Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Gromit on April 02, 2019, 09:01:37 AM
-
For Folk's Sake: Morris Dancing and Me, was an interesting documentary on BBC4 last night even if like me you are not into Morris Dancing.
-
Here's the BBC iPlayer link available until the end of April 2019.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0003vhz/for-folks-sake-morris-dancing-and-me
(Not sure if this is only available in the UK, sorry)
I thought it was a quite well-made programme. Morris dancing taken seriously - no attempt to ridicule, thank goodness - and with a good balance of opinions.
One main topic of the programme covered the debate and eventual decision about allowing women's and mixed sides into the Morris Ring. However, to me there seemed to be some confusion in the minds of the programme producers about the distinction between (a) allowing women's and mixed sides into the Morris Ring, and (b) allowing women to join existing mens' sides (and vice versa). They are different concepts and not mutually exclusive.
I can illustrate this distinction with the example of my own side, Lizzie Dripping, which is a women's side developed from the stepping and clogging traditions. We are members of the Morris Federation and Open Morris, which support all-gendered and mixed sides. But while we allow men as musicians, it would be inappropriate for men to dance. The dance styles and the kit are definitely for women.
Allowing women's amd mixed sides into the Morris Ring does not mean that men's sides have to allow women to dance in their side, nor vice versa.
-
What an awful title "For Folk's Sake" surely that joke died in the seventies. Those BBC types are so witty "Oh look, folk sounds a bit like fuck"!
Disappointed ..........
-
Looking at the Lizzie Dripping videos I think I prefer womens Morris to mens, to me they seem better dancers and not as awkward looking but that maybe down to the dances. Do you do any of the stick whacking stuff and get to wear the flowery hats?
-
I agree with Steve's points about the confusion between opening the Morris Ring to women and having teams become mixed. Regards who are the better dancers I used to think that for Cotswold in particular a good men's team was better than a good women's team but I have changed my mind. It really doesn't matter, it is the quality of the dancers that matters, not their gender. Nice to see the presenter making a serious effort himself.
-
What an awful title "For Folk's Sake" surely that joke died in the seventies. Those BBC types are so witty "Oh look, folk sounds a bit like fuck"!
Disappointed ..........
Ah Rees my friend, if only the juvenile humour (so called) of the BBC stopped there, but it doesn't. At this very moment they are running a show on Radio 4, called, Where's the F in News.
Banal isn't the word.
SJ
-
Looking at the Lizzie Dripping videos I think I prefer womens Morris to mens, to me they seem better dancers and not as awkward looking but that maybe down to the dances. Do you do any of the stick whacking stuff and get to wear the flowery hats?
Lizzie Dripping don't wear hats these days, although when the side was first formed in 1982, a mob cap was part of the kit. No stick wacking either, but some dances have 'wavers' - pom-poms, which is partly a nod to the north-west style of 'fluffy morris' which formed the basis for a couple of our dances. But unlike fluffy morris, we are not competitive teenagers performing in a gym and we have real music, not inappropriate recorded stuff coming from a boom-box.
Here are a couple of examples of the sort of dances we do:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBLyMTa6TSY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5P_gIZqJRMM
-
I thought it was OK; I agree with Steve about the lack of clarity over the gender issue. I also felt it was unfortunate that the footage of Cecil Sharp was Playford, not morris, but there you go. It was nice to see so many familiar faces, some of whom I know quite well.....
Graham
-
Here are a couple of examples of the sort of dances we do:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBLyMTa6TSY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5P_gIZqJRMM
Good stuff!
-
What an awful title "For Folk's Sake" surely that joke died in the seventies.
Totally agree. The BBC wouldn't have allowed that title in the seventies though. Perhaps the culprits have been anxiously waiting all this time for standards of social acceptability to deteriorate to the point where they could get away with it har har.
-
Didn't watch it. Too busy at practice with Jackstraws Morris.It's probably for the best.
-
Actually no Helena, it is worth watching. Just caught up on it now.
quite thought provoking and not, absolutely not the typical 'let's laugh at this lot....'
Give it a go on iPlayer.
cheers
Q.
-
... absolutely not the typical 'let's laugh at this lot....'
it's not so much that. The clip I saw was of a man most often seen in a dress saying that women's morris amounts to 'pound shop copies'.
Not having that - and having sat through the ARM the year before the filming where I was in the capacity of both Bagman of a Ring team and solo musician for a Longborough workshop I have heard it first hand.
I will watch at some point, probably not before Friday though - rapper tour tonight for us both with Green Man Sword, tomorrow I will be out playing for Pilgrim Morris and Thursday my partner will be at practice with Ewell St. Mary. Oh the busy lives of a pair of morris tarts.
-
What an awful title "For Folk's Sake" surely that joke died in the seventies. Those BBC types are so witty...
Well now, I'm not sure who was responsible for the title - the programme was made by an independent
company, so, it may have been them, it may have been the Beeb....
I believe that there was a plan to drop the slightly dodgy initial title and replace it with summat else,
but that seems to have fallen through...
Co-incidentally, I have just been having a cuppa with one of the Molton (sp?) side and his wife. They
enjoyed the film, but I think they were a bit embarrassed by the 'Pound shop Morris' comment which
was made by one of their men.
We (MMM) had a private showing last Thursday, and we all enjoyed it. Our consensus was that a slightly
tricky, possibly controversial and divisive topic was handled fairly and sensitively, if not fully(*)...
Roger
(*) Steve Freereeder is spot on. There are all sorts of different options for 'Mixed Morris', I'm a newcomer,
but am learning fast, and I personally think that some slightly radical, but perfectly viable options have merely
been mentioned in passing, and not really explored/discussed.
-
Helena, yes that made me wince.
Once beyond that I felt it got better, and quite profound at the end.
Much better that some of the 'openly laughed at' occasions we've been interviewed by local independent TV.
Q
-
Helena, yes that made me wince.
Yes, me too, but it was the sincerely held opinion of one participant, and if a documentary is going to be even-handed it has to allow air-time for opinions right across the spectrum. It's not an attitude I'd support personally, but I would absolutely defend the right of the person in question to hold and express that opinion.
On the whole, I thought the programme succeeded pretty well in remaining dispassionate on the gender issue, and, as others have said, it did at least avoid the patronising tone so often adopted in the media.
Graham
-
It's not an attitude I'd support personally, but I would absolutely defend the right of the person in question to hold and express that opinion.
Depending on your own internal reasoning, you may want to re-evaluate choosing to defend certain views: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
At the very least, I'm not sure if this was a view that deserved a platform on the BBC, but, haven't actually watched the show yet due to work scheduling so I have no idea of the context, how it's framed or responded to, so, I imagine it's probably ok for broadcasting - your phrasing at the end there just made me feel the urge to link the paradox of tolerance.
-
Depending on your own internal reasoning, you may want to re-evaluate choosing to defend certain views: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
Thanks Gena - I was unaware of that - seems particularly apposite just now
Simon
-
Gena, that could make a great point for discussion, but I doubt that it would be tolerated, not being melodeon related.
-
Along the lines of no publicity is bad publicity, would you rather have no air time or this documentary? Several people seem to have said, that: 'I haven't seen it yet, but I already don't like it.'
Do we want exposure or do we want obscurity unless it is perfectly inline with our own desires?
Personally I want people to know that the tradition continues.
-
that the tradition continues .... to evolve
-
Here are a couple of examples of the sort of dances we do:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBLyMTa6TSY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5P_gIZqJRMM
I liked those a lot, Steve. Very enjoyable.
I liked the seamless recovery of the "drop" but I especially liked the way the musicians were clearly a part of the side and performers in their own right, rather than something tacked on to it.
-
I liked those a lot, Steve. Very enjoyable.
I liked the seamless recovery of the "drop" but I especially liked the way the musicians were clearly a part of the side and performers in their own right, rather than something tacked on to it.
Thanks Greg - that means a lot to me/us. I've been playing for Lizzie Dripping since 1989, in the beginning learning much about the art of playing for dancing from the late Barry Callaghan ('Hardcore English') who was one of our earliest musicians. We have always tried to incorporate the musicians and the dancers together as a unified team of performers, and mostly I think we succeed. The Lizzies are among my very best friends and I love them to bits. (:)
-
Lizzie Dripping don't wear hats these days, although when the side was first formed in 1982, a mob cap was part of the kit. No stick wacking either, but some dances have 'wavers' - pom-poms, which is partly a nod to the north-west style of 'fluffy morris' which formed the basis for a couple of our dances. But unlike fluffy morris, we are not competitive teenagers performing in a gym and we have real music, not inappropriate recorded stuff coming from a boom-box.
Here are a couple of examples of the sort of dances we do:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBLyMTa6TSY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5P_gIZqJRMM
It's so weird: I just learned about "fluffy morris" twice in the space of two minutes. I had an old thread from like 2009 open on concertina.net where someone was asking about "competitive morris dancing" in Liverpool and this "fluffy morris" was explained, which I had never heard of before. And then I switched browser tabs back to this thread and read your comment!
I love those videos; Lizzie Dripping reminds me a little of Shropshire's Martha Rhoden's Tuppenny Dish with the same constant stepping, which I find very engaging compared to the sometimes static Cotswold dancing.
-
From the Morris Ring web site:
https://themorrisring.org/sites/default/files/attachments/Open%20Letter%20to%20Morris%20Community.pdf (https://themorrisring.org/sites/default/files/attachments/Open%20Letter%20to%20Morris%20Community.pdf)
an open letter from the production company (Libra ) to the Morris community. Also attached to this post.
-
Thank you Roger for sharing that letter.
They recognise other TV representations as often ridiculing the Morris. We have had the misfortune of such an occurrence and it leaves a bad taste for a long time. Luckily our last run with a TV production was great fun had by all which restored the balance somewhat.
Apart from the theme of change within the Ring, it made some good general points. Hats off to the presenter giving it a go and realising it isn't easy and even the most basic dance requires a lot of practice .
The more I think about it and discuss it, I realise it was a good programme for the Morris.
Q
-
I love those videos; Lizzie Dripping reminds me a little of Shropshire's Martha Rhoden's Tuppenny Dish with the same constant stepping, which I find very engaging compared to the sometimes static Cotswold dancing.
Thanks, Jesse!
Your comment about Martha Rhoden's is spot on. In the early days (1980s) of Lizzie Dripping, we had some close ties with Martha Rhoden's, benefitting from some workshops tuition from them. The influence must still be there, even though we no longer have any of the original dancers in our side.
-
Thank you Roger for sharing that letter.
Hear, hear! (:)
The more I think about it and discuss it, I realise it was a good programme for the Morris.
Yes - this is my opinion too!
I don't think anything bad will arise from the programme being shown, and who knows - it may even give a bit of encouragement to some youngsters to have a go; goodness knows we need them!
-
Well I was shocked. There were unpixelated full frontal pictures of........piano accordions! :-\
-
Hah! Calm yourself Mcgrooger.
It was well balanced by many melodeons in shots and many melodeon references. That was a good plug for us lot here.
Q
-
It's so weird: I just learned about "fluffy morris" twice in the space of two minutes.
I find everything about fluffy morris a bit weird. It makes me feel uncomfortable and slightly embarrassed. I'm sure that's an aberration on my part, but I can't help it.
I know others feel the same about other aspects of the world of morris. Takes all sorts, I suppose.
-
Watching the on topic video, it strikes me that it is very even handed in it's approach. If anything, it makes the point that the old attitudes are inappropriate in today's world, but it does it in a way that isn't at all clumsy. Not shock horror, but more, this is the way to Darwinian extinction (please don't take that phrase too literally).
-
Well I watched it, and I enjoyed it. People expressed their views, and no comment was made by the presenter, one way or the other, unbiased reporting at its best. It was made plain that it was the Morris Ring who were historically "men only", and not the whole of the Morris world, and even they folded, albeit that the implementation of the new ruling was left up to individual sides. There will always be single sex sides, and mixed ones too, I think it will remain so for the foreseeable future too.
The presenter was great, and showed both the fun of the Morris, and also that it's not as easy as it looks. Well done him.
I don't know about full frontal PA's but I thought I spotted a well known book dealer lurking at the top of the steps, behind Lizzie Dripping. Now that was scary ;)
Sir John
-
It could so easily have been a hatchet job, instead I thought it was an intelligent and respectful view of morris. Easily the best programme on the topic I can recall seeing. The presenter's struggle to master even basic stepping showed that it is more difficult than it looks and that there is more to it than just prancing about.
The "pound shop" comment was (perhaps intentionally) provocative, but it reflected a view which was also expressed in more moderate terms, that morris is a masculine style of dance, and women move differently from men. This is something which most dance forms recognise and exploit, but which the morris world chooses to ignore. No doubt this is because the question of women dancing morris quickly became a 'political' issue rather than an artistic one, but it has left us in a position where even to express that view is seen as at best outdated and at worst taboo. Of course there are many women who dance with good style, and far more many men who do not, which rather weakens the argument, but they have a point.
-
"Fluffy" is the morris that dare not speak its name. It has been largely ignored by the "real" morris world, and yet it can probably claim to be the true descendant of north-west carnival morris. The singer, musician and researcher Dr Lucy Wright has done some research into this, which I recall was the subject of an article in English Dance & Song.
https://www.efdss.org/floor-spot/diaries/lucy-wright-s-this-girl-can-morris-dance
For their accuracy and precision these little girls could knock most "real" morris sides into a cocked hat.
-
Well said Howard and Sir John.
Q
-
Watched it last night. It seemed very genuine and thoughtful.
It's interesting that while filled with things that are clearly to do with morris, little of the core narrative really related to anything eg our side is currently doing. My main comment would be that I didn't think it did a great job separating what he was seeing and pursuing for the main narrative from 'the whole', as it were; other associations are talked about, but once covered, it would easily shift back to phrasing like "it's the pinnacle of the morris calendar, and if you're a morris dancer, you want to be dancing here: this is sort of the ultimate stage" - Richard Macer talking about Saddleworth Rushcart Festival, an event I've literally never heard of before.
So, the focus was ok, and the periphery was fine, but, I felt there was a lack of connection between them. At the end, it seemed like the takeaway for an uninitiated viewer could easily be that there is a big gender divide issue in all Morris. I think Steve is right about the confusion aspect, although I'm not sure if the producers were actually confused or if it got lost in the edit, or it needed to be framed this way to get screen time. When the views of a few vocal individuals are the 'balance' to a landslide vote and non segregated associations are mentioned as being 3 times the size, I'm... not sure you're really presenting a balance?
My advice to anyone who thinks their side should be for men only, or even for women only, is: always expect individuals to surprise you, and challenge the ideas you have. Things you think would be 'inappropriate' may be fueled by your own biases and beliefs about the way people are, and this will come at the cost of ignoring the reality of the way a person standing before you actually is.
-
Despite the producers efforts to soften it, the dinosaurs of the 'militant wing' of the Morris Ring came over very poorly in their justifications for not wanting female dancers or muso's and appear to have missed a countrywide opportunity for recruitment which, as far as the program was 'concerned, seemed to be the main reason for their broaching the matter and having the vote in the first place, increasing age and infirmity, diminishing membership.
I was expecting something more akin to 'A Life with Bells On' but the desperation to uphold 'The Tradition' even at the cost of it dying altogether in some against the light bulbs coming on with others, without the extreme views being ridiculed was nicely done.
Had they screened one of the more haunting or atmospheric examples of the A-B Horn Dance being performed it might have shown Thaxted in a slightly better light, illustrating why they felt they were justified in believing that their performances were exemplary and traditional enough not to be equalled were they a mixed side.
Not involved in Morris but interested and can appreciate the difference between a well practiced and skilled side and a bunch of friends out for a few beers and enjoying the buzz without taking it or themselves too seriously...................
-
I think any programme of only an hour is inevitably only going to touch the surface, and will overlook matters which others might regard as important. On the whole, I think it did a good job. It was important to understand why the Ring had been so opposed to women, so I'm not sure 'balance' really applies - it was apparent throughout that they were fighting a losing battle. The fact that it was a landslide vote, and the many shots of women morris dancers throughout the programme, and the statement at the end about how many Ring sides had accepted women, were arguably sufficient counter. The issue of the couple who felt they had to move to a different part of the country also made the opposite point forcibly, I thought.
I came away with the sense that it was a lost battle, but also that it is is a more complex issue than simply misogyny (although that was clearly a part). Artistic integrity and tradition also play a part, although sometimes mistakenly. He also made the point that while all-female groups are acceptable and seen as empowering, the same is not now true for all-male groups, and pointed out that these men were pursuing joy and beauty rather than the more objectionable aspects of masculinity.
He was dancing with Manchester Morris, and Saddleworth Rushcart is a very big thing up here which attracts sides from all over the country. However I hadn't heard of it either until I moved up north. It is easy to forget in this connected world how localised some events are.
I take your point about unconscious biases. However one of the distinctive features of morris is (or used to be) that sides were single-sex. and I think the potential loss of that distinctiveness is perhaps of greater regret than whether a side is all men or all women. However I know many will disagree with me, and I have to accept that mixed morris is here to stay.
-
Had they screened one of the more haunting or atmospheric examples of the A-B Horn Dance being performed it might have shown Thaxted in a slightly better light
I hadn't previously seen Thaxted's version of the Horn Dance, which bears little resemblance to the real thing and struck me as far too slow and far too solemn. Of course, the real Abbotts Bromley Horn Dancers include a woman, and so could not accept an invitation to Thaxted.
-
I am not involved (yet) with any Morris side, but my impression in the United States is that most sides here are mixed, which I think makes sense given the nature of American Morris as a modern, imported/borrowed tradition. That said, I have no issues with all-female or all-male groups, and I think there is something to be said for the aesthetics of the uniformity of kit and the ability to focus on the masculinity or femininity of a dance style (although those are amorphous and fraught terms!). I do think it would be rather exclusionary to *only* have a single all-male or all-female side in a region, without either a "sibling" side or a mixed side.
From a historical viewpoint, I'm not even sure that the Morris Ring's hard line makes sense, because there is documentary evidence that there were women Morris dancers in the past, if perhaps not in large numbers.
-
" Things you think would be 'inappropriate' may be fueled by your own biases and beliefs about the way people are, and this will come at the cost of ignoring the reality of the way a person standing before you actually is."
What an insightful statement, thank you Gena! Maybe many of us could take it to heart?
-
From a historical viewpoint, I'm not even sure that the Morris Ring's hard line makes sense, because there is documentary evidence that there were women Morris dancers in the past, if perhaps not in large numbers.
Yes you are quite right, in a recorded interview William Kimber, the man who taught Cecil Sharp how to dance, was recorded discussing memories of women dancing single jigs in particular (he spoke of how well they danced). That puts women dancing morris back into the 1880s at least. After WW1 it was often women who kept the dances going. I remember a conversation with Mrs. Schofield, landlady of the pub in Beck Hole, near Whitby around 1980. She remembered being taken to a dance festival in London and dancing the morris in front of Cecil Sharp himself sometime in the 1920s. (If you are ever in the area the pub is well worth a look, a tiny time capsule).
-
I refer to 'Chats with Uncle Roy', whilst taking a breather in between instructional with the late lamented Roy Dommett in the late '70's onwards:
It was touched on in the programme but not really explained. Cecil Sharp discovered Headington dancers and was surprised to find Mary Neal had discovered Abingdon and was getting her ladies to dance that tradition.
Sharpe was always looking for an earner. If he could get a publication into school to teach them how to Morris dance, then he had more to come with the other village traditions. His first book said it was an energetic dance 'for men or women'
The early collaborations with Neal turned sour when Neal, a friend of the Pankhursts, became more politically active in the up and coming Suffragette movement. Having such things associated with him would make future publications difficult so they fell out and he distanced himself from Neal with letters in the Times newspaper. The second book had an energetic dance for men... no mention of women and a prejudice was created.
Roy had delved into the manuscripts and could quote chapter and verse as to when a sister might have stepped in if the brother was unable to dance through being at war etc. and where and when this had occurred.
As Sharpe was looked on as an authority the newly emerged Ring adopted his ideas and attitudes.
Q
-
... I think there is something to be said for the aesthetics of the uniformity of kit and the ability to focus on the masculinity or femininity of a dance style ...
Ah yes, uniformity. You mean like this?
(https://scontent-lht6-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/50766550_2210119425974162_4979219113114075136_o.jpg?_nc_cat=106&_nc_ht=scontent-lht6-1.xx&oh=6e4f69fdefb7844a28b17b4d7064aef1&oe=5D489640)
-
It tends to be forgotten, when we can now quickly google anything, how little information was in general circulation even only a few years ago. When I started dancing morris in the 1970s most of what I knew about it came from other members of the side. I picked up bits and pieces from workshops at festivals, from the likes of Roy Dommett and Tubby Reynolds, but most of it was really only folklore. The idea that morris had been danced only by men had become deeply entrenched and was honestly, if mistakenly, held by a lot of people.
-
Yes Howard, exactly right.
I came along in '77 and it was a time when it was almost a given thing as you say. Luckily we didn't believe that and listened to Roy and Tubby. Thank goodness for those two!
Q
-
"Fluffy" is the morris that dare not speak its name. It has been largely ignored by the "real" morris world, and yet it can probably claim to be the true descendant of north-west carnival morris. The singer, musician and researcher Dr Lucy Wright has done some research into this, which I recall was the subject of an article in English Dance & Song.
https://www.efdss.org/floor-spot/diaries/lucy-wright-s-this-girl-can-morris-dance
For their accuracy and precision these little girls could knock most "real" morris sides into a cocked hat.
Indeed...but I do wish people wouldn't use the word "fluffy" ...I believe it's a hangover from the early seventies and a relic of much the same thinking that said women can't dance the morris. Still it makes a change from arguing about the origins of blacking up... :|glug
-
;D
-
Nobody should comment on this programme until they've watched it.
Given that the "hook" of the programme was the Morris Ring's vote to allow women rather than being an impartial survey of the state of Morris in the UK today, I thought it was very good. It showed varied opinions -- including from Windsor! -- and without ridiculing anybody made it clear what the reasons leading to the Ring's change of heart were. The presenter did have a wistful view of the camaderie between all-male sides (and Windsor, for balance!) but also made it clear that he really respected what Morris was all about -- his tie-off at the end about encouraging everybody of either (any?) sex to take it up was genuine and heartfelt.
Probably the best programme about Morris on the TV I've seen. It would be great if the same presenter/production team made another one on -- for example -- the growth in popularity of Morris among young dancers, especially in styles like Border and Rapper. And of course Cotswold where there are quite a few fine young teams, though it has to be said that the overall age profile is considerably older...
If even a few more younger people can be encouraged to take up Morris of any type (but preferably good...), this can't be a bad thing ;-)
-
I've employed some dark sorcery and managed to watch the programme.
As someone who has passing familiarity with Morris dancing (snuck into a practice once) I've found it excellent.
It is too easy as a bystander to say "Why can't you just let them join?" and view the whole thing as grumpy misogynistic exclusion, which I admit was more or less my view before watching. After watching I can definitely appreciate the unique social, and to a far lesser extent visual, aspects of a homogeneous side.
This is why it was so important to include the pound shop remark, to not sweep under the rug the fact that while there are some objective qualities to non-mixed sides, misogyny was definitely one of the reasons for exclusion of women.
I believe that it is far more likely that it will encourage people to dance than the opposite, at the very least it had this effect with me.
Unfortunately the closest side is in Cyprus :(
-
...After watching I can definitely appreciate the unique social, and to a far lesser extent visual, aspects of a homogeneous side...
As a relative newcomer to Morris, I think this is actually potentially pretty important.
I have seen examples of:
Mixed (homogeneous) sides with the same kit - ie: women dressed in conventional white trousers, etc.
Mixed (homogeneous) sides with the ladies in skirts, but the same colour scheme as the fellers.
Mixed (not necessarily homogeneous) sides with the boys in conventional kit, and the girls in dresses, but
in a contrasting (not clashing) colour scheme.
For a 'conventional' dance, the first option looks a little odd with a mixed side - contrived is the word which springs
to mind.
The second option is better - pretty good, in fact - perhaps the way to go for 'conventional' dances with a mixed side?
The third option is great, when done properly with a dance like Abram Circle Dance (which, OK, is arguably not a
'conventional' dance).
I know a side not a million miles from where I'm sitting which does the latter when at a dance-out with a ladies side
(which seems to happen a couple of times a year). It looks just stunning!
Incidentally, what happens in other European dance traditions - that's relevant too, innit?
-
...I have seen examples of:
Mixed (homogeneous) sides with the same kit - ie: women dressed in conventional white trousers, etc.
Mixed (homogeneous) sides with the ladies in skirts, but the same colour scheme as the fellers.
Mixed (not necessarily homogeneous) sides with the boys in conventional kit, and the girls in dresses, but
in a contrasting (not clashing) colour scheme.
For a 'conventional' dance, the first option looks a little odd with a mixed side - contrived is the word which springs
to mind.
Women wearing trousers is contrived? How so?
-
Incidentally, what happens in other European dance traditions - that's relevant too, innit?
Possibly not relevant at all.
Most other European dance traditions are social dance rather than ritual so tend towards people wearing either their traditional costume or their everyday wear.
-
Lester has eaten me to it.
The morris is a ritual dance. You dance for an occasion or an event. Social dances are a totally different thing.
I also agree with Helena. In terms of Cotswold morris, to my mind you all wear the same kit as you are a 'side' whatever the makeup.
I have never been associated with North West morris, so don't really have thoughts about their kit......
cheers
Q
-
Women wearing trousers is contrived? How so?
I didn't say that women wearing trousers was contrived....
However, perhaps contrived was a poor choice, I'm not sure I can come up with anything much better,
'inelegant' perhaps. It's a subjective thing...
...Most other European dance traditions are social dance rather than ritual so tend towards people wearing either their traditional costume or their everyday wear.
Which is the answer to the question I was trying to ask - so, it's not relevant...
...I may be wrong, but I took the use of the word "homogeneous" to mean "all-female" or "all-male...
Oops! I was interpreting 'homogeneous' to mean "mixed", "co-ed" if you prefer...
Nothing like a little confusion to keep the pot simmering...
-
...After watching I can definitely appreciate the unique social, and to a far lesser extent visual, aspects of a homogeneous side...
As a relative newcomer to Morris, I think this is actually potentially pretty important.
I have seen examples of:
Mixed (homogeneous) sides with the same kit - ie: women dressed in conventional white trousers, etc.
I may be wrong, but I took the use of the word "homogeneous" to mean "all-female" or "all-male"; I've danced in all-male and mixed sides, and the relationship between members is definitely different - neither "better" nor "worse", but different. I guess the same applies to all-female sides.
BTW we all wear green trousers!
-
I didn't say that women wearing trousers was contrived....
However, perhaps contrived was a poor choice, I'm not sure I can come up with anything much better,
'inelegant' perhaps. It's a subjective thing...
Fortunately we are long past the days when 'ladies' need to be elegant. About a hundred years past.
Personally, I want to be comfortable, be able to move freely without worrying about what I am wearing and the belt loop to hang my tankard off is a bonus too. Trousers all the way.
-
I may be wrong, but I took the use of the word "homogeneous" to mean "all-female" or "all-male"; I've danced in all-male and mixed sides, and the relationship between members is definitely different - neither "better" nor "worse", but different. I guess the same applies to all-female sides.
You are right.
-
I may be wrong, but I took the use of the word "homogeneous" to mean "all-female" or "all-male"; I've danced in all-male and mixed sides,
and the relationship between members is definitely different - neither "better" nor "worse", but different. I guess the same applies to all-female sides.
You are right.
Hmm! Contrariwise, I was thinking of an analogy with 'homogenized' milk - in which the two components ('cream' and 'milk', if you like), are 'mixed'.
-
homogeneous
/ËŒhÉ’mÉ™(ÊŠ)ˈdÊ’iËnɪəs,ËŒhəʊmÉ™(ÊŠ)ˈdÊ’iËnɪəs/
adjective
1. of the same kind; alike.
"if all jobs and workers were homogeneous"
synonyms: similar, comparable, equivalent, like, analogous, corresponding, correspondent, parallel, matching, kindred, related, correlative, congruent, cognate
"you must consider cost efficiency to compete with homogeneous products"
2. CHEMISTRY denoting a process involving substances in the same phase (solid, liquid, or gaseous).
"homogeneous catalysis"
-
BTW we all wear green trousers!
Didn't realise you'd joined Sheffield City... :|glug
-
;D
I was thinking the same Baz!
Q
-
Ours are darker green - green,gold and white, colours of the Cyprus flag......
I had a chat to some members of Sheffield City a few years back at Whitby - slightly different concept from Cyprus Morris ;) :|glug
-
...and a bit cooler temperature wise!
Good friends with Sheffield, a good lot to be with.
Q
-
William Kimber was complementary about Women dancing Morris, but women's Morris dancing goes back a lot longer than that.
Kirtlington Lamb Ale is a Whitsun Ale in Kirtlington, Oxfordshire that can be traced back to the early 1600's.
In 1679 it is recorded it was "......attended with a Morisco dance of men, and another of women, where the rest of the day is spent in dancing, mirth and merry glee."
https://kirtlington-morris.org.uk/kirtlington-lamb-ale-2/
As for fluffy morris: i grew up in Liverpool and there was a local annual Carnival procession with at least 3 or 4 troupes of "fluffy" morris dancers. Although I can see how they could have developed out of North West processional Morris, I don't remember them being called Morris dancers then, certainly not "fluffy Morris', but I may be wrong as I was never involved in any.
-
At a Saturday session yesterday, I bumped into two more folks who saw the film, one a (Morris)
dancer, one not. Both seemed to think it was a very fair presentation of the 'dilemma', 'crisis', or
whatever you want to call it.
-
Just thinking about Sue's comment about Kirtlington:
It reminds me, I think Roy said it was the famous Foreman of Ilmington who, when standing down after his time teaching the side to dance, then trained a boys side and a girls side. The traditional sides had no problem with the concept.
Q
-
The traditional sides had no problem with the concept.
My paternal ancestry is Cotswolds for generations back, agricultural stock basically, until my grandfather returned from the trenches of World War 1 to find no work on the land. He relocated to Wales and raised a large family of which my father is the youngest and from middle childhood years he would be sent to spend the summers with his Cotswold cousins. A few years ago when he found out about me taking to the bells and hankies he commented that it was 'in my blood' and he was pleased I had taken the family full circle - he well remembered watching his aunts and his uncles dancing on the village greens in his childhood. No mention of just the men dancing or anything controversial about the women dancing. My father is not a morris man and had no idea there even was, or could be, a problem with it. Not that it would have stopped me if there had been to be honest, tradition is a living, breathing thing - to be guarded and treasured but not kept under glass, unchanged.
Right, that's my thought for the day. Off to molly practice now.
-
I took a look at the programme, very good. But I got the message that letting female dancers join Ring sides seemed to me more about survival of the aging sides than the traditional women dancing at whitsun etc argument. I have a sneaky feeling it would never have happened if we still had the young sides we had back in the seventies. I am not against it myself by the way. Our local Ring side now have a wife of a younger member dancing and she is very good. It certainly livened up their dancing.
-
Helena, it's weird how things go full circle.
I joined a local side and some years later my uncle told me he used to dance. With a surname of Hemmings, I assumed he danced with Abingdon but no, his parents separated and he moved with his mother to Elsfield. The local teacher's husband got the young cricketers ( he was one) to bolster the sides' numbers when they had double bookings on a day. They would put 3 of the side and 3 young cricketers and dance at several occasions on the same day so increasing the side's takings for the day.
He danced with Headington in the 40's and had 'some old white haired bloke playing concertina..'
'Er could that be William Kimber?'
'Yep that was his name... a right old bugger cos he'd just start and you had to be ready...' None of this 'ok lads, let's go now?' then!
I was stunned, I knew nothing of my uncle's past, and only discovered it after taking up the bells.
Funny how things go.
Q
-
...tradition is a living, breathing thing - to be guarded and treasured but not kept under glass, unchanged.
Absolutely
-
Yes, and manuscripts show that Morris had evolved, individual village traditions had continued to evolve up until the point Sharpe collected them.
Why then freeze it at that point?
Makes no sense, and isn't...traditional!.
Q
-
A quick skim through the lists of dancers and musicians of days gone by in Keith Chandler's excellent "Morris Dancing In The English South Midlands 1660-1900" reveals quite a number of female participants. I recall seeing an 18th Century painting somewhere- I think it may have been Upton House, but it's a long while ago now so it could well be somewhere entirely different - of a rural scene including a morris side consisting of three men and three women, so it probably wasn't particularly unusual then.
-
I have always said the good thing about traditions are, you can always invent a new one and change the old as required.
-
It's interesting finding out unexpected things about your ancestry. I didn't grow up knowing anything about Morris but quite recently my older sister mentioned that one of our Grandfathers had been a clog dancer. I hadn't know anything about that!
-
...and after marrying my wife, she kept talking about a picture her mum has.
It turned up. A traditional high breeches fiddler in top hat
( her great grandfather ) and a side if women in mop caps dresses with one women being her grandmother.
Marked 'Spon End ( Coventry ) June 19th 1909'
No wonder my kids never stood a chance!
Both have played for and also danced the Morris.
Q
proud father of two daughts!
-
My only claim to a trad Morris connection is that my great grandfather came from Brackley, though I have no evidence that he was involved in the Morris. However my grandmother, his daughter, learned Morris dancing at school in Birmingham in the early years of the 20th century.
-
...and she would have learnt from Sharpe's books that he got into schools as mentioned in my earlier list, as did my mum, and I vaguely remember similar things including country dancing when I was at primary school. It seemed in the shires it continued into our lifetimes .
Q
-
... and at Stafford County Junior School (Eastbourne, Sussex) [1957-1961] there was country dancing for everyone and Bean setting, Headington and the Flamborough longsword dance for the boys. All performed to 78 rpm records: including an outdoor performance of the morris and the sword dance in the grounds of one of the long-demolished big houses on Upperton Road.
-
From a historical viewpoint, I'm not even sure that the Morris Ring's hard line makes sense, because there is documentary evidence that there were women Morris dancers in the past, if perhaps not in large numbers.
Yes you are quite right, in a recorded interview William Kimber, the man who taught Cecil Sharp how to dance, was recorded discussing memories of women dancing single jigs in particular (he spoke of how well they danced). That puts women dancing morris back into the 1880s at least. After WW1 it was often women who kept the dances going. I remember a conversation with Mrs. Schofield, landlady of the pub in Beck Hole, near Whitby around 1980. She remembered being taken to a dance festival in London and dancing the morris in front of Cecil Sharp himself sometime in the 1920s. (If you are ever in the area the pub is well worth a look, a tiny time capsule).
I never knew Mrs Schofield (Edie) was a dancer. Will ask if anyone in the Village knew she was, but most of her generation are no longer with us.
For those who are at Whitby Festival, some of the dance teams go up to Beckhole on the Wednesday night for a bit of a gathering, but the bars are too small for many to get inside!
-
It was a long time ago but I am pretty sure that was the story. I assume she would have been at school at the time.
-
... and I vaguely remember similar things including country dancing when I was at primary school. It seemed in the shires it continued into our lifetimes .
Q
Out in the colonies the girls and boys in my primary school class were learning maypole dancing in the early 1960s (to recorded music).
The world map in our school atlas had lots of pink bits to denote the countries of the British Empire.
-
The point about the Morris Ring being men-only is surely that Sharp was educated at public school and Cambridge, and many of the early revivalists were from public or grammar (i.e. boys-only) schools. This was the social life with which they were comfortable. I've only been to one MR feast and was struck by its resemblance to events at my (boys') school and at my university, (which had a tradition of separate students' unions for men and women).
We now have mostly coeducational secondary schools in Britain, so it's not surprising that mixed-sex hobbies and pastimes seem not unusual to the younger generation of dancers.
The other consideration was, again to an older generation, horror at the likelihood that women dancing probably meant wives and, in many cases, children at morris events, with a change in the social dynamic that not all the men would have welcomed; thirty years ago it was well-known which teams/events were or were not child-friendly.
What's this got to do with 'tradition'? Well, nothing if you view view tradition in terms of what happened in Little Snoring in 1638, but it's important if you view folk as a cultural expression of a particular society, or a group within it. All-male dancing was fostered by the traditions and sub-culture of the group that promoted it; this is neither good nor bad, but how the process works. That group is now very much diminished and morris has been taken up by another group, no more or less authentic or representative of society (look at the occupational breakdown of members of any of the three British organisations and compare them with society as a whole - and that's before we get on to ethnicity). And that's also neither good nor bad, it's just what happened.
We could get on to socioeconomic power and dominant narratives, but that's probably for another post or (preferably) forum.
-
Andrew: take a look at my earlier post.
Sharpe discovered Headington and Mary Neal simultaneously found Abingdon. Their early collaboration resulting in Sharpes first Morris book broke down after Neal's increasing political interests with the leaders of the Suffragettes. At that point the preface in the first Morris book stating 'an energetic dance for men or women' became 'for men'.
I suspect strongly your point about the men only culture of public school and academia that Sharpe was immersed in also played a part, but the falling out between Sharpe and Neal seemed to be the seminal moment for the men only attitude according to researchers.
Cheers
Q
-
The other consideration was, again to an older generation, horror at the likelihood that women dancing probably meant wives and, in many cases, children at morris events, with a change in the social dynamic that not all the men would have welcomed; thirty years ago it was well-known which teams/events were or were not child-friendly.
This fits pretty well with my personal theory, certainly about the revival of interest of the 60/70's in the context of gender roles and relationships in those days. Marriages in those days were generally much more gendered than they are today with both partners having pre-defined roles to fill. This, along with all the accompanying stereotypes were then viewed as normal. In that context the husband nipping off the pub with his mates, spending precious household resources and leaving his wife up to her elbows in housework and childcare was often viewed as unacceptable -at least by the wife. As the TV shows of the time reveal, such stereotypes provided fodder for many a comedy sketch as the hapless husband attempted to escape the nagging wife.
Of course once you introduce the pursuit of a wholesome hobby in the name of tradition the dynamic shifts dramatically and the nipping off to the pub with your mates becomes a noble pursuit.
-
It is fairly well documented that from at least 1905 to the end of the second world war, there were significantly more women than men dancing morris. The Morris Ring, formed 1934, was actually to promote a minority aspect of the morris at that time, more in terms of the way it was performed than specifically by gender (as most of the original founder clubs had female teachers and musicians at their inception). But yes, most of the men involved were university chaps, hence the resemblance with a lot of the ceremony and rituals to public school/Oxbridge/ivy-covered professors in ivy-covered halls etc.
The increase in men participating in morris through the 1950's to the 1970's coincided with increasing access to new and more widespread forms of print and broadcast media, hence the impression given by most archival material that morris was predominantly male. It certainly hasn't been for the last 40 years.
Cecil Sharp was impoverished upper middle class, meaning that he struggled to live on more than most of us have to manage on. He was also an absolute egotist. [Do you know who first suggested calling the EFDSS HQ Cecil Sharp House?] Part of the falling-out with Mary Neal related to her politics, part to the fact that her public profile rivalled his. When she was invited for a solo lecture tour in the US, he waited until her ship had left, then telegraphed all the venues she would be speaking at to denounce her as a charlatan! Such a nice chap.
-
Jonm: interesting thoughts about Sharpe. Sounds about right!
Down here in Devon we had the Rev. Sabine Baring Gould collecting and publishing folk songs 30 years before Sharpe. He was a prolific publisher and relied on his royalties to support his massive family of 13 children. On his deathbed he was furious that the third edition of the seminal folk song collection 'Songs of the West' was edited by Sharpe who then got the royalties.
Many times we've discussed Sharpe's collecting methods at workshops. It appears it was a very aloof and superior attitude to the peasants he was collecting from and intimidation must have come into it. He didn't always get it right, but two important points.
There was no way to describe what Sharpe saw at the beginning so he had to create a notation and way of describing the dances.
As Roy demonstrated in his last workshop with us, if you have a number of people watching a dance and ask them to write or re-create what they saw you will have that number of different versions!
....and however critical we ( and I ) can be of Sharpe, without him we would have probably lost the Morris.
Q
-
He was also an absolute egotist. [Do you know who first suggested calling the EFDSS HQ Cecil Sharp House?] Part of the falling-out with Mary Neal related to her politics, part to the fact that her public profile rivalled his. When she was invited for a solo lecture tour in the US, he waited until her ship had left, then telegraphed all the venues she would be speaking at to denounce her as a charlatan! Such a nice chap.
And yet we still toast the his immortal memory. Well, some of us do.... >:E
-
From my perspective as a poorly educated, male, working class old fart, it would seem that Sharp was a typical product of his time and social circumstance.
Those of us who are bordering on being "elderly" but born (and suitably indoctrinated) during the intervening years can have a great laugh at the modern practice of reimagining and judging history (with the now available benefit of hindsight) to suit our current (or burgeoning) social mores.
Nevertheless, no matter how entertaining I find the thread, I see less and less relevance to melodeons in it! Are we drifting to a different place, I wonder?
-
....and however critical we ( and I ) can be of Sharpe, without him we would have probably lost the Morris.
or however critical we ( and I ) can be of Sharpe, without him we would have probably lost the Battle of Waterloo
-
Yes, but there remains the vexed question (now rare but still persisting in a few odd corners) as to whether women should even be allowed to play for the morris. Whilst I've heard discussions couched in terms of whether women dance like men (let's not go there), I've never heard it suggested that women just don't play (melodeon or whatever) like men. So why shouldn't they play for "men's" morris events? That possibly says more about the morris as a boys' club than it does, say, about a split between Cecil Sharp and Mary Neal.
-
It could be an interesting exercise in contra-factual history to consider what might have survived without Sharp and the others.
Dulcimers and step dancing were largely ignored by EFDSS. The late David Williams of Southampton spent much of his all-too-short retirement looking at what folk were actually singing/playing/dancing as distinct from what the folk revival thought they were, or should be, doing.
David's view was that all you needed for performance was a one-row melodeon and a banjo.
-
Some interesting thoughts here.
I remember we were asked to attend a Ring meeting as a guest side in the very early '80's and our stalwart melodeon player was a lady. We could bring her, let her play all day but we were invited to the evening feast and she relegated to the pub with a plate of sandwiches. It took nano seconds to decline.
It would be interesting to ponder 'what if Sharpe hadn't discovered the Morris' by then I think only Headington, Bampton and Abingdon were active. I feel it might not have survived.
He was indeed selective in his collecting. It is said he witnessed some old boys dancing what we now refer to as Border Morris and commented 'it is a bastardisation of the true Cotswold morris' and ignored it. That was an appalling mistake in my opinion.
I'm unaware of all he collected or ignored. He was important in keeping some things going, and perhaps raising our awareness of traditional things. A bit of a marmite person perhaps?
Q
-
He was Sharp, not Sharpe. Adding the "e" requires you to be able to say "b@stard" in a Yorkshire accent, a lot, while being unable to consistently pronounce the letters "ean."http://forum.melodeon.net/Smileys/default/smiley.gif
He never ventured far enough North to see North West, so was dismissive of it from a position of ignorance; this is why most NW teams would not toast the Immortal Memory. I believe the quote on Border morris referred to it as a "degenerate form" and some teams have always aspired to that!
His contribution was undoubtedly to create a form of notation for the dance which enabled it to be recreated with relative consistency.http://forum.melodeon.net/Smileys/default/aemo_morris.gif
-
jonm: Ooopps sorry, spelling was never a strong point!
Yes to be fair, when he first saw Headington he'd never seen anything like it, so creating a notation, or at least *having* to create some method of writing down what he saw was quite innovative and quite a formidable task in itself.
Q
-
....and however critical we ( and I ) can be of Sharpe, without him we would have probably lost the Morris.
Q
I am far from convinced that this is true. I wonder if morris survived and flourishes today, in spite of, not because of, C#.
William Kimber was not exactly an ignorant yokel blindly twitching in the last threshes. He was a skilled artisan in his work life, and the ...art??... he was practicing was something vibrant and current. C# tried to pickle it.
The history of morris is littered with stories of revivals.
-
jonm: Ooopps sorry, spelling was never a strong point!
Yes to be fair, when he first saw Headington he'd never seen anything like it, so creating a notation, or at least *having* to create some method of writing down what he saw was quite innovative and quite a formidable task in itself.
Q
And judging from the film clips in the programme,he was clearly not a dancer!
-
Greg, you may well be right. I would think though, as articulate as Kimber was, C# allowed him to become known and be a celebrity.
I'm not sure that would have happened without the catalyst of C#, but who knows.....
At that time there was no tv, internet etc. and people were very parochial, so this odd dance that had been known in the Cotswolds for a long time might have just stayed in the Cotswolds. Maybe.
GPS, on the contrary, by all accounts he was!
I have had the pleasure of meeting 3 people early on in my dancing life, around late '70's - early '80's, then very elderly and who knew or met Sharp.
At the time we had a dancer with us who was classically trained and went on to ballet and dance training. He was an incredible dancer. A wonderful old lady remembers serving tea to Sharp at the Albermarle Centre as a young girl of about 16 years old, and then being asked to dance. She pointed out our dancer and said he was like Sharp, lithe and poised, an accomplished dancer were her thoughts.
I suspect the clip was not a true reflection of him as a morris dancer.
Q
-
I've never heard it suggested that women just don't play (melodeon or whatever) like men. So why shouldn't they play for "men's" morris events? That possibly says more about the morris as a boys' club than it does, say, about a split between Cecil Sharp and Mary Neal.
Oh the scandal when I turned up to play for Spring Grove Morris Men and they only had five men. Sadly the beard was not in my melodeon bag that day so I was unable to reprise my role as 'Bernard' and just had to dance in the SGM set in SGM kit as an actual WOMAN. At the time the team had an associated mixed team but I didn't have those baldrics with me so I DANCED IN THE MEN'S KIT.
No one was injured in the process. I danced at two for most of the day and instigated some mixed scratch morris in the evening when numbers dwindled.
-
Swoon... ;D
-
Greg, you may well be right. I would think though, as articulate as Kimber was, C# allowed him to become known and be a celebrity.
I'm not sure that would have happened without the catalyst of C#, but who knows.....
Q
My point is that the perpetuation of the morris did not not come from celebrity. Quite the opposite. Celebrity nearly killed it.
Mr Sharp had the narrowest of narrow view points, which could easily have resulted in the demise of everything except his favoured forms of morris and morris practice.
Look at the vigour of what what survived in other parts of the country. This wasn't Sharp's doing and it happened without the need for fame.
Anyway, back to melodeons...
-
And did Cecil ever express any opinions regarding melodeons ? I can make some guesses ! >:E
J
-
This is such an interesting thread! I would agree that Cecil Sharp probably was instrumental at preserving morris and English country dance, but clearly at the same time he ossified it in an unnatural way and overlaid many of his own personal biases or interpretations on the material. I think one of the Brass Monkey CDs keeps going on in the liner notes about Sharp's "bizarre editorial choices" (such as naming the "Radstock Jig" when it clearly is not a jig).
Of course once you introduce the pursuit of a wholesome hobby in the name of tradition the dynamic shifts dramatically and the nipping off to the pub with your mates becomes a noble pursuit.
Ah, but was morris dance considered a wholesome hobby back then? My very first exposure to morris dancing was in an old 1971 episode of "Doctor Who" in which a country village's morris side (played by Headington Quarry!) surround the Doctor on the village green while dancing "Young Collins", trap him with their sticks, and tie him to the maypole to the strains of "The Black Joke". It did seem like there was a predisposition to considering them a bit shifty at the time!
-
My very first exposure to morris dancing was in an old 1971 episode of "Doctor Who" in which a country village's morris side (played by Headington Quarry!) surround the Doctor on the village green while dancing "Young Collins", trap him with their sticks, and tie him to the maypole to the strains of "The Black Joke". It did seem like there was a predisposition to considering them a bit shifty at the time!
Mine? The year would have been about 1977. I was in the beer garden of the Rose and Crown pub in Cotgrave, Nottingham. My Dad was inside the pub and I was sitting there with my bottle of coke with a straw and a packet of salt'n'shake. The morris men (probably Dolphin or Sherwood Foresters given the geography) were dancing in the beer garden. One of the villagers, sitting on a low wall, said something along the lines of 'I think these bloody morris men are a bunch of (insert homophobic term of your choice here)'. One of the lead morris men turned to his heckler and punched him square on the nose, knocking him backwards off the wall on which he was sitting. Five year old Nellie put down her crisps to watch.
-
My very first exposure to morris dancing was in an old 1971 episode of "Doctor Who" in which a country village's morris side (played by Headington Quarry!) surround the Doctor on the village green while dancing "Young Collins", trap him with their sticks, and tie him to the maypole to the strains of "The Black Joke". It did seem like there was a predisposition to considering them a bit shifty at the time!
For me it was mentions in Pratchett's books (which weren't very informative) and the endless quips in Red Dwarf. The latter definitely made me prejudiced.
-
My very first exposure to morris dancing was...
...at the Village Pump Folk Dance and Song Club at a huge pub (The Bell?) on the Binley Road(?) in Coventry
in the '69-'70 academic year. It was a rapper side - I can still remember the buzz I got when they did that
business with the interlocked swords. It was also an interesting juxtaposition of 'ritual' and 'social' dance...
The second was Abingdon on May Day in '71.
I didn't realise it at the time, but those two outings were quite a contrast.
-
Devon County Show 1976.
I remember saying it was good to see but something I'd never do. In just over a year I joined a side and have never escaped. Never wanted to...
Q
-
My very first exposure to morris dancing was...
...at the Village Pump Folk Dance and Song Club at a huge pub (The Bell?) on the Binley Road(?) in Coventry
in the '69-'70 academic year. It was a rapper side - I can still remember the buzz I got when they did that
business with the interlocked swords. It was also an interesting juxtaposition of 'ritual' and 'social' dance...
The second was Abingdon on May Day in '71.
I didn't realise it at the time, but those two outings were quite a contrast.
The Bull's Head, Binley Road, run (the club, that is, not the pub!) by Jim Brannnigan. In 69/70 there would have been two choices of rapper side in the West Midlands - Green Man or Wayfarers. It would probably have been us (Wayfarers) as we had quite close ties with The Village Pump. If so, I'm glad we were able to inspire you!
Graham
-
For me it was mentions in Pratchett's books (which weren't very informative) and the endless quips in Red Dwarf. The latter definitely made me prejudiced.
:D The first time I ever danced morris was doing the Stick and Bucket dance in performances of Mr Pratchet's Lord's and Ladies, under the tutalage of one Ivor Read, the, then, Squire of Trigg Morrismen. Topical comment alert (well, nearly): I just discovered that they have become a mixed side and are inviting ladies to join. The times they really are a changing.
My first exposure was probably by the Two Ronnies
-
Superb programme. It explored tradition, sociology, history, and quite frankly a few modern social trends pretty bravely, well shot, and a personal journey too!
Personal journey: I joined Sallyport sword at 27, to watch the team fall apart in front of me (all happy again now). Switched to Newcastle MM, and slowly moved to musicanship after age 33 when my wife bought me 1st melodeon (my attempts at concertina was torturing both wife, and cat)! Career then took me to Wirral and joining Mersey Morris … a lot of instant friends. Isn't that what it's all about?
-
Having read the various comments and opinions on this this thread I settled down this evening to watch the program with some trepidation and was pleasantly surprised. I thought it was in fact a lovely example of serious TV journalism dealing carefully with a tricky subject and at the same time entertaining and possibly educating the audience. A follow up in three or four years time would be very interesting.
-
The Bull's Head, Binley Road...
Thanks. I wasn't sure I'd got the pub name correct! A great club - I first saw Finbar and Eddie Furey there too...