Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: LJC on September 16, 2009, 01:37:42 PM

Title: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: LJC on September 16, 2009, 01:37:42 PM
Everyone keeps asking about playing in funny keys, or more buttons to play in other keys, or magical switches to play in other keys... other than then easy keys DG and the slightly harder C and A on a DG box, why bother with other keys on an instrument who's very name implies it is supposed to be played in certain key(s)? Is it matcho to play my DG in Gm just because I have the notes and stops to give the chords? It certainly doesn't have the same feel as playing a C/F or Bb/Eb in Gm where it falls much more naturally.

But my real question is - do players of other instruments (folk or otherwise) have this same insatiable appetite for inventing instruments which can play in further out keys? I've never seen an Eb Hurdy Gurdy and none of the players I know go on about wanting one! Do CG anglo c*ncertina players get told to buy another system to play in Ab/Bb/whatever?

I know guitar players are always after that new axe, and I think that fiddlers on the whole seem to be the only musicians who don't fall head over heals to get a new instrument every 2/6/12 months.

I'm just as bad and would rather buy a box in an odd key to play it well rather than fiddle and fudge around with an odd system missing half the notes!
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: george garside on September 16, 2009, 03:03:26 PM
probably because  making the best of a box with obvious limitations is an interesting challenge. If this is not the reason it makes far more sense to go chromatic be it  British Chromatic,piano accordion or continental chromatic.

george 
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Stiamh on September 16, 2009, 03:34:23 PM
It's all a trade-off between what you want to be able to play, with whom and in what setting, and how many different boxes you feel comfortable acquiring, and - just as important - lugging around!

My main aim in choosing a box was to be able to play as much as possible of the music I like - nearly all, but not all, Irish - with a swing that I like. That's why I decided on C#D rather than BC or DG. While I could play stuff in more keys with a British chromatic, CBA or piano accordion, swing, weight and (why not admit it) coolness all militate against choosing one of these. So, do what you can with your chosen box, and don't worry too much about stuff you can't tackle is my philosophy. Turning up at a session with more than one box is distinctly uncool AFAIAC - heck, it's uncool enough carrying more than one tin whistle around  ;)

I agree with George that tackling uncomfortable keys is an interesting challenge - one of the many ways of maintaining your interest in the instrument and increasing your familiarity with the keyboard, which is bound to have benefits that rub off when you play in comfortable keys.

The same thing applies to fiddle playing, by the way: mastering keys with lots of flats or sharps can only benefit your playing in more mundane keys. I think.
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: ganderbox on September 16, 2009, 05:12:26 PM

 I've never seen an Eb Hurdy Gurdy and none of the players I know go on about wanting one!


No, but if french bagpipes were in Eb you most certainly would see Eb gurdies!

I know guitar players are always after that new axe, and I think that fiddlers on the whole seem to be the only musicians who don't fall head over heals to get a new instrument every 2/6/12 months.


I know a fiddle players who has got lots of them....loud, ones, quiet ones, sweet ones, electric ones, octave ones, phonofiddles (that have a horn like an antique gramaphone attached) etc etc


Turning up at a session with more than one box is distinctly uncool AFAIAC - heck, it's uncool enough carrying more than one tin whistle around  ;)



It doesn't look good walking in with an armful of boxes, although I think two is OK.

Unless you are very skilful, you will always perform a tune better if its played in one of the home keys for the box you are using, so  there is rarely any point in starting a tune at a session in an awkward key unless its for the benefit of somebody else, or you are trying to show off. If other people are playing in keys that are awkward for you, however, its nice to be able to play along instead of sitting and complaining that its in the wrong key. It's a pity that so often the keys that are used are dictated by melodeon players, and it's refreshing when different keys are used, especially for players of other  instruments who can get bored with playing in G, D and Em all the time.
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Matthew B on September 16, 2009, 05:29:01 PM
Semitone boxes aside . . . Sometimes playing in "odd" keys (ie other than, say C and F on a C/F) box is necessary because the tune one is interested in is in a key that doesn't show up on a regular box.  For example the minor keys (except on a few custom boxes) just don't exist as "home" keys.  By the same token some of the modes are only available, or are easier to finger outside the home-keys they're named for.  I have also found that figuring out how to undertake even fairly modest adventures in "key discomfort" can be an education.  Thus, learning to play a few Bb and Eb songs on a C/F club box has forced me to rethink some of the ways in which I manage my way around song accompaniment, left hand technique, and using the "dusty" end of the keyboard.  Sometimes it's just entertaining to figure out an ingenious way of doing something, and sometimes it ends up producing some unexpected and rather nice sounds. 

And of course sometimes it's a disaster, and its easier to go and find a different box, or even a different pastime, and to console oneself with the thought that fortunately this is not how one puts bread on the table. 
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Hasse on September 16, 2009, 06:50:23 PM
Turning up at a session with more than one box is distinctly uncool AFAIAC - heck, it's uncool enough carrying more than one tin whistle around  ;)

Yes, it's definitely uncool to turn up with more than one instrument at a session - I'm unfortunately one of those very uncool persons who turn up with 3 boxes two whistles and sometimes even a fiddle, and for some reason I always end up trying to play every tune on one box. Fare to lazy and not enough times to switch instrument inbetween tunes.

Playing keys "outside the box" is kind of cool and simply very practical. But bringing 3 boxes, two whistles and a fiddle to a session is  really hard work, sweaty and maybe thats macho!?!   :P  ;)

Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 16, 2009, 07:05:29 PM
Saw this thread at lunchtime and decided to let it percolate a bit.

I feel Matthew puts it very well. I think it's a really good exercise to try to play say a D/G with accidentals in Em (easy, so far)! then Am, progressing to the tougher keys of Bm A and C. I'd even have a go if I had 'low notes' installed - accepting that it woud be a modal C and A.  That's how folk music is made up.

Beyond that, I personally like to play a little bit of jazz .. which means Bb and Eb. These keys were a bugger on the D/G Oakwood, but dropping a # into G/C and a couple more accidentals has made all possible (if not yet achieved).

What relevance has this to folk music? Frankly not a lot. But if you want to play in say Gm (à la Swede) then the notes are the same as those on the Bb scale, and improvising on the Eb notes gives a nice jazzy 'phrygian' mode relative to G.  If you practice these scales and do your improvising in them (strictly) then your notes will be 'true'. It's then just a matter off keeping rhythm and making a decent improvised line ... "ah, there's the rub"  :Ph

If you are seriously into music then it's worth learning up all the 'blues' scales your instrument can reach. They are not exactly deep music, but great fun nevertheless. I still treasure the time a guitarist (playing with a capo, of course) said to me after soloing in what was supposed to be a 'session' "but you can't play Eb blues on a melodeon"  >:E
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on September 16, 2009, 07:22:37 PM
Many tunes will have three key changes ,one or more of them not being a home key.Or the tune may go from the major to the relative minor,or its own minor.For example you may need to play in D then to Emin-Bmaj or to Dmin-Amaj-Fmaj.

Chris
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Wurdal on September 16, 2009, 10:02:27 PM
If you want to play in "uncomfortable keys" I would suggest going chromatic. For the majority us working your way through something like the "Fiddlers Tune Book" by Peter Kennedy would provide you with session tunes, dance sets and several years worth of work to play well without moving outside of the keys of G,D and A.
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Falseknight on September 16, 2009, 11:43:09 PM
Many tunes will have three key changes one or more of them not being a home key.Or the tune may go from the major to the relative minor or its own minor.For example you may need to play in D then to Emin-Bmaj or to Dmin-Amaj-Fmaj.

Chris

Tunes?

Okay, some dance sets move in that way (though usually when prodded by frets or fiddle players).  Box players play tunes (and sets) that suit their instruments.  PAs can keep up, quint melodeons may not be able to.  We live with it and choose wisely the people we play with.

This does not decry either approach - it simply suggests we do what we can.
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: waltzman on September 17, 2009, 12:17:58 AM
Dancers don't care what key a tune is in........
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on September 17, 2009, 06:06:48 AM
Maybe the Swedish scottische "Balen i Karlstad " is a glorified dance set but it has four parts in C,G(D),F and F(Bb) and uses nearly all of the bass buttons.Some "sets" might force you outside of the home keys but it's nice being able to play the music as it should sound and feel limited by the instrument.

Chris
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 17, 2009, 07:17:46 AM
Tune I've liked and played for 15 years - fis scottich by the Gruupa runs in G, G  and Gm. OK we're now in a wierd key. But F natural isn't used and the only note that feels threatening (this playing on a 2 row Lilli) is Bb. Slight fudge of the tune accommodates nicely and it 'sounds like' true G minor.  (Once I got the oakwood I found I could go back to the original notes).

Obsessional? Don't think so. It's a quite different music feel that's not achievable without putting in the Bb. Hence its beauty. And actually quite easy.

Still not convinced? Play Horse's branle.  Exactly the same trick. It actually modulates into Gm. If you prefer to think of it as 'putting in a Bb accidental' - fine. Except it isn't an accident.
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: LJC on September 17, 2009, 07:58:48 AM
Perhaps I went slightly off track on my original post - I do play in other keys other than DG on my boxes, I think the question/discussion I was thinking of was why do people try to redesign the box to include all the chromatic notes for playing in any key when its really not particularly useful? Sure, a chromatic system or CBA gives you all the notes, but its not a melodeon and doesn't sound like one. The further people seem to get from a "standard" layout the less it starts to sound like a box...
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 17, 2009, 09:22:19 AM
Quote
"standard" layout
Standard? There's no such thing in melodeon world. CBA & PA's are 'standard' - you don't find players of proper accordions discussing whether they're going to switch individual accidentals or low notes around etc. I haven't come across 'standard' yet. My little D/G Primo was bought as brand new and 'standard' from the Musicroom in Cleckheaton - turns out that the low C# on the D row is in fact C natural. I'm not unhappy and it comes in really useful but standard...? Most melodeon players that I talk to in the flesh nearly always tell me about the 'tweaks' and notes they've turned re-tuned etc, etc, in order to be able to play this or type of music. I find it all quite boring really. It appears to me that the 'standard' is that there is no standard.
AL
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Dazbo on September 17, 2009, 04:22:55 PM
...why do people try to redesign the box to include all the chromatic notes for playing in any key when its really not particularly useful? Sure, a chromatic system or CBA gives you all the notes, but its not a melodeon ...

Couldn't agree more
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: george garside on September 17, 2009, 05:55:19 PM
I have often wondered why those wanting a veriety of odd keys  with the simplicity of a one row keyboard can't be catered for  by having about   8 or 9 reedblocks mounted on a vertical shaft with a sort of tram handle at the top of the box to rotate it to bring a particular reed block into line with a hole in an outer tube ( to provide a good seal ) which has just one line of holes lining up with the pallets.  I recon you could get it all in a right hand casing about 7 or 8 inches sqare when viewed from the chin end & the same length as any other 10 or 12 key box.  Maybe the bass could have a similar arrangement so it would really be like driving an old tram with 2 handles!

george ;)
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: stevejay on September 17, 2009, 06:00:58 PM
You might get a lot more reeds sounding than you bargained for? ::)

Interesting idea, but sounds like it might not work. If you create it, please post on youtube  ;)
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 17, 2009, 06:25:05 PM
I have often wondered why those wanting a veriety of odd keys  with the simplicity of a one row keyboard can't be catered for  by having about   8 or 9 reedblocks mounted on a vertical shaft with a sort of tram handle at the top of the box to rotate it to bring a particular reed block into line with a hole in an outer tube ( to provide a good seal ) which has just one line of holes lining up with the pallets.  I recon you could get it all in a right hand casing about 7 or 8 inches sqare when viewed from the chin end & the same length as any other 10 or 12 key box.  Maybe the bass could have a similar arrangement so it would really be like driving an old tram with 2 handles!

  Hmmm - do you plan to install this as a modification to their
   accordions   ...  or are we talking  "monkey and nuts"?   >:E
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Lester on September 17, 2009, 07:03:01 PM
There was someone around the Bucks area who had a pokerwork with quick release belows and easily swapped reed blocks to enable him to change keys easily. Kind of think it would have just been easier to carry more than one box?
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: george garside on September 17, 2009, 07:38:05 PM
There was someone around the Bucks area who had a pokerwork with quick release belows and easily swapped reed blocks to enable him to change keys easily. Kind of think it would have just been easier to carry more than one box?

many years ago there was a band at Whitby Folk Week called, I think, Toque Bleau or something like that. Their box player had a pokerwork  with the treble end sawn in half & hinged with quick release catches & similarly quick release reed bloscks. He could change 2 reed blocks in around 30 seconds & carried a neumber of spare ones in  a sort of quiver like what archers carry arrows in. He also haad a number of additional bass buttons that stuck out here & there.

george
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Theo on September 17, 2009, 10:45:25 PM
There was someone around the Bucks area who had a pokerwork with quick release belows and easily swapped reed blocks to enable him to change keys easily. Kind of think it would have just been easier to carry more than one box?

many years ago there was a band at Whitby Folk Week called, I think, Toque Bleau or something like that. Their box player had a pokerwork  with the treble end sawn in half & hinged with quick release catches & similarly quick release reed bloscks. He could change 2 reed blocks in around 30 seconds & carried a neumber of spare ones in  a sort of quiver like what archers carry arrows in. He also haad a number of additional bass buttons that stuck out here & there.

george

That is Richard Adamson from Hexham.
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: triskel on September 18, 2009, 02:19:55 AM
There was someone around the Bucks area who had a pokerwork with quick release belows and easily swapped reed blocks to enable him to change keys easily.

Their box player had a pokerwork  with the treble end sawn in half & hinged with quick release catches & similarly quick release reed bloscks. He could change 2 reed blocks in around 30 seconds & carried a neumber of spare ones in  a sort of quiver like what archers carry arrows in.

You remind me of an early French accordeon (or "flutina", if you prefer) that I got off eBay in the US last year, which came in a fitted case with a lidded compartment in the bottom for the spare reed pans. So you could simply slide the top off the accordeon (they're built like an old-style pencil case) and swap over the pans in double-quick time. I reckon it was probably made for a travelling professional, maybe with a minstrel troupe a century and a half ago.  ???

There ain't nothin' new under the sun...  ::)
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 18, 2009, 08:16:00 AM
Theo - or any other Geordie: Is that chap with the sawn off box still around. Richard? Last seen headed for Morpeth having married a vet there.

He'd neatly cut right through C/G and a B/C right ends just inside the gasket and fixed clips so he could attach either. Left end was 'permanat' but also heavily modified with extra basses. 

AFAIR Richard could play in most keys .. but it was certainly an uncomfortable box! And he still gets to carry 2 cases ;)
Title: Re: The Obsession With Playing Boxes in Uncomfortable Keys?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on September 18, 2009, 10:47:30 AM
You remind me of an early French accordeon (or "flutina", if you prefer) that I got off eBay in the US last year, which came in a fitted case with a lidded compartment in the bottom for the spare reed pans. So you could simply slide the top off the accordeon (they're built like an old-style pencil case) and swap over the pans in double-quick time. I reckon it was probably made for a travelling professional, maybe with a minstrel troupe a century and a half ago.  ???

That sounds great!  Can you post some pics, please?  I'm also curious about the keys of the various reed pans.
-Andy
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal