Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on January 23, 2020, 11:31:27 PM
-
I've been looking at temperature controlled soldering irons with a view to using one to wax reeds in. I'm happy enough using a waxing spoon to do a whole set of reeds but now and again I find it necessary to dig a reed plate off the block when there's a problem with the inside reed and it's a bit of a faff setting things up and melting a panfull of wax just to refit one plate. Prices for soldering stations vary enormously, and whilst I never begrudge spending money on decent kit I'd rather not spend more than I have to on something that will only get ocassional use.
Not all makers state a temperature range for thier irons, but those who do seem to have 90 degrees C as the minimum temperature. Is this okay to melt accordion wax using direct contact without overheating it? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
-
I use one of THESE (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Antex-S58J470-XS25-Silicone-Soldering/dp/B003ITY13W) connected to a standard lamp dimmer. Seems to work fine.
-
A bit like Lester. Very ordinary 40w (I think - could be less) Weller soldering iron hooked up to a 600w (rated) light dimmer. Dimmer setting is the key, not terribly critical: it's fairly easy to find 'hot enough' setting that will melt wax with minimal smoking.
-
Ditto, simple soldering iron similar to Lester's. I have a dimmer socket, otherwise the same.
-
A temperature controlled iron is much better. It reduces power when the iron is idle, and increases it as you use more heat to melt wax. A dimmer switch is better than nothing, but the iron will still be hotter than ideal when you take it from it’s stand and will cool down as you melt more wax.
-
I use one of these https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/KATSU-48W-Variable-Temperature-Soldering-Station-Iron-Electronic-W-Extra-Tips/272161465372?epid=1760385598&hash=item3f5e16641c:g:tPUAAOSw0hlZEXgQ
Not terribly expensive all in all.
Sj
-
I use one of these https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/KATSU-48W-Variable-Temperature-Soldering-Station-Iron-Electronic-W-Extra-Tips/272161465372?epid=1760385598&hash=item3f5e16641c:g:tPUAAOSw0hlZEXgQ
Not terribly expensive alol in all.
Sj
That’s what I use as well. Don’t know why I waited so long before getting one.
-
Thanks for all of the helpful replies, I'm going to get a temperature controlled iron rather than use a dimmer but haven't quite decided which one yet.
-
Thanks for all of the helpful replies, I'm going to get a temperature controlled iron rather than use a dimmer but haven't quite decided which one yet.
The likes of the iron John recommended upthread is not temperature controlled but just a better packaged dimmer switch
-
Thanks Lester, I'd more or less worked that out from the price, even a simmerstat costs more than that! I'm going to wait until my birthday and have a decent iron at the top of my wish list, it'll be good for adding solder to reed tips too. ;D
-
I have a temperature-controlled soldering iron with a digital temperature display, bought from Maplin before they went bust.
It's similar to this one (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Holife-Soldering-Station-Temperature-90%E2%84%83-480%E2%84%83/dp/B0719H8T8Q/ref=pd_aw_sbs_23_3/257-7708977-9809369?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B0719H8T8Q&pd_rd_r=db399b70-efc7-4e5f-a22d-6d2d38483615&pd_rd_w=3ed5W&pd_rd_wg=l7QQi&pf_rd_p=0208d703-a674-4413-8899-c3889837d212&pf_rd_r=M9803JVKN1JW0E79PJ6Y&psc=1&refRID=M9803JVKN1JW0E79PJ6Y).
It does reed waxing very nicely.
-
I use both in my shop. I have modified irons that I make and both work well.
The temp controlled one is usually used for large jobs otherwise the iron can cool down while working ,but it's big advantage is that it does not smoke while sitting.
the lamp dimmer one works well and you can crank up the heat a bit if you are doing a bigger job ,it does smoke a lot less than a un dimmed one.
I sell the regular iron in eBay , the tip is hammered out and has a brass blade soldered to it with high temp solder for good heat transfer and the blade is riveted to the iron with brass rivets. https://www.ebay.com/itm/193282388610?ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1555.l2649
-
Thanks for all of the helpful replies, I'm going to get a temperature controlled iron rather than use a dimmer but haven't quite decided which one yet.
i just bought a dimmer on ebay , 14.00 , works just fine . No smoke on a 1/4 turn.
-
Speaking of temperature controlled soldering irons vs. those with a built-in dimmer switch (variable power), would this one be an example of the former?:
https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B07Z3KCVCL/ref=sspa_dk_hqp_detail_aax_0?spLa=ZW5jcnlwdGVkUXVhbGlmaWVyPUEzMzFUU0xYSUdYVDBEJmVuY3J5cHRlZElkPUEwOTY1NDc2M0VPVlY3TUxNQjdFTyZlbmNyeXB0ZWRBZElkPUEwMjQ3MDc4M1NaRU5XRFJZRjJMQyZ3aWRnZXROYW1lPXNwX2hxcF9zaGFyZWQmYWN0aW9uPWNsaWNrUmVkaXJlY3QmZG9Ob3RMb2dDbGljaz10cnVl&th=1
-
"would this one be an example of the former?"
That's a nice looking bit of kit, but I'd rather buy a melodeon for that much, and just struggle on with my old "Remploy" iron!
-
"would this one be an example of the former?"
That's a nice looking bit of kit, but I'd rather buy a melodeon for that much, and just struggle on with my old "Remploy" iron!
I’m not sure what price you’re seeing, but for a soldering iron station that would be considered rather inexpensive; a quality unit would certainly cost more…and whatever melodeon you would get for that price would be absolute rubbish!
-
It also comes down to the scope of what you're doing. I overhauled and re-waxed nearly 700 reeds in the last week alone, so I have no wish to 'struggle' along and get by with cheap equipment! I'm actually going to be investing in a proper wax pot and spoon setup for doing bigger waxing jobs, but I'd still like to have a decent temperature-controlled soldering iron on hand for when it's needed. The reason I'm asking is that I was under the impression the soldering iron I had was temperature-controlled (seeing as it had a knob on the front and a temperature range from 150 C to 450 C) but it turns out it's actually a variable power control. The temperature of the tip keeps changing as I wax - it will be quite hot when it's been sitting for a bit, but will cool down (and slow down the process) after melting wax for a while. As I understand it, a proper temperature-controlled unit will help to avoid this.
-
Yes you do need a soldering iron with true temperature control. A dimmer switch or your old type are ok for occasional use, but not for large scale use.
-
"would this one be an example of the former?"
That's a nice looking bit of kit, but I'd rather buy a melodeon for that much, and just struggle on with my old "Remploy" iron!
Wouldn't get much of a melodeon for less than fifty quid!
-
There are iron's designed for wax ? I use one for some jobs & they do not get too hot, but do get hot enough. Mine is a bit older than the one below but the unit is the same and the tips similar. They suit the 'wax pencil/stick' method of delivery....
https://thecraftstore.com/product/45073/encaustic-art-stylus-pro-dual-heat-graphics-tool-with-3-tips/987208?gclid=Cj0KCQjw8eOLBhC1ARIsAOzx5cEIObvFNno4LZpLTDuPiLpQBXNUMtUZVU64TZrxLNQMbbKmljPRfDoaAtOkEALw_wcB
-
.
I had a Hanmatek though in my Raspberry Pi days. Easy to use and very controllable 👍 Much better than my old one
Had a plan to use it for melodeon repairs, but I have now passed it on to a mediaeval armourer
-
On the back of the ongoing discussion about using a Soldering Iron ( designed to melt 'metal alloy') to melt wax, as against using an Encaustic Tool, designed to melt........'wax' ! I decided to look at some options to improve on the 'stock' 'nibs' that come with 99% of the Encaustic Tools in the packet, which tend to be a 'large' heart shape, a square, a wire brush and a 'split nib', none of which are really suited to reed work.
I ended up buying x3 different 'petal' shaped attachments as part of an 'offer' and used a standard needle file to grind a furrow in them.
https://thecraftstore.com/product/47423/encaustic-art-3-x-pick-n-mix-tips-for-stylus-pro/098806?gclid=Cj0KCQjw8eOLBhC1ARIsAOzx5cF2WyYe9d9LNfnDN66oMT1cQVzTXG8jVi5N5rRKLZ0JTGx_2bUVtNAaAjQ6EALw_wcB
The 'Droplet' is best suited to the task although the 'long petal tip' might well wax between Lilliput sized plates.
The end result creates a flat surface against which a 'strip' of wax can be run into the groove.....the wax populates the furrow and runs off the pointed tip like posh writing with a Parker fountain pen. The tip is small enough to fit very successfully between standard placed reeds. Because the tool is regulated to suit wax there is no smoking/smell.
-
Here's what I found to be the best solution (by far).
There's a very good temp-controlled soldering Iron called "A-BF GS90D". If you shop around, you can get one for under £30 delivered. Well-made and works like a dream for soldering - if only I had something like this in my teenage years >:E
Note: If you get it with a non-UK plug you're advised to cut it off and install a UK one instead of using a plug adapter. The adapters tend to spark and this sparking will fry your temp control chip in no time.
For actual soldering I use solid brass tips instead of the fancy never-works-right plated long-life ones that it comes with.
But for waxing you can take the wider long-life bit, drill a hole in it and bolt on a wee brass plate. Has to be a bolt-on design to be able to install it.
Set the temp to, say, about 100 degrees or whatever works for you, and Bob's your uncle. You can use the "spoon" to do single wax-in wax-outs, or you can scoop-melt some wax onto the hot spoon right off the hard block and then feed it onto the reedblock.
(https://i.ibb.co/wLwqKRX/PXL-20240713-081112352.jpg) (https://ibb.co/4fYLj7G)
(https://i.ibb.co/GW4xNyX/PXL-20240713-081100041.jpg) (https://ibb.co/2v1nHxw)
(https://i.ibb.co/GV9F6QB/PXL-20240713-081010274.jpg) (https://ibb.co/khJM72k)
(https://i.ibb.co/LYrTZ3F/PXL-20240713-081001242.jpg) (https://ibb.co/8Nby7HC)
<a target='_blank' href='https://imgbb.com/'>imagehosting[/url]