Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Tony Cipriano on December 22, 2019, 11:06:10 PM

Title: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Tony Cipriano on December 22, 2019, 11:06:10 PM
Im having tough time to learn how to play the diatonic accordion
Any good methods or videos that i can find?
There is some members here that really trying to help me but is time for me to get to the basics
Thank you
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on December 22, 2019, 11:59:05 PM
have sent you a PM

george
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Tufty on December 23, 2019, 12:03:24 AM
Lots of tutor books/DVDs available. If, like me, you prefer to learn more by ear than from print try John Kirkpatrick's pack. Very well thought out and starts with the very basics.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on December 23, 2019, 09:01:05 AM
I know of two tutors giving Skype lessons (there are others, but these two are recommended by people I actually know).

Mell Biggs
www.melbiggsmusic.co.uk

Paul Young
www.facebook.com/paulyoungfolk/info

Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: playandteach on December 23, 2019, 12:29:36 PM
I know of two tutors giving Skype lessons (there are others, but these two are recommended by people I actually know).

Mell Biggs
www.melbiggsmusic.co.uk

Paul Young
www.facebook.com/paulyoungfolk/info
I've actually left a message or two on his facebook page, and assume that the typical facebook messenger issue is that unless he knows there's a message, and if it isn't from someone he's linked to, he may not see it. I'll be trying to book a lesson with him some other way.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on December 23, 2019, 12:47:50 PM

I've actually left a message or two on his facebook page, and assume that the typical facebook messenger issue is that unless he knows there's a message, and if it isn't from someone he's linked to, he may not see it. I'll be trying to book a lesson with him some other way.

He's a melnet member under his own name. Have you tried a PM?

[or an email through melnet? I never seem to get those right, though.]
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: TomBom on December 23, 2019, 12:59:46 PM
You can ring him up: http://www.paulyoungfolk.co.uk/contact.html
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: playandteach on December 23, 2019, 02:04:08 PM
Just pm'ed him here. No rush now - have to be late January at the earliest now.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: The Oul' Boy on December 23, 2019, 03:33:14 PM
Just coming up to a year since I started learning, here are some things I found helpful, in no particular order:

- Get a copy of George Garside's tutor book, a great way to start.
- Dave Mallinson's DG Melodeon tutor book has been my go-to manual after that.
- If you don't already, learn a bit of music theory; it's not hard and it helps enormously (I didn't know any other than a few remembered fragments from school this time a year ago).
- Fiddle about on it and try to play a few simple tunes you know well by ear.
- Find tunes you want to play and learn to whistle them by heart (Lester Bailey's Tune a Day Blog is a source of constant inspiration), then they'll be a lot easier to play. I've taken a lot of inspiration from John Spiers, though I doubt I'll ever get anywhere near his standard, but that doesn't matter, it's fun trying, and when you hear yourself playing something that sounds similar it feels good.
- Don't be afraid of the bass side; it took me about 5 months before I could do anything useful with it, and after that things came quickly. If you're struggling, take it a bar at a time, slowly, until you can play a short bit of treble and bass at the same time. If you can learn one bar, you can learn them all (well, so far this has proved true...).
- Keep your melodeon at your side whenever possible. Mine sits beside my office chair so when I'm at home it's always on hand, and I'm constantly picking it up and having a short play. As a result, I never really feel like I have to set aside time to 'practice'.

Warren.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 23, 2019, 03:39:38 PM
Personally, having tried most of the mainstream tutor books I found Ed Rennie's by far the clearest and the most comprehensive. It includes a CD but also a DVD showing both left and right hands so that you can see and hear what you are supposed to doing. Available on Amazon, E-Bay or from the man himself (http://spinningpathmusic.co.uk/books/).


Also (and this is a bit of a shameless plug) there's Melodeon Playgroup (https://melodeonplaygroup.wordpress.com/) coming in February with classes for Absolute Beginners, Beginners and Improvers giving you a whole day of tuition and a chance to meet other players at your level for £15-£25 for the lot - actual price depends on which class you are in as well as total number of attendees.


Edited to fix broken links.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 23, 2019, 03:47:12 PM
The Oul' Boy  has several valid points there.
Two things I'd amplify on would be:-
'Fiddling about' just playing with the box is good. It lets you get to know it, where the buttons/sounds are etc.
I did this then printed off two keyboard layouts from the Home page of Melnet, armed myself with two coloured pens and..... coloured in notes on the push.... coloured in notes on the push and found it visually a great help.

Start right at the beginning with the bass end.
Learn the two hands together, don't be tempted to just play the melody or you might find you have to un-learn a melody sequence when you bring in the basses. Learn both together!
It will seem like a huge thing to begin with but once your brain will have synchronised both hands the door opens and it is a massive step forward.
Good luck!
Q

Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Lester on December 23, 2019, 03:49:36 PM
If you don't already, learn a bit of music theory; it's not hard and it helps enormously.
This ^^^^^^^. Don't be a "I don't understand music or what button does what" sort of guy, a small investment it learning will make chording/row choice/etc very much easier.

Quote
Find tunes you want to play and learn to whistle them by heart (Lester Bailey's Tune a Day Blog is a source of constant inspiration)
8)  https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/p/tune-index.html (https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/p/tune-index.html)
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: The Oul' Boy on December 23, 2019, 03:55:02 PM
Personally, having tried most of the mainstream tutor books I found Ed Rennie's by far the clearest and the most comprehensive.

I have that too, and it has proved useful, but has never quite grabbed me in the way Dave Mallinson's has. Individual taste no doubt!
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 23, 2019, 03:57:55 PM
Absolutely Lester, well said!
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: The Oul' Boy on December 23, 2019, 03:58:35 PM
Don't be a "I don't understand music or what button does what" sort of guy

That was me for years and years, I was convinced I wasn't musical and could never learn or understand any music theory. Turned out to be completely untrue, which I should have realised as I've spent most of my life constantly whistling and humming tunes I've heard. Basic music theory is easier than most things I've tried to learn. Better late than never...
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Anahata on December 23, 2019, 05:26:01 PM
Basic music theory is easier than most things I've tried to learn. Better late than never...

Music theory is only codifying what you already know instinctively. If you have tunes and harmonies in your head and know what "sounds right",
theory is simply giving some of those concepts names and providing guidelines on what "works" and what doesn't.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: The Oul' Boy on December 23, 2019, 05:38:11 PM
Music theory is only codifying what you already know instinctively. If you have tunes and harmonies in your head and know what "sounds right",
theory is simply giving some of those concepts names and providing guidelines on what "works" and what doesn't.

Yes, that's a nice way to think about it, having some terminology and knowing the representational devices proves to be very useful I've found.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Dick Rees on December 24, 2019, 03:04:55 AM
Basic music theory is easier than most things I've tried to learn. Better late than never...

Music theory is only codifying what you already know instinctively. If you have tunes and harmonies in your head and know what "sounds right",
theory is simply giving some of those concepts names and providing guidelines on what "works" and what doesn't.

Agreed.  I've often maintained that theory is hindsight...or a musical post mortem.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Sebastian on December 24, 2019, 10:16:09 AM
Music theory is only codifying what you already know instinctively.
Music theory changed fundamentally over time, and different cultures developed different music theories. Therefore I would hesitate to speak of 'instinctive knowledge'. There are indeed some musical universals, but they are few. The larger part of what belongs to music differs from culture to culture and is thus learned and acquired. It’s not instinct.

Music theory reveals the structures and raises them from the unconscious to the conscious, so that you know what you’re doing.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: playandteach on December 24, 2019, 10:58:27 AM
I can only say that theory and notation are nothing to be frightened of. Some people can write great tunes by years of practical experience, others can write great tunes by building experience through analysis of the tunes that they like. Avoiding theory is like saying I will only use flat bladed screwdrivers. What happens when you come across a cross headed screw?
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 24, 2019, 12:28:29 PM
If I am being brutally honest, my musical knowledge is very basic.
But.... I know the notes on the stave, those just above and just below the stave, and knowing where D and G is on the melodeon means can count up the buttons to get where the next note is.
Add to it a very fundamental knowledge of what a 3 note chord is and what notes form those chords on your melodeon gives you a massive advantage.
Any more theory is a bonus, but those things provide you with a good base for melodeon music we play, in my opinion.
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Howard Jones on December 24, 2019, 12:47:43 PM
At the risk of stating the obvious, to learn diatonic accordion you should stick to playing diatonic tunes, at least to begin with.  In another post the OP was asking about playing 'O Sole Mio' which relies heavily not only on a distinctive accidental note in the melody but on an accompanying chord which isn't on the bass end of a standard instrument.  I don't want to revisit the discussion on that thread, simply to say that you'll make more progress by concentrating on simple diatonic tunes which suit the instrument.  Once you have developed some skill you can then explore ways of playing other more complicated tunes, but you have to bear in mind that this is a limited instrument - within its limitations it can do some amazing things, but not all music can be played on it.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Anahata on December 24, 2019, 12:54:20 PM
Music theory changed fundamentally over time, and different cultures developed different music theories. Therefore I would hesitate to speak of 'instinctive knowledge'.

Fair enough, "instinct" wasn't quite the right word. More "what you're used to" than "what you were born with", but my point (that theory simply codifies your musical expectations) remains.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on December 24, 2019, 02:57:16 PM
funny thing this musical theory!    Those who have had some 'classical' training seem to worry about it much more than those who play by ear or mostly by ear  working on the basis that if it sounds right it is right.

This could well be because the former group have been brought up to play a tune 'correctly'' ( whatever that means)  and the latter group  just poke around until they get it sounding the way they want it to sound'

There are of course both crap and brilliant players  in each school and for what its worth I have generally found those with little or no 'classical' theory much easier to teach melodeon  perhaps because they worry less about the theory of it.??????????????? 

george
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on December 24, 2019, 05:23:28 PM

Music theory reveals the structures and raises them from the unconscious to the conscious, so that you know what you’re doing.


So, if one plays from the concious, rather than the subconcious,  is it better, or worse, or just...?
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Winston Smith on December 24, 2019, 05:51:03 PM
"is it better, or worse,"

A good question, methinks! I find (I think) that I play better from the subconscious. When I have to think about what comes next, I go all to pot. It's the same as when I try to sing along to a tune, even one that I can play, and/or sing, without the slightest hesitation; my fingers just turn to uncontrollable jelly, and the buttons seem to move about out of reach. It's awful!
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on December 24, 2019, 06:24:51 PM
very good question!   for what its worth I see  playing the right notes in the right order as being done subconsciously   which comes with practice  and leaves the 'concious' department free to transform playing the right notes in the right order into 'music' - and there is a huge difference between the two!.   The right notes in the right order in a mechanical action but changing that into 'music requires  careful consideration and attention to such things as  dynamics, phrasing and rhythm  all of which require active listening to and detailed adjustment of not just the notes but the gaps between them etc etc


george
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Mike Hirst on December 24, 2019, 06:46:50 PM
if one plays from the concious, rather than the subconcious,  is it better, or worse
I have witnesses who will attest to the fact that I have been known to continue playing the accordion whilst unconscious.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Winston Smith on December 24, 2019, 07:07:52 PM
Novice that I certainly am, I'm almost fearful of contradicting Mr Garside!
However, it seems to me that while singing, I have no need to consciously change emphasis, volume, or whatever else is needed to convey the full meaning or emotion of the words which I'm singing; it just comes naturally! I find that it's the same with squeezing, except that I cannot usually do it when the added (conscious) distraction of recording or playing to a stationary audience comes into play.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Winston Smith on December 24, 2019, 09:00:34 PM
Seeing as I'm still recovering from some nasty surgery, I haven't been allowed to go busking or carol singing for our usual Christmastime charity (Action for Children). But I did promise myself that when the carol singers arrived at our door, I'd accompany them on the box!
This is the case which proves the point I made above:
My beloved wanted "In the Bleak Midwinter" which I know double-well. (Even in the right key on the Eb row of my Bb/Eb Liliput.) They only sing two verses, or they wouldn't get home before Christmas dinner time! The first verse went swimmingly, but when I decided to join in with the singing half way through the second verse, I had to stop again almost immediately, as the playing just went awry. It's very annoying!
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 24, 2019, 09:27:56 PM
I've just finished a book entitled 'The Inner Game of Music' and it discusses Self 1  vs Self 2.
Self 1 is your consciousness chatting to you "oh too fast, oops missed a note, what is that shopping we need?, don't forget the anniversary...' etc etc.
It is the chatter that puts you off.

Self 2 is your sub conscious, where all the musical memory lies.
If you can relax into Self 2 and let it take over, then you will play to the best of your ability, but you need to silence Self 1.
I'm working on silencing Self 1!!

I read it then immediately re-read it, and there's a lot of sense in it and I fully understand what it says, I just need to put it into practice.
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on December 24, 2019, 11:46:05 PM
Novice that I certainly am, I'm almost fearful of contradicting Mr Garside!
However, it seems to me that while singing, I have no need to consciously change emphasis, volume, or whatever else is needed to convey the full meaning or emotion of the words which I'm singing; it just comes naturally! I find that it's the same with squeezing, except that I cannot usually do it when the added (conscious) distraction of recording or playing to a stationary audience comes into play.

feel entirely free to contradict me or anyone else in the interest of maintaining good friendly debate

george ;)
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Howard Jones on December 25, 2019, 10:07:28 AM
Theory is the grammar of music.  We don't consciously learn the grammar of our native language when we learn to talk as children, and we can speak before we can read and write.  Similarly, we unconsciously learn what sounds right and what sounds wrong in the forms of music we listen to the most, and apply that knowledge when we play ourselves.  Music theory and notation may help us to understand what is going on, and to communicate our musical ideas to others, but we don't need to know them in a formal sense in order to make music, any more than we need to know the rules of grammar in order to be able to speak. 

Learning some music theory will help you to understand and give names to what you are already doing.  It may help you to be more creative if you can apply rules rather than trial-and-error, and it will help you to communicate your ideas to others.  It is most easily learned alongside learning the instrument itself, rather than as a later addition.  However you don't need it in order to play.

Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Jesse Smith on December 27, 2019, 02:27:29 PM
I've just finished a book entitled 'The Inner Game of Music' and it discusses Self 1  vs Self 2.
Self 1 is your consciousness chatting to you "oh too fast, oops missed a note, what is that shopping we need?, don't forget the anniversary...' etc etc.
It is the chatter that puts you off.

But is there maybe a Self 1b, perhaps "the Controlled Consciousness" that says, "OK, don't forget to play this part nice and bouncy, great, and this part coming up we have to remember to do that twiddle we practiced... Yeah, that was OK but remember we wanted to make that part a lot smoother like on the recording we heard, how do we get there?"

A lot of practicing for me is closely listening to what I'm playing, comparing it to other recordings of musicians that played something I really liked and want to learn to play like, and then figuring out what to do with arms and fingers to make it sound more like that. It's not music theory but it's definitely very conscious awareness of what I am playing.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: arty on December 27, 2019, 03:54:21 PM
I've just finished a book entitled 'The Inner Game of Music' and it discusses Self 1  vs Self 2.

Thank you Q...I have just ordered the book. I hope it helps!


A lot of practicing for me is closely listening to what I'm playing, comparing it to other recordings of musicians that played something I really liked and want to learn to play like, and then figuring out what to do with arms and fingers to make it sound more like that. It's not music theory but it's definitely very conscious awareness of what I am playing.

That, pretty much, describes exactly what I do Jesse. I do try, if the tune is one I want to hold on to and not just a learning exercise, to learn it by heart. Only then do I find that it becomes easier and I can add more feeling to the tune and make it my own. There is a very experienced fiddle player that I know, who I have often seen playing, note perfect and sometimes at speed, while having a conversation with the person sat next to her. I don't know how she does it but it is something that has always impressed me!

Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on December 27, 2019, 04:22:14 PM
listening to the detail of what is coming out of the box in respect of length of notes, phrasing, dynamics etc and making adjustments thereto on the hoof is vital to good playing. however  no conscious thought  should be required as to playing the right notes in the right order , fingering, bellowing or whatever i.e think the tune and leave it to the brain to send the right signals down the arms.

george
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 27, 2019, 05:02:52 PM
Well, Jesse, if listening to Self 1 b you are thinking about this that and the other regarding your playing as you play, that is distracting even though it is on-subject. It means you are thinking and that is the distraction.
It makes the point that Self 2 takes over and subconsciously let's you play with feeling and express yourself *without thinking about it* because your subconscious takes over.

Another point that really hit home was how powerful your subconscious is so long as you allow it to be.
I realised this after reading one chapter. Sometimes playing in a session, especially to begin with, I sometimes feel lost. I'm not getting the tunes, other people's tunes I cannot pick up.
I sit there, and somehow relax and .... other people's tunes start to come to my fingers.
It might sound a bit 'right on' but I've found it makes complete sense to me.

Good luck with the book arty.  Come back and let me know what you think of it.
Cheers
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Dick Rees on December 27, 2019, 06:34:59 PM
Theory is the grammar of music.  We don't consciously learn the grammar of our native language when we learn to talk as children, and we can speak before we can read and write.  Similarly, we unconsciously learn what sounds right and what sounds wrong in the forms of music we listen to the most, and apply that knowledge when we play ourselves.  Music theory and notation may help us to understand what is going on, and to communicate our musical ideas to others, but we don't need to know them in a formal sense in order to make music, any more than we need to know the rules of grammar in order to be able to speak. 

Learning some music theory will help you to understand and give names to what you are already doing.  It may help you to be more creative if you can apply rules rather than trial-and-error, and it will help you to communicate your ideas to others.  It is most easily learned alongside learning the instrument itself, rather than as a later addition.  However you don't need it in order to play.

Well said!

As to the concious/subconscious and Self 1/2, I often state it as letting the Music play me rather than than t'other way 'round.

Happy holidays to all.  Keep skweezin'!
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 27, 2019, 06:55:14 PM
Yes Dick, I think you are right.
We all know those rare ( for me )  occasions where we simply play. The tunes flow, mistakes disappear and we just get lost in the music. That's what the book tries to head you towards and describe it something like 'relaxed concentration'
Once in that state you play your best, I know I do!
Trouble is, learning how to get there regularly!!!
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on December 27, 2019, 06:57:11 PM
or simply just let a tune fester in the brain all by itself.   I sometimes find myself playing a tune reasonably well but have no idea of its title or when and where I've heard it' . Then its over to the polishing department !

george

Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 27, 2019, 08:20:58 PM
Which is another way of saying  letting your subconscious takes over!
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Jesse Smith on December 28, 2019, 02:39:42 AM
Well, Jesse, if listening to Self 1 b you are thinking about this that and the other regarding your playing as you play, that is distracting even though it is on-subject. It means you are thinking and that is the distraction.
It makes the point that Self 2 takes over and subconsciously let's you play with feeling and express yourself *without thinking about it* because your subconscious takes over.

Yes, that definitely sounds like the goal that we all work towards. But on the way to that goal I find it really helpful to be as conscious as possible about what I am playing and what I want to be playing and the gap between the two. Perhaps in its ideal form it's like a sort of meditative state of mind where the conscious mind is observing the performing mind at some degree of detachment.

I fear we may be overwhelming poor Tony, who just wanted a recommendation for a good tutor book or some YouTube videos! ::)
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 28, 2019, 08:13:34 AM
Jesse, yes I think you are absolutely right on both points:
Performing in a meditative state is I think a good way to think of it
....and yes we we've drifted away from Tony's original question, somehow it always happens!
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Brian J Morris on March 19, 2020, 04:48:22 PM
I have a fundamental question. I have a B/C button accordion and I've been working on it for a bit over a year, and I've learned a number of songs. My question is fingering patterns. I've been playing these songs and I don't always use the same finger for the same note. It depends on what preceded it and the positions of my fingers at that time. My question is whether I should relearn the songs and use the same finger always for the same note. For example in the key of D, should my index finger always press low D, middle finger for E, and ring finger for F#? I've never taken lessons, just the occasional online video, and I also have a CD. Just wondering if I'm missing a basic concept that should be cleared up while I'm still in the beginning stages.

Thanks - Brian Morris, Rocky Point USA
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 19, 2020, 05:00:10 PM
Brian,
I'm a DG player and often come across a similar situation.
My fingering pattern changes for the same note depending on how my fingers arrive at the note and where they then need to go. On a DG I have some notes that can be pushed on the G row or pulled on the D row ( or vice versa) and the decision whether to push it or pull it is dictated by the preceding notes or the following notes, whichever falls best to the finger.
That's my strategy!
Cheers
Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: richard.fleming on March 19, 2020, 05:12:49 PM
My question is whether I should relearn the songs and use the same finger always for the same note. For example in the key of D, should my index finger always press low D, middle finger for E, and ring finger for F#?

Thanks - Brian Morris, Rocky Point USA

That approach makes no sense to me. You've a whole keyboard for your hand to roam over. Your brain and your ear learn the positions and sounds of the notes, and you play the notes with whichever fingers are handiest at the time according. for example, to whether the tune is moving up or down the keyboard at the time. You try not overthink about your fingers, concentrate on the tune. People may contradict this, of course - wouldn't be melnet otherwise! But if you watch a competent player's hand move over the keyboard you can immediately see how silly it would be if they interrupted the flow constantly, jumping about so that, for example, their index finger should always play the low D
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on March 19, 2020, 06:04:42 PM
Yes exactly. As richard says, go with the flow and let your fingers walk!
 Q
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Barlow on March 19, 2020, 06:18:12 PM
The question is reasonable enough. (This new post from Brian today could do with its own thread).

When I first started (B/C), without formal lessons but with plenty of general music knowledge, I made a lovely system of playing all notes with the same finger and just moved strictly up and down the keyboard like a violin player might use positions up the fretboard.

I was rather pleased with my system of positions and could soon knock out a few tunes. But pride comes before a fall and soon enough I hit the wall. The system proved restrictive and somewhat ridiculous.

I realised I had to be more fluid with my fingers, the only fixed one generally being the start note, which was often the first finger but not necessarily.

It was the music that was important not the discipline of the fingering (some form of OCD seemed to be kicking in...)

A bit controversial, but something I would suggest is to use only 3 fingers. For plenty of reasons but just now, a good reason enough is that you will have a choice of only 2 fingers to use next, and it will likely be obvious which one. It takes some dexterity but that will come.

I would also suggest use a new finger for each new note, even if it is on the same button, but I doubt I will get too much support here for that one, but it was a cloud clearing for me.

I could write a whole load here, but I'll leave it just now.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: richard.fleming on March 19, 2020, 09:39:51 PM
The question is reasonable enough. (This new post from Brian today could do with its own thread).

A bit controversial, but something I would suggest is to use only 3 fingers. For plenty of reasons but just now, a good reason enough is that you will have a choice of only 2 fingers to use next, and it will likely be obvious which one. It takes some dexterity but that will come.

I would also suggest use a new finger for each new note, even if it is on the same button, but I doubt I will get too much support here for that one, but it was a cloud clearing for me.

I could write a whole load here, but I'll leave it just now.

No one ever seems to have a rational explanation for these theories. Take no notice would be my advice to Brian, just let your fingers roam up and down the keyboard as smoothly and as fluidly and as naturally as possible.
Edited to add:
Watching my fingers while playing and thinking about this post, I see that as the hand roams up and down the keyboard  the next button is always pressed by the finger nearest to it. If there is for example a jump to a note higher up the scale, then the little finger goes to it, because it is nearest. (Forget that nonsense about only playing with 3 fingers). I am talking as a semitone-box player. Obviously if you play DG and have 'accidentals' at some distance from where your hand is playing you've a problem, though that is easily solved.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Open_G on March 20, 2020, 02:55:38 PM
Re musical theory I can only speak for the music of the British Isles that I grew up singing and listening to. We all grew up singing songs (and therefore learning melodies) to things like Baa Baa Black Sheep, Oranges and Lemons, We get to instinctively understand things like resolution, major, minor, I, IV and V, chordal patterns etc. even if we don't understand why our music is so full of them, because these patterns learnt in childhood go all the way through modern music, unless it is deliberately discordant (the flattened 5th/devil's chord is still very prevalent in modern heavy metal). When lionel bart wrote Oom Pah, Pah, he couldn't have told you a waltz from a waltzer (I may have made that bit up, I don't know how much theory he did or didn't know, but I believe he was limited).

Musical theory starts to explain these things to us, and allows us to explore effects without simply fiddling about with our tools trying to find that sound in our head... I am no theoretical guru and still find myself hearing things in music and thinking how have they achieved that sound? the theory I know has helped on occasion. For something I got involved with once, someone asked me to record something spanish sounding on a guitar for a project. I twiddled around in the Phygian mode for a few minutes, and they were ecstatic.. I couldn't to this day state what I'd played, or play it again even close... but knowing that element of theory immediately meant I had a "go to."
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Howard Jones on March 20, 2020, 05:26:17 PM
My question is whether I should relearn the songs and use the same finger always for the same note.

Which finger you use to play a note will depend on the notes around it.  You need to think about how the notes fit together into a phrase and work out the most suitable fingering to play that sequence.  You might play the notes one way going up the scale and differently going down.  Sometimes the best fingering will come quickly, sometimes you have to try several options.  If you've tied yourself into always using a particular finger for each note then you've restricted your choices. 

The same goes with phrases themselves, don't practice a phrase in isolation without thinking about how you got there and where you're going next. Sometimes you may have to compromise because the ideal fingering for a particular phrase doesn't fit well with the fingering of the phrases around it.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Stiamh on March 20, 2020, 09:24:47 PM
Watching my fingers while playing and thinking about this post, I see that as the hand roams up and down the keyboard  the next button is always pressed by the finger nearest to it.

You sometimes see people playing an entire series of notes with, say, the index finger as they move down the keyboard (by down I mean towards the chin!). This would fit with what you have described above - always pressing with the nearest finger. So, too, would reaching for two or three consecutive buttons with the little finger - because every time that was the finger closest to the button required.

But - correct me if I'm wrong - I don't suppose this is what you mean or what you would recommend as an approach. In which case, I think our questioner might need more information.

Quote
Forget that nonsense about only playing with 3 fingers.

Yes - exactly what I thought the first time I heard this apparently absurd suggestion.

The second time I heard it - as a strong recommendation, not a suggestion - I decided to try it. Seriously try it. And there was no going back afterwards.  :|glug
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: richard.fleming on March 20, 2020, 11:16:20 PM
Watching my fingers while playing and thinking about this post, I see that as the hand roams up and down the keyboard  the next button is always pressed by the finger nearest to it.

You sometimes see people playing an entire series of notes with, say, the index finger as they move down the keyboard (by down I mean towards the chin!). This would fit with what you have described above - always pressing with the nearest finger. So, too, would reaching for two or three consecutive buttons with the little finger - because every time that was the finger closest to the button required.

But - correct me if I'm wrong - I don't suppose this is what you mean or what you would recommend as an approach. In which case, I think our questioner might need more information.

Quote
Forget that nonsense about only playing with 3 fingers.

Yes - exactly what I thought the first time I heard this apparently absurd suggestion.

The second time I heard it - as a strong recommendation, not a suggestion - I decided to try it. Seriously try it. And there was no going back afterwards.  :|glug

I'm not - contrary to what some here might think - that given to controversy really. But I like to think that the experience of someone who bought his first semitone box in 1966 is worth something. Worth considering  anyway. To have four fingers roaming up and down the keyboard moving as economically and naturally as possible seems to make sense to me, and to be more natural than playing by some of the theories advanced above because it lets the brain and fingers work out what comes naturally.  Thinking and overthinking can, I think, get in the way of spontaneous music-making. But what comes naturally to me may well not be what comes naturally to Stiamh, who I respect even when I disagree with him.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: playandteach on March 21, 2020, 09:23:10 AM
For what it's worth, I followed Stiamh's advice recently when trying out the one row (which I must pick up again). A lot of people here have advised scale practice, but to the best of my knowledge Stiamh was the only one to actually produce an example of how to approach this. I stuck with it for a week or so, and it made a lot of sense. Patterns of movement became useful for knowing how to predict the change in push pull sequences needed in scales, and although there are more leaps, they are normally smaller leaps and less tangled. I do have fairly good right hand dexterity because of my clarinet years, but Stiamh's advice was worth trying out.
I may not stick with it as many of the things I enjoy working on have elements of 2 part writing in the right hand - which of course requires all my fingers (and thumb). But if I get round to tidying up my one row playing, I'll use his 'system'.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Stiamh on March 21, 2020, 11:23:43 AM
But I like to think that the experience of someone who bought his first semitone box in 1966 is worth something. Worth considering  anyway. To have four fingers roaming up and down the keyboard moving as economically and naturally as possible seems to make sense to me, and to be more natural than playing by some of the theories advanced above because it lets the brain and fingers work out what comes naturally.  Thinking and overthinking can, I think, get in the way of spontaneous music-making.

Of course your experience is worth considering Richard - and having our hand and fingers "roaming as economically and naturally" is surely what we all aspire to. And I agree that one needs to get beyond thinking so that the whole process becomes subconscious.

If it came naturally to you, you are lucky. You were young, which must have helped! But it doesn't come naturally to everyone, as shown by all the questions that are raised here from time to time.

The thing is, as long as everybody realises that suggestions offered here are intended to help others, and are not made for the purpose of being right or laying down the law, we should be able to acknowledge each other's experience and viewpoint and agree to disagree respectfully. My apologies if I haven't always done so.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: richard.fleming on March 21, 2020, 12:26:57 PM
Stiamh - I suspect that it is all very complex. Was I younger when I started? Did I somehow have a more useful little finger than others in the first place? Or has the process of learning to play an instrument meant that my nerves and muscles and braincells have developed in certain ways, as have yours? Music is about the body as well as the instrument, isn't it, and we have to take that into account with the box as well as with, say, the saxophone, which is a more extreme example of an instrument than interacts with the body of the player. But I still think that if one is fortunate enough to be able to play fluidly with all four fingers and that it suits one to do so it may put one at an advantage.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Barlow on March 21, 2020, 01:32:47 PM
[
Quote
Forget that nonsense about only playing with 3 fingers.

Yes - exactly what I thought the first time I heard this apparently absurd suggestion.

The second time I heard it - as a strong recommendation, not a suggestion - I decided to try it. Seriously try it. And there was no going back afterwards.  :|glug

The above is how I experienced starting to play with 3 fingers. (I consider myself a beginner, I am in my 50s.)

It set me back a bit, a week or two, which I was reluctant to do, but well worth the effort in the end. Maybe my subconscious was ready to take over some of my playing anyway (what a feeling that is when you first realise it has happened) but I found that was happening more with 3 fingers.

The little finger is still working, providing balance maybe, and it usually gets the job for the very end of row note. And some occasional high-end harmony

A bit of an extreme illustration, but I see it like a group of mountaineers teaming up to climb Everest. 3 of them strapping 6-footers with bags of experience, with a fourth, a bit of a runt, keen as mustard but nowhere near the physical ability of the others. Do you take him up the mountain because he's there and you may as well use him (well, why wouldn't you), or do you use him for base camp duties, or whatever.

[The new finger for each note is another matter, but one I wish I had gone with at the start. I realise that I will be more-or-less on my own with that one but I am willing to explain how and why I have found it helps].



Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 21, 2020, 01:46:35 PM
You are doing the right thing.  3 finger play is entirely possible, but as you improve it is a difficult habit to move on from, this especially wrt left end chording.  The more  you use that 4th digit the cleverer it will become.

Though I'm perhaps fortunate to still have 4 fingers after my attempt at motor mower maintenance? (see other thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25182.msg300207.html#msg300207))  ;)
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Barlow on March 21, 2020, 02:09:28 PM
Left hand is a different matter for me, Chris. I am strictly 4 fingers and I have to say every button has its own finger, although occasional bass runs I will do some jiggery pokery.

The 4th finger on the right hand, poor thing, realises it is not 'one of the boys' and does some occasional clever stuff of its own. It can throw in harmony quite nicely when it wants to too!
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Peadar on March 21, 2020, 02:31:08 PM
I have a fundamental question. I have a B/C button accordion and I've been working on it for a bit over a year, and I've learned a number of songs. My question is fingering patterns. I've been playing these songs and I don't always use the same finger for the same note. It depends on what preceded it and the positions of my fingers at that time. My question is whether I should relearn the songs and use the same finger always for the same note. For example in the key of D, should my index finger always press low D, middle finger for E, and ring finger for F#? I've never taken lessons, just the occasional online video, and I also have a CD. Just wondering if I'm missing a basic concept that should be cleared up while I'm still in the beginning stages.

Thanks - Brian Morris, Rocky Point USA

Absolutely not! The fact that you don't always use the same finger on the same keys says that you are ctually learning the instument as well as individual tunes. You may later find that some tunes can be made to work better with a different fingering but that's another stage in the learning and development process.
It has been said that it takes seven months to learn the pipes and seven years to master them. That's probably true of the melodeon as well.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 22, 2020, 01:00:25 PM
. It has been said that it takes seven months to learn the pipes and seven years to master them. That's probably true of the melodeon as well.

More or less my experience. My wife (who bought me a pokerwork to stop me practicing concertina!) was gobsmacked when I played a pair of polka’s straight through, no errors 😳  in Whitby Folk club. It was … 10 months in?
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Little Eggy on March 22, 2020, 01:18:11 PM
I've been learning this wonderful instrument for 3 years and a bit.
I know a few music basics but use YouTube to familiarise myself with tunes and learn to play them.
I hope over the coming weeks of isolation to deal with several 'deficiencies', viz :-

Improved recognition of the actual notes coming out of each button (If someone says 'give me an f#' I have to run through the D scale to get to it)

Sight reading and playing simple tunes where I can't quickly find the tune on FolkTuneFinder or YouTube

abc notation

Improving my technique several notches - clarity; smoothness; starting and ending properly - including relearning some tunes



Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: george garside on March 22, 2020, 02:31:55 PM
but keep in mind that honing 'playing by ear' skills is just as or possibly more important than site reading in 'melodeon land'

george
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Brian J Morris on March 22, 2020, 02:51:21 PM
Thanks to all of you for your wisdom gained from experience. I found the responses enlightening and frequently entertaining, but best of all the consensus is to do what I've been doing and let my fingers find their way to the right (more often than not) buttons.
Title: Re: Learning diatonic accordion
Post by: Dick Rees on March 22, 2020, 06:31:41 PM
Thanks to all of you for your wisdom gained from experience. I found the responses enlightening and frequently entertaining, but best of all the consensus is to do what I've been doing and let my fingers find their way to the right (more often than not) buttons.

Each tune you learn will have the potential to add something new to your bag of tricks.  Eventually you'll keep what works and sluff off the less effective bits.  It's beneficial to keep a tune list and go back over it whenever a new tune reveals a new trick to compare and contrast technique developments and go deeper into what makes the music flow.

Two suggestions:

1.  Arpeggio exercises for the fingers and
2.  Interval recognition training for the ears.

Combining 1&2, try harmonizing scales in 3rds and 6ths.

Have fun, good luck.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal