.
Don't try and get up to speed if you have a note wrong, hoping that you will eventually get it right. All that happens is you reinforce your mistake. Then your fingers learn to go wrong at that point.
Slow down until you can play it the way you want. It might be days or weeks before that phrase or chord sounds right, but now it will always be right.
-
Squeaky Pete has said probably the most important point. There was a previous post that advised playing slowly, that didn’t clarify *how* slowly. As Pete says, play as slowly as you need to so you can play without mistakes. Sometimes it’s even worth playing one note at a time with a pause between notes to decide which finger, and which bellows direction to use. “Stop motion†playing as a teacher described it to me.
-
Yep, I'm becoming more aware of accidentally embedding mistakes at the start of learning a new tune by continually making a mistake.
I think it was Squeezy John Spiers who said 'practice makes permanent....'. Including mistakes.
Q
-
I think it was Squeezy John Spiers who said 'practice makes permanent....'. Including mistakes.
Yup, specially when you rush over the hard bits - often to be found in the first half of the B music.
-
Agree too The melodeon looks to be a right hand instrument, with some chords, but that's not the way it's played.
Agree to some extent but also disagree.
It depends on your style of playing. It is perfectly possible to treat the instrument as right-hand, melody dependent and using the basses and chords more or less automatically, without too much thought or analysis, depending on which RH row you happened to be playing on. Many traditional English players did this in the past, morris musicians and East Anglian players particularly, and continue to do so today. In contrast, continental players tend to learn smooth cross-row style right from the start using 'correct' LH harmonies. Both approaches are neither right nor wrong, they are just different and perfectly valid.
-
...How slowly? Slow enough for your brain and body to be aware of exactly what you are doing and learn how to do it. Playing at tempo can come once you are playing it right.
Beware of teaching yourself how to do things wrong, instead of how to do it right.
If a things worth saying, it's worth repeating.
-
Thank you for all the advice! I’ve twidded around with a couple of books but I will try Mel’s course’s 2 week tester and see how I go with that, plus I clearly need to get myself up to Playgroup. (Wow, surely people don’t camp in February?!) Thanks also for the John Kirkpatrick recommendation - really enjoying listening to someone I’d never even heard of before. Is there a pace on the forum where everyone enthuses about their favourite players? [Edit: oops just found it!]
-
... I clearly need to get myself up to Playgroup. (Wow, surely people don’t camp in February?!)
Some people do, in campervans that is. :|||:
Not many places left at Playgroup.