Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Earl Bryce on November 25, 2019, 10:36:52 PM

Title: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Earl Bryce on November 25, 2019, 10:36:52 PM
After pouring over Lester's Hohner Hot Rodding videos and any other repair sources I can find, I'm about to begin to fix up my pokerwork. But before I get started, I was hoping to get some input on whether or not what I am about to undertake is an acceptable and appropriate thing to do.
To my knowledge, I believe it's a 1940's-50's era pokerwork, it has the wooden keyboard with scoops on the edges, made in Germany, and the reeds have an "h" on them. It seems to be all original parts and is in surprisingly good condition.
At a minimum, I want to tune it up, replace the valves, resurface the pallets, limit the button travel, and replace all the straps which have rotted off.
All of that seems to be standard maintenance. However, I'm also considering stripping the black and gold paint and refinishing with a stain or clear coat, as well as drying out the tuning to a light swing, instead of the standard wet hohner sound, and this is where I am hesitant, for two reasons:
1. Is it a shame to modify a vintage pokerwork from its original state? Is this melodeon a piece of history that aught to be kept in its pure state to preserve it? Where I live, all accordions are rare, and this is the first time I've seen in person a diatonic, let alone one thats near 80 years old. Perhaps some of you who have seen your share of these in all shapes and forms can advise me, should I treat this as a restoration like a rare collectors item, or is this just a functioning instrument that happens to be very old?
2. The second part relates to the tuning. Is there a reason I have never heard a dry(ish) tuned pokerwork? Somewhere on here Theo once said he never tunes a hohner completely dry. I wonder if there is a technical reason related to the build and construction that makes pokerworks particularly suited to wet tuning, and if a drier tuning would not sound good. Or is it simply a matter of preference? Has anyone heard a pokerwork swing or dry tuned?
Thank you all for your wisdom and advice!
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on November 25, 2019, 10:40:51 PM
Tune it whatever way you want. I have one box tuned so dry it has absolutely no tremolo. It's a matter of taste. That box is an old Erika, so age is no bar.

Sir John
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Theo on November 25, 2019, 11:06:42 PM
Somewhere on here Theo once said he never tunes a hohner completely dry.

I don't think I said that just in relation to Hohners.  There is a lot of inaccurate use of the word "dry".   The correct usage is that two reeds are tuned exactly in unison so there is no beat at all.  It is often used incorrectly to describes tuning with a slow beat which should be described as "swing".  It is a pity the term has become degraded my misuse because it makes my job more difficult when I try to understand what my customers want.  So if someone asks me for dry tuning I have to have a conversation to discover if they really mean dry, or if they mean some degree of swing.  I'll tune dry if I can discover that the that is what the customer really wants.

We are talking about mass produced boxes here, not rare antiques so go with your own wishes.  My personal preference is swing tuning, and I also like to see the signs of use on an old instrument, it shows that it has some history, and has been played and loved.  I have many wrinkles, and not much hair, but I don't think I will ever resort to cosmetic surgery, or a wig.  Some do, it's your own choice.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Tufty on November 25, 2019, 11:15:58 PM
Back in 1977 when Jean Blanchard recorded his "Accordeon Diaton1que" LP he played a Hohner Erica GC. On the sleeve notes he says he had the vibrato reduced. I have never heard anyone complain about the results (:). Like Theo says go with what pleases you, instruments are for playing.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Tiposx on November 25, 2019, 11:25:06 PM
I had exactly the same issues with my old Pokerwork and I asked for advice on this forum. In the end I replaced all the chrome and leather bits, but didn't touch the finish. My box has lost most of the gold paint is almost totally black. I think it looks really cool -in an old warhorse way.
 Mine is tuned dry for itm, although I like swing tuning also. I have done all the modifications to the playing side of things.
 I play it much more than my Castagnari...
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 26, 2019, 12:07:10 AM
Mind you, when I conjectured about altering the tuning of a 1040, to make it minor key friendly, the reaction seemed pretty shock horror  ;D
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Earl Bryce on November 26, 2019, 01:33:37 AM
Thanks for all the opinions everyone!
Theo, thank you for bringing the use of the term dry to my attention, just from reading my own post I can see what you mean. Sorry if I have misquoted you, I must have misunderstood. That’s also a great point about being mass produced, I hadn’t considered that aspect.

Apparently I haven’t been around long enough, it seems like there are quite a lot of swing/dry tuned hohners here! I do like the look of old “well loved” instruments too, it adds a lot of character.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Anahata on November 26, 2019, 10:56:44 AM
Yes, good point about them being mass produced.
To paraphrase Martin Carthy's oft-quoted statement about songs, the worst thing you can do with an old Hohner* is not play it.
So any restoration into good playing order is a good thing.
I have a (pre-war, probably) Club II that had all the pink pearloid stripped off and it's now bare stained wood. No lettering on it, but it's still obviously a Hohner and it looks and sounds lovely. (Reedwork fettled by Theo when it belonged to previous owner.)

*other brands are available...

Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Steve C. on November 26, 2019, 11:09:31 AM
Many Hohners, mine included, have benefit from being "dried out", i.e. having the tremolo reduced a bit from factory. Plus, they go a little out out tune after 10 or 15 years of savage beating .  But certainly never close to two reeds in unison!  I mean, why have two reeds?  (:)
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Theo on November 26, 2019, 11:25:00 AM
Many Hohners, mine included, have benefit from being "dried out", i.e. having the tremolo reduced a bit from factory. Plus, they go a little out out tune after 10 or 15 years of savage beating

They are never in tune from the factory in my experience ::)

Quote
  But certainly never close to two reeds in unison!  I mean, why have two reeds?  (:)

Because two reeds in unison sound different from a single reed. For example here is Josephine Marsh playing a dry tuned 2 voice Hohner:

https://youtu.be/Ba4x5Ac61LE?t=53
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: playandteach on November 26, 2019, 12:43:41 PM
That's a lovely sound.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: arty on November 26, 2019, 01:03:51 PM
That's a lovely sound.

Isn’t it just!
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Rog on November 26, 2019, 01:54:50 PM
On the other hand you could buck the trend and keep it wet tuned...
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Peadar on November 26, 2019, 05:37:33 PM
Good luck and just remember two things
1. If it doesn't turn out right first time you can always take it to bits again and have a second go.
2. When you discover something that you don't expect and couldn't have foreseen help is only a melnet posting away.....and someone on here has almost certainly seen it before.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Theo on November 26, 2019, 05:41:46 PM
A third thing
Hohner parts are very consistent in manufacture so there is a wide range of interchangeable parts.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Alan Pittwood on November 26, 2019, 07:09:12 PM
Back in 1977 when Jean Blanchard recorded his "Accordeon Diaton1que" LP he played a Hohner Erica GC. On the sleeve notes he says he had the vibrato reduced.
- Accordeon Diaton1que    Diatonique

What Jean wrote:

L'accordéon que j'utilise est un Honher (sic) modèle ERICA sur lequel j'ai, sur les conseils de SERGE DESAUNAY, supprimé le vibrato intempesif.

on which I have, on the advice of SERGE DESAUNAY, removed the unwanted vibrato

For Serge Desaunay see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cINoQxzhHf8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cINoQxzhHf8) and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nb_tOGkOacg (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nb_tOGkOacg)


I bought Jean Blanchard's LP in Kemper, Breizh in 1978 and had my Erica D/G tuned 'dry' the following year; it still is.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on November 26, 2019, 07:36:07 PM
Earl, there are a lots of people on this forum who have old Hohners which have been worked upon in many various, sometimes devious ways to produce instruments which sound great and are lovely to play.
And plenty of people who can provide you with advice and guidance on your journey. You just need to decide where you want to get to with your Pokerwork.
Enjoy :)

Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Clive Williams on November 26, 2019, 08:41:39 PM
Another fan of a dry tuned pokerwork here; had mine dry tuned many years ago and loved it. You can find a lovingly curated list of demos of it in action here...

http://www.melodeonvideo.co.uk/melodeons/

... about half way down the page under Hohner Pokerwork
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: melodeon on November 27, 2019, 01:31:45 AM
HOHNER is well known for its own proprietary tuning , which I believe is patented/copyrighted/trademarked as " ALMOST" tuning.
Wet dry, swing.. if HOHNER tuned it.. it is "ALMOST"

I am a long time fan of  HOHNER melodeons.

They are the MGB of accordeons. Light, fast, fun, cheap, and abundant of parts available, and considering there were approximately 525,000 Bs produced , including my 1964, it is my opinion that making one a 100% original, Concours unit, is time and money wasted. Hohners and MGBs were meant to be modified and driven. RESTOMOD is the word of the day. Go for it.
Wet boxes rust.. dry it out or swing it and put the pedal to the metal.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Quebecois on November 27, 2019, 03:12:02 AM
I have a Morgane and it's tuned "swing".

Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Earl Bryce on November 27, 2019, 10:19:28 PM
I’ve enjoyed listening to all the links posted and hearing what a Hohner is capable of!

They are the MGB of accordeons.
I must admit, I did not know what an MGB was and had to look it up. I’m afraid the subtleties of that analogy were lost across the pond, but I think I catch your drift.  ;) I like the car comparison.
Initially, I wasn’t much of a Hohner fan. I always wanted a Castagnari. But after having one, I’ve fallen for its humble charms. Reliable, unassuming, simple, may I even say elegant in a minimal sort of way. And the sound, wet or dry, can be really lovely I’m hearing. I guess there’s a certain soul or essence to a good old Hohner that makes it a very personal thing.
Disclaimer: I am not paid by Hohner to advertise their instrument. But now I see why so many here are part of team Hohner haha
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Stotty on November 27, 2019, 10:39:03 PM
Many Hohners, mine included, have benefit from being "dried out", i.e. having the tremolo reduced a bit from factory. Plus, they go a little out out tune after 10 or 15 years of savage beating

They are never in tune from the factory in my experience ::)

Quote
  But certainly never close to two reeds in unison!  I mean, why have two reeds?  (:)

Because two reeds in unison sound different from a single reed. For example here is Josephine Marsh playing a dry tuned 2 voice Hohner:

https://youtu.be/Ba4x5Ac61LE?t=53

  Close your eyes and it is still recognisable as a Hohner!
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Steve C. on November 28, 2019, 01:54:06 AM
Jeffe, pretty soon us ol' fots are gonna have to start referring to Hohners as the "VW's of melodeons" or the Honda Civics of Melodeons" or maybe even some totally other analogy as current generations don't work on their own cars.
I mean not knowing what an MGB is/was does mean something, generation-wise, does it not?
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Stockaryd on November 28, 2019, 11:18:22 AM
Jeffe, pretty soon us ol' fots are gonna have to start referring to Hohners as the "VW's of melodeons" or the Honda Civics of Melodeons" 


I would say  "VOLVO"     ;) 
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 28, 2019, 12:16:20 PM
Jeffe, pretty soon us ol' fots are gonna have to start referring to Hohners as the "VW's of melodeons" or the Honda Civics of Melodeons" 

VW is probably a good analogy. The people's instrument and the people's car.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: arty on November 28, 2019, 12:48:30 PM
To my knowledge, Hohner has never lied about it’s emissions  ;)
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: playandteach on November 28, 2019, 01:01:55 PM
There are plenty of Honers who lie about their omissions though.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: melodeon on December 02, 2019, 01:51:03 AM
I am across the pond in Oregon, USA.
I have a 1964 MB, I have owned 7 MGs, 11 Morris Minors, 2 Oxfords, 4 Thames vans, 1 Commer, 1 TVR Grantura, one Fairthorpe ELectron Climax, 5 Land Rovers, 1 Rover SD1 (3500 v8) e58 Frog(bug) eye Sprite, and more.
To add:
VWs.. 55,56,57,58,59,60, 54 VW Bus rt hand drive dbl door, 71 Bus, POS Jetta, 1973 Thing

After 4 years at a BMC, Rolls Royce, Bentley, Aston Martin, Lotus dealership for 4 years, I was the service manager of a Honda dealership for 4 years and bought the first Civic CVCC Sport 5 speed.

I will concede that most VWs  ( most but  not to include the THING which was built in Mexico) are  made in Germany and air "cooled"

The B (MGB) still gets my vote for over the VW ( which was largely a myth for reliability) for a comparison to the Hohner.
Largely because older VWs are now selling for "earth money" ( ridiculous amounts given what they are/were)

A similarity between Hohner and MG is that they are now made in China.. and the quality is not what it was in years gone by.  Many VWs are made in USA and here because they are made by XXXXX XXXXX they might as well be made in China given the quality.    VW lies about their omissions as well, referring to design, materials, workmanship and customer service.

Volvo and Hohner also have a commonality being made in China.

I like older Hohners and older VWs ( Did I mention I owned a 1954 Porsche 1500 Normal bent window)?

 I have owned 14 Castagnaris.. only one was a total dog.. a Mory in C.. absurdly substandard.
All other very good to excellent.. excepting the 4 MELODEONS ( MAX) with the stooooopidly placed air button and the reason I offed all of them.

Rumor has it one Irish dealer now has themmade with a relocated air button and hand made reeds.

Too bad that Hohner USA has rolled over and gone for junk and over priced Ancketas (sp) and ignored the rest of us who made them who they are.

Lecture over.


"Safety Fast"


MOWOG

Down with Leyland
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Winston Smith on December 02, 2019, 07:41:14 AM
That's an awful lot of cars, Mr Melodeon. You must be a very difficult man to please to have gone through, and kept buying (in the case of the VW's) so much rubbish!
But your analogy between cars and melodeons is certainly a good one. I spent most of my working life repairing most of those makes of cars (for my sins!) whilst always having the urge to make modifications to them as well. Now, my attentions have turned to our beloved instruments in the same sort of way.
I greatly enjoy playing them, but because of financial restraints I also have to repair them. Plus, I still cannot help having a go at modifying them, I always have a few Frankenstein's on the go! (Obviously, working in the cheap end of the market, my experience will be nowhere as wide as yours!)
Like motors, I believe there are too many differing circumstances around ownership and use of melodeons to make blanket comments. We can only really pontificate from our own experiences, as you and I have done, to varying extent, here.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Peadar on December 02, 2019, 08:00:17 PM
I don't know about the Hohner being the VolksWelodeon...but I have been getting the impresion that melodeons are the legal high of musical instruments.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: playandteach on December 02, 2019, 09:11:34 PM
I think a Hohner is a bicycle with a basket. And in that basket is a pencil in a brown paper bag, a postcard to a loved one and a map and a packet of sherbet lemons.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Steve C. on December 03, 2019, 12:47:23 PM
"Poetry"  (:)
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Steve C. on December 03, 2019, 12:51:21 PM
The old country
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: baz parkes on December 04, 2019, 10:44:57 AM
I think a Hohner is a bicycle with a basket. And in that basket is a pencil in a brown paper bag, a postcard to a loved one and a map and a packet of sherbet lemons.

In a previous life I spent a lot of time teaching and analysing the use of metaphor. You have just been awarded 100 House Points  :|glug
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Dick Rees on December 04, 2019, 03:02:27 PM
Many Hohners, mine included, have benefit from being "dried out", i.e. having the tremolo reduced a bit from factory. Plus, they go a little out out tune after 10 or 15 years of savage beating

They are never in tune from the factory in my experience ::)

Quote
  But certainly never close to two reeds in unison!  I mean, why have two reeds?  (:)

Because two reeds in unison sound different from a single reed. For example here is Josephine Marsh playing a dry tuned 2 voice Hohner:

https://youtu.be/Ba4x5Ac61LE?t=53

Two reeds may be tuned to the same pitch, but in all probability will not be in phase accounting for the difference in sound compared to a single reed.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: tirpous on December 04, 2019, 04:02:36 PM
Quote
Two reeds may be tuned to the same pitch, but in all probability will not be in phase accounting for the difference in sound compared to a single reed.

Even if they are tuned to the same pitch, in practice it is not the 'same' but rather 'very-close-but-not-quite-the-same'.  Could be because of tuning accuracy tolerances, the way the 2 reeds change frequency with different pressure, drift over time... 

It reminds me of the old analog synthesizers: you could tune 2 oscillators to the same pitch and it would sound fatter than a single one, but with a 'phasy' quality.  If you had a 'sync' option, it would lock the oscillators together and the phasiness would disappear.  There is no sync in Melodeons, so dry tuning has the phasy sound due to the unavoidable very-slow beat.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: David Summers on December 04, 2019, 04:11:05 PM
Many Hohners, mine included, have benefit from being "dried out", i.e. having the tremolo reduced a bit from factory. Plus, they go a little out out tune after 10 or 15 years of savage beating

They are never in tune from the factory in my experience ::)

Quote
  But certainly never close to two reeds in unison!  I mean, why have two reeds?  (:)

Because two reeds in unison sound different from a single reed. For example here is Josephine Marsh playing a dry tuned 2 voice Hohner:

https://youtu.be/Ba4x5Ac61LE?t=53

Two reeds may be tuned to the same pitch, but in all probability will not be in phase accounting for the difference in sound compared to a single reed.
Well typically there will be coupling between the two reeds, and also to the main structure of the melodeon. This means energy can flow between the two reeds.

So with most systems like this, what happens is two modes set up; one where the two reeds are in anti phase, and little energy goes into the main structure of the melodeon; and another where the reeds are in phase, and maximal energy goes into the structure of the melodeon. As these two modes excite different things, there frequencies do differ somewhat, and so that splits the tone again, to give beats.

Its why the note changes, when you take the reed out of the melodeon, and try and tune it in isolation, its different from when its in the box.

But yes, agree with the general point; two reeds, however dry or wet they are tuned, will always sound somewhat different to a single reed.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on December 04, 2019, 06:11:00 PM
HOHNER is well known for its own proprietary tuning , which I believe is patented/copyrighted/trademarked as " ALMOST" tuning.
Wet dry, swing.. if HOHNER tuned it.. it is "ALMOST"

It's true that Hohners do have "a sound" that I love. The Dino Baffetti F/Bb/Eb that I have essentially mimics the "almost" Hohner tuning. It really is lovely and many people comment on it. On the other hand, my first Corso G/C was genuinely wet tuned (MM) and that ALSO drew a lot of compliments because it was so striking amongst the drier boxes of the rooms I was playing in. I do like the sound of a wet box, but don't have one right now. Button Box has a used C/F Erica on its list right now advertised as wet tuned. I would snap it up if it weren't for the money thing.

Here's a piece I wrote many years ago about my Mighty Corso: https://accordeonaire.com/2011/02/12/the-mighty-corso/
And another about the Baffetti, written just after I got it: https://accordeonaire.com/2013/06/02/first-tunes-with-the-baffetti/

Also, I am guilty of sloppy language, also. I say "dry tuned" when what I really mean is "drier."
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Kimric Smythe on December 04, 2019, 06:33:20 PM
"They are never in tune from the factory in my experience ::)" Preach it brother!

I stopped carrying Honers in my shop years ago due to the issue of having to spend 1-3 hrs tuning them before I could sell them, then seeing them on line for a few $ over my wholesale.
 They are reliable once set up but it only makes sense to do so if I get them for almost free before I work on them since I give a 1 yr warranty and 75% 1 yr buyback, so they need to be right before they get sold.

Hohner will give you 90 days warranty and will not authorize or pay the dealer for the work ,and you need to pay the shipping.

 I typically make more fixing the ones people buy online.
Title: Re: The Way a Hohner Should Be?
Post by: Earl Bryce on December 05, 2019, 07:40:24 PM
I think a Hohner is a bicycle with a basket. And in that basket is a pencil in a brown paper bag, a postcard to a loved one and a map and a packet of sherbet lemons.
1
Wow, in this post, I have realized that I've found my home here, a place where all of the wonder of a melodeon is truly appreciated. Well said!

The interaction between two reeds tuned the same (or close to the same) is one of the great joys in life to me. The tonal depth and variations of frequencies that are never exactly the same adds complexity to music that's not totally mastered or controllable by the musician, and to me, that gives a bit of heart to a song that can't be replaced.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal