Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: The Oul' Boy on November 12, 2019, 09:17:31 AM
-
So I took the plunge last night and went to my local Rapper group, which turned out to be enormous fun with lovely people, even if my wrists are aching this morning. When they asked me whether I played any instruments, I told them I'd been learning melodeon for 10 months, and they said I should bring it along next time. Eek! No more terrifying words have ever been spoken. I only know a few jigs and play them neither fast nor all that smoothly, and I don't think my clacky Pokerwork versions of Salmon Tails or Uncle Bernard's are going to impress anyone! Do I (a) Go into hiding, (b) Mumble something about still needing to get better and put it off (and off, and off), or (c) Bite the bullet and turn up with my melodeon in the knowledge that my playing, whilst perfectly adequate for someone who's only been at it for 10 months, is not yet of a standard where anyone could dance to it?
In all seriousness though, at what stage did you 'go public' with your playing, and how did it work out? Is there ever a time when you feel confident enough to turn up and play in front of people who aren't your nearest and dearest?
-
Curious. By the time I took up melodeon I had run 2 folk clubs, and was plonked abruptly to sing in front of 2000 people at Leiden, age 18. I’d expected 200
Yet, melodeon in public was a whole set of new fears. I cracked it at Whitby FC after a year with 2 very well practiced polkas, but 30 years later still get dry mouth and palpitations when I improvise a stanza in public.
-
Playing for rapper is a hard way to start! Best with a solo musician, and the fast pace! Perhaps you will meet other players through being part of the rapper side and set up some opportunities for playing with others.
-
Playing for rapper is a hard way to start! Best with a solo musician, and the fast pace! Perhaps you will meet other players through being part of the rapper side and set up some opportunities for playing with others.
Yes, I don't think they were hoping I'd play for them straight away or indeed any time soon (they have a melodeon and fiddle player), but just to see what I could do and encourage me along (and a couple of them dance morris, and were asking, leadingly I suspect, if I can play Princess Royal, which I can, though I doubt I'd win any prizes for it). But even setting aside playing for the side itself, playing in front of any more experienced musicians is a terrifying thought!
-
fully agree with Theo. Playing for rapper requires not only speed but more importantly speed with great accuracy and the ability to make small adjustments on the hoof . Trying to do it for real before you can is unlikely to benefit you or the dancers. However selecting just one of the sides tunes and practicing it a great deal can help get you ready for the real thing. Also it may be possible on practice nights to stand as far away from the dancers as you can and join in VERY quietly so you hear what you are playing but the dancers/musicians can't!
For what its worth I NEVER used the bass when playing for rapper and my preferred box was a DG Lilly which I saw as a sort of substitute for the traditional fiddle.
george
-
Totally agree, the rapper sides I've danced with would take some playing for.
But..... good for you, you have gone and met some other people who can nurture and encourage you and your playing.
If nothing else, a post practice or post dance out session can be a great way to learn, play the odd tune and build confidence.
...and beer might be involved :|glug
Well done, and keep popping along!
Q
-
For what it's worth, Border Morris seems to be a pretty forgiving tradition to play along with. Some might see that as a weakness but I don't ;D
-
For what it's worth, Border Morris seems to be a pretty forgiving tradition to play along with. Some might see that as a weakness but I don't ;D
Oh totally. I don't play for border regularly having migrated to the light side some years ago but there are a couple of local border teams that we sometimes meet out and and about who will ask me to step in for the odd number if they're short of musicians. Compared to Cotswold it is just easy - a predictable number of A's and B's, steady rhythm no slows, no nuanced changes of pace to accommodate corners, no pulling the speed back for a hey or coming back to an A after a stick chorus ... just play, loud, steady and solid.
I can't comment on playing for rapper because I never have. I mean why would I when there are swords to play with?
On the subject of nerves and fears - I find I get almost none when dancing, except for that lovely good sort of rush of nerves just before dancing on a big stage or taking a new team out but playing is another story. I still get nervous every time I play solo for morris. Every time. Bah.
[Edit: I just realised I don't get nervous on the occasions I am asked to play by the local border teams. I never even realised that....]
-
Yes, I agree Border is easier to play for than Cotswold morris for exactly the reasons Helena gives.
Any form of contact with a dance side will enable you to meet players and talk tunes and simply be encouraged. Watching a good player is also inspiring in itself.
Go forth, meet, talk, listen, watch and occasionally :|glug
You know it makes sense ;)
Q
-
I can't say I ever get nervous playing for dances, whether Morris or social - but for some reason the brain sometimes goes blank just when I need to play the introduction. Must be age I suppose. And this evening I'm going to be teaching some Breton and French dances, then leading the music - that IS a worry ! Post performance angst is another problem - but I remind myself it's part of the learning experience. It's good to stretch and challenge oneself and not be too self-critical when we don't get it quite right.
I have a strong memory of rushing onto the old arena stage at Sidmouth many years ago, out of breath from dancing, picking up the box to play the intro to the next dance by Martha Rhodens, and nobbut a squeak came out when I played the first note. I'm certain my swear word came over the P.A. quite clearly to the assembled crowd. Took a deep breath and big bellows draw and all was fine. But perhaps I just dreamed it... ::)
J
-
e. I'm certain my swear word came over the P.A. quite clearly to the assembled crowd.
J
The assembled crowd probably thought it was the name of the dance
george ;D
-
Ahhh…. Julian, I remember it, so it was you >:E
;D
Q
-
Not only is Border more straight forward, it is also FUN...FUN...FUN.
It spans all sorts of levels of skill. Many sides are happy to welcome beginners and bring them on.
-
Not only is Border more straight forward, it is also FUN...FUN...FUN.
It spans all sorts of levels of skill. Many sides are happy to welcome beginners and bring them on.
I'd love to dance Border Morris (something I once joined in with on a day out in fact), but living in Edinburgh, the nearest side is probably Rag Bag in Berwickshire, which is a bit of a hike.
-
Not only is Border more straight forward, it is also FUN...FUN...FUN.
It spans all sorts of levels of skill. Many sides are happy to welcome beginners and bring them on.
I'd love to dance Border Morris (something I once joined in with on a day out in fact), but living in Edinburgh, the nearest side is probably Rag Bag in Berwickshire, which is a bit of a hike.
Kick The Cat (Appalacian Clog)) in Edinburgh might be interesting. Border Reivers in Glasgow, likewise, but more of a hike.
-
There's a Border team in Glasgow - Border Reivers. Don't know if there's a website, but they're on Facebook.
(Edit: Greg beat me to it)
-
Played for Morris, but Rapper … always too fast for me and stayed on the too hard tray. Well done!
-
Kick The Cat (Appalacian Clog)) in Edinburgh might be interesting. Border Reivers in Glasgow, likewise, but more of a hike.
Yes, Border Reivers is an option too, but maybe more of a hike, not sure. Thanks!
-
Go forth, meet, talk, listen, watch and occasionally :|glug
You know it makes sense ;)
Q
Thanks Q, you are always so encouraging and helpful with your advice! I do think I need to drink more beer when I play, perhaps it would smooth things out a bit...
-
Go forth, meet, talk, listen, watch and occasionally :|glug
You know it makes sense ;)
Q
Thanks Q, you are always so encouraging and helpful with your advice! I do think I need to drink more beer when I play, perhaps it would smooth things out a bit...
A very wise man once told me "to play pi**ed, you have to practice pi**ed". Having been caught out by a few too many sherberts in the early days, I now allow myself no more than a couple of beers during a days playing and then catch up in the evening once we've finished dancing out. It means I have to deal with the nerves other ways, but I've learnt I can't play drunk! ;D :o
-
Thank you Oul' Boy for your kind words.
Yep, I think Nigel's approach is the best way.... sherberts after playing!
Q
-
I do drink, but when I played for a living I never had even one drink before playing. If I knocked a passage over sober, I could accept that it was one of those things, but if you let people down and you've had a drink you are never quite sure if it would have been a different result completely sober. Alertness is vital for adjusting to all the finer points of ensemble too. I did find on the rare occasions that my family had come along to see me, that it made me more conscious of my playing. The best solution to nerves is to focus on the shape of the music, focusing on the direction of the phrases. That takes your mind off everything else. Of course I can't do any of those things on a box.
-
Rapper
Playing for rapper is very hard, I found. My local side (when they've had need of a helping hand) want the music played right at the top end of the speed I'm able to achieve - jigs with about 3/8=150 being their kinda minimum speed for comfort. Playing without the bass end seems like a necessity, and honestly it kinda stops sounding like music to me. It's a work in progress, though, because I never really practiced doing any of that before, and I couldn't really read the dance for a toffee.
In terms of 'what I did', playing career wise, I learnt to play like 4 tunes (Winster Gallop, Egan's Polka, Oh Dear What Can the Matter Be, and Cock of the North) and then joined a morris side to gain experience and continue to get more seasoned advice from the melodeon player they would obviously have. 2 and a half years later, I'm still their only melodeon player Edit actually strike that, my mum has mostly packed in with the drum and gone full time melodeon with the side, so, there is two of us.
Just experiencing going and being part of the band though, playing the music, even if only kind-of, and discovering that it will usually be OK has been the most helpful thing for me. But, we have a very big band where it's easy to hide, if one wanted to. Following that, being thrown in at the deep end and having a bad experience, and hating myself for about 48 hours - then coming back out of that and noting that not one single person has ever commented negatively to me about it... that was also, let's say, character building.
I'd still vote option (c).
-
I remain in awe of those who play successfully with other musicians or dancers. Because I take Erica busking, there is very little pressure on us. We set the repertoire and the tempo. I really cannot recall being daunted by the idea. So I'd recommend busking as a means of breaking the ice.
-
I'd find busking the most daunting of all - you are setting up shop to play uninvited - so I feel you'd better be darn good. Especially if you are within earshot of cafes where people are stuck listening, rather than walking on by. I guess we all have our inhibitions. I've got to play with a choir in our Abbey Christmas concert coming up, and I'm already terrified. Someone else is writing the music, but I'm head of music at the local high school, so playing a hobby instrument makes me feel very vulnerable.
-
I agree with the various comments about the detrimental effects of imbibing 'falling over juice'' whilst playing as it is indeed a double edged sword . i.e you feel your playing is great when the opposite is the reality!
There is of course the additional penalty of feeling you need a pee half way through a tune, particularly when the nearest bog is far away!
george ;D
-
but I'm head of music at the local high school, so playing a hobby instrument makes me feel very vulnerable.
Not sure whether describing a melodeon as a '' hobby instrument'' is a compliment or a criticism of the box we all love to play
george >:E ;)
-
Not only is Border more straight forward, it is also FUN...FUN...FUN.
It spans all sorts of levels of skill. Many sides are happy to welcome beginners and bring them on.
I'd love to dance Border Morris (something I once joined in with on a day out in fact), but living in Edinburgh, the nearest side is probably Rag Bag in Berwickshire, which is a bit of a hike.
Thats a pity. There was a time (a long time ago) when there were at least 4 Morris sides in Edinburgh, one rapper two clogs and one cotswold! BOrder was dome occasionally At one time or another I played or danced with them all (not simultaneously I might add)! Probably your nearest is now Banchory who I suspect are still going. An aside on playing for rapper, Beltane (which was the disappeared Edinburgh rapper side) always danced 160 up (all under 30 years old at the time including the musicians)! An evening out with them resulted always in a very sore right arm.
-
I was thrown in at the deep end. I got my pokerwork in 1977 and soon managed about half a dozen tunes that sounded ok-ish to me. I practised with a couple of very experienced friends in a very informal way and somehow got involved with some of the jubilee celebrations as a bit of quiet background music.
We ended up in a barn and one of the people there happened to be a caller. One thing led to another and I found myself playing all evening with a remarkably limited repertoire. 3 jigs, 2 polkas, a waltz and the Swedish masquerade after a fashion.
Strangely, I wasn't nervous
Not like today.
-
so far Cotswold, Border and Rapper , and apalation clog have been mentioned/discussed in this thread - What about North West ????????????????????????????????????
george
-
And nothing can beat that first drink after a successful evening playing for dancing. Sessions and concerts are all very well, but watching people enjoying dancing to your music is just so wonderful. Best way for me to keep motivated in music and life more generally.
(:) :|glug
J
-
totally agree!
george
-
Rapper has to be fast ???? really????
As a startig point rapper is a traditional dance of Tyneide/Durham coal miining communities. The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back, When the students of Kings College formed the Newcastle Kingsmen in 1949 there were thousands of of pit ponies employed underground (I don't know the number of pit ponies the National Coal Board had, but the newly created British Railways then owned 7,000 shunting horses.)
70 years on and it is 36 years since I left the Kingsmen - I was a member for a couple of years as an undergraduate in the early 80's - a time when the traditional coal and iron industries of the area where in catastrophic decline. By the time I joined the Kingsmen circa 1981 they were one of the longest established rapper teams with an unbroken history. They had also stuck with dancing at the traditional pace- always in jig time but quite slow. In the shuffle the beating foot was turned out for the first beat and straight forward for the second so the toes made a circular movement. Many of the newer sides - formed in areas where rapper wasn't a traditional dance (like everywhere south of the River Wear) danced much faster and their dancers reduced the shuffle to a kick out and back.
But the beat is (agree with George here) absolutely essntial. Rapper is a hard shoe dance and when you hit the spot all the dancers feet come down together on every beat- as in clog the percussion section is the team's feet. On a Friday night pub crawl (dancing round the pubs in a district was the means of raising cash to go to festivals) the one thing you didn't want was the audience clapping along because if you couldn't hear your own feet you couldn't hear the rythm....or the fiddler for that matter.
That's my tuppence worth. But what do I know.
-
Rapper has to be fast ???? really????
Even when it is played at a less than absolutely flat out pace, it is played in ways that a beginner would take a certain amount of time to come to terms with. Something to aspire to, I think, rather than a starting point.
I do think The Kingsmen are great.
-
Now you've done it - a few years ago I went along to see Anonymous Morris at Wimborne folk festival and played along as I had my recorders with me - then I took my drum along to various events where they were dancing, then I got a snare drum - then was lured into trying to play melodeon - this year there was one run of eight days which included the Swanage folk festival weekend where I was out every day - Anonymous Thursday, Swanage Friday Saturday Sunday, Monday was longsword practice, Tuesday a longsword dance out, Wednesday was Cotswold (Bampton), and then it was Anonymous again on the Thursday.
These days my husband enquires not if I am going out, but if I will be in.
-
The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back
Nope. Although this old chestnut is oft repeated, I don't believe there is a shred of evidence for it.
-
Although rappers do bear some resemblance to things like this: https://www.tattiniriding.com/en-us/product/sweat-scraper-two-handles-stainless-steel-1779?fr=p-1810/url
-
Thats a pity. There was a time (a long time ago) when there were at least 4 Morris sides in Edinburgh, one rapper two clogs and one cotswold! BOrder was dome occasionally At one time or another I played or danced with them all (not simultaneously I might add)! Probably your nearest is now Banchory who I suspect are still going. An aside on playing for rapper, Beltane (which was the disappeared Edinburgh rapper side) always danced 160 up (all under 30 years old at the time including the musicians)! An evening out with them resulted always in a very sore right arm.
Wow! A golden age. Alas there don't seem to be any morris sides in Edinburgh now at all, the nearest being Border Reivers in Glasgow and Rag Bag in Berwickshire I think.
-
Yes really? Well of course opinion is divided on speed. I remember the Kingsmen well. I think you came up to Edinburgh a few times in the late 70s/80s. Maybe we met? We danced Winlaton and got our 'speeding instructions' straight from the horses mouth so to speak from Jack Atkins himself. Here is a pic of the team with Jack when he taught us the dance. Of course its different for different dances the 'high Spen' we did was much more sedate! But I could not even attempt is now; it's a young mans dance at that speed for sure! I can also confirm the clapping problem.
Rapper has to be fast ???? really????
As a startig point rapper is a traditional dance of Tyneide/Durham coal miining communities. The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back, When the students of Kings College formed the Newcastle Kingsmen in 1949 there were thousands of of pit ponies employed underground (I don't know the number of pit ponies the National Coal Board had, but the newly created British Railways then owned 7,000 shunting horses.)
70 years on and it is 36 years since I left the Kingsmen - I was a member for a couple of years as an undergraduate in the early 80's - a time when the traditional coal and iron industries of the area where in catastrophic decline. By the time I joined the Kingsmen circa 1981 they were one of the longest established rapper teams with an unbroken history. They had also stuck with dancing at the traditional pace- always in jig time but quite slow. In the shuffle the beating foot was turned out for the first beat and straight forward for the second so the toes made a circular movement. Many of the newer sides - formed in areas where rapper wasn't a traditional dance (like everywhere south of the River Wear) danced much faster and their dancers reduced the shuffle to a kick out and back.
But the beat is (agree with George here) absolutely essntial. Rapper is a hard shoe dance and when you hit the spot all the dancers feet come down together on every beat- as in clog the percussion section is the team's feet. On a Friday night pub crawl (dancing round the pubs in a district was the means of raising cash to go to festivals) the one thing you didn't want was the audience clapping along because if you couldn't hear your own feet you couldn't hear the rythm....or the fiddler for that matter.
That's my tuppence worth. But what do I know.
-
This sounds about the usual tempo. Works great for youngsters.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=3&v=8_JVb97s0EY&feature=emb_logo
Not that fast but very solid.
-
Pretty fast here too, with nice melodeon (including bass!): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVFD2iwObqA
-
The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back
Nope. Although this old chestnut is oft repeated, I don't believe there is a shred of evidence for it.
I'm not convinced either. I worked underground for many years in the collieries of South Yorkshire and South Wales.
There was a tool known as a 'rapper' which was basically a length of flexible steel (perhaps a bit shorter than present-day rapper swords) which was used by haulage men in charge of the underground rope-driven transport system for moving men, coal and materials around the mine roadways. Above the haulage roadway there would be a pair of bare steel wires running the length of the haulage way. These wires carried a low-voltage electric current (about 12v if I remember correctly. When shorted out by placing the rapper across the two wires, a bell would ring in the engine-house which could be over a mile away. There was a system of bell codes signalled to the engine-man to start, stop or reverse the stationary winding engine which would then draw the wagons along the roadway.
The act of signalling in this way was known as 'rapping off' the required number of bell rings to the engine man. "All those girders loaded, Bill?" "Yep!" "Right-oh, rap 'er away then". (two raps to go inbye, three raps to go outbye, one rap to stop at any time. If men were being transported, the signal would be eight raps first of all).
The rapper tool itself could also be a custom-made T-piece consisting of a cross-piece of steel blade mounted on a wooden handle. This made it easier for the haulage man riding on the wagons to signal while in motion to the engine-man to stop the haulage if necessary (i.e. if something was amiss). But often the rapper tool could just as well be a bit of old hacksaw blade, or a pen-knife blade.
A similar useage of the term 'to rap' would be employed at the mine shaft pit bottom, but normally this would be done by pressing a bell push which would cause a bell to ring in the winding engine-house at the surface and signal the engine-man to raise or lower the shaft cage. It was still known as 'rapping off' though, and immortalised in the Geordie song "Rap 'er te bank, me canny lad (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NhW6cVVor_8)". In the really old days, shaft signalling was sometimes done by rapping (beating) a suspended steel sheet with a hammer, a bit like sounding a gong, and hoping the engine-man on the pit top would hear the signals correctly. :o
Anyway - that's what I think a rapper is/was.
-
All sorts of good stuff but too long to edit on my phone
Hence the song Rap her t'bank
https://youtu.be/lKlUQCb5xFw (https://youtu.be/lKlUQCb5xFw)
-
The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back
Nope. Although this old chestnut is oft repeated, I don't believe there is a shred of evidence for it.
I'm not convinced either. I worked underground for many years in the collieries of South Yorkshire and South Wales.
There was a tool known as a 'rapper' which was basically a length of flexible steel (perhaps a bit shorter than present-day rapper swords) which was used by haulage men in charge of the underground rope-driven transport system for moving men, coal and materials around the mine roadways. Above the haulage roadway there would be a pair of bare steel wires running the length of the haulage way. These wires carried a low-voltage electric current (about 12v if I remember correctly. When shorted out by placing the rapper across the two wires, a bell would ring in the engine-house which could be over a mile away. There was a system of bell codes signalled to the engine-man to start, stop or reverse the stationary winding engine which would then draw the wagons along the roadway.
The act of signalling in this way was known as 'rapping off' the required number of bell rings to the engine man. "All those girders loaded, Bill?" "Yep!" "Right-oh, rap 'er away then". (two raps to go inbye, three raps to go outbye, one rap to stop at any time. If men were being transported, the signal would be eight raps first of all).
The rapper tool itself could also be a custom-made T-piece consisting of a cross-piece of steel blade mounted on a wooden handle. This made it easier for the haulage man riding on the wagons to signal while in motion to the engine-man to stop the haulage if necessary (i.e. if something was amiss). But often the rapper tool could just as well be a bit of old hacksaw blade, or a pen-knife blade.
A similar useage of the term 'to rap' would be employed at the mine shaft pit bottom, but normally this would be done by pressing a bell push which would cause a bell to ring in the winding engine-house at the surface and signal the engine-man to raise or lower the shaft cage. It was still known as 'rapping off' though, and immortalised in the Geordie song "Rap 'er te bank, me canny lad (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NhW6cVVor_8)". In the really old days, shaft signalling was sometimes done by rapping (beating) a suspended steel sheet with a hammer, a bit like sounding a gong, and hoping the engine-man on the pit top would hear the signals correctly. :o
Anyway - that's what I think a rapper is/was.
That's the best explanation I've ever come across, Steve, and makes perfect sense. I've never subscribed to either of the pony cleaner/drawknife theories, but until now hadn't found a credible derivation.
Graham
-
Along side Steve's explanation, I remember Roy Dommett commenting on it during one of his Morris instructionals.
He made the point that a rapper sword could not be made before spring steel had been manufactured.
That knowledge was brought over from Germany by the forge masters who set up forges and steel works to make spring steel.
Roy noted that there then seemed to be sword sides formed on those areas. The implication being the sword traditions were brought over by the forge masters.
Q
-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=3&v=8_JVb97s0EY&feature=emb_logo
Not that fast but very solid.
Pretty fast here too, with nice melodeon (including bass!): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVFD2iwObqA
The beat of the steps here are what I would describe as 140 and 145 respectively. Those were the tempos I achieved when asked to play for a side, and, that was about as fast as I could play at the time, and I'm not sure that's changed. Doing so for a whole rapper dance was quite exhausting, and, as I say, this side did still ask if they could get it a little faster. By comparison, the preferred beat of the steps of my border side I'd describe by comparison as being 70.
So I mean idk, I would describe keeping up with both those videos as being challenging.
-
All sorts of good stuff but too long to edit on my phone
??? I didn't write that.
Hence the song Rap her t'bank
https://youtu.be/lKlUQCb5xFw (https://youtu.be/lKlUQCb5xFw)
Previously referenced...
...immortalised in the Geordie song "Rap 'er te bank, me canny lad (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NhW6cVVor_8)".
-
Ma 'se breug bhuam bé breug thugam.....If it is a lie from me it was a lie to me.
Either way the pony scraper was the only narrative of what a rapper was that I ever heard in Newcastle. and I have never heard of rapper as a locally traditional dance outside of Durham/Northumberland.
Temperable " Huntsman' " steel has been around since the 1780's (maybe earlier) and was the foundation (correct me if I'm wrong Steve) of the Sheffield steel ( i.e. knife steel) industry. Mass produced mild steel, which isn't temperable only came on the scene with the invention of the Bessemer furnace in the 1870's.
-
Either way the pony scraper was the only narrative of what a rapper was that I ever heard in Newcastle. and I have never heard of rapper as a locally traditional dance outside of Durham/Northumberland.
I don't doubt that, and it was certainly a commonly held theory when I was doing rapper when I was younger and fitter in the late 60s/early 70s; I was never entirely convinced by it, though, even then. That doesn't necessarily mean it's wrong, but I do find Steve's reasoning more plausible. And I think you're quite correct that it's (as far as current research shows!) unique to the North-East.
Graham
-
"Although rappers do bear some resemblance to things like this: https://www.tattiniriding.com/en-us/product/sweat-scraper-two-handles-stainless-steel-1779?fr=p-1810/url"
That two handled sweat scraper strikes me as having rather more than "some resemblance". Could it not be argued that this implement could have also been used to short the wires as in Steve's explanation? After all, he does describe other tools etc being used to do the same job, possibly because they were just "at hand". A custom made T piece or hacksaw blade would not normally be in the hands of a pony driver, just as the tool shown would only be in the hands of such a man. Indeed, the very existence of a "custom made T piece" would lend credence to this theory! Even if there were no pit-ponies, using the scraper this way could just be a leftover tradition for older pitmen.
Having had a lifetime of using handtools, I could give many instances of using the wrong tool simply because it was at hand and would function OK there and then. I believe this could be the answer to this conundrum.
-
Brass was cheap when steel was expensive. It becomes brittle when worked, as by repeated flexing, but could be replaced equally cheaply. Carlisle Sword once danced in a pub, after which the landlord produced a set of brass-bladed rappers and said 'I always wondered what these were.' He asked for them to be danced into a nut which he could display, but one broke.
Records suggest that old-time teams were much more conservative about bending their rappers than is the case today, which is not surprising bearing in mind the variety of sources they found for their blades, often repurposing second-hand metal.
Horse scrapers were also made out of brass. Designs varied (and still do) but some are indistinguishable from fixed-handle rappers.
'Rapper' or 'raper' is an old dialect word for a sword (and specifically an edged sword rather than the rapier with which it is sometimes confused); I know of examples in records from Huddersfield, Perth, and Elgin using the word in this sense, which is not to say that it didn't have other meanings as well.
Tempo: I've been in dances between the 140s and pushing 200. The latter was an error by a nervous musician on the Sidmouth Arena, and the stepping quality was not the best we had ever done.
Make of these fragments what you will.
-
The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back
Nope. Although this old chestnut is oft repeated, I don't believe there is a shred of evidence for it.
It's also not exclusively a mining thing - what I've heard from Paul Davenport (who also refuted the pit-pony-scraper myth) is that all sorts of workplaces in the NE used to have rapper teams, but the practice carried on in the coalmines long after the others had stopped.
-
Do you guys have a pre-show routine like scales practice, "loosen-up"-tunes or something?
I will generally start to feel nerves one hour pre-show, and down a couple beers (3 tops). Then go in and just try to have fun.
-
I do practice scales, that and the related chords are a sound basis for impro. My performances are generally in the Belvedere session in Liverpool, which has very excellent real ales :|glug
Warming up? Yes to that too. It is a mixed session and I'd tend to start with songs as my turn comes round. In school half terms we often get Rivington's superb clog dancer Ruth Bibby and it has been an absolute pleasure to play for her. NW English clog style is .. relaxed. "Straight" waltzes don't work for it and the line is perforce improvised.
Actually I've discovered that the fewer notes I put in the better it goes!
-
It's also not exclusively a mining thing …
The origin of sword dance is eclipsed by time but the more I've watched it, the more I've come to perceive it as a linked ring dance form. The swords could easily be scarves, or wooden batons, as in some of the NE coast traditions. That's also to say that the dance part is more important that the 'lock' climax.
There are linked ring dance styles throughout Europe, including some of the Swedish Islands, "chorus" is from the Greek for a ring dance according to Lloyd. "Sword" prevalence here seems to map the Danelaw areas? Rapper clearly went … off at a tangent at some stage in history :o
-
"Rapper clearly went … off at a tangent at some stage in history"
Now, that, I like! Following the non-conformist NE traditions nicely.
-
The rapper itslf was originally a 2 handled scraper used in grooming pit ponies- it was used to scrape sweat/coal dust off the animal's back
Nope. Although this old chestnut is oft repeated, I don't believe there is a shred of evidence for it.
It's also not exclusively a mining thing - what I've heard from Paul Davenport (who also refuted the pit-pony-scraper myth) is that all sorts of workplaces in the NE used to have rapper teams, but the practice carried on in the coalmines long after the others had stopped.
Anahata- Denial is one thing, refutation demands a plausible alternative explanation. What do you suggest? The existence of "workplace" rapper teams does not contradict the idea that the rapper was originally a horse driver's sweat scraper
Helena : "This old chestnut" is the folklore of the part of England that rapper comes from.
The tradition that rapper comes from the mining community and that rappers were originally sweat scrapers used for grooming pit horses is one I find entirely plausible.
Nicholas Wood's "A Practical Treatise on Rail-roads and Inland Communication in General...", 1st Edition, 1826, was the first definitive text book on railway engineering- in it Wood explored the mechanics and economics of the railroads which had developed as an ancilliary to and essential component of the Tyneside coal mining and exporting industry. Large numbers of Horses were employed drawing wagons on Colliery wagonways, typically a couple of miles long and linking individual pit heads with coal staithes on the Tyne. Wood calculated that a typical horse would travel at an average of 2 miles per hour over a ten hour day, hauling a payloadof perhaps 5 tons.
To cut the chase, this adds up to significant concentrations of horses, men annd sweat scrapers at colliery stables - each horse with an individual driver and grooming kit.
I rest my case.
-
To answer the actual OP. I think, give or take a fortnight, I have been learning the box for about the same length of time as the Oul' Boy.
My first attempt to play in public was at the begining of October at the local (Skye) accordion and fiddle club, which organises an evening event one a month through the winter. The club not only boasts some superb young players but also is very welcoming to players of any age and level of ability. I have found it a very safe and encouraging place to play and the act of playing to the audience makes it easier for me to just sit and enjoy listening to all the other far more accomplished musicians.
-
George Wallace from North Shields, who used to dance with High Spen, undertook a good deal of painstaking research about rapper dancing, and published a booklet with Gateshead Libraries "Fit to jump ower the moon....". In a short chapter about the swords he covers most of the possible explanations for the derivation of the name rapper set out above, and some others too (but not the suggestions made by Steve Freereeder - which does sound plausible).
In relation to scrapers for pit ponies George says;
"It seems that the early rapper sword was of a similar make and appearance to the early horse scrapers. But the name rapper has not been found applied to the tool. However the name 'rubber' is commonly used for cleaning horse, and has been used specifically for a strigil or sweat scraper. It was also used as an alternative name, by the Swalwell dancers for the rapper sword itself"
So, it seems George concurs with others that any similarities between horse/pony scrapers and rappers for sword dancing are coincidental, and he makes the point that swivels handles have not been found in equine scrapers. George mentions brass horse scrapers for race horses - so the "sword" broken by Carlisle sword may well have been a (race)horse scraper.
George describes how "hoop iron" was used by sword dancers (and for scraping ponies) well before spring steel became available, and before Sharp described dancers swords "as flexible as a harlequin's wand"!
No doubt George's book will be in Gateshead libraries for those who wish to read/research more.
The old black and white films I've seen of old teams suggest they danced at more leisurely paces than some "modern" teams and their stepping may well not have been as precise as it has since the Kingsmen and others took up the dance.
For aspiring rapper musicians, there are some very capable "traditional" rapper musicians recorded on one of the series of Morris Ring CDs (LMM CD13) with, in my opinion, some good traditional tunes. Most are playing around 140-150 bpm.
I think that relatively easy tunes to play at a good pace for dancing include Hexham Races (for "trotting"/moving figures) and New Rigged Ship, which has a strong beat for predominantly "stepping" figures. Both have readily identifiable beginnings and endings to each "A" and "B" part, which I think help the dancers with phrasing, and both are easy to "find your place" if you lose your step mid figure/phrase.
George Wallace was an excellent dancer too, and I was lucky enough to dance with him - in this clip at the Gateshead Garden Festival. George was dancing at No. 4 and Mike Douglas was playing the melodeon (at a fair lick): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-vKZjHXbPI
-
George Wallace from North Shields, ..... "Fit to jump ower the moon....". In a short chapter about the swords he covers most of the possible explanations for the derivation of the name rapper set out above, and some others too. ........
In relation to scrapers for pit ponies George says;
"It seems that the early rapper sword was of a similar make and appearance to the early horse scrapers. But the name rapper has not been found applied to the tool. However the name 'rubber' is commonly used for cleaning horse, and has been used specifically for a strigil or sweat scraper. It was also used as an alternative name, by the Swalwell dancers for the rapper sword itself"
So, it seems George concurs with others that any similarities between horse/pony scrapers and rappers for sword dancing are coincidental, and he makes the point that swivels handles have not been found in equine scrapers. George mentions brass horse scrapers for race horses - so the "sword" broken by Carlisle sword may well have been a (race)horse scraper.
George describes how "hoop iron" was used by sword dancers (and for scraping ponies) well before spring steel became available, and before Sharp described dancers swords "as flexible as a harlequin's wand"!
No doubt George's book will be in Gateshead libraries for those who wish to read/research more.
The old black and white films I've seen of old teams suggest they danced at more leisurely paces than some "modern" teams and their stepping may well not have been as precise as it has since the Kingsmen and others took up the dance.
If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck it probably is a duck.......the similarity between horse scraper and rubber/rapper suggests to me the adoption of the scraper as a dance "sword". No surprise that there was never a swivel handle on a horse scraper -this would detract from its function, allowing the swivel end to twist out of control of the groom. Bad idea.
On the other hand, any pit big enough to be equipped with it's own waggonway also had a blacksmiths shop - we aren't talking a village farrier here, but a fully equipped by the standards of the time engineering workshop. Making and repairing swivels which were part and parcel of plant and equipment was a routine job.
All it takes is for a few boys to have started working up a dance routine using scrapers or hoop iron as swords...and someone has a bright idea about a swivel handle... Plausible? I think so.
(Note: In 1815 Geordie Stephenson was foreman blacksmith at Killingworth Colliery - about 3 miles North of Byker. and built his first locomotive, under the eye of Nicholas Wood in the colliery blacksmith's shop -which gives some indication of the skill sets available in those places).
-
Re the original post - I would never be able to go public at the speeds these rappers seem to go at! I looked at the videos out of curiosity - incredibly fast playing! Hats off to them but those playing speeds are "unobtainium" for me.
I will stick with nice sedate itm..
Ho Ho
-
Re the original post - I would never be able to go public at the speeds these rappers seem to go at! I looked at the videos out of curiosity - incredibly fast playing! Hats off to them but those playing speeds are "unobtainium" for me.
I will stick with nice sedate itm..
Ho Ho
Indeed!
-
To answer the actual OP. I think, give or take a fortnight, I have been learning the box for about the same length of time as the Oul' Boy.
My first attempt to play in public was at the begining of October at the local (Skye) accordion and fiddle club, which organises an evening event one a month through the winter. The club not only boasts some superb young players but also is very welcoming to players of any age and level of ability. I have found it a very safe and encouraging place to play and the act of playing to the audience makes it easier for me to just sit and enjoy listening to all the other far more accomplished musicians.
Interesting. I had assumed you were rather more advanced than me! Sounds lovely by the way.
-
One of the most impressive rapper sets I've seen was a few years back watching Black Swan at a ceilidh during the Chippenham festival.
Matt Crum playing a large Loffet Pro very fast and absolutely cleanly, no basses to get in the way.
It lingers in the mind...…
Q
-
Trying to get (vaguely) back on topic. I just re-read the original post and saw that the OP had actually gone to the rapper team to dance - which is, in my opinion, a very fine idea. Personally I've found that with dancing and playing for sword and morris trying to do both for one team really hasn't worked for me. I've found that I've been asked to dance all winter then miraculously play all the tunes solo in the summer :|glug :M :|||:
Musicians need to practice too - something that some teams don't take on board. I found this especially true when playing for Cotswold with all the changes of pace and nuances in speed but I guess with rapper the need to play reliably fast and accurately would be similarly demanding. If the OP is keen to be a rapper dancer then it is likely that the same could happen here - trying to do both just dilutes the learning of both. I never wanted to play for rapper or longsword - I just want to dance, although I have filled in occasion. With Cotswold I do both but with different teams and that works better for me.
Oh, and the sore wrists thing. That doesn't last long. Go for it. Sword is just about the most fun you can have. Either way 10 months playing is really not long so be kind to yourself and your playing OP.
-
In all seriousness though, at what stage did you 'go public' with your playing, and how did it work out?
I played out for my first time at a proper rapper event (Thrales Rapper do) last weekend. Even after 40+ years of playing I still found it stressful especially when I went to change in the middle of a set of two tunes* only to find my fingers were playing a different tune to what my brain though was going to happen. Luckily I was able to disengage my brain until it caught up with my fingers and all was well.
*Set off playing Oyster Girl, aimed for Oscar Woods, and hit Cock of the North.
-
... I still found it stressful ...
Yup. I know this to be true. Luckily it sounded just great and anyone who doesn't know Lester pretty well would not have known he was nervous.
-
Trying to get (vaguely) back on topic. I just re-read the original post and saw that the OP had actually gone to the rapper team to dance - which is, in my opinion, a very fine idea.
All excellent points. One of the problems is that I think I'd rather dance morris than rapper, but the nearest side is over an hour away...
-
Trying to get (vaguely) back on topic. I just re-read the original post and saw that the OP had actually gone to the rapper team to dance - which is, in my opinion, a very fine idea.
All excellent points. One of the problems is that I think I'd rather dance morris than rapper, but the nearest side is over an hour away...
Over an hour is a bit much. I regularly travel 45 minutes plus but then I am a morris tart. Rapper is no problem 'cos we started out own team so practice is a walk to the pub (literally).
What sort of morris do you fancy?
-
Any dance, whether it be rapper or any of the morris traditions are a massive benefit to you as a player.
It shows you where the beats lie, the nuances within the music, it makes you really listen to the music and you are unconsciously learning the tunes.
As most tunes we use have an origin somewhere as dance tunes, you are sampling the product that you wish to produce.
That's good!
Q
-
Over an hour is a bit much. I regularly travel 45 minutes plus but then I am a morris tart. Rapper is no problem 'cos we started out own team so practice is a walk to the pub (literally).
What sort of morris do you fancy?
A nice mixture of Border and Cotswold would be lovely! I do like a bit of stick clacking. Rag Bag in Berwickshire (the nearest one) do such a mix (though predominantly Border I think), but as I say it's over an hour away and I don't want to intrude on a local scene if that's not what they'd like, though I have contacted them to find out more.
-
... I don't want to intrude on a local scene if that's not what they'd like, though I have contacted them to find out more.
:D Most morris teams will have your arm off, they'd be that keen to recruit you these days :M
-
:D Most morris teams will have your arm off, they'd be that keen to recruit you these days :M
Let's hope so! They do most of their dancing in north Northumberland, which is even further away, though an area I know reasonably well (having once lived there) and love.
-
... OK, this might be dawning on me a bit late. Was it you I danced with at Whitby in the Papa Stour workshops with the wonderful North British? (yes, I am biased).
-
... OK, this might be dawning on me a bit late. Was it you I danced with at Whitby in the Papa Stour workshops with the wonderful North British? (yes, I am biased).
Not me, if by 'you' you mean 'me'! I have only danced once on a day out for fun to try it out with Bolin Morris in Cheshire for a couple of dances.
-
... OK, this might be dawning on me a bit late. Was it you I danced with at Whitby in the Papa Stour workshops with the wonderful North British? (yes, I am biased).
Not me, if by 'you' you mean 'me'! I have only danced once on a day out for fun to try it out with Bolin Morris in Cheshire for a couple of dances.
Sorry, yes I did mean you. I thought it was too much of a coincidence but clearly not. There was a chap who danced in our set, living in Scotland well away from any accessible teams and was mad keen to try sword. He was a melnetter and from memory had only been playing a few months.
Maybe there are two of you and no one told you?
-
Sorry, yes I did mean you. I thought it was too much of a coincidence but clearly not. There was a chap who danced in our set, living in Scotland well away from any accessible teams and was mad keen to try sword. He was a melnetter and from memory had only been playing a few months.
Maybe there are two of you and no one told you?
Ha ha, The only thing I can conclude is that we need more morris teams in Scotland!
-
for what its worth I found that playing for rapper at a fair lick was greatly facilitated by:
keeping the bellows as near closed as possible throughout the proceedings ( 6 to 8 inches max) to make rapid in and outing easier and more crisp sounding
using two carefully adjusted shoulder straps to the fingers played no part whatsoever in locating the box;
using only 2 voices mm on a mml box or better still using a single voice box eg a lilly.
george
-
Showing my ignorance again......There are rapper teams in Scotland these days?
-
Showing my ignorance again......There are rapper teams in Scotland these days?
Yes, Mons Meg Rapper from Edinburgh who are featured in one of the video clips above :
"Pretty fast here too, with nice melodeon (including bass!): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVFD2iwObqA "
-
Two listed here (https://morrisdancedatabase.org.uk/teams.php?name=&location=Scotland&affiliation=any&gender=any&style=Rapper&action=search).
-
I agree with George - having tried a variety of boxes, I find the Lilly an excellent box for rapper, although the Mons Meg clip referred to shows a Baffetti Carnival played 'pretty fast, with basses'.
There's been a more-or-less uninterrupted supply of rapper in Scotland for decades. The beginnings of Mons Meg overlapped with the last Days of Clydeside Rapper. Clydeside began practising in Glasgow in 1986 with rappers borrowed from Beltane Rapper (Edinburgh), who were coming to an end at that time. There might be others here who can say when Beltane started. Banchory Ternan did some rapper as well.
-
Yes and the amazing Goersach from Aberdeen are brilliant..... we keep bumping into them at festivals
Q
-
... the Mons Meg clip referred to shows a Baffetti Carnival played 'pretty fast, with basses'.
The young bloke playing the Baffetti for Mons Meg in that video is quite an impressive player. Does anyone know who he is?
-
Yes, he's my son, James, currently living in Hamburg and missing the English and Scottish folk scenes.
-
Yes, he's my son, James, currently living in Hamburg and missing the English and Scottish folk scenes.
I bet you're proud of him!
BTW I've enjoyed some nice Irish sessions in Hamburg, and no doubt James has checked them out already.
-
The boy done good.
-
Yes, he's my son, James, currently living in Hamburg and missing the English and Scottish folk scenes.
Thank goodness for that, I thought my old eyes were playing up. I was convinced it was James but thought, well if it was surely Andrew would have mentioned it in his previous post.
-
Yes, he's my son, James, currently living in Hamburg and missing the English and Scottish folk scenes.
Thank goodness for that, I thought my old eyes were playing up. I was convinced it was James but thought, well if it was surely Andrew would have mentioned it in his previous post.
...and I checked with Chloe's mother. It is her playing the fiddle and the announcer is her partner, Andy, also of the Kingsmen. Couple of rapper tarts. I, also, thought my old eyes were playing up.
It's a small world, the folk dancing one.
-
Yes, he's my son, James, currently living in Hamburg and missing the English and Scottish folk scenes.
Thank goodness for that, I thought my old eyes were playing up. I was convinced it was James but thought, well if it was surely Andrew would have mentioned it in his previous post.
...and I checked with Chloe's mother. It is her playing the fiddle and the announcer is her partner, Andy, also of the Kingsmen. Couple of rapper tarts. I, also, thought my old eyes were playing up.
It's a small world, the folk dancing one.
It is indeed a small world - also in the Mons Meg set are Trina McKendrick and Kev Theaker, who take some excellent photos and make some great videos of traditional dance, including this one which also features Andy the alleged "rapper tart" in close-up : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeLrwyqTunQ
(But tart is not the right word for a dancer who is so committed and competent)
-
The world gets smaller.
I hadn't looked at the Mons Meg set till now.
Yes I recognise Kev Theaker.
He used to dance with us when he was here in Exeter and I've danced Cotswold with him when he was a member of our side!
I remember seeing him a little while back and he said he'd moved over to rapper from morris.
The world has just shrunk again!
Q
-
...But tart is not the right word for a dancer who is so committed and competent...
It's a good description of a couple of people who are members of at least 3 different sides.
-
Better Ranter tart than pop tart. That's the promise of pudding, but the reality of burnt mouth.
-
...But tart is not the right word for a dancer who is so committed and competent...
It's a good description of a couple of people who are members of at least 3 different sides.
… looking at recent Folk festival, most of the Morris sides had more “musicians†than dancers! 🤔
-
But tart is not the right word for a dancer who is so committed and competent
Tart is the perfect term. Generally used to describe anyone who is in three or more sides. Tarts are generally the most committed and often the most capable as a result. Some sides are made up almost entirely, or even entirely, of tarts.
-
But tart is not the right word for a dancer who is so committed and competent
Tart is the perfect term. Generally used to describe anyone who is in three or more sides. Tarts are generally the most committed and often the most capable as a result. Some sides are made up almost entirely, or even entirely, of tarts.
What an eye opener. I will now watch the dancers in a different light as I try to spot the tart. Reminds me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_w32dZTj8o
-
Yep, agree with Helena, and it is usually said with affection and not deemed derogatory in my book.
Q
-
Tart is the perfect term. Generally used to describe anyone who is in three or more sides. Tarts are generally the most committed and often the most capable as a result. Some sides are made up almost entirely, or even entirely, of tarts.
All of that ^^^^^^^^
Signed a fellow morris/rapper/ceilidh band/ anyone who will let me play Tart
-
Yep, agree with Helena, and it is usually said with affection and not deemed derogatory in my book.
Q
Yes, I have to wholeheartedly agree with the principle too - I'm just not that keen on the term "tart", so I will have to try to think of it with affection >:E.
Many teams and traditions would have fallen away without the tarts, and without the tarts lots of dance-outs would not be possible. I admire the dancing tarts in particular because some of them are able to memorise so many different dances, and in some cases traditions too.
-
Yes Stotty, they often bolster numbers in sides and are much valued.
Q
-
Yep, agree with Helena, and it is usually said with affection and not deemed derogatory in my book.
Q
Absolutely agree. Personally I suppose I qualify as a "morris tartlet" as opposed to a fully-fledged tart as I'm Squire of Cyprus Morris and a floating adjunct to my first side Jockey, with whom I remain in constant contact and whom I join if I happen to be anywhere they are...... Two sides doesn't count for tartship (though I'm a former membeer of three others!).
-
For what it's worth, Stotty, I know that Chloe and Andy would take it in the spirit intended. It's term they would be quite happy to use themselves.
If you want to hear more of Chloe's work you'll find some here. Fine music. Highly recommended.
https://www.facebook.com/BottleBankBand/
-
Yep, agree with Helena, and it is usually said with affection and not deemed derogatory in my book.
Q
Absolutely agree. Personally I suppose I qualify as a "morris tartlet" as opposed to a fully-fledged tart as I'm Squire of Cyprus Morris and a floating adjunct to my first side Jockey, with whom I remain in constant contact and whom I join if I happen to be anywhere they are...... Two sides doesn't count for tartship (though I'm a former membeer of three others!).
that makes me a sort of retired tartlet
george
-
Presumably the term applies to both dancers and musicians ? (Not forgetting some of us are or have been both...)
I don't think I was aware of the term back in my long past dancing days - must have had a sheltered youth ::)
J
-
I have heard contract engineers described as "construction tarts".....usually applied to the kind of individual who would move on in an instant if someone offered him a better rate somewhere else. I am not convinced the term was entirely affectionate.
-
I promise you Peader, in this case it is entirely affectionate, and the first people to delight in the expression are those it applies to. Morris, Rapper, or whatever your speciality, tarts are those in a lot lot of sides, not those who flit from side to side. At least that's how it works down yur in depths of South West peninsula. A mark of honour.
-
Better a Rapper Tart than a Pop Tart. Swords are less dangerous than hot jam.
-
Better a Rapper Tart than a Pop Tart. Swords are less dangerous than hot jam.
;D
-
I promise you Peader, in this case it is entirely affectionate, and the first people to delight in the expression are those it applies to. Morris, Rapper, or whatever your speciality, tarts are those in a lot lot of sides, not those who flit from side to side. At least that's how it works down yur in depths of South West peninsula. A mark of honour.
I don't doubt it.....I thought it might be a modest expression for dedication.
Better a Rapper Tart than a Pop Tart. Swords are less dangerous than hot jam.
I don't doubt this one either.
-
Just a big "Thank You" to all who have been totally honest and bared their fears. It was a great suprise that even the "Stars" of melnet both Ladies and Gents sometimes suffered nerves when playing in front of others. I feel a great deal better about things now when I sit in a cold pub bar sweating as my "turn" to lead or play is creeping closer. It is to Melnet credit that its members feel they can show such openess to assist others, Thank you all.