Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: David Summers on December 20, 2019, 11:49:26 PM

Title: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on December 20, 2019, 11:49:26 PM
Just been to Jackie Oats gig. Highlight for me was John Spiers - he had 8 melodeons, and used every one.

Think all were in different keys, all fourth apart, so the standard DG, CF, then BbEb, and a whole lot others I hadn't heard off. Some two voice, some three (where there was a switch behind the keyboard to take out the low voice).  Think several were franken boxes, one he could switch in any out a third on the right hand!

Two Pokerwork, others I didn't recoginse, several from the 1930s.

Inspiring to see.
Title: Re: John Spires Melodeons!
Post by: richard.fleming on December 21, 2019, 08:30:03 AM
I'd be very interested to know about the tunes - or, more precisely, what keys were the tunes in?
Title: Re: John Spires Melodeons!
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 21, 2019, 09:31:51 AM
I'm sure Squeezy will be along to tell us more in due course........
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Anahata on December 21, 2019, 10:04:45 AM
Pedant alert: while "Spires" (as in dreaming..., of Oxford) is a useful pronunciation guide, it's spelt Spiers.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on December 21, 2019, 10:24:37 AM
Aye, that's always a surprise to me the spires pronunciation, as up here in Scotland, it's always pronounced spears.
Dreaming spears anybody?


Sir John
Title: Re: John Spires Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on December 21, 2019, 10:29:44 AM
I'd be very interested to know about the tunes - or, more precisely, what keys were the tunes in?
He did tell me the keys, but it was a long list, and other than the obvious ones just remember he had several esoteric keys.

Songs were I guess largely chosen by Jackie, folky christmas things, and other songs that were close enough.

Anyway back to keys, on 4th apart systems there are at most 12 possible keys, but hard to see you would need all, e.g. can play a tune in D on a DG, but probably also on an AD. Guess a lot of it may be to do with left hand, and how grunty the left hand was being, in some songs John wasn't doing much more than a drone with the left hand that slowly walked. Anyway guess bass and chords on the left hand changed alot (the 3 row had a full bank of left hand buttons, like a piano accordion; not sure if it was free bass, or arranged in bass/major/minor chords)

Thinking back on it, although not watching closely, don't remember him using the half row on his 2 and a half row boxes (which is what I thing was the majority of the boxes)  - and I guess with that many boxes, can avoid boxes with tricky fingering if needed.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on December 21, 2019, 10:30:46 AM
Pedant alert: while "Spires" (as in dreaming..., of Oxford) is a useful pronunciation guide, it's spelt Spiers.
Doah - that will teach me to type messages when back late at night after a gig! I've modified ....
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on December 21, 2019, 10:45:34 AM
Oh yes - other interesting thing noticed, he did a form of vibrato that I've not seen before  (e.g. more wobble on the notes than the dampness gives). He used his right hand to massage the bellows, as left hand was on the draw. Only other time I remember seeing vibralto was Tuulikki Bartosik waving her fingers on the pull, which worked well. Anyway Johns method works when doing left hand notes, Tuulikki works when doing right hand notes ...
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 21, 2019, 12:22:14 PM
John's got some great boxes - I got to try out a couple last time he played solo locally. I've got his old Streb and I will shortly be getting my very own vintage Pastourelle/Connemara* which has been a dream box of mine for quite some time.


* the one I have is the configuration currently called the Connemara but back when it  was built it was named Pastourelle.  Yes I know I am a pedant.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Lester on December 21, 2019, 12:24:46 PM
John's got some great boxes - I got to try out a couple last time he played solo locally. I've got his old Streb and I will shortly be getting my very own vintage Pastourelle/Connemara* which has been a dream box of mine for quite some time.


* the one I have is the configuration currently called the Connemara but back when it  was built it was named Pastourelle.  Yes I know I am a pedant.


Pastourmara  or  Connelle   (:)
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Corinto on December 21, 2019, 01:03:44 PM
My guess the 3 rows one with lots of bass buttons may be his HOHNER LUCIA chromatic converted to melodeon layout keeping the 48 (4x12) stradella bass (counterbass, bass, mayor, minor).

Look here = https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gV59q--prjQ
and here = https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQtg_jFWRt0

Or this HOHNER CORNELIA = https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDwHiANxeZY
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Graham Spencer on December 21, 2019, 01:21:36 PM
* the one I have is the configuration currently called the Connemara but back when it  was built it was named Pastourelle.  Yes I know I am a pedant.

I have a Pastourelle, and when I played a friend's Connemara some years ago it confused me because the arrangement of accidentals on the half-row was different. I don't know if mine is an oddity, or if his was, or whether the difference was deliberate at the design stage, or whether there was just no consistency between models.....
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 21, 2019, 02:25:30 PM
* the one I have is the configuration currently called the Connemara but back when it  was built it was named Pastourelle.  Yes I know I am a pedant.

I have a Pastourelle, and when I played a friend's Connemara some years ago it confused me because the arrangement of accidentals on the half-row was different. I don't know if mine is an oddity, or if his was, or whether the difference was deliberate at the design stage, or whether there was just no consistency between models.....

Mine's actually the 23 + 4 Connemara configuration rather than 21 + 5 so in modern terms is a Connemara but at the time it was made was called a  The
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on December 21, 2019, 05:53:41 PM
My guess the 3 rows one with lots of bass buttons may be his HOHNER LUCIA chromatic converted to melodeon layout keeping the 48 (4x12) stradella bass (counterbass, bass, mayor, minor).
From what I remember, yes it was the Lucia. Didn`t  realise that it was also a Franken device.

Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 21, 2019, 07:33:20 PM
I wonder if it's a grey celluloid?
I did a workshop with him maybe 3 years back in Cornwall and Mike Rowbotham had just brought it over for him. Two totally different boxes, melodeon right hand and accordion bass end  cut and shutted into one, and you would swear it was originally built that way!
Q
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Clive Williams on December 21, 2019, 09:55:34 PM
My guess the 3 rows one with lots of bass buttons may be his HOHNER LUCIA chromatic converted to melodeon layout keeping the 48 (4x12) stradella bass (counterbass, bass, mayor, minor).
From what I remember, yes it was the Lucia. Didn`t  realise that it was also a Franken device.

I have another one Mike made; really quite similar. It's a converted C system CBA ( the Lucia was originally a B system or C system CBA); the treble reeds reworked into D/G/Acc, and the stradella bass left untouched. There's 2 mods on mine (and squeezy's too I think) is the stradella mechanism is modded to remove thirds from the minor row, and the provision of a proper air button.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on December 23, 2019, 09:38:04 AM
I wonder if it's a grey celluloid?
I did a workshop with him maybe 3 years back in Cornwall and Mike Rowbotham had just brought it over for him. Two totally different boxes, melodeon right hand and accordion bass end  cut and shutted into one, and you would swear it was originally built that way!
Q
And now i'm doubting myself. Any Miles, the main man at downed folk club, took a picture:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=2470597959733805&id=443901609070127&anchor_composer=false (https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=2470597959733805&id=443901609070127&anchor_composer=false).

And you can see the grey celluloid box on the floor. Does make me wonder if both his 3 rows that he used had banked basses.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Clive Williams on December 23, 2019, 04:53:51 PM
I wonder if it's a grey celluloid?
I did a workshop with him maybe 3 years back in Cornwall and Mike Rowbotham had just brought it over for him. Two totally different boxes, melodeon right hand and accordion bass end  cut and shutted into one, and you would swear it was originally built that way!
Q
And now i'm doubting myself. Any Miles, the main man at downed folk club, took a picture:
https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=2470597959733805&id=443901609070127&anchor_composer=false (https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=2470597959733805&id=443901609070127&anchor_composer=false).

And you can see the grey celluloid box on the floor. Does make me wonder if both his 3 rows that he used had banked basses.

Nerd that I am, I zoomed in and had a look. It's clearly a converted CBA from the pattern on the keys; if I remember rightly, the grey one is a Hohner Cordelia conversion. The main difference between this and the Lucia is that it's 3 voice, rather than 2 voice. The Lucia is rare, the Cordelia ridiculously so. Same principle though; keep the stradella bass intact, retune the treble to a D/G/Acc layout, and add a decent air button.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Corinto on December 23, 2019, 07:01:45 PM
Nerd that I am, I zoomed in and had a look. It's clearly a converted CBA from the pattern on the keys; if I remember rightly, the grey one is a Hohner Cordelia conversion. The main difference between this and the Lucia is that it's 3 voice, rather than 2 voice. The Lucia is rare, the Cordelia ridiculously so. Same principle though; keep the stradella bass intact, retune the treble to a D/G/Acc layout, and add a decent air button.

A few months ago 4 Hohner LUCIA came up in less than 2 months time on german ebay, 2 of these on a same week.
But I've never seen a Hohner CORNELIA I on ebay, I got mine from Mike Rowbotham.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Eshed on December 23, 2019, 07:18:42 PM
If anyone is adventurous, one that looks to be either Lucia or Cornelia has been posted on facebook in Germany at least two months ago.
https://www.facebook.com/marketplace/item/601196847080883/
They might agree to ship, you never know :)
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Corinto on December 23, 2019, 09:01:24 PM
If anyone is adventurous, one that looks to be either Lucia or Cornelia has been posted on facebook in Germany at least two months ago. https://www.facebook.com/marketplace/item/601196847080883/ They might agree to ship, you never know :)

My LUCIA has exactly the same grill, and the CORNELIA I has a similar grill but with 2 rows of stars at the keyboard border ... never seen one go for this amount (one went for less than half this asking, shipping included) ... also condition is important, so one needs a fair and known seller ... ymmv ...

Patience and persistence are key to get a good one for a fair price ... at first I missed at least two, then about 2 years nothing showed up, and then at once this spring 4 of these LUCIA were sold between march and may ...
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Microbot on December 23, 2019, 11:03:22 PM
Hi all,

Corinto is correct...the models are Lucia (2-voice) and Cornelia (3-voice), and Squeezy's are CBA to melodeon DGacc conversions. Both with 48 stradella bass.

I think the photo also shows Squeezy's Club VII, which is a small (almost as rare) club model, made into 12 bass, but retaining the Bb/Eb pitch.

All great boxes ... I have available a mint condition cream/white Lucia (later model like Clive's), and a similar colour Club VII, however I have no Cornelias in stock. As Clive says, they are ludicrously rare.

I've converted Lucias/Cornelias with zinc Hohner reeds from other vintage instruments, and also Harmonikas Professional a Mano reeds. Both reed-types sound great....quite a bit of treble reedblock work required, but the stradella bass is straightforward.

These boxes are excellent as original CBAs, and also converted to the Janko layout, (which I came to through yourself, Master Cornito!)

There's also a rare, even smaller Hohner CBA, pretty much the size of a Liliput, called the Hohner Pirol. That is a 2-voice, has the same treble layout as the Lucia and Cornelia, and 3-row stradella - Bass/major/minor.

Cheers!

Mike R
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Rog on December 24, 2019, 09:02:40 AM
Quote
stradella mechanism is modded to remove thirds from the minor row
Curious to know why you would do this as you can get thirdless 'chords' by playing adjacent notes on the fundamental row (and counterbass, if there is one).
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Microbot on December 24, 2019, 10:28:32 AM
Quote
stradella mechanism is modded to remove thirds from the minor row
Curious to know why you would do this as you can get thirdless 'chords' by playing adjacent notes on the fundamental row (and counterbass, if there is one).

Hi Roger,

...true, but that gives a blend of two basses ... a very different, deeper, sound from a thirdless 'chord' made up of reeds from the chord-block.

It's possible to make the minors into thirdless chords by disconnecting links in the stradella, in a way that is completely reversible, allowing a future owner to revert to the standard set-up.

Cheers

Mike
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Squeaky Pete on December 24, 2019, 12:59:22 PM
I had a close look at a couple of Squeezy's boxes at a recent workshop.
The one that fascinated me was the club VII and I've mentioned it on another thread. The 12 bass conversion was what particularly interested me and as we have drifted onto modifying stradella mechanisms I'll ask here.
Microbot has kindly offered to supply me with a bass mechanism for a Victoria type box though I'm going to try a simpler Erica type first. How complicated is it to alter a IIIM from the 60s to 12 bass? The stradella seems to preclude this.
Can I also add how helpful and encouraging Squeezy was both about the instruments and techniques.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Microbot on December 24, 2019, 01:56:19 PM
Hi Pete,

SQueezy's Club VII was modified to 12 bass using the bass soundboard, plus mechanism, plus reedblocks from a couple of Corso-type boxes. This gave the independent 4-note chords required, Plus the mechanism where basses share root notes from the chords ... a fuller sound than standard basses and triads. It's the set-up found in Corsos and some Coronas, as well as Victorias.

If ever needed, that is how I would modify a IIIM .... I've never tried to extend a stradella bass ...Lord knows my brain couldn't cope with all those rods and pins!

The 12-bass work you're planning on the Victoria, if you elect to retain the linked chord/bass system, would be similar to the work on Squeezy's Club VII, though you'd not have to replace the soundboard.

Yes, Squeezy is one of the friendliest and most approachable people you could wish for.... a real squeezebox enthusiast with no airs and graces, despite his stellar status.

Cheers

Mike
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Rog on December 24, 2019, 02:10:33 PM
In reply to Mike R

Yes, after I posted I tried it on my (lovely old 1930s) Settimio Sop Two, and just as you say, the bass is a bit on the heavy side and not necessarily with the tonic as the lowest pitch, so I can see why it would be wanted. I vaguely made a quick mental trip into the bass machine and without much definition thought perhaps something along the lines that you describe might be possible. I’d probably try jumping the minor third pipe collector (or whatever it’s called) over the minor button piston lug (so the third isn’t opened when the button is pushed down), though without trying it I’ve no idea if this would muck up the upward spring tension on any of the buttons.
Happy Xmas to you Mike. 
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Microbot on December 24, 2019, 02:38:16 PM
Hi Roger,

In reply to Mike R

Yes, after I posted I tried it on my (lovely old 1930s) Settimio Sop Two ..... I’ve no idea if this would muck up the upward spring tension on any of the buttons.

That's an important point, Roger .. and yes, it does reduce the spring tension on the buttons where this has been done .... it's an annoying side-effect....so 'festina lente' with your Settimio!!

Happy Christmas to you and all!

Mike
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: baz parkes on December 31, 2019, 11:16:57 AM
Pastourmara
Isn't that what some people put on pizza?  :|glug
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: C K LIGHT on January 02, 2020, 04:22:02 PM
I would just add that Mr Spiers' Saltarelle Connemara 2 is for me the most perfect sounding box I've ever heard. Not so dry that it sounds light and without punch but not so wet that it loses any clarity between individual notes, however fast and twiddly they may be! How much of this is down to the box/his playing I'm not quite sure!

An observation on his choice of boxes is that he seems to tend towards either 2 voices OR 3 voices - as opposed to a box that can easily switch between the two. I presume this is to keep the 2 voice boxes light enough to throw around in his decidedly bouncy style, but it does mean he forgoes the option of switching between voices mid-song/tune like many notable artists choose to do as the piece develops.

Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Anahata on January 02, 2020, 09:52:05 PM
I think it's quite unusual for a 3 voice LMM box not to have a switch for the L bank at least.
But I noticed long ago with the Oakwood range that the 2 voice boxes sounded better than the 3 voice box with with only the MM reeds sounding. So that might be a reason for having both.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 02, 2020, 10:14:48 PM
It is something people have said to me that a straight 2 voice has a 'more focussed sound' than one that can switch between 2 & 3 voices. I didn't really understand until I got my Castagnari Jilly.

I have a 2 voice with the Jilly, and I have a Castagnari Hascy that can switch between 1, 2 & 3 voices.
They are identical size and as far as I know use identical reeds.
They sound very different, and 'focussed' is a good way to explain the sound of the 2 voiced Jilly  compared to the Hascy uskng 2 voices.
Difficult to explain in words, but noticable if played alongside one another.
Q
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 02, 2020, 10:17:31 PM
I would just add that Mr Spiers' Saltarelle Connemara 2 is for me the most perfect sounding box I've ever heard.

... and I'm picking mine up tomorrow and it is the most beautiful, sweet box I ever played  :|||: :|||:

Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: The Oul' Boy on January 04, 2020, 04:15:27 PM
... and I'm picking mine up tomorrow and it is the most beautiful, sweet box I ever played  :|||: :|||:

Jealous (whilst wishing you every joy with it of course)!
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: squeezy on January 07, 2020, 12:27:24 AM
I would just add that Mr Spiers' Saltarelle Connemara 2 is for me the most perfect sounding box I've ever heard. Not so dry that it sounds light and without punch but not so wet that it loses any clarity between individual notes, however fast and twiddly they may be! How much of this is down to the box/his playing I'm not quite sure!

An observation on his choice of boxes is that he seems to tend towards either 2 voices OR 3 voices - as opposed to a box that can easily switch between the two. I presume this is to keep the 2 voice boxes light enough to throw around in his decidedly bouncy style, but it does mean he forgoes the option of switching between voices mid-song/tune like many notable artists choose to do as the piece develops.



Interesting observation!  You have it quite right ... my thoughts have centred on two things ... one is that my style which never shys away from very fast push-pull sequences à la one row technique requires a box that has a bellows area of no more than a pokerwork.  Because of the fact that the cross sectional area of the bellows have a direct impact on how quickly and cleanly the reeds respond I have discovered that my playing suffers massively from an instrument with any larger bellows.  This is compounded by the 2 voice sound on a 2 voice instrument vs the 2 voice sound on a 3 voice instrument.  To this day I haven't managed to work out whether it it because of the presence of extra reeds blocks on the right hand side or whether it is to do with the size of the holes through which the MM reeds sound ... but I have never yet heard a 3 voice LMM box sound as good as a simple 2 voice MM box on the MM setting.  I would love for such an instrument to exist ... but my (fairly wide) experience tells me that it doesn't. 

I would rather carry 2 boxes to a gig than sound a worse player on a single instrument.

And yes I agree with the earlier poster ... my Saltarelle Connemara II is a wonderful instrument.  It is not through any modding of my own.  It is just like that!  No other Connemara II I've ever played sounds like that.  It is absolutely lovely.  The tuning I have tried to maintain on it is the dryest Niels Nielsen would agree to tune it!  I asked for dry and he point blank refused!  He was probably right.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: squeezy on January 07, 2020, 12:30:59 AM
John's got some great boxes - I got to try out a couple last time he played solo locally. I've got his old Streb and I will shortly be getting my very own vintage Pastourelle/Connemara* which has been a dream box of mine for quite some time.


* the one I have is the configuration currently called the Connemara but back when it  was built it was named Pastourelle.  Yes I know I am a pedant.

Pastourelle was always the stepped keyboard version ... Connemara was used for flat keyboard ones ... mine is a Connemara II
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 07, 2020, 08:38:22 AM
Thanks John for your thoughts on 2v v's 3v instruments.
I bought my 2v instrument for it's lightness and to have a 'no frills' box for sessions. I too have grown to really enjoy the 2v sound immensely, something I wasn't really aware of until owning one!
Q
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: C K LIGHT on January 07, 2020, 12:41:34 PM
I would just add that Mr Spiers' Saltarelle Connemara 2 is for me the most perfect sounding box I've ever heard. Not so dry that it sounds light and without punch but not so wet that it loses any clarity between individual notes, however fast and twiddly they may be! How much of this is down to the box/his playing I'm not quite sure!

An observation on his choice of boxes is that he seems to tend towards either 2 voices OR 3 voices - as opposed to a box that can easily switch between the two. I presume this is to keep the 2 voice boxes light enough to throw around in his decidedly bouncy style, but it does mean he forgoes the option of switching between voices mid-song/tune like many notable artists choose to do as the piece develops.



Interesting observation!  You have it quite right ... my thoughts have centred on two things ... one is that my style which never shys away from very fast push-pull sequences à la one row technique requires a box that has a bellows area of no more than a pokerwork.  Because of the fact that the cross sectional area of the bellows have a direct impact on how quickly and cleanly the reeds respond I have discovered that my playing suffers massively from an instrument with any larger bellows.  This is compounded by the 2 voice sound on a 2 voice instrument vs the 2 voice sound on a 3 voice instrument.  To this day I haven't managed to work out whether it it because of the presence of extra reeds blocks on the right hand side or whether it is to do with the size of the holes through which the MM reeds sound ... but I have never yet heard a 3 voice LMM box sound as good as a simple 2 voice MM box on the MM setting.  I would love for such an instrument to exist ... but my (fairly wide) experience tells me that it doesn't. 

I would rather carry 2 boxes to a gig than sound a worse player on a single instrument.

And yes I agree with the earlier poster ... my Saltarelle Connemara II is a wonderful instrument.  It is not through any modding of my own.  It is just like that!  No other Connemara II I've ever played sounds like that.  It is absolutely lovely.  The tuning I have tried to maintain on it is the dryest Niels Nielsen would agree to tune it!  I asked for dry and he point blank refused!  He was probably right.

Cheers

Squeezy

Thanks Squeezy, really appreciate the response!

Quite fascinating and I hadn't even considered the bellows size and sound elements here - I'd presumed it was largely weight rather than everything else the difference can affect. Two boxes it'll have to be then! I'd imagine that starts to turn into quite the set to lug around when C/F's etc are needed for certain arrangements!!
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Guy on January 07, 2020, 12:55:07 PM
To digress slightly, I've just become the proud owner of a D/G/Acc Hohner Lucia but I'm not entirely happy with the layout of the accidental row. I'd be very interested in John's layout for his instruments, as I remember from a different discussion that he recommended the layout that he'd worked out, and I'm sure that he'd do a far better job than I ever could.
I guess that this is a roundabout way of saying "Help, please", but I'd guess that the layouts would be of interest to others as well...
Cheers,
Guy

(PS to Theo/mods, please move this if you think it's too far off-topic!).
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Gena Crisman on January 07, 2020, 01:52:51 PM
Hi Guy, you may find (at least) this post by John helpful: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23174.msg276666.html#msg276666

My understanding from reading his posts + talking to him a few times at festivals is that his requirements for a layout were: a reversal for 'D' on D/G (or G, on a G/C) and repeating 4/5 push pull pattern. The difference between the Jean Michel Corgeron layout I could find and the perhaps more quoted Heim layout is the presence of an accidental reversal or regular reversal (Eb or E F and E I think, actually, on a D/G), so, you could pick your poison there. On a stradella, reversals are less important, however, being able to pick up the instrument and be able to just play it and have it feel familiar was, iirc, an important factor for him.

Care of: http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/3rowGC.html#jmc (http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/3rowGC.html#jmc)
Corgeron GC (http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/jmcGC.gif)
Heim GC (http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/fhGC.gif)

Might be worth grabbing the google doc template and transposing these to D/G for the melnet homepage... also might be nice to know what the existing layout of your instrument is, too.

Hope this (vague) information helps - obviously information is better from the horses mouth but, writing stuff takes time etc.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: rileycat on January 07, 2020, 03:56:30 PM
Just to dip back into the Connemara strand, Brian Peters plays a super-sounding Connemara11 as well -not sure whether Brian said it was Roger Thomas or Dave Jolly who tuned it but it's also quite 'dry'
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 07, 2020, 04:41:29 PM
Just to dip back into the Connemara strand, Brian Peters plays a super-sounding Connemara11 as well -not sure whether Brian said it was Roger Thomas or Dave Jolly who tuned it but it's also quite 'dry'

Brian's box is an early Connemara III - 3-voice, with the tin-plate butterfly logo. As I recall, Brian told me that Dave Jolly tuned it originally, but both myself and Theo have maintained the tuning in recent years.

It is indeed a very sweet soundng box. It has a moderate degree of tremolo, fairly typical of Saltarelles; more tremolo than Castagnari factory tuning, but nowhere near as wet as a Hohner.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Guy on January 07, 2020, 05:20:58 PM
Hi Guy, you may find (at least) this post by John helpful: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23174.msg276666.html#msg276666

Care of: http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/3rowGC.html#jmc (http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/3rowGC.html#jmc)
Corgeron GC (http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/jmcGC.gif)
Heim GC (http://www.geocities.ws/kozulich/fhGC.gif)

Might be worth grabbing the google doc template and transposing these to D/G for the melnet homepage... also might be nice to know what the existing layout of your instrument is, too.

Hope this (vague) information helps - obviously information is better from the horses mouth but, writing stuff takes time etc.

Hi Gena,

Many thanks for the info, I'll follow those up (though my layout planning transposing skills are limited, I'm afraid!). I was particularly interested to hear that Squeezy likes to pick up an instrument and have the layout see familiar, as that's entirely my feeling as well...I guess that's why I'm looking for advice about a "ready-made" layout....

I've got a layout plan for the current layout for mine somewhere, but I'll have to check it out-I'm not sure what format it's in and I'm not sure whether I can shrink it enough to be still legible when posted here.

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: squeezy on January 07, 2020, 09:27:44 PM
To digress slightly, I've just become the proud owner of a D/G/Acc Hohner Lucia but I'm not entirely happy with the layout of the accidental row. I'd be very interested in John's layout for his instruments, as I remember from a different discussion that he recommended the layout that he'd worked out, and I'm sure that he'd do a far better job than I ever could.
I guess that this is a roundabout way of saying "Help, please", but I'd guess that the layouts would be of interest to others as well...
Cheers,
Guy

(PS to Theo/mods, please move this if you think it's too far off-topic!).

Hi Guy ... here is my layout attached ... I hope this works!

It's 5th button start on the middle row (G) ... and 4th button start on the D row.

Although it's almost identical to the JM Corgeron system ... I came up with it independently!  The aim was to have a helper row that maintained the 7 note repeating pattern of the scales on the other 2 rows so fingering is the same in both octaves ... above that the aim was to maximise the number of complete major and minor chords that could be played on the right hand ... only 2 are impossible with all 3 notes ... F# major and Bb minor ... all the other triads are possible with all 3 notes in the same direction.

In reality playing it means that it operates very much like black notes do on a piano.  If you want to switch from playing G major to G minor, you just flick up on to the inside row for Bb and F instead of B and F# - and both are in the same direction as their counterparts on the G row.  Similarly for D minor ... again you flick to the inside row instead of playing the F# for a push F ... and the C natural is of course on the G row.  It can play fairly comfortably in other keys in a similar way.  E major is a similar fingering to E minor but again moving to the inside row for the G# and D#.  Other keys fall rather nicely with a similar push pull pattern to the home keys ... F major is a start on the pull scale that is very comfortable ... Eb is good too.  When you get to the extremes of the keyboard like B major it gets seriously odd ... but then again it's almost impossible to play those keys on the left hand too because you're at the limit of the 48 bass stradella as well.

The low end of the G row is odd and goes right down to the low D/E ... this allows you to play comfortably in an octave lower than usual in G or D.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Guy on January 07, 2020, 10:50:55 PM

Hi Guy ... here is my layout attached ... I hope this works!


Hi John,

Thank you hugely for this-I think that it will  be enormously helpful in getting the Lucia tuned to something that I can make some sense of. There are certainly some notes there (especially the same on the push and pull) that I would never even have been able to consider-as I said, I'm not very technically minded!

It's one of the real benefits of Melnet that we can ask for advice and get it generously offered from some of the most accomplished musicians around without any thought of anything but helping others. I've been fortunate enough to have profited from this for years now, and forget sometimes how much it's helped....

So thanks to everyone who keeps it running....

And John, thanks for the warning that a lot of hours of practice are going to be necessary. Here was me thinking that I could just pick it up and play it...oh dear...

Cheers,
Guy

 
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on January 19, 2020, 12:07:05 PM
It's 5th button start on the middle row (G) ... and 4th button start on the D row.

Although it's almost identical to the JM Corgeron system ... I came up with it independently!  The aim was to have a helper row that maintained the 7 note repeating pattern of the scales on the other 2 rows so fingering is the same in both octaves ... above that the aim was to maximise the number of complete major and minor chords that could be played on the right hand ... only 2 are impossible with all 3 notes ... F# major and Bb minor ... all the other triads are possible with all 3 notes in the same direction.

In reality playing it means that it operates very much like black notes do on a piano.  If you want to switch from playing G major to G minor, you just flick up on to the inside row for Bb and F instead of B and F# - and both are in the same direction as their counterparts on the G row.  Similarly for D minor ... again you flick to the inside row instead of playing the F# for a push F ... and the C natural is of course on the G row.  It can play fairly comfortably in other keys in a similar way.  E major is a similar fingering to E minor but again moving to the inside row for the G# and D#.  Other keys fall rather nicely with a similar push pull pattern to the home keys ... F major is a start on the pull scale that is very comfortable ... Eb is good too.  When you get to the extremes of the keyboard like B major it gets seriously odd ... but then again it's almost impossible to play those keys on the left hand too because you're at the limit of the 48 bass stradella as well.

The low end of the G row is odd and goes right down to the low D/E ... this allows you to play comfortably in an octave lower than usual in G or D.
Thats inspired! I've always taken melodeons to be boxes that are designed to be played in major keys, I guess because the left hand has major chords, and right hand doesn't have access to many triads.

But somehow with that third row on the right hand,  you not only have most major triads, but also most minor. That shouldn't be possible!

I guess the advanatge over a CBA arrangement is just familiarity on first two rows (DG)? Well that and many CBA I guess are getting a fair bit bigger and heavier?

Anyway need to look at that layout in more detail, as makes me as a BC player a tad envious - Where I only have B and E that I can play in both directions ...
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Anahata on January 19, 2020, 12:37:44 PM
Anyway need to look at that layout in more detail, as makes me as a BC player a tad envious - Where I only have B and E that I can play in both directions ...

If you're a B/C player and envious of that 3 row layout, you could always go for B/C/C♯ and have many notes in both directions, lots of RH chords and two rows in a pattern that you already know!
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: David Summers on January 19, 2020, 07:10:54 PM
Anyway need to look at that layout in more detail, as makes me as a BC player a tad envious - Where I only have B and E that I can play in both directions ...

If you're a B/C player and envious of that 3 row layout, you could always go for B/C/C♯ and have many notes in both directions, lots of RH chords and two rows in a pattern that you already know!
Give me a chance, I need to master a two row, and its limitations, before I move onto a three row. I need to crawl, before I walk, before I run. ;)
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: playandteach on January 19, 2020, 09:08:38 PM
Sometimes it's good to run while you can.
Title: Re: John Spiers Melodeons!
Post by: Roger Howard on January 19, 2020, 09:30:01 PM
 (:) Well said.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal