Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: nfldbox on September 10, 2009, 03:46:49 AM
-
I know there are various button patterns on various types of accordions but one thing that fascinates me is how the scale is arranged, especially systems in which you must come back up the row for a lower note. Anyone know when and how this started? Is there an obvious reason for it?
-
Here goes a wild shoot from the hip- richter tuning of the harmonica.
oops
Richter System harmonica has a comb sandwiched between two reedplates, the upper one with the blow reeds and the lower one with the draw reeds. Each chamber in the comb leads to a pair of reeds, one blow and one draw, with a single reed being sounded for each note of the scale. The tuning scheme used on the Richter System harmonica has varied a little over the last century and a half, but is essentially the same as that used on other types of harmonica, such as the Viennese octave and tremolo harmonicas, the Knittlinger octave harmonicas and others (for more details see this page). In fact, the same principle is used as the basis for the note layout of the diatonic accordion and various mouth-blown free reed instruments that came out of Europe in the 19th century. Was it devised by Richter? Probably not. This tuning scheme seems to have been used on accordions almost from their first invention and was certainly established by the mid 1800s. US patent number 11062 (the earliest US accordion patent, granted to Anthony Faas in 1854), clearly shows a keyboard layout that is based on this typical diatonic arrangement, suggesting it was the so-called Richter tuning was the standard layout for diatonic accordions prior to that date.
-
I have no idea about the history, but in terms of the underlying logic the main problem is how to arrange a seven-note (and thus an odd-numbered cycle) diatonic scale in a push-pull (and thus an even-numbered cycle) sequence.
One simple option is to move up each step of the scale as you move from push to pull and along the row. Thus in C major, with push underlined:
[C D] [E F] [G A] [B C] [D E] [F G] [A B] [C D] ...
This pattern repeats over a 14-note (two-octave) cycle. But within this each octave is radically different from the previous, and for obvious reasons this layout is not attractive for playing, especially in conjunction with push-pull basses.
If the pattern is instead required to repeat exactly from one octave to the next then there would have to be repeated or blank notes, for example:
[C D] [E F] [G A] [B ?] [C D] [E F] [G A] [B ?] [C D] ...
which is inefficient, i.e. uses more buttons than necessary.
So you can't efficiently have exact octave-by-octave repetition of the whole scale. However as a compromise you can efficiently have octave-by-octave repetition of only part of the scale, and the obvious choice is the tonic triad C E G. Thus the standard layout:
[C X] [E X] [G X] [C X] E X] [G X] [C X] ...
There are clear attractions to this for playing. But here in each cycle of the triad there are only three Xs to cover the remaining four notes in the scale (D F A B). So as you move up from one octave to the next you're forever playing catch-up with those notes, with the result that (i) no octave has the same pattern as any other, and (ii) pretty soon you reach a point where you have to come backwards to move up from a non-triad note to the next triad note in the scale.
I suppose another way of looking at the standard layout is that it separates the scale into two distinct subsets of notes, one of which is assigned to push and the other to pull, and each of which cycles in exact repeats. But since the scale has an odd number of notes these two subsets are necessarily of different size, so their cycles are of different lengths and therefore out of synch with each other.
-
Well done jb - that's one of the clearest explanations I've ever seen. Thanks!
-
Nice explanation jb
iIalso think the mouth organ was an easy layout that allowed you to blow or suck chords (1,3,5) quite easily and get a tune without too much effort as a beginner. It's what attracted me as a kid. The melodeon followed that pattern I reckon ( play in a day!)
-
If the pattern is instead required to repeat exactly from one octave to the next then there would have to be repeated or blank notes, for example:
[C D] [E F] [G A] [B ?] [C D] [E F] [G A] [B ?] [C D] ...
which is inefficient, i.e. uses more buttons than necessary.
On the other hand you could have Bb for the ? draws giving C/F on one row in a logical layout.
You'd have your C and Bb major chords on the row, but not F.... ::)
-
[C D] [E F] [G A] [B ?] [C D] [E F] [G A] [B ?] [C D] ...
On the other hand you could have Bb for the ? draws giving C/F on one row in a logical layout.
You'd have your C and Bb major chords on the row, but not F.... ::)
looks like a nifty idea. Get it patented.
Actually, apart from the obvious problem with basses, I am now wondering whether there might after all be some merit in the simple option:
[C D] [E F] [G A] [B C] [D E] [F G] [A B] [C D] ...
E.g. lots of nice triads.
Any thoughts?
-
You fellows might enjoy this page: http://www.accordeon101.com/clavpolymodal.html
Leaving fancy 3-row redesigns out of it: While having the buttons getting out of synch above and below the two main octaves trips me up all the time, I can't help thinking that if there were really a better solution, it would be in use by now.
Yes I know the Dvorak keyboard is more efficient than QWERTY and will never catch on because QWERTY/AZERTY etc. are too well entrenched (just like VHS-Beta and many other examples from the world of technology), but I don't think this is an analogous case. Extra notes either have to be extraneous to your diatonic scale (an open invitation to spectacular bum notes), or repeated (chromatic harmonicas I believe have two dohs next to each other in the same direction) and I wouldn't fancy either scenario.
You should all just get a C#D and get on with it. Oops sorry George that should be BCC# >:E
-
You should all just get a C#D and get on with it. Oops sorry George that should be BCC#
So much truth spoken in jest ;D
AL
-
You should all just get a C#D and get on with it. Oops sorry George that should be BCC#
So much truth spoken in jest ;D
AL
You actually mean D/D#, of course! ;D
-
You should all just get a C#D and get on with it. Oops sorry George that should be BCC#
So much truth spoken in jest ;D
AL
Thanks Al! Having looked through some of the wonderful re arranging suggested in this thread it makes the BCC# look remarkably simple, especialy when you take into account that it offers genuine (i.e. 5 scales for 12) chromasticity or chromaticness or whatever. Even without the bass for all 12 keys you could have a great melody box the size of the small 3 row castagnari (is it the benny) . I tried one once - brilliant on right hand & as light as a feather but the silly sods had made it with push/pull 'melodeon basses!
george ;D
-
While having the buttons getting out of synch above and below the two main octaves trips me up all the time, I can't help thinking that if there were really a better solution, it would be in use by now.
In some ways its quite useful having different layouts for the two octaves, because, especially when you play across the rows, some tunes seem to sit better in one octave rather than the other.
-
Having looked through some of the wonderful re arranging suggested in this thread it makes the BCC# look remarkably simple, especialy when you take into account that it offers genuine (i.e. 5 scales for 12) chromasticity or chromaticness or whatever. Even without the bass for all 12 keys you could have a great melody box the size of the small 3 row castagnari (is it the benny) . I tried one once - brilliant on right hand & as light as a feather but the silly sods had made it with push/pull 'melodeon basses!
Yep - agreed, there does seem to be an irrational fear of simple stradella in some circles - which just leads to another kind of madness, namely sticking in a push/pull bass that's no earthly use at all!
AL
-
A thread over at thesession.org led to "zirkular" (circular/spiral) tuned harmonicas, ie the scale just goes around and around, suck/blow press/draw, without worrying about getting octaves on the same "side." (English concertina anyone?) Of course, basses make a difference, but some people seem very happy with the system
http://www.seydel1847.de/epages/Seydel.sf/en_GB/?ObjectPath=/Shops/Seydel/Products/10209/SubProducts/10209G
-
I've had my head stuck in the stradella system of my morino most of this afternoon. My midi wasn't happy playing just 3 notes in each chord, it wanted more more more and was just getting silly, worked fine last night but hey ho. It's fixed now.
I do see why manufacturers stick to the push/pull basses for simplicity reasons, as it doesn't look like an easy system to build although I'm sure if you build one, it would be easy to build another, just a case of understanding it.
As for the treble end, I am quite happy about notes being the wrong way round. I remember the fact that all the IN notes are the same pattern & all the OUT notes are another pattern. Worked it out pretty early on and it helped a lot. I'd rather that than having extra notes from other scales stuck in there. Would cause havock! Would also ruin the other scales played by cross rowing on any semi-tone box
-
This is the system that I wish had been invented.
[C D'] [E F'] [G G'] [A B'] [C D'] etc...
The gleicton and push 6th are present,the notes are the same all the way up the keyboard and there are no discordant triads.An extra button is required but the advantages are tremendous.
Edited to correct [C B'] to [C D']
Chris
-
It would require the thumb for a scale but it's not a bad idea
-
This is the system that I wish had been invented.
[C B'] [E F'] [G G'] [A B'] [C D'] etc...
The gleicton and push 6th are present,the notes are the same all the way up the keyboard and there are no discordant triads.An extra button is required but the advantages are tremendous.
Chris
Not a bad idea. If you talk to Bill (I think it was nicely) then you could see whether he could modify the virtual melodeon to have that fingering. I tried to get a programmer friend of mine to mod the thing so that it the fingering was user-generated, but he hasn't yet got round to it.
-
the push/pull sequence - blow/suck, blow/suck,blowsuck, suck/blow. is exactly the same in both octaves. The only difference being that in the lower (middle) octave each pair of suck/blow is done on the same button whereas in the high octave it is done on 2 adjacent buttons thus maintaining repeated notes every 4th button on push & 5th button on pull throughout the box. The problem of plaaying in the higher octave is eliminated by practice of scales & by also playing the same tunes an octave higher. This gets it programmed into auto pilot . It can also make for an attractive variation by playing the tune alternately in either octave or A part in one & B part in the othr etc.
george