Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on February 21, 2019, 10:51:05 PM
-
I have recently acquired a one-row, 4-stop instrument that was handmade in Quebec. From what I understand it is an earlier model, with the maker's current boxes having come a long way since then. It's a fun, little box with a lovely sound, but very quiet. I am not sure yet if this is something I'll keep or if I'll fix it up a bit and then pass it along.
I can see that someone has done a bit of work on it in the past, having sealed up some obvious air leaks. The construction of the box is admittedly a bit rough in a few places. Two of the blocks are removable (which is quite unusual for a box like this made in Quebec), but they only fasten down on one side, leaving the other end floating unsecured. As a result, it's not a particularly good seal. A couple of temporarily placed shims had the blocks fastened down more securely. This made a noticeable difference in the tuning, but surprisingly did nothing for volume.
I'm attaching a few photos to illustrate the design of the reedblocks and sliders. I've noticed there is no gasket on either the block or the inside of the box. I considered adding a gasket, however my concern then is that the sliders will simply fall down (as they are held in place with the fastened-down block) or that there will audible leaks from one reed to the next. Considering that putting the shim in made no difference in volume, would there be any benefit to actually having some kind of gasket?
The box has handmade (or near enough) Salpa reeds which I believe are of good quality. I'm curious why one box, such as this, would be so quiet when another of rather similar design might be noticeably stronger/louder?
Any ideas on how this box might be improved before it ends up wherever it's going are most welcome!
-
More photos:
-
The stops look a lot like the ones on Sagné models :D
-
Same stops on its close relative ;)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Gagne-Accordion-1-Row-2-Bass-10-Treble-Button-D-Handcrafted-Diatonic-Accordion/323700097250?hash=item4b5e0780e2
Are the holes in the fondo round? I wonder if that could be increased to match the air flow from reed block. Note: air hole seems large in the block and slide. Can you make this hole to big?
I see what you mean when you say rough in places.
-
The stops look a lot like the ones on Sagné models :D
;)
-
Same stops on its close relative ;)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Gagne-Accordion-1-Row-2-Bass-10-Treble-Button-D-Handcrafted-Diatonic-Accordion/323700097250?hash=item4b5e0780e2
The box in that link is actually a Sag’ne and not a Gagne. It is incorrectly listed on eBay. The confusion might arise from the fact that the box builder is Marcel Desgagne (which they have correctly listed)
Are the holes in the fondo round? I wonder if that could be increased to match the air flow from reed block. Note: air hole seems large in the block and slide. Can you make this hole to big?
I see what you mean when you say rough in places.
The holes in the fondo are round(ish), and match the size of the holes in the slides. They would both have to be increased in size to make any difference in volume, but doing so would result in the slides failing to properly close off the holes in the down position.
-
Same stops on its close relative ;)
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Gagne-Accordion-1-Row-2-Bass-10-Treble-Button-D-Handcrafted-Diatonic-Accordion/323700097250?hash=item4b5e0780e2
The box in that link is actually a Sag’ne and not a Gagne. It is incorrectly listed on eBay. The confusion might arise from the fact that the box builder is Marcel Desgagne (which they have correctly listed)
yep, I knew it was a Sag'ne that's why I winky faced ;) probabaly should have added a tongue sticking out :P
-
I knew that... ::) The little emoticon faces don’t show up too clearly on an iPhone...
-
I'm attaching a few photos to illustrate the design of the reedblocks and sliders. I've noticed there is no gasket on either the block or the inside of the box. I considered adding a gasket, however my concern then is that the sliders will simply fall down (as they are held in place with the fastened-down block) or that there will audible leaks from one reed to the next. Considering that putting the shim in made no difference in volume, would there be any benefit to actually having some kind of gasket?
My guess is the gasket would only help seal and not improve on the volume.
You could gasket the fondo so the slides would stay in the same alignment within the block but then you would have to adjust the slide to stop block to bring it back into position. Might be more trouble than it’s worth?
How does the row that is mounted flat sound compare to the others?
One thing I see ( or think I see) is the depth of chamber ( stand up blocks) appears deep, I think that could have an effect on volume.
-
I agree, boxcall, that’s it’s probably not worth the effort. I was looking to see if there were ways to improve the box before passing it along. I gave it a tuning and replaced some wonky valves, and will sell it as is. The keyboard has a nice touch to it and the box a nice tone. I was considering keeping it as a second D box but I have a hard time holding onto instruments that don’t get regular play.
I’m not sure what you mean by deep reed chambers. The chamber height is just tall enough to fit the reedplate, and wide enough at the base for there to be the appropriately sized sound hole. Not sure how this could have been done differently?
-
After looking more carefully at the second lot of pictures; is boxcall referring to the top of the reed chamber being too deep, at the reed tip behind the reedplate?
Probably not, but the block does look a little wider than normal, and you'll have seen the highest reed chambers which have been tapered more towards the reed tip by adding filler or wax, or something else. I suspect that is to increase the volume of those tiny reeds.
(Mind you, I've really no idea of what I'm rabbiting on about!)
-
I’m not sure what you mean by deep reed chambers. The chamber height is just tall enough to fit the reedplate, and wide enough at the base for there to be the appropriately sized sound hole. Not sure how this could have been done differently?
I meant the space below the reed, the width and length of chamber being determined by the reed plate and the depth being variable under it. As Winston said sometimes top being filled in.
Most of the 4 stop slide setups are not slotted into the reed block and I was wondering, if by doing so the reed chamber is deeper than others. May not matter so much for volume ( I think) but must for pressure. What’s the depth? And is it the same as the reeds laying down.
You could always try varnish!! ;)