Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Peadar on January 12, 2020, 11:45:26 PM
-
Anyone who wants to play old style boxes is going to have to get used to using a thumb strap because that's all they were ever fitted with.
The material ranging from oilskin, to leatherette backed webbing strap, to real leather
So what makes a thumbstrap well adjusted?
-
About the same principles as a well-adjusted trouser belt. ;)
With comparable social consequences, too tight is restrictive, too loose and the tune falls down.
-
Anyone who wants to play old style boxes is going to have to get used to using a thumb strap because that's all they were ever fitted with.
I guess that doesn't mean they have to stay that way. I've got a comfortable set up on light two-row boxes - won't that do to use? But to answer the question, I suppose we have different sized thumbs and hands, and adjusting it for size, placement along the edge to accommodate bigger or smaller hands, and perhaps angles are all areas to tweak.
I think that we are ergonomically much more aware these days - multi adjustable office chairs for example. No point in being uncomfortable.
-
There was a fair bit of general discussion about thumbstraps in this thread http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22144.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,22144.0.html) which may be of interest.
What comes to my mind is:
- comfortable for the thumb
- places hand in such a way that all treble buttons can be reached conveniently
- solidly fastened to box
- no lost motion, so snug fit for thumb and strap preferably of fairly stiff material
- optimal fit will be player-specific, more so than for shoulder straps. We all have different hands... trial-and-error is your friend ...
In the end, the well adjusted thumbstrap (just like well adjusted shoulder straps really) enables the player to comfortably control the box and fully use it.
-
Usually the general opinion about thumb straps is that they are well-adjusted when removed from the instrument and consigned to the waste bin.
But - as I say to my students and workshop attendees - there are no rules. Consider and try various options but ultimately do what best works for you.
If this means fitting brackets and shoulder-straps to an instrument which doesn't already have them, then so be it. No harm done, ergonomically it may better, and it may well make for improved stability and hence improved playing.
Personally speaking, the onset of arthritis in my RH thumb now makes it painful for me to use a thumb strap, even if I wanted to.
-
I don't use a thumb strap, but it does strike me that some method of adjustment, like with bass end straps, would have benefits (though of course the actual location of the strap can be the problem as well as it's fit with the thumb)
J
-
A more flexible thumb, is the answer?
SJ
-
see youtube jimmy shand melodeon solo for a good example of thumb strap use on a hohner Erica.
george
-
It's interesting that there is such an anti-thumbstrap sentiment prevalent among our members. I think it really depends on one's style of play, the kind of music that is being played, and the type of instrument that it's being played on. As a predominantly one-row player, I can tell you that after trying every strap arrangement possible (one shoulder strap, two shoulder straps, shoulder strap plus thumbstrap, box braced on outside leg, box braced inside leg, etc) I find the using the thumbstrap alone works best for me. I actually find it the *least* constrictive out of all the options! If you play in a fast push-pull style and you use a shoulder strap, I find that it requires keeping your body position a certain way (at least to some degree) in order to maintain tension on the strap, which I find restrictive and uncomfortable. Using the thumbstrap alone and resting the box on my knee, my entire body is freed.
There is more to it than that, though. One-rows have generally been used to play dance music, which it lends itself well to on account of its push and pull style of play. The thumbstrap can actually allow one to achieve a kind of punchiness or 'snappiness' with certain styles that isn't always as adequately accomplished when using a shoulder strap alone. It's a very subtle difference, but it's one that I noticed going back and forth between a thumbstrap and a shoulder strap. It's also a sentiment that is shared by most one-row box players here in Quebec, where using a shoulder strap on a one-row is much less common. I find my playing greatly improved when I ditched my reliance on the shoulder strap!
As Tirpous mentioned, it is essential that the thumbstrap is positioned in such a way that allows you to *comfortably* reach all of the notes. There is a HUGE amount of room for adjustment in this regard. A small adjustment can make a huge difference in comfort. Personally, I've found that moving the thumbstrap up a little higher (closer to the chin) makes a big difference in reaching those first few notes but still being able to reach the ones on the other end. For myself, I also find it essential that there is no lateral movement between my thumb and whatever part of the instrument it is being braced against (such as the edge of the keyboard, for example). This way, whatever movement is made translates directly into playing as opposed to being wasted with trying to keep the box steady.
-
Another little tip which doesn't seem to have been mentioned. Some players use a rather longer thumbstrap so that the thumb can be put into the strap from above, then rotated 180º. This needs careful adjustment of the length of the thumbstrap and the leather needs to be quite flexible.
-
The best thumbstrap I have is on a 114 and is (I'm told) made from bagpipe leather. Whatever the truth of that, it's very soft as well as being strong enough to have lasted over 30 years.
-
I typically drill out the rivets on Honers and replace them with https://www.fastenersuperstore.com/products/tee-nuts-3-prong (https://www.fastenersuperstore.com/products/tee-nuts-3-prong) fitted from the inside of the keyboard. I trim off the spikes and glue them in place. You now have a threaded hole that allows for repeated adjustment.
I use a soft tough leather from a fancy handbag I got at a second hand shop.
-
I typically drill out the rivets on Honers and replace them with https://www.fastenersuperstore.com/products/tee-nuts-3-prong (https://www.fastenersuperstore.com/products/tee-nuts-3-prong) fitted from the inside of the keyboard. I trim off the spikes and glue them in place. You now have a threaded hole that allows for repeated adjustment.
I use a soft tough leather from a fancy handbag I got at a second hand shop.
That is essentially what the maker of Mélodie accordions does with own instruments and with used Hohner 4-stops that he sells through his shop.
-
I learnt to play on single rows with thumb straps as a youngster (without any sign of a shoulder straps), and I have carried on using a thumb strap. My 1980s German pokerwork has a fabric reinforced "plastic" thumb strap and that was extremely uncomfortable when it had "sharp" edges. Now it is down to the bare fabric it is OK, and I have played for years with a single shoulder strap and thumb strap on the pokerwork and a number of other 2 row, 2 voice boxes.
What I have noticed is that single screw leather thumb straps (such as on the Boube, Lilly and Tommy) are much more adaptable and comfortable than the two rivet pokerwork thumb straps affairs on Hohners - I can now appreciate why people who start out playing with pokerworks don't like thumb straps because they are more restrictive than the "Italian" designs.
When I bought a Nuage I tried to manage without using a thumb strap for playing standing for dancing and I was just about coping with two shoulder straps. However, I have since found that using two shoulder straps was causing pain in my left shoulder (I think because it was because the second strap was lifting the left hand end of the box too high). I have now added a thumbstrap and reverted to a single shoulder strap, AND I have had a lot less trouble with my shoulder (Having eventually plucked up the courage to drill screw hole!).
For what it is worth, with my hands I have found that with the Castagnari/Saltarelle thumb straps, which seem to be about 12.5cm centre to centre (of the screw holes), the pivot/screw is about 15mm from the back edge of the fingerboard. The pivot point (screwhole) is roughly midway between the 4th and 5th buttons (on the outside row) on a 3rd button start and midway between the 5th and 6th button on a 4th button start DG box.
-
Usually the general opinion about thumb straps is that they are well-adjusted when removed from the instrument and consigned to the waste bin.
Frankly - a bit prejudiced and broad-sweeping, aren't we, Mr. General Opinion ?? Besides, the recycle bin would be more appropriate environmentally speaking.
Hey BTW, the thumbstrap is greener than shoulder straps: no need for brackets, buckles and half a cow's worth of leather.
:||: :||: :||: :||: Look Ma, no shoulder straps ! :|||: I'm no Ma, I wear shoulder straps over me head ! ;D
-
My dad has played a 2-row Hohner (pre-Erica model) and a Erica for some 50 years with a thumbstrap, then had them removed and had shoulder straps installed! I had some boxes with a thumbstrap but I found it too restrictive to my taste. Your mileage may vary :D
-
I've never had luck with thumb straps, but I always assumed it was my fault.
-
I should clarify an earlier statement I made regarding my playing improving when I ditched the shoulder strap; it's not so much the lack of a shoulder strap itself that made a difference but rather getting my thumbstrap working to my advantage and relying on it more than anything else for stability. I can't say that adding a shoulder strap in addition to a thumbstrap would hinder my playing any other than it potentially being less comfortable for me for the reasons mentioned earlier.
-
Thanks for all the replies- some more helpul than others.
I will reply at length when I am not too tired to think straight.
-
Anyone who wants to play old style boxes is going to have to get used to using a thumb strap because that's all they were ever fitted with.
The material ranging from oilskin, to leatherette backed webbing strap, to real leather
So what makes a thumbstrap well adjusted?
Out of my four soxes, two have thumbstraps two have had them removed. All four have shoulder strap brackets fitted.
Both the boxes with thumbstraps allow me to reach all the notes on the box when my thumb is located. I could use them if I wanted.
Two comments:
1. If you don't get on with thumbstraps it's easy to fit shoulder strap brackets.
2. If you can can get your thumb inside the strap and reach all the treble buttons when it's in there, it's sufficiently well adjusted. Fiddling with it won't help. The thing to do is play the instrument and get used to it, if that's the way you choose to go.
They're a bit like air buttons in that using them will feel natural with practice, even though they feel weird to start with.
-
From Tone Dumb Greg
"Out of my four soxes, two have thumbstraps two have had them removed. All four have shoulder strap brackets fitted.
Both the boxes with thumbstraps allow me to reach all the notes on the box when my thumb is located. I could use them if I wanted."
Out of my four soxes, two are boxes - two are foxes. I like the basses but the basses are faces. Faces for basses, boxes for foxes. The birds are for watching, the words are for botching.
Dr Seuss wannabe.
-
If you can can get your thumb inside the strap and reach all the treble buttons when it's in there, it's sufficiently well adjusted. Fiddling with it won't help.
Except that there is still a lot of room for adjustment even if you are able to reach all the buttons in one position. For example, adjusting your thumbstrap so that your thumb rests behind the keyboard will feel very different from adjusting it so that your thumb rests on the edge of the keyboard, even though you can reach all the buttons from either position. One position may facilitate easier playing over another for a particular individual. I know some people who play with their thumb well behind the keyboard and their fingers curled over the buttons, almost as if they were clutching it, while others will play with the thumbstrap adjusted in such as way as to allow them to play with fingers that are perfectly flat. It does take a bit of experimenting to find what feels and works best for you. Of course, at some point you have to just start playing - you can always change the way your thumbstrap is positioned at any point down the road. I certainly have!
-
So what makes a thumbstrap well adjusted?
I'd remove it, every time, and replace with a strap and brackets. They only fitted thumbstraps because they were cheaper. With a strap your fingers have so much more freedom and fluidity of movement.
-
So what makes a thumbstrap well adjusted?
I'd remove it, every time, and replace with a strap and brackets. They only fitted thumbstraps because they were cheaper. With a strap your fingers have so much more freedom and fluidity of movement.
...except if you prefer the thumbstrap to a shoulder strap as I do, and as many others do. As mentioned earlier in the thread, one suits my particular style of play and needs over the other. There are no hard and fast rules and one option is not inherently better than another for everyone.
-
What is really annoying about these kinds of forum is that a post gives you a chance to share your opinion on whatever is the topic, and as soon as you do immediately someone chimes in and says, in effect, 'That's just your opinion'. Of course it's just my opinion. I'm not saying I'm right. I'm just saying that's my opinion. For what it is worth. There is an argument that says when your hand is not attached to the accordion by a thumb strap it is free to move more freely. That's my opinion on the subject. You have a different opinion. I won't be advancing that opinion because I don't share it. I mostly advance an opinion when there's a new member who may be making decisions about ways to play music. The old hands won't want to know because they are, like me, set in their ways.
-
My comment was not intended as an admonishment. I guess it’s just that when I reply to someone’s query, I try not to speak in absolute terms but rather offer suggestions for what might work, keeping in mind that one-size does not fit all. There’s sometimes a tendency for people to drop advice on here like its gospel, rather than suggesting “maybe try this...†I certainly wasn’t trying to negate your perspective. Apologies if it came across that way (:)
-
It's not really you, it's a general tendency. An opinion is just an opinion. Obviously it is different if someone states as 'fact' something you think is not.
-
They only fitted thumbstraps because they were cheaper.
All the Pokerworks and Ericas I have bought new came with both thumbstraps and shoulderstraps in the box.
-
All the Pokerworks and Ericas I have bought new came with both thumbstraps and shoulderstraps in the box.
Blimey! I know, theoretically that all Hohners must have been bought new, in the same way that 85% of the mass of the universe is dark matter, and most elements were formed in supernovas or neutron star collisions. It’s just that nearly every one I’ve seen bears the scars of passage through the hands of multiple owners. Makes you think.🤔
-
Two very different types of thumbstrap working well for me - Stiff leather fixed by two screws to the back of the keyboard and loop at 45 degrees to keyboard and a broad ribbon from the local haberdasher.
The leather strap (On my Vienna Type International AD)- thumb goes into the loop - and then turning hand so that the thumb points straight toward the case work "locks" the thumb in the grip of the fairly stiff leather. With left knee over right and box sitting on knee this seems to match the hold described in Wyper'tutorial.
The Ribbon- on the anonymous 19 key 4 bass 4 (2x2) stop C/C# - The ribbon loop is fixed at 90 degrees to the keyboard. Thumb through, resting against edge of keyboard and a slight turn of the thumb tightens the ribbon and pulls the the thumb against and near paralel to th keyboard. Very firm and comfortable. This strap is a replacement - the original worn through when I got the box was a green brocade material - as is the left hand strap. I surmise that this box is probably dating to the early 1920's was originally sold as a ladies model.
I don't intend adding shoulder straps to antiques - I would rather play them the way they are. I take a different view on more modern boxes - HA112 /114, 1040 etc.
-
the only box I use a thumbstrap on is my hohner 4stop one row. I find that a strap attached with just a single screw works best for me as it is free to move sideways
and is long enough for my thumb to rest lightly on the edge of the keyboard whilst allowing enough articulation to reach all 10 buttons. An overtight thumbstrap or one attached with 2 screws is unlikelt to provide enough articulation.
george
-
I have been playing a Quebecois made box with a heavy strap set at a 45 degree angle. My thumb tip would rest on the corner of the keyboard which had a rounded front. It worked OK but I often found my thumb would slip off and be floating behind he keyboard. Because of the discussion today I checked some videos and I found that Sabin Jacques when playing a similar box has his thumb completely through the loop and on the bottom of the keyboard. I found that with other Quebecois players it varied with some resting the thumb tip on the edge of the keyboard and others behind it. I tried playing a little with my thumb all the way through the strap and resting on the back of the keyboard and it is actually the crotch of the thumb and first finger that provides the resistance when squeezing. I also noticed that the people I observed had a very smooth style with the bellows and used minimal bellows movement. It appeared to me that their leg did the bulk of the work keeping the melodeon in place and the thumb strap was used to give their hand a reference point as much as supporting the instrument. I have a lot to figure out yet about the thumb strap.
I recently purchased a Lilly and I have found that the thin thumb strap with a single screw and the groove in the keyboard work well and are very comfortable on a box this size. As I purchased this and a soft case from Eagle Music to be a compact travel instrument I have no interest in carrying the straps that came with it.
-
I also noticed that the people I observed had a very smooth style with the bellows and used minimal bellows movement. It appeared to me that their leg did the bulk of the work keeping the melodeon in place and the thumb strap was used to give their hand a reference point as much as supporting the instrument.
Those players who wedge the box against their left leg as described above don't need a thumbstrap. Using that style you hardly need to press your thumb against the thumb-groove either. It gives you a lot of fluidity, compared with those who, for example, have their thumb behind the fingerboard.
-
Those players who wedge the box against their left leg as described above don't need a thumbstrap. Using that style you hardly need to press your thumb against the thumb-groove either. It gives you a lot of fluidity, compared with those who, for example, have their thumb behind the fingerboard.
Richard, do you mean with a box that has shoulder straps too ?? (Larry was talking one-row with thumbstrap only, I think)
-
Yes, for that you would need one strap on your right shoulder (assuming right-hand playing).
-
Yes, for that you would need one strap on your right shoulder (assuming right-hand playing).
Just looking at videos of Irish players e.g. Bobby Gardiner & Johnny Connolly on the melodeon they seem to play thumbstap only - though on the accordion a shoulder strap usually comes into it.
-
Here are 2 examples of thumbstrap arrangements that have worked for me (YMMV):
My first box was a Hohner HA-112 in. It has a flimsy and way-too-long thumbstrap of some kind of fake leather, held in place with a single rivet. I just turned the strap around the rivet and flipped it over to shorten it. This (kinda) worked, holding my thumb more or less on the rear corner of the keyboard. Access to center buttons was OK for most buttons but awkward for #1 and 2 - it's like I had to shift gear before playing any low note. Not a perfect setup, but it got me going...
Many years (and boxes) later, I find the arrangement in the other picture works better for me: I shortened the strap (leather, but not too rigid) so that my thumb is behind the keyboard. The strap is angled at '2 o'clock' and is a snug-loose fit around the thumb (no struggle to slide it in and out). The trick is that when I get in playing position the strap bends up and there is a kind of camming action that locks the thumb securely in place without undue pressure.
-
I also noticed that the people I observed had a very smooth style with the bellows and used minimal bellows movement. It appeared to me that their leg did the bulk of the work keeping the melodeon in place and the thumb strap was used to give their hand a reference point as much as supporting the instrument.
Those players who wedge the box against their left leg as described above don't need a thumbstrap. Using that style you hardly need to press your thumb against the thumb-groove either. It gives you a lot of fluidity, compared with those who, for example, have their thumb behind the fingerboard.
I believe Larry meant that the box resting on the thigh did a lot of the bracing (it does), not wedging it against their left leg as some Irish players do when using a shoulder strap. Correct me if I'm wrong, Larry!
-
Couple more pictures to show hand position for access to low and high buttons. Also note the way the thumbstrap is bent upwards. Obviously, I'm not really in playing position (taking the picture with my left hand etc..) but this should give an idea.
-
[quote author=mselic l
I believe Larry meant that the box resting on the thigh did a lot of the bracing (it does), not wedging it against their left leg as some Irish players do when using a shoulder strap. Correct me if I'm wrong, Larry!
[/quote]
Worth bearing in mind that having the bellows on your thigh causes wear to the bellows tape area and eventually the bellows themselves, whereas having the box wedged against the outside of the thigh does not.
-
[quote author=mselic l
I believe Larry meant that the box resting on the thigh did a lot of the bracing (it does), not wedging it against their left leg as some Irish players do when using a shoulder strap. Correct me if I'm wrong, Larry!
Worth bearing in mind that having the bellows on your thigh causes wear to the bellows tape area and eventually the bellows themselves, whereas having the box wedged against the outside of the thigh does not.
[/quote]
I’ve really only found this to be the case with instruments like Hohners that use a cheap, papery bellows tape. None of my one-rows that have proper bellows tape show any signs of wear on the bottom, and they all rest on my thigh. I come across a lot of one-rows here in Quebec, most of which are played with the thumbstrap alone, and the bellows tape on the bottom likewise holds up just fine.
-
The weight/friction of the box on the leg does most of the support for anchoring the box. The second part of this is to fan the box open at the top so the bottom doesn't move much. This creates a curve that hugs your leg and helps hold the box in place.
-
Try this, perfectly adjusted I would say.
https://www.facebook.com/vi.wickam/videos/10220368061449766/ (https://www.facebook.com/vi.wickam/videos/10220368061449766/)
-
Yes it looks really ergonomic. I've never felt comfortable however with a digital piano in folk settings. I love digital pianos and think them superior to most affordable pianos, but can't get used to them in this context.
-
Try this, perfectly adjusted I would say.
https://www.facebook.com/vi.wickam/videos/10220368061449766/ (https://www.facebook.com/vi.wickam/videos/10220368061449766/)
That’s a D/C# that he’s playing...a *heavily* modified Beltuna Sara. Timi is also a proponent of moving the thumbstrap slightly higher up keyboard than what is typically done.
-
Yes it looks really ergonomic. I've never felt comfortable however with a digital piano in folk settings. I love digital pianos and think them superior to most affordable pianos, but can't get used to them in this context.
Try carrying an upright piano to a session!
-
Try this, perfectly adjusted I would say.
https://www.facebook.com/vi.wickam/videos/10220368061449766/ (https://www.facebook.com/vi.wickam/videos/10220368061449766/)
More than anything else, I love the delight they take in doing something they love..
-
To me a well adjusted thumbstrap has to meet 2 requirements
1, be comfortable to use
2. allow the fingers to cover the whole keyboard
I only use a thumb strap on one row boxes and have it long enough to allow the thumb to rest easily on the edge of the keyboard but tight enough to stop the keyboard trying to move away from the thumb when playing on the pull. Playing on the push takes care of itself as the push is against the thumb. As to resting the box on the knee I play with the treble end body resting on left leg with the bellows not in contact with anything. Using this set up I don't find it necessary to raise right leg against edge of keyboard.
I dont play one row standing but if I did I would probably use 2 carefully adjusted shoulder straps.
george