Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on March 08, 2019, 07:43:50 AM

Title: wax fumes
Post by: mselic on March 08, 2019, 07:43:50 AM
I wear a respirator when working with wax, but I still notice that I feel somewhat nauseous after doing it for a while.  I don't smell it while working with it, but obviously the fumes are still getting through to me, despite my respirator being rated for both vapours and fine particles.  I also keep the wax from smoking visibly.  I need some suggestions, because I can't keep doing it like this.  I seem to be sensitive to even short-term exposure to wax fumes.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Rog on March 08, 2019, 08:08:04 AM
I use a Carini supplied wax heater and sometimes have it on all day, with a low temp setting, so no smoking wax at all. You can smell the wax a bit, though not noticeably, so I don’t think it’s actually releasing fumes. I used to heat the stuff in a heavy saucepan on an electric ring, and then you could feel it getting into your lungs in a most unpleasant way, so it wasn’t safe or desirable. I tried a cheap cosmetic wax heater but could never get the right temperature and quite quickly the switch underneath the pot waxed up and the unit stopped working. I even tried for a short (and frankly scary) time heating wax in little pot in a gas stove, but this was even more undesirable, smoky and a fire hazard. I think a few people on here uses a soldering iron and wax sticks, which minimises the time wax is in a melted state, but personally I don’t get on with this method. I have an extractor fan unit, but this was awkward to use. I think Rees actually uses a fume cabinet, which perhaps is the way to go. For me the purpose made wax heater from Carini works very well, though it’s isnt cheap.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: rees on March 08, 2019, 09:11:47 AM
Yes, I built a wooden box about 65cm on all sides. It has a light inside and a socket for my waxing iron. At the top is a 10cm flexible tube feeding to a bathroom extractor fan in the outside wall.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Theo on March 08, 2019, 09:42:00 AM
I have a commercial fume extractor. It’s basically a fan in a box with a flexible tube so you can position the inlet directly above the work.  I got this after wax fumes cause me to have asthma. I’d never had asthma before. I was on medication for months.  After getting the fume extractor the symptoms eventually disappeared.

I only discovered the link between the fumes and asthma after a chance conversion with a GP friend who does some occupational medicine.  He told me that the biggest occupational cause of asthma is exposure to fumes from rosin used as a flux in the electronics industry.

You do not want to give yourself asthma, so if the respirator is not working get something that does work without delay.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on March 08, 2019, 10:12:01 AM
Has anybody tried the Wachsboy system, where only a small amount of wax is heated in an enclosed reservoir, which has a nozzle for application of the wax?  I have been tempted by them ever since I first saw one, but they aren't cheap.

Sir John
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Rog on March 08, 2019, 10:22:32 AM
Looking at the pix of the Wachsboy I’d say yes, I’ve tried it or something similar... and I couldn’t get it to work. It looks like a tjanting tool. I bought such a one, with the bulb like reservoir attached to a soldering iron (they cost a fraction of the wachsboy). The tube clogs up very easily when it cools and it's very difficult to get the wax to go anywhere near where you want it. You can’t get it to flow etc. I got the idea from Paul Flannery who uses one. He mixes paraffin wax and bees wax together in equal number of pellets and then holds his tjanting tool over a burner (with extinguisher nearby) and then sort of pours it over the reeds, with them layed out on the block and supported on a stand. The wax mixture he uses flows much better than Italian style reed wax, and this method only works in fair weather conditions. I tried it and failed. But others may like it. ...LOL...I’ve tried all sorts of ways to wax...LOL. The tjanting tool was the most disappointing.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on March 08, 2019, 10:29:01 AM
The Wachsboy is maintained at the heat you select, so shouldn't suffer so much from clogging up. I have read about the Tjanting tool on here, and seen it at work on a video, and I'm not surprised it is a struggle to use for reed waxing.
SJ
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Broadland Boy on March 08, 2019, 01:10:04 PM
The other option is to use a positive pressure air fed mask, air supplied by hose from well away from fume area a by fan in sufficient volume to ensure fume laden air is kept at bay (something relatively loose fitting over nose & mouth, doesn't need to be sealed like a divers mask) I find this less restricting and awkward than the full face Airflow masks used for dusty processes like sanding / grinding / blast cleaning as I wear specs.

As Theo notes, the sensitisation that this sort of fume triggers does not always depart when exposure is stopped - sometimes makes tracing the cause difficult but resin / colophony is one of the best known causes.

Then there is the psychological desensitisation approach, keep thinking 'If I can't cure this I will end up having to play banjo'   >:E
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: mselic on March 08, 2019, 02:57:10 PM
Theo, would you be willing share a photo of what your commercial fine extractor entails? Rees, I’m also curious to see what you’re describing. Thank you all so far for your replies.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on March 08, 2019, 04:17:51 PM
Was looking for Air Flow face masks, horrendously expensive, when I came across this. Interesting?

SJ

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Fresh-Air-Supply-Smart-Electric-Face-Mask-Air-Purifying-N95-Anti-Dust-Pollution/264141878216?hash=item3d801533c8:g:75wAAOSwpLdcQUeg
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: boxcall on March 08, 2019, 04:47:27 PM
Was looking for Air Flow face masks, horrendously expensive, when I came across this. Interesting?

SJ

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Fresh-Air-Supply-Smart-Electric-Face-Mask-Air-Purifying-N95-Anti-Dust-Pollution/264141878216?hash=item3d801533c8:g:75wAAOSwpLdcQUeg


“
Specifications:
Material: The mask uses filter elements of N95 grade and high quality polyester, soft silica gel of food grade ensure no exotics and no damage and comfortable wear.
Color: Black
Size: Electric masks

Notes:
1.The real color of the item may be slightly different from the pictures shown on website caused by many factors such as brightness of your monitor and light brightness.
2.Please allow slight deviation for the measurement data.
3.Thanks for your understanding.
Fresh Air Supply Smart Electric Mask Air Purifying Mask N95 Anti Dust Pollution for Running,Cycling and other outdoor activities
Advantages: Electric intelligent air purifying technology, produce air with high effectivity and actively deliver fresh air; HEPA 99% strong filtering effect of medical grade; Right inlet and left outlet make sure air in and out orderly, effectively cycling.
Unique Design: Fit face in 3D and keep good sealing; It has large space within mask for air cycling.
Power: Built-in 500mA safety li-battery can work for 4-6 hours. Charging time only need about 30 minutes. Battery life have 3 years at least.
Protection against gases, smells, all PM; PM2.5, PM0.3, pollen, second smoke and pathogens such as viruses and bacteria.
It can be used for Running / Travel / Dust / Air Pollution / Motorcycle / Sport.
Package included:
1*Electric Face Mask “


Says medical grade that may not be enough, it does say protection from gases but how much?

I like this part
“It can be used for Running / Travel / Dust / Air Pollution / Motorcycle / Sport.”

If your crazy enough to get on a motorcycle you probably won’t care about it anyway >:E

Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: mselic on March 08, 2019, 05:13:54 PM
Was looking for Air Flow face masks, horrendously expensive, when I came across this. Interesting?

SJ

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Fresh-Air-Supply-Smart-Electric-Face-Mask-Air-Purifying-N95-Anti-Dust-Pollution/264141878216?hash=item3d801533c8:g:75wAAOSwpLdcQUeg

The one that I use is similar but rated higher:

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?cat=1,42207,43647&p=74167

Even with the mask, the room I’m working in will still fill with fumes, which would become an issue afterwards. I want to avoid having any contact with potential fumes. I’ve had some lung sensitivities in the past, and I can’t afford to mess about with this. The Carini wax pot sounds interesting, but I’m concerned about the points I just mentioned.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on March 08, 2019, 05:26:38 PM
Even with the mask, the room I’m working in will still fill with fumes, which would become an issue afterwards. I want to avoid having any contact with potential fumes. I’ve had some lung sensitivities in the past, and I can’t afford to mess about with this. ...
In that case, you definitely need to consider something with a higher technical spec than just a mask, no matter how sophisticated the mask is.
You need a device which will stop you breathing wax and derivative vapour which will be on a molecular scale, not just particulates. A proper fume extraction system such as Theo describes is pretty much essential for you. It will actually remove the fumes from the room as well as the point source where the waxing of the reed plates is occuring.

It may be a bit expensive or awkward to install (or both), but you need to weigh that up against your health. If you don't want, or can't afford, to undertake this degree of protection, it's probably best to leave the waxing to someone else who (a) has suitable gear and/or (b) is less sensitive to the fumes.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on March 08, 2019, 05:32:56 PM
This seemed a reasonable price, but it doesn't appear to be vented to the outside, which I would prefer.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/3D-Printer-Air-Purification-Scrub-Cabinet-Fume-Hood-Enclosure-by-Makergadgets/173658100958?hash=item286ed454de:g:2toAAOSwl1FcUmHy

SJ
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: boxcall on March 08, 2019, 07:59:52 PM
this might do ?
Weller company for soldering fumes, they have a couple of models for less than 2 bills.

https://www.verical.com/pd/apex-tool-group-hand-tools---accessories-ft91000037n-5037377?gclid=CjwKCAiAwojkBRBbEiwAeRcJZBZ3Ico0eqqRk_dCve285c2apVjNwOK6kqu_1TERgt8DQbi9XIK3-xoCP3cQAvD_BwE
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: playandteach on March 08, 2019, 10:50:19 PM
As someone who has made bad choices in the past, and suffered long term reactions since, don't find a cheap answer. Find the best answer or don't do it.
If Theo's solution is not within your reach, then take a breather from waxing until it is. I know this sounds like advice from someone who is inexperienced - I only waxed one accordion, and that was laughable - but I have had to stop playing for periods (not to mention avoid cedar reedblocks and perfumed woods because my lungs are now so sensitive - as a result of messing around with rosewood).
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: mselic on March 09, 2019, 01:58:45 AM
I do take this seriously and my intention is to find a proper solution, not a cheap one. So far, a commercial fume extractor sounds like the best choice. However, I’m still not sure what I’m picturing when it comes to Theo and Reese’s solutions..
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Winston Smith on March 09, 2019, 07:49:19 AM
I'm really quite horrified at these tales of woe, regarding the effects of inhaling fumes/smoke/whatever from overheated wax. And I'm astonished that the effects should be so severe and long lasting, too.
My own experience, so far, has been that, although I've noticed the odd plume of smoke from the end of my soldering iron, I've hardly noticed any smell or discernable difference in what I'm breathing in. (It may well be that the nasties contained in the smoke are like asbestos filaments, and not noticed?) Mind you, I was a heavy smoker for 50 years, and spent most of my working life in a haze of diesel engine exhaust fumes!
I would have thought that an open tube, of reasonable diameter, positioned very close to the small actual working area (maybe a couple of inches above and behind?) and fed to an extractor fan (as per Rees) would have been quite sufficient to remove any noxious particles from the scene.
However, I cannot imagine what effect these eventual emissions into the open atmosphere will have on the man-made element of global warming, or on the environment in general. Perhaps the producers of accordions, or of the wax itself, should be paying some sort of pollution tax, as long as it's not the end-user, eh?
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: rees on March 09, 2019, 11:05:33 AM
I'd love to post a picture but even though my pic is only 159kb and the limit is 400kb it still won't let me upload!!!
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 09, 2019, 12:00:06 PM
Steve's right, invest in an extractor of some sort.
Once sensitized you will suffer long term so the trick is to *not* get sensitized by investing in whatever extractor system suits your circumstances and pocket.
Q
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: boxcall on March 09, 2019, 12:00:29 PM
I just would add the link I provided was just a starting point model the company Weller sells the $1000 plus models also and they are for the type of fumes you want to extract and are industrial.
There are others of course.
I did my waxing with a table set up in front of a window with a small two way box fan set up in it drawing the air out, it work pretty well. Would have been better if it wasn’t winter time ;)
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: tirpous on March 09, 2019, 04:13:18 PM
Quote
Yes, I built a wooden box about 65cm on all sides. It has a light inside and a socket for my waxing iron. At the top is a 10cm flexible tube feeding to a bathroom extractor fan in the outside wall.

Just an idea: something similar could be cobbled up using an old range hood as the lid of the box.  These things usually have light and variable speed fan built-in.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on March 09, 2019, 04:25:40 PM
Good thinking, a new one is cheap enough. Just fasten it on top of a suitable box, connect to the power, and add ducting to take it outside.



https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/ESSENTIALS-C60SHDX17-Visor-Cooker-Hood-Stainless-Steel-Currys/132303396102?epid=2196513558&hash=item1ecde59d06:g:4lAAAOSw2sxcPvqr


Sir John
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: diatonix on March 09, 2019, 04:52:51 PM
In order to avoid possibly hazardous fumes: Do NOT use soldering irons, at least not for time consuming jobs such as rewaxing whole instruments. Get yourself a melting pot (with a heat regulator), place it under some kind of extractor fan ( the one placed over a kitchen stove will do just fine) and use either a German type wax spoon or its Italian equivalent, the spatula.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Winston Smith on March 09, 2019, 05:47:14 PM
I'm still reading this thread with fascination.

It's all very well recommending this extractor, or that fan box or whatever; to folk who can easily afford to buy them. It becomes a different kettle of fish when you're suggesting such expenditure to those of us who become amateur repairers mainly because of our financial inadequacies.
If I could afford it, I'd try to have Mr Theo as my personal fettler, and then I wouldn't have to risk my health with hot wax fumes. But I cannot, so I have to make do and mend, using a soldering iron which I already had to hand. I'd thought of borrowing my Number One Daughter's wax melting pot, which she uses in her shop, just to give that a try! But maybe she wouldn't like to get it back stinking of burnt waxy resin etc.
My waxing is done in relatively short spurts, so I'm never exposed to any fumes for very long, and I'm careful enough to not cause it to smoke except when a momentary lack of concentration occurs. But I'm convinced that a simple extraction device which draws the air from very close to the workpiece, would be protection enough for most waxers, without spending hundreds of pounds and taking up half of our workshop space!
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: mory on March 09, 2019, 05:52:41 PM
You can always open the window, door or otherwise, bit of through draft never hurt anyone, well maybe a crick in the  kneck when it's cold. AtB mory
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Kimric Smythe on March 09, 2019, 06:28:27 PM
Invested in a small room air filter for the workroom last fall since the California fires last fall were so bad that the local air quality was worse than Bjeing and everyones eyes were burning (over 400). I now leave it on low all the time in the work room when we are working since it does a great job of dealing with rosin/wax smoke.
The little one I got was about $65.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Broadland Boy on March 09, 2019, 06:58:47 PM
Have you got a nearby scrapyard or recyclers taking in domestic or commercial stuff rather than just cars ? if so just about all commercial electrical drive systems - servo's or variable speed stuff need to shed a lot of heat so generally have large finned ali heat sinks and axial fans to pass large amounts of air over them, a fan ought to cost next to nothing, you can make a duct for it (like the old 2 gallon can funnels) from cardboard box material and duct tape into a booth, sides made from stripwood with pvc sheet stapled to it (opened out carrier bags) the outfall from the fan can be made using that collapsible convoluted (?) ducting for clothes driers to a suitable window, door, catflap. Not much difference to a jury rigged spray painting booth but smaller and can be made to knock down so the space is not wasted.

Oh, a lot of such fans are 110 volts (US heritage) not a problem, if you can find two the same current rating, run them in series.

Some domestic radiators also feature a fan as do kitchen extractors, all frequently scrapped long before their life has expired in this world of constant remodelling of residences...

HTH
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: boxcall on March 09, 2019, 08:20:30 PM
In order to avoid possibly hazardous fumes: Do NOT use soldering irons, at least not for time consuming jobs such as rewaxing whole instruments. Get yourself a melting pot (with a heat regulator), place it under some kind of extractor fan ( the one placed over a kitchen stove will do just fine) and use either a German type wax spoon or its Italian equivalent, the spatula.
Of course listen to experience!, but if you must use soldering iron it might not be a bad idea to have a rag on hand to wipe the tip between use, I found it smoked more after it was removed from the work when there was just what was remaining on the tip of the iron.  So wiping helped to cut down on it.
I only use it for touch up, did the bulk with a spoon but I need practice.
I like that the spoon could give you a good amount of wax at once, bit of a curse to the inexperienced though.
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: mselic on March 09, 2019, 09:00:15 PM
Quote
Yes, I built a wooden box about 65cm on all sides. It has a light inside and a socket for my waxing iron. At the top is a 10cm flexible tube feeding to a bathroom extractor fan in the outside wall.

Just an idea: something similar could be cobbled up using an old range hood as the lid of the box.  These things usually have light and variable speed fan built-in.

That’s a good idea!
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Peadar on March 09, 2019, 11:35:39 PM
Winston mentions No.1 daughter's waxing pot....No.1 daughter's old PC might be a better bet- there will be a low voltage fan and just as important a power pack (aka transformer) in the casing.

 I will be scrapping a couple of old PC's in the next few weeks-I will be happy enough to salvage the fans for anyone willing to pay for a jiffy bag and a stamp.

Peadar
Title: Re: wax fumes
Post by: Squeaky Pete on March 09, 2019, 11:56:21 PM
Use Freecycle if you want to do it on the cheap. Just ask for a scrap extractor fan. It might be in a hood or expelair or an inline fan. I used a scrap hood mounted in the roof to keep down the dust in my workshop.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal