Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Julian S on July 23, 2019, 07:38:13 AM

Title: Time for the metronome
Post by: Julian S on July 23, 2019, 07:38:13 AM
For two years or so I have been struggling to master a tune by Rob Harbron 'Rain on the Woodpile' (recorded on the Leveret album 'Inventions'). Quite a lot of notes, quite fast, difficult to maintain rhythm.
I know the tune very well, having put many hours of practice into it, but I'm always running into problems in the b part where fingers keep getting tangled. I was about to consign the tune to the 'failed project' file, but a week ago I decided to apply myself really properly.
Out comes the metronome. Start off really slowly, right hand only, concentrate on accuracy of each note. Right hand rhythm fundamental J !
Then bring in left hand - different options with drones, short/long bass chord, standard oom pah, pauses.
Then up the rhythm gradually but use the same approach. I'm now nearly at Leveret speed and so far it's really going well...but the challenge will be internalising the metronome and trying the tune in public. And tweaking rhythm and introducing variations to make the tune more of my own whilst keeping it together. (And what about 'Terminus' which follows it - hours of fun !)
The lesson is clear - should have done this a year ago and saved quite a bit of pain. And apply this to others of my problem tunes...
Some tunes are great to learn by - just far enough out of the comfort zone, and I'm certainly finding this with several of the Leveret tunes. And I can heartily recommend the Leveret workshops at Halsway.

Julian
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 23, 2019, 08:42:17 AM
Interesting, I too have reached for my metronome app on my phone over the last couple of days. Not for a Leveret tune, but one I've transposed.

My problem is rushing triplets and not giving them their 'proper' time and added to this, some having a dot on the first note so emphasising it .
I've been using the abc midi file in combination with a metronome to maintain a constant beat as opposed to rushing through the tricky triplets and yes, taking it much slower to establish these two things.
It is coming along and working for me.

I conclude I need to concentrate on such parts of tunes rather than fly through them hoping momentum gets me through.
It's made me wonder about tunes already under my belt.
Perhaps reviewing one's playing and learning processes is a lifelong journey....
A profound thought whilst still drinking my first cuppa ;)
Q



Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Lester on July 23, 2019, 08:45:39 AM
rushing through the tricky triplets


Speeding in built up areas   ;)
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 23, 2019, 08:58:13 AM
Yep I was just coming back to make that point!
Speeding up in built up areas is an offence in many situations and not just confined to driving  ;D
Q
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: ChrisP on July 23, 2019, 10:07:01 AM
I think working with a metronome is essential. It helps with timing, and really tells you where the tricky parts of a tune are. It makes you pay attention to external prompts while also playing, which is good training for playing along with other people. I've used a little oblong Wittner pendulum(?) one for years. I have also tried using the digital jobbies on my phone, various types, but I find them very difficult. It's so much easier to align yourself with a pendulum (is that the right word, it's upside down) than any phone display I've ever seen.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 23, 2019, 10:58:29 AM
It was one of the main messages given by the three tutors at last years' Halsway Manor DG  weekend last year - use a metronome!
I admit to trying it last year then it fell by the wayside.
Now, trying to reproduce tunes that in some instances have a fixed rythm I'm finding it useful as a reference.

A current tune being learnt is a Slow March. As it was a military manuscript 'slow' has a distinct time to it, the British Army gave it 60 beats a minute for a slow march, so I'm trying to play it as it was writ. As it wants to flip along nicely, that's difficult, so a metronome is trying to reign me back!
Q
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Roger Hare on July 23, 2019, 11:23:24 AM
I think working with a metronome is essential...
Hm! I've been thinking of acquiring a metronome for the last few weeks. I've tried the
'electronic' ones on the computer, and don't like 'em.

Can anyone recommend a particular make/model of metronome? I think my preference
is leaning towards the classic 'pyramid' style and to the 'mechanical' (clockwork?) rather
than the 'electronic'...
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: nigelr on July 23, 2019, 11:45:50 AM
I've tried a variety of apps and always come back to the Wittner pyramid clockwork metronome I've used for years.  The electronic ones just don't seem to feel right and some can't even keep regular time!
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Roger Hare on July 23, 2019, 12:08:16 PM
...always come back to the Wittner pyramid clockwork metronome...
Thank you - I'd already clocked the Wittner brand - looks very promising, so your
recommendation is good news. I'm sorta tempted to take a flyer and buy a 'vintage'
example.

I'm also thinking about Rayzm and Iron Tree brands...
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: playandteach on July 23, 2019, 07:27:38 PM
Wittner's are great. You don't need to get the pyramid type though - the Wittner Taktell super mini is loud enough, and packs away small. The Piccolo is bigger, and louder. The Yamaha dome electronic is great too, though (Model QT-1). Keeps good time. Remember that the pendulum ones need a level surface or they limp.
I think that if you focus too heavily on staying in time with the pendulum then you create an artificial situation. It's better to listen and try to play as musically as possible whilst staying on the click. Having done quite a few years of click track playing, it is a more difficult skill than you might first think, as the metronone can make you play mechanically if you don't consciously think in longer phrase lengths and make the direction of your phrasing clear. It's a bit like a dancer 'marking' the moves, it can train you away from the communication of the phrase.
One good exercise is to put the metronome on and partially ignore it - treating it like another musician, but record it in short bursts. Listen back and see if you kept to tempo.
It's also good to know where the pit falls are. They're often the easiest parts - like two minims, or where you have a rest. An upbeat figure can also encourage rushing. So that 3 note pick up in TOTM St Geneste is a typical place to rush (at the end of bar 2 etc) - you have a longer note, and a rest, then an opportunity to rush. I know I'm as bad as anyone else (on melodeon) for this, but thought these might be worth pointing out. Feel free to ignore.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 23, 2019, 07:43:49 PM
P&T: Good tips. I value opinions and comments from people far more used to such things.
Thank you
Q
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Julian S on July 24, 2019, 07:40:21 AM
Definitely food for thought P&T - many thanks.
Something I have found from using the metronome is that often there is more time to play a difficult phrase than I think - mind and fingers have a tendency to play tricks...
I might enlist the help of my wife in turning down volume on my metronome after a couple of times through a tune- and then turning it up to see whether I have deviated too much. Unless I made a conscious decision to vary pace and phrasing of course !

J
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 24, 2019, 08:22:06 AM
I too have found there is more time in certain phrases than I've been giving to them. It's using a metronome/midi file and really thinking about it that has enabled me to realise this.
Consequently not giving a phrase time, but playing it more quickly means.....the tune speeds up.
The Tune Police then issue me a summons for speeding up in a built up area  :(
Q
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: boxer on July 25, 2019, 07:11:56 PM
I like to use an Alesis programmable drum box now and again, especially for reels.  I have a metronome function on the bench tuner that I use, and I set it up to "chime" on the first beat of every second bar when I feel the need for metronomic discipline in my practice.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2019, 11:40:56 PM

 
Perhaps reviewing one's playing and learning processes is a lifelong journey....
 

it certainly should be!

george
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Dick Rees on July 26, 2019, 03:52:35 AM
Laser metronome:

https://youtu.be/Mg8iThRwzlw
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 26, 2019, 12:38:57 PM
I find that my personal sin is speeding up in easier passages that can be played in one direction. There are sections that I play push-pull because if I try doing it across rows I speed up -- like a bike going down hill. Metronome's rock.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Julian S on July 26, 2019, 02:21:47 PM
Yes Gary ! Cross rowing can sometimes make runs too easy. Definitely strikes a chord with me.

Julian
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Schnorbitz on July 26, 2019, 03:11:49 PM
There is some good advice here re playing with a metronome. I totally agree with Playandteach's warning re the dangers of getting too locked into the metronome and therefore loosing the phrasing of a piece. In my other musical lives I sometimes have found it difficult to practice to a metronome (it just feels a bit binary and lifeless). My solution has been to use something like Garageband to write a drum beat backing in the correct time signature. It just seems to have a bit more groove and to be easier for me to use as a backing. The benefits whichever way you choose though are very clear.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 26, 2019, 03:19:35 PM
My solution has been to use something like Garageband to write a drum beat backing in the correct time signature. It just seems to have a bit more groove and to be easier for me to use as a backing.
Exactly what I do! it's much more friendly than a sterile metronome or click-track beat.
 (:) :|glug
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Roger Hare on July 26, 2019, 05:19:39 PM
I find that my personal sin is speeding up in easier passages that can be played in one direction...
I have been told by a professionally trained orchestral musician that this is a very common
problem for amateur musicians. On more than one occasion, she has stopped playing, and
has started beating time to force me into maintaining (or re-gaining) the rhythm...

Thank you all for the helpful advice given regarding metronomes - I'm going to mull it over
for a week or so before committing one way or t'other.

Is there any way an ABC 'metronome' could be built, I wonder...
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Dick Rees on July 26, 2019, 05:29:23 PM
I find that my personal sin is speeding up in easier passages that can be played in one direction. There are sections that I play push-pull because if I try doing it across rows I speed up -- like a bike going down hill. Metronome's rock.

 Without casting aspersions upon anyones playing, might I suggest that the LH be your "metronome" and add a bit more focus on it as a time keeper marking the pace of the piece.  Too much focus on one hand over the other can be problematic.  Each has its part to play and basic time-keeping is IMNSHO
more a function of the LH.

Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Pete Dunk on July 26, 2019, 08:04:55 PM
Is there any way an ABC 'metronome' could be built, I wonder...

Very simply! Think about it for a while.  ;) :|glug
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: george garside on July 26, 2019, 09:05:05 PM
metronomes undoubtedly have a use for those indulging in classical/exams and grades learning where foot tapping is frowned on, However in the folk/trad world I think the majority of players ( of any instrument) keep time, often quite vigerously,  with  a foot or even feet.  i.e the foot tapping provides an excellent metronome  that can do things that a mechanical or electronic metronome cannot do such as matching the tapping of the musicians foot/metronome to that of dancers  so that you are playing 'with them'  in other words the dancers and musicians are  a single entity  helping each other,  Foot tapping is easy to learn but comes naturally to most people,  its simply foot down on the beat ( bass note) and foot up on the offbeat  (chord) for 4/4 and 6/8 tunes anad foot down on the beat (bass note) and foot up up (chord chord ) for a 3/4,

Watching dancers or singers enables small alterations to speed to be made without any change in rhythm where a metronome going bonk bonk does not!

george
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 26, 2019, 09:10:54 PM

 Without casting aspersions upon anyones playing, might I suggest that the LH be your "metronome" and add a bit more focus on it as a time keeper marking the pace of the piece.  Too much focus on one hand over the other can be problematic.  Each has its part to play and basic time-keeping is IMNSHO
more a function of the LH.
This is so right in a dance context.

A common problem I notice when playing in a dance dance context is that certain other people in the band tend to finish the final bar in a part without allowing sufficient time for the dancers to finish their moves. I determinedly play the basses on the beat in the hope that they will notice what is going on. They are getting better at it but progress is sometimes slow, with certain people. It can be like wading through treacle.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: george garside on July 26, 2019, 09:19:57 PM
to me , the bass should be played in time with the foot  which should in turn be synchronised with that of the dancers. In a band  all members foot/feet should be going up and down at precisely the same time as the band leader  and anybodys who foot isn't should be entitled to at least a 'dirty look' fom the leader

george ;)
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: ChrisP on July 26, 2019, 10:47:34 PM
I think there is some forgetting of the function of a metronome. It's a practice tool, not a performance tool (we are not talking about click tracks in the recording studio, but if you can't handle a metronome, you can't handle a click track either).
It can help you learn that awkward tune by highlighting the bits you thought you knew but didn't. And by doggedly mastering playing exactly to the beat, which takes practice and determination, you learn to play where your brain wanted to, and not where your fingers defaulted to, thus gaining control over your instrument.
Of course it sounds wooden and unnatural, it's private practice and nobody is listening.
In performance you are better able to bend things how you really want to when you are more in control of the physical side of things, and when playing with others you have to be able to listen and respond to them.
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Roger Hare on July 27, 2019, 06:49:55 AM
(1) Very simply! (2) Think about it for a while.  ;) :|glug
(1) Yers, I see - that was easy wasn't it....
(2) Which is precisely what I hadn't done...

It's almost usable innit? I might just try and use it in cold blood to see if it 'works'...
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: george garside on July 27, 2019, 10:19:16 AM
just a thought on avoiding the 'speeding up' process is to develop a sort of  continuous feedback loop  .  brain - fingers - box - ear  - brain - fingers etc etc.  In other words listen to what you are playing  and slow down if you are speeding up - or vice versa.  It always surprises me that many players don't actualy listen to the detail of what they are playing

george
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 29, 2019, 08:20:55 AM
Last year our melodeon tutors, all three professional musicians, recommended a metronome for practice and all three admitted they tended to speed up on tricky bits and needed the precision of a metronome to get those tricky bits right.
A metronome is mechanical and uncompromising.
My foot is much more accommodating and forgiving, and so I need the hard line in the first instance to get the tube right.
Then the foot can take over!

Also I've set my metronome app speed for certain tunes. Once they are getting under the belt I start the app to get the speed, get my foot going, then turn it off. That gives my foot the hint. That's quite useful to embed the speed.
Q
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 29, 2019, 01:59:09 PM
just a thought on avoiding the 'speeding up' process is to develop a sort of  continuous feedback loop  .  brain - fingers - box - ear  - brain - fingers etc etc.  In other words listen to what you are playing  and slow down if you are speeding up - or vice versa.  It always surprises me that many players don't actualy listen to the detail of what they are playing

george

It isn't that surprising to me, considering that many of us kind of panic when we get on stage or in front of a microphone or join a session -- the continuous feedback loop is the first thing to go. This, I think, is why practicing (with or without a metronome) is so essential, to quell the panic!
Title: Re: Time for the metronome
Post by: Dick Rees on July 29, 2019, 02:26:53 PM
just a thought on avoiding the 'speeding up' process is to develop a sort of  continuous feedback loop  .  brain - fingers - box - ear  - brain - fingers etc etc.  In other words listen to what you are playing  and slow down if you are speeding up - or vice versa.  It always surprises me that many players don't actualy listen to the detail of what they are playing

george

It isn't that surprising to me, considering that many of us kind of panic when we get on stage or in front of a microphone or join a session -- the continuous feedback loop is the first thing to go. This, I think, is why practicing (with or without a metronome) is so essential, to quell the panic!

If nothing else, playing along with an "other" helps develop ensemble technique. 

Edit:

Audit your breathing...both lungs and bellows.  If you're holding your breath for a difficult part it will be even more tense, and if you're too closed or too open with the bellows it'll surely put stress on tempo as well.

Another "check-in" point for me is to go "a tempo" at a repeat and/or a shift from the A to the B part, etc.

Happy skweezing!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal