Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: arty on January 10, 2020, 11:31:19 AM
-
Picking up on something Squeezy said in a previous topic....
â€I have never yet heard a 3 voice LMM box sound as good as a simple 2 voice MM box on the MM setting. I would love for such an instrument to exist ... but my (fairly wide) experience tells me that it doesn't.â€
Makers of boxes must be fully aware of this and, I would guess, is something that designers of boxes are constantly trying to improve upon. But what is the reason for this and are all makes of 3 voice boxes as bad as each other?
I find a big attraction in having a 3 voice box and being able to switch between voices mid-tune, to add variety and different colours to the sound. Are some boxes better at this than others?
In the past, I have been interested in the Castagnari Trilly, for example and the ease with which one can change voices using the row of push buttons on the grill, within easy reach while playing. I have never tried a Trilly myself but I have been put off by the rather muffled sound that
I can hear on recordings of this instrument. It doesn’t seem to work on any setting that I have heard but, maybe I am being unfair, as I haven’t actually played one myself. I know that those who play them, absolutely love them. I would like to try one.
I have just acquired a second hand Beltuna 3 and I am really enjoying the ability to change the sound but I am fully aware that the character of the sound completely changes when I pull up or push down the stop. I don’t find it unattractive though.
I once had a Hascy D/G and I didn’t get on with it at all, because of this reason. I didn’t like the sound that came out of it on any setting. Such a personal thing, isn’t it, sound? Does the same problem arise with bigger boxes like a Handry?
I have a Castagnari Laura G/C, 2 voice box and it is an absolutely exquisite instrument with a most wonderful sound. I could easily be tempted to add a 3 voice G/C box to my collection though, if the sound was right on all settings.
Sorry for waffling on but it is something that interests me greatly. Of course, we all have different tastes, we play different types of music, we hear differently....what is your experience?
There must be some makes of boxes, where this problem is less noticeable than others, surely?
-
Maybe this should be added to the other thread, I don't know. I'm sure our beloved Leader will decide.
â€I have never yet heard a 3 voice LMM box sound as good as a simple 2 voice MM box on the MM setting. I would love for such an instrument to exist ... but my (fairly wide) experience tells me that it doesn't.â€
Perhaps one of our more expert converters could isolate the low voice on such an instrument by somehow splitting the reed chamber into two independent chambers?
-
Replying especially to Arty....
It has been said many times on this forum and elsewhere - there is no substitute really for trying each individual instrument to see which one speaks to you best.
Even instruments of the same make and model can vary a little bit in sound, responsiveness and simply un-analysible general 'feel'. I remember buying my Castagnari Mory: I was lucky enough to be able to try three instruments (thanks Pete!) and to be able to compare all three. They were all good, but one just stood out as being 'the right one for me'. Someone else might have chosen one of the other two.
I've played a few new Trillys in the last few months and all have been very good indeed, but I remember when they first came out, perhaps 15 years ago they were a little disappointing compared with the Lilium which I had at that time.
I've been interested in the recent comments about the possible superiority of the two-voice MM sound in a two-voice dedicated box compared with the two-voice MM sound on a three-voice LMM box. I have to say that on my current '1914' LMM box, the two voice MM sound is very fine indeed, extremely focussed and flexible. The 1914 is a superb box; I can't understand why more people don't snap them up.
-
arty, we seem on parallel journeys and similar thoughts.
I have become really attached to my 2 voice Castagnari Jilly but there are times when I too would like to vary the voices 'on the fly' i.e. in mid tune.
A brilliant example of this has been demonstrated in recent times by Saul Bailey's posts for Tune of the Month, using various voices matched with exquisite and thoughtful playing.
In recent posts he uses a Mory which for me adds a further complication - modifying my playing to accommodate a half row for accidentals when I have become proficient at using the chin end ones. Having sat beside a Mory in a summer session the sound was simply glorious, rich and full. A quick twiddle on one on a stall was nice, but I have the feeling it's too much box for me and a 2r 8b covers (most) of my needs.
The Trilly has caught my eye too. It is a 'super' 2 row 8 bass with the voice options available to hand of the Mory without my need to change my playing style to a half row but..... I'm not sure. Having 7 switches across the front seems a bit overkill. You've mentioned a muffled sound, something I've not noticed but could believe.
I keep going around in circles, giving up on the idea until something triggers the thought again.
Like this thread !!
Q
-
Lmm boxes typically have palettes that cover 3 holes, and contain 3 reed blocks. The L reeds are placed in the middle reed block, since you need one per row and are typically longer than the matching M reeds, and also makes turning them on and off easier. This typically means that the M blocks are pushed out, one block towards you, one away, like an over filled Sandwich. This moves then out of optimal place, much farther apart than normal in a regular MM instument. Additionally, due to the pallets being longer, when they lever away, there is more variation in their distance from each of the sound hole they cover.
This all leads to a much more perceptible difference in the sound of each row on the MM setting, as they're coming to your ear from more different places, one with more keyboard and casework. And (I think) slightly less ideal performance due to the internal air mechanics surrounding them, due to the casework proximity. Plus, because of the larger pallets and pressure, you'll usually have to have heavier springs keeping your pallets closed, and thus buttons feel heavier to play, regardless of setting.
The solution to this problem is never turn the 3rd voice off. Or maybe split the L reeds onto two, thin single side reed blocks and stick them at either end idk (ie, butter the outside of the bread, rather than make a sandwich).
-
Ah, cross posted with Steve.
Again, the 1914 is in the mix with these, and something I would consider but again, it would prompt a change of style for me.
Something I might be making more of than necessary, as people seem to switch between 2r 8 b and a 2.5r fairly easily.
Q
-
Thanks Gena, I seem to be cross posting with everyone!
-
Lmm boxes typically have palettes that cover 3 holes, and contain 3 reed blocks. The L reeds are placed in the middle reed block, since you need one per row and are typically longer than the matching M reeds, and also makes turning them on and off easier. This typically means that the M blocks are pushed out, one block towards you, one away, like an over filled Sandwich. This moves then out of optimal place, much farther apart than normal in a regular MM instument. Additionally, due to the pallets being longer, when they lever away, there is more variation in their distance from each of the sound hole they cover.
This all leads to a much more perceptible difference in the sound of each row on the MM setting, as they're coming to your ear from more different places, one with more keyboard and casework. And (I think) slightly less ideal performance due to the internal air mechanics surrounding them, due to the casework proximity. Plus, because of the larger pallets and pressure, you'll usually have to have heavier springs keeping your pallets closed, and thus buttons feel heavier to play, regardless of setting.
The solution to this problem is never turn the 3rd voice off. Or maybe split the L reeds onto two, thin single side reed blocks and stick them at either end idk (ie, butter the outside of the bread, rather than make a sandwich).
Your last idea was used on some 20th century boxes Gena. I think I have an example, possibly it was this "Artist" model Italian GC LMM box. Photo is handy, but the box is tucked away due to serious casework damage from a drop at some point. Although not economical to repair, I saved it as a document of this construction idea. Its reeds are also superb and in a beautiful non-equal temperament throughout (melody and bass sides) that has survived well. Next time I have this one out of storage I'll photo the reedblock layout of the melody side, but IIRC it's 2 MM blocks in the middle and then 2 blocks at either edge of the soundboard that each are one sided with a single rank of L reeds.
PG
-
Lmm boxes typically have palettes that cover 3 holes, and contain 3 reed blocks. The L reeds are placed in the middle reed block, since you need one per row and are typically longer than the matching M reeds, and also makes turning them on and off easier. This typically means that the M blocks are pushed out, one block towards you, one away, like an over filled Sandwich. This moves then out of optimal place, much farther apart than normal in a regular MM instument.
The modern Castagnari three-voice boxes (excluding the Tommy) are not like this. They have the reeds for each of the voices shared out between the three reed blocks. E.g. for a D/G box as follows:
Reed Block 1:
G-row M+ reeds
G-row L reeds
Reed block 2 (middle):
G-row M reeds
D-row M+ reeds
Reed block 3:
D-row L reeds
D-row M
Make of that what you will, but the MM+ sound is very fine and focussed.
-
Ah, cross posted with Steve.
Again, the 1914 is in the mix with these, and something I would consider but again, it would prompt a change of style for me.
Something I might be making more of than necessary, as people seem to switch between 2r 8 b and a 2.5r fairly easily.
Q
The 1914 box really feels and behaves much more like a two-row than a 2.5 row. Yes, you have what were the chin-end accidentals shifted to the 2-button helper row, but the accidentals are then in the 'right' place. After playing a box with chin-end accidentals, it takes all of 5 minutes to get accustomed to the 1914.
It also frees up the chin-end buttons for low notes, so you can have a third button start, and have low notes and have the full range up at the top (useful for playing with the L-voice in when you want a nice cutting sound).
-
Thanks Steve.
I'm aware the 1914 has switches on the top of the grill like a Hascy, so keeing the grill clear, though not quite as handy for bringing in the low reed mid tune.
Or go the whole hog and have a full half row and all options of a Mory?
I think the only way for me to decide is to spend time with the boxes and see if something grabs me - or not!
....and it could be 'or not'!
Q
On the merry - go - round again!
-
The modern Castagnari three-voice boxes (excluding the Tommy) are not like this. They have the reeds for each of the voices shared out between the three reed blocks. E.g. for a D/G box as follows:
Make of that what you will, but the MM+ sound is very fine and focussed.
That is very interesting. Many of their instruments are fitted with coupler switches that can turn off not just the L, but also the M+ reeds too. I wonder if their choice to put the reeds as they did was influenced by this, or, by tackling the sound issues alone. I probably would have put both M reeds in the middle, but, maybe they're better this way as they each end up with similar amounts of pallet opening above them (since farthest reeds have the most). I'm sure they've already experimented, though. In either case, thank you for sharing that info. I can say the modern style of adding of cut outs around the keyboard definitely seems to help a lot in making the sound more uniform.
The 1914 box really feels and behaves much more like a two-row than a 2.5 row.
I was interested to hear that 1914s are going to be coming as 12 bass instruments now (with Eb and Bb standard)? I've not seen one out in the wild, though. With those extra bases I really feel that's really asking for 4 accidentals, with 2 each on the chin and half row, but, idk.
-
Thanks Steve.
I'm aware the 1914 has switches on the top of the grill like a Hascy, so keeing the grill clear, though not quite as handy for bringing in the low reed mid tune.
Or go the whole hog and have a full half row and all options of a Mory?
I think the only way for me to decide is to spend time with the boxes and see if something grabs me - or not!
....and it could be 'or not'!
Q
On the merry - go - round again!
Just to say that the 1914 is basically the same weight as the Hascy, but the weight of the Mory is noticeably more and it has larger bellows dimensions. Don't expect to waggle the Mory around with the same ease as on the Hascy/1914. So - IMHO the Mory is definitely not a morris box.
-
Don't expect to waggle the Mory around with the same ease as on the Hascy/1914. So - IMHO the Mory is definitely not a morris box.
Unless you are Saul Rose! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U24Iz_RBFJc
-
my mml serenellini sounds fine with either 2 or 3 voices in gear the only snag being the impossibility of changing voices on the hoof with the push pull 'stop' (as in one row boxes)
Have considered extending the stop so it could be pushed down with chin and pulled up with teeth - but might pull out my false choppers in the process which would be a bit embarrassing - back to the drawing board
george
-
I have to say that on my current '1914' LMM box, the two voice MM sound is very fine indeed, extremely focussed and flexible. The 1914 is a superb box; I can't understand why more people don't snap them up.
I agree that the Liliums I've tried have been bliss. So has the 1914, but you don't snap up something that means that you don't have family holidays for a couple of years. Still toying with the idea of selling both my boxes to be replaced with a 3 row, or something similar, but the amount of money I'd get for both wouldn't come close to buying a 1914.
As a GC player, though, 2 voices is enough for me.
-
Don't expect to waggle the Mory around with the same ease as on the Hascy/1914. So - IMHO the Mory is definitely not a morris box.
Unless you are Saul Rose! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U24Iz_RBFJc
Yes, and look at the subsequent shoulder/arm problems Saul has had. :o
-
Yep,the Mory is a beast, and it is overall larger cross section than the 1914/Hascy/Jilly.
I would guess that the larger size accounts for the overall richness of sound. I have tried a Trilly, 1914 and Mory albeit briefly at a workshop weekend, and if it was sound alone to my ears the Mory comes out best.
But it is a beast....
Q
Who has no intentions of playing for Morris, dancing is paramount for me!
-
From Squeezy..."I have never yet heard a 3 voice LMM box sound as good as a simple 2 voice MM box on the MM setting.....â€
....what is the reason for this and are all makes of 3 voice boxes as bad as each other?
Hi Arty, Steve and all,
...I notice that there are not many replies to Arty's question above ...why?
It's simple .... The current understanding of the acoustics of melodeons is hampered by dogma, which discusses reeds, chambers and airflow, but does not allow that materials and the internal layout/space within a melodeon also contribute to the sound.
The fact is, if you stick a lump of wood and metal in the middle of a musical instrument, this will affect the way it plays/sounds. The fact that this lump of wood and metal is a reedblock with some excellent octave reeds doesn't take away from this fact, when you're in 2-voice setting.
Here's a simple Experiment I did earlier with a Salterelle Berry... Take out the centre reedblock (Low octave set)...play the instrument in 2-voice mode. Re-insert the reedblock and play again in 2-voice mode....
Here's a link to the recording ... And there is a noticeable difference.
https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2/salterelle-berry-effect-of-removing-centre-reed-block-on-2-voice-tone
With the reedblock out (first 22 seconds) the sound is fuller and more sonorous. With the centre reedblock replaced (next 22 seconds), the volume is slightly diminished and the tone is much more 'top-end', or brighter.
It's not an unpleasant sound, as Arty observes of his Beltuna....but it is different and that is the point.
To what extent this audible difference is a result of the internal space being occupied by a 'lump', affecting the internal acoustics, or whether it is partly due to that 'lump' being fastened to the soundboard (Oh yes it is!), is a matter of further debate ...probably a bit of both.
Gena's comments on pallet-lift certainly helps explain the related issue, of a muffled tone from the inner row, but the outer row on a 3-voice box often gets super-doopah pallet lift, yet is still less 'full' sounding than the outer row on a 2-voice box. So pallet-lift is clearly not the whole story.
This is an issue I've wrestled with practically for many years in making 3-voice pokerworks, pressedwoods, Erikas and Ericas.... There are many ways to address the constraints of internal acoustics (and pallet-lift) to make a 3-voice box that is NOT simply a 1-trick pony...great in 3-voices but somewhat disappointing in 2-voices.
In my experience, the best 3-voice melodeons (and your Beltuna Sara3 is a great example) don't offer a sound that is necessarily 'the same' as (eg) a Beltuna Sara 2, but is a 2-voice sound that has its own quality.
Cheers
Mike R
-
If you want to try the Castagnari ,1914 or Trilly,in DG or GC Acorn Instruments have both in stock and will be heading south in February,April poss and July,I have the 12 bass 1914 also
February to Bretforton near Evesham and Oswestry, inApril possibly to Harwich [More than likely] then July,Halsway Manor near Taunton.
-
I have had and still have both two and three voice instruments and currently own a Mory having stepped up from a Hascy just over a year ago. It is a substantially bigger and heavier box, and that’s just the way it is. The jump up wasn’t the easiest thing to do. I like the ability to switch voices and also the fact that on the Mory you can just have the single L or single M Reed sounding which is different to many boxes with two voices and a third low voice you can simply switch in or out. I like the way the two voice MM sounds on the Mory but you (or certainly I) can’t chuck it round like you would do a smaller box. I have a different box for Morris!
However there is another, unexpected benefit with the Mory that I hadn’t really considered when I got it in that the larger bellows and heavier bass end allow some really powerful playing, it has a lot more ‘oomph’ than a smaller frame box which has also been fun to explore.
Having said all that, I have a Lilium, and that, for me, is the best of all worlds!
Vicky
-
Here's a simple Experiment I did earlier with a Salterelle Berry... Take out the centre reedblock (Low octave set)...play the instrument in 2-voice mode. Re-insert the reedblock and play again in 2-voice mode....
Here's a link to the recording ... And there is a noticeable difference.
https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2/salterelle-berry-effect-of-removing-centre-reed-block-on-2-voice-tone
With the reedblock out (first 22 seconds) the sound is fuller and more sonorous. With the centre reedblock replaced (next 22 seconds), the volume is slightly diminished and the tone is much more 'top-end', or brighter.
.
.
.
In my experience, the best 3-voice melodeons (and your Beltuna Sara3 is a great example) don't offer a sound that is necessarily 'the same' as (eg) a Beltuna Sara 2, but is a 2-voice sound that has its own quality.
Very interesting Mike, and a good demonstration recording of the two different states! The difference is indeed audible in your recording, but, we know in advance to listen out for it. However, I wonder how many otherwise uninformed listeners would pick up these sorts of subtle differences, say in a performance situation? Not many, if any, I would guess.
Ultimately I suppose it's very much a personal thing. I love the sound and flexibility of a three-voice box, especially when using the L-reed switched in and playing in the upper octave of the keyboard (on a D/G box). I'm therefore prepared to accept a very slight compromise on the MM sound for the sake of having the LMM box with all its extra sound qualities.
-
When it comes to the mechanics of a box, I am a complete numpty and, if I was to be completely honest, I would have to admit that it doesn't interest me at all. My only interest is in learning to play the damn thing and the sound that I can get out of it!
Having said that, I read with great interest, what Mike has described and listened to the sound sample, where the difference is noticeable if not glaringly obvious. So thank you for all that Mike, I feel better informed now! Also, Steve's input, as usual, is very relevant and helpful and only makes me wish I lived in the UK, so that I could visit people like Pete at Acorn easily, to try these things out. Thanks also to Gena, Heartshaped1, Q et al
The thing is, I have been playing for 7 years now, I love my 2 row boxes and I know that I don't want to go to a two and a half row, because I have tried and I didn't find it suited me. A 2 row is the only true diatonic box and I love it's simplicity and it's restrictions. Also, I am 71 years old now and, while I am fit and able, I don't think it is the best age to be taking on a heavier instrument.
Just a few weeks ago, I bought a Beltuna Sara 3 voice A/D and that is what has got me thinking a lot. I am really enjoying the 3 voices and being able to change the sound completely, to suit the piece I am playing. When the 3 voices are all playing, the sound is wonderful and I can feel it vibrating in my chest as I play. But when I take out the low note, leaving just the MM, the sound takes on a completely different character. It is sweet and very pure, remarkably so, I think. It is beautiful and the higher notes have a bell-like quality to them quite unlike the sound that comes out of my Castagnari. It is more pure, less raspy. Wonderful.
So, this is the reason I have been thinking about why the quality/character of the sound changes so much when I change from 3 voice to 2 and how lovely it would be to have an instrument where the buttons to alter the sound were as readily accessible as they are on instruments such as the Trilly. Of course, so much depends on the type of music one plays. One of my great loves is Stephane Delicq and for that, my Castagnari Laura is perfect, so I will never change that. It is all very interesting!
Thanks all (:)
-
I'm very happy with the sound of my Pariselle box, both as 2 voice and 3.
It's heavier than the pokerwork, but I only really notice after I've finished playing.
It's pretty dry but the 2 voice sound to me is very sweet. I did the Christmas theme of the month on 2 voice as I thought it more appropriate.
-
I remember Steve saying he was unimpressed by the early Trillies. I had tried to order a Lillium, having once blagged a go on Rees' one and having loved it. In the end my order got converted to the Trilly and I wasn't at all disappointed. It was a completely different beast to the Lillium I had tried, probably a bit drier tuned and if you leant into the bellows it was so loud it felt like your ears were being attacked with a chisel! Surprisingly, it would also play soft and sweet - notably with a very clear sound, not at all muffled. Indeed as a two-voice it was quite convincing, though I preferred to use the bandoneon setting usually.
Since the Trilly was stolen, I was lucky enough to find a second hand 1914 which is indeed a nice box, but lacks that extra fortissimo capability and the overall tone is not as clear, slightly "boxy". I an told that Pete has said that when the case of the Trilly was restyled using the angular grille rather than the original curved one, the fondo was changed from aluminium to wood and the sound is now very similar to that of the 1914.
Rob.
-
I've found this a really good thoughtful thread, thanks to arty for starting it and all who've added their thoughts.
A comment leaping out to me is from Mike who makes the point that a 3v is different.
i.e. not better or worse, just different.
A good point.
The only way I can resolve for me is to spend time with Pete and try the boxes mentioned, something on my mind when life settles down for me in the future.
Cheers
Q
-
Since the Trilly was stolen, I was lucky enough to find a second hand 1914 which is indeed a nice box, but lacks that extra fortissimo capability and the overall tone is not as clear, slightly "boxy". I an told that Pete has said that when the case of the Trilly was restyled using the angular grille rather than the original curved one, the fondo was changed from aluminium to wood and the sound is now very similar to that of the 1914.
There seems to be some confusion here ,the grill material was changed from veneered aluminium to wood
This change took place when laser cutting was installed
-
Since the Trilly was stolen, I was lucky enough to find a second hand 1914 which is indeed a nice box, but lacks that extra fortissimo capability and the overall tone is not as clear, slightly "boxy". I an told that Pete has said that when the case of the Trilly was restyled using the angular grille rather than the original curved one, the fondo was changed from aluminium to wood and the sound is now very similar to that of the 1914.
Sorry to learn that your Trilly was stolen, Rob. But puzzled that your replacement 1914 'lacks that extra fortissimo capability and the overall tone is not as clear, slightly "boxy"'. Not sure what you mean by 'slightly boxy'. All I can say is that my own 1914 and the others which I have tried are superb instruments.
I used to have a D/G Lilium which I kept for 15 years and swore I would never ever part with it, it was that good. But I tried the 1914 and was so impressed I bought it on the spot, and soon afterwards I sold my Lilium. The 1914 definitely has the edge in terms of sound, and is far more flexible in terms of the keyboard layout and stops/grille switches arrangement.
But for whatever reasons, maybe I got an exceptionally good one and perhaps you one which was not so good.
-
I think you're right. These models are all near enough top of the range and can be expected to display small variations in a way you wouldn't detect in lesser instruments. It may well be that my Trilly was exceptional (though some didn't like it) and my 1914 is more run of the mill. As I have a Dino /Oakwood that Steve fettled and which others would bite my hand off to swap for their examples of the same box, I know he recognises and appreciates even the most subtle differences one encounters!
Rob.
-
I didn’t like the two voice MM setting on my LMM Nuage and played it with all the stops out. The MM was tuned with a slight tremolo and it sounded thin and unappealing. So I tweaked the MM tuning, to make it considerably wetter. It transformed the box and now it gets played as much in MM as LMM. In LMM mode it’s quite loud so I often remove the L now when playing with other musicians.
-
I like the 2 voice setting on my Sander, and only using the 3 voice if I'm playing higher up the box, transposing French music.
I've also tried taking out the low reed block, and didn't actually notice a difference in weight or in sound. I do play with 2 straps and hardly any bellows reversal - so that might explain why the weight makes little difference, but the similarity in sound surprised me. I do have fairly dry tuning - could it make more difference on tremolo tunings where there might be different overtone requirements?
-
This issue is even more prominent with a 4-stop box. Even with treble springs lightened to match those of a 2-voice instrument, I've never found the sound and response of a 4-stop played in MM to quite equal that of a 2-voice instrument.