Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: AndyShear on September 23, 2009, 11:42:37 PM
-
While visiting a friend the other week in Durham , doing a few gigs , he showed me a thing they do over on a mandolin forum ( mandolin cafe ) where they have a tune for the month , or maybe a week . So they pick a tune , not sure how this comes about , then people go off learn it and post up presumably on youtube their take on said tune , and comment , share ideas etc about it .
This sounds to me like a great way of
A People being able to learn from each other
B Broarden their approach to playing tunes they may never would have considered learning
C Learn where their own strengths , weakness lay in their own playing
D And generally share what they know in a good demonstrative way
If the tunes were put up in abc then it would be easy to transpose to any key for what ever box you've got , then converted to dots etc
I see it as a great way that we could discuss and learn from each other various approaches to the same tune .Like making an simple tune sound complex and a complex tune sound simple
I know that a lot of people will be put off , and would say I'm not that good etc but the fact is that how ever bad that you think you are their is always someone not as good as you and likewise how ever good you think you are there is always someone better , so there's no need for any self disparagement .
Anyway it's an idea that Ithink would be good to persue
Andy
-
sounds like a good idea. I particularly like the idea of hearing one and the same tune played by many of the parish members and hopefully on numerous different sorts of boxes.
Personally I belong to the "not yet good enough" bunch and I've never had ago at uploading to you tube. But I'd certainly be one of the closet participants (:)
Louise
-
It takes me 2-3months to get a tune good enough for me to post on youtube... :o So I'd have to do every other one if it was monthly.
-
I think that's a really interesting idea - I'd have a go (:) You'd get to see the variations and other improvements from other players. Very useful for those of us at the 'less practised' end of them spectrum ;D
-
I'd give it go. Any excuse to perform :||: :M
-
With sufficient support, I think this could be a very interesting idea.
-
Sounds like an interesting idea. I would certainly like to hear different people's take on the same tune, even though I am not up to much myself thus far.
-
I don't have the luxury of Broadband, and dabbling in youtube uses too much of the available bandwidth on our satellite connection, so it will all have to pass me by (as do nearly all the threads on this forum which involve youtube) :(
-
I'd be interested, but I would probably have more difficulty posting a video or Youtube than in playing the tune. Do you just need a webcam, or is there any other equipment one needs? How expensive is this equipment? Is it difficult to use?
-
It's a great idea (:), and sounds ideal for those of us who can't get out much to sessions and stuff in giving a goal to work towards, I would be up for it.
But I am under the same limitations as Bob. I have video camera in the house but getting stuff off the tapes onto the PC and then onto YouTube is a night's work. My phone does video but the sound quality is appalling (and that's even before I've mucked the tune up)...unless someone can give tips on how to make it less so.
-
I found that my ordinary digital camera takes acceptable quality (though not great) videos, and isn't a total nightmare to upload (we don't have the fastest broadband in the world either ::)).
-
I'd be interested, but I would probably have more difficulty posting a video or Youtube than in playing the tune. Do you just need a webcam, or is there any other equipment one needs? How expensive is this equipment? Is it difficult to use?
Bob it's cheap and easy to use. A webcam or video file fom your camera or even mobile phone is sufficient to load up to UTube. My webcam cost about £25.
AL
BTW I'd be all for it.
-
Fantastic idea! How to choose tune of the month? I like how Mandolin Cafe do it - send tune nominations to a nominated bod, set up a poll of suggested titles and everyone can vote on which they'd like to do next. Winning tune is the next tune to learn; anything else that gets at least 2 votes goes back into the pot for next month. 'Tune bod' has the casting vote in the event of a tie.
Any volunteers to be 'tune bod'? I'd be happy to do it (because heaven knows I do very little other admin work!) unless someone else particularly wants the job?
Cheers,
Clive
-
Actually it is sufficient to record the audio only ... creating mp3s is less complicated and does not require that much bandwidth.
-
I found that my ordinary digital camera takes acceptable quality (though not great) videos, and isn't a total nightmare to upload (we don't have the fastest broadband in the world either ::)).
A few of my older videos (those without titles and editing - like, for example, this one http://www.youtube.com/GbHandlebar#play/uploads/11/6vnBPZ2fEq8 (http://www.youtube.com/GbHandlebar#play/uploads/11/6vnBPZ2fEq8)) were done with a pocket stills camera. The video quality wasn't the best, but the in-built mic seemed to prove more melodeon-friendly than anything else I've used to date. If you've got something similar available (and with enough storage space), it's certainly worth a go.
Another option worth looking at are the new(ish) breed of mini camcorders like the Flip http://flipvideo.co.uk/ (http://flipvideo.co.uk/). These are quite cheap, very easy to use and from what I've seen, seem to produce surprisingly good results.
-
Another option worth looking at are the new(ish) breed of mini camcorders like the Flip http://flipvideo.co.uk/ (http://flipvideo.co.uk/). These are quite cheap, very easy to use and from what I've seen, seem to produce surprisingly good results.
All YouTubes are recorded on a Flip, v easy to use and surprisingly good quality.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6tghTavixE&feature=player_profilepage#t=21 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6tghTavixE&feature=player_profilepage#t=21)
LDT, I believe, just uses the camera and mic on her Laptop (mind you it is a Mac ;D )
-
LDT, I believe, just uses the camera and mic on her Laptop (mind you it is a Mac ;D )
yep....its usually ok as long as I don't sit too near the laptop ::)
-
I think it's a brilliant idea and I would love to take part.
I have just started uploading videos to youtube, and it's surprising how easy it is. I've just got a fairly basic stills camera that also does video clips (it's a Fujifim A180 10mp, about £70). You just put the camera on a desk, point it towards your melodeon, and start filming. The sound quality is basic but good enough. You can then edit it in Windows Movie Maker if you want (comes as standard on Vista) and upload it straight to youtube (as it is, in AVI format).
I've done a couple - my youtube name is craigus69, so if you search for that name you should be able to see my videos.
Only question now is... what tune, and who chooses it?
-
I would, tentatively, be up for this, in the 'somewhere in the middle' category.
-
Well, it would depend on the tune also. I'm not quite ready for that "Bum of the Blitle Flea" yet.
-
I've done a couple - my youtube name is craigus69, so if you search for that name you should be able to see my videos.
i stumbled upon those vids today....
-
Well, it would depend on the tune also. I'm not quite ready for that "Bum of the Blitle Flea" yet.
That thought had entered my mind. How do we pitch the tune's fiendishness so as to engage the clever clogs and not alienate the newly able?
-
Pick a tune that can be played on one row
-
brilliant idea! il have a go!
-
Only question now is... what tune, and who chooses it?
OK, since it's our first time, let's have a few suggestions here. Once we've got a number of thoughts I'll set up a poll and we can vote on the first tune of the month on it. If the idea takes off, I'll set up a new discussion section for it, with a new poll and thread for every tune.
To start the nominations, here's a couple of relatively simple thoughts:
- Spirit of the Dance
- Princess Royal (any of the many versions)
Both of these can be played on one row (play Spirit in the upper octave!), but I don't think we should necessarily restrict ourselves to one-row tunes at nomination stage; it's down to the power of the poll to choose whether we end up doing something simple, tricky, one-row, two-row or more. I expect that tunes that fit easily on most instruments will get more votes; however some of the fun will come from reworking tunes to fit the strengths and weaknesses of your particular instrument - there's no need to play it verbatim!
I'm sure there are plenty more great suggestions to be had. So post them here!
Cheers,
Clive
-
Some of those one-row tunes get pretty fancy. For example, of the stuff from the various Franco-American communities is quite complex.
However, the two tunes above are both new to me, so I'm prepared to give either one a go, if we have a consensus. Or other nominations?
-
Would suggestions be PM'd or posted on this thread?
-
Would suggestions be PM'd or posted on this thread?
Eventually probably posted in a special thread in the new discussion area, but for now while we're playing with the thought, just post them here I think.
Cheers,
Clive
-
Well, it would depend on the tune also. I'm not quite ready for that "Bum of the Blitle Flea" yet.
That thought had entered my mind. How do we pitch the tune's fiendishness so as to engage the clever clogs and not alienate the newly able?
I would have thought it would be most flexible (and perhaps most interesting) to specify only the core tune and then let individuals choose how best to arrange and adapt it. I'm not sure that there is such a thing as a tune that's too easy - that aspect is surely more a factor of the arrangement. Thus, I don't see why it would be a problem to choose a fairly basic tune and to then see where people are able to take it.
-
Am I right in thinking that once the selection had been made the dots would be made available via ABC or some such thing?
AL
-
Am I right in thinking that once the selection had been made the dots would be made available via ABC or some such thing?
AL
Hmmm.... a little beyond my talents. Could we have a volunteer to do that?
Cheers,
Clive
-
My suggestion is the following reel:
'Granny Hold the Candle While I Shave the Chicken's Lip'
The ABC is :
X: 1
T: Granny Hold The Candle While I Shave The Chicken's Lip
M: 4/4
L: 1/8
R: reel
K: Amin
|: eA (3AAA c2(c2|c)Acd e2dc|eA (3AAA ABcA|BGdG eGef|
eA(3AAA c2(c2|c)Acd e2dB|GdBd e2dB|e2dB eA (3AAA:|
|: eaag a2ga|a2ga c'bag|a2ga eage|dged Bde2|
eaag a2ga|a2ga c'bac'|ba^gb a^ge^f|^gedB e2ed:|
It's pitched in A minor but is quite easily transposed here (http://www.8ung.at/abctransposer/index.html)
It is challenging, fun, and has the best tune title that I have ever come across!
;D
AL
-
Al
That might be a challenge for non-B/C/C#ers as it has F nats and G Sharps and no easily achieved bass line. Think something more along the line of Clive's selections for starters??
To start the nominations, here's a couple of relatively simple thoughts:
- Spirit of the Dance
- Princess Royal (any of the many versions)
Cool name though (:)
-
I think tune selection would be best left to Theo, Clive or someone that they directly nominate. Hopefully, that would help prevent disagreements about what is or isn't suitable.
-
To start the nominations, here's a couple of relatively simple thoughts:
- Spirit of the Dance
- Princess Royal (any of the many versions)
Either of those tunes would be ideal. I don't play either, but have been meaning to learn Spirit of the Dance for ages.
I have a lovely version by Tim Van Eyken which I could upload to youtube, if anybody likes to learn things by ear (I do).
(I'm pretty sure Tim wouldn't mind, given the spirit of the venture.)
-
Both of those tunes are available as black dots in 'Paul Hardy's Session Tunebook', available as a PDF here http://www.pghardy.net/concertina/tunebooks/pgh_session_tunebook_paged.pdf (http://www.pghardy.net/concertina/tunebooks/pgh_session_tunebook_paged.pdf)
-
With sufficient support, I think this could be a very interesting idea.
ditto (:)
-
We all have different interests, tastes , machines, keys, experience, and some will have the tune already (unless it's really obscure, Al) other not at all. Sorry to be a Jeremiah but .. I wish this scheme every good fortune. It may need it.
-
Great idea!
For newbies to the DBA like myself, to learn a tune and be able to compare with players of more experience (at various levels) and those at a similar level would IMO be a great learning tool. To also hear the different styles that a tune could be played in would also be interesting.
Also, as someone who has never posted a video or mp3 on the internet , it would be good motivation for learning how to do this (and starting to play in 'public').
Maybe it doesn't matter if someone already knows the tune - their version of it would be worth hearing and they may try something new with it.
-
re:'Granny Hold the Candle While I Shave the Chicken's Lip'
Cool name though
Yeah - been saving it up for a time such as this!
;)
Anyway, I see from recent comments that we're reduced to the lowest common denominator again by only wanting to put up stuff for folk who play D/G boxes. Why don't we just call this forum DG.net?
>:E
AL
-
Anyway, I see from recent comments that we're reduced to the lowest common denominator again by only wanting to put up stuff for folk who play D/G boxes. Why don't we just call this forum DG.net?
>:E
AL
'cus we play Emin as well :P
-
if anybody likes to learn things by ear (I do).
So do I, and I was going to ask just now if there's even a hideous midi version (for that is better than nothing) of the chosen tune could it be put up along with the dots, ABC (:)
-
if anybody likes to learn things by ear (I do).
So do I, and I was going to ask just now if there's even a hideous midi version (for that is better than nothing) of the chosen tune could it be put up along with the dots, ABC (:)
If the ABC is available, any ABC programme, eg ABC Navigator, will play the tune on the computer.
-
If the ABC is available, any ABC programme, eg ABC Navigator, will play the tune on the computer.
If you go to the other side Concertina.net here (http://www.concertina.net/tunes_convert.html) it will play the ABC's.
All you have to do is paste in the ABC and press submit. Then the music pops up in sheet form and gives you the option of playing a midifile of the blessed thing. They're clever over there aint they?
AL
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Why? Because it is a tune that has travelled widely to may lands and instruments for some reason, and most people know it.
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Why? Because it is a tune that has travelled widely to may lands and instruments for some reason, and most people know it.
Do they? I just dug out my copy of Hardcore English and played through the tune and I didn't recognize it at all. Perhaps I have been going to the wrong sessions.
-
If this is going to take off, the first tune (at least) needs to be well known, not too difficult for those who are inexperienced and capable of sufficient variation and ornamentation to interest those who already know the tune very well.
Princess Royal meets those criteria and Spirit of the Dance may also do so, but I would like to nominate a tune that is very well known, seems to have a number of different versions and is easy to ornament in a variety of ways; Speed the Plough.
Hackneyed it may be, but I think some of us will be surprised about the variety of ways in which it can be (and is) played.
-
here[/url] it will play the ABC's.
All you have to do is paste in the ABC and press submit. Then the music pops up in sheet form and gives you the option of playing a midifile of the blessed thing. They're clever over there aint they?
AL
Clever and cool!. I can't read ABC at all (I did try but it's too much for my brain/eyes or something!) so am unaware of all its magical properties. Thanks! ;D
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Why? Because it is a tune that has travelled widely to may lands and instruments for some reason, and most people know it.
Do they? I just dug out my copy of Hardcore English and played through the tune and I didn't recognize it at all. Perhaps I have been going to the wrong sessions.
give me a break lol
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Never heard of it ;D
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Never heard of it ;D
me neither ... its here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RIvuR7nPwyA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RIvuR7nPwyA)
it sounds familiar.. but i think its because it sounds like every other hornpipe
it wouldn't get my vote... sorry
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Never heard of it, I'm afraid. Googling and YouTube suggests that it is an American fiddle tune.
-
Fishers Hornpipe is famous in bluegrass mandolin circles, and the amazing and multi-talented Andy Statman is associated with the tune. I think this clip is based on his arrangement:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEWeLJMzI-s&feature=related
(Need at least a couple of rows for this one, I would guess!)
-
As a beginner not knowing anything I hope its ok to suggest one I'm already trying to get to grips with...(hope I got it right?)
what about Marmalade Polka (as seen here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNP5mPr_MgM)
ABC
http://abcnotation.com/tunePage?a=www.banjolin.co.uk/tunes/abcs/marmalade/0000
-
Speed the Plough isn't a bad one to start with. Easy to play (had a 6 yrear old playing it at home) but in its simplicity there's big scope for varation and self expression. eg loads of ways of twiddling the A music.
Does anyone else play the B music inititial bars on the pull against the Em chord (its actually easier)? Or ditto against an Em>D>C pull bass run (useful in loads of other stuff)? doesn't even clash the G others might be playing.
Hacknied is may be, but you can often attend a session and no longer hear it. I've long felt it is due a re-fit. D3R
-
Speed the Plough is a good one: if you play it already, you can try and surprise yourself and do something new with it; if you don't play it already, then it's a good tune to know because it gets played at sessions everywhere.
-
Mmm is actually quite a good tune to work on. It was the first one I worked out and (other than a few twiddles on the melody) I was playing it much in the same was as when I started. Probably a very good thing to go back to the old easy tunes and see what new bits can be fitted in with better playing. The E D C bass run spices it up a fair bit. So does fudging playing it in A or in Em.
-
Speed the Plough is a good one: if you play it already, you can try and surprise yourself and do something new with it; if you don't play it already, then it's a good tune to know because it gets played at sessions everywhere.
I can play it slowly with no LH...
-
When choosing the tunes, I'd quite like them to illustrate a point.
For example, if we have a waltz one month, another month how about a mazurka? They are both in 3/4 and I am sure I just play them all as sort-of waltzes! Seeing how better players make them sound different would be good. I guess the same is true of the various 4/4 based tune types as well...
I know that might sound a bit like 'lessons' but personally I would find it valuable (probably more valuable than learning a lot of tunes of the same type).
Just an idea!
-
When choosing the tunes, I'd quite like them to illustrate a point.
Depending on how we get on, I was thinking on those lines myself... perhaps 4 tunes a month starting on different weeks, with each of the weeks having a different flavour - simple well known tunes, continental, tunes you've never heard of, etc.
... but we'll see how we get on with one tune first I think.
Cheers,
Clive
-
personally I think it would be better, and also more fun, for the TOTM to be relatively new to most people, i.e. not Speed the Plough etc.
And also not particularly constrained by compatibility with a particular layout, or even with melodeon (whatever that is) at all. Part of what might make this interesting would be to see how different boxes cope with a given tune, including by transposing the key and perhaps making other modifications. I suppose that crazily complicated or generally box-incompatible tunes would be fairly obvious on inspection and normally would not get elected anyway.
Any particular tune in mind? It's not too late to modify the poll, or for those who have voted to change their mind if a cracking suggestion comes along!
Cheers,
Clive
-
personally I think it would be better, and also more fun, for the TOTM to be relatively new to most people, i.e. not Speed the Plough etc.
Melnet has an excellent 'tunes' section for that.
I don't see a lot of benefit in learning something relatively obscure, that won't turn up in general sessions (which is what such 'newness' implies). Rather I'd like to get into some of the many standard tunes that I've never properly practiced - or a new way of ones I do know.
-
Fishers Hornpipe is famous in bluegrass mandolin circles, and the amazing and multi-talented Andy Statman is associated with the tune. I think this clip is based on his arrangement:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEWeLJMzI-s&feature=related
(Need at least a couple of rows for this one, I would guess!)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Afzl3A8o7vE&feature=related this one is much better, the other video is copied straight out of a Bluegrass Mandolin book.
-
Fisher's Hornpipe
Why? Because it is a tune that has travelled widely to may lands and instruments for some reason, and most people know it.
Do they? I just dug out my copy of Hardcore English and played through the tune and I didn't recognize it at all. Perhaps I have been going to the wrong sessions.
Played alot (and originally learnt by me) in quite hardcore Irish Sessions when I used to play Irish, and also heard in English Sessions (the Ryburn fiddlers certainly play it) - may be slightly different styles, but still basically the same tune.
In this respect, this may be a more 'homogeneous' tune for initial selection than some of the quintessential English tunes suggested, in recognition that not everyone on here plays the latter.
Diane
-
Here we go! The reason I do not play in sessions so much nowadays. It ends up with one small group playing flash, fast and furious on a tune nobody has ever heard and showing off for the next half hour, so the rest of us retire to the bar and leave them to it.
This TOTM will end up just the same. Shame it sounded like a good idea.
-
Here we go! The reason I do not play in sessions so much nowadays. It ends up with one small group playing flash, fast and furious on a tune nobody has ever heard and showing off for the next half hour, so the rest of us retire to the bar and leave them to it.
This TOTM will end up just the same. Shame it sounded like a good idea.
Not so sure .. if we resist pressure on clever tunes and regard it as a mutual self education thing. As I say above - there's a new tunes section for flash pieces. I've posted my new polska there - but would resist it being used as a 'tune of the month'. D3R
-
Like sessions, this is something people can opt in or out of. If you don't like the tune or have difficulty, don't do it. If you find a tune you can, or want to play, play it for us. Also suggest which tunes which could go to the poll.
We all know there is various levels of abilities here on melnet, from beginner to pro. We should cater for everybody, this means mostly simple everyday stuff for the majority, but we do need the odd tricky tune to satisfy the better players hunger to improve. (hopefully without any feelings that they'd be showing off)
There is also a lot of people who will be able to help others get their fingers round these tunes. If you're having trouble with a tune, just say! I can garantee there will be someone at the rescue.
-
it would be nice if there was a 'theme' each month and the tunes nominated had to reflect that theme.
-
I'm good with Egan's Polka , Speed the Plough, or Princess Royal. I'm still a beginner. ;D
I thought you folks would be bored by these old pub standards...
Hearing theses old tunes from members would be great... maybe if members somehow played something to "make it their own" if possible. Turning a major chord to minor somewhere etc.
-
I'm good with Egan's Polka , Speed the Plough, or Princess Royal. I'm still a beginner. ;D
I thought you folks would be bored by these old pub standards...
Quite the opposite really for me. Technical tunes require so much effort and thought that musicality often goes out the window; playing stuff you know really well lets you get that musicality back and adds a bit of magic to the music. I've been 'learning' some technical tunes for years, literally, but they rarely make it to the stage where I'd play them out...
Cheers,
Clive
-
Here we go! The reason I do not play in sessions so much nowadays. It ends up with one small group playing flash, fast and furious on a tune nobody has ever heard and showing off for the next half hour, so the rest of us retire to the bar and leave them to it.
This TOTM will end up just the same. Shame it sounded like a good idea.
I am puzzled, nay, somewhat dismayed by the above comment, which I see as considerable over-reaction (and somewhat of an attack ???) if aimed at my comments on Fisher's Hornpipe. When I used to play Irish tunes (as that was what was played where I was living at the time) I was certainly very much a beginner - but the thing about polkas and hornpipes was that, unlike the fast reels, they were not something which were played 'fast and furious'. Rather, they were much more akin to the English dance tunes that I was familiar with from dancing at lots of ceilidhs in the late 70's and 80's, and hence felt playable, at reasonable tempo, and in those styles, on an English G/D box (unlike the majority of the reels). Plus, there was the added advantage that you only tended to play the right hand - as left hand basses were rarely appropriate (or played by the B/C players) - so, as long as you could pick out a simple melody in a hornpipe or polka rhythm, with one hand, then such tunes made the sessions inclusive, and meant that I could at least play something of the repertoire (and, even lead a few simple polkas - such as Egans, or some of the Ballydesmond's).
Not all Irish players/ Sessions play everything 'fast and furious'. I used to attend the local branch of the Ceoltus Ceolteiri Eireann [probably not the right spelling]. Lovely musicians, singers and dancers there, and a lot of talent. Mostly, but not all, native Irish - tremendously warm people, and always welcoming and encouraging to anyone who wanted to share their traditions (I myself was born O'Connell - but not in Ireland).
To imply that Fisher's, on the basis of the extremely small proportion of session-playing musicians who actually have any input on this Forum, is, globally, 'a tune nobody has heard', and hence elitist, is a gross over-exaggeration. It is also not 'flash' nor seriously difficult - not at all, compared to the tunes that the younger people tend to play as a matter of course nowadays!
Reactions such as the above will only serve, I fear, to self-select this Forum to a rather low ie in terms of playing level, common denominator, which is in danger of being self-perpetuating - as those who have made the effort to get on with learning, and get out and about and play and progress (sometimes in the face of tremendously adverse life circumstances) will risk being decried. So, they will leave it alone...
-
I'm good with Egan's Polka , Speed the Plough, or Princess Royal. I'm still a beginner. ;D
I thought you folks would be bored by these old pub standards...
Hearing theses old tunes from members would be great... maybe if members somehow played something to "make it their own" if possible. Turning a major chord to minor somewhere etc.
yep the'yd get my vote too... Princess Royal especially, is a very flexible tune ... loads minor chords / bass runs etc.
Here we go! The reason I do not play in sessions so much nowadays. It ends up with one small group playing flash, fast and furious on a tune nobody has ever heard and showing off for the next half hour, so the rest of us retire to the bar and leave them to it.
I'd like to think that the 'flash' and 'fast and furious' of us might all want to consider we were once newbies at some point ... unfortunately
that doesn't seem to be considered in most sessions... as it all goes down the 'mass show off route'
personally i prefer playing 'old pub standards' ..because it gets the whole session playing. But I dont think my views are often shared by some Prima donna's... its a real shame
-
I didn't know your tune by name, Diane but I've found two versions on youtube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMJtkOaJW10&feature=related
Something more sedate (1'17"), almost dancable, except he quasi-medlies a 3/4 waltz with a 4/4 polka ???
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMJtkOaJW10&feature=related
No B music so I'll have to get that from the more furious version.
Agree - it's a lovely tune which (played sensibly) has that super 'drive' that makes British polkas go. Though I have heard it somewhere - it's not mainstream for me.
I will have a go. I'm going to aim for something in between these two and if my session starts to race it - well I'll fold my bellows and go for a pint.
My view is that people experienced on the instument can always pick up tunes of this genre, from youtube, or on our tunes thread.
However I'd see TOTM as more of an intermediate/advancers class - I personally think it'll do most good in that way. To me that makes 'old pub standards' quite a natural choice. Certainly we shouldn't puick anything that needs super technique.
I don't feel fisher's to be much beyond my 'targeted' level of difficulty. But we should perhaps start easier and see how it goes. Chris
-
Reactions such as the above will only serve, I fear, to self-select this Forum to a rather low ie in terms of playing level, common denominator, which is in danger of being self-perpetuating - as those who have made the effort to get on with learning, and get out and about and play and progress (sometimes in the face of tremendously adverse life circumstances) will risk being decried. So, they will leave it alone...
All fair points (including the ones I've deleted), but I think the history of this forum would tend to suggest that everything should pan out nicely. We'll see how it goes and take things accordingly. I think Fisher's is a nice nomination by the way; a nice tune, not one I play very often or well admittedly, but certainly a good suggestion. Please don't be put off from making more suggestions! Looking at how the polls are going though, I think the Fisherfans will need to do a bit of lobbying if it's going to be picked! (My vote's not winning either - it's not even in 2nd place! Pah!)
Cheers,
Clive
-
(My vote's not winning either - it's not even in 2nd place! Pah!)
mines in 4th place.
-
Here we go! The reason I do not play in sessions so much nowadays. It ends up with one small group playing flash, fast and furious on a tune nobody has ever heard and showing off for the next half hour, so the rest of us retire to the bar and leave them to it.
This TOTM will end up just the same. Shame it sounded like a good idea.
Perhaps I should have said be carefull it could go this way.
I was not targeting any individual, and a pint is waiting as an apology if we ever meet. (don't all be offended now) ;D
-
Granny is resoulutely taking up the rear! Fie on the lot of you for leaving a poor old lady in the lurch like that!
;D
-
Am I the only melnetter who has downloaded the dots for 'Granny hold the etc...' and is trying to nut it out? I am obviously very easily led ;D
-
Go for it Juker! You are a star..got round the 'B' section yet?
;D
-
As a beginner not knowing anything I hope its ok to suggest one I'm already trying to get to grips with...(hope I got it right?)
what about Marmalade Polka (as seen here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNP5mPr_MgM)
ABC
http://abcnotation.com/tunePage?a=www.banjolin.co.uk/tunes/abcs/marmalade/0000
Actually i am not convinced that the tune being played in that clip is the same as the music, although marmalade polka is quite a nice tune (from the music). What does the team think? I think i know the tune in the clip as something like "Poor old ?? can't get the ?? out" (?).
-
Am I the only melnetter who has downloaded the dots for 'Granny hold the etc...' and is trying to nut it out? I am obviously very easily led ;D
Nope, I had a look, and will print it off when I get into work again ;D It's about time I made use of that high G# (if only I can find some time...)
-
Am I the only melnetter who has downloaded the dots for 'Granny hold the etc...' and is trying to nut it out? I am obviously very easily led
Nope, I had a look, and will print it off when I get into work again It's about time I made use of that high G# (if only I can find some time...)
Go for it Ellie!
;D
-
As a beginner not knowing anything I hope its ok to suggest one I'm already trying to get to grips with...(hope I got it right?)
what about Marmalade Polka (as seen here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNP5mPr_MgM)
ABC
http://abcnotation.com/tunePage?a=www.banjolin.co.uk/tunes/abcs/marmalade/0000
Actually i am not convinced that the tune being played in that clip is the same as the music, although marmalade polka is quite a nice tune (from the music). What does the team think? I think i know the tune in the clip as something like "Poor old ?? can't get the ?? out" (?).
The first tune in that clip is Uncle Bernard's Polka which goes into the Maramalade Polka. I spot our (Devil's Dyke Morris Men) fiddle player and one of our melodeon players there.
-
As a beginner not knowing anything I hope its ok to suggest one I'm already trying to get to grips with...(hope I got it right?)
what about Marmalade Polka (as seen here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CNP5mPr_MgM)
ABC
http://abcnotation.com/tunePage?a=www.banjolin.co.uk/tunes/abcs/marmalade/0000
Actually i am not convinced that the tune being played in that clip is the same as the music, although marmalade polka is quite a nice tune (from the music). What does the team think? I think i know the tune in the clip as something like "Poor old ?? can't get the ?? out" (?).
The first tune in that clip is Uncle Bernard's Polka which goes into the Maramalade Polka. I spot our (Devil's Dyke Morris Men) fiddle player and one of our melodeon players there.
oops, sorry, I didn't play to the end. Apologies LDT.
I haven't yet voted, so i might go for the marmalade polka in that case... (I love polkas)
-
I haven't yet voted, so i might go for the marmalade polka in that case...
good for a jam session
Is there any toast themed tunes? Then you can have marmalade on toast....
-
I haven't yet voted, so i might go for the marmalade polka in that case...
good for a jam session
:-\
-
I'm starting to think people just record and link to whatever they want for a tune- but the commonality is a 2 row D/G box for now, since it's most common.
-
I've been away for the weekend and mayhem appears to have broken out. ::)
I'm still up for 'tune of the month' in principle. My personal preference, though, would be for a tune which is neither a standard that 90% of any session will join in on enthuastically (like Speed the Plough, Egan's Polka or Princess Royal), nor yet a party piece like 'Granny Hold the Candle'. Instead, I'd like to propose tunes that are slightly less well known but still session standards, and completely accessible to relative beginners. Marmalade Polka would fit well here (and gets my vote this first month); others in this category that spring to mind are The Perfect Cure, Foul Weather Call and Horse's Brawl (a special for those who like accidentals). But there are hundreds of suitable tunes.
-
Is there any toast themed tunes? Then you can have marmalade on toast....
X: 1
T:Daminen's Toastie
M:C|
L:1/8
Q:180
C:John McCusker
R:reel
D:John McCusker: Goodnight Ginger
Z:Devin McCabe
F:http://trillian.mit.edu/~jc/music/abc/mirror/irishtunes.net/reels/daminemstoastie.html 2009-09-28 17:15:24 UT
K:E
B2BA G/2A/2BE2|e/2f/2g fe deB2-|Bc A/2B/2c BeEG|A/2B/2c BA GAF2|
!B2BA GBE2|e/2f/2g fe deBe|c/2d/2e af gedc|1Bagf feec:|2Bagf feeg|
!|:gafe dBB2|c/2d/2e dc- cBGB|c3e B2Be|c/2d/2e de fgag|
!g2ga f2fe|c/2d/2e dc- cBGB|c2A/2B/2c BeEe|1f/2g/2a gf fe e/2f/2g:|2f/2g/2a gf feec||
-
Somebody just post a basic version of any tune, and I'll try it lol. Just not too tricky. This is funny, like family members who can't decide on what restaurant to go to. :D
-
And GbH of this forum has already responded with a great recording of 'Granny Hold the Candle While I Shave the Chicken's Lip' (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOax0QGo4I4) - although it may lose in the poll, Granny has still won the race! You see, you just can't trust those polls ;D
AL
-
How about having, say, one month a selection of reels, then jigs, then polkas etc etc (alphabetically) In this way if we don't particularly want to learn e.g. "polka of the month" we could pick up some general ideas on "polkas" and apply them to whatever "polka" we played or were learning.
Just an idea to take the focus away from one tune in particular and refocus on a broader area of e.g. playing a "polka" for dance, developing the left hand for "waltzes" etc etc etc
cheers
Bryson
-
Is there any toast themed tunes? Then you can have marmalade on toast....
X: 1
T:Daminen's Toastie
M:C|
L:1/8
Q:180
C:John McCusker
R:reel
D:John McCusker: Goodnight Ginger
Z:Devin McCabe
F:http://trillian.mit.edu/~jc/music/abc/mirror/irishtunes.net/reels/daminemstoastie.html 2009-09-28 17:15:24 UT
K:E
B2BA G/2A/2BE2|e/2f/2g fe deB2-|Bc A/2B/2c BeEG|A/2B/2c BA GAF2|
!B2BA GBE2|e/2f/2g fe deBe|c/2d/2e af gedc|1Bagf feec:|2Bagf feeg|
!|:gafe dBB2|c/2d/2e dc- cBGB|c3e B2Be|c/2d/2e de fgag|
!g2ga f2fe|c/2d/2e dc- cBGB|c2A/2B/2c BeEe|1f/2g/2a gf fe e/2f/2g:|2f/2g/2a gf feec||
doesn't work when I put the abc in the tune o tron. :(
-
Works fine for me, but it's in E (4#'s), so I'm not sure you'd want to try it!
-
Works fine for me, but it's in E (4#'s), so I'm not sure you'd want to try it!
How about in D
X: 1
T:Daminen's Toastie
M:C|
L:1/8
Q:180
K:D
A2AG F/2G/2AD2|d/2e/2f ed cdA2-|AB G/2A/2B AdDF|G/2A/2B AG FGE2|
A2AG FAD2|d/2e/2f ed cdAd|B/2c/2d ge fdcB|1Agfe eddB:|2Agfe eddf||
fged cAA2|B/2c/2d cB- BAFA|B3d A2Ad|B/2c/2d cd efgf|
f2fg e2ed|B/2c/2d cB- BAFA|B2G/2A/2B AdDd|1e/2f/2g fe ed d/2e/2f:|2e/2f/2g fe eddB||
Carried out by Jens Wollschläger's ABC-Transposer (http://www.8ung.at/abctransposer/index.html)
-
Clever clogs!
I have to say, if nothing else, then recording and listening to myself playing, and listening to others playing the same thing has certainly made me realise that I need to go back and *think* about how I'm playing. I had no idea that my StP was so mushy! Back to basics for a while I think, and a bit more (or at least *some*) focus on how I'm playing as well as what I'm playing...! That's a bit of a shock to the system :-[ ::) (:)