Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: Clive Williams on April 01, 2019, 08:52:32 AM
-
After a somewhat dodgy electoral procedure, this months winner is the Dorset Four Hand Reel.
Fortunately for me, Lester has already been there, seen that, done that, got the t-shirt, recorded the video and posted the ABC here:
https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/2012/10/tune-33-dorset-four-hand-reel-i-i-can.html
A nice straightforward tune that is useful to have in your repertoire for sessions; what can you do with it?
Cheers,
Clive
-
I confess. It were me wot knocked down the Kazi. Didn't realise Clive was sat in it ;D
-
;D
-
Recorded back in January at Whittlesea Straw Bear this is me playing for C&E. The set of tunes is Dorset Four Hand Reel, Portsmouth (in D) and Bonny Kate.
https://youtu.be/BIF3I1DYcAI
-
Fortunately for me, Lester has already been there, seen that, done that, got the t-shirt, recorded the video and posted the ABC here:
https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/2012/10/tune-33-dorset-four-hand-reel-i-i-can.html (https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/2012/10/tune-33-dorset-four-hand-reel-i-i-can.html)
But he is playing it in C on a G/C box 8)
-
That's why I couldn't join in ;)
SJ
-
Just to help further here is the Dorset Four Hand Reel/Jig/Waltz in F (https://youtu.be/8IwK3jhUu3E)
-
Played on my Loffet Graet e Breizh D/G in Dmaj
https://soundcloud.com/laubblaeser/dorset-four-hand-reel-take-2
Slow and steady so that people can listen and play along (if they want to, at least).
-
And another one. This time in a feeling somewhat reminiscent of an air.
https://soundcloud.com/laubblaeser/dorset-four-hand-air
Played on my Loffet Graet e Breizh D/G in Gmaj
-
Had a good chuckle at the record turnaround from ‘I think I’ll sit this one out’ to first out of the gate with new recording.
The air version is a good reminder that when a tune doesn’t inspire, to turn it into something that will. I keep forgetting that.
-
Had a good chuckle at the record turnaround from ‘I think I’ll sit this one out’ to first out of the gate with new recording.
The air version is a good reminder that when a tune doesn’t inspire, to turn it into something that will. I keep forgetting that.
Heh. Well, I said I was contemplating on skipping this month's tune. Decided to go for a quick recording to get it out of my head.
-
And another one. This time in a feeling somewhat reminiscent of an air.
https://soundcloud.com/laubblaeser/dorset-four-hand-air
Played on my Loffet Graet e Breizh D/G in Gmaj
Very nicely done, too.
Just because a tune seems straightforward doesn't mean you have to deliver a simple interpretation. I suspect it might turn into a great 3/2 hornpipe, or, possibly, a mazurka. Clive is a master of that art.
-
Recorded back in January at Whittlesea Straw Bear this is me playing for C&E. The set of tunes is Dorset Four Hand Reel, Portsmouth (in D) and Bonny Kate.
https://youtu.be/BIF3I1DYcAI
Nicely played and very tidy stepping. Only what I would have expected of C&E. I'm sure I saw you somewhere last year, but I'm not sure where. Did you do the Wrecker's DoD?
-
Recorded back in January at Whittlesea Straw Bear this is me playing for C&E. The set of tunes is Dorset Four Hand Reel, Portsmouth (in D) and Bonny Kate.
https://youtu.be/BIF3I1DYcAI
Nicely played and very tidy stepping. Only what I would have expected of C&E. I'm sure I saw you somewhere last year, but I'm not sure where. Did you do the Wrecker's DoD?
Thank you :-) thinking back to last year, I didn't do any South West gigs - bloodstone, Evesham and Shrewsbury were the main ones i did. The other events would have been Jim or naglis. I'm sure our paths will cross at some stage!
-
A nice straightforward tune that is useful to have in your repertoire for sessions; what can you do with it?
In my case? Try to learn it.
-
Played on my Loffet Graet e Breizh D/G in Dmaj
https://soundcloud.com/laubblaeser/dorset-four-hand-reel-take-2
Nicely done, and box sounds great. I hope people aren't offended when I comment on the quality of their box, I've heard great boxes sound terrible in the wrong hands, so there is a compliment in there somewhere.
-
Apologies for lateness on parade
https://youtu.be/8Q3zsLQSK5Y
in the key of Suffolk
All the best
Bill
-
Apologies for lateness on parade
https://youtu.be/8Q3zsLQSK5Y
in the key of Suffolk
Really liked all the places you took the tune! Well done.
-
Apologies for lateness on parade
https://youtu.be/8Q3zsLQSK5Y
in the key of Suffolk
All the best
Bill
Ah that was definitely very enjoyable, thanks for posting this. (:)
-
Apologies for lateness on parade
https://youtu.be/8Q3zsLQSK5Y
in the key of Suffolk
All the best
Bill
Super. You been playing this tune for long?
-
And another one. This time in a feeling somewhat reminiscent of an air.
https://soundcloud.com/laubblaeser/dorset-four-hand-air
Played on my Loffet Graet e Breizh D/G in Gmaj
I like that better than the vanilla presentation. Have you tried the jig. It works great if you get the cross rowing sorted out.
[apologies to those who believe a tune is a tune is a tune and evermore should be so. I love the playing around game with tunes can can cope with it.]
-
And another one. This time in a feeling somewhat reminiscent of an air.
https://soundcloud.com/laubblaeser/dorset-four-hand-air
Played on my Loffet Graet e Breizh D/G in Gmaj
I like that better than the vanilla presentation. Have you tried the jig. It works great if you get the cross rowing sorted out.
[apologies to those who believe a tune is a tune is a tune and evermore should be so. I love the playing around game with tunes can can cope with it.]
Not quite sure what you mean? If you're referring to Lester's jig approach (second in his video of three variants), then I don't quite see where there's any cross rowing to be done.
-
https://youtu.be/8Q3zsLQSK5Y
in the key of Suffolk
Bill, that's great! (And gives me many ideas for my own recently acquired 4 stop in C.) The breaks in G mixolydian are :|glug ! 8)
-
Have you tried the jig. t works great if you get the cross rowing sorted out.
Not quite sure what you mean? If you're referring to Lester's jig approach (second in his video of three variants), then I don't quite see where there's any cross rowing to be done.
Sorry, I didn't realise that Lester (or anyone else) had a jig version. I was thinking of what came out when I played around with it. I found myself doing a lot of cross rowing in the B part.
Edit: Ah, found it. Didn't realise there was more than one setting there. Nicely done Lester, but not what happened when I did it. I was going to practice it a bit but I might just try and get a chance to record it. I only have a brief window of opportunity for playing in the morning, while my wife takes the dogs out.
-
Just a quick thank you for some wonderfully positive feedback. (I don't understand how to use "" etc).
THis is a tune which I played for dance back in the day, (at least three decades BitD!) Not in the current playlist but not forgotten.
The idea for the key change 'bridge' came from the 'Mardi Gras' tune which employs a similar device.
The two versions of the tune are in the Community Dance Manuals (in G and A) to fit the dance.
Loquacious for me but hopefully answers the points raised.
THank you again.
Bill
-
Have you tried the jig. It works great if you get the cross rowing sorted out.
As an absolute beginner, listening only to the Soundcloud version in D, and not having patience for reading dots of any sort, I am totally enjoying the cross rowing bits in both the A and B parts, which to me seem needed in order to get the chords on I want on the left hand.
Im playing about a third of it cross row.
So I just went back and listened to Lester's version on the C/F, and see the difference... he's playing it on the inner row, and it sounds quite different as a one row tune. Melodeon is a very cool instrument!
At the moment I kind of prefer the way it sounds as a combination in out and cross row tune. It makes for some contrasts in rhythmic articulation that I quite enjoy.
-
That's the nice thing about the videos: to see what fingering different people chose. I think I am only cross-rowing (while playing in G) to get the short A and B notes in various places. Oh, and also to enable some right-hand harmony against the C chord in the B part, but that isn't necessary if just playing the melody part.
-
When we used to play this tune for the dance, it was in four parts. The first two parts were as people have played here. When the dancers started ranting the reel, we changed to the third and fourth parts. Was this wrong?
-
Re: Tune of the Month for April 2019: Dorset Four Hand Reel
« Reply #28 on: Yesterday at 10:02:44 AM »
When we used to play this tune for the dance, it was in four parts. The first two parts were as people have played here. When the dancers started ranting the reel, we changed to the third and fourth parts. Was this wrong?
Using the dots from Ed Raineys book (The available resource to me) Part 1 x 2 = 16 bars, Part 2 x 2 = 16 Bars : total 32 bars. ... If I remember rightly the dance is essentially an English version of the Foursome Reel/Ruidhle Ceathrair : (Set for 8, Reel for 8) four times through - first setting to partners, women back to back in middle. 2nd set men in middle to each other, 3rd set women in middle to each other, 4 th setting, men in middle to partners. final reel back to starting position = 64 bars.
It looks like we've only got half the dance...
Has anyone got dots for the other parts?
-
You can find 'both' parts in Mally's English Country Dance Tunes book.
Both tunes seem available here on folk tune finder (http://www.folktunefinder.com/tunes/60490), with the 'correct' (afaik) progression for the dance, but... not when also combined with the repeats - the structure is written to be read by a person, not the ABC interpreter.*
Also 2nd version on the session (https://thesession.org/tunes/7072) has the other parts, and a lot of the versions on abcnotation (http://abcnotation.com/tunePage?a=abc.sourceforge.net/NMD/nmd/reelsd-g.txt/0014) do too.
My understanding is that the structure would be roughly as Peadar posted. (edited because I misunderstood something) The dance is in two parts, and has two different stepping patterns, and it appears that rant step slowly 'takes over' the dance as it progresses. The dancers go through 4 'reels', and partners exchange places every reel, so, 2 reels = back to starting positions. Each 'reel' for the dancers is 32 bars, and so we make this up of Tune Part 1 * 2 (16 bars) Tune Part 2 * 2 (16 bars), repeated to cover the first two 'reels' (so, AA BB AA BB) giving for 64 bars and putting the dancers back in place. Then, the band swaps to the 'other' tune (the C and D part) and the dancers mostly skip or rant step, rather than walk, through the final two reels for a similar CC DD CC DD D 72 bar structure - the additional 8 bars of D on the end as fast as the dancers are comfortable with while they swing their partners to finish. I think anyway, I'm hardly a dancer.
Most versions I've seen also have a key change - We (the band I'm in) have been playing the C & D music in D (2 sharps), rather than A (3 sharps), but I might see if I can work out playing it in A. I also know some people don't change key at all.
I'm yet to find a complete version of both the tune, and the dance, all put together the way most of what I've read suggests that it would be may have found one, see end of post.
*I guess then I'd say a correctly flowing ABC would be something along the lines of (this is just the version from folk tune finder with a fixed P: line) - it's still written poorly, so, I hesitated to share it. I'll probably edit in a better version in a minute I uploaded a L:1/8 version with a tempo change.
X:4301
T:Dorset Four Hand Reel
% Nottingham Music Database
P:(AABB)2(CCDD)2E
S:Trad, via EF
Q:1/2=110
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:G
P:A
BA|"G"G2B2 d2cB|"C"c2e2 c2e2|"G"G2B2 d3c|"Am"B2A2 "D7"A2BA|
"G"G2B2 d2cB|"C"c2e2 c2e2|"G"G2B2 "D7"d3c|"G"B2G2 G2|
P:B
d2|"G"g2g2 "C"gfe2|"G"d2d2 "Em"dcB2|"Am"A3B c2d2|"D"e2d2 d2ef|
"G"g2g2 "C"gfe2|"G"d2d2 "Em"dcB2|"Am"A2AB "D7"c2A2|"G"G4 G2|
K:A
P:C
cB|"A"A2ce aecA|"D"d2f2 d2f2|"A"A2ce aecA|"E7"B2e2 B2e2|
"A"A2ce aecA|"D"d2f2 d2f2|"E7"eagf edcB|"A"A2c2 A2|
P:D
cd|"A"e2c2 e2c2|"D"f2d2 f2d2|"A"e2c2 e2c2|"E7"B2e2 e3e|
"A""F#m"e2c2 e2c2|"D""Bm"f2d2 f2d2|"E7"eagf edcB|"A"A2c2 A2|
P:E
Q:1/2=150
"^As before, but faster!"cd|"A"e2c2 e2c2|"D"f2d2 f2d2|"A"e2c2 e2c2|"E7"B2e2 e3e|
"A""F#m"e2c2 e2c2|"D""Bm"f2d2 f2d2|"E7"eagf edcB|"A"A2c2 A2|
Mel playing the C/D section in D: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4To9Jl9svk
Maybe the dance with the music & step change: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pCgnAjuLYPw
The dance written out: http://www.socalfolkdance.com/dances/D/Dorset_Four-Hand_Reel.pdf noting First Reel = AABB, Second Reel = AABB, third reel = CCDD, fourth reel = CCDD, 13/Swing partners = D.
I imagine the lack of videos showing it played & danced in what would appear to be the 'correct' manner gives rise to the revelation that there's little subscription to that concept.
Gena, the 'B' music is short a beat in the last bar.
Sure is - I visually checked for minims but missed it before regexing it
-
Gena, the 'B' music is short a beat in the last bar.
-
Here goes...after a week of practicing and following my rule of "3 takes only" my first attempt to contribute my "interpretation" of Tune of the month. Before recording I tried it on every box in my possession. In the end I settled on trying to record just AA BB (32 Bars) rather than a full 64 bar version.
Inevitably the best version I could produce came out of the "Brexit Box" - Tory blue, made in China, and gets worse as it goes on.
https://youtu.be/SvoPAOhFLlg
The second posting which features some brilliant several brave attempts at improvisation (OK I lost the plot- as well as my grip on the thumb strap) done on the Antoria in a key approximating to A. As the box itself carries the stamp "Made in Saxony" it probably pre-dates the Entente Cordiale never mind the EU.
https://youtu.be/EUk0jmzGOxM
Peadar
-
Gena, the 'B' music is short a beat in the last bar.
That would be the least of my troubles ::)
My understanding is that the structure would be roughly as Peadar posted.
I picked up the dance (so far as I can remember) at a dancing ceilidh in - Newcastle upon Tyne...probably in the Student Union c.1982 and I only remember it being danced as a rant & in rant step right through.
-
Here's mine: https://youtu.be/1ch1nLflccg
As mentioned in the blurb under the video, we used to play this four times, with the tune variant and key change from G to A for the 3rd and 4th time. I've not played this at a ceilidh since the 1980s - has it gone out of fashion?
-
Here's mine: https://youtu.be/1ch1nLflccg
As mentioned in the blurb under the video, we used to play this four times, with the tune variant and key change from G to A for the 3rd and 4th time. I've not played this at a ceilidh since the 1980s - has it gone out of fashion?
Video shows up as present but with a length of 0:00 and no content.
-
Here's mine: https://youtu.be/1ch1nLflccg
As mentioned in the blurb under the video, we used to play this four times, with the tune variant and key change from G to A for the 3rd and 4th time. I've not played this at a ceilidh since the 1980s - has it gone out of fashion?
Video shows up as present but with a length of 0:00 and no content.
Video is up and running for me.
Lovely playing as alaways. I personally do enjoy the change to A and will try it out should I ever happen to play this tune again. :)
-
I hesitate to post this in tune of the month...but played after a fashion on my latest aquisition- arrived today and played in the state received.
Key is Bb (ish) , brass reeds on zinc H plates. and apart from anything else the valves all need renewed.
https://youtu.be/5hC7rBlxdEs
Peadar
-
I just want to say how much Ive enjoyed learning this tune, and how helpful the recordings are to someone who does not have the patience to wade through dots. Especially inspired by Gina's playing, and appreciative of the moderate tempo. Now if I could just get through the whole thing without tripping up somewhere.
A separate question about beginner melodeon: despite having my accordion fettled by a pro, I'm still having issues with needing to play with a fair amount of bellows wind in order to get the reeds to start reliably, or so it seems to me. I THINK thats part of what is making it hard for me to get through a long push only passage (and occasionally pull only) on my pokerwork, as when I try to play with a more moderate amount of gusto quite often the sound gets wimpy or absent... It just looks like others are not really having to be quite as strategic in their "breathing" playing more staccato, especially on the bass buttons, of course helps, but there aretimes when you want a note to linger.... Hopefully all Begginer issues in general.
-
It might be worth having a word with the person who did the reed work just to check it is ok.
-
Here's mine: https://youtu.be/1ch1nLflccg
As mentioned in the blurb under the video, we used to play this four times, with the tune variant and key change from G to A for the 3rd and 4th time. I've not played this at a ceilidh since the 1980s - has it gone out of fashion?
This dance still popular in Devon Folk Dance clubs, although older dancers tend to avoid it because can be a bit vigorous.
-
Here's mine:
1. The 'normal' tune
2. Variations as mentioned by Hugh earlier in the thread
3. A minor version
4. The 'normal' tune again
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXiTEww4DLY
-
I saw your video via youtube before coming here, and as I was watching the tune through I was just thinking, oh I wonder what a minor version would be like! You sure did deliver!
Very nicely played!
-
I just turned it to into Gm using abc then transposed it to Em. Wasn't sure how it would come out but it seemed to work ok. Thank you for the nice comment Gena.
-
I just turned it to into Gm using abc then transposed it to Em. Wasn't sure how it would come out but it seemed to work ok. Thank you for the nice comment Gena.
abc please ;)
-
'Ere you go:
X:121
T:Dorset Four Hand Reel (min)
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:Em
E2 G2 B2 AG|A2 c2 A2 c2|E2 G2 B3 A|G2 F2 F2 GF|
E2 G2 B2 AG|A2 c2 A2 c2|E2 G2 B3 A|G2 F2 E4:|
e2 e2 ed c2|B2 B2 BA G2|F3 G A2 B2|c2 B2 B4|
e2 e2 ed c2|B2 B2 BA G2|F3 G A2 D2|F2 E2 E4:|
-
Funnily enough I've also played it in D major and its parallel key B minor a few days ago. I've also found the change to be very refreshing for this melody.
When listening to your version, Mcgrooger, my SO came over from the other room and asked whether or not that's the same Tune of the Month I've been playing. She commented very positively on your playing and the idea to mix this tune up by playing it in a minor key. So, well done, I'd say. ;-)
-
Sounds like a well done to us both Fred! (:)
-
Here's my version this month. I had my violinist friend round last night, so we had a go at it together.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JnH20JgeyuA
Slowed down (a lot), and played very much in the "vivant style" in D on a Castagnari Mory in D/G.
Cheers,
Clive
-
I had a go at the C & D but steered well clear of any key changing jiggery pokery - that's not the sort of thing that'd go down well round my way.
https://youtu.be/7csUZpyLLTo (https://youtu.be/7csUZpyLLTo)
Gren
-
Well played. Nice steady pace right through.
-
Here's my version this month. I had my violinist friend round last night, so we had a go at it together.
Clive
Love this Clive. Your friend has a beautiful tone on the fiddle. You don't sound three bad yourself. Really works. It sounds gorgeous
-
I'm a bit surprised how interesting this TOTM has turned out to be! The basic two-part tune is how its known around my area but when I heard the 3rd part I recognised it from an old recording of Sally Sloane playing a step dance tune (at a decent tempo on her old one-row box I might add).
Here's my version (https://youtu.be/XvL7U9cACtI) of how Sally played that 3rd part of the Dorset Four Hand Reel together with another variation she added to it. It was described by John Meredith as "Break Up (Step Dance)" which might refer to step dancers competing to see who danced the fastest and outlasted the others. I used an old Hohner one-row box in G but couldn't get up to the pace she played.
-
Yeah, it was pretty fun. I surely am a sucker for all the minor tunes and sensitive interpretations we've lined up lately, but it feels really nice to bring it home with a solid, major, four-to-the-bar, oompa-loompa, english-folk-dance, diatonic capital-A-Ccordion tune. Paddy Carey's turned out to not quite be what I wanted, but this one will do fine.
One take, before breakfast:
https://youtu.be/3xX8X7MDwas
-
I was going to post a "straight" version of this, but there have been too many great ones posted already, to compete with (especially Nigel's Straw Bear version). So I've had a lot of fun with it.
I tried it as a jig in G and it was...ok, so I tried as a reel in Em. Then McGooger did his brilliant version.
So I tried it as a jig in Em. Hmm. Getting there.
So I tried it as a jig in Am. Too squeaky.
So I tried it as a jig in low Bm and thought bingo.
It's still a work in progress, but I tried it out in the pub last night and it went down ok, so here it is: Dorset, one take before breakfast, like Ransom. Still a work in progress, but I think we will end up playing it quite a lot.
https://soundcloud.com/greg-bradfield-smith/dorset-25-04-2019
-
So I tried it as a jig in low Bm and thought bingo.
It's still a work in progress, but I tried it out in the pub last night and it went down ok, so here it is: Dorset, one take before breakfast, like Ransom. Still a work in progress, but I think we will end up playing it quite a lot.
https://soundcloud.com/greg-bradfield-smith/dorset-25-04-2019
That's really interesting! The A part is a little murky for my tastes (maybe the lower notes are getting lost in the bass side) but I think the B part works really well this way. Clever!
-
The A part is a little murky for my tastes (maybe the lower notes are getting lost in the bass side) but I think the B part works really well this way. Clever!
Thanks for the feedback Jesse. I think I'll try thinning out the basses a bit.
-
"I had a go at the C & D but steered well clear of any key changing jiggery pokery - that's not the sort of thing that'd go down well round my way." That really made me laugh.
I've just been catching up with everybody else's versions. All nice in their own way and so many different approaches. Really liked Fred's slow air. I don't think Soundcloud will let me make comments though without signing even more of my life away!
Mcg (aka Steve)
-
"I had a go at the C & D but steered well clear of any key changing jiggery pokery - that's not the sort of thing that'd go down well round my way." That really made me laugh.
I've just been catching up with everybody else's versions. All nice in their own way and so many different approaches. Really liked Fred's slow air. I don't think Soundcloud will let me make comments though without signing even more of my life away!
Mcg (aka Steve)
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it.
-
OK, here's mine. I had worked out a handful of nifty right-hand harmony bits for the second time through, but found myself incapable of making it twice through without falling off the tracks in the time I had available. Still needs more practice, I guess. So, I have opted for a simpler (but hopefully reasonably tasteful) once-through version. I did take some ideas from Anahata and made a tentative foray into a more active bass line using the B bass with the G chord, etc.
https://youtu.be/LDQNgCmMGmE
-
OK, here's mine. I had worked out a handful of nifty right-hand harmony bits for the second time through, but found myself incapable of making it twice through without falling off the tracks in the time I had available. Still needs more practice, I guess. So, I have opted for a simpler (but hopefully reasonably tasteful) once-through version. I did take some ideas from Anahata and made a tentative foray into a more active bass line using the B bass with the G chord, etc.
https://youtu.be/LDQNgCmMGmE
Nicely done Jesse. It's surprising how much lift moving the chords around a little bit can lift the tune. Are you playing out at all?
-
Nicely done Jesse. It's surprising how much lift moving the chords around a little bit can lift the tune. Are you playing out at all?
Thanks, Greg. Not so much; apart from Irish sessions I haven't really found anywhere locally to play traditional music. I might have to start my own session. (I've actually given it some thought, but I think these things must be a lot of work to keep the momentum going.) I might go get a busker's license and literally play "out" a bit this summer, just for laughs. Probably need to be able to consistently play twice through a tune first, though. ;)
-
Busking would certainly improve your ability to "get through" a tune twice through or more! Not necessarily consistently, of course, but that wouldn't matter.
-
Busking would certainly improve your ability to "get through" a tune twice through or more! Not necessarily consistently, of course, but that wouldn't matter.
There's definitely something to be said for "sink or swim"! Last September I got to sit in with a contra dance open band and even though 3/4 of my playing was vamping chords on tunes I didn't know, I probably learned more from that hour than a whole month of playing at home.
-
I've just signed up to a facebook group, the solitary cyclist. No meets, no trips, no gatherings. It's a bit like my melodeon playing. Hopefully at Wensleydale I'll be a bit more sociable.
As far as this months tune goes, I played it through a couple of times, but had no desire to go any further with it, then of all things, I've mostly enjoyed the more vanilla versions posted. Life is strange.
-
Thanks all - gently parking this thread and moving on to the new tune and theme! Please don't hesitate to place late contribs (or even on time ones before midnight!) here on this thread!