Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: forrest on January 13, 2020, 09:50:21 PM

Title: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: forrest on January 13, 2020, 09:50:21 PM
  I have had an issue with my D/G Hohner 2815. The basses were always overbearing and raspy-sounding. Often the high and low bass would sound out of sync with one another. When played at rather low volume or pressure, they improved. However, the trebles would then be very soft, with low volume. The treble reeds were well set on a tuning bellows, as were the basses. But once back in the box, they did not sound or play up to par. This led me to the theory that the basses were being "overblown" in relation to the trebles, which prompted me to try this remedy.
  As an experiment, I removed the bass block and using some painter's tape, partially covered the entry ports of the bass block. I noted that the bass ports measured 20mm. After reassembly, viola! The basses were well behaved, in tune, and trebles sounded a bit brighter in the mix. Since this box was converted by me from a G/C, is it possible that Hohner engineered different port diameters for the blocks according to the reed pitch and airflow? Would love to hear some comments on this. Also some ideas for a more permanent fix.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Corinto on January 13, 2020, 10:03:22 PM
Did a similar mod on the bass side of my little HOHNER PIROL, and it works!
As recommended by the late Bernard Loffet.
link = http://diato.org/trucs/dimbass.htm#1
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: playandteach on January 13, 2020, 10:57:11 PM
Did a similar mod on the bass side of my little HOHNER PIROL, and it works!
As recommended by the late Bernard Loffet.
link = http://diato.org/trucs/dimbass.htm#1
Isn't that mod restricting the exhaust air, rather than the intake air? Does either work better?
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: forrest on January 13, 2020, 11:11:23 PM
From my reading of the translation of Bernard's article, I think he is talking about masking areas of the grille. The mod that I was trying was to actually decrease the working area of the bass ports in the reed-block itself.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: george garside on January 13, 2020, 11:42:49 PM
whilst partially binging up the bass air flow may be worth experimenting with  the main reason for the bass sounding disproportanately loud compared to the treble lies in the way the box is played.  The air pressure in the bellows at any given time is the same for both treble and bass i.e push/pull harder and both go louder . ease the pressure and both go quieter .  AS the bass reeds are larger than the treble they will  always sound louder for a given air pressure.

The trick is to create a sort of aural illusion  by shortening the bass notes.  this is easily done by lifting the fingers completely off the bass buttons between stikes - the further the  fingers are lifted off the bass buttons the shorter the notes will be  and this will creat the aural illusion that they are being played more quietly.  The bass rhythm will not be effected in any way.

if playing continuous bass i.e droning bass notes rather than generating rhythm  using chords only (no bass notes as they are louder)  can help as can leaving gaps here and there with no bass or perhaps just relying on right hand chords as and where they  are appropriate.

in other words blame the driver rather than the vehicle!

george
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Grape Ape on January 14, 2020, 01:34:07 AM

in other words blame the driver rather than the vehicle!

george

Except that having watched many videos of Forrest’s playing over the years that just can’t be the case.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Anahata on January 14, 2020, 07:43:57 AM
I'd guess that tape is not significantly restricting the air flow, i.e. not reducing the pressure drop across the reed, because the reed itself will be far more restrictive. More likely it works by blocking some of the sound, most of which comes out through that hole.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Rog on January 14, 2020, 09:26:14 AM
I have a 1930s Settimio Soprani PA that has this problem. The bass side is rather loud and tends to drown the treble side. When I originally stripped it for its rebuild I pulled out a lot of card blocking the holes on the bass side. I really ought to put it back.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Theo on January 14, 2020, 10:53:24 AM
Rather than trying to block up holes I think a more effective method is to place sound absorbing inside the bass end in the cavity which holds the mechanism.  Felt is quite effective placed as a lining on any of the inside surfaces.  I’ve done this and it is effective. 

Advantages are:

No interference with air flow which if done sufficiently would reduce volume but could also flatten the pitch, and slow the response of the bass reeds.

Felt will absorb higher frequencies more than low, so you will reduce the brightness without having much effect on the actual bass sound.   I suspect I t’s the higher frequencies that have the effect of drowning the melody side.

One other very important point -  the player always hears a different bass/treble balance compared with someone in the audience,  so always get someone else, preferably an experienced player, to listen to you playing from the audience position before making changes. 
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 15, 2020, 12:50:37 PM
Another easy way to quieten your bass is to use it less. I think a good bass line should be … about 50% empty space. This is particularly true in 3/4 or 6/8  time

Don't worry about rhythm, the right end, and audience's brains still carry that. And frankly, a quaver of silence is as much a rhythm event as a quaver with your finger jamming the button down.

Guess I’m echoing George, and definitely Anahata, whose creative left end lines can be fabulously light. Not a felt blanket in sight …
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: george garside on January 15, 2020, 01:37:01 PM
perhaps we should start a NON TURGID BASS society!

George >:E ;D
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 15, 2020, 01:56:53 PM
I recognise Forrest's problem, and most players do indeed adjust the length of bass notes accordingly, because a braying bass is awful.  However, and as a bass guitar player as well, I have some concerns about the idea that just shortening bass note lengths is always an effective remedy - you need the freedom as a box player to vary the balance between LHS and RHS volume, and this isn't available on a box. I wonder whether there might be a technical fix here, involving some sort of adjustable bass baffles?
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Pat McInnis on January 15, 2020, 04:39:36 PM
Great topic. I've been trying to help my friend deal with this issue on his Saltarelle PA. So far I've just used some light cloth on the inside of the bass grill but it didn't do too much. I like Theo's idea of adhesive felt inside the bass side cavity. I'll give that a go next.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: george garside on January 15, 2020, 04:55:15 PM
adhesive felt works on a castagnari  lilly  which is the only box I have had  in which the bass are, to me, inherently loud in relation to the treble and which is difficult to ''quieten'' with playing technique.  I also have a felt pad across the outside of the bass end where all th'oles are.  Not only does this help it is incidentaly very comfortable on the had!
george
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Anahata on January 15, 2020, 05:44:10 PM
you need the freedom as a box player to vary the balance between LHS and RHS volume, and this isn't available on a box. I wonder whether there might be a technical fix here, involving some sort of adjustable bass baffles?

We (some of us) already have thirds stops and low reed stops on the bass end: isn't that enough?
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Graham Wood on January 15, 2020, 05:57:07 PM
Sharon Shannon always has a big sponge thing under her left wrist. I suspect that's more for comfort but it surely must muffle some of the bass side.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Graham W on January 15, 2020, 06:51:23 PM
Slightly off topic - but Hello to Graham Wood!

Just for the avoidance of confusion I'm also Graham Wood, albeit a different one, in Wales.
Many years ago I had the possibly naive idea that it wasn't a good plan to broadcast my name on the internet so abbreviated it, but there are plenty of people who will know me as Graham Wood
so just to say I'm very definately still in Wales :)

Graham W (ood)

Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Graham Wood on January 15, 2020, 07:29:56 PM
Hi Graham Wood who is still in Wales. Pleased to meet you.

One thing you could do is record yourself with the mic out at the front of where you are playing. The recording might sound more balanced than from where you are actually playing. I mentioned it because the video I made sounds slightly different to how I remember it sounding when I actually played it. Just a thought.....
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Theo on January 15, 2020, 07:40:49 PM
Hi Graham Wood who is still in Wales. Pleased to meet you.

One thing you could do is record yourself with the mic out at the front of where you are playing. The recording might sound more balanced than from where you are actually playing. I mentioned it because the video I made sounds slightly different to how I remember it sounding when I actually played it. Just a thought.....

That's the point I was trying to make further back on this page.  Bass sounds travel pretty much equally strongly in all directions, irrespective of the nature of the source.   Treble sounds are much more directional, and in our case radiate forward and to the side much more strongly than behind.  The result is that the player hears an exaggerated the bass sound, compared to what a listener in front will hear.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Winston Smith on January 15, 2020, 09:04:26 PM
"the player hears an exaggerated the bass sound, compared to what a listener in front will hear."

I don't play the basses properly (that's not all, actually!) but I have noticed in my recordings that the bass notes are always louder than the trebles.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Dick Rees on January 15, 2020, 10:47:06 PM
Another easy way to quieten your bass is to use it less. I think a good bass line should be … about 50% empty space. This is particularly true in 3/4 or 6/8  time

Don't worry about rhythm, the right end, and audience's brains still carry that. And frankly, a quaver of silence is as much a rhythm event as a quaver with your finger jamming the button down.

Guess I’m echoing George, and definitely Anahata, whose creative left end lines can be fabulously light. Not a felt blanket in sight …

Well said, Chris.  I notice this in retrospect as I've played stock Hohners for more than 40 years and somehow have learned to balance the two sides as my "style" developed over time.  A couple of observations:

Not only does varying the LH touch and content help balance, but shading the chord buttons toward a percussive rather than a tonal component can well resolve and/or expand the modal palette in playing beyond the literal comp of "oom-pah" LH.

I often will use a boundary  coupling to enhance the bass by dropping the LH side to reflect sound off the floor.  I suspect bellows control also factors in but assume that it's a subtle, results-driven phenomenon developed over years of playing.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: playandteach on January 15, 2020, 11:06:54 PM
I often find that there's a wonderful richness to videos of French music melodeons in the bass end. The basses are frequently full length notes, and cross chords. There's usually a swan neck mic involved, and I've always wondered if that richness is achievable live or whether it's only in careful recording and editing that it happens.
In this recording (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=srVvtqsQJsY) Duo Montanaro Cavez - Gaspacho - there's frequently a drone and some punchy basses, but always out of the way.
Is it the box, the recording, the voicing...
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Anahata on January 15, 2020, 11:32:15 PM
I'm sure those bass notes don't sound as they would when heard purely acoustically, so they will have made the best of it with the recorded sound. That said, Sophie's very clever with her basses. At the start of that tune, she's holding sustained thirdless chords (inherently quieter than full triads) while hitting bass notes in a syncopated and quite staccato rhythm where the gaps between the notes make them less intrusive.

Interesting to compare with https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zKW4mxiiXY4 where there's no close miking. I wonder if she's cut out the low reeds in the basses there, because they sound much thinner.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Dick Rees on January 15, 2020, 11:56:43 PM
I often find that there's a wonderful richness to videos of French music melodeons in the bass end. The basses are frequently full length notes, and cross chords. There's usually a swan neck mic involved, and I've always wondered if that richness is achievable live or whether it's only in careful recording and editing that it happens.
In this recording (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=srVvtqsQJsY) Duo Montanaro Cavez - Gaspacho - there's frequently a drone and some punchy basses, but always out of the way.
Is it the box, the recording, the voicing...

Pretty sure the primary difference is achieved in post by active mixing of discrete miking.
Big tell-tale is the low noise floor/ambient component compared to area miking or camera mic(s).
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: playandteach on January 16, 2020, 01:14:09 AM


Pretty sure the primary difference is achieved in post by active mixing of discrete miking.
Big tell-tale is the low noise floor/ambient component compared to area miking or camera mic(s).
Dick, can you put the second sentence in laymen's terms for me?
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Dick Rees on January 16, 2020, 02:10:43 AM


Pretty sure the primary difference is achieved in post by active mixing of discrete miking.
Big tell-tale is the low noise floor/ambient component compared to area miking or camera mic(s).
Dick, can you put the second sentence in laymen's terms for me?

Think of your linked example as hi-rez audio and Anahatas link as low-rez.  In your example there's no "room" component per se due to the closely focused pickup of the instruments.
In the second example you hear a lot of random reflected sound (and possibly ambient room noise) with the resulting phase anomalies due to multiple arrival times of sound at the mic(s).

Close miking allows for mixing of the sound with a high degree of fidelity.  Area/room miking "is what it is" and is not really amenable to a significant increase in fidelity  with post-production.

Sorry for the pedantry.  Comes from working as a broadcast engineer.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: playandteach on January 16, 2020, 08:06:38 AM
Expertise isn't pedantry. I also worked in that industry, but on the other side of the mic's. I used to hate recording in the churches that were commonplace choices in London, even though the bloom on the sound made me feel like a superhero. I found that the BBC were incredibly clued up and very very fast to problem solve compared to even very good studio technicians.
I guess what you are saying though, is that the boxes don't sound that fabulous in real life.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Julian S on January 16, 2020, 08:32:20 AM
I feel we ought to spare a thought for any non-melodeonistas sitting on our left in sessions. It's all very well having a good balance in front of the instrument, but sat next to the bass end the treble can easily be drowned out. Definitely less is better in these circumstances !

Julian
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 16, 2020, 08:45:17 AM
I found that the BBC were incredibly clued up and very very fast to problem solve compared to even very good studio technicians.
Indeed! I remember an occasion back in about 1970 when I was a clarinettist in the Hertfordshire County Youth Orchestra. We'd been invited to make a recording as part of a BBC Radio 3 programme. The orchestra set up in the BBC Maida Vale studios in NW London and about 5 minutes into the first take, the studio manager (or whoever) came in from the control room and stopped the playing. Although no-one else had heard it, he'd picked up the tiniest creaky chair sound from the depths of the 2nd violins. A quick chair swap to replace it with a silent one and off we went again.  I probably still have the recording of the Radio 3 programme on reel-to-reel tape somewhere...
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: heartshaped1 on January 16, 2020, 09:58:16 AM
I feel we ought to spare a thought for any non-melodeonistas sitting on our left in sessions. It's all very well having a good balance in front of the instrument, but sat next to the bass end the treble can easily be drowned out. Definitely less is better in these circumstances !

Julian

I remember being at a mixed (i.e not just Melodeons!) weekend at Halsway and the lady who had been sitting to my left all morning repositioned herself at the back of the room for the afternoon. “Are you ok?” I checked, “Yes and I’ve heard quite enough of your left side thank you!” Oh.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 16, 2020, 10:21:32 AM
Last monday I tmre-positioned myself to angle away from the melodeon on my right.
Someone I've known for gover 40 years, a stunning box player and very good friend. I just angled my body away from his bass end so I could hear myself better. He understood, took no offence.
It's a fact of life in a session or playing with others, you position yourself so you can hear what you are playing....
Q
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 16, 2020, 01:17:03 PM
you position yourself so you can hear what you are playing....
Q

WHAT???   Are you some sort of masochist?  Wait, what am I saying...?
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 16, 2020, 01:27:37 PM
Well, only vaguely  ::)
 ;D
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: george garside on January 16, 2020, 02:25:59 PM
an advantage of having 2 hearing aids is the you can turn off your right side to quieten the bass   next to you on that side . those without hearing aids  may find relief by bunging some cotton wool in the right earole  or maybe using a proper earplug

george
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 16, 2020, 02:33:10 PM
I often will use a boundary  coupling to enhance the bass by dropping the LH side to reflect sound off the floor.

Interesting...  In a practice room situation where background noise and so many bodies in the room tend to absorb the bass, I used to position close into a corner which would then reflect the bass out in a more concentrated way!  If I could have got closer to the ceiling it would have been even more effective, but a short@rse like myself gets stuck in the two dimensional effect rather than three dimensional.

Rob
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: tirpous on January 16, 2020, 05:20:25 PM
Quote
If I could have got closer to the ceiling it would have been even more effective, but a short@rse like myself gets stuck in the two dimensional effect rather than three dimensional.

No problem, the same effect could be achieved by sitting on the floor.  (:)  See Wall and Corner Loading on this page: https://www.presonus.com/learn/technical-articles/configure-your-pa (https://www.presonus.com/learn/technical-articles/configure-your-pa)
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Rob2Hook on January 16, 2020, 06:07:29 PM
Yes, that's exactly what I was meaning though with a room full of dancers' bodies the projected sound would only make it to the first set of knees!  If you could use the ceiling it would project overhead to their ears.

Rob.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: forrest on January 16, 2020, 08:40:31 PM
     Well, this thread got rather interesting. :|glug But back to my enquiry, which I perhaps had not defined well enough. Firstly, the bass reeds are not too loud. It's that their tonal quality and pitch is not good. It's not a matter of how long the finger is pressing the button, nor who's finger is pressing it.
   As the reeds were all tuned in their respective left and right end cases and set using the same test bellows, there is a shift somehow when they are put together with the original bellows. The basses get a raspy and flatulent sound, and the hi and low bass diverge from one another. My theory is that, compared to the trebles, the basses are getting pushed harder so that there is some distortion. Thus far, I've found that slightly limiting the air flow settles things down. I'm thinking it has more to do with physics and the design of the box. My other 2815's don't exhibit this.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Theo on January 16, 2020, 08:55:24 PM
Hohner bass reeds do vary greatly in their tonal quality, and in their pitch stability.  Some of the older ones on Zinc plates have a lovely smooth sound, respond quickly, and have pretty good pitch stability (for bass reeds).

Bass reeds can take an appreciable length of time to come up to their stable pitch, so in normal play they may never reach their "correct" pitch.  To compensate when tuning bass reeds I sometimes find that they sound better tuned so that their stable pitch is a little sharp.  This is a matter of judgement and will vary depending on the reeds, and they way they are played.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Pearse Rossa on January 16, 2020, 09:13:16 PM
  The basses get a raspy and flatulent sound, and the hi and low bass diverge from one another.

Check your valves.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: playandteach on January 16, 2020, 09:46:46 PM
I found that the BBC were incredibly clued up and very very fast to problem solve compared to even very good studio technicians.
The orchestra set up in the BBC Maida Vale studios in NW London and about 5 minutes into the first take, the studio manager (or whoever) came in from the control room and stopped the playing.
I know those studios well. I did my first recording there (and many subsequent ones). The first one was a re-recording of Sailing By. I've yet to find out which version they use on the Shipping Forecast. If they did indeed use the 1980s one I played on, then I'm due some royalties. I've never had a response from the Beeb about it. I should try harder to find out. Mind you I can't bear the tune.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: forrest on January 17, 2020, 05:45:46 AM
  The basses get a raspy and flatulent sound, and the hi and low bass diverge from one another.

Check your valves.

 The valves are fine, replaced new about 2 yrs. ago.

 
Hohner bass reeds do vary greatly in their tonal quality, and in their pitch stability.  Some of the older ones on Zinc plates have a lovely smooth sound, respond quickly, and have pretty good pitch stability (for bass reeds).

Bass reeds can take an appreciable length of time to come up to their stable pitch, so in normal play they may never reach their "correct" pitch.  To compensate when tuning bass reeds I sometimes find that they sound better tuned so that their stable pitch is a little sharp.  This is a matter of judgement and will vary depending on the reeds, and they way they are played.

Thanks Theo....They are Hohner reeds, one set is H on zinc, all the rest are T on aluminum plates. I appreciate the tip on tuning. Thanks to everyone for the comments!
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Anahata on January 17, 2020, 09:03:15 AM
     But back to my enquiry, which I perhaps had not defined well enough. Firstly, the bass reeds are not too loud. It's that their tonal quality and pitch is not good.
Fair enough, but I suspect your thread title set the agenda for the discussion that followed.

I'd hazard a guess that you were using lower pressure when checking the bass reeds on your tuning rig than they are subjected to while being played in the box.
The rasping quality may be because of excessive reed movement at the tip, possibly hitting the valve or adjacent block. That would certainly sound rough!
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: playandteach on January 17, 2020, 02:15:26 PM
     But back to my enquiry, which I perhaps had not defined well enough. Firstly, the bass reeds are not too loud. It's that their tonal quality and pitch is not good.
Fair enough, but I suspect your thread title set the agenda for the discussion that followed.

I'd hazard a guess that you were using lower pressure when checking the bass reeds on your tuning rig than they are subjected to while being played in the box.
The rasping quality may be because of excessive reed movement at the tip, possibly hitting the valve or adjacent block. That would certainly sound rough!
I've had this, on a well tuned box, and it was difficult to identify, but easily sorted by skilled hands (not a DIY fix).
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: forrest on January 17, 2020, 07:04:55 PM

I've had this, on a well tuned box, and it was difficult to identify, but easily sorted by skilled hands (not a DIY fix).

Yes, good advice, but unfortunately, skilled hands for this are far away. And the nearest to me, at 250 miles distance, informed me that Hohners were junk and not worth the effort and expense. That was 20 odd years back, but nothing has changed. Since that time, I have undertaken my own repairs and tuning, with the help of Theo and Diatonix, and others.  ;)
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Earl Bryce on January 24, 2020, 07:01:00 PM
Having just gone through tuning my own Hohner, I noticed that the bass reeds are significantly thinner (in thickness, not width) towards the rivet than they are at the tip, almost as if they were ground down. I’m not sure if this is normal for all bass reeds or not?
The result of this, as far as my inexperienced guess can take me, is that the reed is weak. The gap needs to be set fairly far, otherwise the tongue is sucked in and there’s not enough spring for it to pull out and vibrate. I realize that can happen with any reed, but it seems to me that the dynamics are off, that the weight at the tip is too heavy for the thickness at the back to support an even vibration.
I hope this all makes sense, and perhaps this is normal, Ive never had the opportunity to examine other reeds, but is it possible that a scenario like this is the cause for your bass reeds being unreliable and finicky with tone and pitch?
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Theo on January 24, 2020, 07:11:22 PM
It’s normal for low pitch reeds to be thinner towards the fixed end.  It’s a consequence of making reeds small enough to fit into a sensible sized box.  If the bass reeds were the ideal length they could be half as long again, or more.
Title: Re: Bass/Treble Balance
Post by: Earl Bryce on January 24, 2020, 08:07:46 PM
Ahh good to know. I figured there would be a trade off somewhere in either length or thickness, but I had no idea it was that drastic. Although I suppose it makes sense, if the low basses are an octave lower. Thanks Theo!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal