Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Richard J Delong on May 06, 2019, 08:54:28 AM

Title: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Richard J Delong on May 06, 2019, 08:54:28 AM
Hello!

I've been searching through past discussions about shoulder straps and, although I'm a beginner and have no experience playing with them yet, I've concluded that I'd like to begin with two shoulder straps (then try the one just over the right shoulder, as I see used so effectively by many of you!) - so it's not my intention to open a debate about strap preference necessarily, but rather to ask advice on what type of double straps may fit a Pokerwork well?  I recently found these nice looking double straps made by Neotech (sold through the Button Box) for a reasonable price -

https://www.buttonbox.com/accessories.html#DoubleStraps

Has anyone used these for a similar sixed box to a Pokerwork?

Also (if you can open the link above), has anyone used the Neotech Harness Straps that appear to have the additional back belt design as well?  This seems like it could have its advantages and feel really supportive, but perhaps a bit more restrictive than the first pair mentioned above?

In general I anticipate playing while seated and don't foresee standing much.

Any advice on specific types of straps and where to purchase them (ideally in the US, but I'm open to any suggestions) would be very much appreciated!  Lastly, I'll be placing an order for pallet felt from Mr. Charlie Marshall soon, so if someone is familiar with his strap selection and has a recommendation it could be good timing.

I should mention that my budget is very much on the 'economy' end of the spectrum (less than $40 US would be ideal...)!

Thank you all so much for your advice!

Rich
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Winston Smith on May 06, 2019, 09:59:53 AM
I'd offer a word of warning here; after trying a good number of strap lengths and arrangements, I now just play with a thumb strap and the box over my knee as I couldn't find a pair of straps which allowed a comfortable playing position. It's probably due to me having a typical beer belly (although I don't drink it!) and I cannot get away with the one strap and crossed legs style either.
My experimental strap collection didn't cost me any money to speak of, but I'd hate to see a fellow, financially restricted, aficionado waste what little cash he may have available. Just saying!
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Theo on May 06, 2019, 10:27:50 AM
You should be able to improvise a temporary strap from a belt or luggage strap possibly with some bits of cord to join things together.  If you plan to play mainly sitting down a sing strap may be all you need.

With a light box like a pokerwork you may not need padded straps.  A single plain strap will be much cheaper than double padded straps.  Something like this from Charlie Marshall (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Shoulder_Straps.html#26) may be all you need.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Richard J Delong on May 06, 2019, 10:58:09 AM
Okay, thank you both - I'll put some more thought into this... I'm getting excited about the prospect of finding good support for the box to free up my hands more, particularly on the treble side as the thumb strap is just barely manageable (for me anyway, at this point) and gets a little uncomfortable and awkward... yep, looking forward to some strap set-up, even a simple arrangement, and the thought of moving more freely along the right side.

Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Theo on May 06, 2019, 11:20:23 AM
Don't expect any strap arrangement to give you instant results.  It takes time and practice to find a method that works for you so try the simplest methods first and give yourself at least a few weeks before you reject any one method. 
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve C. on May 06, 2019, 01:11:32 PM
The Italcinte 323 work very nice on the Pokerwork. Button Box have them. I think this is what CGM sells as well.
If you buy the long set, you can use it as a "one strap".  Depending on how tall you are, how long your arms, how high you like the the box, the medium might be enough.  I am 5'8 and find the medium to be fine with a few added holes. 
But I suppose you could do the same with the longer set and add extra holes to shorten, if needed.  Very nice straps.
(IMO) don't let the videos of a lot of the more experienced Melnetters fool you.  It is damn hard to hold the box steady when you are learning!  Plus with a nice light PW it is nice to play standing and walking around.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve C. on May 06, 2019, 02:52:52 PM
Richard, also, Theo's thoughts are right on.  Here are my "loaner" straps, they are ¾" web from the outdoor store, 52" each, plus added delrin "D" adjusters.  Cheap, don't scratch and fine for a PW since they are light. 
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: playandteach on May 06, 2019, 03:07:53 PM
I think those web straps with quick adjusters are also good for finding your length. It can be a bit of a pain to adjust stiff leather straps for playing around with different positions, particularly when you are covering up the buckles each time to stop the risk of scratching.
Personally I found it easier to find a strap position when standing up, as the box tends to find a place to sit making it obvious if it's too high or too low, whereas when sitting (it seems to me) there can be more options for trying to make the box sit right (distance from body, how to hold it against which leg etc.).
It's obviously a trial and error thing, but most two strappers have the right hand strap slightly longer than the left, so as not to cramp the right arm.
I bought some plain leather accordion straps on ebay from Poland (seller is called musicstickers1) for £14 plus postage and they look very good, but haven't used them yet.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 06, 2019, 06:30:46 PM
It was a revelation to me to be able to support my instrument by straps and free up my hands after coming from an English Concertina where its supported on thumb straps and little finger.
I use two straps and it took me a while to get them right. Every so often I'd mess around to try new positions. It takes a while to find your personal sweet spot.
I have the bass end slightly lower than the treble end, or to be more specific, the treble keyboard doesn't hang straight down my body, it leans out from the vertical slightly at the bottom.
I have tried to keep my arms, wrists and hands in a relaxed position with fairly straight lines. I have friends who have developed tendon problems from playing with a single loooong strap and wrist bent at a bad angle, so have tried to keep angles as gentle as possible.
...but that's me, others will be different!
Cheers
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: TomBom on May 06, 2019, 07:04:03 PM
I started using a pair of padded straps, after that unpadded ones. Now my favourite straps: a thin old camera strap and a shoelace for my left shoulder ...
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Winston Smith on May 06, 2019, 07:07:15 PM
TomBom, you sound like a man after my own heart!
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 06, 2019, 08:46:53 PM
Just a warning about the plastic 'dog-clip' fasters often found on the end of nylon webbing straps. The plastic clips are hard and rigid, and if you use them to attach the strap to the melodeon, sooner or later the plastic clip will dig in to the woodwork of the melodeon and leave an unsightly dent. The damage often occurs when the instrument is stored or carried in its case or gig bag and there is little clearance or flexibility around the clips.

A leather strap attached with traditional buckles is more flexible, and if the buckles are further protected with a leather or fabric sleeve, the risk of cosmetic damage is minimal.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 06, 2019, 09:51:43 PM
Does your wife not own a handbag or two with detachable shoulder straps? It is only convention to have both straps the same colour.

If the answer is no then visit a charity shop (you may call them thrift shops) and find a nice looking handbag which you think your good lady might like....just remember to remove the shoulder strap before you give her the bag.

Steve is right about these not being a good permanent solution but as an initial trial rig they will do no harm.

Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Richard J Delong on May 06, 2019, 10:16:29 PM
Excellent advice, thank you all. 

It's funny, even though my budget is a little tight at the moment (I'm becoming a full-time again at age 37 this fall...), I'm really feeling inclined to set myself up to learn as well as possible, and in my beginner's mind that has meant buying some plush gear!  But I really see the logic that strap preferences are not only unique to the player, but also take time to settle-into and require patience and adjustment...

I must admit that I'm still curious about the double Neotech straps with the back closure, as the (probably naive) thought of being "locked-in" and having both hands much more free to move sounds wonderful!  We'll see if I can resist spending money unnecessarily as an enthusiastic beginner, but that's not my strong suit...

As a note, I did just purchase an adjustable padded bass strap, and shiny bass feet from Mr. Marshall, along with enough felt to resurface the pallets on both sides.  I can't wait to dive into that, and I send my heartiest is THANK YOU to Lester for the empowering videos!  I feel like I already know the innards of a Pokerwork without ever having turned a screw yet.  Thank you so much Lester for taking the time to make those videos - the joy of playing has already quieted the clacking pallets to a degree, but the thought of a softer slap is motivating!

Thank you all again for you advice.  I will report back on what works best over the months to come if it can help other raw beginners like myself.

Rich

PS - I played a couple simple French waltzes the other night around a fire for the first time for a group of friends - was good timing as the mead had been flowing and I think everyone was surprised enough to hear a melodeon (for many for the first time...) that no one really seemed to notice how nervous I was and all the false starts!  Great fun though, and we all sang an improvised song afterwards while I just omm-pah-pah'd a waltz beat and held some buttons together!  What other instrument can you play for a month and do that with you friends?!

Thank you MelNet!
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 06, 2019, 11:03:50 PM
Quote
I must admit that I'm still curious about the double Neotech straps with the back closure, as the (probably naive) thought of being "locked-in" and having both hands much more free to move sounds wonderful!  We'll see if I can resist spending money unnecessarily as an enthusiastic beginner, but that's not my strong suit...

Richard ::) You are a bloke. You have got shoulders. A small rucsack doesn't fall off your back for want of a chest strap does it? Sure if you are carrying a fully laden 70 litre rucsack on a two day expedition :Ph a chest strap helps but this is a 3.6kg (8lb) Pokerwork you're talking about. :|bl

There is a well known photograph of Rose Murphy (PJ Conlon's sister) standing in her kitchen with what I think was a Hohner Double Ray hanging off a single shoulder strap. You may also wish to consider whether the US coastguard still has the drowning category  MOFO  (Man Overboard Flies Open)... :|glug :||: :|glug.  Accidents still happen on small boats and you don't want to be the first man recorded drowned by being dragged down by his melodeon.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 06, 2019, 11:18:43 PM
Steve is right about these not being a good permanent solution but as an initial trial rig they will do no harm.
You'd be surprised how easy it is to inadvertently cause denting/bruising with the plastic dog clips fittings. You only just got to get a clip at the wrong angle when getting the box hoisted up on to your shoulders and bam! the damage is done.
I speak from experience... :(
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Richard J Delong on May 07, 2019, 02:36:17 AM
Quote
I must admit that I'm still curious about the double Neotech straps with the back closure, as the (probably naive) thought of being "locked-in" and having both hands much more free to move sounds wonderful!  We'll see if I can resist spending money unnecessarily as an enthusiastic beginner, but that's not my strong suit...

Richard ::) You are a bloke. You have got shoulders. A small rucsack doesn't fall off your back for want of a chest strap does it? Sure if you are carrying a fully laden 70 litre rucsack on a two day expedition :Ph a chest strap helps but this is a 3.6kg (8lb) Pokerwork you're talking about. :|bl

There is a well known photograph of Rose Murphy (PJ Conlon's sister) standing in her kitchen with what I think was a Hohner Double Ray hanging off a single shoulder strap. You may also wish to consider whether the US coastguard still has the drowning category  MOFO  (Man Overboard Flies Open)... :|glug :||: :|glug.  Accidents still happen on small boats and you don't want to be the first man recorded drowned by being dragged down by his melodeon.

Thank you Peadar, points well taken! 

Yep when I was younger I worked in a big outdoor gear store and I can remember all the folks starting a new hobby (hiking or paddling or fly-fishing) and the mountains of gear they'd walk away with - most of which they had no idea how to use or even why it was such a critical purchase in the first place... just happy to be starting a new pursuit!  It's a good thing everyone here gives such solid (minimalist) advice, otherwise I'd be spending even more time searching for the best triple-strapped harness and forget that I can't play a jig yet...  yep, practice is what I need most now (and those quiet, newly-felted pallets)!

Thanks all!



Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 07, 2019, 06:54:53 AM
Steve is right about these not being a good permanent solution but as an initial trial rig they will do no harm.
You'd be surprised how easy it is to inadvertently cause denting/bruising with the plastic dog clips fittings. You only just got to get a clip at the wrong angle when getting the box hoisted up on to your shoulders and bam! the damage is done.
I speak from experience... :(
Richard- I would take Steve's advice on this one.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Emily Peabody on May 07, 2019, 07:40:54 AM
I use Neotech shoulder straps (without the back strap) for my piano accordion, and they're great because the accordion is a big heavy monster. My Pokerwork by comparison is light as a feather and came with much lighter padded straps, which are all I need.

If you've got a really heavy instrument or are trying to ease back or shoulder pain, the big Neotech straps can be very useful.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Richard J Delong on May 07, 2019, 07:58:47 AM
Thanks Emily - I think I'm going to start simple as was suggested above (very simple, in fact, with some small diameter rope to at least get a feel for the single strap and a sense of the needed length), then probably look to a basic leather melodeon strap (maybe two!) once I have a better sense of the length. 

Looking forward to it, as I'm recognizing that I'm already developing a different technique of resting the bass end against my left leg with the treble side angled upwards and freely moving (so that I'm pushing and pulling using the thumb strap) which definitely feels limiting as my right hand is not very mobile while hooked into the thumb strap and trying to control the bellows... I see that many of you fine players here are 'reversed' in a sense, with the treble end set stationary on the leg and a single strap hooked on the opposite shoulder, moving only the bass end and leaving your right hand totally free... Anyway, all new revelations to me and looking forward to experimenting!

Rich
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 07, 2019, 08:21:16 AM
By keeping the treble end stationary, and slightly higher than the bass end ( as it sounds like the position you have ) you can simply let the bass end fall away. Gravity is your friend  ;)
I think as well, for me, it puts the treble keyboard at a slight angle which suits the natural position of my hand.

The reason I use 2 straps is not because of weight, for me it keeps the box in the position I want. When trying friends' single strapped boxes I feel I'm in an odd position with my shoulder in the air to keep the strap on... but I concede that's because I'm not used to it.
Whether it's single or double, you need to ensure the box stays where you want it to enable you to play it easily in your style.
Cheers
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Chris Brimley on May 07, 2019, 01:38:08 PM
1 1/2 straps, for sitting down.

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1032.msg8876.html#msg8876
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: boxer on May 07, 2019, 03:17:54 PM
I've seen some wonderful box players who produce their magic despite their shoulder straps rather than because of them.  I've also seen players who are probably setting themselves up for a later life of chronic discomfort if not permanent pain.  It's worth taking time to find the best strap configuration to suit your personal requirement.

A complicating problem is that as your playing skill and strength develop, a box position that suited your initial style may become inappropriate, and a change might improve matters.

My own experience has been that over fifteen years or so my boxes have migrated about 12" (30 cm) leftwards across my body to enable a gradual straightening of the line of my right forearm, hand and fingers.  You may not need to do this, or you may already be there.  We're all different.

The purpose of the strap(s) is to keep the keyboard end of the box as stable as possible (as well as to stop it dropping on the floor).  I don't see any virtue (beyond the speed with which you can get into harness and start playing) in using a single strap if two do the job better, and if a backstrap and two shoulder straps is better still, that's OK too.  The more secure the treble side of the box, the less work your right thumb (resting on the edge of the keyboard, and tensioning the right shoulder strap) has to do.

On light boxes like the Pokerwork my personal preference is for a pair of Mally straps (they're as long as you'd ever need) with a backstrap.  I'd encourage you to experiment and keep on experimenting with different lengths and numbers of straps until you find the best for you.

Good luck




 
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 07, 2019, 03:45:41 PM
I wholeheartedly agree with boxer.
A good friend and renown player plays with the box almost vertical. His left wrist is at an incredibly bent angle. About 18months ago he was suffering numbness and loss of control to his left fingers. He narrowly missed having to be operated on.
It was a salutary lesson.
I made sure both arms were in a relaxed position, keeping the forearm/wrist/fingers in as relaxed and straight as possible.
It might not look as 'hardcore' a position as some, but I hope to avoid longterm damage and play for as long as possible.
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 07, 2019, 07:40:03 PM
I would always go for a plain leather strap as wide as you need it- which depends more than anything else on three things: the weight of the box, your peripheral blood pressure and the amount of subcutaneous fat you carry (your very own God given internal padding sytsem). Well tanned leather, a material made from the skin of an animal, will give and conform over pressure points where it contacts your body to spread the load naturally, in exactly the same way as leather shoes break in to the wearers feet. Plain leather will get more comfortable as they age, whereas padded straps will get less comfortable.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve C. on May 08, 2019, 12:47:02 PM
Steve, where do I find the woodwork on my Pokerwork that is going to scratch/dent?  (:)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 08, 2019, 06:01:06 PM
Steve, where do I find the woodwork on my Pokerwork that is going to scratch/dent?  (:)
Are you serious?
The entire Pokerwork casing is wooden construction apart from the steel corner pieces.
It will dent, the same as any other box.

On the other hand, perhaps your Pokerwork is so well-used and covered in dents and scratches that the odd few more from a plastic dog clip won't be noticeable!  :o
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: malcolmbebb on May 08, 2019, 06:42:23 PM
Richard ::) You are a bloke. You have got shoulders. A small rucsack doesn't fall off your back for want of a chest strap does it? Sure if you are carrying a fully laden 70 litre rucsack on a two day expedition :Ph a chest strap helps but this is a 3.6kg (8lb) Pokerwork you're talking about. :|bl
I know a number of people who use backstraps on light boxes. It's not the weight, it stops the straps sliding down or off your shoulders as you play. If you intend to play seated, it's unlikely to be necessary but standing it depends on your shape and build.
Personally I play with one strap when seated, and two + backstrap when playing standing.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: george garside on May 08, 2019, 08:55:53 PM
the only time I use a backstrap is when playing for ceilidhs as lead musician as a strap sliding off my shoulder mid dance  could be awkward to handle and may bugger things up!  Otherwise its two straps  using exactly the same adjustment whether seated, standing , processing or whatever'

The standard recommendation for ''accordions'  of all sizes  from 12 to 120 bass is top of treble end about a stretched handswidth below the chin when stading 'to attention' i.e looking straight ahead with back straight.  right strap longer than left so top of treble end is roughly under the chin and right arm can be more or less down  your side so movement up and down the keyboard is using elbow joint rather than shoulder joint.   That's the rough starting point  and obviously it can then be fine tunes according to individual anatomy.

I use the same basic setting on everything from 8 bass pokerwork to 120 bass piano box ( exept for  4 stop one row  which I play using only thumb strap)  and once finetuned it never needs further adjustment.

It has suited me for 60 years but of course everybody to their own

george
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 08, 2019, 09:30:04 PM
...You are a bloke. You have got shoulders. A small rucsack doesn't fall off your back for want of a chest strap does it? Sure if you are carrying a fully laden 70 litre rucsack on a two day expedition :Ph a chest strap helps but this is a 3.6kg (8lb) Pokerwork you're talking about. :|bl
....

OK so I'm not a bloke but I'm not at all convinced this is about gender or size or any of that stuff. As in so many cases I think it's how you play that matters.

I primarily play standing up and for morris. My style of playing is very physical - probably due to being a morris dancer myself - I tend to step along with my playing, move up and down with the set and move around quite a bit generally.  A lightweight back strap is invaluable here - yes, even with a 3.6kg Pokerwork.  It's not about the weight, it's a matter of keeping the box steady so I don't have to be.  Losing a shoulder strap mid-slows would be a bit of a disaster - the backstrap is simply a good insurance against this.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Stotty on May 08, 2019, 09:41:51 PM
Okay, thank you both - I'll put some more thought into this... I'm getting excited about the prospect of finding good support for the box to free up my hands more, particularly on the treble side as the thumb strap is just barely manageable (for me anyway, at this point) and gets a little uncomfortable and awkward... yep, looking forward to some strap set-up, even a simple arrangement, and the thought of moving more freely along the right side.

I coming round to thinking that the Hohner pokerwork thumb strap is rather more unhelpful than the single "screw" fixings and slightly longer thumb straps on Italian and other boxes.  Up until recently I had always played with thumb straps, and I still prefer them, but I've come to the conclusion that slightly longer thumb straps which can pivot are less restrictive than the Hohner 2 rivet designs.  It is perhaps a bit frustrating that the boxes that so many people learn to play on are not necessarily the easiest to get comfortable with.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 08, 2019, 09:54:16 PM
Losing a shoulder strap mid-slows would be a bit of a disaster - the backstrap is simply a good insurance against this.
Nothing to the disaster of drowning on your way home from the ceilidh. :M

(Confession...MAD struck again and I have just acquired an old Hohner 2 row A/D.....and compared to the 1040 the bass end is b****y heavy....2 straps on this one. :|bl)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 08, 2019, 10:12:11 PM
I've come late to this chat, but....

I have a pair of Neotech straps complete with back strap. The plus side is the combination of the neoprene and the backstrap means my left shoulder strap stayed in place when playing standing up for dance (ceilidh/morris). The downside was the neoprene caused nasty black marks on my nice white morris shirt  :(

I now use padded leather straps, irrespective of the weight/size of box, and have added a backstrap (CGM) to my main morris and band boxes.

But anything can be used to 'stabilise' your melodeon. I remember seeing Tony Hall playing in a concert with baler twine attached to his old Hohners as improvised straps  ;D
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 09, 2019, 08:27:40 AM
My two morris box players play Hohners ( Erica and Pokerwork ) and both use back straps.
One is a leather bespoke one, the other is a soft piece of thick rope and gets tied in by whoever's available.
Both say it's a stability thing, not weight.
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2019, 08:31:39 AM
I have really only ever played with a single strap on any melodeon I've had right up to a Castagnari Mory. I have had no difficulty with stability. I have tried 2 straps and found it to be constricting and uncomfortable.
Each to their own.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 09, 2019, 08:42:33 AM
Yes absolutely Lester, we all have preferences.
Somewhere previously it was implied that it was a weight issue and a Pokerwork being light, only needed one strap. Both my friends, Helena and others use two and a backstrap for stability alone.
But as you rightly say 'each to their own..'
Q

Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Anahata on May 09, 2019, 08:53:09 AM
Quote from: malcolmbebb
I know a number of people who use backstraps on light boxes. It's not the weight, it stops the straps sliding down or off your shoulders as you play. If you intend to play seated, it's unlikely to be necessary but standing it depends on your shape and build.
Personally I play with one strap when seated, and two + backstrap when playing standing.

I strongly resemble that remark!
I have particularly sloping shoulders and straps fall off easily. Even a one-row played sitting down can work its strap off my shoulder if I'm not careful.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 09, 2019, 08:59:39 AM
I use two straps standing or sitting.
I do confess that when sitting sometimes my left hand bass strap starts to slip...   :|bl
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 09, 2019, 09:05:11 AM
Quote
I remember seeing Tony Hall playing in a concert with baler twine attached to his old Hohners as improvised straps  ;D

Something else to add to the list of uses of baler twine.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 09, 2019, 10:01:47 AM
Trouble is, baler twine's  all red and plastic now, not the coarse light brown rope that held together the farmers coats..... and much else on the farm!
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: george garside on May 09, 2019, 11:11:51 AM
the sole  purpose of 'straps' , be in thumb strap, single shoulder strap, 2 shoulder straps  or 2 plus backstrap is , whilst  taking 'comfort' into account, to keep the keyboard  in exactly the same position relative to the  player whilst playing

this will vary from person to person but any set up that does not  keep the keyboard  steady and in a good position leaves scope for experimentation

george

Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2019, 11:22:23 AM
I must be older than all you 'baler twine' people, I call in 'binder twine'  (:)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 09, 2019, 12:10:47 PM
Trouble is, baler twine's  all red and plastic now, not the coarse light brown rope that held together the farmers coats..... and much else on the farm!
Q
I seem to remember Tony Hall's baler twine 'straps' were colourful polypropylene :)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 09, 2019, 12:18:11 PM
Each to their own.

Unhelpful though it may first appear to say it but this is really the crux of the matter. As far as straps are concerned it really is a matter of whatever suits you best. The hard part is in working this out in the first place. During my early months of playing I remember straying from the paths of righteousness into one-strap territory, many, many adjustments of straps, discomfort, dissatisfaction and then trying again.

The good news is that not only do you eventually work out what strap arrangement works best for you, you also become more flexible in being able to play using other strap configurations when the need arises.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Chris Brimley on May 09, 2019, 12:56:01 PM
Lots of contributors have been here before, many years ago!

Yes, George is right (except that he hasn't added in my system :) ), when he says:  'the sole  purpose of 'straps' , be it thumb strap, single shoulder strap, 2 shoulder straps  or 2 plus backstrap is , whilst  taking 'comfort' into account, to keep the keyboard  in exactly the same position relative to the  player whilst playing.'

If you sit down, I still commend the tripoint idea for any player, because it is comfortable and rigid.  My playing advanced very significantly by adopting it.

If you need to play standing up, you will have difficulty, because you can't control the position of the RHS of the box adequately, whatever you do (controversial but true!)  I have experimented with a figure five shaped metal brace that goes round your waist and the box RHS, and it works but it bends your spine.  I think the best answer is the tripoint and a right foot high support, such as two hard box cases on top of each other.

Playing a piano accordion is obviously different from playing a button accordion because you play long passages of all push or all pull, and you can see PA players making the change.  You need a better system for an in-out instrument.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2019, 01:09:18 PM
You could, of course, use on of these and not need any straps


(https://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/MTAyNFgxMDI0/z/3swAAOSwT~9WliT9/$_86.JPG)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 09, 2019, 01:17:57 PM
You could, of course, use on of these and not need any straps


(https://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/MTAyNFgxMDI0/z/3swAAOSwT~9WliT9/$_86.JPG)

You can go off people you know.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve C. on May 09, 2019, 02:47:44 PM
Steve, serious as the grave. 

This PW, my first box bought new in the late '70's is pretty much the only box I play outdoors or loan out. 

I keep it in the Hohner rucksack, usually.  "Pokerworking" paint finish seems to be pretty durable. (but you are right Holmes, close inspection does show some minor wear and tear).

Point I was making, mostly, was that delrin D sliders are "relatively" safe.

Related to the strap issue: I cannot find it, but isn't there a great, great video of a solo morris melodeon player playing and dancing at the same time?  I mean, really really big moves, all around the stage?  I feel like he might have been recently deceased, for some reason, as I remember it...

Was trying to find what strap setup HE used!
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: baz parkes on May 09, 2019, 02:58:25 PM
Steve, serious as the grave. 

This PW, my first box bought new in the late '70's is pretty much the only box I play outdoors or loan out. 

I keep it in the Hohner rucksack, usually.  "Pokerworking" paint finish seems to be pretty durable. (but you are right Holmes, close inspection does show some minor wear and tear).

Point I was making, mostly, was that delrin D sliders are "relatively" safe.

Related to the strap issue: I cannot find it, but isn't there a great, great video of a solo morris melodeon player playing and dancing at the same time?  I mean, really really big moves, all around the stage?  I feel like he might have been recently deceased, for some reason, as I remember it...

Was trying to find what strap setup HE used!

I've not got time to google but I suspect the one you're thinking of is the late lamented Dave Roberts, ex Blowzabella and all round good chap dancing Knuckledown...I may check rather than seek insurance quotes... :|glug
Yer t'is….and looking remarkably like a single strap, chap...

https://youtu.be/-rzRdgsquak

Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 09, 2019, 03:36:07 PM
Point I was making, mostly, was that delrin D sliders are "relatively" safe.

Yes I think the D-shaped sliders are probably OK. It's the type of plastic clips shown in the attachment which can cause the damage.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Mike Hirst on May 09, 2019, 03:44:34 PM

Yer t'is….and looking remarkably like a single strap, chap...

https://youtu.be/-rzRdgsquak


I was witness to this and can confirm single strap, also 'death grip' hold for right hand.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Chris Brimley on May 09, 2019, 04:47:40 PM
Haven't heard that description before, Mike:   

also 'death grip' hold for right hand.

but it's pretty accurate!
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 09, 2019, 04:56:58 PM
Yes I was there too and witnessed Dave's dancing whilst playing for himself.
It was a remarkable jig!
Q
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve C. on May 10, 2019, 01:03:13 PM
Baz, that's it!  Amazing.  (my knees can feel it....  :Ph)
Steve, I hear ya.  Why would someone use the clips when you can just run the strap through the bracket?
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 10, 2019, 01:53:46 PM

If you need to play standing up, you will have difficulty, because you can't control the position of the RHS of the box adequately, whatever you do (controversial but true!) 


It does depend on your definition of adequate. Some players seem to find two straps perfectly fine for playing standing up
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 10, 2019, 02:04:52 PM

If you need to play standing up, you will have difficulty, because you can't control the position of the RHS of the box adequately, whatever you do (controversial but true!) 


It does depend on your definition of adequate. Some players seem to find two straps perfectly fine for playing standing up


And some find one perfectly fine  ;)


(https://www.folkmusic.net/pics/kirkjo_01.gif)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 10, 2019, 02:08:48 PM

If you need to play standing up, you will have difficulty, because you can't control the position of the RHS of the box adequately, whatever you do (controversial but true!) 


It does depend on your definition of adequate. Some players seem to find two straps perfectly fine for playing standing up


And some find one perfectly fine  ;)


(https://www.folkmusic.net/pics/kirkjo_01.gif)

My humble opinion: There is no wrong way. Just good ways that work for you.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 10, 2019, 02:12:46 PM
My humble opinion: There is no wrong way. Just good ways that work for you.


Correct, go to the top of the class  (:)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Stiamh on May 10, 2019, 04:34:53 PM

Yer t'is….and looking remarkably like a single strap, chap...

https://youtu.be/-rzRdgsquak


I was witness to this and can confirm single strap, also 'death grip' hold for right hand.

Excuse the thread drift, but what system of box was he playing? He likes to throw Ebs in now and again, including one at 1:20 in a pasage that sounds like D-Eb-D played in one bellows direction. Not a semitone box surely??  :o
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 10, 2019, 04:48:58 PM


Yer t'is….and looking remarkably like a single strap, chap...

https://youtu.be/-rzRdgsquak (https://youtu.be/-rzRdgsquak)



I was witness to this and can confirm single strap, also 'death grip' hold for right hand.


Excuse the thread drift, but what system of box was he playing? He likes to throw Ebs in now and again, including one at 1:20 in a pasage that sounds like D-Eb-D played in one bellows direction. Not a semitone box surely??  :o

Quite possibly his infamous G/D box. If not the direction of the accidentals is variable so D-Eb-D is quite possible depending on the installation
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Stiamh on May 10, 2019, 09:03:04 PM
Excuse the thread drift, but what system of box was he playing? He likes to throw Ebs in now and again, including one at 1:20 in a pasage that sounds like D-Eb-D played in one bellows direction. Not a semitone box surely??  :o

Quite possibly his infamous G/D box. If not the direction of the accidentals is variable so D-Eb-D is quite possible depending on the installation

Thanks.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Chris Brimley on May 13, 2019, 01:57:41 PM
Notice how standing up players usually use the thumb grip technique?  Fine unless you have to move the fingers around a lot, I'm afraid.  Like I say, controversial but true!  Just Physics, I'm afraid.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: boxer on May 13, 2019, 06:59:30 PM
"thumb grip" (if it means pressing the thumb against the back of the keyboard) is probably most useful for a standing player using a fourth-apart box.  You need to move up and down the keyboard a lot more on a (B/C) semitone box and have to keep your thumb on the edge of the keyboard to enable this.  Having said that, I'd guess that some B/C players will probably now come forward to swear by the thumb grip.

I've found that I can play my PW well enough standing (with 2 shoulder straps and backstrap) for straightforward dance tunes, but faster or more complicated numbers are a lot less hair-raising if I'm sitting down.   Heavier boxes are more stable when played standing - they still move, but not as jerkily, because of their greater inertia - but spending three hours with the weight of a Nuage hung round my neck isn't my idea of fun.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 14, 2019, 12:16:55 AM
I don't want to labour the point, but my favourite players are perfectly capable of playing standing (some with one strap, some with two) or sitting.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Peadar on May 14, 2019, 12:29:44 AM


The good news is that not only do you eventually work out what strap arrangement works best for you, you also become more flexible in being able to play using other strap configurations when the need arises.

When the need arises...like anytime someone lets you get your sticky paws on their own beloved box.
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Lester on May 15, 2019, 08:12:21 AM
You could, of course, use on of these and not need any straps


(https://i.ebayimg.com/00/s/MTAyNFgxMDI0/z/3swAAOSwT~9WliT9/$_86.JPG)


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tai8QmSzho0 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tai8QmSzho0)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 15, 2019, 08:30:47 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tai8QmSzho0 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tai8QmSzho0)
Lovely bride and nice playing! Despite the stand, I see she is still using a thumb strap and a shoulder strap. Maybe the latter is to stop her falling over if she were to get too carried away with the excitement of the day. (:)
Title: Re: Shoulder Strap Recommendations?
Post by: Mike Hirst on May 15, 2019, 09:25:19 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tai8QmSzho0 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tai8QmSzho0)
Ha Ha. I was watching this only the other day. nice maggiore/minore strumenti.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal