Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => News and Events => Topic started by: mikesamwild on September 05, 2009, 05:50:54 PM

Title: Folk against Fascism
Post by: mikesamwild on September 05, 2009, 05:50:54 PM
This as a new organization formed to combat the influence of the British National Party who are using traditional songs and music and performance.  Their 'Activists and Organizers Handbook' advocates celebrations like St George's Day and Pace Egging  e.g. in northen UK towns with large Muslim communities.


The first folk revival of the 1900s was quite nationalistic as was a lot of music in various countries and influence 'classical' composition, nationa identity etc.  The revival of the 50s and 60s was influenced by the Communist Party  and other left organizations as well as Irish and Scottish resistance movements and support for Civil Rights in the US , South Africa etc.


Can or should trad and folk be non political?

Will FAF be against black faced mummers and the slaying of the Saracen King?

How inclusive is the 'folk' community  I don't see too much at festivals etc apart from World Music events

www.folkagainstfascism.com
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 05, 2009, 06:22:09 PM
This as a new organization formed to combat the influence of the British National Party who are using traditional songs and music and performance.  Their 'Activists and Organizers Handbook' advocates celebrations like St George's Day and Pace Egging  e.g. in northen UK towns with large Muslim communities.

 Er -- why not? They celebrate Eed (or Diwali if hindus). Invite them to join in!

Quote
The first folk revival of the 1900s was quite nationalistic

I can't argue with that historically. (But we hadn't yet had the fun of the 14-18 War) ::)

Quote
The revival of the 50s and 60s was *influenced by the Communist Party  and other left organizations as well as Irish and Scottish resistance movements and support for Civil Rights in the US , South Africa etc. Can or should trad and folk be non political?

I've personally not sung an Irish rebel song - ever - not even a chorus - after what the IRA did to their fellow citizens. I personally think 'Folk' is intrinsically non political, but is then is made so by people with axes to grind. In the case I cite here - me.  

* Is 'highjacked' perhaps a better term?
Quote
Will FAF be against black faced mummers and the slaying of the Saracen King?

Probably - and that's one reason I won't be joining it.  Nor will I join the BNP whom I see as a bunch of numbskulls for whom politics goes little further than rearranging their predjuduces (sorry, that's the Tories) wallies whose only concept of balance is a chip on both shoulders (hmmm - the Hard Left) unreformattted skinheads  8).  

I've noticed that they only ever get elected when UK mainstream parties screw up completely.   I was in Paris for both weekends of the 2001 French Presidential election. Now that was a neo-Facist threat! There was even a website to rally the obliterated socialists - wvw.CommentVoterChirac.fr (now defunct)
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 05, 2009, 06:37:57 PM
Quote
www.folkagainstfascism.com
Just a fundraising page, no other info?
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Keithypete. on September 05, 2009, 09:53:18 PM
Will be watching this one very closely.  Who are they? Who is running the show? Just because they use the words 'Folk' & 'Against' does not mean I am throwing my weight behind this or any other campaign they might organise. Have to agree with previous comments about not joining the BNP though. However I can't agree that folk is/was/should be non-political - it's not all 'hampen shawls' or 'what a marvelous trade is the computer programmer though some people say the accountant is best'. A word of caution though: tolerate this and your children will be next. Vive la revolutione, vive la difference.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Peter Brook on September 05, 2009, 10:46:16 PM
I rather sing/play for the sake of the music for any other purpose. "People" are always trying to analyse why others act in certain ways, I rather not get into it and just enjoy the music, dance and song. Perhaps we should start a "Folk for Fun" movement?

Having said that I have dedicated my working life to promoting tolerance and understanding between people of different cultural backgrounds, and I certainly wouldn't anyone to feel that they couldn't join in. Isn't that the point of folk, it's of the people and everyone is welcome to have a go?
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on September 05, 2009, 10:54:15 PM
I've always liked the nonpolitical mood of this forum and I really hate wading into this but...I hope the folk will also be against this kind of fascism.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vEs-T-2Zi_s&feature=related

 These guys are a heck of a lot scarier,I can't believe that your gov't has allowed this kind of hatred to grow unchecked.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Jake Middleton (brinwins) on September 05, 2009, 11:19:50 PM
I've always liked the nonpolitical mood of this forum and I really hate wading into this but...I hope the folk will also be against this kind of fascism.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vEs-T-2Zi_s&feature=related

bloody hell
I rather sing/play for the sake of the music for any other purpose. "People" are always trying to analyse why others act in certain ways, I rather not get into it and just enjoy the music, dance and song.

YES! STRONGLY AGREE. I also think in todays sometimes rather boaring consumerist world strange unexplained and bizare actions (eg a bunch of blokes waving hankies about) are really a breath of fresh air just go with it!
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Jake Middleton (brinwins) on September 05, 2009, 11:22:31 PM
Can or should trad and folk be non political?

trad - traditional? traditional activities? Ive been in a Morris side 1 year now and believe quite strongly that people practicing traditional activities such a Morris/muming/mollying are in themselves non political activities (apart from molly dancers they used to go on riotous protests but not any more... to my knowledge???) but Sometimes people might assume they are, for example once a quite intelligent Friend of mine said something along the lines of "you do know that Morris groups and things like that are nests of national front/bnp people" a very strong comment which simply is not true of any Morris side I know. The sad thing is however that the man is an intelligent bloke, and although morrising/mumming wasn't attached to any bizare political agenda he believed it was! I think maybe he heard about the bnp en courageing such activities..... BOTOM LINE I think folk against fascism is a good'un and should be a decent way to prevent people sort of associating traditional activities with the far right/aggressive nationalism, raceism etc.

now I feel I must correct myself, molly dancing (and border Morris?) were quite political once. and indeed the whole blacking of the face to hide the identities of the people so they could demand the food they needed to survive in the winter is quite rebellious. They would also go on protests blacked up and wearing a dress so that their actions couldn't really be punished because a: who knew who the hell they were B: the rules in the 1700s/1800s were less harsh on women because they were believed to be irrational and moody and shouldn't really be held to account for all their actions (LOLZ!!!!!!!) This form of disguise was also practiced by Luddites who were around the same sort of time (were they ever connected i wonder?)

So some of these traditions have roots in quite protesty political issues but in todays world arent really anything to do with it...... unless someone wanted to use it as a form of protest again (a bunch of huge men in dresses with blacked up faces sounds pretty terrifying) could be quite a powerful protest tool, some protests these days can be really ineffective (poor old Brian haw)

sorry this is all rather convoluted and related in ways but not completely, I'm tired but a day of Morris dancing will do that to you. Goodnight! :M
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: jb on September 05, 2009, 11:54:54 PM
Quote
www.folkagainstfascism.com
Just a fundraising page, no other info?
The website is new and awaiting more content, I think. More can be learned about FAF by googling "folk against fascism", which hits their facebook entry, for example (http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=114616997574). Personally I'm all for it.

I hope the folk will also be against this kind of fascism.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vEs-T-2Zi_s&feature=related
These guys are a heck of a lot scarier
Certainly very scary, and arguably fascistic. But unlike the BNP they do not have any significant electoral support in the UK, or any known strategic plan to exploit/infiltrate our folk music and traditions, which is what FAF is trying to point out and oppose.

the BNP whom I see as a bunch of numbskulls for whom politics goes little further than rearranging their predjuduces (sorry, that's the Tories) wallies whose only concept of balance is a chip on both shoulders (hmmm - the Hard Left) unreformattted skinheads
But we shouldn't underestimate them as a serious and canny political force, or the damage they can do.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: JohnA on September 06, 2009, 12:23:23 AM
I'm firmly behind Folk against Fascism too. Living not so far from BNP strongholds in West Yorkshire and Lancashire some of their propaganda has dropped through my letterbox - uncomfortable reading that is hard to ignore. Knowing who support FAF I think their approach will be a sensible one.

John
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Andy Simpson on September 06, 2009, 12:25:40 AM
The very worst thing that could happen to folk is that it becomes associated in the public mind with the BNP and narrow-minded retarded nationalism alá the Daily Mail. I think it's vitally important that it is made emphatically clear that they have no place in the folk world and they and their views are not welcome at festivals, folk clubs, etc and attempting to hijack the tradition to serve their hateful, thinly-veiled racist agenda will absolutely not be allowed or tolerated.

I for one will be happy and proud to display their logo on my boxes.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: emrock on September 06, 2009, 12:28:46 AM
I think there is a very strong danger that the BNP and other fascist organisations may use folk music as a way of encouraging there racist politics, and this must be opposed. I am not involved in Folk Against Fascism but I am involved in Love Music Hate Racism, which is a campaign which fights to oppose the politics of the BNP by uniting people behind music, and folk should be included in this.

I do believe that left wing ideas have been part of folk music for many years. Not just with Martin Carthy, Billy Bragg, Woody Guthrie, Pete Seeger et al, but even before with folk music being performed by ordinary people. Folk is also very diverse and borrows from many cultures, be they African, European, Roma, Asian and this is part of what makes folk truly unique. I can't for example see the BNP (who only allow whites as members) endorsing Edward II as quickly as they have other folk bands.

I think the potential significance of Folk Against Fascism is summed up by the amount of support it has from big name folk musicians. Martin Carthy, John Boden, Paul Sartin to name a few. And they clearly feel there is a danger from the BNP. For example John Boden has for a long time displayed an Anti Nazi League sticker on his violin.

The BNP are not an ordinary political party, they are racist and fascist and if they are allowed to claim folk for the far right then folk will be done immeasurable harm.



Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: C age ing on September 06, 2009, 07:08:38 AM
Woody used to play a guitar with a "This machine kills fascist" sticker. Franco used to play a Spanish guitar with "This machine kills communists" sticker, only in Spanish. Realise that I am peculiar but I've never wanted to kill anyone, whatever their politics.

As for Chris's claim never to have sung an Irish rebel song, perhaps he should explore Anglo-Irish history and learn why those songs were written. As a Brythonic Celt I'm waiting for Owain to come down from the hills and then you will all be playing and singing Welsh songs or I might change my mind about killing.
Extremely old and Celtic Gwilym.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 06, 2009, 08:44:00 AM
I recall that Woody also supported Stalin! My personal antipathy to BNP is not that they are against that ranting muslim boy on the video. I agree that he should leave UK (the comment lower down puts it more strongly) and not be allowed back.  Rather that they aggitate against peaceful communities who have lived here peacefully for generations - but just happen to be dark skinned.

Nor do have I a problem with people using Folk as a medium. That's part of free speech here (Woody was a genius at it). But I still hold that 'Folk' is intrinsically non political.  It's what you do with it.

Another example a piece of paper. Quite neutral (unless you are a one-issue forest person). But there are newspapers in this country that I wouldn't wrap chips in!
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Selam on September 06, 2009, 09:05:44 AM
I would say that politics has always had a place in some parts of folk music. I don't mean the politics of parties etc but if you look at the subject of many traditional songs, there's a lot of political comment in there, particularly about feudal system and various rebellions. Granted that some of these were just commentary on what was happening but some are very much in support of a political movement.

However, that said, I don't think that ALL folk music is politic. The point of FAF is that they want to prevent music being politic. The BNP have begun to use 'English' folk music and folk traditions in propaganda. I know that at the moment they're not comparable, but Hitler and the Nazis did the same thing with German music. We all know how influencing music can be...

So yes, I support FAF. I don't know what it is they do exactly but I will wear my T-shirt with pride because of what it says, which I'd imagine is the point! It was great to see the musicians at Towersey festival supporting them. (Saul Rose and Simon Care both wore the T-shirts on stage, and Roy Bailey read a letter from their founders.)

Please excuse the waffly post. As a black English folkie, this subject is very important to me. Please also excuse my making the post adhere to Godwin's Law. To be honest, it was inevitable...  ;)

Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: C age ing on September 06, 2009, 10:01:40 AM
One of the problems is the definition of 'Folk'.
Does the Spinners, "The ink is black, the paper's white, together they make a beautiful sight." count? Would the BNP use it?
"The Banks are made of Marble." can only be political and very relevant.
Rabbie's "A parcel of rogues in a nation" was set to music, is political, relevant but again will the BNP use it?
Sorry to add,okay, so I lied yet another problem to this thread.
Old Bill.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Keithypete. on September 06, 2009, 10:48:05 AM


Another example a piece of paper. Quite neutral (unless you are a one-issue forest person). But there are newspapers in this country that I wouldn't wrap chips in!
The chip is mightier than the Mail!!!!
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: xgx on September 06, 2009, 10:53:35 AM
Methinks FAF is about right (as in pfaffin about)

Just how long do you reckon it will take before you are the next in line for folk against whatever ...
last man put the lights out please :P 

 ;D I did think of setting up an organisation Folk Opposing Codswallup but decided not because it wouldn't leave enough time for doing the things I like e.g. not supporting fascists [too busy getting a life!] ;D (I have to say that I never give them a thought until someone mentions them... who was it said 'there's no such thing as bad publicity  ::) )

Off to make some coffee... I do like the aroma 8) ;D ;D :P
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: John C on September 06, 2009, 11:41:00 AM
Perhaps we should have a governmental department that only allows certain music to be played by correct and accredited groups.  We could have groups of dedicated "correct" thinkers roam the country reporting any infractions to music police - just like those enlightened people in Afghanistan.

When trying to play my melodeon I prefer not to lean to the left or right as it makes staying on the chair difficult.

John




Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: jb on September 06, 2009, 11:50:54 AM
... who was it said 'there's no such thing as bad publicity
Not sure. I know it's been around a while though. Maybe John Profumo? Gerald Ratner? Jeremy Thorpe? Richard Nixon?

Perhaps we should have a governmental department that only allows certain music to be played by correct and accredited groups.  We could have groups of dedicated "correct" thinkers roam the country reporting any infractions to music police - just like those enlightened people in Afghanistan.
Nobody is suggesting excluding anyone from playing any kind of music. The point is that a small-ish political party here in the UK is seeking to exploit some folk music/events to promote racial intolerance. FAF are trying to make people aware of this and to oppose it. Is all.

I've no problem with anyone disagreeing with FAF or being indifferent to them. But it's a good idea to first take a look at what they have to say and are about (http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=114616997574).
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: xgx on September 06, 2009, 12:10:04 PM
Quote
....it's a good idea to first take a look at what they have to say and are about[/url].

Done that.... I can now see why they call themselves FAF ... 'We are anti BNP' just wouldn't have the same ring to it....

Religion and politics.... God knows how we're going to explain that to people....................... zzzzzzzzzzzzz
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Howard Jones on September 06, 2009, 12:14:41 PM
The Right is just as entitled to use music to support its cause as the Left is.  If BNP supporters wish to use songs to put over their point of view, there's nothing to stop them - whether they'd find a sympathetic audience amongst most folkies is another matter.

What FaF is objecting to is the attempts by BNP to associate all English traditional music and customs iwith its cause.  The Nazis succeeded in doing this with German folksong, which to this day remains tainted by the association.  I'm all for celebrating St George's Day - but in the right way and in a spirit of inclusiveness for everyone who considers themselves to be English, whatever their origins.

The other thing FaF objects to is that the BNP is marketing folk performers' albums through its website, implying that they support its aims - in most cases nothing could be further from the truth.  Unless the performers have retained the rights, they cannot take legal action to prevent this.  What they can do, through FaF, is to disassociate themselves, and one of the initiatives is the creation of a logo for artists to display on future albums.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: xgx on September 06, 2009, 03:57:10 PM
(...) celebrating St George's Day - but in the right way and in a spirit of inclusiveness for everyone who considers themselves to be English, whatever their origins.

Very nicely put... even the BNP could live with that ;D


I wonder if FAF and the BNP use the same formula :Hay + Male Bovine =  :-X :o
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on September 06, 2009, 04:42:42 PM
B******t? You cynic!
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Keithypete. on September 06, 2009, 08:45:26 PM
Time, me thinks, to nail ones colours to the mast. In the 1980s I was a peace campaigner at Faslane, a founder of the Aquarian peace camp at the base U.S. submarine base at Holy Loch and the Occupation site at Upper Heyford. I am 100% opposed to fascism and folk music being hijacked by such tossers. I fell out with others back then because they were Anti everything. I wasn't opposed to fox hunting - or any other form of hunting - then and I'm still not. The BNP, NF, Combat 84, et al are particularly odious and deserve no mandate whatsoever in any department. My father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists to win the freedom of speech we enjoy, and freedom generally. Sadly it is being eroded at both ends. On the right by the Fascists, and at the other extreme by Nutters who are anti everything and possess no common sense at all. This cynical BNP activity could become very boring. It's supposed to be fun isn't it?
   Put me name down.


   Re newspapers not fit to wrap chips - I don't think I'd want my saveloy staring up at me from the pages of the Daily Sport.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: emrock on September 06, 2009, 08:54:31 PM
I appreciate the feeling that folk should be apolitical, but I think this is the very reason we need support for FAF. FAF is trying to bring people together and show that folk has nothing to do with fascism and racism. Surely this is opposing folk being used for the wrong political purposes?

The BNP on the other hand seek to exclude non-whites and promote fascist ideas. Among their guests at their red, white and blue 'festival' were Eastern European Fascists who have organised pogroms against Roma, Racists such as Le Penn and a leading KKK member (who was barred from entering the country). We must not allow these people to associate themselves with folk and claim it for their own ends. This happened in Germany and the association still scars German Folk Music.



Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: xgx on September 06, 2009, 10:13:43 PM
B******t? You cynic!

Moi?

nope, just a simple realist...

(with happy memories of Ebor and Ginge awards at a certain Lincs town many moons ago :P)
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 07, 2009, 12:09:02 AM
     BNP is marketing folk performers' albums through its website ...

I barely dare ask this ....  .... Pete Coe?


Do not think so.
 After reading all these comments I  was curious enough to have a look at the BNP website!
 All I could find was an advertising banner for "Excalibur" who offer (in addition to stuff like Golliwogs and "Union Jack" money boxes) a couple of CD compilations containing stuff as diverse as Whiskey in the Jar and Curragh of Kildare. Hardly "TRUE BRIT." or a serious threat of equating Folk with facism?
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: C age ing on September 07, 2009, 07:27:00 AM

 My father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists to win the freedom of speech we enjoy, and freedom generally.
   Re newspapers not fit to wrap chips - I don't think I'd want my saveloy staring up at me from the pages of the Daily Sport.
Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that your father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists because they were conscripted? If your father and his generation fought as a member of The International Brigade in the Spanish Civil War, then it would have been voluntary and possibly postponed or prevented WW2.

As for newspapers, paper was rationed during the war and you were grateful for whatever you could wrap your fish and chips in, although most chippies insisted on you taking your own newspaper which meant rationing that which was torn up and hung in the loo.  ;D
An old, grumpy and bombed out in the Second World War Bill.

Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 07, 2009, 07:59:45 AM
Hmmm - interesting web site. I didn't find any folk stuff there but they do sell Enoch T shirts! I recall my old Grandma in Wolverhampton West constituency thinking Powell was great. Seems like any political organisation they'll do whatever they can to stimulate publicity.

I think I'll go back to opposing BNP as a concept. Full stop. I suspect all this FAF will simply give BNP publicity and credibility. In the end they need to be faced down politically, and the present general weakness across mainsteam UK politics has a lot to do with it. If the Lab/Con/LibDem/Nationalist axes were more robust these nasty parties would soon be back to having a single councillor somewhere in the Lancashire hills.  But it's the age of the sound bite.
Apologies for that chips analogy -  it seems to have started a new Movement  ???
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 07, 2009, 09:03:28 AM
Quote
I suspect all this FAF will simply give BNP publicity and credibility.
I can't help but agree with you there I'm afraid - but such as the BNP need to be oppossed in as many ways as possible.
'Evil prospers when good men (and women) do nothing'
AL
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 07, 2009, 06:37:46 PM
'Evil prospers when good men (and women) do nothing'
That is SO true! Thanks for reminding us, Al.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 07, 2009, 06:41:53 PM
A similar thread over at concertina.net has had to be closed down by the moderators because it got abusive and personal.

I am very heartened that here we are able to discuss this emotive topic sensibly and without sinking to name-calling and nastiness. It says a lot for this forum and the lovely people who post here. Well done everyone and please keep it up.  (:)



Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Theo on September 07, 2009, 07:10:29 PM
A similar thread over at concertina.net has had to be closed down by the moderators because it got abusive and personal.

I am very heartened that here we are able to discuss this emotive topic sensibly and without sinking to name-calling and nastiness. It says a lot for this forum and the lovely people who post here. Well done everyone and please keep it up.  (:)

I've had my moderators fingers crossed ever since this thread started.   8)
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Fi on September 07, 2009, 07:19:58 PM
Quote
'Evil prospers when good men (and women) do nothing'

Exactly. I spoke to one of the FAF organisers at Towersey, and as I said to her, I do feel I can't just sit about and do nothing about what's happening, especially having heard BBC Radio 4's 'The World Tonight'  coverage on the FAF launch at Sidmouth, with a contribution from the BNP. If anyone hasn't heard it it's still on the iPlayer:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00lttsp/b00ltts7/The_World_Tonight_07_08_2009/

it starts about 34.50 minutes in.  As Steve just said, it is an emotive topic, and I may have reacted to this broadcast on an emotional level -  I certainly felt really sick listening to the BNP representative, but I also felt the arrogance of the man comes across and shows them for the cynical, sly people they are.


Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: mikesamwild on September 07, 2009, 07:25:25 PM
A similar thread over at concertina.net has had to be closed down by the moderators because it got abusive and personal.

I am very heartened that here we are able to discuss this emotive topic sensibly and without sinking to name-calling and nastiness. It says a lot for this forum and the lovely people who post here. Well done everyone and please keep it up.  (:)





Steve
I don't think it was particularly abusive and I was surprised at the censorship.  The Session has a wide ranging and generally good debate
Cheers
Mike
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 07, 2009, 10:14:02 PM
Lovers of debate here will be delighted that the Mainstream Parties's negligence in letting BNP get a couple of parliamentary seats  - has qualified it to go on BBC 'Question Time'.

  http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/8240206.stm (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/8240206.stm)
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Keithypete. on September 08, 2009, 01:05:43 AM
I was very much saddened at work today to see that some of the Polish boys had engraved swastikas into their work bench. If only they knew.....

(with happy memories of Ebor and Ginge awards at a certain Lincs town many moons ago :P)
[/quote]

I am on the board of ex-Squires of that morris side; who did you/ do you dance with or play for?
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Keithypete. on September 08, 2009, 01:18:58 AM

 My father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists to win the freedom of speech we enjoy, and freedom generally.
   Re newspapers not fit to wrap chips - I don't think I'd want my saveloy staring up at me from the pages of the Daily Sport.
Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that your father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists because they were conscripted?


As far as I am aware, dad volunteered. He was decorated above and beyond the general campaign medals too. There was also a C.M.O. somewhere in the family - of whom I am equally proud. He did what he had to do.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: C age ing on September 08, 2009, 08:19:59 AM

 My father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists to win the freedom of speech we enjoy, and freedom generally.
   Re newspapers not fit to wrap chips - I don't think I'd want my saveloy staring up at me from the pages of the Daily Sport.
Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that your father and his generation fought a war against the Nazis/fascists because they were conscripted?
As far as I am aware, dad volunteered. He was decorated above and beyond the general campaign medals too. There was also a C.M.O. somewhere in the family - of whom I am equally proud. He did what he had to do.
I am sure that many who served in the various Axis Forces could say the same, suggesting that the governments lead the countries into a war position. Maybe if they had dealt with the Spanish situation, Hitler's aims might have been moderated.
We must always remember awkward facts like Margaret Hilda Thatcher classing the ANC as terrorists, yet you certainly disapproved of apartheid and thought of them as freedom fighters.
Maybe we should ask the BNP why they adopt a, to us, extreme philosophy, and then try picking at it until it gets better. Sadly it is the way of the world for extreme positions to be adopted by power seekers. My father was a conscientious objector in WW!, something to do with "Thou shall not kill". I'm proud of that.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Sebastian on September 08, 2009, 02:08:05 PM
This as a new organization formed to combat the influence of the British National Party who are using traditional songs and music and performance.
You mean, if I would be a fan of the BNP, I shouldn’t be allowed to play, sing, enjoy or listen to folk musik ("traditional songs and music an performance")?  ???
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Andy Simpson on September 08, 2009, 02:30:59 PM
Even though they're probably doing so for all the wrong reasons, there's nothing to stop BNP supporters enjoying folk. It's using traditional music to promote their repugnant political views and publicly associating it with them that FAF objects to.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: joe on September 08, 2009, 03:21:55 PM
Mind you they have to steal other's music for their use if this is the best they can do within their supporters:

http://www.myspace.com/joeysmithuk (http://www.myspace.com/joeysmithuk)

Still it made me feel a bit sick listening to the R4 programme, I despise the BNP and everything they stand for. The BNP rep sounded like a right ****(choose sexual organ), more childish and idiotic than sly and cynical.

Supporting a legitimate party that opposes mass immigration is one thing, supporting a party with lightly veiled, extremely racist policies is quite another. Supporting the BNP doesnt say much about what your political views are, it says a lot more about what kind of person you are.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: xgx on September 08, 2009, 04:39:29 PM
Good lord!  those fools want to take us out of Europe too!!!!

That is beyond the pale.....
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: an bosca ceoil on September 08, 2009, 04:42:24 PM
Even though they're probably doing so for all the wrong reasons, there's nothing to stop BNP supporters enjoying folk.

Cannot help thinking that this assumption smacks of bigotry - even fascists do not need a reason to enjoy a particular type of music other than Horst Wessel.
Considering the impression that most of their spokespeople give, you can hardly blame the BNP for grasping at anything that conveys the impression that they are halfway moderate/normal/intelligent.
I sympathise with performers who, having taken the Kings Shilling and made their work commercially available, are now dismayed that the general public may get the impression that they endorse the less savoury aspects of one of their customers.
If they feel the need to take a leaf out of the breweries book and label their products as "Only to be enjoyed in moderation/ by moderates" fair enough but I do not think their gripe warranted founding a quasi political  organisation, whose main current concern seems to be trawling for any songs that could be construed as anti - BNP
As someone said earlier, there is no such thing as bad publicity - but for the mention of FAF I doubt that these pages would have carried a link to a BNP sympathisers site!
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Andy Simpson on September 08, 2009, 08:23:45 PM
Cannot help thinking that this assumption smacks of bigotry - even fascists do not need a reason to enjoy a particular type of music other than Horst Wessel.


A few years ago I had the misfortune of seeing a documentary about a man who'd started his own private school, a living Little Englander stereotype, (ironically, he had to do it in France), that the Daily Mail's more bigoted readers would probably think was a bit too much. He was trying to turn back time to his imagined ideal embodiment of "British tradition" and Morris dancing was part of this curriculum, it was obvious what part of his psyche his enthusiasm for it was from.

Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 09, 2009, 08:44:45 AM


... I'm still trying to wrap my brain round the concept of taking up Morris dancing
  ... in order to appear moderate, normal or intelligent  ??? 
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: Howard Jones on September 09, 2009, 11:24:05 AM
[I do not think their gripe warranted founding a quasi political  organisation, whose main current concern seems to be trawling for any songs that could be construed as anti - BNP
Where did you get that from?  The main focus of FaF, so far as I can tell, is firstly to raise awareness so that folkies can watch out for attempts by the BNP to infiltrate their activities, and secondly to discourage the BNP from selling albums and thereby implying that the artists support their aims.

Individuals may be performing songs in this vein, but I don't think that's what FaF is about.

As for taking the the Kings Shilling and making their work commercially available, that is what professional musicians do and part of how they make a living.  Have you never bought an album?  The problem is that they have no control over the distribution and cannot stop the BNP from marketing their albums, so they need some other way of distancing themselves from it.
Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: xgx on September 09, 2009, 11:41:38 AM
Can we be sure that FAF is not a publicity arm of the National Nasties... if it is.... it's working extremely well ;D

Tip of the Day:

Learn to recognise a dead horse!

 :P ;D :P ;D :-*

Title: Re: Folk against Fascism
Post by: EeeJay on September 09, 2009, 10:35:15 PM
So many ideologies, dogmas and ideas seem to be wrapped up in that single word. I think old Eric Blair said a lot here (http://www.orwell.ru/library/articles/As_I_Please/english/efasc)...

However, use of the word might be a good thing. I personally think it manifests itself in many shades of nasty people. Extremism may be a more concise description, but for shaking people into action, the f-word is blunter.

If it's an attempt to protect intellectual property, then I'm all for it.

However, just so long as the movement avoids closing ranks with those who, in my eyes, are just as abominable as those the movement claims to be against. I have absolutely no truck with the bastard spawn of Mosley, the quasi-respect of Galloway, belligerent Caliphatism, or other such bankrupt ideas.

BNP... Half the time I get the vague inkling of an establishment sockpuppet... a safety valve to vent the spleen of the disgusted frothing at the mouth letter/blog writing types, and keep tabs on them and their even nuttier associates. A particular German right wing group was recently threatened with proscription... until it subsequently came to light it was largely full of deep undercover police on surveillance ops!

I fell out with others back then because they were Anti everything. I wasn't opposed to fox hunting - or any other form of hunting - then and I'm still not.

Interesting that hunting analogy... remember, the RSPCA were a staunchly pro-hunting organisation - until the anti brigade made a concerted effort at infiltration. Which in itself shows just how well infiltration works if you've a mind to it... which is slightly disconcerting...

I've just been revisiting Alan Bleasdale's drama, GBH... which reinforces my long held notion that a lot of what goes on politically in this country is like an iceberg... so much is hidden underneath... and half the stuff we think we know is wrong (cut to 2:20 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHBmpb9ajgM))...

There's a brilliant little speech (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gwjRqpwQLo) by Michael Palin... takes the same rhetoric as Billy Connoly's spleen venting rant (at 3:05 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IwooM4yhiiY))... about never trusting anyone who reads one book... be that Mein Kampf, Das Kapital, the Koran, Ladybirds (http://www.flickr.com/photos/johnbullas/3770105550/sizes/o/)...

Ed J
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal