Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sean McCann on April 28, 2019, 01:34:30 PM
-
Hey all,
I've got a B/C 21 button Hohner with 12 basses and I'm interested in changing the bass layout. I've gotten a few suggestions which I'll
post below, but I'd like to hear your thoughts/suggestions.
The current layout is:
B \ E+|A+ G+|D+
e / E|A G|D
l \ C+|F+ C+|G+
l / C|F C|G
o \D#+|A#+ B+|F#+
w / D#|A# B|F#
s \
where: E|A= E on the push, A on the pull
where: E+|A+= E chord on the push, A chord on the pull, etc.
The two suggested layouts I've gotten are:
B \ B+|F#+ D#+|A#+ b \ B+|F#+ D#+|A#+
e / B|F# D#|A# e / B|F# D#|A#
l \ E+|A+ G+|D+ l \ E+|A+ D+|D+
l / E|A G|D and l / E|A D|D
o \ D+|F+ C+|G+ o \ C+|* G+|G+
w / D|F C|G w / C|F G|G
s \ s \
The * indicating B and F# reeds, which would make a D6 when combined with the D on the draw, and a Gmaj7 with the G.
I think I'm leaning towards as combination of the two but would like to hear any thoughts or suggestions from other accordion players.
Thanks!
-Sean
-
I have a hohner black dot dpuble ray with 12 'stradella'' bass ( same notes both push ad pull) which I find particularly useful as the operation of the bass and treble are completely independent of each other. Bass and major chords for FCGDAE
george
-
May I ask why you're considering a change ?
One thing: you could remove the third (D#) from the B+ chord to get the * pair (B and F# reeds) and also keep the F+ chord.
-
I find it difficult to play accompaniment for many tunes in D with my current layout. None of the basses sound good with the F#’s that are so common in D tunes, that’s the biggest reason, and since D is a pretty common key for Irish tunes I’d like to be able to add in accompaniment for that key.
-
My layout for what it's worth:
Bellows
C/F A/A E/E
G/G D/D B/B
No thirds. It's the chords as per the John Williams layout but not in the same places.
F# would be nice to have, but it's only really a requirement for the B minor tunes and even then A mostly works.
Assuming you are playing Irish music then you won't find much use for Bb(A#) or Eb(D#).
-
I’m not sure if you’ve seen this page...near the bottom, with semitone box layouts. But in case you haven’t ... it might help wrt 12 bass..well a bit anyway.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard_2_row.html
-
I find it difficult to play accompaniment for many tunes in D with my current layout. None of the basses sound good with the F#’s that are so common in D tunes, that’s the biggest reason, and since D is a pretty common key for Irish tunes I’d like to be able to add in accompaniment for that key.
I know it's a silly question and I know zilch about B/C boxes, but is your bass end in tune with your treble end? F# is the third of D..so it's in the D major chord. If the two F# reeds don't sound sweet together my first thought would be a tuning issue.
-
I find it difficult to play accompaniment for many tunes in D with my current layout. None of the basses sound good with the F#’s that are so common in D tunes, that’s the biggest reason, and since D is a pretty common key for Irish tunes I’d like to be able to add in accompaniment for that key.
I know it's a silly question and I know zilch about B/C boxes, but is your bass end in tune with your treble end? F# is the third of D..so it's in the D major chord. If the two F# reeds don't sound sweet together my first thought would be a tuning issue.
Peadar, I think Sean is referring to the fact that his current layout does not have a D chord on the push, and since the right-hand note of F# on a B/C box is on the push, he cannot sound a chord of D against an F#.
This is why all the various modern B/C bass layouts (e.g. McComiskey, Burke, Nolan) all have a D chord in both directions.
-
I'm considering having my 12 bass B/C black dot DLX converted from unisonoric F, C, G, D, A, E (thirds are already removed) I want a bisonoric C/F added to the rest to give C/F, G, A, E, B - I think this is the arrangement John Williams uses on his 12 bass Saltarelles and it makes a lot of sense because B mi occurs commonly in Irish tunes. I'm used to only having push C and draw F on modern Irish 8 bass layouts.
-
Peadar, I think Sean is referring to the fact that his current layout does not have a D chord on the push, and since the right-hand note of F# on a B/C box is on the push, he cannot sound a chord of D against an F#.
Stiamh, Thanks for explaining that- I learn something new every day.