Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Kon on May 04, 2019, 08:00:12 PM

Title: Getting started with GC
Post by: Kon on May 04, 2019, 08:00:12 PM
Hi all,

I'm a new member and looking to start playing the melodeon. I have fallen in love with the sound of the instrument listening to the likes of Andy Cutting, Cyrille Brotto and Remi Geffroy and would love to learn to play myself.

I've got a few questions about getting started. First and foremost I would love to actually get my hands on a box! Do any members live around Cambridge (UK) or have acquaintances here who would be prepared to let me have a squeeze, or even borrow or rent a box (or give a couple of beginner's lessons)? I am hoping to buy a melodeon soon but don't have much spare cash at the moment and would like to get hands-on with a box before spending lots of money.

Secondly, thinking ahead to buying an instrument, based on the style of music I enjoy and would want to play I am thinking a fourth-apart box would be best suited, and I am drawn to a GC melodeon (liking the mellower sound of the lower-pitched instruments) but wouldn't be choosy about key, as I am unlikely to be playing with other people in the foreseeable future. It seems that a standard 2-row 8-bass instrument is the best starting point. Does this all sound sensible? If anybody has a working box that meets these criteria that they could imagine selling for around £200, or advice on how to find one, I would be very interested. Obviously not expecting the world from a melodeon at this price point, just something that plays would be enough to get me started - but let me know if you think I am deluded to hope to find something usable for that amount of money.

Last but not least I am curious about the pros and cons of starting out on a one-row. I am drawn to a two-row because it seems like that would offer a greater range, and because I really like those long cross-row melodies, but it seems much easier to lay hands on a cheap one-row, and I wondered whether that might be a good starter instrument.

I look forward to reading your replies, and to joining in the forum as I learn more. Cheers!

Konrad

(EDIT: title modified to be more informative/specific)
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: playandteach on May 04, 2019, 10:15:54 PM
It all sounds sensible. I would, however, choose your key not on the sonority but on the type of pieces you might like to learn. If you like English pieces, then DG is probably wiser, if you like French, then GC works well. You can of course apply any learning to any keyed box, but it does make some sense to pick according to style. Andy Cutting may play different keyed boxes to Remi Geffroy.
In terms of cost, you may have less luck picking up a GC for £200. Hiring a box is the way I started - I think it was £25 per month, which was with someone who trusted I would look after it well. That way you might get something really pretty decent to learn on.
You don't mention if you have any previous musical experience, which may impact on your ability to pick up some tunes quickly. I'm sure the Cambridge based melnetters will be out in force to support you. There is a Bb Eb old Hohner on Ebay which was up for bids of £150 or so.
Buying from a player on here is a really great idea, as I can't think of anyone who would sell you something unusable - ebay is a different story as most people don't really know how badly in need of restoration their attic finds are, or how expensive that restoration could be.
Good luck, and I'm keen to hear how you get on.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on May 04, 2019, 10:46:19 PM
Thanks for the reply playandteach!

You are right of course - I believe Andy Cutting plays in DG typically, whereas GC seems more common with the French players I enjoy. I am probably more drawn to the French style at the moment, but suspect that may change over time.

I did use to play the piano, but have not had access to an instrument to practise on for the last 6 years, so am far worse than rusty, but hopeful that some basic music theory and note reading ability will stand me in good stead.

I will update you here on any progress! Fingers crossed I can work out an affordable hire arrangement similar to yours.

Konrad

Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Tufty on May 05, 2019, 03:38:58 PM
There are a few C/F boxes around in your price range, usually older Hohner types. C/F fits between D/G and G/C in tone, so would be flexible. Downside being not many people in UK play C/F as their main box. So fewer chances to play together. 
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Alan Pittwood on May 05, 2019, 05:04:51 PM
There are other tonal possibilities between G/C and D/G:

A/D
Bb/Eb

But always think about playing with others.  Doing so will make learning easier and more rewarding.

Also remember that as musicians we play for others - best to dance and but sometimes to listen.   Finding opportunities for either of these may help to make your learning more focussed.

D/G is the best advice.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Theo on May 05, 2019, 05:16:29 PM
DG is I’m sure the dominant system among players of English and in particular Morris music.  But if you are drawn towards French music then it’s not really suitable.  For that you need a GC, or possibly AD.  There is a thriving European music scene in many parts of England where you will find kindred spirits and many GC players.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on May 06, 2019, 12:37:57 AM
Thanks all for the helpful advice! Plenty to think about. The generally lower price-point of the slightly less common CF/AD/BbEb boxes is attractive, but GC seems like a better choice if it best suits the style I enjoy. For now, however, this remains a purely academic question, as I can't justify spending the money on buying a box before I've even tried one out!

I suppose visiting a shop would be a good way of trying out a few boxes, any suggestions on what might be the nearest shop with a good selection? Might it be possible to visit one of the forum's fettlers and have a go on some of the boxes they've got for sale at the time? There doesn't seem to be anybody particularly near Cambridge, but I have family in the North-East, so could come visit the Box Place, if you'd have me Theo, when I'm next up - though that won't be for a few months.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Dick Rees on May 06, 2019, 01:44:06 AM
Kon...

Welcome to the world of diatonics.  I also am a big fan of the sonority of the G/C boxes.  I heartily endorse your choice of a G/C for your first box...

Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 06, 2019, 08:19:15 AM
As others have hinted at, it's good to be able to play along with other melodeonists, perhaps in sessions or in small workshop groups or even one-to-one lessons (Mel Biggs does excellent lessons via Skype (https://melbiggsmusic.co.uk/teaching/skype-lessons/)). Playing along with others is a great way to learn very quickly. But to do this, you ideally need to obtain an instrument in the same pitch which is most used in your locality. In the Cambridge area (and indeed much of England) this will be D/G. There are morris sides who will have helpful melodeon playing musicians, and sessions too. If you start a thread along the lines of "Melodeon players in the Cambridge area" and asking for help, you should get some useful responses from forum members.

I note your interest in French music. While there are some G/C players around in England, it is still not the normal choice for most, so you may be struggling to find similar players nearby. A lot of French music is playable on a D/G melodeon.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Theo on May 06, 2019, 08:48:26 AM
You are welcome to visit The Box Place when you are in the NE.  Please contact me to arrange a time.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on May 06, 2019, 09:45:50 AM
Haha, looks like opinions continue to be divided for/against GC for a starter box - thanks both for the input Dick and Steve.

I will start a thread with a more informative title to search for players in my area, thanks for the hint Steve.

I look forward to meeting you when the opportunity arises Theo!
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Winston Smith on May 06, 2019, 10:26:09 AM
I had a G/C for a while, and I loved the sound of it. I've also had a few in D/G which I've got rid of because I find the squeaky sound quite offensive, of course that might have more to do with my playing or dodgy hearing, or the way the instrument has been set up and tuned (or not tuned, as the case may be!).
Surely a 2+ row G/C would be an ideal tuning option, offering the lovely lower tone plus the facility to join in with the French loving lot, whilst it could also be played from the outside in (with any required C#'s on the + row) when in D/G land? It would certainly seem to be a way to overcome my current aversion, other than having an octave tuned D/G. (I'm suggesting this from a position of musical ignorance, btw or perhaps obviously!)
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Squeaky Pete on May 06, 2019, 10:53:45 AM
You can play anything you like as long as you are playing on your own. French stuff that is normally played in C on the inside row of a GC box will sound higher if you are using a DG box and English tunes you would play in D on the outer row of a DG will sound lower on the outer row of a GC.
It only really matters when you play with other instruments, and ultimately that's what I imagine you want to do.
Fiddle tunes seem to be in G and D and occasionally A as it's an easy reach in the first position. Country fiddlers made use of the D and G open strings to give a bit more oomph and volume to their playing. It doesn't really affect  you why it happened, but the the result is most people play English stuff on a DG box .
French stuff on the other hand is more driven by hurdy-gurdy players and pipers. The natural scale of the pipes made these days is G, which is C with a middle hole start. Gurdies are much the same.

Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Winston Smith on May 06, 2019, 11:55:14 AM
"French stuff that is normally played in C on the inside row of a GC box will sound higher if you are using a DG box"

As I imagined, and unpleasant to my ear.

"English tunes you would play in D on the outer row of a DG will sound lower on the outer row of a GC."

Also as I experienced with my own G/C (but with the missing note!?) and much easier on my ear.

Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Peadar on May 06, 2019, 03:41:33 PM
Kon,

You can save yourself so much trouble if you just start with a real melodeon i.e. 1 row!

Joking aside you need to get your hands on a box and start learning how the in-out action of this- the original form of the accordion- works between your hands. I started with a Hohner 1040 in G (two voice, no stops, no frills) which came with the caveat that it is in tune with itself would probably need tuning if I wanted to play in sessions-as someone else said- tuning isn't an issue (unless you have perfect pitch) until you want to play with others. It lives under a napkin in the kitchen and I consider it  Eu115 well spent.

Put it this way....If you are prepared/can afford to spend £25/month on a hire accordion to get started, then a one row at that sort of price pays for itself while you learn a few tunes which in turn will give you a sense of what  (relative to the one you already have) an accordion feels like when you get a chance to try one in a fettler's shop.

Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Winston Smith on May 06, 2019, 04:11:57 PM
I'd like to say "Amen" to Peader's post. I too started on a 1 row (but not a fancy Hohner!) mine cost £7.01 and it turned me into a raving sufferer of MAD within a relatively short period of time! Although the cross-row style of playing which so many players prefer, does come with a bit of difficulty after playing on just 1 row all the time, I don't think that the problem is insurmountable to anyone with the will to do it.
I love my 1 rows to bits!
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Nigel on May 06, 2019, 04:41:32 PM
I'm selling an old Hohner GC. I've sent a Pm about this and PlayGroup.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Larry Powers on May 06, 2019, 04:43:07 PM
As a beginner myself I will offer this.  It would be best to buy a melodeon that is suitable for the music you like and to learn using the music you like.  I struggled off an on for years trying to learn to play an instrument.  Typically lessons were formulaic, designed for kids and used music I did not care for.  I would start, get bored and quit.  Wait a few years and do it again.  Now I have fallen in love with Quebecois music and I have a teacher who is a Quebecois player and we are using Quebecois tunes (and I have time since I am recently retired).  I am quite happy and making reasonable for an old retired guy. 

I don't know much about G/C but I would recommend that you locate some good books or dvd's that teach two row G/C or locate a teacher who teaches using two row G/C and a repertoire that will hold your interest before buying your first melodeon.  And as others have mentioned it would be good if there is a group in your area that you can meet up with and eventually play with.

That being said I have found that resources for playing D/G are the most common.  If after looking for resources for learning G/C you find they are not abundant in your area then a D/G may be the way to go to learn and it will leave you with a reason to buy a second melodeon in G/C as you progress.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Theo on May 06, 2019, 04:50:03 PM
Here is a link to the Cambridge French Dance group (https://www.cambridgefolk.org.uk/cam-french/).  It includes links to similar groups several of which are also in the Southeast.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Theo on May 06, 2019, 04:56:37 PM
Here is a decent looking Hohner Erica GC on ebay.   It has a new Acorn keyboard fitted which shows that it's been looked after.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Hohner-Erica-GC-melodeon/323796363208
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: -Y- on May 06, 2019, 05:26:25 PM
It all sounds sensible. I would, however, choose your key not on the sonority but on the type of pieces you might like to learn. If you like English pieces, then DG is probably wiser, if you like French, then GC works well. You can of course apply any learning to any keyed box, but it does make some sense to pick according to style.

I don't really understand this argument. Our instruments are transposing instruments. True, the pitch will change depending on the tuning, and it may not produce exactly the same effect, but if you go for a fourth-apart system, the style with which you play is by far more important than the pitch of the instrument (the same cannot be told for semitone-apart system).
You could very well play French style pieces with a D/G instrument, it will only sound higher. It may be related to the fact that, broadly speaking, the key of any tune does not really matter in French traditional music (whereas it's not the case for Irish music, I don't know how British music is in that respect), you just play it at the pitch that suits you.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: playandteach on May 06, 2019, 05:34:15 PM
It all sounds sensible. I would, however, choose your key not on the sonority but on the type of pieces you might like to learn. If you like English pieces, then DG is probably wiser, if you like French, then GC works well. You can of course apply any learning to any keyed box, but it does make some sense to pick according to style.

I don't really understand this argument.
It's not really an argument, just a view, and for two reasons. The first is that tunes that go quite high on GC boxes (Chevaux de Bois  (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wTxO--ffIKQ)for example - this is David Henley playing from this forum) can sound very squeaky on DG boxes. The second reason is that if you know you like the music from one of those two countries then you might as well get a box that means you can play along with youtube recordings, even if you don't want to play with others. It also helps you learn from video where you get a good idea of which buttons to use.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Dick Rees on May 06, 2019, 07:05:42 PM
I have generally played solo or been the band leader, so I play the pitch I like and the fiddlers have to lump it.  As a fiddler myself that doesn't seem like a big deal.

 I think there are a few other issues in box preference:

1.  For D/G you have 3rd or 4th button start.

2.  LH/bass layout as to how the bass notes relate to each other.  I find the C low of the G/C to have a     better feel for comping and bass runs whereas the D/G seems "jumpy" when instead of a one step interval I get something an octave off.

3.  Club layout/gleichton.  I'll admit I like it, especially for O'Carolan tunes and anything needing that one "extra" chord/bass on the pull.

But I'll admit to loving the challenge of being able to play everything on one 21/8 box...in one way or another.  If I had to play in "other peoples keys" I'd just take my little Weltmeister 60 bass or a Melodica.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on May 07, 2019, 02:16:53 AM
This is getting beyond my abilities to reply to everyone individually, but just wanted to say I really appreciate everybody's input and am reading along attentively - thank you for your comments and suggestions.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Peadar on May 07, 2019, 08:03:46 PM
Don't worry. It's part of the nature of this forum. If you scroll up you'll probably find that most of the questions bear no relation to the question you originally posed.

If you haven't decided on your ideal/immediately attainable starter box by now I suggest going down to your nearest music shop and buying a "Chanson" child's button accordion ( The Busker is an alternative model...which appears to come off the same production line). Either way it will set you back about  £25 (£22 for the box and £3 for the busfare to the music shop).

For that modest investment you get a small but genuine 2 octave box in C. Sure it has limited capabilities, but you can use it to learn to play a scale , use the air button and play a few simple tunes. Do not under-rate "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star". It is also a box you can let your mates try without too much anxiety.

PS I am the proud owner of a Chanson...so is my 6 year old grandson.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Howard Jones on May 08, 2019, 12:15:23 PM
1.  For D/G you have 3rd or 4th button start.

I think it's probably worth explaining this.  Because the D/G is higher pitched than other melodeons, we tend to play in the lower octave, whereas a G/C for example is usually played in the higher octave.  This means we may find we don't have some of the notes when the tune drops too low. 

Starting the scale on the 3rd button, which is standard, you have the choice of having the top (chin end) buttons tuned as either lower notes in the scale or as accidentals.  At some stage in your playing you will find you need both.  Starting the scale on the 4th button allows you to have both a pair of low notes and a pair of accidentals, at the expense of some very high notes at the knee end which you'll probably never require.  This is so useful it is starting to become the standard D/G layout with some makers.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on May 08, 2019, 03:16:53 PM
Thanks for explaining that in more detail Howard! I must admit it did go over my head at the time. I assume the same problem doesn't arise on a GC, for the reason you mentioned (playing in the higher octave) - does that mean a 3rd button start with accidentals on the chin end are standard on GC?
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Dick Rees on May 08, 2019, 04:44:02 PM
Thanks for explaining that in more detail Howard! I must admit it did go over my head at the time. I assume the same problem doesn't arise on a GC, for the reason you mentioned (playing in the higher octave) - does that mean a 3rd button start with accidentals on the chin end are standard on GC?

Yes.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on June 19, 2019, 10:09:33 AM
An update on this as promised:

I have bought Nigel's old GC Erica and am pleased to bits with it, and I had a lovely time at the North-East melodeon playgroup, where I learned to play a tune thanks to heartshaped1's excelllent tuition.

Now my plan is to get on with practising and learning a second tune. I have just ordered Pignol & Milleret Vol. 1 and hope to steadily work my way through that, supplemented with tuition and/or playing with others as or when opportunities arise.

Thanks again for your help and the friendly introduction to the forum!
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Michael Montcombroux on June 19, 2019, 04:31:01 PM
Kon, as a GC player myself (Castagnari Brancu), I followed this threat with interest. My take on the Milleret books is that they are excellent but often challenging (read quirky) for a beginner. I gravitated to the more user-friendly Yann Dour Accordéon diatonique, Le livre du débutant (vol 1 of 2 in French and English) available from:
www.editionscaruhel.wix.com/site-officiel
The Yann Dour learning curve is far less steep and, in my humble opinion, much more fun, without wishing to knock P&M.
Michael
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on June 19, 2019, 09:06:57 PM
Thanks for the input Michael! I had stumbled across Yann Dour, and my current plan is to buy Le livre du débutant once I get fed up or bored with M&P - just figured I may as well start with one, and I am at least theoretically drawn to M&P's apparently more technical approach. We shall see!

If you have any other advice for starting out in GC I am all ears!
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: richard.fleming on June 20, 2019, 08:46:56 AM
All the difficulties of choosing which system - which might have huge implications for your future as a melodeon player - would be put off if you chose to play a one-row. The advice you get here is a peculiar mixture because while people are often knowledgeable and want to be helpful, most people think the system they play is the best way to go. I have strong views too but I'll not trouble you with them because what you need is to get to a point where you can see for yourself which way to go, and playing a one-row might keep you going as an aspiring player while you work this out. It might be cheaper,  it wouldn't matter too much which key it was in because playing up and down the row can be transferred to any box, and whatever you learn will never have to be unlearned in the future. And don't base your choice on the idea that you will be playing by yourself, because you are almost inevitably going to find  that playing with other people is where you get the real buzz.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: playandteach on June 20, 2019, 10:49:59 AM
Richard, I think Kon has made a start by buying a GC box, but I agree that with my own playing the GC style of French tunes in A minor leaves holes in the push pull techniques that might be supported by one row practise. However, in the mean time there's plenty to get on with on the GC.
Kon, do let me know if I can be of help, either in suggesting tunes or in any other way. GC is my thing, although I'm not as experienced as many players here.
I recently did a couple of videos on playing right hand chords to learn where the notes are.
Title: Re: Getting started
Post by: Kon on June 20, 2019, 03:42:57 PM
Thanks playandteach!

I really enjoy your videos, particularly your own compositions, and I have got those exercises earmarked to incorporate into my practice, thanks. They seem like a useful way to get to know the keyboard and also to start adding RH harmonies to melodies, which I enjoy in the music I listen to.

But for now I think getting a couple of tunes working right and left hand together might take priority. Thought maybe that's the wrong way round to think about it?

How did you get started then? I hear that you are/have been a professional musician, so your starting point will have been very different to mine now, but I saw in a discussion of the Milleret and Pignol books elsewhere that you didn't get those until you'd been playing for a while and skipped straight to Vol. 2. So I'm curious what you used to get started on the instrument - tuition? Tunes? And whether you have any tips on habits to encourage or avoid in practicing.

In particular, if you have any recommendations of starter-friendly tunes with a French-y feel I would be very grateful, as most of the beginner tunes I've seen so far fall fairly squarely into Morris/English folk territory, which is less my taste. To complicate matters slightly I am currently without a G# at the moment, not sure how much that will restrict the repertoire (my box has low notes instead of accidentals, which I will be changing soon...).
Title: Re: Getting started with GC
Post by: playandteach on June 20, 2019, 07:02:34 PM
A minor is the base key for a lot of French stuff, and 3/4 is the most common time signature of the stuff I started playing - of course there are huge numbers of other dance tunes in different time signatures. But for me I waded in with waltzes and mazurkas. As a Delicq fan I played some of his very early in my learning curve.
I also used the Loffet site for pieces which come with tablature. Even if you are a fluent reader this can help as it will give you an indication of whether to try the G chord on the push or pull etc.
If you pm me your email I can send a bunch of stuff through. Probably at the weekend. I was a clarinet player by profession for about 30 years. It is surprisingly similar in right hand shape. Although I do play the piano, I never found the piano accordion sat well in the right hand - a very different hand position, but the clarinet 'hand' slips perfectly onto a melodeon.
If you're keen to get going before I can send you stuff I'd have a look at the Bear Dance, Valse a Ollu, En avant Blonde and Valse Triste.
Here's Loffet's site.
http://diato.org/tablat.htm
Don't click on the navigation link, it just gives you midi files for some reason, just scroll down until you see the tunes, but I've attached those tunes from the site anyway.
For what it's worth, because I never saw the 2 row melodeon as 2 separate keys, the cross rowing is entirely ergonomic. My fingers don't even feel that they go across, it is just like moving up a piano keyboard, and it still surprises me when I see my hand in the video screen changing rows, because they just feel like one continuous scale (first bar of Valse a Ollu for example).
Good luck.
Title: Re: Getting started with GC
Post by: Kon on June 20, 2019, 07:25:44 PM
Thanks for this P&T! Will PM you too, though this should see me through for a while. (And all without G# too!)

Really appreciate your support. That looks like a lovely selection of starter tunes, and the tablature is really helpful as reading the music and figuring out where it fits on the box are still very much two separate steps for me.

Interesting comment re cross-rowing. I will see if I can use that idea. The one or two tunes I can play so far are more or less on the one row, but given that long-term I am more interested in music played across rows it makes sense to me to disregard the concept of separate rows, as you suggest.
Title: Re: Getting started with GC
Post by: Kon on July 23, 2019, 10:53:45 PM
Have shared a first recording to the "Beginners Showcase", wanted to link to it here in case anyone's interested. Thanks for everybody's help in getting me started!

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9228.msg288843.html#msg288843
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal