Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Steve C. on January 12, 2019, 08:38:56 PM
-
Having acquired a C/F Erica (thanks Jimmy!) I find myself wanting that low F (Anahata-style keyboard) that I am already used to on D/G (i.e. low G).
Seems like no good reason not to. Main reason for getting the C/F was that I just iike the pitch. I noticed that 5 of the 8 "patches" I set up on the Streb were C/F (the others were A/D, Bb/Eb and D/G).
All 8 patches have Anahata-low "X". (miracle of Streb auto-transpose or whatever you call it)
Aside from the fact that C/F isn't particulary popular this side of the Pond (i.e. no great resale either way), any reason why the F-scale is a bad idea? (I think the reeds will fit...)
-
My C/F is set up like this, it means that all my boxes are 4th button start and thus less finger confusing.
-
C/F seems to be becoming more popular here, and why not. I don't like D/G as I find the home key too high. and I only keep one because it's necessary to fit in at sessions in Whitby, At least we now have the George sessions, where I can use my 2 favourite keys, G/C, and Bb/Eb
Sir John
-
Having acquired a C/F Erica (thanks Jimmy!) ........Main reason for getting the C/F was that I just iike the pitch.....
There is a richness to the sound of a C/F (:), my C/F and Bb/Eb get used a lot to accompany the singer in our band, they suit his vocal range where the D/G can be a bit too "starched undies" for his comfort ;D .... " Those were the Days my Friend" ( orig. tune "The long Road", Russian) played on the C row is a belter of a tune to get people singing along at parties :|||: ;D
-
It depends hat you want to play on the CF. If it’s mainly G tunes played in F then the low F scale will be helpful. If you want the CF to play n Gm and Dm, then it might not be so much help.
-
Thanks all for the input.
It's ½ about fingering (Lester) and the other ½ about that richness (Ann) I guess. I had never thought about having a C/F box until I realized that I was playing in C/F â… of the time, given total choice of key. Of course, Johns right, one must carry the trusty DG Pokerwork to sesssions...
(as an aside, I thought the Streb would be ideal to carry around; you know, play in any key at a session. But the problem here is that no one has usually ever seen one, of if they have, never played one. So it spends all its time being passed around playing space tunes in synth or (actually not bad) string chorus!)
-
I have two C/F boxes and they get played a lot - somehow they just sound more satisfying than a D/G. I've thought about converting to 4th button start, like my D/G, but in the end decided to leave them as they were with 3rd button start. Yes, I do have to do a quick mental gear change when I swap boxes, but most of the tunes I regularly play don't throw up any real problems. I guess it depends on your repertoire.
Graham
-
Graham, completely agree, it's a do-able gear change. My "repertoire", as it is, not being too experienced a player, isn't big, so being able to play all of my tunes (on the new box) would be nice.
-
It's always a good idea to do the learning first and the box modifications second!
-
Truer words were never spoke.
-
On the other hand........it depends on how much you enjoy messing about with the instruments.
-
Philosophically and player-development and general character building, I agree with Theo.
"But" I have always been taken with the (can one say) genius of the extended low scale.
I feel like it takes buttons that one never uses and turns them into buttons one uses all the time.
It really "makes" the 2 row a complete box.
-
Yes it can, but as I said earlier it depends what you want to play. If it's mainly G tunes played a tone down go for the low F scale, if it's more for Dm and Gm tunes, or for RH chords then you may want something different.