Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Reedman on September 04, 2009, 07:20:01 PM

Title: Grey Paolos
Post by: Reedman on September 04, 2009, 07:20:01 PM
Hi Guys,
Can anyone tell me if grey Paolo Sopranis come up often on e-bay? Like are we talking one a year or one every five years?? I was told it might be a good place to see one but no luck  :-[ :-[ :-[ WOuld I be better off looking somewhere else??
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Bananayogi on September 04, 2009, 07:37:34 PM
Try this thread:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1523.0.html

Mostly it is (pictures of) the same box! Be very careful...
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on September 05, 2009, 09:57:52 AM
I check ebay regularly, and always gets a few phonecalls if there's a grey paolo on that I haven't called others about first!

I've seen about 2 or maybe 3 a year, if we're talking grey paolo sopranis. The price always depends on the condition and specific model, the most desireable ending at a whopping 6 grand sterling... (I actually met a guy at the Tønder Festival last weekend who just sold one for 8000...)

So the answer is... No. They don't come up that often. It seems that the only way to get one is to get a load of cash, and spread the word. And I mean, a LOT of cash...

(But if I ever get my hands on one, don't ask ME to sell it;) )
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Reedman on September 05, 2009, 01:12:30 PM
Thanks for the advice friends, Wow.. 8000! That box must have been in good condition. Did you play it or see it be any chance? A friend of mine was at that festival and said it was great. Where was the guy that sold the box from, Ireland? 
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Bocsa on September 05, 2009, 01:45:18 PM
The usual price for one in fairly good nick is around €8000. Some people wont let them go for less than €10,000.Hope you have a lot of cash ;D
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on September 05, 2009, 03:34:15 PM
Thanks for the advice friends, Wow.. 8000! That box must have been in good condition. Did you play it or see it be any chance? A friend of mine was at that festival and said it was great. Where was the guy that sold the box from, Ireland? 

Nope, I didn't see it, I just had a pint with the fellow and he told me. Irishman and musician, but not a box-player. It was a dark grey 3 voice with black bellow frames (Tony Mac Mahon plays this model), which is a very nice model indeed.

The usual price for one in fairly good nick is around €8000. Some people wont let them go for less than €10,000.Hope you have a lot of cash ;D

I've only ever heard of ONE that sold for 10.000 euros - it was a "bucktooth coupler" 4 voice dark grey, same as what Billy McComiskey plays.

It's a shame with these prices - it makes it close to impossible for musicians to afford one...
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Andrel on September 05, 2009, 04:00:06 PM
  What is so special about those boxes that they cannot be replicated ? The design, the reeds, sound projection or what ? They're revered like Stradivarius violins. Do they get better with age like wine ? A challenge for box designers, I guess...
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on September 05, 2009, 04:26:38 PM
They just have a very special sound - what I would describe as close to the ultimate sound.

It has been replicated, the Jubilee model, but it's just not the same, though the sound is remarkably close to that of the original.
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Andrel on September 05, 2009, 04:51:20 PM
  I do agree that the sound is exceptional, Lars, but it owes its quality to identifiable features, that's what I am getting at. Also, my favourite players on the grey Paolo are Joe Cooley, of course, Tony McMahon (playing Joe's old box) and Mick Mulcahy, all three playing in D/D#. I find that Eb sound simply irresistible. Somehow,  I don't get as much enjoyment from players using grey Paolos  with different tunings, however talented they may be.
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: mikesamwild on September 05, 2009, 05:28:27 PM
I've got a two voice black Erica in D/D sharp which is  a nice poor man's box!  I agree about the key which is nice and bright
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: boxlad on September 06, 2009, 12:32:14 PM
Quote
I do agree that the sound is exceptional, Lars, but it owes its quality to identifiable features, that's what I am getting at. Also, my favourite players on the grey Paolo are Joe Cooley, of course, Tony McMahon (playing Joe's old box) and Mick Mulcahy, all three playing in D/D#. I find that Eb sound simply irresistible. Somehow,  I don't get as much enjoyment from players using grey Paolos  with different tunings, however talented they may be.
I've played many dark grey and light grey boxes and there is a big difference between the sound of them both. McMahon's box is a dark grey whereas Mick Mulcahy's box is the later light grey with the celluloid grille. He took that grille off though and had a metal one made and fitted to it. Perhaps to make it look more like the more desirable dark grey box or one of the silver grey boxes..
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: triskel on September 07, 2009, 01:30:34 AM
... my favourite players on the grey Paolo are Joe Cooley, of course, Tony McMahon (playing Joe's old box) and Mick Mulcahy, all playing in D/D#. I find that Eb sound simply irresistible. Somehow,  I don't get as much enjoyment from players using grey Paolos  with different tunings, however talented they may be.

Though, you know, almost all Joe Cooley's recordings were made on the red 3-voice Paolo Soprani he's pictured with (in San Francisco, in 1969) below:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/cooley1969.jpg)

He's playing the same box in the 1973 film clip too: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGzJdoMeoQY (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CGzJdoMeoQY)
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Andrel on September 07, 2009, 01:38:49 AM
 Ha! That's news to me. I've always associated Joe Cooley with the grey box. Thanks for the info,Stephen. Great sound anyway, and the key he played in has something to do with it. I never get tired of listening to "The Bucks" by Cooley. I'm sure he would have sounded great on a Rossetti :D
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on September 07, 2009, 06:11:05 PM
- and a classic would be the old San Fransisco audio recordings of Joe (recorded around 1971) where he's playing in D (outside row) while happily tooting away on the Eb bass :D
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Bocsa on September 07, 2009, 06:35:58 PM
- and a classic would be the old San Fransisco audio recordings of Joe (recorded around 1971) where he's playing in D (outside row) while happily tooting away on the Eb bass :D
Lars ,Is that the one I have with someone singing "My Little Thatched Cabin" at the beginning of the recording?( possibly Seamus Cooley)It has 39 tracks.It includes a very nice setting of Miss McClouds.
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: boxlad on September 12, 2009, 02:48:31 PM
Quote
I've only ever heard of ONE that sold for 10.000 euros - it was a "bucktooth coupler" 4 voice dark grey, same as what Billy McComiskey plays.
Here's a nice photo of John Nolan playing his grey bucktooth Paolo a few weeks ago. A lovely box indeed. This was taken at a pre-Catskill party. With him is John Whelan also having a few tunes!

Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: pgroff on September 12, 2009, 07:35:54 PM
Here is an old Paolo with a sideways rocker switch (like on some Walters etc), instead of the two couplers. It is a 4 voice LMMM and the rocker pulls out the bassoon reed. I converted it from a stepped keyboard G/C, but the 21 melody buttons, the 12 basses, and the sideways rocker switch are original!

I hadn't seen a switch like that before but a dark grey Paolo piano box just finished on ebay (sold right here in Miami Florida USA) that had two of them!

Paul Groff
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on September 12, 2009, 07:41:50 PM
Here is an old Paolo with a sideways rocker switch (like on some Walters etc), instead of the two couplers. It is a 4 voice LMMM and the rocker pulls out the bassoon reed. I converted it from a stepped keyboard G/C, but the 21 melody buttons, the 12 basses, and the sideways rocker switch are original!

I hadn't seen a switch like that before but a dark grey Paolo piano box just finished on ebay (sold right here in Miami Florida USA) that had two of them!

Paul Groff

Nice box indeed!

I'm about to perform the same procedure on a 21 button 3v box. Where did you manage to get the buttons? They appear to be very identical to old Paolo buttons. Nice job you did there!
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: pgroff on September 12, 2009, 08:00:09 PM
Hi Lars,

The buttons and replacement aluminum keyboard plate were made to my specs by a brilliant machinist friend of mine. He normally makes parts for priceless antique sportscars but luckily for me, he took an interest in the concertina and had some that needed reedwork.

I don't remember the resin material he used for the buttons but we considered and tested a few options. The color is a good match, the material is a little denser and harder wearing though. They are made with screws installed, to screw into the black celluloid button-bases on the levers. But of course, new pilot holes into those bases were needed after re-profiling them, because the original screw-in mushroom-top buttons of the original stepped keyboard screwed in vertically, whereas the buttons from both rows are now in the same plane, at a slight angle from the original keyboard orientation. I still have the stepped aluminum board, original buttons, and original reeds, so (with a little work to those black button bases, reprofiling and adding a spacer) it could be taken right back to original state.

The grille is original and much like the grille of the dark-grey boxes. Oddly (to me) the bellows-strap "hardware" is just taller, bulbous screws to retain a leather strap. This box had zero playing wear when I got it, a real time-capsule. I suspect it might have been imported to the USA for the Portugese-American market -- I've seen a few of their groups featuring 21 key, 12 bass, 4 voice Paolos, which they call "concertinas."

Reedblocks are interchangeable with an open-action (1930s ?) 4 voice Paolo I have in storage, also in G/C and 21 key/12 bass.

It would be interesting to hear about your project as it progresses. I heard you completed and sold that baby-blue Baldoni Bartoli but that it broke in shipping...

PG

Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on September 12, 2009, 09:54:26 PM
Hi Lars,

The buttons and replacement aluminum keyboard plate were made to my specs by a brilliant machinist friend of mine. He normally makes parts for priceless antique sportscars but luckily for me, he took an interest in the concertina and had some that needed reedwork.

I don't remember the resin material he used for the buttons but we considered and tested a few options. The color is a good match, the material is a little denser and harder wearing though. They are made with screws installed, to screw into the black celluloid button-bases on the levers. But of course, new pilot holes into those bases were needed after re-profiling them, because the original screw-in mushroom-top buttons of the original stepped keyboard screwed in vertically, whereas the buttons from both rows are now in the same plane, at a slight angle from the original keyboard orientation. I still have the stepped aluminum board, original buttons, and original reeds, so (with a little work to those black button bases, reprofiling and adding a spacer) it could be taken right back to original state.

The grille is original and much like the grille of the dark-grey boxes. Oddly (to me) the bellows-strap "hardware" is just taller, bulbous screws to retain a leather strap. This box had zero playing wear when I got it, a real time-capsule. I suspect it might have been imported to the USA for the Portugese-American market -- I've seen a few of their groups featuring 21 key, 12 bass, 4 voice Paolos, which they call "concertinas."

Reedblocks are interchangeable with an open-action (1930s ?) 4 voice Paolo I have in storage, also in G/C and 21 key/12 bass.

It would be interesting to hear about your project as it progresses. I heard you completed and sold that baby-blue Baldoni Bartoli but that it broke in shipping...

PG


Yeah, I did re-reed that blue baldoni and tuned it up, and it found a new home in the states. The new owner had it fixed - despite it being a massive blow it took, it was apparently quite easy to fix - it's now back in action.

That little red I'm about to start work on (when I get the time!) is this:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/21478603@N06/3878565549/
A very impressive box, superb condition, never played much, and it's got a massive cut in the 3 voices. I'm going to make a new grill with more opening, I found some perforated aluminium to make it pepperpot-style to let out more sound than the celluloid grille does. The buttons are the tricky part - I know a paolo-playing machinist, maybe I should have him take a look at it...

Do you have a trick for cutting the levers? My friend Anders and myself are both about to perform this procedure (I located one of these for him as well) and it's a little tricky to get it even and precise.

BTW: I heard you got a little black baldoni - that looks like a very very nice box! How many voices? Congrats!
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: pgroff on September 14, 2009, 06:29:04 AM
Lars and all,

Guess we're getting a little off the topic of "Grey Paolos" here.

Although, my reason for mentioning that red Paolo was that some instruments of very similar internal construction (and sound and balance) to the old grey ones can be found at less than stratospheric prices, if you are willing to invest some time and work into them. That would also apply to the conversion projects you mentioned.

Maybe we should have a thread under a different category for details about Paolo restoration or mods...

It's late here though and I have a busy week ahead. Just returned from a memorable trip to New York City where I introduced two friends of mine, both D/C# players, to each other.

PG
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: boxlad on October 10, 2009, 10:55:16 AM
Lovely box there Paul with the rocker switch although I assume that the bass side might be a little heavy with the 12 layout? Here's a nice grey D/D# box that looks like a three voice but is actually a four voice. It has a slide coupler on the back of the keyboard. A fairly rare model I would imagine.
 
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on October 10, 2009, 11:00:59 AM
Lovely box there Paul with the rocker switch although I assume that the bass side might be a little heavy with the 12 layout? Here's a nice grey D/D# box that looks like a three voice but is actually a four voice. It has a slide coupler on the back of the keyboard. A fairly rare model I would imagine.
 

Rare, yes, but nice one. Colm Gannon's, isn't it?

Joe Cooley is holding a similar box in that famous picture with the young Tony Mac Mahon in the back.
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Bocsa on October 10, 2009, 11:11:56 AM
Very interesting model.Though I have never seen one in the flesh I have been told that the lever mechanism inside is something similar to that of a hohner and not the cantilever like system in most Paolos.Can anyone confirm?
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: pgroff on October 10, 2009, 11:22:51 AM
Boxlad,

Yes, the red 12 bass conversion is definitely heavier than the 3 voice 8 bass dark grey ones I have been lucky enough to have around at times. I had two of those over the years, from a Connemara man living in Boston who would trade them to me for concertinas.... Wish I had never let the 3 voice ones go, they would be worth a fortune today... But the red one you get used to, and the sound from the basses is beyond belief -- if you like basses. I re-used many of the original basses from the original G/C configuration (moved around of course), which are very high quality on zinc plates... again that adds weight, but what a resonance, and I left the tuning of the triads a little unequal-tempered. I gave it some chords you don't often find on a C#/D, such as G press C draw, and B press Em draw, that are lovely for some of the Cooley tunes (though he didn't use those chords, to my knowledge). I have never had an original dark grey 4 voice, 8 bass myself, but have played a few nice ones, and the 12 bass is about as comfortable to me. Maybe because its action, bellows and woodwork are so perfect and tight.

The bad news.... that red conversion box was traded away around the time I posted its picture. The good news .... it's in good hands, and knowing the new owner very well I may get a chance to trade back again someday. More good news .... he traded me another prize for it.


Lars,

If you know Colm Gannon, tell him hello for me, I haven't seen him in a few years.

PG
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on October 10, 2009, 11:28:59 AM
More good news .... he traded me another prize for it.


Lars,

If you know Colm Gannon, tell him hello for me, I haven't seen him in a few years.

PG


Paul,

I don't know Colm Gannon - I've just seen that box on his website. The only time I saw him in real life he was playing his 3 voice light grey celluloid grill paolo.

Now, WHAT PRIZE? ;)

BTW: I just put Binci reeds C#/D into the pepperpot red paolo of mine. It roars alright! It may be red, but it sure sounds more grey than red to me!
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: pgroff on October 10, 2009, 11:47:19 AM
Very interesting model.Though I have never seen one in the flesh I have been told that the lever mechanism inside is something similar to that of a hohner and not the cantilever like system in most Paolos.Can anyone confirm?

liammcg,

You might be referring to the grey one posted by Boxlad, and I don't know for sure about that. But I suspect it's set up like many 1930s Paolos (and Baldonis, and Hohner clubs, and ..... ) that had switches behind the keyboard (see below). The red one works similarly except its lever penetrates the soundboard above, rather than behind, the keyboard. Here's the way the 1930s Paolo levers often look (pic below); I have a rounded "grey-like" red Paolo club from the 1940s that has a lever behind the keyboard also.

PG
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: Lars on October 10, 2009, 11:48:21 AM
Very interesting model.Though I have never seen one in the flesh I have been told that the lever mechanism inside is something similar to that of a hohner and not the cantilever like system in most Paolos.Can anyone confirm?

Yes, this very early grey paolo with the more square keyboard has direct opening pallets, who really lets some air gulp through.

The soundboard holes are also 13 mm compared to the usual 11 mm of the later more common grey paolos. This, along with the direct opening pallets, really lets the sound scream.
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: pgroff on October 10, 2009, 12:19:42 PM
liammcg and Lars,

Oh, sorry, I understand now that liammcg was talking about the button levers.... thought you meant the lever on the switch, which operates slightly differently than the switch for the 2-coupler models.

Very interesting about the direct-opening pallets on that grey Paolo. I just was corresponding with another repairman who was complaining about a later Walters with direct-opening pallets, vs. some (not all) of the early Walters.... but like Lars, I think the direct-opening ones can work and sound great.

PG
Title: Re: Grey Paolos
Post by: boxlad on October 10, 2009, 12:40:34 PM
Quote
Rare, yes, but nice one. Colm Gannon's, isn't it?

Correct Lars, You know your boxes!

Quote
Boxlad,

Yes, the red 12 bass conversion is definitely heavier than the 3 voice 8 bass dark grey ones I have been lucky enough to have around at times. I had two of those over the years, from a Connemara man living in Boston who would trade them to me for concertinas.... Wish I had never let the 3 voice ones go, they would be worth a fortune today... But the red one you get used to, and the sound from the basses is beyond belief -- if you like basses.

Worth a fortune is right Paul, I'm lucky to have got my hands on the odd one.

You can't beat the boom off the basses! I am a big fan of that. I was recently listening to Tony MacMahon and Noel Hill's album 'Live in Knocknagree' and also their later album 'The Music of Dreams' accompanied by Iarla O'Lionaird. The basses on MacMahon's box are so full and powerful..amazing stuff!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal