Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: arty on January 21, 2019, 10:37:16 AM
-
I have just chosen a beautiful tune to learn, called La Candela by Cyrille Brotto. I found this lovely video of a young couple playing the tune, in a manner that I feel I should attain without too much trouble. Here it is: https://youtu.be/LgO-uHqnrLM
Then, I came across this video, of the same tune being played with lots of improvisation, decoration, changes of sound and I think, WOW! Here it is: https://youtu.be/-H3gTTAfNm8
What intrigues me, is the improvisation. What skills does one have to learn in order to be able to do something like this? I guess a knowledge of scales and arpeggios would be a starting point. And then there is the imagination and sensitivity to invent passages in such a way as they sound like they could have been written by the composer.
Where does one start? I would love to be able to make a stab at improvisation like this....Help anybody?
-
In relation to guitar, I've come across the suggestion of humming/singing ideas and practising being able to play what you sing.
-
As one of the steps towards improvising, my teacher has me playing right hand chord accompaniment, then playing the chords in different positions on the keyboard. Now playing the individual notes in these chords, up and down the keyboard. Eventually I should be able to easily find harmonising notes. I still have a long way to go..........
Maggie :|||:
-
Oh, thank you Maggie, that makes sense (:)
-
There's no substitute for knowing your scales, then you know what notes fit with the key you're playing in.
SJ (who doesn't know his scales)
-
Then, I came across this video, of the same tune being played with lots of improvisation, decoration, changes of sound and I think, WOW! Here it is: https://youtu.be/-H3gTTAfNm8
Simple, just be Aurelien Claranbaux :-) He's one of the very best players out there IMHO, and his work with Duo Absynthe is just exquisite. So don't beat yourself for not being able to play like him! On a more practical level, and Chris would be able to confirm I'm sure, but I think a lot of this is done 'Grenoble style', via a large amount of the improvisation theory that Pignol and Milleret have championed - so a visit to their workshop weeks in Grenoble would undoubtedly help. It's based around jazz theory, rather than being specific to an instrument to a melodeon I think, and a large part of being able to do that comes from the Pignol/Milleret layout which is fully chromatic on the pull - such players spend a lot of their time on the pull rather than push because it opens up the chromatic scale. Aurelien also uses unisonoric 'Darwin' bass instruments, so he's not *that* fussed about whether something is on the push or pull - he's got all chords in both directions.
Us mortals can do our best, but without an astonishing amount of time and practice, we're not going to get that close. I had a go myself under TOTM a year or so back
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZimjIGTQKKs
... and while I found it an interesting exercise, I'm not kidding myself that I'm anywhere near performance standard, especially in my "improv" section (3rd time through). My approach to improv can be described as "start high, then work your way down the scale".
Oh, and Aurelien uses quite a bit of reverb. He's got a pretty decent recording studio I gather - facebook informs me that the wonderful Ciac Boum are recording there at the moment - so you can expect even a quick recording he makes to be of very high sound quality.
-
I can't claim to be any good at improvisation but I've found sessions a useful place to start - trying to busk along with something that sounds vaguely right while other people play the tune.
Other advice I've heard is to pick a simple tune (or part of a tune), play it over and over and try to change one thing each time. It can be really small to start with, e.g. just change one note or syncopate the rhythm slightly in one bar, and so on.
-
I contrived to lose the entire text of the answer I was composing and in the meantime Clive and Butimba have covered some of what I was saying, but here is a summary.
Know your scales and chords, yes. Know your keyboard and your right-hand chords inside out. But you can glean a lot by studying what he does here and there and identifying the techniques he is using. Yes, a lot of it is pure inspiration (just sit back and enjoy and be grateful), but other stuff is more accessible: e.g. using a spare finger to tap a note that is part of the chord a couple of times; dressing up a downward run with grace notes to make triplets; playing the melody in octaves but with the lower note delayed so that the lower octave shadows or chases the melody in the higher octave, and so on. These are techniques you can identify, practise and incorporate into your playing of more straightforward tunes before you attack something of this nature. This isn't perhaps improvisation, but improvisation requires technique...
Wonderful interpretation by M. Claranbaux - thanks for bringing it to our attention.
-
Tony Hall is a pastmaster at 'improvisation' on the melodeon. He described the technique as something on the lines of ' keep playing a single note of a tune and at the same time press other treble buttons until you get a sound you like - then remember that combination for future use - or something like that!
There are plenty of interesting youtube vids of Tony doing his stuff
george
-
As an occasional improviser I suggest starting simple and building up a toolkit of things that you find can work. There are some examples above to which I would add: simplifying parts of the melody, eg hold the first note of a short phrase or a bar or where chord changes come. Occasionally there are tunes (usually played on the row) where you can play the same pattern of push/pull but starting one button up. Play the chords you would normally but on the right hand instead of the left. If the tune is tending to start low and go up try starting high and going down. If there is part of a tune which is simply a run up a scale try starting on a lower note and going up in parallel. You can probably think of more. You have to try these things out with some tolerant musicians and find out what works where and, very important, what doesn't work!
-
I have just chosen a beautiful tune to learn, called La Candela by Cyrille Brotto. I found this lovely video of a young couple playing the tune, in a manner that I feel I should attain without too much trouble. Here it is: https://youtu.be/LgO-uHqnrLM
Then, I came across this video, of the same tune being played with lots of improvisation, decoration, changes of sound and I think, WOW! Here it is: https://youtu.be/-H3gTTAfNm8
What intrigues me, is the improvisation. What skills does one have to learn in order to be able to do something like this? I guess a knowledge of scales and arpeggios would be a starting point. And then there is the imagination and sensitivity to invent passages in such a way as they sound like they could have been written by the composer.
Where does one start? I would love to be able to make a stab at improvisation like this....Help anybody?
It appears that the improv guy is playing an essentially chromatic instrument. As others have said, know your keyboard, scales and arpeggios. Learn how to play harmonies to the melody. I particularly agree with the hint about vocalizing and would just add:
Listen to as many different people/versions of a tune as you can. All you need is one good tune with lots of recorded performances. It can be anything, so I listen to singers and instrumentalists both. Louie "Satchmo" Armstrong and Ella Fitzgerald are great for picking up scatting. Andy Cutting is great.
So are Clive and Ellison.
One of the best takes on how to play freely comes from jazz great Jimmy Raney. Watch this several times:
https://youtu.be/f29a1RL2ly0
-
He is also playing a variety of rhythmic patterns on the bass and hardly ever Om Pah Pah
-
He is also playing a variety of rhythmic patterns on the bass and hardly ever Om Pah Pah
It does occur to me that most folks actually start melodeon improv in the LH as they decide which chords to use and how to combine the buttons in combinations other than the nominal pairings.
-
Maybe start with a simple blues - 'Lay me down a Pallet on your Floor' or similar for instance. I find thinking 'blues harmonica' has helped using outer row and crossing to inner and using a draw bellows to start, again like the blues harp folks. Just a thought ;)
-
Wow...what an amazing amount of advice !
Thank you, everyone, so much. There is loads there for me to work through, which should take me through the next few years!
Wish me luck (:)
-
Arty...
Try starting to put the info into practice by making harmony lines for a few...or a bunch...of your favorite tunes.
Good luck and enjoy the journey!
-
I find it useful to improvise in my mind as I'm wandering along, shopping, driving or whatever.
Try it, you probably do it all day long anyway.
Later you might try and reproduce something like it. It won't be quite the same but it will be related to the tune and with a bit of luck, sound ok.
This sounds a bit contrived and long winded and in the end it's certainly not improvised, BUT it gets you into the habit and you learn the fingering of a few phrases you just made up. Next time you play the tune, you have the chance to stick in that odd phrase, or stick to the original. You will be improvising, in a very modest way, but it's a start.
I'm a pretty rubbish player, but I improvise all the time, making tunes up or little grace notes and flourishes. If I was a better technical player I'd make a much better job but I don't practice enough.
-
Hi Arty,
For my tuppence worth, of course he knows his instrument intimately. I can write (English) pretty well on the keyboard, because I know what I want to say and I know where all the letters are.
But, it doesn't have to be the only way.
Others here have mentioned the left hand rhythm. I think the right hand rhythm, dynamics, phrase shaping and textures are equally important. I think if you can build the confidence to commit to a strong rhythm for your chosen melodic line and really stick to that commitment, the actual pitch choices become less scary. If poor pitch selection becomes an issue, I bet it is because it's made you lose the rhythm.
Try it.
Pete
-
Thank you Pete, as usual, you make a lot of sense.
I have decided, that what I have to do first, as Maggie suggested, is to learn some right hand chords. This will increase my knowledge of the right hand keyboard and will also give me a way in to improvisation. I can hear many of the melody sounds present in the chords already and so, I should be able to start finding notes to link from one chord to the next, in much the same way as a guitarist might.
I recognize the importance of keeping the rhythm and feel of the tune going as I do this Pete, so thanks again for highlighting that.
-
for anyone relatively new to the DG ( or CF etc) box it is worth keeping in mind that on the push any combination of buttons 'on the row' will harmonise and on the pull there is just one pair of button that won't ( find this out by suck and see method so you will remember it)
This simple fact opens up the way for all sorts of Improvisation which can then be added to by experimentation 'across the rows' etc etc
george
-
for anyone relatively new to the DG ( or CF etc) box it is worth keeping in mind that on the push any combination of buttons 'on the row' will harmonise and on the pull there is just one pair of button that won't ( find this out by suck and see method so you will remember it)
Depending on the underlying harmony!
If you're playing C push on the LH, your only real harmony on the RH is G.
-
Eric Clapton once said he learned a number of classic blues riffs and tried to incorporate them into his playing whenever possible - a sort of cut and paste.
When I was learning the guitar - more years ago than I'm prepared to admit to - I was told to take the phrases of a tune and embellish them by adding, substituting, or even subtracting notes where appropriate. Start by taking a simple tune, something like Stephane Delicq's 'Septembre', or even better, 'Once I loved (a Maiden Fair)'. In 1651's version (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=slmTxkkJoH4) Mark Emerson takes a very simple melody and builds on the phrases by improvising. The simplicity of the tune also allows for a great variation in left hand chords. Best advice I was given was to break everything down and proceed very slowly. Good luck
-
Improvisation (and harmonisation) on an instrument is a bit like harmony singing -- you have to have a feel for the chord sequence (or sequences) and the tune before you can do it effectively. The two-row diatonic box has a huge inbuilt advantage in that if you learn a tune (and bass accompanment) playing almost anything on the same row (in the same direction) will fit (with some exceptions...), but it probably won't sound good unless you have some idea about how harmony and counterpoint works. If you haven't got this skill, probably the only way to acquire it by practising is to noodle along to a recording at home and see what fits and what takes your fancy.
If I'm playing melodeon in a session with several other melodeons I quite often don't play the tune all the time -- because that's just another identical sound -- but instead something that goes with it. Sometimes this will be a harmony (e.g parallel thirds -- but not all the time), sometimes a rhythmic right-hand vamp, sometimes ornamental bits with gaps in, sometimes a contrapuntal line against the tune (good old JSB was great at this...) -- but rarely the same thing twice. However to do this live you need to have a pretty good idea of what works and what doesn't, and make sure that you're not louder than the tune to avoid great confusion...
One of the best tunes I found (accidentally!) for harmonising is Sir Sidney Smith's March -- in the flat session at Sheffield last year Rich Arrowsmith was leading it, I was sitting next to him but I don't think I played the tune once. Maybe a good thing because both our Melos boxes have very similar sounding treble ends in spite of the fact that his is three times the size of mine ;-)
-
Eric Clapton once said he learned a number of classic blues riffs and tried to incorporate them into his playing whenever possible - a sort of cut and paste.
In my youth I used to do that a lot on the piano. It's a good plan.
If I'm playing melodeon in a session with several other melodeons I quite often don't play the tune all the time
I do that a lot. It's something you can easily practise in a session or possibly at home listening to a recording. Nick Barber is good at this too.
Playing along with a tune (while someone else is playing the real tune) is a slightly different skill from what happens when a jazz player solos over the chord changes, but both require a pretty good knowledge of the harmonies. You also need the ability to play by ear, because you (I do anyway) 'hear' in your head what you're about to play.
-
There have been a few suggestions about learning scales and arpeggios but I don't think I've ever seen any 'standard' cross-row scale fingering diagrams anywhere for the main D/G key possibilities. Do they exist?
-
You can work it out from the keyboard charts on here I by a bit of picking and prodding amongst the 21 buttons
George
-
If you want great examples of harmonization and chord structure, simply haul out a hymnal and go to it.
-
Llisten to Leveret. Masters.
-
I try hard to improvise, not always successfully, and some have a natural gift.
There ARE rules, an for eg a tune in A one good start is to learn the A and F# (relative minor) blues scales on your kit. The latter particularly fluent on a DG 😉
As others have said : Keep strict rhythm, and a true scale. FEEL the chords in there. Breaking a 44 scsle into 12 (ternary) is another simple but effective trick. Then … play what you hear in your head! And NEVER neglect to power of a big of a bit of SILENCE. So kften “more os less�
The rest “is†technique. The Grenoble clique do an annual week Impovisation course every February, fir some 30 years now. Brotto will definitely have been there. This year it was sold out in 5 days
Finally, when someone tries an improvised line … give him space. Play flat chords rather than tune. But that’s not the English session way. 🙂
Finally when someone starts an improvised line … give him or her space. Play flat chords, not tune. But tfat isn’t yge English session way? 🙂
W
-
As others have said : Keep strict rhythm, and a true scale. FEEL the chords in there. Breaking a 44 scsle into 12 (ternary) is another simple but effective trick. Then … play what you hear in your head! And NEVER neglect to power of a big of a bit of SILENCE. So kften “more os less�
The rest “is†technique. The Grenoble clique do an annual week Impovisation course every February, fir some 30 years now. Brotto will definitely have been there. This year it was sold out in 5 days
Finally, when someone tries an improvised line … give him space. Play flat chords rather than tune. But that’s not the English session way. 🙂
Finally when someone starts an improvised line … give him or her space. Play flat chords, not tune. But tfat isn’t yge English session way? 🙂
W
I think you're improvising with letters here, Chris. (I'm sure it's typing on a phone). Good to see you back and commenting again. Hope you're well.
-
surely 'improvisation' is about experimentation and trial and error unfettered by theory or whatever as if there were rules it wouldn't be improvising?
A friemd who played trombone asked if he could 'sit in' at our regular ceilidh band practice to which I agreed. He asked for the written music of our tunes and I provided him with this him being classicaly trained and all that. His attempts to join in with winster gallop etc etc sounded grim to put it politely.
Not wanting to tell him to bugger off I suggested that perhaps if he just played a series of notes a bit like a double bass it would sound better. His eyes lit up and he said do you mean I can improvise , I used to be a jazz trombonist. I thought why not and we proceeded to play the Swedish masquerade. He improvised and it sounded brilliant and he became a regular band member improvising on the hoof when we played tunes he had never heard be they marches, jigs, reels, waltzes etc . his 'improvisation ' was as he put it 'just following his nose!
george
-
Great story, George. Here's one for you:
My wife has a yearly appointment with an allergist whose clinic is a 4 hour drive away. She cannot drive after treatment and can't stay in a motel or hotel because of her allergic reaction to the usual suspects...carpet cleaners, mold, air fresheners and a host of other chemicals. So I drive her both ways and take a skweezbox along to kill the 3-4 hours at the clinic.
We go in May, so Spring has sprung. I set up my travelling wooden folding chair and just play out back by a small pond surrounded by young trees. It never fails, being Spring and all, a bird will perch in the tree and sing along if I play up the dusty end. Last year it was a robin who stayed for almost an hour, the year before a cardinal. Neither bird knows the tune or reads music, but they can improvise!
I've learned a lot from them...
-
There's a "Grenoble way" to improvise, and it's based on the underlying chord "path" that lies behind a theme tune. You can play "in" chord. You can do things based on chord extensions. I'll use a friendly Em chord as exemplar
That is great for melodeon music - we generally define only tonic, and intervals 3 and 5 in our chords (eg EGB in Em). The 7th can be minor or major. You can play 9th (F#) note true, or flatten it? The 6th is a key note - b6 C is the simple minor., C# is dorian. BOTH work against Em chord. It is also great fun to mix them, to slip from C to C# (MAIN ROW notes 😉) in a bebop scale.
Play on E minor scake with a C# and D# over Em and you are improvising in melodic/jazz minor. That sounds cool,😎
or move the rhythm into ternary and …feel … totally indifferent to whether C and D are natural or sharp … gosh! You now sound like Hot Club "minor swing". There ARE rules …
Rules too about what chords work as a sequence … cadence. ii V i progression. Too hard? Is it Hell!
ii chord is F#m75b … ANY 4 touching bottons, pull, on G row
V is B7, so use accidentals, but Bm7 works too, less cadence, never mind …
Resolving to Em7, Em with a D added. That might be a different bass? Trivial on a Club box
So … futher rules, driven by "what works" Most 1950s jazz was 2/5/1 sequence driven!
Then they went modal … NOW you need a third row!
But "WTF"? The only thing that never works is to play major scale over minor chord. It is vile. Yet minor scale over a major chord … cool! Another thing to learn.
And blues scale … E G A Bb B D E works over either major or minor scale! Magic! So does C blues! More magic. You can drop,that in anywhere. The keys to success are 1. Strict rythm, and 2. Some silence to create tension. Another "rule"!
Want to play "out"? Well pentatonics based on all notes of the Em chord notes seem to work! They don't all use Em scale notes. So they move in and out of tension. Build on that (another rule)! Over the B7 turnaround … virtually anything works so long as it is structured! Experiment with D, Ab, or F(!) Major triads - amazingly they ALL work! They ALL resolve back to Em! Extraorodinary! There is a reason : They are all notes contained in the Bb diminished scale.
"Out" play without intrinsic structure? Well, you've been warned…
So yes, enjoy, the beauty lies in phrasing, pregnant silences, motifs, repetition, building tension, resolution. But the "rules" help stop you exploring a line that might go sour, or ugly.
As I say, it's all covered in the course. Even its "Blues day".
But Blues = Rules, plus "attitude" 😉
-
Link to some of the rules based stuff as per above. Isère summer course, Friday night about 3am. Zi like the fast auvergnat best. And it's ALL danceable!
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8143.msg101116.html#msg101116
-
Chris, much as there are great reasons for many people to understand what they are attempting to do, I'm not sure that the typical melodeon player wants to think like that. Apologies for pretending to know what others might think.
I suspect that for many, improvisation equates to freedom. Rules that are so detailed are more likely to be obstacles to experimentation than paths to success.
Perhaps a softer start would help.
Reading through your advice, you could distil it to say that you should try minor keys first but avoid playing the major 3rd in the right hand.
On another point, as an ex sax player I used to find the pattern based improvisation of Mike Brecker hugely impressive but ultimately predictable. The tuned based improvisation of Johnny Hodges and Paul Desmond has never left me feeling cold.
-
the two most recent posts go a long way to confirming that so called improvisation is very much ''each to his own'' some liking a theoretical model and others the ''suck and see'' method.( or should it be the 'blow, suck and see' method)
aand long may this diversity continue!
george ( a paid up member of the 'suck and see' camp)
-
Being a musical ignoramus, George's way seems best and easiest to me. In fact, a great deal of my ordinary playing contains improvisation, as I cannot always remember exactly how the real tune actually goes!
As one of the online dictionaries says, "something that is improvised, in particular a piece of music, drama, etc. created spontaneously or without preparation."
Sounds like my mess most of the time!!!
-
Chris, sorry for jumping in on your post. I'd hate you to think that I didn't value your approach and contributions.
-
in the world of folk/trad music many of the tunes we play were thought up a long long time ago and were passed on 'by ear' rather than on a sheet of paper. Even those that started off on paper have usually forked out in many directions, some arrangements, or should it be re arrangements ,deductions, additions or whatever being notated and others simply passed on 'by ear' . Others have been sort of 'accidentally' re arranged as.#, like Winston describes, the hearer of a tune cant remember all the detail of a tune he heard at eg a dance or session and fills in the missing bits with something slightly or not slightly different - yet another arrangement creeps in as somebody else hears that , forgets some of it and rearranges/ad libs etc etc ad infinitum.
Of course there are those who own up and add ''arrangement Joe bloggs'' to the notation or recording
so its all a bit like the original executioners axe 17th century axe ( that just happens to have had 3 new heads and six new handles!
but its all good fun
george
-
I have no problem with "play what you hear in your head" improvisation. Did it myself for many years. Sometimes it works fine - and in my case - sometimes quite awful. I have to say that my daughter Dolly improvises on gut feeling with much more success.
I was trying to express that there are no rules as to what you play, but there ARE rules as to what won't work.
Here are some field recordings from an Isère summer "trad" course, Friday night about 3am. #4, the fast auvergnat" bourrée is a good case in point. Fairly simple theme? the first Impo break is by an Italian bagpiper. Due to his instrument he plays "In" scale. Very nice too? Let's all note how the other players "give space" for him to do his thing. That's important too ;)
2nd break is by the obsessively experimental Norbert Pignol, and … he quickly goes "Out" of scale? But it works! Why? Because it respects the "rules" as to what doesn't work.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8143.msg101116.html#msg101116
The whole thing is danceable, right through, incidentally. My «chavallière» was a delightful parisienne pharmacist. We were both quite astonished as the musical fireworks went off, you can hear the gasps.
But we kept dancing. That's why keeping strict rhythm matters, but it also matters in simple "for listening" improvised lines.
they finish with a Maj7 C# note on the Dm chord. That's another "thing that works" An F# wouldn't 😝
Do listen to them please, they show what I mean. 🙂
-
They're pretty great clips Chris aren't they? Am listening to Outhouse Allstars' sax break in Engelska at the moment - it occurs to me that in both of these, it does seem to help to have a rock solid rhythm section when doing that. What Aurelien does, is improvise, and keep the rhythm rock solid, at the same time. All by himself. Level 10 playing.
-
Here's a bit more Rhône-Alpes festival small hours stuff then
https://youtu.be/9MADCBYCXZ8
Strict approach to rythm, and fluid use of ternary rhythm. Straightforward here as Chabenat's Impasse mazurka is already 9/8.
The riff is modal |: Em C Em C :|: G D/F# F Em :|
Scales sound … Blues (Em pentatonic with Bb passing note) and some dorian bebop? Yes, you need to practice yer scales too. Norbert often hangs the 9th of the Em scale. That's F# - yes?
And as the chord changes to C the F# becomes the #4 passing note of the C Blues scale or Characteristic note of C lydian. He can "from there" either reslove it, or stay in tension playing either C blues, or C lydian scale CDEF#GABC.
Note how Stef stops playing tune and assists, swithchingbto |: Em9 C :| chords, played "flat"
In the B music I hear … a chromatic run (echoing the bass line)? And quite a lot of D mixolydian, that's D with a C natural, ie D scale played on the G row. Not exactly rocket science?
Apart from the chromatic run, and the Bb accidental in E blues scale this ALL plays on a British standard D/G 😉 Main rows!
[edit] … Lot's of "silence" in there too? And finish on a cool note. He's picked the 9th again, F#.😎 A D (m7) would work too. Bb would feel more jazzy. Finishing on E - that ain't cool 😉
-
I have played blues guitar, largely for my own amusement, but also in jam sessions with friends, for over fifty years. Mostly 12 bar blues, an easy sequence on an 8 bass melodeon, but with many melodies I do miss the availability of accidentals for blue notes. Lately I have been playing a few Billy Holiday songs in G. If you have the usual top end accidentals on a D/G box then you should be able to play “Blue Moon†and “I’ll Be Seeing You†along with several others. Once you’ve got the feel of the notes and the intervals of the blues scale(s) you can slip them in to other tunes where they fit.