Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Hugh Taylor on May 17, 2019, 02:47:50 PM
-
Just had a peak at Dave Shepherd's Facebook page and he's said the following to a video of some dancing in Ireland -
This is of great interest to anybody who is into European couple dancing. Dances like this existed in England as well (but effectively stamped out by the EFDSS concentrating on 17th century dances from the Playford Dancing Master, and the sudden popularity of both American Square dancing and Scottish country dancing in the 1950s). We have a lot more in common with both our Irish and European neighbours than most English folk dancers are prepared to admit!
Does anyone know of any evidence to support that theory?
-
Just had a peak at Dave Shepherd's Facebook page and he's said the following to a video of some dancing in Ireland -
Is it possible to have a link to the video, please?
-
...Does anyone know of any evidence to support that theory?
I don't know whether it's 'evidence', and I don't know whether it 'supports' the theory, but I'm
currently looking at a late 18th-century collection of tunes for the fife (and German flute and
fiddle). There are ~115 tunes in this book, and a lot of them seem to be French in origin.(*) I have
tracked down what I think is the French original for some of these tunes (I will check more carefully
when I get a chance), but the French 'original' certainly has both tunes and dance instructions.
Saturday Morning Edit: Here's what I meant. The two attachments have a tune (Gigue Anglaise)
which is the same, apart from the key. The first is from Stewart's Select Collection of Airs...
(https://archive.org/details/selectcollection00rugg/page/44 (https://archive.org/details/selectcollection00rugg/page/44)), the second from Landrins Pot-pourri
François des contre-danse ancienne (https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b90832820/f55.item.zoom (https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b90832820/f55.item.zoom))
The dance instructions in the second indicate that the dances are for sets of four couples, so it's
not quite what the OP had in mind :(, but it seems to indicate that there was some 'leakage' across
the Channel...
-
A quick bit pf Googling more or less supports what I thought, which was that waltzes, polkas and schottisches became widespread in Europe and America in the 19th century. It seems they caught on in England a little later than elsewhere, but we certainly had them.
So they existed here, but perhaps never completely displaced the set dances that have always been part of our country dancing tradition.
We had ballroom dancing too - that's all couples, isn't it? (and includes waltzes, anyway, and possibly polkas?) - that's the sort of dancing I thought of as belonging to my parents' generation.
-
The American Square Dance throws a long shadow.
The other day I saw a local advert for 'a ceili' mentions a couple of bands and " Western dress optional..."
Years ago when I was helping out with a band, checked shirts and cowboy influenced attire was common.
A barn dance seems to still conjure up the Americanisms. Perhaps people have disconnected with the countryside so much as to not realise we have barns in this country, and a barn dance often heralded the end of harvest..... ::)
Hey ho....
Q
-
A quick bit pf Googling more or less supports what I thought, which was that waltzes, polkas and schottisches became widespread in Europe and America in the 19th century. It seems they caught on in England a little later than elsewhere, but we certainly had them.
So they existed here, but perhaps never completely displaced the set dances that have always been part of our country dancing tradition.
We had ballroom dancing too - that's all couples, isn't it? (and includes waltzes, anyway, and possibly polkas?) - that's the sort of dancing I thought of as belonging to my parents' generation.
Waltz, polka and schottische...the rock 'n roll of the 1880's. Does this coincide with the rise of the accordion and the advent of "factory made" instruments?
-
Is it possible to have a link to the video, please?
Here it is - https://www.facebook.com/ciarank1/videos/10155132956619125/?t=72
-
Thanks. Interesting seeing the varsovienne in a different context, but still called shoe the donkey.
I don't have much knowledge of the Irish traditions but it does seem to share some features with Cornish Tea Dances, while being in the Irish traditional style (straight back etc).
-
Lovely footwork.
-
The American Square Dance throws a long shadow.
The other day I saw a local advert for 'a ceili' mentions a couple of bands and " Western dress optional..."
Years ago when I was helping out with a band, checked shirts and cowboy influenced attire was common.
A barn dance seems to still conjure up the Americanisms. Perhaps people have disconnected with the countryside so much as to not realise we have barns in this country, and a barn dance often heralded the end of harvest..... ::)
Hey ho....
Q
I have to Agree with this, I play fairly regularly in a Country/Barn dance band playing (Predominantly) English tunes for(predominantly) English Dances ! often held in barns !!, regularly a third to half the audience turn up in Cowboy outfits packing Toy Guns ( at least I hope there toys ) the whole evening is often punctuated by Cries of "Yeehah "" and they get really excited by the possibility of a "Do Si Do".
Our callers often patiently explain that what they are doing is English or at least British, but for some reason most Ceilidh/Barn Dance guests still automatically equate Barn Dance with American, and I remember one occasion we were soundly berated by a dissapointed Punter that we had no Fiddle or Banjo,he couldnt beleive you could have a Barn dance without either of these !!. our normal Line up at the time was Melodeon, Anglo Concertina, Guitar and Bass. At the end of the day I suppose it doesnt matter what the Customers Think they are doing as long as they enjoy it,( and they mostly seem to ) but some times I find it frustrating that these people seem to have so little knowledge of our home grown social customs.
-
In Northumberland and Durham we get a 50/50 split on cowboy hats or kilts for the gents, with a good 75-80% of the ladies wearing tight skirts and stilettos. We have recently been asked to quote for a medieval ceilidh. I'm hoping it'll be more game of thrones than sackcloth and ashes.
-
"but effectively stamped out by the EFDSS concentrating on 17th century dances from the Playford Dancing Master"
Hmmm, try consulting the Community Dance Manuals and upholding the claim that EFDSS concentrated on 17th century Playford, and the idea that EFDSS was capable of "stamping out" anything is pretty fanciful I think.
-
...Perhaps people have disconnected with the countryside so much as to not realise we have barns in this
country, and a barn dance often heralded the end of harvest...
...but for some reason most Ceilidh/Barn Dance guests still automatically equate Barn Dance with American...
I hear what you both are saying, but I'm really surprised. It simply wouldn't occur to me that 'barn dance'
meant anything but, well, 'barn dance'. I think that this would also be true for most of the folks I know. Is
this 'transatlantic' association really common then?
-
I don't see why it would be false. But the main thing is that you have to differentiate between the original context for couple dances (mainly the upper-class salons) and the shortly-lived dancing occurring in traditional societies. For the former, you'll have evidences of it throughout all Europe, the upper-class habits being quite permeable. For the latter, there was not enough time for these dances to be adapted by the popular milieu. You have some exemples of mazurka being adapted by traditional society here and there, but, roughly speaking, you have very few variations over space for those dances, they were mainly transposed "as is" in lower-class dancing.
-
The idea that they disappeared is a bit odd. Does nobody watch Strictly? Have you all forgotten Victor Silvester? My father started his dance band days in the 1920s, and his father before WW1. The Beresford Band. Scan Tester's Imperial Jazz Band. It was all working class couple dance. Waltz, schottishes, polkas, barn dance, tango, foxtrot
-
Hi, Chloe here Jake’s wife.
Yay! People are taking an interest in English couple dancing! I did a workshop on couple dances collected in England including Varsovienne, Schottisches, The Highland Fling, and Double Schottisches as part of the ‘Forgotten social dances’ workshops at Chippenham this year with John Kirkpatrick. We’re all set for a re-run at Sidmouth 2020. I’m currently uploading videos onto my Youtube channel: Chloe Middleton-Metcalfe. This includes other dances as well as couple dances, but the focus in on collected material.
I’ve written short essay which addresses the lack of couple dances in the current folk dance revival in England. It can be found in the new VWML’s annotated bibliography on social folk dance. Find it here: vwml.org/socialdancebibliography
Briefly, couple dances were not so popular amongst English folk dancers for a number of reasons, from not being considered to be English enough to the competition the EFDSS had in the 1940s from the Old Time movement, which more or less specialised in couple dances.
I’m all up for a English bal-folk movement. Bring it on. Let’s have more couple dances, especially in sessions. Jo and Simon Harner run great sessions in Hampshire at the Samuel’s Rest, they have revived Alice Gillington’s dances collected from the New Forrest gypsies, this includes some fantastic couple dances. At Chippenham Somerstep were also doing some of these dances – with audience participation.
Exciting times.
-
Chloe...
Thanks for the videos on your YT channel.
I'm subscriber number 4 I am
Subscriber number 4 I am, I am...
-
Could it be that couple dances are not as much fun, and not as likely to engender community spirit as group dances, which being "common enterprise", like hunting in packs and playing rugby, require cooperation and humour (but unlike hunting and sport don't usually end in bloodshed, though we could all tell a tale or two)?
-
Maybe, but the right couple dances can result in a pursuit of an altogether more fascinating kind!
-
Theo, really! I'd expect a bit more decorum from you.
-
Maybe, but the right couple dances can result in a pursuit of an altogether more fascinating kind!
In some denominations, sex was discouraged as it might lead to dancing...
-
Maybe, but the right couple dances can result in a pursuit of an altogether more fascinating kind!
Perhaps, but you only get one partner. ::)
-
Maybe, but the right couple dances can result in a pursuit of an altogether more fascinating kind!
The Horizontal Polka ;D
I have seen couple dances in the step-dancing traditions of East Anglia and the West Country (both from Gipsy roots).
It's pretty informal and can get quite sweaty.
-
I can't remember where or when (but I have had my tablet...) but Kerry Fletcher and John Howson organised an evening of couple dances once...
It had dance cards and everything...
and a splendid time was had by all...
-
Disentangling the history of couple dances needs a structure based on time, place and class.
The time period is the 19C; the place is western Europe and the class extends from the elite to the peasantry. The entertainment of the elite included dancing: they paid dancing masters/dance teachers to prepare them for the ballroom. The dance teachers needed novelty to ensure the continuation of their trade, as illustrated in the three distinct eras in 19C social dance.
Regency [1800-1830s] the quadrille dates from 1815; the mazurka (the Russians added the -ka to its original Polish name) arrived in England in the 1820s. The most important novelty of the Regency was the waltz from Germany which broke the formations of squares and lines and required partners to embrace - the elite had seized a peasant dance, although the sensuousness was alarming.
Romantic [1840s-1860s] the demand for couple dances led to the introduction of the polka from Bohemia; Der Schottische from Germany; the Scotch Reel from Scotland. The waltz gradually overcame criticism, aided by the galop and the polka and the developments into Valse à Deux Temps, Redowa, Five-Step Waltz. The intricate footwork of the quadrille was replaced by walking.
High Victorian [1870s-1890s] the social dances of the Regency were now one, even two, generations old: the Mazurka, Schottische, Redowa and Polka began to fade. In desperation, dancing teachers created new steps: dancers were not impressed. The elite changed their social events from balls to the parlour while public, middle-class, balls were left with the waltz and the Two-step.
Though a dance might fall out of favour with the elite, it might be continued at lower levels in society and even spread to become an international 'folk dance' - the polka being an example. In the 20C many of the couple dances of the 19C were preserved in the Old Time Dance movement. Or remained as folk dances in the remoter rural areas.
-
The American Square Dance throws a long shadow.
The other day I saw a local advert for 'a ceili' mentions a couple of bands and " Western dress optional..."
Years ago when I was helping out with a band, checked shirts and cowboy influenced attire was common.
Q
I have to Agree with this, I play fairly regularly in a Country/Barn dance band playing (Predominantly) English tunes for(predominantly) English Dances ! often held in barns !!, regularly a third to half the audience turn up in Cowboy outfits packing Toy Guns ( at least I hope there toys ) the whole evening is often punctuated by Cries of "Yeehah "" and they get really excited by the possibility of a "Do Si Do".
I blameSeven Brides for Seven Brothers…. >:E
-
Alan, great summary. It's interesting to add that we have very few knowledge of the movements between upper and lower classes for the dances. There are several conflicting theories on this, but intellectual honesty would recommend caution.
Except maybe for some couple dances (I mean by that, not the quadrilles but waltzes and so on) that were pretty much danced similarly by the lower class. Others began to be adapted by people, but the traditional societies died before they had time to make these dances their owns (contrary to quadrilles and country dances that had time to evolve).
-
It's interesting to add that we have very few knowledge of the movements between upper and lower classes for the dances. There are several conflicting theories on this, but intellectual honesty would recommend caution.
Quite right. It is easier to show the role of dancing teachers in the development of dances from their rural origins into the balls than it is to show the reverse. It is rather easier to identify the elite and those providing them with goods and services [the dances and the dance teaching].
It is difficult to determine the pace and extent of working class adoption of the elite's new dances. And to determine whether these dances were pulled back into a dancing style that already existed [for example, a dance vocabulary of stepping] and therefore underwent further change and development.
-
The Beresford Band. Scan Tester's Imperial Jazz Band. It was all working class couple dance. Waltz, schottishes, polkas, barn dance, tango, foxtrot
The Beresford Band is a reference to:
Yorkshire Dales Dance Night A location recording of The Beresford Band Leader LEA 2069 (LP, UK, 1977)
On this nine-track LP the band played for a sequence dance repertory, recognisable today:
Friendly Waltz
The Maxina devised 1917 by Madame Low-Hurndall and was based on some movements from the modern ballroom dance
of the day, the Brazilian Maxixe;
The Eva Three-Step novelty sequence dance, arranged by Sydney Painter;
Waltz Marie a sequence dance;
Military Two-Step arranged by Ethel Finnigan of Manchester in 1903, derived from a dance called the Raw Recruit (1897/8);
Doris Waltz
Royal Empress Tango an early Tango sequence dance from England, choreographed by H. A. Clifton in 1922;
Breakaway Blues blues and glide;
St. Bernard's Waltz old time waltz, sequence
-
It is difficult to determine the pace and extent of working class adoption of the elite's new dances. And to determine whether these dances were pulled back into a dancing style that already existed [for example, a dance vocabulary of stepping] and therefore underwent further change and development.
Also, it's unclear that there was indeed an adoption. It's often thought that the working class copied as they could the dance practice of the upper class, which is quite improper. For the country dances from where I grew up, they are not poorly executed substitutes of The Lancers or whatever, but an expression in its own right, that may have derived from the upper-class practice at first, but lived its own life until the end of the traditional societies. Of course it may not translate well for English popular dances, I'm not an expert :)
In addition to what you said about already existing dancing style, it was often postulated that popular quadrilles just were danced with the step from pre-existing branles. That's true for some dances, but not all of them, that could develop specific steps, without a clear link with other dances that we know of.
-
Also, it's unclear that there was indeed an adoption. It's often thought that the working class copied as they could the dance practice of the upper class, which is quite improper.
We may consider such an adoption through the example of the mazurka:
William Cavendish [Duke of Devonshire] attended the coronation of Czar Nicholas I, Emperor of Russia, on 3 September 1826, in St. Petersburg. Cavendish danced the mazurka at Russian balls and brought the dance back to England where it was performed at his estate balls during the 1820s and 1830s. The dance was published in London in 1829.
Performance by persons of all classes may be derived from Cavendish's novelty and the subsequent commercial publication.
But this is, of course, in no way to suggest that rural traditional dances in line, chain and circle formations were derived from the dances of the elite.
-
The mazurka is an interesting example. Evidently it began as a Polish folk dance that was adopted by the local elite. That would've been before any visiting aristocrats picked it up. I suppose Polish seamen and other 'lower class' folk could've introduced the dance wherever they travelled back in those days?
-
In terms of exchanges between classes, mazurka is closer to a counterexample than the rule (compared to quadrilles and older dances), but so are most of couple dances. Yves Guilcher worked a lot on those issues, but I'm not sure his work was ever translated in English, sadly.
-
The mazurka is an interesting example. Evidently it began as a Polish folk dance that was adopted by the local elite. That would've been before any visiting aristocrats picked it up. I suppose Polish seamen and other 'lower class' folk could've introduced the dance wherever they travelled back in those days?
The visiting aristocrats were the military elite of Austria, Prussia and Russia. The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth was visited by them in 1772-1795: the period of the three partitions (seizures and annexations of the territory). The masur dance, as it was named in Polish, was part of that conquest.
-
In terms of exchanges between classes, mazurka is closer to a counterexample than the rule (compared to quadrilles and older dances), but so are most of couple dances. Yves Guilcher worked a lot on those issues, but I'm not sure his work was ever translated in English, sadly.
The mazurka is an example of a couple dance taken from its source and processed through dancing teachers, dance publishers and the elite. Durang (1847, Philadelphia, USA) continued to develop the dance to challenge dancers with five figures and complex choruses.
I am aware of of Yves' doctoral thesis Culture traditionnelle et danse ancienne en France [Popular traditional culture and ancient dance in France] (Université de Bretagne occidentale, 1994) but the translation of the Résumé suggests that it is more concerned with the long-run retention of medieval or renaissance dance and song forms into the popular culture of the 20C.
-
You're right, it's on a broader level than just couple dances. He also dedicated a whole chapter to these questions in his book "La danse traditionnelle en France: d’une ancienne civilisation paysanne à un loisir revivaliste" (Traditional dance in France: from an ancient farming civilisation to a revivalist leisure activity). It may not fare well with English tradition though, but it's an interesting read nonetheless. I've no time these days but when I have if it's of some interest to anyone I can try and do a summary of this specific chapter.
-
Some very interesting information here: thanks to all contributors.
Does anyone have comment on -
1. Dave's assertion that - Dances like this existed in England as well (but effectively stamped out by the EFDSS concentrating on 17th century dances from the Playford Dancing Master
[/b]
2. Anyone been to a ceilidh where couple dances were included?
-
Some very interesting information here: thanks to all contributors.
agreed
2. Anyone been to a ceilidh where couple dances were included?
As has been stated earlier couple dances were an important element of Beresford family dances. I attended some of these in the early eighties.
When I was younger I visited English concertina player Dan Wilshaw in Wheelock (Cheshire) he had played as part of a family trio in the years before the first world war, playing for dances up and down the canal. With the exception of the eightsome reel and various quadrilles, most of his repertoire was aimed at playing for couple dances.
In the 1960s there was a melodeon, drums + piano trio in Smallwood (Cheshire) playing an exclusively couple dance repertoire in the Blue Bell Inn on Saturday nights.
My own ceilidh repertoire has a number of couple dances. We always include the "Gay Gordons", "Canadian barn dance" and "Heel and Toe Polka". We will sometimes include a "St. Bernard Waltz", or "Eva Three-Step".
-
2. Anyone been to a ceilidh where couple dances were included?
Yes, regularly in the northeast of England. St Bernadrs Waltz, Skye Waltz, Gay Gordons, Ideal Scottische, Military two Step, Canadian Barn Dance and a few others including the ones mentioned by Mike in the previous post. It's normal to include 2 or three of these.
For example there's one tonight (http://redheughers.org.uk/ceilidhs/) where I expect some of these will be included.
-
2. Anyone been to a ceilidh where couple dances were included?
I regularly call The St. Bernard's Waltz and Dave Hunt's Double Gloucester March (A version of the Caerphilly).and sometimes the Canadian Barn Dance.
And it's rare to find a ceilidh in the eceilidh heartland that won't have Gordon Potts' Rozsa waltz making an appearance... :|glug
-
It is perhaps worth stating that even in areas where traditional dancing remained untainted the EFDS impact was acknowledged. In both East Anglia and Yorkshire I have heard older dancers describing their own experience of social dance as being distinct from folk dancing taught in school. Indeed, though the figures and steps may have been similar they were never accepted to be the same.
That is not to suggest that dancing was not taught. A pertinent reference here would be the publication "Traditional Step-Dancing In Lakeland" - J.F. & J.M. Flett, in which the latter days of itinerant dance teaching are documented. If this is not in print now, it certainly should be.
For further references to (Northern) terpsichorean pedagogy , this article I wrote nearly 20 years ago may be useful.
http://www.folknortheast.com/learn/social-dance/the-dancing-master1
-
Hugh Taylor wants us to deal with Dave Shepherd's comments on a video clip from RTÉ (1989) dealing with music and dancing in Donegal.
I'm a melodeon-player, and have been since 1967, and occasionally a dancer. I was involved in step dance and social dance research and performance and the Campaign for Real Reels in the 1970s and 1980s [Reading Clog and Traditional Step Dance Group aka Reading Cloggies].
(What Somerstep are shown dancing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2qc1-UZ-D0 the Cloggies were doing fifty years ago: that's nearly two generations.) [Today the Cloggies are known as Aldbrickham Clog & Step Dancers http://aldbrickhamclog.org/]
I'll venture the following.
This is of great interest to anybody who is into European couple dancing.
Probably not of great interest: perhaps some interest at best. The five examples are a mazurka, a Highland, Shoe the donkey (aka waltz Vienna), Maggie Pickens [a solo step dance] and the four-couple Donegal Set [acknowledged as a revival]. They all need a measure of teaching and learning to acquire the steps-vocabulary required.
Dances like this existed in England as well
Has some truth in it: the waltz Vienna has wide distribution. Maggie Pickens is interesting as it is based on the pas de basque which is fundamental to step dancing in England.
(but effectively stamped out by the EFDSS concentrating on 17th century dances from the Playford Dancing Master,
Rather overstating the case, in fact, wildly inaccurate. Two strands here. Firstly, the Society did not 'stamp out' anything: although one may find instances in which there was, arguably, ignorance and indifference toward dances, dancers and some musical instruments. Secondly, there were dancers and musicians who were completely removed from the influence of the Society. Just at the moment of his untimely death in 1997, Dave Williams [Southampton] had published an analysis of the repertory of Stan Seaman [Buckler's Hard, on the Beaulieu river] in the periods 1925-1939 and 1946-1960s, http://www.mustrad.org.uk/articles/seaman.htm showing just what the "folk" were really dancing.
And as others have commented, the Old Time Dance movement has maintained performance of the couple dances.
and the sudden popularity of both American Square dancing and Scottish country dancing in the 1950s).
In all my research with the late Jennifer Millest in Devon and Norfolk, into both social dance and step dance, I cannot recall anyone mentioning Square dancing or Scottish dancing as factors in the decline/demise of these dance forms.
We have a lot more in common with both our Irish and European neighbours than most English folk dancers are prepared to admit!
Again, a bit wild, but there is some truth. Previous posts have shown that the waltz, polka, schottische, mazurka and varsoviana were snatched from folk origins in central Europe and sent around the world.
-
Alan,
It feels to me that there is something interesting here. We have expressed pertinent elements of the same argument. I think it is important that we continue this discussion.
To play devils advocate, I would postulate the relation of solo dance and presentation dance to social dance.
vis-a -vi "line dancing"/"March of the Mods"
-
Mike,
If you look at Dave Williams' analysis of Stan Seaman's repertory http://www.mustrad.org.uk/articles/seaman.htm you will find March of the Mods in the 1946-1960s period. Proof positive that the "folk" have always been alert to new opportunities.
Jennifer Millest, who with Ian Dunmur, founded the Reading Cloggies in 1965, was a pupil of Tom Flett and a member of his dance demonstration team when she was a student at Liverpool University. Jennifer was deeply influenced by Tom's research methods and collecting and built her own exacting standards from them. Jennifer's papers are with Chris Metherell at the Instep Archive.
Joan and Tom's book Traditional Step-Dancing In Lakeland influenced Ailsa and Ian Dunmur in their collecting in south Lakeland. Joan and Tom's papers are in the Instep Archive. Ian's seventeen-step Lakeland set remains one of the most impressive solo step dances I have ever seen.
-
I had not read the Stan Seaman article. Thanks for that reference.
I'm particularly taken with the idea of playing the Run Away train for the Gay Gordons and Camptown Races for the Twist.
-
2. Anyone been to a ceilidh where couple dances were included?
Yes, regularly in the northeast of England. St Bernadrs Waltz, Skye Waltz, Gay Gordons, Ideal Scottische, Military two Step, Canadian Barn Dance and a few others including the ones mentioned by Mike in the previous post. It's normal to include 2 or three of these.
For example there's one tonight (http://redheughers.org.uk/ceilidhs/) where I expect some of these will be included.
When playing for ceilidhs I include many of what Theo says and where possible play tunes with words i.e. songs that dancers and those sitting out can join in with.
on one occasion when the caller didn't turn up and nobiody else could call ( I can't talk and play at the same time) I finished up playing 'single' dances as somebody shouted 'cant you play something we can jive to! never having done this before I started off with a travesty of Lonne donegans putting on the style then went into ken john peel and many other tunes adapted on the hoof to a 'jve' rhythm nd kept in time by playing to the swinging arses rather than feet pf the dancers.
This plus a smattering of 'couple' waltzes and the hokey cokey got me through the evening and there was hardly anybody 'sitting out''
george