Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Rog on May 03, 2019, 03:49:12 PM
-
Some of the biggest Hohner bass reeds 'moo' when you drive a lot of air through them quickly. I’m not sure if this is because they are fatigued. I admit I’m talking about (in particular) the G and the C bass reed (in a few Hohner PAs....but not all, so something is going on) though you do find them in the Trichord so I think I am allowed to ask here.. :D)
Not all the bass reeds do this and the only variables I can think of are: the setting, the tuning and the valve, which can allow more or less air through depending on how it is glued, how stiff it is.
The moo is when the reed takes a moment to settle into its pitch. It drops a bit and then settles in.
Is there a trick to stopping this? Big bass reeds tend to be a bit flat of the higher ones anyway, and sharpening a little bit reduces the moo, and tinkering with the set seems to help. But can anyone give me a cast iron chapter and verse on the cause and a solution? These reeds are long and have weights, so maybe they have just lost some of their spring which is why they moo..?
-
"maybe they have just lost some of their spring which is why they moo..?"
Instead of baaa, I suppose, which they might do if they hadn't missed their spring.
(Yes, OK, I'm going back to my hibernation!)
-
These reeds are long and have weights, so maybe they have just lost some of their spring which is why they moo..?
I think the weights have something to do with it, however old or new.
-
I think it’s also how this person plays. The pitch on the bigger reeds lowers the more air I push through, but with an aggressive push or pull the reed takes a moment to start so it’s pitch wavers..hence the mooing sound.