Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Scotty Gring on September 05, 2019, 01:55:46 AM
-
Hey everyone,
Partly I wanted to show how beautiful this 12 button bass box is :D ...
But the other part is I want to know how badly I may have offended the melodeon gods by substituting carbon fiber rod for the brass I struggled with to remove from my keyboard action. I looked all over trying to find the proper material, but stumbled across this and how it is used by model airplane enthusiasts. Having 10 pieces now in hand I can't overstate how excited I am with this material. I can put a bow into it to put in my transport pack when I take a project with me, yet it returns immediately to a perfectly straight condition. I've even been a little rough with it, as I have spares and wanted to see just where it will yield. It sure makes inserting back into place much easier. Some of you are probably asking what my plan is for keeping it in place. Well, I'm thinking I will chamfer the ends of the thru hole and drop a spot of wax.
Here's the product on Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PB3VHTR/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_U_TNfCDbT9DSG58
Okay, slam away...
-
No need for slamming.
There is no reason not to try the carbon fibre rod. So long as it is a free but not a sloppy fit through the axle holes and lever arms it should be fine and, as you say, it has the advantage of not risking permanent distortion as you insert the rod.
As for keeping the rod in place once inserted, I don't think you need worry; there should be enough friction to hold everything in the right place.
I would suggest making the rod slightly longer than the keyboard length so that there is a protruding end. This is so you have something to grip with pliers if/when you need to remove the rod at any point in the future. The protruding end need only be a few millimetres and can be covered up with an axle rod end cover as found on many Italian boxes. Available from Charlie Marshall (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hardware_Misc..html#21) (he ships internationally).
Let us know how you get on.
-
Interesting idea to use carbon fibre. The additional stiffness must be a good thing. I very precise fit in the holes in the keyboard and the levers is critical to a good action. Too tight and keys don't move freely, too loose and the keys and pallets will have too much sideways movement. Keys will fell sloppy, and pallets may hit each other. I wonder how carbon fibre surface will wear in contact with wood? Only time will tell.
-
Carbon fibre is a reinforced epoxy resin, which is very stiff and light -- but these aren't really the desirable qualities for an axle rod, you want something which is smooth and hard-wearing when in contact with whatever pivots on it -- either wood or a metal alloy, depending on what type of action is used -- and which doesn't corrode. The general engineering principle for long-lasting bearings is that one surface should be as hard and smooth as possible and the other softer, this is why case-hardened steel is common for one and either brass or something even softer like white metal for the other.
For melodeon actions the lever (wood or alloy) will usually be the softer of the two, so the best material for the other is probably something like a hard chrome/stainless steel -- whihc is what is normally used. CFRP is both softer and rougher so is likely to wear faster, its advantages of high stiffness and low density are of no advantage here. It also has much lower crush strenth than stell, which could lead to probelms in future trying to grab the end of the rod and pull it out if the mechanism has tightened up.
For making the case these are some advantages for CFRP, but again only if the design is changed to take advantage which means making it much thinner and possibly with reinforcing ribs -- the one Doug Briggs made was the same thickness as wood which means it was incredibly strong but also no lighter than wood. But if you read up on the desirable material properties for making stiff panels (see J E Gordon's fantastic books on structures and materials) then it turns out that wood is better than almost anything else, including carbon fibre...
-
I use stainless steel.
-
Okay, I'll use the carbon fiber for temporary fit-ups (since I've already got them and they are a joy to use) and upon searching more for this size in stainless (thank you, Rees) I only find welding wire. Eureka! I work for a fabrication company and our welding department has stainless welding wire in the proper diameter all day long. Funny how sometimes you can look the world over and the item you need is in your own back yard. Thanks again, everyone!
-
Okay, I'll use the carbon fiber for temporary fit-ups (since I've already got them and they are a joy to use) and upon searching more for this size in stainless (thank you, Rees) I only find welding wire. Eureka! I work for a fabrication company and our welding department has stainless welding wire in the proper diameter all day long. Funny how sometimes you can look the world over and the item you need is in your own back yard. Thanks again, everyone!
Stainless steel welding wire is easily available cut to 330mm lengths in 1.6mm and 2.4mm diameters for only a few pounds... :-)
-
Had our welding engineer go downstairs and cut me a few lengths here at work. What I was looking for was "beneath my feet" the whole time. Yes, it will be stainless welding wire this weekend, carbon fiber for fit-up only. Thanks everyone!!
-
Had our welding engineer go downstairs and cut me a few lengths here at work...
Shhh! Your Commodities Manager will hear. >:E Unless that is you.
-
Shhh! Your Commodities Manager will hear. >:E Unless that is you.
Eh, these squeeze out and discard that much (if not more) every time they change a tip on the welder. I could start a side business.
-
Shhh! Your Commodities Manager will hear. >:E Unless that is you.
Eh, these squeeze out and discard that much (if not more) every time they change a tip on the welder. I could start a side business.
I used to know a chap who talked, very quietly, about the time he spent in a factory making microchips. The chips connected to the pins by welding a gold wire link. When a reel was replaced the equipment did a slight overfeed of wire that had to be trimmed off. Apparently they called it their Christmas bonus.
-
I second the use of a hard stainless rod. I would polish the hell out of it before installing for longer wearing of the wood parts. I am pretty sure the wear characteristics of the carbon fiber rod would not make it a long term candidate in this case.
-
I assembled using the carbon fiber, and then inserted the stainless gently as I backed out the carbon fiber piece. Worked very nicely and I was able to make the little curl on the end as was in the original brass. Thank you everyone for the guidance!
-
Related question.
I have a box to repair where the holes in the wood levers have worn so badly that the pallets move sideways enough to hit and sometimes prevent closure. I have some new ground steel bar that is nominally 2mm, but actually measures 1.95. I have found some brass bushes with 2mm bore that I can’t measure but is certainly not less that 2.00. Result I still have some sideways movement.
Any suggestions?
-
I'm seeing a little movement in mine but I haven't re-attached the pallets permanently yet and was wondering if I will need to use some stainless steel shim stock to mitigate some of the "wiggle."
-
Being a butcher; I'd probably do away with the bushes and file a reaming flute into a bigger rod, ream the whole lot out in one go and then use the unfluted remainder of the rod as an axle.
Easy Peasey! (But then I don't work on expensive boxes belonging to other people!)
-
Reboring is pretty standard practice. If one if only one or two are really wobbly I often roll a paper piece and put it in the hole ,spread it out against the sides of the hole with a rod then flood the hole with super glue , wait about 30 seconds and blow the remaining glue out with a straw and my breath. let harden for an hr then rebore to old size.
Use a new rod though since it does get worn down and will not give good results if it is.
-
I quite like Winston's advice. However reaming out the whole lot seams quite time consuming.
Some time ago I did this kind of repair. Original rod diameter was 2 mm. Used a 2.3 mm bicycle spoke as a drill (the old rod still in place) - and put in a 2.5 mm steel rod.
-
Related question.
I have a box to repair where the holes in the wood levers have worn so badly that the pallets move sideways enough to hit and sometimes prevent closure. I have some new ground steel bar that is nominally 2mm, but actually measures 1.95. I have found some brass bushes with 2mm bore that I can’t measure but is certainly not less that 2.00. Result I still have some sideways movement.
Any suggestions?
Unfortunately it's my Oakwood that Theo's referring to :-(
I'm surprised that 50um clearance is still a problem; if the levers are 5mm wide (my guess) this would allow a sideways movement of +/-1mm on a 100mm long lever, which should be small enough to stop the pallets catching. But then I don't have the bits in my hand and Theo does...
BTW it looks like some of what is sold as "2mm" stainless rod might actually be "14 gauge" which is 0.078" diameter, a little bit smaller than 2mm...
-
"reaming out the whole lot seams quite time consuming."
On the contrary, TomBom. Once the reamer is made, it only takes a few minutes to twist it through all the levers and keyboard spacers when they're all married together. The picture below was the first one I did like this, but I realised that it's easier again to do it with the levers already in place.
-
Winston, that was one method I was considering. Next step is I am going to make up a dummy lever with brass bush to get an accurate measurement of the movement in place. The .05mm clearance is more than you find in new Italian metal actions.
-
Winston, that was one method I was considering. Next step is I am going to make up a dummy lever with brass bush to get an accurate measurement of the movement in place. The .05mm clearance is more than you find in new Italian metal actions.
Needless to say, I'm leaving it entirely up to Theo -- I don't care *how* he fixes it so long as it's properly fixed... ;-)
[but finding out that not all "2mm" rods are even nominally 2mm wasn't easy, not many suppliers specify the exact diameter and tolerancing...]
-
It’s fairly normal that metal, even ground to size, is normally slightly under the nominal size.
-
Winston, that was one method I was considering. Next step is I am going to make up a dummy lever with brass bush to get an accurate measurement of the movement in place. The .05mm clearance is more than you find in new Italian metal actions.
Needless to say, I'm leaving it entirely up to Theo -- I don't care *how* he fixes it so long as it's properly fixed... ;-)
[but finding out that not all "2mm" rods are even nominally 2mm wasn't easy, not many suppliers specify the exact diameter and tolerancing...]
In the end Theo drilled out both the keyboard and levers to take a 2.2mm diameter axle rod -- problem solved :-)