Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: David Colpitts on July 01, 2019, 02:58:19 PM

Title: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: David Colpitts on July 01, 2019, 02:58:19 PM
Hello, all.

In a related thread about quieting a Pokerwork, some mention has been made of taping off a reed row, which I have done, but to dry the old, wet Hohner factory sound, rather than to quiet it.  I like to play drier for Irish and practice, but wetter for other genres.  Now, I take the treble end off, tape the (#) reed row holes, and reassemble.  Takes probably four minutes, but requires pliers (there’s a rhyme for a song I must write) and I am envious of larger box folk (boxes larger, not necessarily the folk) who can push a stop or flip a switch to similar effect.  Now, I can do the same job without tools if I just take the grill off, and put the tape under the pallets.  Problem there is I can only hold a few buttons while I place the tape under the pallets, and can’t use a full length strip of tape.

My next try will be for a tool (keyboard length of balsa, maybe) and a way to gently clamp the whole button row (and also both button rows, for the lower hole to be accessible.)

Anybody done something like this for fairly regular switching?  Or, a better idea/approach?

Thanks, and regards,

David
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Theo on July 01, 2019, 04:26:18 PM
Just a strip of wood the length of the keyboard, clamp it over the buttons.
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 01, 2019, 05:41:30 PM
I assume you will be using masking tape or similar to tape over the holes. I recommend reducing some of the tackiness of the tape before you apply it, by first sticking the tape to a tee-shirt or pair of jeans, then removing. It should still retain enough stickiness to do the job but if/when the time comes to remove the tape, the lower tackiness will reduce the risk of the tape fetching off slivers of wood from the fondo/pallet board thingy.

Edit: typo correction
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Microbot on July 01, 2019, 05:50:27 PM
Hi David,

...alternatively, you can 'do it proper', and fit a pullstop allowing you to switch from 1-voice to 2-voice...

https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2/pressedwooddg-1voice-2voice

In this recording, You need to go through to about 2mins 30 secs before it switches to 2-voice, which is a good full-on Hohner musette.

Cheers!

Mike R

Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Phil B on July 01, 2019, 05:55:07 PM
? from Dave  Colpitts Anybody done something like this for fairly regular switching?  Or, a better idea/approach?
Dave I have a presswood ( same size case as your pokerwork ) with a slider fitted so I can have single or two voice treble  by just pulling a stop. I use it when accompanying singers Mike Robot at St Ives fitted it for me
 
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: David Colpitts on July 01, 2019, 06:59:32 PM
Yet again, the rapid and appropriate response team comes through!  Thanks to all!  Mike and Phil, that’s a great sound, and as Mike said in the soundcloud note, a richer and more textured sound than I would expect of a single voice.  It doesn’t sound “just like a hybrid concertina” much at all.  Very cool.

And, Steve F., I have learned that the hard way, about the tack-reduction on the tape.  But, luckily, only a tiny splinter in a non-critical space.

And, Theo, of course.  I will carry the wood and clamp with me to camp, so I can switch without disassembly.  I can’t believe all the times I have pulled the pins just to tape off a row....

And Stiamh, please note it’s the C#D!

Now, for the singers:  Does the single voice just suit better?  Or have I got it backwards?

Thanks again, and regards,

David
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Lester on July 01, 2019, 07:02:37 PM
Now, for the singers:  Does the single voice just suit better?  Or have I got it backwards?
The singers I play for seem to prefer a 1 row 4 stop played with some restraint. 
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Anahata on July 01, 2019, 09:13:33 PM
Now, for the singers:  Does the single voice just suit better?  Or have I got it backwards?
The singers I play for seem to prefer a 1 row 4 stop played with some restraint.

Same here, but also one of the nice things about the 4 stop is the variety of sounds available; I use mine LM, LMM and LMMH for different songs.
When I had a Saltarelle I used it in single voice for some songs as well, including one where the L voice on its own played an octave up was just right.
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Jesse Smith on July 02, 2019, 04:46:32 AM
...alternatively, you can 'do it proper', and fit a pullstop allowing you to switch from 1-voice to 2-voice...

https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2/pressedwooddg-1voice-2voice

In this recording, You need to go through to about 2mins 30 secs before it switches to 2-voice, which is a good full-on Hohner musette.

Mike, this really surprised me with how good the single voice sounds! When I read these discussions of taping off one of the Pokerwork voices, I was highly skeptical to say the least, but I'm favorably impressed by how much it still sounds like a Hohner!
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Microbot on July 02, 2019, 10:19:18 AM
Thanks for that Jesse...

I also was surprised ...although in another sense I wasn't so surprised!

That's because I know from tuning, and blocking off a set of reeds, how good these instruments can sound with just a single voice. What I was pleased/surprised with was that introducing the pullstop mechanism ... sliders, plus rails, block and pullstop ... retained this quality of sound. The single voice is full and balances well with the chords/basses, whilst the standard 2-voice is undiminished.

I had 1mm aluminium sliders made at a local metal works, carefully sized to operate with the existing reed blocks...the usual rails made from thin birch ply, as you'd use to fit a bass-end thirds pullstop.

But as regards whats best for song accompaniment, I think it's more a matter of developing a song-accompanying 'style', which supports the song and doesn't intrude on the vocals, rather than any specific set-up/tone or instrument.

Cheers

Mike R
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 02, 2019, 10:27:31 AM
Going back to the original post, my thoughts about the wisdom of this approach (taping off under the pallets as an periodically reversible method to limit the M+ reed) continue to nag. I don't think this is an advisable/sustainable method in the long run. The continual application and removal of the tape will have a deleterious effect on the pallet board/fondo. The timber used for the fondo in Hohners tends to splinter easily, with the potential for air leaks where the pallets no longer seal properly due to slivers of wood coming away.

Far better to get a proper stop fitted - one of Mike Rowbotham's special modifications would be perfect. He does a great job!
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: rees on July 02, 2019, 06:26:24 PM
I added treble stops to my Pokerwork in 1978 (so there  ;D )
My favourite trick was to play a tune on delicate single voice D row then rip into a tune on two voice G row with full tremolo.
Works well on the dancers.
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Conjunto Dave on July 02, 2019, 10:55:54 PM
Hi.
I've masked off the "sharp" reeds simply by placing strips of A4 (80gsm) paper to cover the holes of the reed blocks. See attached picture with reed blocks removed. (Hohner Panther 3-row).
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Microbot on July 02, 2019, 11:09:47 PM
I added treble stops to my Pokerwork in 1978 (so there  ;D )
My favourite trick was to play a tune on delicate single voice D row then rip into a tune on two voice G row with full tremolo.
Works well on the dancers.

Darn it Rees!! ... there's me feeling all clever and original ... is there anything I've done that you didn't do first!?!

Mike
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Rog on July 02, 2019, 11:46:51 PM
..but why go to the bother of putting tape under the pallets when you can stick it to the bottom of a reed block...?
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: David Colpitts on July 03, 2019, 12:21:13 AM
And that’s my conclusion, too.  I took about 8 minutes to put the tape under the pallets, and about the same to remove, plus it wrecked the tape!  I can reuse with the “reed block” method lots of times.  So, I’ll just keep the pliers nearby, and it takes about 3 or 4 minutes.  So, until I do the legit stop, it’s tape for me.

Regards,

David
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 03, 2019, 01:18:33 AM
And that’s my conclusion, too.  I took about 8 minutes to put the tape under the pallets, and about the same to remove, plus it wrecked the tape!  I can reuse with the “reed block” method lots of times.  So, I’ll just keep the pliers nearby, and it takes about 3 or 4 minutes.  So, until I do the legit stop, it’s tape for me.
Just bear in mind that each time you remove the bellows pins and remove the reed blocks, you are gradually increasing the wear on the bellows pins holes and the screw threads in the soft wood. Ordinary tuning/maintenance work requires this sort of removal enough times; what you are proposing to do will hasten that wear and eventually things become loose. Personally, I wouldn't do it on my own instruments. My recommendation would be to stick with one set-up or the other until you have a proper stop and slide fitted.
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: David Colpitts on July 03, 2019, 01:26:00 AM
There, again, is something I didn’t think about.  My guess is you are precisely correct, and I think I’ll leave ‘er as is (right now, “Hohner wet”) until the proper slide/stop can be effected.  Especially since the grill-eyes seem the weakest of all;  I will leave them alone, too!

Thanks, and regards,

David
Title: Re: Taping off a reed row to dry tuning
Post by: PhilD on July 03, 2019, 06:11:24 AM
Does anyone have an internal picture of one of these (post factory fitted) reed stops?  Would be very interested to see how its achieved.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal